@MySanim Perhaps it is, but there is no real evidence - likely it is just from borrowing. For example, Finnish has borrowed alot words from Swedish, but our language still is not related to Swedish.
@ahtamov Многим алтайским (в особенности тюркским), также как и уральским, языкам присуще правило гармонии гласных, потому языки тебе и могли показаться схожими, но на самом деле это не так. Мари - финно-угры, и их язык принадлежит к уральской языковой семье, а не к индо-европейской.
If "setunle" means "I love you" in a language I'm guessing it's a Ugric language. Hungarian for example has the verb suffix "-lek" which means "I ... you" for example szeretlek is "I love you".
That's because Mari language contains the greatest amount of Turkic loanwords, as I mentioned above. )) But Turkic-speaking person nevertheless wouldn't understand Mari language - it has different root and therefore different grammar, syntax, the most of verbs in basic vocabulary etc.
Would an English understand a hypothetical phrase "He dogovayet do stora i pocallayet?" All words except prepositions and conjunctions are English here (!), but I suppose he still wouldn't understand a thing. :)
Sure, I don't argue with that. I know that Mari language is a part of Finn-Ugric languages, therefore I was just surprised about the existence of common words.
Well, no wonder. As I also said, even Slavic languages contain a noticeable amount of Turkic loanwords. You could examine such Russian words as "богатырь" (from ancient Turkic "ba'atur" - Kaz. "batyr"), "туман" (no comments - just a slight shift in meaning), "кулак" (from ancient Turkic "kulak"<-"kolak"<-"kol"), "боярин" (from either "bay" or "boyla"), "хозяин" ("hoja"), "кабан" (no comments at all) - and see that they're also of Turkic origin.=)
Joltash is a Turkic loanword in the Mari language. The language itself is still Finno-Ugric in synthaxis, grammar and the most of vocabulary. There are many Turkic loanwords even in the Russian language: khozyain (owner, from Turkic hoja), tuman (fog), khalat (some kinds of clothes), bashmak (shue or clog), kulak (fist) etc. Most of such words have come into Russian and Mari languages during the sway of the Golden Horde (XIII-XV centuries).
"Em" affix in Finno-Ugric languages is very ancient (for example, it presents in Hungarian language too, despite of all the difference between these languages). Similar affixes take plase also in Turkic languages (-ym suffix in the Tatar language). But thats not all: the similar words exist in Indo-European languages too! Although these words arent affixes (Indo-European languages just dont use em so wide), all they contain m sound and different service sounds. My, mein, moy, mi, miy etc.
Ezek a mari számok.A kiejtést fonetikusan írtam. Nem tudom hogyan kell cirill betűket gépelni, pedig már ismerem őket. Gondolom, valmi külön berendezés kell hozzá vagy külön program, nem tudom.. Órán így írtam le őket, gondoltam, hátha akad majd 1-2 ember, aki majd örül nekik.:)
I just saw this - a Novgorod vid. Four men singing who sound as if they are 40 men.
Great singing so you might check it out. Quite different from the tune of your vid here. We just got back from Alaska so several vids up for Ketchikan.
neat cat! 14erjohn has two black ones like this one. The male will chase after a crumpled piece of paper, play with it and then bring it to you to throw again. Kinda like a dog wanting to play "fetch:
Dimuska, исправьте, пожалуйста, "тӱсЕтлан" и "ошоМ чие"
Yulavy 5 months ago
Скажите, марийский язык Ваш родной?
dimuska 5 months ago
@dimuska, да, я марийка
Yulavy 5 months ago
А, спасибо. Я не заметил. Жалко, что нет больше слов..
kloiten 7 months ago
Здравствуйте! Где можно найти слова к этой чудесной песне? Спасибо!
kloiten 7 months ago
@kloiten Не знаю, но кое-что имеется в информации о видеоклипе.
dimuska 7 months ago
Beautiful song
andres6868 7 months ago
My mother was studying with him when I was a little kid. I remember him=)
Dima100 10 months ago
what a great song
andres6868 10 months ago
We all have common Altaian roots, but we mostly forgot each other ... :(
IdelUralState 1 year ago
Кунам чонетлан келша,чонетат куана!!!!!
Madera309 1 year ago
I found some Kazakh/Turkic words in Mari language.Very interesting did not even think that Maryi is related to Turks.
MySanim 1 year ago
@MySanim Perhaps it is, but there is no real evidence - likely it is just from borrowing. For example, Finnish has borrowed alot words from Swedish, but our language still is not related to Swedish.
tvpnbb 7 months ago
Ничего общего с татарским =)
Ve1nard 1 year ago
на татарский похоже...
ahtamov 1 year ago
@ahtamov Многим алтайским (в особенности тюркским), также как и уральским, языкам присуще правило гармонии гласных, потому языки тебе и могли показаться схожими, но на самом деле это не так. Мари - финно-угры, и их язык принадлежит к уральской языковой семье, а не к индо-европейской.
GordonFreeMANness 11 months ago
Mari's such a lovely language. Are there good resources for learning it? Only found basic grammar and small vocab list on net
Thanks, setunle
BTW that means "I love you" in my language- you'll never guess which I bet!
setunle 2 years ago
See the information of the video, there are some links :)
dimuska 2 years ago
@setunle
If "setunle" means "I love you" in a language I'm guessing it's a Ugric language. Hungarian for example has the verb suffix "-lek" which means "I ... you" for example szeretlek is "I love you".
So... Khanty? Mansi?
wilsonsamm 2 years ago
No, it's not a Ugric language.
Se= I , tun=love, le= you
I'll give you numbers and see if that is a clue
1 ze 2 gel 3 noi 4 cy 5 dy 6 bek 7 mas 8 tol 9 up 10 lan.
c as in "cello" y is like a in "extra" (schwa)
Mai = hello, Gile? How are you?
Deti kos! Very well thanks!
Selat os le zadu lati = I think you're really clever
Zidar ezike palatse pale= all kinds of everything remind me of you
Mari ze ke zisa kum se lubanim = Mari is one of the mostbeautiful languages I have ever heard
setunle 1 year ago
@setunle 1 ikot 2kokot 3kandash 4tengeche, 5vizyt
Dima100 10 months ago
@Dima100 1 ikyt, 2 kokyt, 3 kumyt, 4 nylyt, 5 vizyt, 6 kudyt, 7 shymyt, 8 kandashe, 9 indeshe, 10 lu.
dimuska 10 months ago
@dimuska Ну да) Просто я не знаю марийский хорошо. Очень плохо, а сам мариец)
Dima100 10 months ago
"jalkaisin"= "by feet", "walking" in finnish.
"jalka"= foot. "yalka"
We share the same path, to some extent......
siconen75 2 years ago
Zholdas in Kazakh - friend also. Interesting, so similar to Turkic languages.
Glazagoluboisobaki 2 years ago
That's because Mari language contains the greatest amount of Turkic loanwords, as I mentioned above. )) But Turkic-speaking person nevertheless wouldn't understand Mari language - it has different root and therefore different grammar, syntax, the most of verbs in basic vocabulary etc.
Would an English understand a hypothetical phrase "He dogovayet do stora i pocallayet?" All words except prepositions and conjunctions are English here (!), but I suppose he still wouldn't understand a thing. :)
Alexey6759 2 years ago
Sure, I don't argue with that. I know that Mari language is a part of Finn-Ugric languages, therefore I was just surprised about the existence of common words.
Glazagoluboisobaki 2 years ago
Well, no wonder. As I also said, even Slavic languages contain a noticeable amount of Turkic loanwords. You could examine such Russian words as "богатырь" (from ancient Turkic "ba'atur" - Kaz. "batyr"), "туман" (no comments - just a slight shift in meaning), "кулак" (from ancient Turkic "kulak"<-"kolak"<-"kol"), "боярин" (from either "bay" or "boyla"), "хозяин" ("hoja"), "кабан" (no comments at all) - and see that they're also of Turkic origin.=)
Alexey6759 2 years ago
Very close to Turkic languages.
Yoldaş (Turkish) as Joltaš in Mari means "friend" or "comrade"
It comes from the word "yol" (way) i guess. Joltaš literally means people who share the same way, called friend. =)))
-daş/-taş is used for common things between people. i dont think it comes from the word "jol" which means foot in Mari.
for example
yurt -> homeland; yurttaş is used for people who live in the same homeland, it also means citizen.
TheHunnicHorseman 2 years ago
marin kieli on mielenkiintoinen xD nice song
blackmambafreak 2 years ago 5
Kiitos!
dimuska 2 years ago
a nice song..
Siberyah 2 years ago
go ural-altai brothers ! sizde minem yoldashlarimiz siniz !
OrthoDogs 2 years ago
Én ritkán érzek nemztei büszkeséget, de ezek a dalok kihozzák belőlem.
Go Finno-Ugric brothers!
viharsarok 2 years ago 2
anatolian turkish = oh, yuldashim
finno-ugric mari = oh, joltashem
OrthoDogs 2 years ago 2
Joltash is a Turkic loanword in the Mari language. The language itself is still Finno-Ugric in synthaxis, grammar and the most of vocabulary. There are many Turkic loanwords even in the Russian language: khozyain (owner, from Turkic hoja), tuman (fog), khalat (some kinds of clothes), bashmak (shue or clog), kulak (fist) etc. Most of such words have come into Russian and Mari languages during the sway of the Golden Horde (XIII-XV centuries).
Alexey6759 2 years ago
what is with the endings "im" and "em" ?
OrthoDogs 2 years ago
These endings mean "my". Joltaš - friend, joltašem - my friend :)
dimuska 2 years ago
its is like in the turkic language, we are using these endings too :)
OrthoDogs 2 years ago
Comment removed
Alexey6759 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
"Em" affix in Finno-Ugric languages is very ancient (for example, it presents in Hungarian language too, despite of all the difference between these languages). Similar affixes take plase also in Turkic languages (-ym suffix in the Tatar language). But thats not all: the similar words exist in Indo-European languages too! Although these words arent affixes (Indo-European languages just dont use em so wide), all they contain m sound and different service sounds. My, mein, moy, mi, miy etc.
Alexey6759 2 years ago
Comment removed
Alexey6759 2 years ago
Some scientists even suppose that Indo-European, Altaic and Ural languages are all related
Alexey6759 2 years ago
Пеш кугу тау эстон гыч!!!
stacyashford 2 years ago
What a sweet cat! Is the song about the cat (as a friend) ?
SashSegal 3 years ago
No xD
But the cat is really sweet :)
dimuska 3 years ago
This is superb, where do you find all these great Mari songs?
OgeLin 3 years ago
Register at marisong{dot}ru and you'll be available to download Mari songs!
dimuska 3 years ago
Who is talking in Mali language? ;/
kapsjel 3 years ago
I can talk little bit, because i'a, half Mari
Dima100 3 years ago 2
ik, kok, kum, nöl, vics, kut, söm, kándás,
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8,
indés, lu
9 10
Ezek a mari számok.A kiejtést fonetikusan írtam. Nem tudom hogyan kell cirill betűket gépelni, pedig már ismerem őket. Gondolom, valmi külön berendezés kell hozzá vagy külön program, nem tudom.. Órán így írtam le őket, gondoltam, hátha akad majd 1-2 ember, aki majd örül nekik.:)
admirerofvoguls 3 years ago
I am very glad you liked it :)
dimuska 3 years ago
This language is so beautyful!I love mari language!
admirerofvoguls 3 years ago
but joltashem is from turkic?
Qaraqurt 4 years ago
Joltašem means "my friend", joltaš (friend) is from "jol" - "leg, foot".
dimuska 4 years ago
jol is way
Qaraqurt 4 years ago
"yul" is way in Tatar! In Mari language "jol" means "leg" or "foot" :)
dimuska 4 years ago
There could be a common root with jalka (gen. jal-a-n) in finnish, couldn't it?
vikinen 4 years ago
Yes, it is a common root with jalka!
dimuska 4 years ago
jol-tash-em is a loan from turkic/tatar
Qaraqurt 4 years ago
This word is not connected with Mari word "joltaš"!
dimuska 4 years ago
in turkish "kol" -> "arm , leg for animal"
amca1923 3 years ago
in turkish "kol" -> "arm , leg for animal"
and in turkish's trıbe yoruk say "ayakdas" like "yoldas" ; "ayak" = "foot"
amca1923 3 years ago
kar - arm of a person in hungarian
ready4anyting 2 years ago
Erdekes mari zene de alig hasonlit a magyarra :)
Lempi21 4 years ago
Did I understand it correctly when you said that this sounds like Hungarian?
golddragonfly 4 years ago
No , maybe who is not a Hungarian speaker Phonetic for them sons like Hungarian. But its fare away from Hungarian. But its a nice song.
Lempi21 4 years ago
Super song and super cat :)
golddragonfly 4 years ago 5
You are right! :D
dimuska 4 years ago
Beautiful cat.
Did you know there is a village called Dima in the province of Bizkaia? Bizkaia maite...
kelomike 4 years ago
Now I know =) Gracias
dimuska 4 years ago
Is that your own cat?, you look after it well.
Duncanish41 4 years ago
No, that's not my cat, although I would like to have that cat :)
dimuska 4 years ago
Singing men in Kostroma - Russia
I just saw this - a Novgorod vid. Four men singing who sound as if they are 40 men.
Great singing so you might check it out. Quite different from the tune of your vid here. We just got back from Alaska so several vids up for Ketchikan.
granskare 4 years ago
рахмат)))
DimaVal 4 years ago 2
Отлично))) Классная песенка))) а есь ещё Шакиров?
DimaVal 4 years ago 2
Зарегистрируйтесь на сайте marisong ru и поищите. Там много марийских песен)) И Шакиров там тоже есть.
dimuska 4 years ago
neat cat! 14erjohn has two black ones like this one. The male will chase after a crumpled piece of paper, play with it and then bring it to you to throw again. Kinda like a dog wanting to play "fetch:
mvh,
granskare 4 years ago