Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (769)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Yeah that wasnt a good start but they are still great!

  • 0:12 Wuuuuuuuhuuuuuuuuuuuuuuhhhhhh.­..

  • mollie looks well pretty !!!!

  • i think they were sick so they turn up the actual song or somthing..

  • vanessa saves the performance at the end!

  • Poor Mollie. =/ At the beginning...I still love her!

  • i LOVE the saturdays! but the most of that was all lipsyncing :(

  • i love the sats..but girls aloud have more dance moves and they can sing bettter live..

  • rochelle is the best

  • ok tht was totally mimed.

  • lol

    mollies opening note

    soundman : ouch wth ? turn off their mics QUICKKK!!!

    End of song: Vanessa can sing, turn on her mic.. LOL

  • @rysc123 LOL

  • I just love them, but that single Mollie's note was worth it as humor relief. LOL

  • Molly wasn't singing....

  • Vaness'a end note was live

  • i saw them live and THEY WERE AMAZING THEY CAN SING!!!!

  • obvi mollie's opening was live and also the rest of her verse was aswell. you can tell as she is off my a milli second. but the rest is lip synced

  • I lovte The Saturdays. They sing great live, so it really bugs me that this is lip synching. you can just tell. so just for those of you who are wondering if they ever sing live, they do and you can always tell the difference. i notice they mimed because it sounds way too much like the song. Mollie's opening not was not lip synched. but anyways. i love them and always will. they're amazing.

  • how can she sing soooo bad on her opening live then the rest of the song mimmed!!! this group is so crap!!!!

  • @marleybear09 why are you watching if you dont like them, and they are NOT crap. they have had over 8 top ten singles, 3 top ten albums, a book, a TV show, 2 sell out tours, can you have the cheek to call them crap.

  •  so sad... can't they sing in real life?

  • @AdiVampire check out their radio 1 live lounge performances. yes, they can.

  • @AdiVampire I saw them live they were amazing

  • lololololol that first note

    does anyone actually think this isnt shit?

  • it just doesnt get hotter than Mollie!!!!

  • @Jimbojub lol yes it does ROCHELLE!

  • frankie's hair =(

  • @TheCookiedoughdough what about it

    it suits her

  • Mollie my fav, i'm glad she got to sing alot in this, it may not have been the best opening vocal but she had to start the whole thing of and dance and everything so yh lol

  • Mimed!

  • they seem so amatuer lol

  • Even if una hardly sings in this she is the hottest! No arguing on that

  • VANESSA vocal is good. This song is nice. Good sound quality.

  • I LOVE THE SATURDAYS n_n!!!!!!!

  • MOLLIE = TERRIBLE BUT LOOKS AMAZING

    VANESSA = LOOKS AMAZING AND HAS A AMAZING VOICE

    FRANKIE = SO CUTE AND LOOKS AMAZING

    ROCHELLE = ATTENTION SEEKER WANTS TO CAMERA ALL THE TIME

    UNA = CUTE VOICE AND LOOKS AMAZING

    xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx­xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx­xxxxxxxxxxxx

  • Mollies mimeing at the beging is blaitent:L

    all the girls look gorgeous thou:)<3

  • OMG Mollie had a terrible time last night xD :P

  • talentless tarts

  • @muntario1982 talentless?! are you crazy?

  • kick mollie out

  • mollies got the snooki look. haha

  • would you all leave them alone. There better than ALL of you, so fuck off

  • i love all the saturdays but i think vanessa had the best voice out of them x

  • mollies hair like wowwww!

  • the start by mollie was crap:/

  • @LolCat1998 hahahah yeah! it sounded like, "WHOOOAAAA..." in deep voice. haha

  • omg the opening was soo rong =/

  • ekk terrible opening note followed by terrible miming

  • Vanessa Doesn't need to lip sych most of the time its just the rest of them who are

  • OMG! they are not miming! they just have the track in the background. Some people really do need to listen and not talk about stuff they do not know about!

  • @jamradplayer Mollie started off loud and then her voice when different?

    Sounded like miming :S

  • The opening note by mollie was live and no offence to her terrible,

    The ending by Vanessa was live and great though :P

    Love the saturdays and yeah they do mime alot but they equally sing live

  • playback smell on miles xd -

  • Only one of them can acctually sing live all the rest of them are shite .

  • if they had the headset microphones, it wouldn't look so obvious

  • I saw them in concert and they were definitely live! x

  • they don't normally lip sync, some of it's live you can tell but most is lip syncing x

    Frankie and Rochelle are used to that cos when they were in s club juniors/8 they always lip synced but they defo can all sing x

  • would love to lick their minges.

  • I LOVE THIS CHOREOGRAPHY!!!

  • I've heared them live, and they are by no means bad, I love the Saturdays, but the opening note by Mollie, was just sooooooo not good, however Work, ironically their best recieved single, is the one song the girls can't nail live, tracks like "up" and "ego" they perform quite well, however about half of time they lip sing, but at least they do sing live, unlike other artists :)

    xoxo

  • wow the opening note is terribleeeeeeeeeeeee

  • 0.41 frankie looks gorgeous!!

  • Do NOT get me wrong , i adore the saturdays , but agreeing with @MickeyyD9 ..molly didnt open so well x

  • playback :(

  • playback :(

  • this is live to some degree. by that i mean its probably about 80%backing track 20% their vocals so any major vocal mistakes are filtered out by the track overlaying their live voice.

  • Mollie is deferent hear ..

  • wow thank gawd for the back track WTF and don't try and distract with smoke and lights.

  • despite the bum note and the miming, i still like this performance

  • i dont understand why ppl are watching live performances and this stuff if they dont even like The Sats. maybe they should get a life?!

    love the vid. :)

  • @McFLYsuchtii MAYBE ITS CALLED BEING HONEST AND GIVVING AN OPINION I LIKE THE SATS BUT THINK LIE THEY ARE AWFUL!! I HAVE SEEN THEM 5 TIMES AND THINK LIVE THEY ARE CRAP IM SORRY BUT BEING HONEST!!! :)

  • yea ... but i guess you like 'em if you've seen them 5 times?!

    i just dont understand why the Haters are watching the vids.

  • @McFLYsuchtii i like the sat... but the only part off this pa that is life... is mollie at the beginning... and that says it all.... oh and the end with van

  • I think people watch this sort of stuff/live performances as its like watching a car crash etc, horrific but cant not watch it.

  • they are singin live u dipshit

  • And you can do one as well, you retard. Do you know what gullible means? You're the epitome of it - they're about as 'live' as Cheryl Cole was for X Factor, ie, pre-recorded in front of a select audience. You imbecile

  • urrrrrrrrrm, no.

  • Well I would say Cheryl Cole was Live in fact with some backing vocals, not a pre-recorded show. As for this, they were probs meant to sing live but due to Mollie's mishap they switched to mime.

  • @smalley2k6 em hun no the diffrence between molie's vocal run & when she starts singing is to big they are lipsyncing

  • this choreography was immense!

    dunno why they changed it. maybe cos of nessas ankle?

  • OMG LOL i am a big fan of the Saturdays but that opening note from Mollie was so terrible!

    the rest is lip syncing but they do sing live most of the time, but when they sing live with Choreography it doesnt sound so good :-/

  • I agree... this is bad playback :(

  • Comment removed

  • They are lip syncing but I don't know why because they hardly ever do and they don't need to because they CAN sing.

    I've seen them live twice and a friend of mine who came with me (and is really not into girlbands and sings indie/rock stuff) said:

    "They can sing... but I'd be more impressed if one of them picked up a guitar."

    Then I pointed out that both Mollie and Una can play guitar!

    I love the sats!

  • I think the only reason they lip-synced was cause the night before they sang Just Cant Get Enough live on Comic Relief, so they probably didnt have time to choreograph & rehearse this live in time for the show :(

    And yeah I agree they're amazing live, I saw them on 28th June 2009 - best night of my life!!

    and I think Frankie can play guitar too, I'm sure I heard that in an interview. The host joked Rochelle & Vanessa could play triangle as the others can play guitar haha!

  • Obviously lip-synching.. apart from the first note, which sounded absolutely terrible lol! They can dance, but they wouldn't be able to sing live for shit.

  • i know, they're truly talented! specially nessa xD

  • guys, they're really talented and everything and i love them, but don't be so blind.. or deaf in this case. They're LIP SYNCING! and i can tell cuz i know this song perfectly! as Irenuni said: Mollie and Nessa tried to make us think they were really singing. Just think about it: Thye're dacing! you can't sing perfectly and dance at the same time. Anyways.. they're awesome live or not! xD

  • they r all wearing wayy too much makeup!

    especially frankie she looks like shit!

  • how can u say its lip sync ??? its really sing live , check other performance , u'll se they really sing live so good !!!

    and again , in this performance it's singing not lip sync !!!

    Mollie always pretty & cute ! Una sp beautiful & sexy , Vanessa is the best vocal , Rochelle & Frankie is pretty cute too but Rochelle voice is more strong than Frankie , Frankie's voice is cute only !

    But love them , all girls so good :))

  • actually this is lip sync... the only thing that wasnt mimed was the first Mollie's "woooohhh", i think that was just to make us thing it's not a play back, but it actually is. Still love them though!

  • Are they lip syncing? I can't really tell.

  • @krazyboi232 ..it's a bit of both live and miming. i would think it's like 15%-live 85%-miming.. =/

  • lollolol oh jesus, GA fans you are SO amusing. its like you cant like two girlbands with you lot, seriously ;D its all GA this.. theres not one video of The Sats without a comparision to GA n its getting annoying now! You cant compare The Sats to GA yet, its way too early in The Sats career. Do it in 7 yrs if you like.

    also you can judge their singing once you've seen them live.

    because they are great.

    but right now, you can stfu. ;D

  • btw id like to add its not all of us GA fans cos i love the sats,sugababes,booty luv mini viva etc so i like a lot of girlbands

    but your right no point in comparing them just talk about the sats not GA

  • I just saw a bunch of their music video and I started to like them, especially vanessa, her voice was amazing so I decided to watch a live performance. This one. And now Im back to not liking them. Groups who lip sync arent worth watching. Im surprised vanessa even lip synced. This just shows the lack if talent they have and how success should and have gone to a group like Girls Aloud. I LOVE GIRLS ALOUD

  • most show performances are lip synced overseas. so it's nothing new...if you check out actual concert footage you can hear them live.

  • they are all so fit!! My favs are Rochelle Molly and Una in that order

  • What talent does this group possess just out of interest?

    Do they write their songs? I know one of them can play an instrument but what about the others?

    They aren't singing....

  • Check out their tour video's or acoustic sets on here. They are a really good group. I don't know why they lip sync sometimes cause they can sing live. Several of them play an instrument as well =P

  • @raphaelnik three of them play the guitar and vanessa has been in the theatre since she was small so they are talented like..... just sometimes they cant sing live

  • @louiseyheartsbuble10 Mollie and Una play guitar right? who's the other one? :P

  • @JenniferSilvaOday umm i think its frankie

  • @raphaelnik

    They've written 6 of their own songs and are doing that more often now. 3 of them play guitar. They've done some amazing live performances. This isn't one of them (but i still enjoy this choreography) however, the day before this performance was comic relief night and they were fantastic live. They all have really nice individual voices.

  • They look like a bunch of saleswoman from H&M or New Look

  • @Yeaahright no they don't

  • @Yeaahright thats what saleswomen look like??? wow O__O

  • ok so maybe theyre not the best live with the whole lipsyncing thing. but they dance awesome, look GORGEOUS, and their music is ace. in my opinion = they are awesome. :)

  • they're miming singing, right?

  • what the hell is up with frankies hair? she looks freakin ridiculous! she cant sing for shit! shes annoying! she dreses terribly! shes ugly! she also wears wayyy too much makeup!

  • GOD i agree with u 100%

  • If thats the first blonde girl that sings then she proli slept with their manager jus to get in the group

  • oh shut up.

    that would make mollie a lesbian :')

    seriously, we get it,you hate them

    no need to slag off mollie, shes amazing and the most down to earth out of them all.

  • They're a talent group , love them! i likes frankie hair styles , my opinions is better than girls aloud sorry if you like girl alouds .There lives singing is so GOOD!

  • They remind me of the pussycat dolls, but I like them :) They're lip syncing in this one.. too bad.

    The ''Whoa'' wasn't impressive though. haha how embarrassing.

  • omg!! why do everybody have to compare GA with the sats. they are both good, in different ways. doesn't matter if girls aloud lipsync or not. doesn't matter if the sats aren't good live. GA have worked hard to get wher they are now. and the sats r new. they will get better to. they work hard, to achiev this all. so just let them be. and stop talking shit about them. and comperin.

  • aaw :/ this was no their best performance. but still, that doesn't mean they don't have talent. they could go playback cause maybe one had a soar throat?

    and plus, it was a crappy sound.

    the sats rule!

  • Mollie can never seem to do that Wohoooaa bit at the beginning LOL. They should have got one of the other girls to do it

  • LOOOL @ that "WOAAAHHH" Molly attempted to do at the beginning

  • Um, they're MIMING. GA never mime.

  • ROFL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • i like the saturdays but frankie NEVER sings, like the odd line yeah but i think theyre talented

  • ahhh terrible

  • err this isnt live its just them singing with a backing track.....

  • Roch, Frankie and possibley Vanessa's bit are live with backing track FOR SURE

  • i dont think mollie was suppose to song that bit , cause then she started to mime.Seriously.. If ur gonna be on the show then you need to sing live init.

  • you can tell they didnt want to mime :(

  • Why they don't sing live? Oh, I know: they CAN'T!

    And I think they can't dance.

    GIRLS ALOUD are sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooo

    much BETTER!!!

  • I absolutly hate to, but I agree. Im not a fan of girls aloud, (trust me!), but they can sing and dance, atleast from the little I have seen. I do much prefer the saturdays songs though. They beat GA hands down with that, but performance wise they are terrible compared.

  • for some reason the saturdays have never been able to sing this song live. but if you listen to chasing lights or issues live acoustic on here, i mean wow, that really proves their talent.

  • watch?v=slt9PQHEllk

  • for some reason the saturdays have never been able to sing this song live. but if you listen to chasing lights or issues live acoustic on here, i mean wow, that really proves their talent. Girls Aloud are just as good, but you have to admit even they have their songs that they can't sing very well, e.g the promise, and this is theirs.

  • No actually.. i think they both are equal alright

  • They look like a bunch of tacky hairdressers doing kareoke.

    :/

  • its bad for an up and coming band to lip sync. its so obvious awel. they were reliii bad wen i saw them live on telly th other day, reli out of tune!

  • what awful miming!

  • I like the saturdays, but they always seem uncomfortable when it comes to dancing. When I saw them on radio 1 live lounge, they looked comfortable just playing a guitar and singing-either way they are still talented.

  • Surely to be a singer you first HAVE to be able to sing well. They girls are shite. The only thing going for them is their fuckability.

  • I agree, and they dont even have much of that tbh.

  • фанерщици только в начале и в конце слышны голоса настоящие

  • they shud sing live all im sayin.

  • that blonde girl is STUNNING!!!!!

  • shes mollie n she is stunning

  • They dont choose to mime they are told to.

    Love The Sats :)

  • it's a shame they mimed, they're good singers

  • yes but sometimes if your dancing you have to lip sing because. it hard to do both!

  • Comment removed

  • i think vanessa sang live but def nooot mollie

  • girl aloud are good the saturdays are fake its about the dancing there not reeli singing there voice gets edited to make them sound good the dont sing live they put there cd on and and pretended so get ure fucking facts right

    x

  • LMAO! I love Mollie so much, but she makes me laugh when I see how she looks compared to the way she opened this song! I love them so much. They could be so successful in the states! COME TO THE STATES GIRLS!!!

  • love it how old are they?

  • love this song

  • wow the begining was shit !but good song

  • init

  • frankie n rochelle (i think) were in S Club Juniors

  • yep they were, and rochelle presented smile on cbbc at one point

  • how is it genetically possible for frankie to be that hot

    if they came to america they would be hot

  • I love itttttttttttttt =)

  • i was listening to that when i booked

    the ticketss to go see emm :D:D:D:D

  • Mollie! That miming was so obvious hahaha. I still love them. They're gorgeous. And a few of them actually sing well live..not that you'd know lmao x

  • stop hating for god sake,

    you must have a pretty boring life to sit at your computer to comment about someone you dont even know,

    and they dont want to be like PCD or GA they have there own style?

    and tbh they can dance but people have differnt veiws, but really, is it about the dancing? no.

    and fair enough you might not like them but why comment on one of there videos being all mean and nasty? its not needed is it?

    sorry,

    great video btw!

    ox

  • shit miming silly tarts

  • they are a shite version of girls aloud

    the saturdays can't sing

    apart from Vanessa shes got a good voice

    they can't dance haha

    0.53 ahahaa Frankie is soooo behind

    I liked them before this performance

    at least Girls Aloud can sing and dance!

    i can't even imagine how bad the work tour must be!!

  • shut the fuck up stop hating

  • Girls aloud are shit live did you see them on paul o grady?

  • Only joking they are amazing

  • much better than saturdays

  • well at least they are hot! lol

  • Im sure thats the cd and they are lip sinkin

  • tey cant :)

    the cant sing either :)

  • but they cant dance