@poopersooper123 This is self expression. Expressing your creativity. Like she said creativity is the greatest rebellion known to mankind. No one expresses themselves more than this women. You claim it's not art, I claim it is. Not every kind of art is something you will like - it's her form of beauty, sorry, But I absolutely fucking love it!
this bitch has made her bulimia acceptable. People who consider this art are borderline retarded have some puking fetish. If Millie was fat and ugly, I guarantee everyone's mind would change about the validity of her so called art.
@ti3nt She's not throwing up because of bulimia. She's vomiting because she's indicating that the fame she got to has made her sick. The girl throwing up on her indicates Stefani, her real name..her real hair color, the girl she was before she became Gaga. So, yes it is art. Learn your facts.
I liked Lady Gaga when she first came onto the music scene. However now I think she's just trying to appeal to people as being "special". Which is very clever advertising, acting weird for attention has worked for many people in the music industry. I'm just over it now, it's gone overboard, idiotic and attention whoreish.
Art is about expressing yourself and give people different points of view ,make people think and feel something . And i agree that art sometimes can be disturbing ,and sometimes it really should disturb people in order to tell them something .But what Lady Gaga and all her little monsters don't know is that art is never meant to advertise some kinda pop music which is also not art because it is made to gain money ,art has nothing to with money. THIS IS WHY THIS VIDEO IS NOT ART ,IT IS BULLSHIT.
@RubikMinds So you're saying if an artist is compensated for their work, they aren't artists? REALLY? Being an artist is a job like any other, albeit a magical one. The fact that Lady Gaga gets paid for her work doesn't make her any less of an artist. She's just like anybody else who hopes they can make a living off of what they love. Any artist makes art to gain money. If you can't make your work into a career, then you're forced to confine your work as strictly a hobby.
@Zarathrustraexe I'm not saying you're not an artist if you're getting paid . I'm saying that if you do it for money you're not an artist . And i don't believe that being an artist is a job like any other . Art is about emotions , it can never be just another occupation . Just like @TheFugitiveMango said , she's doing all these stuff just to remain popular and not to express herself . AND AGAIN , NO ARTIST MAKES ART TO GAIN MONEY , THOSE WHO DO ARE NOT ARTISTS .
@RubikMinds Why do you think I said, "albeit a magical one"? I said being an artist is a job because, like any other, it is a means to make money. Of course being an artist, first and foremost, deals tremendously with emotion and expression. But it is still an occupation. To think that Lady Gaga doesn't do these things to express herself is ridiculous. There is always a concept or commentary behind her work. For one, this video was a metaphorical expression of how she became Lady Gaga.
@Zarathrustraexe Remember the first time she came out , she was nothing like this , she was just another pop singer . Then she got all weird and started to change herself frequently because she realized that this works well on the market . I just don't see what you see in this and there's no point of us arguing since you believe art is an occupation and i don't . We just have different opinions about art .
@RubikMinds Alright, we can agree to disagree. :) I just think the way she is now is what she set out to be, and she expresses this identity through her work. I feel that art can be an occupation because it can be a career if you work hard at it, but if you don't feel the same way, that's okay.
@Claaaudz Aesthetic art died over a century ago. At the turn of the century (from 19th to 20th C. CE), artists were no longer interested in the same work that existed as previously seen in the Renaissance, Baroque, Rococo, and Neo-Classical periods. Things changed quickly and aesthetic art was as good as dead by the 1950s. There was a revival in the 70s for very kitschy realism...but that didn't last long. No one famous that is alive today paints like Ingres, Louis-David, Singer-Sargent, etc
Lady Gaga is the best fucking thing in the whole world, she's my inspiration for life. I couldn't survive without MOTHER FUCKING Lady Gaga!!! I <3 you Mother Monster!
@HiKikiLol no acutally my mom did last year when we both went to the Monster ball in July, and she's like what the fuck look at her feet, and I like what what's wrong with them, and I was like AHHHHHHHHHHHHHH, THERE BACKWARDS, and we both laughed (^_^)
Or the interlude could be about how she is trying to bring some of her old self back into her music. The Lady Gaga in the white dress represents who she is/has become and the brunette Gaga is who she once was and the real her who was still just a dreamer. Her puking on the blonde Gaga is more like the brunette Gaga puking out her souls and marking blonde Gaga who had succumbed to the mainstrem and the fame so that she can put soul back into her music like she did before...did that make sense???
So why did she eat the heart? A cows heart was given to her by Nick Knight who told her to conquer her fears of her father's heart surgery by eating it...IT'S NOT SICK, IT'S ART.
@Flakillou For one, I Feel Love is NOT by Madonna. Its by Donna Summer. And GaGa is totally original. You're probably like all the other skeptics and have only seen the more famous stuff. Look at her more underground works, and you'll find that she is a tru genius. :D
Personally...I think that the blond Gaga is truly and inexplicably who she is. It's her choice and what she identifies with. I don't believe that the change of hair color was done to conform to what the media and public wanted her to be, I think it is just her...being who she truly feels she is intended to be. Free.
Im guessing the bloody part was supposed to kind of mean that pop ate her heart. Although I beileve the hidden meanings in her work are far more complex then we know. If you truly beileve the Alejandro video was about gays then you need to watch again. i guess you could say its a triple entendre. A meaning wraped in a meaning wraped in a deeper... darker meaning.
OK so the girl puking on her is an artist - who makes art by vomiting paint - Millie Brown...look it up the heart is bovine - not human- Nick Knight used it as a creative way for her to get over the fear of her dad's heart surgery(let's be real she didn't eat the whole thing she prob just bit it. At the end she wanted to be styled Alexander McQueen style
JEEZ humans do some research y'all already spend so much time on the internet !
#Marilyn
mrpogonaviticep 14 hours ago
#I'MAFREEBITCH
408RaRa 2 days ago
sounds is so am 4 hours into my extacy drop and ive got my chanel glasses on before the moon sets
duhavifk 5 days ago
#FINDYOURJESUS
lovelinnr1 6 days ago
It's official disabled....imbeciles )))
LeiGatta 1 week ago
#WTF
2012jamess 1 week ago
#bitch
sxepika 2 weeks ago
#TELLTHEMHOWYOUFEELGIRLS
GaGaSophie 3 weeks ago
#LETSGETSTONED
AllieLittleMonster 3 weeks ago
#DIVA
HeiNekenSP 1 month ago
#LETSGETSTONED!
AllieLittleMonster 1 month ago
#marilyn
DifferentD123 1 month ago 4
esta loca dios miooo!! q asco :S!!
SUPERHEWOLF 1 month ago
I ♥ Lady Gaga so much >.<
ViviCamilaJara 2 months ago 6
#ART
spirosbtw 2 months ago 3
do u have the jumping interlude in this quality plzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz reply i need it :)
juzzKilldmaGalfrnd 2 months ago in playlist Lady GaGa - Live ♥
#marylin
ElectricNightTV 2 months ago 10
tell me how you feel girls!!!!
daliafoe 2 months ago 4
ugh i miss the monster ball so much!!! this brings back so many memories
MarryTheGaga 3 months ago 4
WTF??????????????
fabinhuux 4 months ago
@HiKikiLol they change at :28. They are facing the right way when it starts.
PurrL3n 4 months ago
,♥love gaga
,♥love
globofito 4 months ago
wtf???????
Ladygaga5410 4 months ago
this is what im fucking talking about gaga!!! not poker face shit!!
andybondoir18 4 months ago
I oddly.. love this! (:
<3 ✞
hotliliB333 4 months ago
this is just...ART
BagreMonsterJm14 4 months ago
A R T
MrXanthii 4 months ago
hq? really?
Lauratribbiani 4 months ago
i love lady gaga i am a little monster!
BraulioDark1 4 months ago
WHAT IS SHE EATING???!!!
dereknguyen1999 5 months ago
@dereknguyen1999 A real cow's heart, for her father's surgery =D Isn't she a crazy bitch? I love her!!
kevincanary 5 months ago
@kevincanary Oh R u sure its a reeal coe's heart? I FUCKEN LOVE HER TOO XD
dereknguyen1999 5 months ago
@kevincanary that's not a cow's heart, it's bovine's heart
LADYGAGAPUERTORICO 5 months ago
@LADYGAGAPUERTORICO It's the same ¬¬
Regards! ^.^
kevincanary 4 months ago
esto es arte
sKtOoO1 5 months ago
Eu tbm vi .
metidos69 5 months ago
this song and You and I are my fave Gaga songs.
CountessMarlene 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
#jonbenetramsey
madonna4president 5 months ago
#sylvia
madonna4president 5 months ago 30
#judy
madonna4president 5 months ago 28
#marilyn
madonna4president 5 months ago 4
if this is art then i dont want to live in this world any longer...
poopersooper123 5 months ago
@poopersooper123 bye then.
dizalawn 5 months ago
@poopersooper123 This is self expression. Expressing your creativity. Like she said creativity is the greatest rebellion known to mankind. No one expresses themselves more than this women. You claim it's not art, I claim it is. Not every kind of art is something you will like - it's her form of beauty, sorry, But I absolutely fucking love it!
megaclaw6 5 months ago
I miss the Monster Ball and the Fame Monster Gaga :/ I still love her, but everything she did back then (besides music) was so much better.
MyMyMyTelephone 6 months ago
2:40 - i love this ;***
BORNTHISWAYperson 6 months ago
2:38 - i love this ;***
BORNTHISWAYperson 6 months ago
Wheres the audio :S
Spac3man88 6 months ago
"I'm too ghetto. I'm too ghetto."
TheTaylorNelson 6 months ago 4
It's not sick, it's not stupid, it's not disgusting, it's art.
Everything in this video has meaning, mostly that only she knows herself.
RapturianAngelxx 6 months ago 4
i love this so much and i dont care if my sister lucy thinks it a stuppid video. its so artistic and she just dont get it. go gaga lets work together
monster4611 6 months ago
when her legs twisted i freaked.
LOVE YOU MOTHER MONSTER
skinnymelon09 6 months ago
1:38 im too ghetto im too ghetto im too ghetto im too ghetto
1691christian 6 months ago
OOOH child look at me in the top comments. Ma, I'm famous!!!
GCkidd 7 months ago
@GCkidd lmao
1691christian 6 months ago
I just now noticed her feet are backwards in the intro to this!!!
Misterrcheshire 7 months ago 3
is amazing!!!
PaoLittleMonster 7 months ago
this bitch has made her bulimia acceptable. People who consider this art are borderline retarded have some puking fetish. If Millie was fat and ugly, I guarantee everyone's mind would change about the validity of her so called art.
ti3nt 7 months ago
@ti3nt U are retard baby. And most of all you didn't understand a damn thing about this short film. fuck off silly bitch!
1971sweetangel 7 months ago
@1971sweetangel go suck a dick and wash out that potty mouth of your lul.
ti3nt 7 months ago
@ti3nt She's not throwing up because of bulimia. She's vomiting because she's indicating that the fame she got to has made her sick. The girl throwing up on her indicates Stefani, her real name..her real hair color, the girl she was before she became Gaga. So, yes it is art. Learn your facts.
randomnameherexx 7 months ago
lolwut.
GovermentxHooker 7 months ago
shes so fine with that girl puking on her
mkykewlbooboolover12 7 months ago
I liked Lady Gaga when she first came onto the music scene. However now I think she's just trying to appeal to people as being "special". Which is very clever advertising, acting weird for attention has worked for many people in the music industry. I'm just over it now, it's gone overboard, idiotic and attention whoreish.
TheFugitiveMango 7 months ago
Art is about expressing yourself and give people different points of view ,make people think and feel something . And i agree that art sometimes can be disturbing ,and sometimes it really should disturb people in order to tell them something .But what Lady Gaga and all her little monsters don't know is that art is never meant to advertise some kinda pop music which is also not art because it is made to gain money ,art has nothing to with money. THIS IS WHY THIS VIDEO IS NOT ART ,IT IS BULLSHIT.
RubikMinds 7 months ago 4
@RubikMinds So you're saying if an artist is compensated for their work, they aren't artists? REALLY? Being an artist is a job like any other, albeit a magical one. The fact that Lady Gaga gets paid for her work doesn't make her any less of an artist. She's just like anybody else who hopes they can make a living off of what they love. Any artist makes art to gain money. If you can't make your work into a career, then you're forced to confine your work as strictly a hobby.
Zarathrustraexe 7 months ago
@Zarathrustraexe I'm not saying you're not an artist if you're getting paid . I'm saying that if you do it for money you're not an artist . And i don't believe that being an artist is a job like any other . Art is about emotions , it can never be just another occupation . Just like @TheFugitiveMango said , she's doing all these stuff just to remain popular and not to express herself . AND AGAIN , NO ARTIST MAKES ART TO GAIN MONEY , THOSE WHO DO ARE NOT ARTISTS .
RubikMinds 7 months ago
@RubikMinds Why do you think I said, "albeit a magical one"? I said being an artist is a job because, like any other, it is a means to make money. Of course being an artist, first and foremost, deals tremendously with emotion and expression. But it is still an occupation. To think that Lady Gaga doesn't do these things to express herself is ridiculous. There is always a concept or commentary behind her work. For one, this video was a metaphorical expression of how she became Lady Gaga.
Zarathrustraexe 7 months ago
@Zarathrustraexe Remember the first time she came out , she was nothing like this , she was just another pop singer . Then she got all weird and started to change herself frequently because she realized that this works well on the market . I just don't see what you see in this and there's no point of us arguing since you believe art is an occupation and i don't . We just have different opinions about art .
RubikMinds 7 months ago
@RubikMinds Alright, we can agree to disagree. :) I just think the way she is now is what she set out to be, and she expresses this identity through her work. I feel that art can be an occupation because it can be a career if you work hard at it, but if you don't feel the same way, that's okay.
Zarathrustraexe 7 months ago
@Zarathrustraexe I'm happy that we can agree to have different opinions and we're just fine with it . :)
RubikMinds 7 months ago
lady gaga is sick mentally!! how the f*ck is this art?? lol what has happened to true aesthetic art? :'(
Claaaudz 7 months ago
@Claaaudz Aesthetic art died over a century ago. At the turn of the century (from 19th to 20th C. CE), artists were no longer interested in the same work that existed as previously seen in the Renaissance, Baroque, Rococo, and Neo-Classical periods. Things changed quickly and aesthetic art was as good as dead by the 1950s. There was a revival in the 70s for very kitschy realism...but that didn't last long. No one famous that is alive today paints like Ingres, Louis-David, Singer-Sargent, etc
Berumira 7 months ago
i like this kind of art:) its so disturbing
djhornymoney 7 months ago
Lady Gaga is the best fucking thing in the whole world, she's my inspiration for life. I couldn't survive without MOTHER FUCKING Lady Gaga!!! I <3 you Mother Monster!
MrBiscuitkeeper 7 months ago
I find this hard to masterbate to
apalmer12 7 months ago 5
@apalmer12 hahaha you get around lol
luannalovell 7 months ago
@apalmer12 I could, and it feels great.
whitelightanimegirl 5 months ago
Like eww! but in a good way! ;)
delilahahh 8 months ago
psicotico.... me gusta
EddyLM100 8 months ago
what's the name of this song?
omarmmedina 8 months ago
@omarmmedina
dance in the dark
DionisVEVO 8 months ago
@omarmmedina It uses pieces of Dance in the Dark, but it is a song on its own :) It was used for one of the interludes in the Monster Ball
JosephKayeTV 7 months ago
Am I the only person that noticed her feet are facing the wrong way at the beginning?
HiKikiLol 8 months ago 66
Comment removed
elesigblake 8 months ago
@HiKikiLol are you the only one that didn't notice that they were the right way ... then changed
morganBeBop 6 months ago 4
@HiKikiLol What happened
danielucas0123 6 months ago
@HiKikiLol no ... -_-
cactusmilo918 5 months ago
Comment removed
dandyaufpferd 5 months ago
@HiKikiLol no acutally my mom did last year when we both went to the Monster ball in July, and she's like what the fuck look at her feet, and I like what what's wrong with them, and I was like AHHHHHHHHHHHHHH, THERE BACKWARDS, and we both laughed (^_^)
1994fashionboy 5 months ago
@HiKikiLol no...
TheVermeercrisostomo 4 months ago
@HiKikiLol maybe because they turn a couple of times in the video and it is on purpose?
Rozepoester 4 months ago
@HiKikiLol I noticed it too.
Diego15C 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Did lady gaga blink.?
JesseGermanotta 8 months ago
k rARO VIDEOOOO jeje pero me enkanta ... :)
paoladygagense 8 months ago
on to ghetto?
coolboy1490 8 months ago
why does the music end half way through?
Madriley1 8 months ago
@Madriley1 its more dramatic
elesigblake 8 months ago
it's a real heart???????'
MonsterLovato 8 months ago
Honor your vomit :D
hebbu11 8 months ago 82
i loooooooooove this crazy interlude! eating heart and puking on yourself.. that's ART, pure & nice ART!
myfullromance 9 months ago 4
i love this! <3
HelloImKeila 9 months ago
miedo ._.
claudivalelu 9 months ago
Big slap on complete fashion industry
Ti4tiable 9 months ago
Its amazing
monxxesita 9 months ago
satanista di merdaaaaaaaaaaa!!!!!!!!!!!!
coracory 9 months ago
What the fuck is this?!?
Lihkan38 9 months ago
this is more like bulimia not Exorcist but....
2mbunlimited 9 months ago
fantastic
2mbunlimited 9 months ago
The audio do not match with the vido... fix it please ;D
OCTAVIODUFF 9 months ago
it isnt a real heart is it?
xSasquatx 9 months ago
@xSasquatx Its a real cow's heart. She didn't really eat it. Just bit the fuck out of it.
mouseyaup 9 months ago
@mouseyaup but i swear shes vegan? hahaa
xSasquatx 9 months ago
i just noticed how her legs turn the opposite way in the beginning.
chilipeppers29 9 months ago
OMG Iwas in the concert in mexico city was nice !!!
125valentin 9 months ago
Honor your vomit much gaga? Lol
leolion1990 9 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
crazy illuminati bitch!!
Daphneketje 9 months ago
Watching her eat the heart in silence is kind of weird...
BLinDaTbESt 9 months ago
Awesome
BUweB 9 months ago
♫MAKE IT STOP!!!!!!!!!!♫
missladydiva 10 months ago
pure art...
taneyramoyre 10 months ago
She scares the shit out of me.
DawnBarbourOfficial 10 months ago 3
Only a little monster can understand this (:
xCandiceMichelle 10 months ago 4
i would shot she fa dissss!!!!
timome1 10 months ago
Ewww what the fuck is she doing, eating a heart ???!O__O
Lizette54321 10 months ago
crap...
diamondcrazy1 10 months ago
As many times that I have seen this I never knew her feet were backwards
Fergiegirl998 10 months ago
Im A Free Bitch
AlejandroBitch 10 months ago
I ♥
Goonzaaloo18 10 months ago
Or the interlude could be about how she is trying to bring some of her old self back into her music. The Lady Gaga in the white dress represents who she is/has become and the brunette Gaga is who she once was and the real her who was still just a dreamer. Her puking on the blonde Gaga is more like the brunette Gaga puking out her souls and marking blonde Gaga who had succumbed to the mainstrem and the fame so that she can put soul back into her music like she did before...did that make sense???
Chojifan96 11 months ago 4
auntentica LOCURA! PERO amo a GAGA i la quiero aga loke aga.....E DE ADMITIR que esto nose ake VIENE?
gitanochoco 11 months ago
o i miss all of her concert interludes, thats gorgeous!
lovetonkin 11 months ago
this reads nyu tisch school all over it
deathcabforjessie 11 months ago
you guys notice that in the beginning gagas feeet are backwards then it changes
MONStERkiiyaanii 1 year ago
this is so stupid.
iafhn 1 year ago
am i the only 1 aroused by the puking???
Nisho67 1 year ago 74
@Nisho67 yep
MARTINCORNFLAKES 8 months ago
@Nisho67 if its lady gaga puking, then i'm with you on that one.
xBabyGaga 8 months ago
@Nisho67 nope. no you're not...
nikos576 7 months ago
@Nisho67 i sure hope so!
ImCool415 7 months ago
@Nisho67 YEP .. :D
DavidTranAnh 6 months ago
is this leaked?
LoveOfPop 1 year ago
could u upload this to filestube or some other sharing site? PLZ!!!!!????!!? :(
TheJustineBell 1 year ago
Oh My this is sexy as fuck O__O think I will draw the gory scene ; 3
MadnessInAWhishper 1 year ago
So why did she eat the heart? A cows heart was given to her by Nick Knight who told her to conquer her fears of her father's heart surgery by eating it...IT'S NOT SICK, IT'S ART.
GCkidd 1 year ago 142
What Dance in the remix is this?
splicio 1 year ago
fucking love this one
monochromedx 1 year ago
i remember when me & my friends went to her concert & saw this video we all looked @ each other and said "WTF IS GOING ON"
but she's a true artist & i love her :)
rose7art 1 year ago 2
Out of synch. Fail.
CosmopolitanPsycho 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
help this kid spread the word so his vid reaches kesha! search "lordexin kesha"
joeterino18 1 year ago
This is dance in the dark, right? The lyrics...I'm sure
rockaroundtheclock56 1 year ago
i found out that the person who plays her in the black dress is her sister melani germanotta
CirqueDeEliaoko 1 year ago
@CirqueDeEliaoko First of all, her sister is called Natali Germanotta, second, she is called Millie Brown
billzrockin09 1 year ago
@billzrockin09 oh i thought she said her sister name was melani...oops xD
CirqueDeEliaoko 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This Is A Copy Of The Song I Feel Love Of Madonna... The Rhythm Is Same... Lady Gaga It's Not Original, Is A Copyyyy...
Flakillou 1 year ago
@Flakillou For one, I Feel Love is NOT by Madonna. Its by Donna Summer. And GaGa is totally original. You're probably like all the other skeptics and have only seen the more famous stuff. Look at her more underground works, and you'll find that she is a tru genius. :D
airborn100 1 year ago 2
@Flakillou If Gaga's not original why the fuck would you watch her vids?!
AsmaAlshehri 1 year ago
Personally...I think that the blond Gaga is truly and inexplicably who she is. It's her choice and what she identifies with. I don't believe that the change of hair color was done to conform to what the media and public wanted her to be, I think it is just her...being who she truly feels she is intended to be. Free.
ginny7676 1 year ago
I think she's a goddess!
Thnx 2 Lady GaGa I'm a writer now
She changed my life
i'm gay and i feel proud
:')
EdiciusStreax 1 year ago 4
I just noticed how Gaga's feet are backwards
BerryBerryChara 1 year ago 2
so artistic! and nice shoes too
nikos576 1 year ago
OMG !! Thank you so much for this vid.
Blackhole233 1 year ago
Im guessing the bloody part was supposed to kind of mean that pop ate her heart. Although I beileve the hidden meanings in her work are far more complex then we know. If you truly beileve the Alejandro video was about gays then you need to watch again. i guess you could say its a triple entendre. A meaning wraped in a meaning wraped in a deeper... darker meaning.
Graylikeamonster 1 year ago
Heh, the URL has "Cum" in it.
ManfredMitchum 1 year ago 8
Is this played at her shows?
LadyLeesa 1 year ago
Can You send Me a Link For This ? Please ??
BreatheOfMusiic 1 year ago
it reminds me of one of mcqueens performances
gustavou2009 1 year ago
Di-di-di-dick !
Karacuz 1 year ago
OH MY GAGA. This is freakin awesome! I need to download this! where can I? please tell me!
living88dead 1 year ago
Comment removed
danceiztoxic 1 year ago
@danceiztoxic well I knew that its not exactly difficult to hear it in the song :D
BabyGaGaMonster 1 year ago
@danceiztoxic lol are you actually serious? you're joking right?
Sethew2010 1 year ago
OK so the girl puking on her is an artist - who makes art by vomiting paint - Millie Brown...look it up the heart is bovine - not human- Nick Knight used it as a creative way for her to get over the fear of her dad's heart surgery(let's be real she didn't eat the whole thing she prob just bit it. At the end she wanted to be styled Alexander McQueen style
JEEZ humans do some research y'all already spend so much time on the internet !
TheDrewclawson 1 year ago
I loved this and after about an hour waiting for her it was just pure beautiful to see this! Heart you GaGa, dont ever change and give in to The Fame
Tasharocker 1 year ago