'beguiled' is pronounced be-giled (not be-gwiled) and 'vexed' is said with a 'v' sound, not a 'w' sound.
Oh my god, your voice is pure honey... you must already be a performer... and if not, WHY NOT!? You have such a gift and you should be sharing it with the world!
You have good tonal quality. I'm not sure if you're trying to sound like Ella Fiztgerald or not. If you are, I would recommend you just try to sound like yourself. Nobody can compare to Ella and if you try to immitate her, you open yourself up to unnecessary criticism. By the way, check the pronounciation of the word beguiled.
I'm not sure if you are listening to the recording or not, but if you are not...you've done an excellent job of keeping the tonal center. This is a very good recording except for the noise. Please try turning your mic down, and this may help. I'll be subscribing to your channel so I can hear more of recordings. Your voice is very soothing. (Tough song though) I want to hear more of the story in the song though. More than notes and words.
Really. When a music or film critic says he/she thinks a piece of work is very bad, is that constructive criticism? Is he/she trying to explain to the performer or the film director how they can improve it? No.
But here's some constructive criticism for Cey: don't give up your day job.
Really. Music / film critics worth the name don't just say "this d00d suxx0rz", they critique.
Yahwhous either doesn't understand or care what "constructive criticism" means. Constructive criticism is trying to help the person do even better by noting what aspects they can improve.
What you're doing isn't constructive criticism, it serves no other purpose than to show that you're just mean--which I'll bet you already knew, and probably very few other people care to know. Move along, troll.
So only praise without analysis (of which there are many examples below) is permitted?
Anway here is my analysis: Cey's pitch control is poor, her enunciation is fuzzy, her voice lacks the range and tonal color necessary to make it warm and engaging.
She should work with a voice coach to improve (and should be herself rather than impersonating a once-in-a-lifetime talent like Ella Fitzgerald)
At least now you've given her something to work with--or reject.
I find her voice warm and engaging--but then, these are subjective qualities.
Maybe this really is her own vocal style.
Soft enunciation--I think I can hear what you're describing. Might be due to the singer working in a 2nd language. I don't insist on any particular accent of English--I'm fine with her being herself, rather than impersonating someone else's English. :-)
you have some strange pronunciations, but your voice does have a certain quality that's very similar to Ella's. I definitely think you've got talent, and your voice is extremely enjoyable to listen to!
I think American Idol is making people forget what good singing is. I admire this lady's taste in music, but this is a decent amateur performance, nothing more.
When I play basketball, I make some lucky shots. It doesn't make me Michael Jordan.
If you don't believe me, listen to the real thing, on Ella's Rodgers and Hart Songbook, or one of the compilation albums.
imitation/shmimitation - I've never heard her version, but your voice is breathtaking. I hope you're doing more than just singing in youtube with it :)
So I guess, at this point I should not admit that "all I do is sing at home, record by the extremely primitive 'windows voice recorder', and upload to youtube" :o)
Thank you very much for your flattering comment... Yet, I have to admit that, it is not my "rendition", but "Rosemary Clooney"s... Unfortunately all I did was imitating her style and trying to sing like her... :o)
'beguiled' is pronounced be-giled (not be-gwiled) and 'vexed' is said with a 'v' sound, not a 'w' sound.
Oh my god, your voice is pure honey... you must already be a performer... and if not, WHY NOT!? You have such a gift and you should be sharing it with the world!
leananshae 3 months ago
GREAT SONG!!
Getrealpeeps 6 months ago
:Touched by your divine voice and interpretation!!! Thank you so much!!!
Andieshrink 1 year ago
I could see katie from x factor doin this song this weekend :) x
hbecca176 1 year ago
wonderful!!! big big respect! but your voice has got a bit more sexappeal than doris^^
Pudl13 1 year ago
wonderful!!! big big respect!
Pudl13 1 year ago
WOW I adore your voice. It is amazing. XX
MikeHudson65 1 year ago
You have good tonal quality. I'm not sure if you're trying to sound like Ella Fiztgerald or not. If you are, I would recommend you just try to sound like yourself. Nobody can compare to Ella and if you try to immitate her, you open yourself up to unnecessary criticism. By the way, check the pronounciation of the word beguiled.
erikzen1 2 years ago
I'm not sure if you are listening to the recording or not, but if you are not...you've done an excellent job of keeping the tonal center. This is a very good recording except for the noise. Please try turning your mic down, and this may help. I'll be subscribing to your channel so I can hear more of recordings. Your voice is very soothing. (Tough song though) I want to hear more of the story in the song though. More than notes and words.
D3master4 2 years ago
Love the song--the performance not so much.
Maybe when my Ella Fitzgerald CDs wear out I'll be interested in this imitation.
yahwhous 2 years ago
I love the song and Ella's performance. This performance is also very good.
Unconstructive criticism is worthless.
aptshr 2 years ago
Really. When a music or film critic says he/she thinks a piece of work is very bad, is that constructive criticism? Is he/she trying to explain to the performer or the film director how they can improve it? No.
But here's some constructive criticism for Cey: don't give up your day job.
yahwhous 2 years ago
Really. Music / film critics worth the name don't just say "this d00d suxx0rz", they critique.
Yahwhous either doesn't understand or care what "constructive criticism" means. Constructive criticism is trying to help the person do even better by noting what aspects they can improve.
What you're doing isn't constructive criticism, it serves no other purpose than to show that you're just mean--which I'll bet you already knew, and probably very few other people care to know. Move along, troll.
aptshr 2 years ago
So only praise without analysis (of which there are many examples below) is permitted?
Anway here is my analysis: Cey's pitch control is poor, her enunciation is fuzzy, her voice lacks the range and tonal color necessary to make it warm and engaging.
She should work with a voice coach to improve (and should be herself rather than impersonating a once-in-a-lifetime talent like Ella Fitzgerald)
Constructive enough for you?
yahwhous 2 years ago
Permission isn't an issue. Public forum.
At least now you've given her something to work with--or reject.
I find her voice warm and engaging--but then, these are subjective qualities.
Maybe this really is her own vocal style.
Soft enunciation--I think I can hear what you're describing. Might be due to the singer working in a 2nd language. I don't insist on any particular accent of English--I'm fine with her being herself, rather than impersonating someone else's English. :-)
aptshr 2 years ago
I should have written superb! Superb! xx
Jgerman 2 years ago
Yay Cey, GREAT JOB!!!!!!!
MamaJacqueroo 2 years ago
Brilliant, well done. I enjoyed singing along with you
TehCheese 2 years ago
Nice voice!
If you'd like feedback on what to polish, I'd say work on the English lyrics. Some examples:
On the blink, not on 'a' blink.
Beguiled: not be-gwyled
I've sinned a lot, I mean _a lot_, not 'I'm mean"
Vexed, not 'wexed',
Thank, not 'tank'
Bothered, not 'boddered'.
etc.
Stay with it!
aptshr 2 years ago
Sounds good. It's totally out of time though. If you're serious, you should get some Aebersold backing tracks and sing it up.
jobaba64 2 years ago
Beautiful...Ella would be proud 8^)
6celery8 2 years ago
I'd love to hear it with the accompaniment.
you have some strange pronunciations, but your voice does have a certain quality that's very similar to Ella's. I definitely think you've got talent, and your voice is extremely enjoyable to listen to!
imlagrlstieve 2 years ago
very good :)
Jgerman 2 years ago
I think American Idol is making people forget what good singing is. I admire this lady's taste in music, but this is a decent amateur performance, nothing more.
When I play basketball, I make some lucky shots. It doesn't make me Michael Jordan.
If you don't believe me, listen to the real thing, on Ella's Rodgers and Hart Songbook, or one of the compilation albums.
yahwhous 2 years ago
Wow, Why are you singing at home and not recording somewhere?
wint222 2 years ago
A le cappella. Bravo!!!
The passion and pitch slipping towards the end of this lengthy classic.
However, the trill in your voice is charming and don't try to emulate anyone except yourself by developing your own style.
Well done
jajomal 2 years ago
hey. u hav an awsome voice and r really good.
u dnt hav 2 listen 2 me, but just a tip, try singing with a metronome.
btw i love ur version!!
idntcare1111 3 years ago
This isn't Ella but you tried.
minieinstein319 3 years ago
Your voice is simply amazing.I HATE anyone who tries and fails to do justice Mizz Ella.You are amazing.
prawnbutters 3 years ago
lol - Phhhhhttt :)
cthulhuchan 3 years ago
Singing does not get better than Ella
buttsyrc8 3 years ago
Yes, but this sure as hell is not Ella, as anyone who has heard the original can tell you.
yahwhous 2 years ago
Have heard the songbooks etc - but am surprised when I listen again.
But still a good impression!
buttsyrc8 2 years ago
We agree it is an impression.
And we certainly agree on the Songbooks. They never get old--the kind of albums you'd want if you were stranded on a small island.
yahwhous 2 years ago
I would love to live on a small island and listen to Ella!
buttsyrc8 2 years ago
imitation/shmimitation - I've never heard her version, but your voice is breathtaking. I hope you're doing more than just singing in youtube with it :)
cthulhuchan 3 years ago
So I guess, at this point I should not admit that "all I do is sing at home, record by the extremely primitive 'windows voice recorder', and upload to youtube" :o)
exorbitantj 3 years ago
your voice is amazing!! beautiful rendition!
cthulhuchan 3 years ago
Thank you very much for your flattering comment... Yet, I have to admit that, it is not my "rendition", but "Rosemary Clooney"s... Unfortunately all I did was imitating her style and trying to sing like her... :o)
exorbitantj 3 years ago
This almost has the real lyrics :] I <3 this song. always have. Pal Joey has some lovely music.
nerdygal216 3 years ago
awesome. ella's version is my favorite
supergrrl5212 3 years ago
beautiful voice!
3muimui 3 years ago
Thank you very much :o)
exorbitantj 3 years ago