how come most of the covers i saw did it on the key of "G" when it was suppose to be Key of "C" as on Neil Youngs version. how did you get your chords? i'm not saying this is wrong but it's awefully unpresidented.
@edwin4759 You have to realize that people have to put any song in a key that is comfortable for their own voice. Neil has a high voice. I cannot sing the notes of this song in the key of C so a lower key, like the key of G, is a much better range for myself and other people.
@edwin4759 I don't know about awful but I'm a little surprised with the apparent obsession, if you google the chords, with different chords to Neil's studio version.
@Xenostrobe i know everything about his chords... i listened to him well enough to know play and sing most of his songs. too bad his range was too high for me.... and i do transposition too. my point is the guy's chord pattern here is somewhat odd
@edwin4759 Yeah, I don't think I was disagreeing... I knew the minor chord was Dm from playing along myself but when I google for chords they tend to be in different key... go figure
@Xenostrobe I've just worked it out, bit of a revelation... it wasn't a Neil Young original, well, fair enough then, that explains it. I probably should have known.
MANY thanks...I am 45 yo and just starting back playing after 25 years. I have the cords and are watching you play...still have problems with the strum but getting there. Kind regards
Good vocal and playing!
kentmotsinger 2 months ago
Man, that is one of my all time favourite songs and you do it great ! By the way nice Martin D-16 RGT ! It sounds awesome !
hosscash 1 year ago
Mate the way u play the guitar in this is absolutely brilliant..... Singing is not bad either!!
twynn1982 1 year ago
bravo!great job!
filavadrit 2 years ago
how come most of the covers i saw did it on the key of "G" when it was suppose to be Key of "C" as on Neil Youngs version. how did you get your chords? i'm not saying this is wrong but it's awefully unpresidented.
edwin4759 2 years ago
@edwin4759 You have to realize that people have to put any song in a key that is comfortable for their own voice. Neil has a high voice. I cannot sing the notes of this song in the key of C so a lower key, like the key of G, is a much better range for myself and other people.
Amadeus1066 1 year ago
@Amadeus1066 i agree... didnt realize that would mean the wrong impression.. my apologies
yamaha4759 1 year ago
@Amadeus1066 i agree to that, my bad.... but that wasn't my point
edwin4759 1 year ago
@edwin4759 I don't know about awful but I'm a little surprised with the apparent obsession, if you google the chords, with different chords to Neil's studio version.
Xenostrobe 1 year ago
@Xenostrobe i know everything about his chords... i listened to him well enough to know play and sing most of his songs. too bad his range was too high for me.... and i do transposition too. my point is the guy's chord pattern here is somewhat odd
edwin4759 1 year ago
@edwin4759 Yeah, I don't think I was disagreeing... I knew the minor chord was Dm from playing along myself but when I google for chords they tend to be in different key... go figure
Xenostrobe 1 year ago
@Xenostrobe I've just worked it out, bit of a revelation... it wasn't a Neil Young original, well, fair enough then, that explains it. I probably should have known.
Xenostrobe 1 year ago
@Xenostrobe i guess i just didnt know what i was talking about.... my bad
edwin4759 1 year ago
du har aldrig hørt den med ian tyson ved du så heller ikk det ham der har skrevet den
catsovner 2 years ago
Jeg ved godt han har skrevet den og jeg har også fået den hørt sammen med lidt andet Tyson. Tusind tak for linket.
bjarne66 2 years ago
Hey, it's Neil doing Neil! ie. Neil "Diamond" doing Neil "Young"!
clearvu1 3 years ago
Nice version of a classic song.Well done buddy.
tinhandle 3 years ago
Great rendition of this timeless classic!! I'll send you my rendition! 5*****
All1Song 3 years ago
MANY thanks...I am 45 yo and just starting back playing after 25 years. I have the cords and are watching you play...still have problems with the strum but getting there. Kind regards
xGothicMoonx 3 years ago
Nice cover, I'll play the song also on You Tube! Nice cover from you! 5* greetz harry
harmusic 4 years ago
Is that a HD-35?
LJUNGWALD 4 years ago
No, it's a D16 rgt.
BTW thanks for the nice comments - appreciated :-)
bjarne66 4 years ago
Beautiful!
deaconis 4 years ago
I like it, man.
FairWeatherfan999 4 years ago
A+ I've seen & heard Ian Tyson sing this song several times, you are right up there with him, keep singing buddy.
Dunitlucky 4 years ago
your singing and playing are so natural! Sounds beautiful!
morningjane 5 years ago
BEAUTIFUL!!! I LOVE it!
VronRN 5 years ago
Great job. Just noticing the other covers out here now and yours is nice.
LeilaniRocks 5 years ago
nice - we sang this song on the bus with my buddys guitar on baseball roadtrips
Greg16SK 5 years ago
Very nice
secretstrummer 5 years ago