lots of the comments are BS, I mean, nevermind, people are smply too self serving to learn from other people.. so if you gonna leave a BS comment just keep them to youself.. Ikaw na ang hari at may alam ng lahat..
he does not treat them like wolves; in fact in one episode he asks help from someone else to try to rehabilitate wolf-dog breeds; that goes to show the difference between how you treat dogs and how you treat wolves.... he treat dogs like dogs, and the wolves he does not pretend to know about. he knows where he should be. :)
this man is amazing...he worked with my pit aussie mix and ever since i saw his work i keep applying it to my other dogs and new dogs...without fail it works. Emily turned out to be a great dog for those of you who haven't seen the full episode
@GoldEyedNickCLover, you are a liar. First make up your mind. He worked or you worked? And Emily is as aggressive as ever. He said so in the DW Ultimate Episode Guide book.
its a shame for national geographic to show such absolutely nonsens. This dog was not relaxing he almost couldnt breath - and doin gthis to an bracheocephal Kind of dog whithout having vets behind of you is so damn stupid. There will be the day one of them will die. But this as sure will not appear on the screans
@Jasemin1 Yes but this dog couldn't calm itself down. Like Cesar said, it saw fighting as the way to release the tension. This dog was not safe, it would have injured other dogs given the chance and that likely would have led to it being put down. The dog is happier at the end - it just had to get past feeling like she had to get rid of all the other dogs to have peace.
Dogs come from wolfs not humans,The number one biggest mistake dog owners can make with their dogs is to treat them like humans. The human race is such a kind, compassionate species that we tend to look at our canine companions as little humans. When in reality, they are canines and have a very different thought process. This is what differentiates mankind from other species in pack societies; there must be a specific order, from the leader on down to the last follower. Everyone has a place.
@MrsLeanneElliott As a dog behaviorist I agree that dogs need to be treated like dogs. Cesar Millan treats them like dumbed down wolves and there is a mountain of scientific evidence against his techniques. Dog operate quite differently than wolves, as dogs first separated to become scavengers and wolves still hunt in the pack. Dog breed, eat, forage, and explore the world differently than wolves. Looking at wolf behavior to explain dog behavior is like looking at chimps for how to raise kids.
The white dog is submitting to the alpha roll because of the placement of the lead/collar, high up on its neck, inhibiting breathing and possibly damaging the trachea. Milan's wife's 'Illusion' collar works on the same principle - discomfort and pain. Milan should be investigated for his methods. He knows nothing about modifying canine behaviour.
The white dog is submitting to the alpha roll because of the placement of the lead/collar, high up on its neck, inhibiting breathing and possibly damaging the trachea. Milan's wife's 'Illusion' collar works on the same principle - discomfort and pain. Milan should be investigated for his methods. He knows nothing about modifying canine behaviour.
Pitbulls are not bad. Out of all the pitbulls i have met i havent met a bad one. i have petted WEIGHT TRAINED pitbulls with the crazy ass muscles and they are as sweet as can be
I mean,I know that he has been very successful with hundreds of dogs,but it just seems like sometimes,he's very aggressive with dogs that aren't . A lot of the dogs get aggressive when he nudges or kicks them in the groin area.Then he claims that they're "in the red zone" because they try to attack him. If you were kicked in your groin I think you might get a little mad too.My dog is naturally pretty calm and if I kicked him, he would get mad. That's a normal response.
no, your are... your completely incorrect... dogs dont think like humans for one thing, so you cant compare our reaction to theirs, and he doesnt nudge them for nothing, he nudges them to correct their behavier... idiot
@reesy1251 you are wrong . Decades of studies shows that humans like many other animals react in very similar ways and like many other animals - including humans - dogs often respond to violence with violence
@AboutDogTraining3 i like the thing that you said "dogs often respond to violence with violence". so if the "kicking" is violent then the dog should respond with violence too, but they didn't respond that way.
@YuberSepiroth. Emily did respond with violence. That's why up to this day she is attacking dogs. I've already mentioned temporary suppression through violence. Try to keep up.
my little dog acts like this, i roll him on his side and hold him down but he still flips out everytime we see another dog. what did ceaser do to stop the behavior?? treats?
i really hate the people who come to his videos trying to say he's wrong and whatever else. get your own videos, or shut up. he's amazing at what he does. he trains dogs, the way they would've been trained by another dog. dog psychology.
Well when i see you discipline your children like that, grabing their neck pushing their head to the ground. I will call the cops and you can be sure you will see your kids never again. Nothing else is this ... you will never see a Wolf or Lion discipline his pups like this. When a wolf is going for the neck bite he is normaly going to kill. And when the other is laying on his back and stops moving, he is not calming down.. he is gigving up and is ready to die.
@TROJANMICHAEL Are you crazy? Wild dogs discipline by nipping their young in the neck all the time. They also carry their young by the nap of the neck. And submission does not mean they're ready to die. Instead, they're saying, you win! You're the better leader! You need to actually research before you make comments.
Also, as far as comments being made about disciplining children, I think you're trying to be too literal. Humans have proper forms of disciline that work & animals have theirs.
I've trained pitbulls for most of my life, and he obviously had no idea what he was doing. I cannot believe how many of you defend this idiot... It makes me ill just thinking about it. I've trained a fight exposed pitbull to become a service dog for the mobility impaired.... They don't deserve this kind of treatment even if she is lunging. There are tons of ways to train and calm down dogs that doesn't require this kind of behavior.
"There are tons of ways to train and calm down dogs that doesn't require this kind of behavior."←I agree with you, but it seem a lot of people is OK with training dogs by using physical harm and scare tactics. >_>
Nothing about that came close to hurting that dog, people are waaayy oversensitive and don't want to understand the nature of things. Dogs are real %100 of the time and only respond to what is natural, not what people want reality to be.
Half of the people here blaming Cesar for his methods never had to deal with an unstable dog, or a powerful breed. I'm curios what would they do in front of a 5 year old unbalanced rottweiler and how would they train the dog in the long run. What Cesar does is very natural, and in order to change a behavior so obsessive as Emily's you have to practice something that is intense enough to snap her out of the drive. What would you like him to do?
like cesar always says. Never release frustration on an animal. or any living creature.. I would have to say its better not to feel frustration at all. But what he is doing to the dogs is NOTHING compared to what Dogs do to each other to correct one a another. He's just being firm and dominant.
@AboutDogTraining3 Sorry for the delay. Got sucked into work and have been working insane hours for months. Anyway I don't get any lore from anyone. I don't let people influence my decision. I see things for myself. Instead of watching TV and getting an idea from that I do my own work. I own a wolf dog. I work with him constantly. I watch him constantly. He has a very high prey drive and his wolf side shows but I work with it. If you were a real dog trainer you would understand.
don't really get it why people have to be so over dramatic over professional job here.Seriously , even you were a kid , parents have to teach you through certain discipline and stuff, it's more of a question you wanna teach them the right way they should be or you want them to be a spoil child and being send off for a death penalty before anyone even really try to help them out?
I really dont understand why Cesar always use chokecollars of any kind. This dogs behaviour reminds me of my dog when he see another male. and when I used chokecollar on him, it just got worse, witch you can see at 1,25 in this clip, where the dog aims its behaviour towards the leash/Cesarm due to the collar being tensed and limiting his breathing even more. Its more panic in this case than agression. All animals struggle to get free if they are being choked, even humans.
@NaurDulin i remember him saying he prefers not to use choke chains, but he often uses what the owner has and what makes them more comfortable, and i think this was an early episode before he made the illusion collar which he uses a lot more in his recent episodes.
@MrsLeanneElliott true , and some people see them as shit and just hit and abuse the dogs, i have nothing but respect for animals , animals do NOTHING wrong , its the people who do EVERYTHING wrong, im a human myself lol but i hate humans compared with real animals
@MrsLeanneElliott i know, same case here at my home, i took my dog of the street and u can see and feel he gives all hes love to us, its like he knows we are taking good care of him , some dogs behave without anny training or strong hand , but some dogs need to be corrected and some people dont know how. but i believe if the dog does something wrong its not their fault but ours. i just hate when they "need" to kill an animal just cuz the humans did something wrong and got attacked, a bit sad..
@StrayGhostWolf yes we are animals and like all animals dogs too need rules and teaching like you do with children. People who do not teach their dogs rules and dress them up like babies have dogs that know no boundaries. Dogs are not children they are dogs and they want to be treated that way.I have two wonder dogs they are also well loved and we behaved.
@MsZoraZ A dog is an animal and does not possess the same reasoning skills as humans. They do have emotions, but their emotions are different than those of humans. They are simple creatures with instincts, and their emotions lack the complex thought process. They feel joy when they know you are pleased, they feel sad when someone dies. However, they do not premeditate; do not plan ahead and do not dwell in the past or future. They live for whatever is happening at the moment.
@MrsLeanneElliott, your emotions are based on the same architecture as a dog. It's evolution. What you are suggesting doen't make any sense and has a lot of evidence against it.
@MrsLeanneElliott I do not agree with that. My dog clearly remembers some of what he experienced as a puppy. When I was very young he pooped on the floor, I shoved his muzzle IN the poop and locked him in the bathroom with the poop still on his face. He NEVER pooped in the house again. Also around 12 or so he goes to the window because the mail truck is coming and he hates it. There are lots of little things that let me know he remembers and that he plans.
Reactions like my dog doenst need this handeling doenst say that in thsi case its unnesessarry... if a dog is not fed up well with respect, rules, training exercise and affection... this kind of cases become of that... good to have cesar and his way, i have not seen any real violence from cesar.
Who objects to this methode should also give a right solution for this kinda dogs... but then it becomes very silent...
All you Cesar Millan Fans have no idea what you are talking about, you probably have never had a dog and should never be allowed to have one.
This guy has some very serious mental problems and he is no where near to communicating the DOGS WAY...Have you ever seen a dog strangle and suffocate another dog to teach him something? Do you thing anything that goes anywhere near this behavior even exists in nature??I can't believe such violence is tolerated in your country...
A consortium of 26 animal welfare organisations including the RSPCA, the Australian Veterinary Association, the Kennel Club and the British Veterinary Association, has written an open letter warning that Cesar Millan’s methods will lead to “pain and fear”, and are “not only unacceptable from a welfare perspective, but not necessary for the modification of dog behaviour”.
I have a fully grown Great Dane & a 5 month old Basset Hound. My dane gets fed up with the obnoxious puppy behavior from our basset & she pins him atleast once a day. She uses her teeth to get a good grip on his head when she does it (just because she has no opposable thumbs for a softer grip) but she really does pin him till he yips and calms down. then she lets him up and she naps in peace. Caesar IS comunicating the dogs way, he's just not using his teeth to do it.
@Jujuopea, she doesn't pin him. If the dog wanted to move, it could. What happens is that the dog willingly offers this behaviour and the behavior is finished ritualized by the fake 'bite'
If this were to really happen we would see one dog ending up dead.
If you try his techniques at home you'll cause more psychological damage to your dog and probably get bitten! He is a dangerous dog trainer! The reason they "submit" is called learned helplessness!
? Dogs are not fragile if he were training cats he'd do it differently the reason why this works on dogs is because this is how dogs behave towards each other. This dog would probably be put to sleep for biting someone if not for him are there really people out there who are clueless to the point of thinking this is improper technique?
Oh please he didn't choke it until it became unconscious he simply just pinned the dog down until it calmed down. A dog can only stay in that state of mind for so long until it becomes tired and then submits. Besides dogs do this kind of thing to their pups, wolves in the wild use methods that are a lot like this it's just the same with any living creatures I mean WE discipline our children right well this is how dogs do it with their children.
@HarvestStation When have you ever seen a dog do this to another dog? tell me please? This does NOT happen in the wild, mainly because dogs are NOT wild animals - there domesticated - and as such your example is invalid.
As for wolves - they are a completely different species - so equating wolf behaviour and dog behaviour is again completely invalid. Like comparing Homo sapiens sapiens and Homo erectus
At dog training. At the end we let loose the dogs and let them play. Some dogs bother the other dogs and the dog will pin the other down which means it is telling the other dog that is invading it's space to cut it out and leave them alone. None of the dogs get hurt, they simply sort out amongest themselves who is top dog and so on it's what they do. Anyway if Cesar was being cruel to these dogs don't you think that the Animal protection agency will be stepping in.
@HarvestStation Well to be Frank I have never seen any such thing, barking - biting maybe, but not clutching the throat and slamming another dog to the ground until the other dog shuts down and just lies there.
As for your last point, there is:- only every single Animal protection agency worth it's salt is stepping in.
@HarvestStation have you ever seen dogs with their pups? I have and I've NEVER seen them doing that to their puppies. If one get's too hyper they show signals with their body / voice, but they won't immediately catch them. I've once seen a mother dog catch the pup. She fixated it's head with her mouth for maybe 4 seconds. That's it. It's a fairy tale that dogs behave this way with their puppies. And btw. we are NO dogs.
@Kuddebrunzer no youre not a dog, but you apply dog psychology TO THE DOG because the dog doesnt understand human psychology. Were you watching the mother dog 24 / 7? You must have glimpsed a few minutes of her training her pups. If you have, you would see that if she wouldnt put up with a behavior, she does the simple biting thing to assert herself. Thats how I saw the mother of my dog blackie does it :)
"How do you think pups in the wild are raised?"←Do you have wolves as pets? Because dogs are a bit different from wolves.
"In the wild how it works is the strongest is leader and they take control because they feel stronger than the rest"←Wrong, in the wild, the mating wolves couple are leaders by nature, the born puppies obey the parents just like your mom and dad are leaders and you obey them. There is no fight to be the strongest, watch this video: watch?v=tNtFgdwTsbU
Because I have seen what happens when people treat dogs like they are a human being. My auntie has a Westie and she spoiled it rotten and now it thinks it owns the house and growls at people for no reason what so ever.
Dogs are not people. The only thing that dogs and human children have in common is that they both need discipline and be taught what is right and wrong. Yes training your dog with treats is good but what do you do when your dogs bites someone? Give it a treat and say 'good boy/girl'? No you need to teach them that what they did was wrong. Cesar's methods DO WORK and they DON'T harm the dog, if it did Cesar wouldn't still be working on TV now would he?
"training your dog with treats is good but what do you do when your dogs bites someone?"←You tell the dog that he/she did something wrong, and you train him to not bite in a safe environment.
"Cesar's methods DO WORK"←I'm not saying that they don't, but they are cruel and abusive.
"DON'T harm the dog"←FACT: kicking and alpha roll are harmful for the dog.
"Cesar wouldn't still be working"←MJ molested kids/teens and he still had a job.
I meant he still wouldn't have a job involving animals and anyway how can you be so sure that MJ even molested children/teens? Did you know him personally? No I don't think you did so stop accusing him of doing something that he may not have even done in the first place.
Dr. Sophia Yin: She lectures and teaches workshops internationally on animal behavior and has served as a behavior expert for shows such as Dogs 101 on Animal Planet. She is on the executive board for the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior, the American Association of Feline Practitionern, Handling Guidelines Committee, and the American Humane Association, Animal Behavior and Training Advisory Committee.
►Are you saying she is mistaken to think that dog is aggressive?
@DogsneedpIeasuretoo it may be aggressive (since almost all dogs are) but she was giving treats to a dog which isn't in its red zone. I want to see someone try to calm a really aggressive adult pitbull with food. You know very well that the dog in this video will not accept any sort of treat during 1:23 - 1:34
"I want to see someone try to calm a really aggressive adult pitbull with food."←You can mail Dr. Sophia Yin with this link and ask her if a dog like that can be trained to be a nice dogs by using threads. Why don't you do that? Bet you 1$ that she will say "yes it is possible"
PS: Do you have any evidence that this dog can't be trained with threats?
I wouldn't bother trying to argue with DogsneedpIeasuretoo because I just took a look at his profile and he's more than just your average dog lover which is what I thought at first before I took a look at his profile O_o. This guy is a sick individual.
I'm zoosexual and that is not a sickness, it is a sexual orientation, like heterosexuality, homosexuality and bisexuality. None of them are sickness.
And my sexual orientation has nothing to do with my arguments, so stop with the red herring and don't change the subject to something that has nothing to do with my arguments.
I have nothing against heterosexuality, homosexuality or bisexuality but I'm against zoo sexuality, if you ask me it's another form of animal abuse and it should be illegal. I'm not referring to homosexuality as a sickness but zoosexual?! It's just completely wrong. I'm an animal lover but seriously it's just complete wrong to be sexually attracted to animals.
I thought he was just one of them overly protective animal lovers that let their pets get away with everything but when I saw his profile I just couldn't believe it O_O
But I'm one overly protective animal lovers that lets his pet get away with everything. XD
Don't know why people freak out so much, dogs have natural sex urges, is the human responsibility to take care of the dog urges, that includes the sexual urges too. Dog owners has to do many gross things like picking up dog poop, is part of the job of being a responsible owner, you can't saw "ewww gross I won't do that" that would just set the dog on a "less happy" environment.
You shouldn't have a sexual relationship with a dog or any animal for that matter and besides if your dog is lonely or has sexual urges then get it a mate, simple. It's like when I go to buy or adopt a puppy or kitten or even fully grown dogs or cats, I don't get just one I get two because then when you are not home they won't feel lonely and also if there's a male and a female then they can mate.
I personally don't care. Dogs mate and then there's puppies, it's the circle of life. If you don't want puppies then get them fixed, if that's not your cup of tea then don't get them fixed and just let them reproduce.
Of course I care, when did I say I didn't care? You must of misunderstood me I meant I didn't care if one of my dog has puppies not that I don't care about any unwanted puppies or stray's out there. My family have on any occasions took in dogs that we have found on the street. Of course we rung the dog warden to file that we found a lost or stray and we would look after it until after 30 days if no one claims it then we have kept them.
I'm trying to tell you that I can't take care of puppies or any more dogs, having a bitch for him is not a solution for me, my hand (or other body parts) solves the problem easily and in a cheap way.
Is none of your business how I take care of my doggy needs, specially because I'm not harming him in any way, if you ant to mutilate your dogs sexually (to avoid dealing with their sex urges) or you are rich to have litter after litter, go for it, but that is not an option for me.
It's still wrong to have a sexual relationship with an animal, it's just not natural. Gay relationships are fine they are between 2 people of the same kind, humans but a human and animal, it's just wrong. I think of my pets as my friends but that's it, having a sexual or not relationship is simply unthinkable. Dogs commonly hump but sometimes it's not because they have a sexual urge, sometimes it means that they are showing dominance over another.
"it's just not natural"←It is natural, everything that exist in the universe is natural, This video explains it: watch?v=-jrh8VVwMI4
Also, on youtube, you can find videos of dogs having sex or trying to have sex with humans, cats, sheeps, tigers, goats, pigs, ducks, etc. Interspecies sex has been reported in hundreds of species, that means it is natural.
I respect what ever sexual orientation you may have, why can't you respect my sexual orientation?
You could catch something from the animal by having sex with it. I know humans can catch things off other humans like HIV etc. but I mean because of the difference in species and the sperm or egg. (Sorry it's hard to type what I mean but I hope you understand what I'm trying to say)
Thanks for worrying about me, but the only think I can catch are fleas or ticks. XD
My dog is fully vaccinated and dewormed, so he doesn't have any zoonosis that can make him sick or make me sick.
PS: Diseases are not a reason to stop peope from having sex, sex between humans is way more dangerous, you can catch over 60 STDs and hundreds of Non-STD diseases by having sex with a human. If my dog where not vaccinated and dewormed, I would have the risk of catching only 10 zoonosis.
"But there is nothing that you can catch because of the difference in species?"←Yes, there are like 10 or so dog zoonosis (those are diseases that can go from animal to human) but like I said before, dogs gets vaccinated against those zoonosis, dogs also get dewormed and given baths against fleas and ticks, so is is very hard to get sick from a home owned healthy dog.
what I´m concerned with that what if this dog becomes a ticking time bomb following this kind of training methods. Sure you may be able to walk the dog easier for a while, but then what if one pretty day when the owners least expects it, the dog attacks another dog that's walking past. Dogs do have a good memory and if the owners are abusive they will remember it and it might lead into loss of trust and respect towards their owner. Dog owner has to earn the trust but it can be lost quite fast.
That dog is being abused, i do not care what you call it! Abuse is abuse! And i do not think that an unconcious dog learns anything from this torture!
Cesar says 'never let the dog walk in front' and I disagree with that. The dog that is the leader does not always walk in front. Wolf and dog packs often travel in miscellaneous or varying order- but the leader usually decides which way they are going, and he doesn't have to be in front to do it. When wolves hunt, it is not always the pack leader which selects the hunting route- it can be a lower ranking animal, who may happen to be a better hunter. Canids are complex with complex behaviors.
the man is acting like he has no balls. Tell that fucking dog to behave like you mean it and be prepared to get physical. My dog lunged tried to bite a guy( I believe the guy was asking for it) and I kicked him in the ribs. It's the only time I ever struck my dog and I did it because it was an emergency. You don't stand there saying in a sissy voice 'stop, stop nowI said. Talk like you mean business and follow it with force if neccessary. An impending attack is definitely an emergency.
Yeah, hanging a dog by the most sensitive part of its neck and then slamming it on the ground is the best way to train. I know; I've seen this tv entertainer with no credentials whatsoever doing it all the time. Plus he's always getting bitten, and that's how you know he's a real trainer. All those "certified animal behaviourists" who desensitise reactive dogs with positive reinforcement and don't ever get bitten, they're just pansies.
Kudos to him. I don't think I could handle a dog that aggressive. My little Blue Heeler's worst fault is pulling the leash when we walk. Other than that, she's pretty laid back and only poses a threat to squirrels, birds, butterflies, and sheep lol
@AboutDogTraining3 It sounds to me like you haven't really worked with dogs or wolves in a natural environment where there weren't people there to interfere? 'Cause it doesn't sound like you have. Wolves in the wild do that all the time. And I don't agree with EVERYTHING Cesar says/does. And he doesn't expect you to agree with EVERYTHING he says and does. There's different approaches for different people.
@Okuhou, the research of people who've been working on wolves for the past 50years and who have published more peer reviewed papers than you could ever read, confirm what I've stated.
It sounds like you get all your wolf lore from Millan and other unreliable sources.
@AboutDogTraining3 You're evil, get out of youtube. It feels like you're getting paid for saying bullshit stuff all the time. Cesar Millan is the best thing that ever happened to dogs all over the world. He changed the lives of so many dogs and humans as well, and you there post about 500 things about him being bad and everything. YOURE A DISGRACE. His technic work and so do yours, but like he says the most important thing is your energy.
@pokerfreak11 YOU ARE AN IDIOT. My energy is solar, hydroelectric, possibly nuclear. Millan has destroyed 2 decades of advancement in dog training with his simplistic, punitive approach. He is the worst thing to have happened to dogs.
@AboutDogTraining3 Wolves and dogs do a ton of things the same way! Wolves dominate by putting another wolf on the ground just like Cesar did and dogs do the same. Wolves ask for forgiveness by licking under the chin and dogs do the same. Also Human Psychology and dog Psychology is not the same. You can't sit and say "Okay Fido how did it feel when your old owner beat you?" They don't think back to that. The bad behavior isn't reprimanded properly so they think it's okay to keep doing it.
@Okuhou, you should stop getting your "info" from Millan. Neither dogs or wolves "dominate" and they don't put each other to the ground. It is a damn lie perpetrated by those who are trying to justify this draconian approach.
Human and Dog psychology out of necessity share many of the same traits... it's called evolution.
@AboutDogTraining3 Um... where did you get your facts from? I've seen dogs at the park who practice dominance and submission all the time. My dog is very submissive and will lay HERSELF on the ground to show she isn't going to challenge a bigger dog. Small chihuahua's have shown her the same respect if she gets too close. And Ceaser has an accent so english isn't his first language. Cut the guy some slack.
@ Aboutdogtraining3....Then why doesn't human psychology work for all Cesar's clients? They obviously are not doing something right..Go face to face with a growling pitbull and explain to him the reasons and consequences of his biting your face off...That he can kill you and then be put to sleep. Go ahead...and tape it for me...tell me if that part of human psychology is working for you.
@maculandia Is Cesar suppose to talk to the dog and tell him that he's not suppose to attack other dogs? thats stupid human psychology that doesn't work on dogs!
@cmy81685, human pyschology and "dog" psychology share many of the same traits. So human pyschology does work on dogs.
If you were a better thinker or knew more, it would be obvious.
There is a lot of room between talking and forcing... marine mammal trainers have been using these techniques for almost 50 years, it they have been proven effective in dogs.
This is not what I call educating a dog!! this is animal abuse, he's strangling the dog, anyone can do that!! education is a completly different thing
@maculandia - you're a total tool; let me guess- you're a chick!!! so, I'm assuming you use "please and thank you" with your dogs?? hahaha. Are you a dog trainer??
By the way, I don't see the dog being strangled.... restrained / subdues yes, abused-
@ContinuosChange -I have 3 dogo argentino and an amstaff and none of them has ever experienced this type of ABUSE, yet they are all well trained and behave normally.
There is no need to use this methods if you know how to handle a dog, fear is NOT a good teacher
@ContinuosChange I have 3 dogo argentino and an amstaff and none of them has ever experienced this type of ABUSE, yet they are all well trained and behave normally.
There is no need to use this methods if you know how to handle a dog, fear is NOT a good teacher
some people are so stupid. They think being firm is being abusive. Cesar is the best! He knows his shit.... hasnt found a dog yet he hasnt been able to rehibilatate
love caesar's methods, he works just like a pack leader. i think aboutdogtraining3 is obsessed with the dog whisperer, i haven't seen a video it hasn't commented on
In a situation like this, you need to be firm. Now if you have a sweet cuddly little dog (your lucky) who behaves, than don't, but for some dogs, this is the only thing that works.
Cesar's wife isn't hot at all. As a wife of a celebrity, she needs to be more attractive and in better shape. No wonder why they are getting a divorce.
I object to him on a number of levels, I have to say. His methods are based primarily on force, with little or no knowledge of what has caused the dog to be acting the way it's acting. He uses forceful methods on dogs who are very fearful, forcing them into situations where they become so overwhelmed with fear that they simply give up.
@MsLabMom Alright, fine. What would you do then? If his methods are so sinister, what would YOU do? Go on, say it. Let's hear from the Mom who knows dogs better than Cesar. Do you even own a dog? I'm sure it talks to you and explains that it doesn't like redirection. What would be better to you? A dog put to sleep because of aggression, or another chance at life thanks to some guidance? WHICH IS BETTER TO YOU?!
@KidAnime20, idiot the methods are very easy to follow. Look them up if you are truly curious. However they don't involve strangling the dog, Wresting the dog to the ground or shoving the dog's face into the thing that sets him off.
@AboutDogTraining3 I wasn't talking to you. And I hope you read and answer my last e-mail. I am aware that MsLabMom is ignoring everyone. It's clear to me that she's not different from you. But putting that aside... like i said, just answer he last e-mail I sent you, honestly.
lots of the comments are BS, I mean, nevermind, people are smply too self serving to learn from other people.. so if you gonna leave a BS comment just keep them to youself.. Ikaw na ang hari at may alam ng lahat..
guayaboso815 1 week ago
he does not treat them like wolves; in fact in one episode he asks help from someone else to try to rehabilitate wolf-dog breeds; that goes to show the difference between how you treat dogs and how you treat wolves.... he treat dogs like dogs, and the wolves he does not pretend to know about. he knows where he should be. :)
sylvantasybil 3 weeks ago
You a ass hole mother f@@ker u dog killa
50sandmann 1 month ago
this man is amazing...he worked with my pit aussie mix and ever since i saw his work i keep applying it to my other dogs and new dogs...without fail it works. Emily turned out to be a great dog for those of you who haven't seen the full episode
GoldEyedNickCLover 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@GoldEyedNickCLover, you are a liar. First make up your mind. He worked or you worked? And Emily is as aggressive as ever. He said so in the DW Ultimate Episode Guide book.
AboutDogTraining3 1 month ago
its a shame for national geographic to show such absolutely nonsens. This dog was not relaxing he almost couldnt breath - and doin gthis to an bracheocephal Kind of dog whithout having vets behind of you is so damn stupid. There will be the day one of them will die. But this as sure will not appear on the screans
Jasemin1 2 months ago
@Jasemin1 Yes but this dog couldn't calm itself down. Like Cesar said, it saw fighting as the way to release the tension. This dog was not safe, it would have injured other dogs given the chance and that likely would have led to it being put down. The dog is happier at the end - it just had to get past feeling like she had to get rid of all the other dogs to have peace.
jacqui835 1 month ago
Daddy: Chill the fuck out man! he's trying to help you
Other pit: Come on! Bring it!
dawgyo 4 months ago
Badass.
BlackFuryFx 4 months ago
cesar millan is great
007strager 4 months ago
Dogs come from wolfs not humans,The number one biggest mistake dog owners can make with their dogs is to treat them like humans. The human race is such a kind, compassionate species that we tend to look at our canine companions as little humans. When in reality, they are canines and have a very different thought process. This is what differentiates mankind from other species in pack societies; there must be a specific order, from the leader on down to the last follower. Everyone has a place.
MrsLeanneElliott 4 months ago
@MrsLeanneElliott Look up "Dr Karen Overall co-evolution" on youtube.
MsZoraZ 4 months ago
@MsZoraZ i did`nt say they are not like us but the truth is we want animals to feel the way we do and to be honest they don`t.
MrsLeanneElliott 4 months ago
@MrsLeanneElliott As a dog behaviorist I agree that dogs need to be treated like dogs. Cesar Millan treats them like dumbed down wolves and there is a mountain of scientific evidence against his techniques. Dog operate quite differently than wolves, as dogs first separated to become scavengers and wolves still hunt in the pack. Dog breed, eat, forage, and explore the world differently than wolves. Looking at wolf behavior to explain dog behavior is like looking at chimps for how to raise kids.
TVSheShe 3 weeks ago
@TVSheShe I agree with you. I don`t tend to agree with many of the ways he chooses to train animals.
MrsLeanneElliott 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I hate the Dog Whisperer. Victoria Stillwell all the way
emmaminiepink 5 months ago
The poor thing can barely breathe... You can hear it choking. :/
StrayGhostWolf 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The white dog is submitting to the alpha roll because of the placement of the lead/collar, high up on its neck, inhibiting breathing and possibly damaging the trachea. Milan's wife's 'Illusion' collar works on the same principle - discomfort and pain. Milan should be investigated for his methods. He knows nothing about modifying canine behaviour.
Duneenzo 5 months ago
The white dog is submitting to the alpha roll because of the placement of the lead/collar, high up on its neck, inhibiting breathing and possibly damaging the trachea. Milan's wife's 'Illusion' collar works on the same principle - discomfort and pain. Milan should be investigated for his methods. He knows nothing about modifying canine behaviour.
Duneenzo 5 months ago
Pitbulls are not bad. Out of all the pitbulls i have met i havent met a bad one. i have petted WEIGHT TRAINED pitbulls with the crazy ass muscles and they are as sweet as can be
TheArgenis1 5 months ago
I mean,I know that he has been very successful with hundreds of dogs,but it just seems like sometimes,he's very aggressive with dogs that aren't . A lot of the dogs get aggressive when he nudges or kicks them in the groin area.Then he claims that they're "in the red zone" because they try to attack him. If you were kicked in your groin I think you might get a little mad too.My dog is naturally pretty calm and if I kicked him, he would get mad. That's a normal response.
ruotolbr 5 months ago
@ruotolbr
idiot
reesy1251 5 months ago
@reesy1251 Why am I an idiot? Because I believe a certain way? Maybe you need to look in the mirror and see that YOU are the idiot talking.
ruotolbr 5 months ago
@ruotolbr
no, your are... your completely incorrect... dogs dont think like humans for one thing, so you cant compare our reaction to theirs, and he doesnt nudge them for nothing, he nudges them to correct their behavier... idiot
reesy1251 5 months ago
@reesy1251 you are wrong . Decades of studies shows that humans like many other animals react in very similar ways and like many other animals - including humans - dogs often respond to violence with violence
AboutDogTraining3 5 months ago
@AboutDogTraining3 i like the thing that you said "dogs often respond to violence with violence". so if the "kicking" is violent then the dog should respond with violence too, but they didn't respond that way.
YuberSepiroth 5 months ago
@YuberSepiroth. Emily did respond with violence. That's why up to this day she is attacking dogs. I've already mentioned temporary suppression through violence. Try to keep up.
AboutDogTraining3 5 months ago
@AboutDogTraining3
whatever m8, dont wanna start an argument
reesy1251 5 months ago
@trojanmichael: insolent fool! You can never compare kids to dogs, idiot!
agentcobra112 5 months ago
emily is a nice pittbull I need a girlfriend like her for my pittbull...
humilde9818 5 months ago
my little dog acts like this, i roll him on his side and hold him down but he still flips out everytime we see another dog. what did ceaser do to stop the behavior?? treats?
ktco83 5 months ago
i really hate the people who come to his videos trying to say he's wrong and whatever else. get your own videos, or shut up. he's amazing at what he does. he trains dogs, the way they would've been trained by another dog. dog psychology.
AllishunsRule 5 months ago
Well when i see you discipline your children like that, grabing their neck pushing their head to the ground. I will call the cops and you can be sure you will see your kids never again. Nothing else is this ... you will never see a Wolf or Lion discipline his pups like this. When a wolf is going for the neck bite he is normaly going to kill. And when the other is laying on his back and stops moving, he is not calming down.. he is gigving up and is ready to die.
University Berlin.
TROJANMICHAEL 5 months ago
@TROJANMICHAEL Are you crazy? Wild dogs discipline by nipping their young in the neck all the time. They also carry their young by the nap of the neck. And submission does not mean they're ready to die. Instead, they're saying, you win! You're the better leader! You need to actually research before you make comments.
Also, as far as comments being made about disciplining children, I think you're trying to be too literal. Humans have proper forms of disciline that work & animals have theirs.
kiwibaby02 5 months ago
yes they carry theyr pups by the neck but do not discipline them like that... not lions and not the wolfs.
you should do some research... ask official experts not self named experts like those on tv.
TROJANMICHAEL 2 months ago
Emily became even more aggressive. That's because you can't treat aggression with aggression.
AboutDogTraining3 5 months ago
I seen Emily on his later shows in Ceasars dog pack. I guess the owners gave up!!!
Bigtruck2007 6 months ago
I've trained pitbulls for most of my life, and he obviously had no idea what he was doing. I cannot believe how many of you defend this idiot... It makes me ill just thinking about it. I've trained a fight exposed pitbull to become a service dog for the mobility impaired.... They don't deserve this kind of treatment even if she is lunging. There are tons of ways to train and calm down dogs that doesn't require this kind of behavior.
TheBahaiGirl 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@TheBahaiGirl
"There are tons of ways to train and calm down dogs that doesn't require this kind of behavior."←I agree with you, but it seem a lot of people is OK with training dogs by using physical harm and scare tactics. >_>
DogsneedpIeasuretoo 6 months ago
The dog will be able to breathe better if it calms down, and Cesar will loose the leash. So stop saying he choke the dog.
MishalMooreLover 6 months ago
Nothing about that came close to hurting that dog, people are waaayy oversensitive and don't want to understand the nature of things. Dogs are real %100 of the time and only respond to what is natural, not what people want reality to be.
boulder000 6 months ago
i dont think you should get a big dog uf you dont have the will or the strength to show it that your the boss
brownfredster 7 months ago
Half of the people here blaming Cesar for his methods never had to deal with an unstable dog, or a powerful breed. I'm curios what would they do in front of a 5 year old unbalanced rottweiler and how would they train the dog in the long run. What Cesar does is very natural, and in order to change a behavior so obsessive as Emily's you have to practice something that is intense enough to snap her out of the drive. What would you like him to do?
IulianTu 7 months ago
At the End you Can still hear the cesar Shhht
;)
SuperMRAgent 7 months ago
like cesar always says. Never release frustration on an animal. or any living creature.. I would have to say its better not to feel frustration at all. But what he is doing to the dogs is NOTHING compared to what Dogs do to each other to correct one a another. He's just being firm and dominant.
nuxinq 8 months ago 8
Yup that's the way to them who's the leader of the pack.
nwl213 8 months ago
@AboutDogTraining3 Sorry for the delay. Got sucked into work and have been working insane hours for months. Anyway I don't get any lore from anyone. I don't let people influence my decision. I see things for myself. Instead of watching TV and getting an idea from that I do my own work. I own a wolf dog. I work with him constantly. I watch him constantly. He has a very high prey drive and his wolf side shows but I work with it. If you were a real dog trainer you would understand.
Okuhou 9 months ago
Comment removed
Okuhou 9 months ago
don't really get it why people have to be so over dramatic over professional job here.Seriously , even you were a kid , parents have to teach you through certain discipline and stuff, it's more of a question you wanna teach them the right way they should be or you want them to be a spoil child and being send off for a death penalty before anyone even really try to help them out?
peacfulkitty 9 months ago
the only thing I don't agree with is cesar's use of choke collars.
Blitzzyful 9 months ago
I really dont understand why Cesar always use chokecollars of any kind. This dogs behaviour reminds me of my dog when he see another male. and when I used chokecollar on him, it just got worse, witch you can see at 1,25 in this clip, where the dog aims its behaviour towards the leash/Cesarm due to the collar being tensed and limiting his breathing even more. Its more panic in this case than agression. All animals struggle to get free if they are being choked, even humans.
NaurDulin 9 months ago
@NaurDulin i remember him saying he prefers not to use choke chains, but he often uses what the owner has and what makes them more comfortable, and i think this was an early episode before he made the illusion collar which he uses a lot more in his recent episodes.
LostSoulWithoutHeart 9 months ago
What season/episode/series/DVD is this clip from? I need to see the full clip again. Thanks.
STiBLUES 10 months ago
the problem is people see dogs as PEOPLE and not dogs/pets
MrsLeanneElliott 10 months ago 35
@MrsLeanneElliott agree
MaeXXXerine 6 months ago
@MrsLeanneElliott amen
DownBeatTime 6 months ago
@MrsLeanneElliott yep that is the problem :(
56labeba 6 months ago
@MrsLeanneElliott true , and some people see them as shit and just hit and abuse the dogs, i have nothing but respect for animals , animals do NOTHING wrong , its the people who do EVERYTHING wrong, im a human myself lol but i hate humans compared with real animals
iAMoverLVL9000 6 months ago
@iAMoverLVL9000 hey i love my two boys they are my family but they have rules an they are good dogs if you train them with care they are loveable x
MrsLeanneElliott 6 months ago
@MrsLeanneElliott i know, same case here at my home, i took my dog of the street and u can see and feel he gives all hes love to us, its like he knows we are taking good care of him , some dogs behave without anny training or strong hand , but some dogs need to be corrected and some people dont know how. but i believe if the dog does something wrong its not their fault but ours. i just hate when they "need" to kill an animal just cuz the humans did something wrong and got attacked, a bit sad..
iAMoverLVL9000 6 months ago
@iAMoverLVL9000 oh i agree they are animals so why are people so shocked when they act like one lol x
MrsLeanneElliott 6 months ago
@iAMoverLVL9000 i totally agree with ur view
patilpooja392 5 months ago
@MrsLeanneElliott ... Dogs ARE like people... We're animal, too, in case you didn't know.
StrayGhostWolf 5 months ago
@StrayGhostWolf yes we are animals and like all animals dogs too need rules and teaching like you do with children. People who do not teach their dogs rules and dress them up like babies have dogs that know no boundaries. Dogs are not children they are dogs and they want to be treated that way.I have two wonder dogs they are also well loved and we behaved.
MrsLeanneElliott 5 months ago
@MrsLeanneElliott Dogs and people are more alike than any other two species.
MsZoraZ 5 months ago
@MsZoraZ A dog is an animal and does not possess the same reasoning skills as humans. They do have emotions, but their emotions are different than those of humans. They are simple creatures with instincts, and their emotions lack the complex thought process. They feel joy when they know you are pleased, they feel sad when someone dies. However, they do not premeditate; do not plan ahead and do not dwell in the past or future. They live for whatever is happening at the moment.
MrsLeanneElliott 4 months ago
@MrsLeanneElliott, your emotions are based on the same architecture as a dog. It's evolution. What you are suggesting doen't make any sense and has a lot of evidence against it.
AboutDogTraining3 4 months ago
@MrsLeanneElliott I do not agree with that. My dog clearly remembers some of what he experienced as a puppy. When I was very young he pooped on the floor, I shoved his muzzle IN the poop and locked him in the bathroom with the poop still on his face. He NEVER pooped in the house again. Also around 12 or so he goes to the window because the mail truck is coming and he hates it. There are lots of little things that let me know he remembers and that he plans.
mjfromga89 3 weeks ago
Reactions like my dog doenst need this handeling doenst say that in thsi case its unnesessarry... if a dog is not fed up well with respect, rules, training exercise and affection... this kind of cases become of that... good to have cesar and his way, i have not seen any real violence from cesar.
Who objects to this methode should also give a right solution for this kinda dogs... but then it becomes very silent...
7nevyn7 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
All you Cesar Millan Fans have no idea what you are talking about, you probably have never had a dog and should never be allowed to have one.
This guy has some very serious mental problems and he is no where near to communicating the DOGS WAY...Have you ever seen a dog strangle and suffocate another dog to teach him something? Do you thing anything that goes anywhere near this behavior even exists in nature??I can't believe such violence is tolerated in your country...
donguri2280 10 months ago
Comment removed
claudiopolipo 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
A consortium of 26 animal welfare organisations including the RSPCA, the Australian Veterinary Association, the Kennel Club and the British Veterinary Association, has written an open letter warning that Cesar Millan’s methods will lead to “pain and fear”, and are “not only unacceptable from a welfare perspective, but not necessary for the modification of dog behaviour”.
tallykita 10 months ago
I have a fully grown Great Dane & a 5 month old Basset Hound. My dane gets fed up with the obnoxious puppy behavior from our basset & she pins him atleast once a day. She uses her teeth to get a good grip on his head when she does it (just because she has no opposable thumbs for a softer grip) but she really does pin him till he yips and calms down. then she lets him up and she naps in peace. Caesar IS comunicating the dogs way, he's just not using his teeth to do it.
Jujuopea 11 months ago
@Jujuopea, she doesn't pin him. If the dog wanted to move, it could. What happens is that the dog willingly offers this behaviour and the behavior is finished ritualized by the fake 'bite'
If this were to really happen we would see one dog ending up dead.
AboutDogTraining3 11 months ago
If you try his techniques at home you'll cause more psychological damage to your dog and probably get bitten! He is a dangerous dog trainer! The reason they "submit" is called learned helplessness!
Poochesgalore 11 months ago
If you try his techniques at home you'll cause more psychological damage to your dog and probably get bitten! He is a dangerous dog trainer!
Poochesgalore 11 months ago
? Dogs are not fragile if he were training cats he'd do it differently the reason why this works on dogs is because this is how dogs behave towards each other. This dog would probably be put to sleep for biting someone if not for him are there really people out there who are clueless to the point of thinking this is improper technique?
thefofomtl1 11 months ago
My dog is just like that, except if she gets put onto the ground by me shell stop, but would keep wanting to attackX
happpyhalo 11 months ago
All of you condemning cesar suck and had never had issues with such dogs and pretty much don’t know what you are talking about.
3231687 1 year ago
Oh please he didn't choke it until it became unconscious he simply just pinned the dog down until it calmed down. A dog can only stay in that state of mind for so long until it becomes tired and then submits. Besides dogs do this kind of thing to their pups, wolves in the wild use methods that are a lot like this it's just the same with any living creatures I mean WE discipline our children right well this is how dogs do it with their children.
HarvestStation 1 year ago 47
@HarvestStation When have you ever seen a dog do this to another dog? tell me please? This does NOT happen in the wild, mainly because dogs are NOT wild animals - there domesticated - and as such your example is invalid.
As for wolves - they are a completely different species - so equating wolf behaviour and dog behaviour is again completely invalid. Like comparing Homo sapiens sapiens and Homo erectus
heavyrocklegend 1 year ago
@heavyrocklegend
At dog training. At the end we let loose the dogs and let them play. Some dogs bother the other dogs and the dog will pin the other down which means it is telling the other dog that is invading it's space to cut it out and leave them alone. None of the dogs get hurt, they simply sort out amongest themselves who is top dog and so on it's what they do. Anyway if Cesar was being cruel to these dogs don't you think that the Animal protection agency will be stepping in.
HarvestStation 1 year ago
@HarvestStation Well to be Frank I have never seen any such thing, barking - biting maybe, but not clutching the throat and slamming another dog to the ground until the other dog shuts down and just lies there.
As for your last point, there is:- only every single Animal protection agency worth it's salt is stepping in.
dogwelfarecampaign org/press-statement
heavyrocklegend 1 year ago
@heavyrocklegend You can be Frank, and I'll be Steve. Stop spreading lies and bullshit just becase you're bored.
JimB667 11 months ago
@HarvestStation have you ever seen dogs with their pups? I have and I've NEVER seen them doing that to their puppies. If one get's too hyper they show signals with their body / voice, but they won't immediately catch them. I've once seen a mother dog catch the pup. She fixated it's head with her mouth for maybe 4 seconds. That's it. It's a fairy tale that dogs behave this way with their puppies. And btw. we are NO dogs.
Kuddebrunzer 7 months ago
@Kuddebrunzer no youre not a dog, but you apply dog psychology TO THE DOG because the dog doesnt understand human psychology. Were you watching the mother dog 24 / 7? You must have glimpsed a few minutes of her training her pups. If you have, you would see that if she wouldnt put up with a behavior, she does the simple biting thing to assert herself. Thats how I saw the mother of my dog blackie does it :)
TheHazelh0814 7 months ago
@TheHazelh0814, it is a very successful lie, this human/dog psychology distinction. But of course it is a lie.
AboutDogTraining3 7 months ago
@HarvestStation
What works better, giving candy to your kid if he does the homework? Or telling him that you will beat him with a baseball bat if he doesn't do it?
Positive reinforcements works better than the shit Milan does to dogs, what he does is borderline abuse.
DogsneedpIeasuretoo 6 months ago
Comment removed
HarvestStation 6 months ago
@HarvestStation
"How do you think pups in the wild are raised?"←Do you have wolves as pets? Because dogs are a bit different from wolves.
"In the wild how it works is the strongest is leader and they take control because they feel stronger than the rest"←Wrong, in the wild, the mating wolves couple are leaders by nature, the born puppies obey the parents just like your mom and dad are leaders and you obey them. There is no fight to be the strongest, watch this video: watch?v=tNtFgdwTsbU
DogsneedpIeasuretoo 6 months ago
@DogsneedpIeasuretoo
Because I have seen what happens when people treat dogs like they are a human being. My auntie has a Westie and she spoiled it rotten and now it thinks it owns the house and growls at people for no reason what so ever.
HarvestStation 6 months ago
Comment removed
arishachan777 6 months ago
@DogsneedpIeasuretoo I want to see you try to calm an ANGRY PITBULL with treats. GO AHEAD, POST IT ON YOUTUBE.
arishachan777 6 months ago
@arishachan777
Watch this video and learn how to calm an ANGRY dog with treats: watch?v=sI13v9JgJu0
You can train any angry dog with treats, much better than training the dog with kicks/pain/fear (ie abuse)
DogsneedpIeasuretoo 6 months ago
Comment removed
HarvestStation 6 months ago
@DogsneedpIeasuretoo
Dogs are not people. The only thing that dogs and human children have in common is that they both need discipline and be taught what is right and wrong. Yes training your dog with treats is good but what do you do when your dogs bites someone? Give it a treat and say 'good boy/girl'? No you need to teach them that what they did was wrong. Cesar's methods DO WORK and they DON'T harm the dog, if it did Cesar wouldn't still be working on TV now would he?
HarvestStation 6 months ago
@HarvestStation
"Dogs are not people"←Who say they are?
"training your dog with treats is good but what do you do when your dogs bites someone?"←You tell the dog that he/she did something wrong, and you train him to not bite in a safe environment.
"Cesar's methods DO WORK"←I'm not saying that they don't, but they are cruel and abusive.
"DON'T harm the dog"←FACT: kicking and alpha roll are harmful for the dog.
"Cesar wouldn't still be working"←MJ molested kids/teens and he still had a job.
DogsneedpIeasuretoo 6 months ago
@DogsneedpIeasuretoo
I meant he still wouldn't have a job involving animals and anyway how can you be so sure that MJ even molested children/teens? Did you know him personally? No I don't think you did so stop accusing him of doing something that he may not have even done in the first place.
HarvestStation 6 months ago
@HarvestStation
What this video watch?v=dSkYVwZKMSs
HE abuses dogs, though he is so "famous" that nobody cares.
DogsneedpIeasuretoo 6 months ago
@DogsneedpIeasuretoo that is not an 'aggressive' dog.
arishachan777 6 months ago
@arishachan777
Dr. Sophia Yin: She lectures and teaches workshops internationally on animal behavior and has served as a behavior expert for shows such as Dogs 101 on Animal Planet. She is on the executive board for the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior, the American Association of Feline Practitionern, Handling Guidelines Committee, and the American Humane Association, Animal Behavior and Training Advisory Committee.
►Are you saying she is mistaken to think that dog is aggressive?
DogsneedpIeasuretoo 6 months ago
@DogsneedpIeasuretoo it may be aggressive (since almost all dogs are) but she was giving treats to a dog which isn't in its red zone. I want to see someone try to calm a really aggressive adult pitbull with food. You know very well that the dog in this video will not accept any sort of treat during 1:23 - 1:34
arishachan777 6 months ago
@arishachan777
"I want to see someone try to calm a really aggressive adult pitbull with food."←You can mail Dr. Sophia Yin with this link and ask her if a dog like that can be trained to be a nice dogs by using threads. Why don't you do that? Bet you 1$ that she will say "yes it is possible"
PS: Do you have any evidence that this dog can't be trained with threats?
DogsneedpIeasuretoo 6 months ago
@arishachan777
I wouldn't bother trying to argue with DogsneedpIeasuretoo because I just took a look at his profile and he's more than just your average dog lover which is what I thought at first before I took a look at his profile O_o. This guy is a sick individual.
HarvestStation 6 months ago
@HarvestStation
I'm zoosexual and that is not a sickness, it is a sexual orientation, like heterosexuality, homosexuality and bisexuality. None of them are sickness.
And my sexual orientation has nothing to do with my arguments, so stop with the red herring and don't change the subject to something that has nothing to do with my arguments.
DogsneedpIeasuretoo 6 months ago
Comment removed
HarvestStation 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@DogsneedpIeasuretoo
I have nothing against heterosexuality, homosexuality or bisexuality but I'm against zoo sexuality, if you ask me it's another form of animal abuse and it should be illegal. I'm not referring to homosexuality as a sickness but zoosexual?! It's just completely wrong. I'm an animal lover but seriously it's just complete wrong to be sexually attracted to animals.
HarvestStation 6 months ago
@HarvestStation I just checked it... OH MY G- O_O.
arishachan777 6 months ago
@arishachan777
I felt physically sick after reading it :S
I thought he was just one of them overly protective animal lovers that let their pets get away with everything but when I saw his profile I just couldn't believe it O_O
HarvestStation 6 months ago
@HarvestStation
But I'm one overly protective animal lovers that lets his pet get away with everything. XD
Don't know why people freak out so much, dogs have natural sex urges, is the human responsibility to take care of the dog urges, that includes the sexual urges too. Dog owners has to do many gross things like picking up dog poop, is part of the job of being a responsible owner, you can't saw "ewww gross I won't do that" that would just set the dog on a "less happy" environment.
DogsneedpIeasuretoo 6 months ago
@DogsneedpIeasuretoo
You shouldn't have a sexual relationship with a dog or any animal for that matter and besides if your dog is lonely or has sexual urges then get it a mate, simple. It's like when I go to buy or adopt a puppy or kitten or even fully grown dogs or cats, I don't get just one I get two because then when you are not home they won't feel lonely and also if there's a male and a female then they can mate.
HarvestStation 6 months ago
@HarvestStation
"You shouldn't have a sexual relationship with a dog or any animal for that matter"←And why not?
"if your dog is lonely or has sexual urges then get it a mate"←That leads to unwanted puppies, but I guess you don't care about that...
DogsneedpIeasuretoo 6 months ago
@DogsneedpIeasuretoo
I personally don't care. Dogs mate and then there's puppies, it's the circle of life. If you don't want puppies then get them fixed, if that's not your cup of tea then don't get them fixed and just let them reproduce.
HarvestStation 6 months ago
@HarvestStation
So... you don't care about unwanted puppies, strays dogs, etc, then why you leaving comments in a dog video?
DogsneedpIeasuretoo 6 months ago
@DogsneedpIeasuretoo
Of course I care, when did I say I didn't care? You must of misunderstood me I meant I didn't care if one of my dog has puppies not that I don't care about any unwanted puppies or stray's out there. My family have on any occasions took in dogs that we have found on the street. Of course we rung the dog warden to file that we found a lost or stray and we would look after it until after 30 days if no one claims it then we have kept them.
HarvestStation 6 months ago
@HarvestStation
I'm trying to tell you that I can't take care of puppies or any more dogs, having a bitch for him is not a solution for me, my hand (or other body parts) solves the problem easily and in a cheap way.
Is none of your business how I take care of my doggy needs, specially because I'm not harming him in any way, if you ant to mutilate your dogs sexually (to avoid dealing with their sex urges) or you are rich to have litter after litter, go for it, but that is not an option for me.
DogsneedpIeasuretoo 6 months ago
@DogsneedpIeasuretoo
It's still wrong to have a sexual relationship with an animal, it's just not natural. Gay relationships are fine they are between 2 people of the same kind, humans but a human and animal, it's just wrong. I think of my pets as my friends but that's it, having a sexual or not relationship is simply unthinkable. Dogs commonly hump but sometimes it's not because they have a sexual urge, sometimes it means that they are showing dominance over another.
HarvestStation 6 months ago
@HarvestStation
"it's just not natural"←It is natural, everything that exist in the universe is natural, This video explains it: watch?v=-jrh8VVwMI4
Also, on youtube, you can find videos of dogs having sex or trying to have sex with humans, cats, sheeps, tigers, goats, pigs, ducks, etc. Interspecies sex has been reported in hundreds of species, that means it is natural.
I respect what ever sexual orientation you may have, why can't you respect my sexual orientation?
PS: My dog humps are sexual.
DogsneedpIeasuretoo 6 months ago
@DogsneedpIeasuretoo
You could catch something from the animal by having sex with it. I know humans can catch things off other humans like HIV etc. but I mean because of the difference in species and the sperm or egg. (Sorry it's hard to type what I mean but I hope you understand what I'm trying to say)
HarvestStation 6 months ago
@HarvestStation
Thanks for worrying about me, but the only think I can catch are fleas or ticks. XD
My dog is fully vaccinated and dewormed, so he doesn't have any zoonosis that can make him sick or make me sick.
PS: Diseases are not a reason to stop peope from having sex, sex between humans is way more dangerous, you can catch over 60 STDs and hundreds of Non-STD diseases by having sex with a human. If my dog where not vaccinated and dewormed, I would have the risk of catching only 10 zoonosis.
DogsneedpIeasuretoo 6 months ago
Comment removed
HarvestStation 6 months ago
@HarvestStation
"But there is nothing that you can catch because of the difference in species?"←Yes, there are like 10 or so dog zoonosis (those are diseases that can go from animal to human) but like I said before, dogs gets vaccinated against those zoonosis, dogs also get dewormed and given baths against fleas and ticks, so is is very hard to get sick from a home owned healthy dog.
DogsneedpIeasuretoo 6 months ago
@HarvestStation but I still want him to tell me how will he train an aggressive dog with treats.
arishachan777 6 months ago
dis a breed mint to b da glad-he-ate-her!
lanark31 1 year ago
what I´m concerned with that what if this dog becomes a ticking time bomb following this kind of training methods. Sure you may be able to walk the dog easier for a while, but then what if one pretty day when the owners least expects it, the dog attacks another dog that's walking past. Dogs do have a good memory and if the owners are abusive they will remember it and it might lead into loss of trust and respect towards their owner. Dog owner has to earn the trust but it can be lost quite fast.
Natheyja 1 year ago
Wow! I think "AboutDogTraining3" guy is extremely unstable and needs to be rehabilitated! Clearly a red zone case...
Turbopit100 1 year ago
Cesar=cute
jmatassa 1 year ago
That dog is being abused, i do not care what you call it! Abuse is abuse! And i do not think that an unconcious dog learns anything from this torture!
strayivan 1 year ago
he just choked the damn thing unconscious. but I like it. pit bulls shouldn't be bred anyway.
audionickw 1 year ago
Cesar says 'never let the dog walk in front' and I disagree with that. The dog that is the leader does not always walk in front. Wolf and dog packs often travel in miscellaneous or varying order- but the leader usually decides which way they are going, and he doesn't have to be in front to do it. When wolves hunt, it is not always the pack leader which selects the hunting route- it can be a lower ranking animal, who may happen to be a better hunter. Canids are complex with complex behaviors.
mikethebike7 1 year ago
the man is acting like he has no balls. Tell that fucking dog to behave like you mean it and be prepared to get physical. My dog lunged tried to bite a guy( I believe the guy was asking for it) and I kicked him in the ribs. It's the only time I ever struck my dog and I did it because it was an emergency. You don't stand there saying in a sissy voice 'stop, stop nowI said. Talk like you mean business and follow it with force if neccessary. An impending attack is definitely an emergency.
mikethebike7 1 year ago
Yeah, hanging a dog by the most sensitive part of its neck and then slamming it on the ground is the best way to train. I know; I've seen this tv entertainer with no credentials whatsoever doing it all the time. Plus he's always getting bitten, and that's how you know he's a real trainer. All those "certified animal behaviourists" who desensitise reactive dogs with positive reinforcement and don't ever get bitten, they're just pansies.
Spazzcopter 1 year ago
Kudos to him. I don't think I could handle a dog that aggressive. My little Blue Heeler's worst fault is pulling the leash when we walk. Other than that, she's pretty laid back and only poses a threat to squirrels, birds, butterflies, and sheep lol
splendidwren 1 year ago
@AboutDogTraining3 It sounds to me like you haven't really worked with dogs or wolves in a natural environment where there weren't people there to interfere? 'Cause it doesn't sound like you have. Wolves in the wild do that all the time. And I don't agree with EVERYTHING Cesar says/does. And he doesn't expect you to agree with EVERYTHING he says and does. There's different approaches for different people.
Okuhou 1 year ago
@Okuhou, the research of people who've been working on wolves for the past 50years and who have published more peer reviewed papers than you could ever read, confirm what I've stated.
It sounds like you get all your wolf lore from Millan and other unreliable sources.
AboutDogTraining3 1 year ago
@AboutDogTraining3 You're evil, get out of youtube. It feels like you're getting paid for saying bullshit stuff all the time. Cesar Millan is the best thing that ever happened to dogs all over the world. He changed the lives of so many dogs and humans as well, and you there post about 500 things about him being bad and everything. YOURE A DISGRACE. His technic work and so do yours, but like he says the most important thing is your energy.
pokerfreak11 1 year ago
@pokerfreak11 YOU ARE AN IDIOT. My energy is solar, hydroelectric, possibly nuclear. Millan has destroyed 2 decades of advancement in dog training with his simplistic, punitive approach. He is the worst thing to have happened to dogs.
AboutDogTraining3 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@AboutDogTraining3 Are you a robot ? You're definitaly not human. Ignorant sob.
pokerfreak11 1 year ago
shame on you for doing that to the dog and showing it on tv.
cinnamon8884 1 year ago
@cinnamon8884 O.o
splendidwren 1 year ago
@AboutDogTraining3 Wolves and dogs do a ton of things the same way! Wolves dominate by putting another wolf on the ground just like Cesar did and dogs do the same. Wolves ask for forgiveness by licking under the chin and dogs do the same. Also Human Psychology and dog Psychology is not the same. You can't sit and say "Okay Fido how did it feel when your old owner beat you?" They don't think back to that. The bad behavior isn't reprimanded properly so they think it's okay to keep doing it.
Okuhou 1 year ago
@Okuhou, you should stop getting your "info" from Millan. Neither dogs or wolves "dominate" and they don't put each other to the ground. It is a damn lie perpetrated by those who are trying to justify this draconian approach.
Human and Dog psychology out of necessity share many of the same traits... it's called evolution.
AboutDogTraining3 1 year ago
@AboutDogTraining3 Um... where did you get your facts from? I've seen dogs at the park who practice dominance and submission all the time. My dog is very submissive and will lay HERSELF on the ground to show she isn't going to challenge a bigger dog. Small chihuahua's have shown her the same respect if she gets too close. And Ceaser has an accent so english isn't his first language. Cut the guy some slack.
splendidwren 1 year ago
I am pretty sure he is using his special collar. He wouldn't strangle to dog.
Jalynn419 1 year ago
@Jalynn419 It's a slip leash. The pressure releases when the dog stops pulling. Softer than a choke chain but can be just as affective.
splendidwren 1 year ago
@ Aboutdogtraining3....Then why doesn't human psychology work for all Cesar's clients? They obviously are not doing something right..Go face to face with a growling pitbull and explain to him the reasons and consequences of his biting your face off...That he can kill you and then be put to sleep. Go ahead...and tape it for me...tell me if that part of human psychology is working for you.
cmy81685 1 year ago
@cmy81685, it should be obvious that Millan has no idea about human or dog psychology. HELL! He can't even use the words correctly!
AboutDogTraining3 1 year ago
@Caninefan999, too bad a dog is not a wolf and too bad wolves don't do any of the thigns seen on the dog whisperer.
In the end your response is devoid of meaningful content.
AboutDogTraining3 1 year ago
@maculandia Is Cesar suppose to talk to the dog and tell him that he's not suppose to attack other dogs? thats stupid human psychology that doesn't work on dogs!
cmy81685 1 year ago
@cmy81685, human pyschology and "dog" psychology share many of the same traits. So human pyschology does work on dogs.
If you were a better thinker or knew more, it would be obvious.
There is a lot of room between talking and forcing... marine mammal trainers have been using these techniques for almost 50 years, it they have been proven effective in dogs.
AboutDogTraining3 1 year ago
This is not what I call educating a dog!! this is animal abuse, he's strangling the dog, anyone can do that!! education is a completly different thing
maculandia 1 year ago
@maculandia - you're a total tool; let me guess- you're a chick!!! so, I'm assuming you use "please and thank you" with your dogs?? hahaha. Are you a dog trainer??
By the way, I don't see the dog being strangled.... restrained / subdues yes, abused-
NOT!!!!
ContinuosChange 1 year ago
@ContinuosChange -I have 3 dogo argentino and an amstaff and none of them has ever experienced this type of ABUSE, yet they are all well trained and behave normally.
There is no need to use this methods if you know how to handle a dog, fear is NOT a good teacher
maculandia 10 months ago
@ContinuosChange I have 3 dogo argentino and an amstaff and none of them has ever experienced this type of ABUSE, yet they are all well trained and behave normally.
There is no need to use this methods if you know how to handle a dog, fear is NOT a good teacher
maculandia 10 months ago
Dogs are not people nor do they think like people.
Kittyautie 10 months ago 2
@Kittyautie sure, but that doesn't justify this type of "training"
maculandia 10 months ago
I love this gay he deserved the name DOG WHISPERER!!!
Dragana44love 1 year ago
The more I get to know people the more I love my dogs!
GSDlover7 1 year ago
I thinks its hilarious how everything on all youtube videos always turn into a fight... its pretty entertaining
Jesskelly397 1 year ago
some people are so stupid. They think being firm is being abusive. Cesar is the best! He knows his shit.... hasnt found a dog yet he hasnt been able to rehibilatate
Jesskelly397 1 year ago 2
love caesar's methods, he works just like a pack leader. i think aboutdogtraining3 is obsessed with the dog whisperer, i haven't seen a video it hasn't commented on
decaturgurl1975 1 year ago
i have this EXACT case
brilliant dog with people playful indoors does my commands until i go for a walk he wants to attack other dogs
wot season episode is this ????
ChrisL1100 1 year ago
pitbulls are banned in ottawa canada YEAH!
jocelyna38 1 year ago
In a situation like this, you need to be firm. Now if you have a sweet cuddly little dog (your lucky) who behaves, than don't, but for some dogs, this is the only thing that works.
JillTheOddity 1 year ago
Cesar's wife isn't hot at all. As a wife of a celebrity, she needs to be more attractive and in better shape. No wonder why they are getting a divorce.
scotth602 1 year ago
@scotth602, your comment is totally unnecessary and quite ignorant. You don't even know why they are getting divorced in the first place.
osang828 1 year ago
I object to him on a number of levels, I have to say. His methods are based primarily on force, with little or no knowledge of what has caused the dog to be acting the way it's acting. He uses forceful methods on dogs who are very fearful, forcing them into situations where they become so overwhelmed with fear that they simply give up.
MsLabMom 1 year ago
@MsLabMom Alright, fine. What would you do then? If his methods are so sinister, what would YOU do? Go on, say it. Let's hear from the Mom who knows dogs better than Cesar. Do you even own a dog? I'm sure it talks to you and explains that it doesn't like redirection. What would be better to you? A dog put to sleep because of aggression, or another chance at life thanks to some guidance? WHICH IS BETTER TO YOU?!
KidAnime20 1 year ago
@KidAnime20, idiot the methods are very easy to follow. Look them up if you are truly curious. However they don't involve strangling the dog, Wresting the dog to the ground or shoving the dog's face into the thing that sets him off.
AboutDogTraining3 1 year ago
@AboutDogTraining3 I wasn't talking to you. And I hope you read and answer my last e-mail. I am aware that MsLabMom is ignoring everyone. It's clear to me that she's not different from you. But putting that aside... like i said, just answer he last e-mail I sent you, honestly.
KidAnime20 1 year ago
@AboutDogTraining3 How old are you?
KidAnime20 1 year ago