Lemme correct myself. Typing a little too fast today. You dont have to lift your hands during rests lol. If you did playing some of the more difficult and faster pieces would be hard and it is accustomary to leave your hands close to the piano so you could jump right back in.
Dude Bach inventios never had dynamics for they were written on and for the harpsichord in which dynamics didn't exist. To make up for that he added the trills and mordants to keep the pieces interesting. This counts for Sinfonias too. Other then the dynamics you did good. And yes you can lift your hands during rests, nonamepoeple123 is on crakc :).
Luck this is a baroque piece which means it doesn't required too varied dynamics but syaing that varied dynamics is stilled required. It was a bit monotoned. Also you should define the phrasing more. Another point is that during rests your holding the note which is a big no no. 17/22
@GaleoDeus May I please comment that I did not find your playing monotonous or boring, and if you played through some rests or did not express the piece just exactly as the composer indicated, I hope you can be happy with the idea that music is for enjoyment and not for a mathematical or analytical exercise. let the Purists play like robots, exactly as the the composer indicated (because they spoke to the composer in a dream, yea right), but your playing was enjoyed by everyone here THankYOU.
the sheet music upside down, not you... unless you want to.
VolkColopatrion 1 year ago
now play it upside down.
VolkColopatrion 1 year ago
This was very enjoyable. This invention is slow, together with the E-major invention. They dont work in higher speed in my opinion.
HerrWarja 1 year ago
yea i like it at this tempo..it has more room for musical interpretation..
i'm playing this right now and my teacher makes me play it crazy fast and it doesn't sound as good as this.
TrueRango 1 year ago
I love that this piece was written so monotoned. Hearing it somewhat legato was nice. Good ending
chellephone 2 years ago
The baroque style has a lot more staccoto style, you could play all the 16th's and 8th's staccato. Would make it mroe interesting :)
YellowMagi 3 years ago
Lemme correct myself. Typing a little too fast today. You dont have to lift your hands during rests lol. If you did playing some of the more difficult and faster pieces would be hard and it is accustomary to leave your hands close to the piano so you could jump right back in.
Croimos14 3 years ago
Dude Bach inventios never had dynamics for they were written on and for the harpsichord in which dynamics didn't exist. To make up for that he added the trills and mordants to keep the pieces interesting. This counts for Sinfonias too. Other then the dynamics you did good. And yes you can lift your hands during rests, nonamepoeple123 is on crakc :).
Croimos14 3 years ago
Luck this is a baroque piece which means it doesn't required too varied dynamics but syaing that varied dynamics is stilled required. It was a bit monotoned. Also you should define the phrasing more. Another point is that during rests your holding the note which is a big no no. 17/22
yuxuanz 3 years ago
monotone...the dynamic markings are there for a reason!!! But you're pretty good for a self taught person. Also, don't play through rests. :)
ariesisalive 4 years ago
Playing through the rests was a deliberate style decision on my part. But I agree my playing here is quite monotonous and boring. :)
GaleoDeus 4 years ago
@GaleoDeus May I please comment that I did not find your playing monotonous or boring, and if you played through some rests or did not express the piece just exactly as the composer indicated, I hope you can be happy with the idea that music is for enjoyment and not for a mathematical or analytical exercise. let the Purists play like robots, exactly as the the composer indicated (because they spoke to the composer in a dream, yea right), but your playing was enjoyed by everyone here THankYOU.
aricmm 1 year ago 2
ariesisalive your a noobckae. Not a single 2 or 3 part invention has any dynamic markings in it whatsoever.
Croimos14 3 years ago 3
And another thing is he didnt play through any rests nob. Get the Music, read it, and learn it before you make critisizing posts.
Croimos14 3 years ago
You should lift your hand during rests, understand?
nonamepoeple123 4 years ago
what are u? a music teacher
jxw6762 3 years ago
Wow, look how flat my right hand is. I'm playing like I still have guitar fingernails!
GaleoDeus 4 years ago