Added: 3 years ago
From: harmonyaddict
Views: 24,936
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (179)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Nice cover, good job

  • Has anyone ever said you look like Jennifer Nettles?

  • Let's not forget it's a dead woman, or more likely a ghost borne of bad conscience who knocks on the window

  • Good cover. Tough song to sing. I;ve heard a few and most end up being a caricature rather than a cover of the song itself. Elegantly done.

  • This was the best interpretation. The quality of your voice, overcome Kate Bush.

    Congratulations

    José Roberto

    Esta foi a melhor interpretação que já vi. A qualidade de

    sua voz, supera, Kate Bush.

    Parabéns

    José Roberto

  • Beautiful.

  • very very good!

  • This is so haunting and beautiful.

  • Not bad, but still, there's nobody like Kate Bush ..

  • This is lovely.

  • That wasn't bad. Would have liked to see you hit the lower pitches in the song because when you don't it flattens the melody. But other than that this was a decent run at this tune.

    Hayley Westenra also does this song. You should check her version out.

  • Beautiful voice, captivating...

  • Enchanting......

  • Hhahhahahaha.

    Reminds me of fairies.

  • wow well done! that was really impressive ae gurl, kate bush songs aint easy to sing well, but wow you really pulled it off! good work! lol

  • I love that you sang it your own way rather than just imitating Kate - beautiful, very well done.

  • im sorry to say this but i so much prefer your version of this cover, your voice is so beautiful and haunting, perfect for this song, that and your enviroment around u looks very eerily ghost like, again perfect for the song. well done x

  • ... I totally would.

  • a wonder *.*

  • you do have a very good voice,in other videos.but this song just wasnt for you....it looks like you lipped sing.and yeah just no.

  • rhytm is totally wrong but good voice

  • Wow, you have a GORGEOUS voice. This is wonderful.

  • Cathy, shove off, your voice irritates me you little slapper!

  • but i think you are better

  • Wonderful!

  • You made it sound very ghostly. Pretty cool.

  • you look and sing like an angel.

    amazing.x

  • a song not so easy to sing a real heavy song..but you got the voice of a angel..wonderfull tune

    greets

    ender

  • u r fit :P

    email me plz :)

  • Very good! You are very good indeed!

  • Pretty good for such a challenging song. I think there could be more emotion.

  • Brilliant!  *applauds*

  • In the beginning some of the notes sounded wird but the rest was great!! *****

  • um...what the hell...who are you yin gto lip sinc too?

  • Read the desciption she is lip synching herself... this song is really hard to sing live...

  • i like this much better than the original...i feel like you have a very new age-y voice that really got the atmosphere of this song.

  • Oh wow. You nailed it!

    Good job!

  • Impressive. Your voice is pure like a cristal, probably a little less powerfull than Kate Bush's but more delicate.

    5 stars.

  • at the very beginning and especially in 00:02 you look a lot like Kirsten Dunst. I love your hair. You're really pretty.

  • really amazing, great performance of a stunningly haunting song. close to tears, beautiful.

  • u scary gothic girl.....

  • I just listened to about twenty covers by loads of people and each time I expect someone to begin to strangle themselves after the first few notes but everyone did it well and you did it effortlessly.

    Now what would a clever looking nice chick like you be singing about a lowdown sonofa***** like Heathcliff? No offence but Cathy was a bad girl full of spunk and probably even into a bit of pugilism in her quiet moments. She was a Tomboy you don't look like no tomboy.

    Off to find more covers

  • Ohh. your voice :")

  • It looks like you are lip syncing. Sound is good. Maybe the upload was off.

  • my gosh...you're beautiful! wow! haha, though that's probably not the type of feedback you wanted...your voice is beautiful. you have a great range, and the whole effect was very eerie. i loved it. :)

  • you seem an angel!!! =)

  • :O Amazing, Your Soo Pretty Aswell

  • Omg!!!

    Uu should sing you belong with me by taylor swift!!

  • You have an amazing range! I was thinking you were an alto but you blew this out of the water:) Great video!

  • Great voice, pretty girl, nice cover! One of my favorite songs ever. Well done. Keep on singin' Harmony!

  • I made "me dancing-wuthering heights" because of that video:):)very nice voice,you should keep it up:]

  • ouuuhh... I think I love u ^^' look so cute in this vid ;] I'll let u in ;d take everything ;d

  • All of a sudden there are all these songs I've never heard you perform!!! Wonderful, Amy. That's a HIGH VOICE! Marius

  • waauw

    so high and still exactly pinpoint right.

    amazing,

    why not a singing career instead of an acting one?

  • Rally enjoyed this one! Your voice suited the song well, although anyone that can sing that high and stay in tune has to be good :P

  • amazing voice:) amazing face:=

  • ma non capite che non sta cantando lei ma è un playback con la voce di kate bush in sottofondo. ma ci vuole tanto a capirlo?

  • Brava!

    Your Amazing.

    And you sound like Kate B.

    WOWA!

  • Wow, congrats! Mesmerizing cover!

  • Amy, very good! Your voice is definitely very unique and I know the secret, but I'll keep it quiet that makes it sound more amazing!

    I hope you try a career in musical theatre, your go far I reckon! x

  • wait seriously?? amazing voice!

  • god your beautiful,

    so's the voice :)

    x

  • More solo from you :-D Your sing amazing. I'm so in love with your voice :-)

  • Great voice and expression!!!! Pretty close to Kate Bush!!! I'm impressed!!!! :o)

  • you have a beautiful voice.

    and you are GORGEOUS

  • omg. please please sing green finch and linet bird from sweeny todd! it would be incredible!!! x

  • Shit, is that really your voice?

    Fantastic rendition.

  • nicely sung! not an easy song and you have the right range for it - well done.

  • very beautiful voice and cover....  thank you very much :)

  • hello amy, this is the best voice what i have hear in a cover of this song.

    please more from this, best regards ronny

    i hope we write in future

  • That was.. captivating. Very delicate, but still full of passion. Great performance. And this is coming from a Kate fan. Keep singing!

  • massive fan, you did this song beautifully haunting!!

  • You made my day with this version :-)

    I love this song and if a girl sings it with that look in your eyes for me, I'd fall in love with her, but because you are only a videoimage I won't, sorry for that.

  • WOW ! WONDERFUL VOICE ! ^^

    Where did you find this karaoke song ?

  • you is very sexy .

  • u kinda look angry

  • WOW!

    This must be a really hard song to sing, but you are amazing :D

    I've never heard such a beautiful voice!

  • I think this is a great song, and you did it well.

  • Very well performed!! Bravo!!!

  • wow thats reely goog well done

  • OMG ahhmazing.

  • i like your chair *highfive*

  • holy shit

    you have an AMAZING voice

  • Do you no what you'd be good at 'green finch and linet bird'... Youtube it... you want the movie version of sweeney todd that would be a class song to add to your covers, apparantley it's challenging and it got vibreto's in havn't a clue what they are lol =] x

  • You have a beautiful voice. I love your version of this song. :-)

  • you voice is amazing! almost hard to believe! i LOVE LOVE LOVE it!

  • I don't know how many times I have listened to this! It always gives me chills! Always amazes me and makes me want to hear more! Don't pay any attention to that weirdo. All the pros use more that just a little reverb. Just listen to Annie Lennox's song "Into the West" the studio edited one released in the movie and her live performance at the oscars, they are both great but there is an amazing difference. It takes Enya up to a yr, I have read, to do one song!! with all the xtra stuf she adds

  • Holy crap... just watched your Brooke White Let It Be video and clicked on your profile, saw this, and promptly subscribed! You have GREAT TASTE! lol :) Looking forward to more of your vids - thanks for sharing with us.

  • very good =)

    I like it

  • I adore this song to death! I enjoy the most Kate Bush's version which was done for her greatest hits album, and I also think Pat Benatar's version is great. But of all the "non professional" versions on YouTube, this is my Favorite. Your voice is lovely. You perform the song with very sweet and pure emotion. Hope to hear more from you. Best wishes!

  • You can Sing!! Realy!.. :D.

  • I think you should definately take the music that he did and stick you voiceover and make it an MP3 I would love to dl it lol :P

  • I really enjoyed this. Your voice is slightly more pure and wholesome compared to Kate Bush (for this song). And you're very pretty too. Need an agent?

  • woah, well that was brave, and you didn't destroy it! thats quite an achievement! how many times did you get lost in the precise yet eccentric vocal meandering of kate bush while trying to get this one?

  • Great voice?  That much electronic wizardry could make me sound good! About as genuine as Posh Spice.

  • lol, your name is fitting. If by "electronic wizardry" you mean adding reverb, then ok.  That's the only thing I did in post...I'm afraid I'm not much of an electronic wizard. :)

  • Great performance!

  • You are an excelent singer I love this

    song in your voice, Thanks Amy.

  • wow holy shit u have a damn good voice i really like the sort of distant feel that you put to your voice. You simply sound great love it, keep it up girl your awesome!

    ~Scott~

  • OMG!!! this is my favourite song!!

  • How on earth do you hit those notes lol

  • haha it's really cool to hear your voice without a background voice track, it sounds like something unreal, what we can imagine sounds an angel voice. It has a little "mylene farmer" (a french singer which has many fans here) style too. Great video !!

  • Hi Amy!

    Please read the comments on this song on my channel. Its strange that some people write here positive comments and write negative on mine.

    Interesting!See you my friend;)Bernd

  • because she can sing (at least a little) and you cannot?

  • hahahahahahah you are funny:)

  • speachless...

  • First off I am a huge Kate Bush Fan, this song is very very hard to cover. I think you're brave, and definitely gave it a good shot. It's done well, I understand why you did the echo, but try it without. Underneath you have a fantastic voice.

  • First off I am a huge Kate Bush Fan, this song is very very hard to cover. I think you're brave, and definitely gave it a good shot. It's done well, I understand why you did the echo, but try it without. Underneath you have a fantastic voice.

  • wow you should sing like this alot more!!!!!

    love your hair!!

  • I've got to say, I like your voice so much better. You should do some enya or something from celtic women you have that sort of etheral quality to your voice. that was great^^good job!!!!I love it^^

  • I've got to say, I like your voice so much better. You should do some enya or something from celtic women you have that sort of etheral quality to your voice.

  • It looks like you're playbacking it.. too bad..

  • Your voice is tender and high and sweet and beautiful :D And the angle and lighting on the visual contributes to the feel of the song. Magical. Very beautiful, thanks for uploading

    Sissy

  • Uu r so amazin at singin, its so unfair

    im tone deff lol xx

  • LOL, I know what you mean! ME too, but you are not tone deaf if you can hear how sweet Amy's voice is, my ears are pitch perfect but I can't carry a tune is really an understatement but if my soul could sing I would want it to sound just like Amy!

  • Another five stars! Great job and love the lighting! :)

  • that was great^^good job!!!!I love it^^

  • LLLLLUV IT!!!!! ITS EXCELLLLLLLLENT! Sorry I am so late to watch but I did not know you put it up! BAD FRIEND! I was so adamant about hearing your solo! sheesh!

    keep em comingAmy ! xo-ario

  • Hi! I comming to watch your last vidéo, i am suprised ! I ear this song interpreted by "Angra" since many year, i did not know Angra borrow this song from other artist lol ! ;P Was on "Angel cry" album. Keep it up to sing with your nice angel voice, you are sunshine! :)

  • This is a great video, but even better after watching the movie, Wuthering Heights. I recommend the 1992 version with Ralph Fiennes and Juliette Binoche. Watch the movie; then listen to Amy's rendition of the song. Then comment! :)

  • You are absolutely right, dblcha!

  • Amy, your voice is so angelic and unique! It can go anywhere! I have read the word pure to describe it and that is what comes out. Your hit notes so pure and clean sometimes it makes my heart jump. I can't wait untill someone is smart enough to sign you and you start making CD's, Your voice is amazing and I think you have only touched the beginning of coming into, growing into, finding your talent.

  • This REALLY works for you! Bravo!

  • Your high voice makes me melt like candle wax :D

    I don't need to see the video, just your voice is enough that I tend to say 'Marry me' ;))

    5

    Kris

  • Love this loads. :)

    Just about as much as my fake blonde top :)

    (My favourite version of this song.. EVER! but shusshhh, don't tell Kate Bush!) xx

  • I've never seen or heard this song before you guys did the collab, I've sinced watched Kate Bush do it and I still like your version better Amy, although both Kate and Sarah have amazing voices, theres something about your voice that soothes me (guess its that savage beast within)

  • no offense, but tis looks a little fake... also, it's echoeing. er... explain plz? (soz if it's not fake)

  • what do you mean fake?

    The only thing fake I see is her beautiful blonde hair

  • I mean that it's echoeing, and well... just looks a little fake... but I honestly don't actually thin k it is

  • Oh, lol, that's just a reverb effect. It's an effect I added when editing the sound. She's supposed to be a ghost out on the wiley moors, so I wanted it to have that faraway, eerie feel to it. :)

  • The first thing i felt was Spooooky!! then i had a hard time hearing the lyrics through out the whole song more wailing then lyric :] but your always so beautiful all the time hugs! ciao

  • So, what is your real hair colour then?? xD

    :) Amizing stuff hon.

  • I do believe you can see Amy's non-blonde hair color in her video:

    Love is Patient - A Funny Short Film starring Amy Treadwell

  • Love it! Such an amazing voice you have!

    -Juliet

  • You are really pretty Amy! The song sounds great!

  • Ah, I've looked at the other videos! Kate Bush is great of course, but you should know that YOU really do something special with this! Awesome I think is an understatement!

  • Wow this is awesome! I can't wait to listen to your other songs/vids! 5/5 :D Jess

  • Ah, this song brings me back. You sound good -- though maybe the reverb is maybe too echoey -- your face is close to the screen, but the singing sounds far away. I hope I don't sound too critical as I am a Kate Bush fan :)

  • U said my range is remarkable. haha...I wanna say Ur range is incredible.

  • Amy you are wonderful! And I watched your video many times before I did our collaboration video;)

    Thanx for being my friend!Bernd

  • Good one.You have some of Kates quirky style and mannerisns :)

  • Is 3000 miles too far... Oh yeah cause i guess the most anyone has walked was 500 and 500 more haha... I fall in love every time I hear you sing :) Peace hun and keep up the great singing..

    dave

  • Your voice is beautiful!

    I love this!

    Great job as always! (:

    -McKenzie

  • haha i started to listen while seeing another page, and suddendly i thoght, waow but who's taht chil singing haha... and it was you. That is very cute :D would you mind telling me if you ever received the message about the collab (i had lots of pb with messages on yt lately). 5* ciao

  • Good!!! :*

  • Kate Bush has an awesome voice and an incredible range. She is not the easiest person to cover. The collaboration video was excellent and so is this. I am glad that you posted it. 5 stars.

  • beautiful

  • omg your hair is SO gorgeous and becoming of you it makes me go wtf roflkopter all over the floor.

  • eeeeeee!

    Me likes!

    A lot!

    I'm jealous of your beautiful voice! And hair.

    Fantastic-o job!

  • i LOVE your hair like that

  • Absolutely beautiful...especially after watching the movie last week. Amy makes Cathy "come alive" again!

  • Were you really singing!! If you were your awesome!!!!!!!

  • I've never heard this song before. You sound great!!

  • Great job AMY!! You have a lovely voice xx

  • great singing! It's a nice song. :)

  • Love the book. This is hauntingly beautiful. You make a good Cathy.

  • I saw that before...as a collaboration, Amy hun wonderful I feel as I am in heaven.

  • what an amazing and icredible sound :) i feel lack of words to explain how beautiful cover you`ve just created:) *****

  • Just Beautiful...

  • excellent,great cover!!!!!!!!

  • The angel is singing for us again ;o)

    Wish you a great weekend, hugs Fab

  • perfect! would you do this song as a duet with me? you did it great!

  • pretty good. the best part was "Oooh, let me have it! let me grab your soul" that was even sung better than Kate Bush(to all Kate Bush fans: I am a great Kate Bush fan, too)

  • great job with a tough song!! I enjoyed your performance..

  • great job..sound pretty close to original to me....peace

  • Amy..This deserved 2 comments!!! =)

    Great singing as ALWAYS!!!

    =)

  • Fantastic Vocals and Performance Amy!!

    you're really spectacularly talented!!!

    =)

  • cool Amy! Finally you did it!;)hahahah

    you look so lovely on this video

    I am happy this song started it all:)hahaha well, actually you were famous beforee already:)hugs, Bernd

  • hauntingly beautiful...

  • wow girl you cant forget that smile of yours so much emotion, hmm i havent done a vid with one lately, hm wonder why? ohh yeah im

    waiting for my new cam, finally

  • you are soo great..I love all your vidz!! can't wait for more!!

  • Very well done Amy, this is a very interesting song.

  • A voice of an Angel... WoW..Thanks!

    E!

  • Woah, so beautiful! A lovely song.

  • niceeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee! i love it. hey you should do samson by regina spektor!

  • Thank you!! And lol, I already did Samson! I love that song. :)

  • hey, yeah, i forgot you did. lol sorry! =]

Loading...