I think this is a killer song, and I dig Shinedown, but this version is only a few shades off of U2's, and that whiner rock he does at 3:50 just sinks it for me.
Come on Shinedown, you can do better than this eh?
Its a great song in and of itself. I appreciate that they stripped it down to its essence. Brent's vocal is perfect. He doesn't oversing the song or miss the emotion. He hits the notes and emotion spot on.
Sorry, you guys are living in a hallway with no doors and no rooms if you think Brent outsings Bono on this. Don't get me wrong; the guys has crazy pipes (see the 5 acoustic sets from some dude's living room) and is one of my favorite singers, but Bono's ragged/emotional vocals ~2:48 blow Brent away on this. That said, Chris Cornell pwns them both.
Sorry, you guys are living in a hallway with no doors and no rooms if you think Brent outsings Bono on this. Don't get me wrong; the guys has crazy pipes (see the 5 acoustic sets from some dude's living room) and is one of my favorite singers, but Bono's ragged/emotional vocals ~2:48 blow Brent away on this. That said, Chris Cornell pwns them both.
So U2 writes probably one of the best songs of all time...Shinedown does a cover and they do it better??? Sorry I disagree, I am a Shinedown fan, but U2 is on a different level then most bands today. If someone does a Shinedown cover after they have been around for 30 years I will give them their deserved credit. But it is one of the best covers I have heard.
Well, I was expecting this to be terrible... and surprisingly its not. Its actually pretty good. Nowhere near the U2 version of course, but its not bad. I usually hate shinedown, but his isn't bad at all.
Like the cover of Simple Man, I am infinitely impressed with this cover. Very few bands can cover a song and actually improve it. I have to say, here, they've done it, like in the Simple Man cover, but in that one they changed the song enough to make it theirs, in this, they're tackling the song, but not claiming it, so it's just a try at a song where they put their all into it. Impressive.
I cannot begin to tell you guys how talented shinedown are ! I've not come across a band apart from Rhcp that has changed me so much. There song Second chance, changed me almost instantly. And Call me , makes me reflect.
I have seen U2 and Shinedown in concert (several yrs apart). Both are great performers vocally and musically. I love both bands. This song is equally as good as the original
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
How dare you put this song on youtube? This song deserves to be bought or to be listened to by Shinedown Fan Nation members, now people are going to just come here and listen to it. Really man, why did you do this? I payed $35 dollars to get into the fan nation, and THAT was when I heard this song. You suck.
I heard this version before I heard U2's. So, naturally I like this one better. Plus factor in Shinedown is my favorite band, and this song is amazing anyway.
Plus Shinedown...puts so much meaning into the songs they sing. Brent has a very powerful voice. <3
this is the worst blasphemy i've ever heard!! o my fucking god!!! what da fuck is this fucking crap!! it's like he's shitting for gods sake!! he sings horrible.. how do you people like this fucking shit?? we're all nuts at this days!! god damned!!
Are you deaf? Brent Smith(lead singer of shinedown) has an amazng voice. I would love for you to name 5 singers with better rock voices. Singing Hard rock music is very difficult. Show some respect.
Such an incredibly good song. I actually heard the shinedown version BEFORE I heard the u2 one. (one haha) I personally prefer that the acoustic version is better ... mainly cause I like acoustic music more. Awesome cover 10/10
I'm a massive U2 fan and a moderate Shinedown fan, but I have to say that Brent Smith's voice impresses me more and more each time I hear him do something different.
Completely nailed, although it's a near chord-perfect cover at times.
@TheSmithbelynda Without a doubt, Mr. Smith is thee best rock singer on the planet..The Sound Of Madness album has etched him in a special place..songwriting..and a voice to match and beyond..all 3 Shinedown Albums are epic.
@TheSmithbelynda he's in the top, for sure... but he could be a lot better.... what you hear now is pure, unpolished talent.... think of what he could do with vocal training.... but then again, maybe that's his charm :D.....
I heard U2 did a cover of this :-P
RedLesterCheese13 1 month ago
@RedLesterCheese13 I see what you did there :D
DarkLionInteractive 1 month ago
@lilyd11 ?
zuzakto 2 months ago
its definitely getting better
Driveshaft12345 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos 6
The best remake I've heard of "One" by U2 was Adam Lambert's version he sang on American idol xD
This is pretty good though :P
PunkAquarius13 3 months ago
They did a great job on this tune...I had to favorite it...hell I think I have favorited almost every song I hear from these guys
Driveshaft12345 3 months ago 3
fuckin love how these guys take a cover and remake it with the passion that it needed...awesome remix
rollinaces91 4 months ago
Realy bad quality :(
im0amd62 4 months ago
as far as acoustic covers are concerned, this is one of the better ones.
kmyerslufc1 4 months ago 2
thought the original version was close to perfection until shinedown made a cover
jfatz358 6 months ago
better than the original
Arrrg18 6 months ago
this sng turns to shit after 4:27 !
84emo84 7 months ago 18
damn it, i thought it was a metallica cover ;( :L
DepthsOfRealityTV 7 months ago 4
awesome!
CynthiaJanes 9 months ago
I think this is a killer song, and I dig Shinedown, but this version is only a few shades off of U2's, and that whiner rock he does at 3:50 just sinks it for me.
Come on Shinedown, you can do better than this eh?
lazarusad 9 months ago
I thought this was a cover of Metallica's "One", anyone else here make that mistake?
Optimus4eva 9 months ago 104
@Optimus4eva Haha... Thats the only reason i clicked to watch it......
loveaddict10 8 months ago
@Optimus4eva that would be sweet too....
drgoodspd 5 months ago
@Optimus4eva yup
jkahan 5 months ago
@Optimus4eva me... xP hahaha but the music still beign simply great
SUPERALENUS 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Optimus4eva Me =) I forgot this song was good.. High Five for uploading !!
THATCHIKY6666969 4 months ago
@Optimus4eva This is not mistake! Its Shinedown!
luucja 3 months ago
@Optimus4eva This is not mistake! Its Shinedown! :)
luucja 3 months ago 3
@Optimus4eva yup me. i was like....-_- COME ON!
Selintriel 2 months ago
@Optimus4eva Yep I actually thought i'll be Metallica and was praying it wasn't a Creed cover.
tascherman22 2 weeks ago in playlist More videos from tonyflrb
@Optimus4eva Me :)))) I hoped to be Metallica's "ONE"
mjoey19 2 days ago
Its a great song in and of itself. I appreciate that they stripped it down to its essence. Brent's vocal is perfect. He doesn't oversing the song or miss the emotion. He hits the notes and emotion spot on.
mschleis82 9 months ago
drew081886
What about aerosmith?
TheFernodragon 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Shinedown - One of the greatest bands i know !
DoronZeus 10 months ago
One of the greatest bands i know !
DoronZeus 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Sorry, you guys are living in a hallway with no doors and no rooms if you think Brent outsings Bono on this. Don't get me wrong; the guys has crazy pipes (see the 5 acoustic sets from some dude's living room) and is one of my favorite singers, but Bono's ragged/emotional vocals ~2:48 blow Brent away on this. That said, Chris Cornell pwns them both.
TiltOWhirl 10 months ago
Sorry, you guys are living in a hallway with no doors and no rooms if you think Brent outsings Bono on this. Don't get me wrong; the guys has crazy pipes (see the 5 acoustic sets from some dude's living room) and is one of my favorite singers, but Bono's ragged/emotional vocals ~2:48 blow Brent away on this. That said, Chris Cornell pwns them both.
TiltOWhirl 10 months ago
how can such an amazing beautiful voice come from such an ugly guy, meant in the nicest possible way, I absolutly love shinedown
RHCPawsomeness 10 months ago
you arent wat tyhe call wrong the best an even more.
TheCyberman54 10 months ago
I think there's one thing we can agree on. Musical talent aside, Shinedown is one of the ugliest group of human beings ever assembled.
drew081886 10 months ago
@drew081886 I disagree with you, I have seen much worse.
demagos009 10 months ago
@drew081886 'Ugliest group of human beings ever assembled'...? Its a band, its not about their damn image.
Focus on the musical talent will you?
crakrjak661 9 months ago 4
@drew081886 'i think there's one thing we can agree on'
umm... actually we can't agree.
childsfan999 8 months ago
hmm i am sorry but U2 Ain't that good ... yeah i said it loud and clear !!
ahmedtevez 11 months ago
@ahmedtevez
Then why the fuck are you here listening to a U2 cover dope? Listen to Shinedown's original tunes fag.
mattressjedi 9 months ago
@mattressjedi dude chill out
ahmedtevez 9 months ago
U2 is on a diferent lvl. however its about 10 lvls under shinedown
kashmier81 11 months ago
So U2 writes probably one of the best songs of all time...Shinedown does a cover and they do it better??? Sorry I disagree, I am a Shinedown fan, but U2 is on a different level then most bands today. If someone does a Shinedown cover after they have been around for 30 years I will give them their deserved credit. But it is one of the best covers I have heard.
Kniner7 11 months ago
FINALLY A U2 SONG THAT I CAN APPRECIATE...so glad it's NOT U2 though!
eyeman2007 1 year ago
Fuck glee. They covered this. :l They wrecked it. I fucking love shinedown
Lollipop708 1 year ago
Best frekin band EVERRRRRRR! Brent is freakin AWESOOOOOMMMMMMEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
madbaby256 1 year ago
Eat that Bono!!! U2 sucks bawahhaa
mtdesignz 1 year ago 2
Bono just lost his job!
thebailey67 1 year ago
If Brent Smith's voice was a women i would make sweet sweet love to it.
MisterSam1000 1 year ago 3
back when shinedown was cool. great cover.
p2haley 1 year ago
this is amazing. this blows away all the other versions
cantwellben20 1 year ago
IF BONO HEARD THIS , HE WOULD DIE OF ENVY!!! BRENT IS THE BEST.
CAN'T WAIT TO SEE HIM AT THE PABST THEATER IN MILWAUKEE, WI NOVEMBER 30 FOR THEIR ACOUSTIC TOUR...
MM
MRMED123 1 year ago
definitely the best cover but Bono is still the man..
chosgalindosoriano 1 year ago
this is fantastic!!
londonblue61 1 year ago
how do i find this song to DL myself?
Deadcrows1981 1 year ago
Sounds alot like bono
Jakekissfan 1 year ago
@Jakekissfan but better.
thebailey67 1 year ago
@thebailey67 Idk I'm more of a bono fan but hey Shinedown is good too. xD
Jakekissfan 1 year ago
Never heard the original =(... Ima go watch it right now =)
BT1ZER 1 year ago
I love this version much more than the original one.I really love his voice!
angelaki21 1 year ago
Incredible. I like this much better than the original U2 version. Thanks for posting.
KDub1961 1 year ago
Best vocalist of all time!! :)
SimplyEnrico 1 year ago
brent smith is just like M and M's you just cant get enough.
crewcutter2030 1 year ago
well done! you did a really good job on this one!
maybe you have time to check out our videos!
we uploaded cover songs and 2 own songs.
leave a comment and subscribe!
love, GBS
nicki & ruben - gold becoming silver
goldbecomingsilver 1 year ago
LOVE IT....His soulful voice never cease to amaze me!
Cutsiepea 1 year ago
dam this is a cover!!!!!!
hregalado49 1 year ago
"best rock singer?" nore like best singer ever well robert plant but still the best of the best
happytoad1211 1 year ago
only 23k views???? so many millions are missing out on some epic shit here...
moron32 1 year ago 4
Well, I was expecting this to be terrible... and surprisingly its not. Its actually pretty good. Nowhere near the U2 version of course, but its not bad. I usually hate shinedown, but his isn't bad at all.
ohnojoeohno 1 year ago
this is the most beautifying song by shinedown
jeremyrhodes0218 1 year ago
@jeremyrhodes0218 yea and its by u2 dumbass
dxdx124 1 year ago
awesome cover of a great song!...wow....sounds very good.....
MandrewG 1 year ago
beautiful :)
they impress me more each time they perform a song<3
giolessthan3 1 year ago
so amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
sevenender 1 year ago
@ctru2000 smiths' voice was better for the job.....
ratu4000 1 year ago
i've loved this cover for YEARS, i wish more ppl new about it n wish they'd release it on an EP or something!
Shiner1991 1 year ago 4
someone please tell me how this only has 14k hits??
jamessmack 1 year ago 2
brent could drag some kids from a high school band and be great
jamessmack 1 year ago
Like the cover of Simple Man, I am infinitely impressed with this cover. Very few bands can cover a song and actually improve it. I have to say, here, they've done it, like in the Simple Man cover, but in that one they changed the song enough to make it theirs, in this, they're tackling the song, but not claiming it, so it's just a try at a song where they put their all into it. Impressive.
addisonshinedown 1 year ago
I like it.
frank787922 1 year ago
I cannot begin to tell you guys how talented shinedown are ! I've not come across a band apart from Rhcp that has changed me so much. There song Second chance, changed me almost instantly. And Call me , makes me reflect.
U2 on the other hand... ¬_¬
terryusa 1 year ago
I have seen U2 and Shinedown in concert (several yrs apart). Both are great performers vocally and musically. I love both bands. This song is equally as good as the original
jls1274 2 years ago
well if you payed $35 dolllars thats your fucking problem!!
lopezj4550 2 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
How dare you put this song on youtube? This song deserves to be bought or to be listened to by Shinedown Fan Nation members, now people are going to just come here and listen to it. Really man, why did you do this? I payed $35 dollars to get into the fan nation, and THAT was when I heard this song. You suck.
ElfAttacker 2 years ago
I heard when I saw the "Shinedown - One [Unplugged] Cover" video on YouTube, then it was taken off.
Sk4T3Z3r0 2 years ago
It is almost exactly the same as u2's
13yofrolfer 2 years ago
better
bigddetroit 2 years ago
Only because u are a shinedown fan they are litterally the exact same
13yofrolfer 2 years ago
its a cover of the song by U2. so yes, it should sound the same..
kaleb1414 1 year ago
@ctru2000 Same here . . .
Gazoooooodfbudh 2 years ago
Brent has such an amazing voice
Happy Birthday Brent!!!
whomitaw 2 years ago 5
He has a good voice. Not much for the guitar though. :\
EliteSonic 2 years ago
best cover of this song. . and I like this version better. . .brent is awesome
redph0enix2000 2 years ago 3
This guy will go down in history as one of the best vocalists, song writers and musicians of all time. And it couldn't be more deserved.
MarcoFranko 2 years ago 3
I heard this version before I heard U2's. So, naturally I like this one better. Plus factor in Shinedown is my favorite band, and this song is amazing anyway.
Plus Shinedown...puts so much meaning into the songs they sing. Brent has a very powerful voice. <3
ILoveCMPunkForever 2 years ago
I heard U2's before this one and I still like this one better.
Sk4T3Z3r0 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Eh I still like U2s version better
vindicatedafi 2 years ago
Agreed, but the boys do they job.
pacovailoes 2 years ago
i love it so much
brent's voice is amazing <3
ijsislekkerderdanjou 2 years ago 4
I love Shinedown!!!
JoeJonasLover123654 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this is the worst blasphemy i've ever heard!! o my fucking god!!! what da fuck is this fucking crap!! it's like he's shitting for gods sake!! he sings horrible.. how do you people like this fucking shit?? we're all nuts at this days!! god damned!!
kiltrus89 2 years ago
Are you deaf? Brent Smith(lead singer of shinedown) has an amazng voice. I would love for you to name 5 singers with better rock voices. Singing Hard rock music is very difficult. Show some respect.
penman1188 2 years ago 3
hahahaha... no shit. he's awesome. i like ivan moody from five finger death punch too. i think they are my 2 fav. singers
tombeals69 2 years ago 4
Love it!
lilmsash01 2 years ago
Such an incredibly good song. I actually heard the shinedown version BEFORE I heard the u2 one. (one haha) I personally prefer that the acoustic version is better ... mainly cause I like acoustic music more. Awesome cover 10/10
ravenprey666 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
shame the other video of this song has been removed
vidar99999 2 years ago
This is extremely impressive.
I'm a massive U2 fan and a moderate Shinedown fan, but I have to say that Brent Smith's voice impresses me more and more each time I hear him do something different.
Completely nailed, although it's a near chord-perfect cover at times.
AlphaAquila 2 years ago 5
This is the first time I've heard this, I think that Brent is the best rock singer out there today.
TheSmithbelynda 2 years ago 85
@TheSmithbelynda. I think Brent isn't the best rock singer. But he's in the top 5.
1. Brett Scallions (Fuel)
2. Chris Daughtry
3. Adam Gontier (Three Days Grace)
4. Jesse Hasek (10 Years)
5. Brent Smith
Aaron02890 1 year ago
@Aaron02890 god thats a horrible list but ure allowed an opinion
litatyas 1 year ago
@Aaron02890 where the fuck is bono
dxdx124 1 year ago
@dxdx124 I'm not really a big U2 fan.
Aaron02890 1 year ago
@Aaron02890 Brent, J. Hasek, Lajon Witherspoon, Brandon Boyd are better than Scallions and Daughtry but Gontier is up there.
77SoUnDoMaDnEsS77 1 year ago
@TheSmithbelynda He is.
wenser13 1 year ago
@TheSmithbelynda Without a doubt, Mr. Smith is thee best rock singer on the planet..The Sound Of Madness album has etched him in a special place..songwriting..and a voice to match and beyond..all 3 Shinedown Albums are epic.
smakman41 1 year ago
@TheSmithbelynda he's in the top, for sure... but he could be a lot better.... what you hear now is pure, unpolished talent.... think of what he could do with vocal training.... but then again, maybe that's his charm :D.....
DarkLionInteractive 1 year ago
@TheSmithbelynda I disagree. I'd have to go with Matt Shultz, or Josh Homme for sure
YcantWeAllGetAbong 9 months ago
@TheSmithbelynda myles kennedy.....
JosephTheRocker 8 months ago