this is a great cover, no matter if his voice doesn't sound like morisseys's voice. This is a cover, and isn't supposed to be like a Morissey's incarnation
It sounds too much like the original. And the singer doesn't capture the feeling of the song. And there are too many instrument players on the stage. Those are my only complaints.
i feel bands should only cover smiths if they can hit morrissey's notes, they shoulda just did joy division (prob atmosphere by the looks of win butler)
good band, prob the joy division of indie pop (which is very good to be compared to JD) but terrible cover mates
do the people deriding this cover have a clue about the mechanics of performing music? I can't help but think you're all entirely too preoccupied with the image and mystique of Morrissey to enjoy a fantastic band performing a classic Smith's song with conviction
0.o Smiths + Arcade Fire= the merging of two of the most important musical acts of all time, and two of my absolute favorite. Why didn't I know this existed before? I'm suprised this sad world didn't implode of an overdose of awesomeness all at once.
Any band has no business covering a bloody great song, no matter how good they think they are. I think it's just blasphemous and maybe even arrogant to even think they can come as close to the original band who sang and played the song.
@videoboooman Strange, isn't it? Though Morrissey sure hasn't a great voice (and be assured that I absolutely love The Smiths), few artists dare to cover their songs. And fewer still manage to come out with decent versions (either they're exactly alike, or they're a complete mess).
this is a great cover, no matter if his voice doesn't sound like morisseys's voice. This is a cover, and isn't supposed to be like a Morissey's incarnation
kitonn90 4 days ago
it sounds good and you know it!!
chacho6011 6 days ago
i love arcade fire and i LOVVVVE the smiths but im not in love with this cover :/
Diskotraxxxxx 1 week ago
Good crack at the guitar riffs. Can't say I'd do better.
AshmanGT 1 month ago
It sounds too much like the original. And the singer doesn't capture the feeling of the song. And there are too many instrument players on the stage. Those are my only complaints.
howsoonisnow93 1 month ago
Well done! Morrissey likes it - as I heard! :)
Fends 1 month ago
NO just NO
EvilEmpireStudios 2 months ago
The gang vocals are terrible other than that, pretty good cover.
MrHumphreyDavy 2 months ago
Listening to this cover makes me ill.
Mitcg 2 months ago 2
fuckin fail lol
StoneyX213 2 months ago
obviously no-one beats The Smiths but this is a good cover.
bababoum 2 months ago
Musically a good cover but I'm just not feeling his vocals on this.
simonsaintgilles 2 months ago
Only Morrissey guys, only Morrissey.
joseitsme 2 months ago
i feel bands should only cover smiths if they can hit morrissey's notes, they shoulda just did joy division (prob atmosphere by the looks of win butler)
good band, prob the joy division of indie pop (which is very good to be compared to JD) but terrible cover mates
mncr
JoddTamison 2 months ago
great cover. and i dont even like these guys.
MrFightinghellfish 2 months ago
not my cup of tea
caseyramone 3 months ago
I really think this is a good cover. I Love The Smiths. I Love Arcade Fire. great to combine the two
PastPrinciple 3 months ago 5
I don't particularly care for this cover, but I give this band kudos for having good enough taste in music for wanting to cover The Smiths.
satchmodan 3 months ago
Don't focus on the quality, focus on the fact!!
cvs84 3 months ago
do the people deriding this cover have a clue about the mechanics of performing music? I can't help but think you're all entirely too preoccupied with the image and mystique of Morrissey to enjoy a fantastic band performing a classic Smith's song with conviction
thequagmire421 3 months ago
5 out of ten and i like them.
dirkbogarde44 3 months ago
0.o Smiths + Arcade Fire= the merging of two of the most important musical acts of all time, and two of my absolute favorite. Why didn't I know this existed before? I'm suprised this sad world didn't implode of an overdose of awesomeness all at once.
IndieMusicFan13 3 months ago
only morrissey can sing songs morrissey wrote
Jackwell1029384756 3 months ago 3
I like their Smiths version, but I still prefer Arcade Fire playing guns of brixton because was quite different than the original.
iesus68 3 months ago
why the fuck does everyone think this sucks? The Smiths are my favorite band in the entire world and I think this is an awesome cover
bassplayer1617 4 months ago 5
At least Win looked really happy performing it.
ddubs123 4 months ago
music aint bad,but he is not even close to a Morrisey,not even in the same realm,
evelskunny 4 months ago
Butchers!
zweiosterei 4 months ago
Comment removed
edenobrien 4 months ago
Not great.
Or maybe it's just the recording's sound?
Damalycus 4 months ago
I just died a bit...... that was bad.
TheUntouchablezzzzz 4 months ago
the top two comments are contradictive
Dguillotine 5 months ago 4
arcade fire and The Smiths doesn't fit for me.
taila1976 5 months ago
respect to Arcade Fire for their taste in music :)
OToMb 5 months ago
@YaSoshlaSUma95 It's a lesser of several evils.
UnderTheAffluence 5 months ago
such a beautiful cover
jprigotto 6 months ago
Comment removed
jprigotto 6 months ago
good choice, guitar is ok
bvrzum 6 months ago
really good cover they got the guitar part just right
chrlskrkl 6 months ago
Any band has no business covering a bloody great song, no matter how good they think they are. I think it's just blasphemous and maybe even arrogant to even think they can come as close to the original band who sang and played the song.
mistergrin 6 months ago
AWFUL
utubes4noobs 6 months ago 8
2 of my 3 favourite bands in one video
ymechaie 6 months ago
bloody awful
MrStelord 7 months ago
Fuckers. Don't cover the Smiths
michelcollet 7 months ago 6
Arcade Fag
SERPENTSEEKER 7 months ago
Arcade Fire covering The Smiths :D Awesomee!
Friggin Bombaliciouss <3
Zfagster 7 months ago
I dunno, i'm not buying Win Butler as a tortured soul.
fadeintoyou77 7 months ago 2
Morrissey is god and the only potential man to replace him is ian curtis
rubezmess1 7 months ago
God this is fucking horrible. lol Why just why?
Nigelxman 7 months ago
I love how the crowd adds in the ohs
LIZnumber10 7 months ago
I don't think this is a shit cover, certainly not as good as The Smiths, but they still did it justice.
nokturnal5647 7 months ago 2
My two favourite bands of all time :)
markieowen4eva 8 months ago 3
I actually think his voice sounds really good for this style of music.
Angrynudfo 8 months ago 4
Horrible!
extracashnow 9 months ago
i like arcade fire, but there's nothing to compare with morrissey's voice. at least he could have danced like morrissey (:
kat9213 9 months ago
No way, this is amazing.
epr01pk 11 months ago
HOLY SHIT the smiths and arcade fire i shat myself
chrlskrkl 11 months ago
lost all my love for them
kildunne 11 months ago 2
cunts
ilolindafaceofdanger 1 year ago 2
This made me fall in love with Arcade Fire a bit more.
MrThisisolidixon 1 year ago 40
When will people learn to never cover the Smiths
videoboooman 1 year ago 131
@videoboooman Strange, isn't it? Though Morrissey sure hasn't a great voice (and be assured that I absolutely love The Smiths), few artists dare to cover their songs. And fewer still manage to come out with decent versions (either they're exactly alike, or they're a complete mess).
peterpuck365 9 months ago
@videoboooman I completely agree. Lol! But you have to give credit to Arcade Fire for having The Smiths as inspiration. I would, if I could sing. XD
ZeroYuuki17 1 month ago
@videoboooman /watch?v=OrgKtFVKTmI
StripedWhiteJet 1 month ago
@videoboooman you heard the cover of headmaster's ritual by radiohead? Fucking awesome.
DocSandwiches 1 week ago
@videoboooman Thank you, I have never heard one that has work at all.
thegoldenarmkid 5 days ago
@videoboooman Apparently you haven't heard Radiohead's Headmaster Ritual cover.
RainbowsAndSwaztikas 3 days ago
Inmense!!
Hamiltroll 1 year ago
Thank you for uploading this!! x
cazishere 1 year ago
wow, that was dope..
morbius13 1 year ago