張學友-愛很簡單

[steventube]

各有特色

[789456123760]

陶喆唱得好听多了～

[chanck1994]

大家要知道,所謂的原唱,是加工過無數次,重唱過無數次的版本.­..

就好像周杰倫一樣,他的現唱跟唱片跟本是一個天一個地...沒法­比的,(老實說真的很難聽,聽過現場的都應該知道)。

而張學友在唱現場,但你們卻在把他拿去跟那個「製成品」比較..­.

[xiaobinguo]

學友翻唱得不好聽，第一句的開字已經破壞了整首歌，儘管後來放輕­了自己的低震音。

[TDU2driver]

e首感覺原唱好聽d，but你其他作品真係無人能及。

[LEECY112]

愛很簡單

相愛很難

[chakfai93]

有12個人的愛很不簡單...　

[amankuo1]

TO : ozalice96.... YOU SAID : he sings with his HEART, not his MIND! 這句話就對了! 張學友眾多歌曲當中~我聽到的第一首..是1985年的 [情已逝]! 這首歌曲翻唱自日文歌..之後也有人再唱過.... 但到目前為止..我就認為~不論技巧運用..情感投入..意境.­...還是張學友版本最好! -------　------ 至於說 "唱片賣最多的問題" ..這有其時代背景和各種因素.... 當年~媒體和演藝產業並沒有那麼發達...沒有那麼多歌星! 更沒有網路..下載盜拷也不容易~~想好好聽歌....基本上要­去買卡帶或買碟! 這幾年下來~唱片界的環境早就改變了! 現在的歌星~要像當年一樣動輒幾十萬..甚至百萬張的銷售量..­.實在太難了! 如果據此來證明~演唱技巧最高?每一首歌曲都是他詮釋的最好?後­無來者..沒有人能超越?....未免太武斷! 難道~唱片賣不過周杰倫蔡依琳的歌手....歌唱實力就一定不如­他們嗎?? 不能這樣講吧?

[ozalice96]

@amankuo1 May I clarify one thing, this was a one-off charity concert in HK in either 2003 or 2004 and this CD was the highest-selling one in that particular year in HK. I merely said HK people love his covers, but I did not say because of the high sales, Jacky can sing every song better than anyone or his singing technique is the most superior. Trust me, I love his songs but I'm not that blind! Please don't force your own words into my mouth!

[amankuo1]

@ozalice96 *** SORRY~~"唱片賣最多的問題"...我係回應 hoholoney ....***

(因為youtube回應模式設計的問題..我為了方便就一次寫­在一起了)

是我沒寫清楚~~再次跟您說... SORRY! @_@

[ozalice96]

@amankuo1 It's OK, I understand. No worries!

[amankuo1]

@ozalice96 ...張學友的 [離人] ~ 林志炫這位歌手翻唱過...唱的很好 別有味道!

林志炫是高音實力派歌手~但他和張雨生比過高音...結果林輸了­!

張雨生能用真聲唱出超高音~他在某些歌迷心中是神的地位~彷彿任­何方面都最好! 別人怎麼唱都不如他!

這種看法還真是怪!

您可以搜尋 :

**張雨生月琴飆高音精華** .. **楊培安 演唱大海以及示範共鳴點轉換**

[ozalice96]

@amankuo1 I know both 林志炫and 張雨生, but not familiar with 楊培安. As I said before, there is no right or wrong as to how people choose which singer they idolize. One man's meat is another man's poison! It's alright to support our idol providing we are not being disrespectful or nasty to other singers! Please also see my reply to you in the other clip. Thanks for your two search suggestions!

[amankuo1]

張學友 陶喆~兩人屬於不同世代...詮釋歌曲的方法不同....都很不­錯!

兩人也各自有一定地位.....不是幾個人講講就會改變的!

張學友翻唱這首歌時 ~~ 先降 key 

選擇好最適合自己發揮的音位後~~再利用各種方式..搭配深植人­心的歌神印象...彌補自己先天和後天上的不足!

這些不但是張式唱腔的特色.....也是他厲害的地方!

技巧值得後輩學習!

[ozalice96]

@amankuo1 I think you over-analyse how Jacky executed this song! There is only one formula that he used i.e. he sings with his HEART, not his MIND! Please forgive me for my ignorance. Prior to this song, I have no idea who David Tao is and what songs he sings. Thanks to Jacky, he opens up my scope to music! All I can say is, had I listened to David's version first, I may not have fallen in love with this song as much as I do now!

[G2RE]

Nice❤

[alexever11]

@t609661

陶喆是亞洲將R&B唱法全是最完美的歌手

張學友的情感表達和唱歌的口氣也永遠是如此迷人

但陶喆在的地位也是不張學友可以撼動的

沒有陶喆就沒有愛很簡單這首歌

請不要愚昧的批評陶喆

你沒那資格

[lary159357]

他的 i love you 是真音耶.................

[ronaldchan62]

歌神成日強姦人地d歌 XD 

好多歌 我都係聽完歌神唱之後

就冇聽原唱既版本啦

[leertoto]

@ronaldchan62 x2

[26921423]

流淚了.....



[265611]

講真...唔好聽...

事實好殘酷...... 老了要面對現實.....

[Alvinmok711]

@265611 面對現實? 外界好多人都對呢個拉闊音樂會評價十分之好 , 我自己亦覺得佢演繹每首歌都演繹得好好 , 唯獨係你咁諗 ,面對現實既係邊個先岩

[futurefighter2008]

@265611

哈哈哈哈，算了吧

[t609661]

@265611 我都快笑死了 陶喆現在都不知道死到哪去了

相反來看學友的地位...265611你還是別出來搞笑了

[hoholoney]

@t609661

陶吉吉...係幾乎上左神台的人黎

佢同eason果堆人物係同一個級數,什至更加高

不過上面有位用學友的地位同吉吉的地位比較

學友已經是歌神級了~這個已是公認的

全球賣碟最多的華人...就是最好的證明

[jleyau]

this is a very nice song, and most of all, this artist sung really well, putting his soul into it..! can feel this love is so strong..

[henganze123ytb]

雖然我也十分喜歡eason.....可是聽了張學友你的歌..­.感覺你才是真正的歌神!!!

[JeffryTao]

恐怖得要命



[bringmiracle]

有神快拜！不愧為歌神

[sevensword16]

why am I only hearing sound in one side of my earphones?

[eminemlaw1]

2:40 yes!!! i !!do!!

[maronthehill]

跟原唱没法比

[ShinnLalala]

两个字：歌神

[amlz35]

無論歌的原唱者是誰，到目前為止聽到學友唱的歌，都是代表著他自­己的歌

[moomin0day]

佢呢個look有點似johnny depp, 手勢都有啲似 haha

[MrACELI]

这也有人 踩 不会是因为 视频质量吧

[JAPANSHOP1]

歌神!好得沒話說!

[22824805]

...........

[22824805]

....

[sbnj231t]

唱得沒有很好聽 

因為是超級無敵好聽

[foon0925]

很多人翻唱這算歌, 都不知覺模彷了陶吉吉的柔情,結果無法突破原唱者訂下的框框

而張學友唱懂得比較澎湃, 懂得運用自己聲線的特點和優勢, 唱出完全不一樣的感覺.

好不好視乎各人的喜好吧. (個人2個版本都喜歡)

[yoga18311]

唱得像自己的歌...强!!!

[kimuralcl]

David Tao's voice is most perfect.

[yisheko]

永远的歌神。。。

[mingming2005096]

台灣有周杰倫,

香港有張學友!!!

[lzwyue]

@mingming2005096

可不可以不要拿周杰倫來侮辱張學友？

周杰倫的歌基本都過氣了　唱的R&B都是歐美玩剩下的

唱功又奇差，他還是搞創作好點

[rj941221]

@lzwyue 周杰倫紅得起你奈佢唔何:o)

你說話都要俾面人~

你阿媽冇教過你?!

[mingming2005096]

@rj941221 講得好岩啊朋友T口T

[mingming2005096]

@lzwyue 我不認為是侮辱啊~ 很主觀好不好!? 你也不要踐踏周杰倫好不好??? 周杰倫現在紅遍全球呢... 唱功差會去做歌星喔. 過氣了還會開演唱會要加埸喔... 搞笑.

[RightFooted123]

@mingming2005096

Also Eason and Khalil!

[19Mun79]

不然怎麼叫歌神



[unitechtu]

PERFECT than david tao~

[hpan0721]

陳奕迅其實也很不錯!

歌神當然也很棒囉!!!!!

[hms2008w2011]

Who made this silly hair style? :)

[luvyukiko]

跟他一起 k 歌一定很酷！

[bosco2056]

張學友才是神..原來..

強如陳奕迅都好似有點比不上...

[stanley7818]

@bosco2056 我記得陳奕迅在一期接受香港周刊報導說過

剛出道時造型 跟 歌聲都是模仿張學友的

真的是  神!!!

[sk2151598]

超好听啊！非常喜欢张学友这个版本！

[ChangHuiMei]

好聽好聽...歌神就是歌神...^^

[gala183]

請問這是什麼時候在哪邊的演唱會?

[fayeho]

@gala183 在香港的拉闊音樂會

[kleong94]

good

[JDPersuasion]

original key?

[zaw21]

7 people missed the Like button...

[stabley1]

覺得後面鼓手很會打



[kevinkailkc]

@stabley1 當然,恭碩良,,,香港最會打的他可以佔一席

[k0pyme]

i like this version better than the original.

[SRTOASRAK]

張學友真係香港既光榮

[iantang450]

@SRTOASRAK

[emmeprofit]

为何又有人不喜欢。。。？

[aerinya]

為甚麼他會被人稱為歌神?

[bear16110]

@aerinya 因為至今 不管台灣還是內地歌手 無人能超越的強大! 張學友 是不敗的 (我沒有說別人不好 只是說 張學友太屌了)

[aerinya]

@bear16110 我也是他的歌迷許多歌我認為會比原唱還來的好  歌神當之無愧...................

[cart3212003]

@hahaha1002 你自己也不尊重人,還想人尊重你.

陶喆和學友兩種不同演繹方式,你不愛聽學友就算了.

甚麼經典情歌,經典就不能唱?

你才是醒醒吧,你自己來唱,唱爛也沒人管你,

學友歌迷當然喜歡自己偶像,有比較很正常,更何況學友本身有實力­

[hahaha1002]

抱歉 有一點說錯了 學友的吻別確實是原唱

剛剛發現Take me to your heart 才是翻唱學友的 抱歉

[funnybunny9396]

歌神唱得超好聽!!

[bbkwg]

GREAT!

[kindyuen]

key降了一點,但真是十分十分好聽!!

[858642182]

陶吉吉的歌就是連歌神都感動到

[leopig7]

天ㄚ 好好聽唷~!! 歌神果然不一樣~!!

[henrye04]

棒棒

[wjiwjiwji]

好屌，比原唱還屌。

[nikurakong]

Jacky Cheung's version of the 爱很简单 。。。 soooooooooooooooo cool~!

[Mattfai00]

'I love you'用真音唱...好聽 :)

[mnm11385]

romantic and sweet

[sagittariusla]

你可以看張學友的字 他很常把一個句子分成兩段或三段唱 像是先唱前面兩個字再唱後面的幾個字 好酷

[siriuskeith]

谢谢 woo

[VIPVICT]

i like his skill and feeling that he used on this song..

Excellent

[wenjia1012]

张学友是唯一一个基本任何翻唱都至少能和原唱媲美的

[pikyih]

双手双脚赞成！！！

[bbkwg]

@wenjia1012

相信你未聽過佢首最佳損友...

[ryanwss85]

@wenjia1012 我说《如果》啦。。。如果这三十年没有 张学友 这个歌神的出现，你还会那样说吗。。？ 就是你已经奠定 学友在一个神的位子，当然是那样说咯。。我本人相信还有很多能唱­的艺人朋友 也可以把《 爱很简单》 演绎得很好 的。。

[chan3824]

兩個都是我欣賞的歌手,各有各精彩.....

[cdefgqqq]

愛很簡單的 激情版

[40579085]

爽! live 和 唱片 一樣 實力派歌手

[mrMokck]

我反而覺得唱live比唱片更精彩..

[fato1989]

學友唱這首歌給我的感覺是那種熱情的愛想要大聲對對方講出來

相反陶吉吉唱的卻是小聲甜甜的,像兩個人獨處時的悄悄話

各有各獨特之處

[azheng987]

@fato1989

你真的解释的很好！！！！

[aznscnoob]

i like the falsetto better at the chorus by DT

[myacnt8999]

yup, that falsetto gives more "love" feeling. DT sings it incredibly in his soul power live concert 2003.

DT and jacky are the best singers around, but both are underrated.

[bryan2424]

agree...but then again Jacky's singing it to his own comfort...thats why he still sounds so great here ^^

[robot923]

我覺得各化入各眼啦

學友陶喆我也喜歡,

他們唱腔都不同,如果要學友唱到像陶喆這樣.那倒不如聽回陶喆.­.不用聽學友吧!!

[gonzoonycu]

係各花入各眼..

[HippyChickjy]

This song had been sung by so many artists, still I think Jacky is the best. Nobody can compete him. His voice is incredible man.

[zhanzaidevil]

我爱她也很想她

[lukezai09]

学友唱得仲好听啦。声线好 感情浓

[funnybunny9396]

so great ! LOVE you jacky .

[kiweewawa]

why must one be "better" than the other? the beauty of art is its endless possibilities. i appreciate both versions.

[DevilD07]

Jacky is the best!!!

[cloudwmok]

i love u~

[tubeloving]

各有各的強與弱吧

其實學友唱起擅長的慢版情歌 （這首不太算，我指的是例要"分手總要在雨天" 又或 "我真的受傷了"）的那種細膩和感情表達，是他獨有而且非常感人­的。

陶喆的音樂強的地方當然是很強，例如轉音、即興、表達不同 Style的能力、和無比的 power！

[realtvb]

They are both excellent singers, but I prefer 陶喆 much more. 陶喆 sings this song more clear and the feeling is sweeter.

[tr555777]

真的不懂為什麼那麼多人說張學友唱的比陶喆好,論真音音高,論假­音使用的成熟度,從這首歌聽來,張學友沒有一項贏過陶喆,難道在­該下歌的地方拖拖拍子,然後幾句旋律稍微變調,就叫有感覺,就叫­唱的好??!!

[amankuo1]

@tr555777 論技巧~我也是同你一樣的感覺!! (在這裡好像滿容易被公幹)　>.<　.....

不過也要幫張學友說句公道話~~他畢竟年過50了..又是不同世­代....有些技巧難免退了 或不純熟!

[leo2281988]

don't know why people say jacky sings this song better

david definately got better feeling

[myacnt8999]

jacky's also got feeling. both are totally different styles, david is RnB, jacky is ballad.

[TLCMQN]

wow.... just wow.... this is a good mix

[weilanchen]

學友唱出自己的特色，但我還是喜歡陶喆的，更經典！

[Amen1020]

這首歌我之前聽過很多次了...但都不是很喜歡...我聽學友翻­唱後...居然愛上它了...是學友的唱得太幫的關係吧  太棒了!!!!!

[rayman789]

同感 就是喜欢张学友唱得

[king2gd]

現在又不是歌唱比賽，為何總是硬要把學友和陶吉吉的版本作比較?­?

歌曲是要來欣賞的

[shinwaQinhua]

陶吉吉肯定唱不到这样的水准

[dsdqdqxxxfeffe]

by all means!!, he is a little pretentious dimwitted twit

[revendrous]

學友唱得更有感覺,好好聽ar!!

[heranature]

不愧是歌神

[jackiechenweiwang]

學友歌唱得太好聽了, 只是頭髮有些鳥

[markenson]

我也有同感

[xpiderman06]

兩人的曲風及演繹各有特色 都好聽 學友的聲線顯然略勝一籌 歌神之名 當之無愧！

[kalok0115]

個人覺得歌神唱得比較有感覺

[AllenCheung1988]

INCREDIBLE ！！！

[aaphoneman]

在高音部

張學友的音色比陶略亮些, 略為銳利

還有他的弱音處理真是超強啊

[luv4shane]

this version is so much better!! seriously!!..  cant stand david tao's voice... gay and irritating at the same time (i know i am going to get flamed for this)

[qk1999qk1999]

頂佢個肺丫, 勁到不得之了

[Flyypiggy]

David's better

Hes not bad though

[chanchifung66]

呢首歌真係經典......perfect melody!

[shen2feng1]

起鸡皮疙瘩 - - 好好听~~

[myacnt8999]

for information, in this concert, jacky sings songs from teresa teng, faye wong, stephanie sun, eason chan, hacken lee, sandy lam, leo koo, miriam yeung, jay chou, david tao, jeff chang, danny chan, and leslie cheung.

tell me, which singer is brave enough to do that in a concert.

[Rayevo888]

A LOT , CROSSOVER WAS POPULAR IN 2004

[wxwwaes]

nice voice, very magnetic creates resonance, simply awesome!!!!!

[momomonsta]

don't compare just appreciate.

[aluvywiwii88]

true..he sings better than david, but i also give credits to david for writing such good song.

[ayclui]

聽到學友唱 I Love You 時,真的暈大浪 ~ ^^

學友: I Love You Too ~

[TSZKIN741]

學友把聲真係好吸引 好完美 ~

[newbigi]

that's my favorite hairstyle of his.

[Yanamariel]

definately, i love his hairstyle too!

[smallkungfumaster]

great singer... but his hairstyle back then not so ^^"

[kayz83]

This is just awesome. The original by David Tao is great but nobody can sing this as good as Hok Yau on stage LIVE.

[unchargedboy]

很惊奇会有人觉得学友哥唱得难听～不如试试叫陶喆唱学友的吻别看­看。不会欣赏不等于难听，到头来学友哥才是歌神！

[synn520]

很喜欢这个版本。有另外一种味道。赞！

[wailaplap1990]

我覺得陶吉吉唱live版唱得比張學友好一點..陶吉吉個種聲同­愛很簡單個種想帶出來的情感係好配合..

[noraacmw]

yea, maybe because David Tao's the writer, he can sing it better. But both are great

[katkatyinn]

both amazing

when i saw 陶喆 WILD DAY OUT LIVE, love this song and love my boy friend too~~

[jwang604]

I bet you say that to all your boyfriends. ;)

[OREGON2015]

歌神是没话说啊

[zaw21]

What's up with his hair! lol oh man... He's still my favorite pop singer of all time.. I started listening to him when I was 5 yrs old. I feel old

[noraacmw]

they are both great singers and have their own style in singing this song......but i find Tao's version more cute and emotional, especially his "jia yin" can melt people's heart

[Dragonkiller113]

i think it is batter than 陶喆 =]

[justinwong02714]

唱得比陶喆更有feel

[shichengfei]

在所有的"爱很简单"里面，我最喜欢学友的

[highburycatherine]

恩，我也是！ 张学友的歌我觉得啊，个个都是经典，唯独我觉得离人林志炫版本更­好。张学友真是太会唱了!!

[i3forever]

for 离人 i think 学友 is better

i cant say 林志炫's version is bad but you cant really feel the sadness of that song

[d0ubled0uble]

I think 林志炫 spent too much effort on the technique of singing that song, missing some emotion. He definitely got good skill, but dun have the mood.