Added: 2 years ago
From: Cinetic
Views: 94,497
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (327)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • this is what happen when you let your kids get away with thing . parent always pay the price

  • peace, just beautiful.

  • awesome movie!!! good job everyone!!!

  • This movie broke my heart. It says so much about the barriers we put up to separate ourselves from each other. The producer, directer, writer and actors have produced a master piece for peace.

  • Comment removed

  • This film brings people to tears, the film is really great.

  • A heart touching story.

    Sad that ordinary people suffer pain due to conflict between nation.

    Both nations buy weapons instead of providing basic necessity goods to its people.

  • absolutely love this movie! A well directed, well acted film all the way!!

  • It's a nice movie, tht the family got reunited again =). 

  • What a nice movie.. Brilliant work by all.. Touching one,@@

  • Very beautiful and sad movie. Much better than that bollywood shit!

  • just like veer zara ,,, almost

  • yea im 20 and im a guy,, nd i think im very strong bla bla bla ,, but the last scene made me cry :'(

  • very nice movie,,,i love pakistan

  • good film

  • This movie is wonderful! I was deeply moved by the sincerity, truthfulness, and emotional tribute to human suffering between India and Pakistan. I highly recommend this film to anyone who enjoy great cinematographic motion pictures. One Love ~ Kamal

  • is there HINDU IN PAK....LOL

  • @jkarry163 about 500 lol.

  • Awww..such a nice movie. That last scene was so touching!

  • Oh man, what a beautiful film.

  • Uh .... one times one? Definitely not two lol.

  • very nice movie! i love it... Pakistan Zindabad

  • good movie ever. why american dont make this kinds of movie?

  • Wow amazing movie. I hope family is doing well now.

  • nice movie

  • theme of this movie is really good. Nandita, maria wasti and rashid farooqi has done a good job. Tempo is a bit slow and end of the movie could be even better. Anyway its a good attempt by mehreen jabbar and should be appreciated.

  • A bit slow, a bit sad, and a bit to cheer about as well. A Pakistani Urdu film - only non-Pakistani actor is Nandita Das. Well done.

  • i love nandita das....shes always taking really good film roles.

  • Every problem in this world seems to stem from politics.

    Great movie. It makes me want to learn more about Hindus in Pakistan. Hindus and Muslims can live in unity, but whenever politics comes up it seems to ruin whatever friendship was left. All of this arguing on this page is pointless, and then some fuckers contributing to the argument comment other videos asking questions like, "Why does it have to be these way between us? Why can't we be united?"

  • @blazin436 I felt the same way.

    In addition, I felt my worries about retirement fund balance (401K), net worth, my children's college fund, vacation, status among friends etc. are so trivial after watching this movie.

  • The movie is really great, and the basic message shows many examples of how ordinary Muslim and Hindus can get along with in both sides.... that's what people should learn

  • @Karakalpakstan WTF 

  • The movie is really great, and the basic message shows many examples of how ordinary Muslim and Hindus can get along with in both sides.... that's what people should learn

  • Comment removed

  • Nice movie! Liked it.

  • Nice movie... I wonder how many innocent people are held on both sides of the border even today...

  • sayin indian r gay.....FUK U FUCKIN PAKISSSSSSSS.....DUMB AS MOTHERFUCKER

  • awesome movie!

    I wonder why it wasnt as famous and stuff.

    oscar deserving.

    amazing acting from everyone!

    great direction too.

    the kid was so adorable! =D

    both of them, actually.

  • "Imagine there's no countries, it isn't hard to do,

    Nothing to kill or die for, No religion too,

    Imagine all the people living life in peace...."

    John Lennon

  • i sure hope kids like that everywhere get good beatens by there parents

  • Nice, touching movie.

  • A Soul touching movie. This is called cinema with a purpose........ Cinema is more than businessthis movie is the perfect example of that.

  • Nadita Das is soo damn beautiful. I lover her

  • And 'Slumdog Millionaire' was the Oscar nominated 'Best Movie' ? Just, Wow!!

  • auh786: Thats EXACTLY, came to my mind. 'Slumdog Millionaire' just had hoopla behind it... I dont even see a comparision. ramchand Pakistani is much better movie and desreved oscar more than atleast Slumdog..

  • @grqk lol nobody gives a shot to what u think!! Slumdog is way better!!!

  • @ssukhwal lol on what? First dont live in any imgination. Slumdog Millionaire is a 2008 British film directed by Danny Boyle, written by Simon Beaufo. So the awards were for those and not for pathetic indian talent. Second on what it was awarded, showing the filth in indian life... now you can lol.

  • lol!!! We indians always look at ourselves and go ahead!! what do you think? the county who got its independence about 60 years ago can be perfect in a short amount of time!! it took USA 200 years to become perfect. Man! of you compare India today to 1947 India, then you will know how much we have progressed!! But Pakistan is still living in 1947!! no progress! except in terrorism and poverty!! guess what the biggest slum in Asia is Orangi Town, Krachi!! now you can lol!

  • I said in my last comments that dont live in any imagination you did not listen !. Yes. there may be 3/4 indians in top 10 richest people but 90% of the rest of india is living in slumps. And just to keep records straight anybody reading the comments serach for Asia's biggest slum and see for yourself if you see Orangi Town or some thing else.:)

  • who the fuck told you that 90% on indians live in slums!! only less than 30% of indians live in slums!! and if 90% lived in slums then there would have been slums in every city! the slums are only in kolkata and mumbai! Majority of Indians are middle class and about 10% are rich like hell and only 30% live below poverty line which will be 5% by 2020! and orangi town is the biggest slum in asia! please dont listen to some mullas!! listen to news and read some fact books not some religious books!

  • @ssukhwal ok 30% live in slums :)

  • and guess what!! 90% of pakistan lives in slum because whole pakistan is a slum!! I know people who are from pakistan and they work in 7-11!!! they told me that every single street of pakistan is fileld with pigs and shit!!! they had to move to islamabad, the only nice city of paksitan!!!

  • Abbey harami kutte @ssukhwal...Pakistan is like heaven as compared to India. half of your bombay and Delhi lives on roads you bastard...Pakistan is WAY better then india

  • AHAHAH!! Finally you arrived at your aukaad!!!! I knew it was coming!! that is the comeback of paki extrimists!!

  • learn to speak first harami kutte...what is aukaad? you bastard must be a south indian....haha...speaking some animal language

  • @ssukhwal well 30% makes it about 300 million of Indian population which is more than whole population of Pakistan. And I did read the news as you suggested. bbc co uk/new/10609407. or Google "'More poor' in India than Africa" Cheers :)

  • Slumdog was better than this I agree....but Slumdog was definitely overrated if you ask me....

    It's just that people in the West have never seen a movie like that so they go gaga over it.

  • I agree with you!! west only recongnizes western movies. They have no clue about 99% og asian movies. Specially south asian movies, which deserve much more than the western movies in some cases. and Ramchand Pakistani was an awesome movie. It should have been gone for oscars. But guess what, I dont give a shit to oscers. they are western awards. we south asians should make our own oscar. name it something south asian and then do our own movie festival. that would piss west off!!

  • Ignore my last comment because it was neccessary for that pakistani noob who was abusing India!! but this movie made me cry!!

  • I ernjoyed this film alot

  • Such a moving story. Gets you thinking more like a human being and less like a pakistani or indian.

    What are borders anyway ... other than an artificial line in the ground? How is a border between two countries all that different from a border between two states?

  • India gets its name from the Indus river which flows in Pakistan. We are not different, its we dont believe each other which causes most confusion. Politicians must learn to believe.

  • To all in this forum,

    If u have seen the movie in you tube and enjoyed it, you would be surprised to know that the movie shown in Pakistan did not have the scene where maulvi (Naseeruddin Shah) defends Islam and denounces terrorism in the court scene. A lot of mullahs in Pakistan could not take the criticism. There was a lot of debate and that scene (the most vital in that movie with some amazing active by Shah) was deleted.

    Pakistanis may want to debate here why that scene was deleted.

  • wow, it is actually an almost 2hrs long movie!! great youtube allow it and thanks for helping me grow a little bit tonight

  • plz think..keep pressure on your own governament, now to be sad they are tasting the taste of their own medicine from talibans.very sorry to pakistan in the condition they got in to!

  • to respected civilians of pakistan ,

    India.

    Every time there is a war b/w both the countries

    India recieves bodies of shahid jawaans from pakistan very ill tortured ,brutally butcherred! But never from India side.And India never invaded foriegn province for the pat 10,000 years thats fact and history.

  • people,y politicize a film?does anybody not know that india violates human rights in kashmir?how about the 2002 gujarat genocide of muslims?or the 2008 christian genocide in orissa?not to mention the sikhs killed only cuz they wanted a khalistan to secure their rights..Amnesty International anybody?i have nothing against indians ppl,but i hav everything against their human rights abusing government...same for the U.S and israel

  • @ Heartgold92

    India doesnt violate human rights but u muslims and pakist do by killing hindus in pakistan!! India just kills the violent muslim pigs living in India!! Muslim killed over 80 million Hindus when they invaded India so we are taking some revenge!! Today muslims in kashmir kill kashmiri pundits and force them out of their own homes.!!! You muslims are not humans but u guys are wild pigs!! So India doesnt violate huma rights!!

  • "India dosnt violate human rights"??? The funniest joke I have ever heard

  • @ssukhwal: The kind of language you are using ONLY shows your family background

  • the joke of the century! "islam is the religion of peace" lol muahahahaah

  • Comment removed

  • No thats a uneducated comment you made!! Hindus dont have 1 billion gods you asshole!! there is only one god and those one billion are just forms of that one supreme lord Krishna!!! But you guys worshipp a non existing god or in other words Satan. Thats why you guys blow your self up, kill innocent people, marry 9 year old innocent girls, beat girls, marry your own sisters, do jihaad to get 72 virgins, etc. Now lol on that!!!

  • ill tell you now everything you said is absolutely wrong.. and if you get upset at what people say about your religion learn to respect others, especially when you dont know anything about it. maybe you'll sound a little bit more "educated" than you think you are :)

  • I learned this language when I was learning urdu. The word of origins from urdu--- bhenchod, madarchod, bhen ka luada, maa ki choot, etc. I am learning lot of urdu!!

  • lmao and you say im uneducated?

    get your facts straight boy then ill get mine straight ..i actually 100% respect every religion even hinduism.. what i said came out of anger im sorry about that lol

    no disrespect for real, you have you opinions and i have mine and im not pakistani but i understood one of the words you said hahaa niice ;)

  • You are confusing me now!! First you strted fighting with me and now you are being nice! I am confused???? and what i said also came out of anger!!

  • i wasnt fighting lol i just didnt like what you said.. and im sure you didnt like what i said and we both were wrong so im sorry really i respect everyones religion it wasnt right what i said :(

    so yeah im done goodbye :) peace to all!! lol :D

  • ok I am sorry too!! Peace!! USA rocks!!

  • @ssukhwal: You dont deserve an answer. BTW,All these words which you are attributing to Urdu, are WLL KNOWN sanskrit words but this is not the point. I dont think I need to explain you the point as I dont want to wast any more time answering you.

  • Lol!! you are undecucated these words didnt exist in india till muslim invasion!! and i dont want you to teach me your wrong mulla book!! you go to a madarsa! I dont!! please dont talk to me!!

  • @ssukhwal: you are not only stupid, but ill mannered.

  • lol you are ill mannerd!! didnt i told you to not talk to me!! Are you gay?

  • @ssukhwal: Why? are you looking for a gay?

  • no! I was making sure that you are because then i would know who not to talk with!!!

  • So you dont talk to gays? Are you not in touch with ANYBODY from INDIA as all indians are gays.

  • You wish indians were gays but if we were gays then we would not have had a population of over a billion!! but in pakistan, there are so many gays that few not gay guys have to marry 5 girls each to cover them!! muahahah!!

  • ok @grqk, I will follow your advice but just as a last check with @ssukhwal

    Hey @ssukhwal, did you forget to drink cow pis today morning?

  • stop drinking camel and pig piss now!!! please stop reading some mulla books!! you are going out of your mind you mindless sheep!!

  • @qkhan001: Please dont waste your time to talk to @ssukhwal bastard. He is too silly to talk to. I did that mistake of replying to him but then I backed off as he does not use his brians and just keep writing stupidities

  • Lol I dont know about cow piss!! but how many times have a told you to stop drinking camel psss!!

  • Abe Sukhwal... Why do you talk nonsense? We Indians need to set an example, not mess our name talking crap in public forums. If you have an argument against someone, make it politely and stick to the point. If someone abuses you, just ignore them because they don't deserve your attention. Simple!

  • ahahhah!! you are right!! there is nothing that can be achieved by educating porks!!!

  • @ssukhwal: Thats exactly why we are not trying to educate you. lol...

  • why are you talking to me?? Havent I told you that I dont talk to fags like you? Pleasse go blow yourself up for the sake of this world!!

  • abbe harami kutte... soour ki aulad...dick sucker. madarchod, bhenchod...just thought of letting you know who you are.

  • I am from Rajasthan and Aukaad is something you lack!!

  • Why @ssukhwal talk nonsense....cos he is non sense and idot...Simple!

  • moron..

  • moron?...I thought your name was hellfireyoutube' bastard.

  • If I have a explain that I am calling you a moron then Muslims like you really don't have a brain. Blowing up airplanes and terrorism thats all you are good for. Oh and reading that stupid book and talking about muhammad the pedophile. FREAK!

  • qkhan001!! Get a life you bastard!! thank god indian muslims dont have to live with low life kanjars like you!! thats why indian muslims have always progressed and you cunts are making the records of failing!!

  • grqk - Your lame come back show that you cant think on anything good to say, moron. Dont you have some public place in pakistan to blow yourself up in? freak

  • @hellfireyoutoob: you are a bhenchod and mother fucker. your sisters and mother are randis. your father is there dallal. You hindus are dick suckers and has brought up sucking muslim dicks. You haram zade keep your filth out of this. and btw, normally I dont use this language BUT you sure desrve it, harami kutte

  • LOL, I said your "comebacks suck" and you prove me right with this insults and lies. Thats all?? again, MAN, "your comebacks suck... mohammed's hairy balls" ahaha. Please reply with more lies, everyone knows lying, stealing and blowing up is all you guys are good for. Go wank off to writings from the koran, bitch.

  • As I said you hindus are bhenchod and maderchod you wont listen and continue sucking dicks and raping there mothers and sisters...I am just speaking your mother tongue. Haramazade shudar!!! I am still keeping myself speaking against your religion which I can do very easily if you bastard understand...But you wont as you are a neechli zaat ka hindu and brought up licking feet of brahamns

  • Wow, thats alot of homo talk, you must be gay. Dont come out of the closet buddy, with muslims around you, you probably will be stoned to death (a very civil way to die). Does it make you feel better talking and lying like this or is this just to prepare yourself before committing suicide bombing. Also, learn to fucking type eng you illiterate fool, or stop using the language. But I guess, you dont have time to learn eng, with all the time you spend reading how muhammed fucked little girls.

  • You are gay so I am talking your mother tongue. Abbe harami kutte mother fucker n bhen chod...your mother and sisters are randis. your father is a dalla... you are harami aulad of harami baap,,,i am just speaking your mother tongue...chutiye apni bakwas band kar you shudar

    saale bandar aur haati ki puja karne wale dickhead bastard. All your fucking gods and everything can be god in your fucking hindu religion including the fraud of all time sai chutiya ....sob

  • and listen bhenchod...normally I dont talk this way but since understand only your mother tongue so I am talking your language...dick sucker

  • for someone who doesnt "nomally talk this way" it seems you are very fluent in it. People like you give animals a bad name. I have to go take a shit and wipe my ass with the pages from the koran. If you can wait from blowing yourself up till then good. If not, I know a crowded place in karachi with tons of muslims....

  • Yes, with a dickhead bastard like you, I learnt this language. You coward son of a bitch, do not need Quran...you continue to wipe your filthy black shudar ass with your gita or ramayan as these are already filthy enuf so more appriopraite for it...You go and blow urself randi ke bache

  • ma ka lauda ....abbe cow piss drinker and ape and elephant worshpper.. Janwar ... your gods Krishna/Ram/seeta /geeta all dick suckers ---bhenchod use ur brain. Do I need to be creative to talk to you? Hahahahah. abbe harami janwar go suck your fathers dick and rape your mom as all hindus do.

  • Wow you get mad so fast!! Did you just read Quran?

  • wow, that is the most UNoriginal comment by you yet. I see, this time, you put in even less effort. Why dont you just copy my comment here, and paste it the next time you reply. WHat did one muslim say to another?

    You BLOW me away. ahaha

  • @hellfireyoutoob: oh btw, are you and @ssukhwal homos and partners...why the hell you had to reply for him...bastard... asshole

  • Are you retarded? I say camel, you say camel? Cant you think of anything new to say? Its really not the hard.  Take your finger out of your ass and just think.

  • @hellfireyoutoob Hinduism supports gay and lesbian marriage. So why the fuck are you talking about him (A Muslim) Being gay?

  • @hellfireyoutoob Quran not Koran. Go masturbate to an elephant

  • @PakHidOsama shut up, non muslim/pakistani.

  • @P4KiiST4N I'm Muslim and I'm Pakistani

  • a very interesting and beautiful movie, I'm glad I watched it

  • Im a fuck up them dots

  • India & Pakistan is ONE country due to some political problem & some other non political reason we have been separated but end of the day we are BROTHERS & one day we will be UNITED & then we will show other country how much power we have. Please god I dont want to die before I see the morning I am waiting for. I born & brought up in Germany. Only speak German forgive me for my bad English but I am an INDIAN

  • Nice one.

  • i m a nepali....still love pakistan n india...the film depicts a real relation between pakistan n india.why india sometimes is so cruel to pakistan??it sud end soon.i wish frm my heart.

  • DO YOU EVER READ NEWS PAPER OR DO YOU HAVE TV. AT HOME ? Brother please watch & read i just request y, brother we dont do anything wrong its the PAK. they are doing it . We never attack PAK first. they attack us first then we JUST REPLY . now you are saying we are CRUEL not sure why you are saying this , but fell very sad about .We Indian always LOVED them helped them .still now we fell like they are our own they are our brother . but its very unfortunate that they dont think so .we all brothers

  • they are cruel because they thought that if they were united, they would defeat great britian and the world.

  • Dude, you seriously need to read the paper or see news of tv or anything. Right now pakistan is suicide bombing central. If they dont like your religion, they just blow themselves up...

  • OMG! this story is amazing and heart breaking!..so sad. Love it.

  • its better to watch something meaniningful rather than watching million dollar piece of shit. Like reality tv shows etc.

  • that was such a good movie but its short 4 a hindi movie its really good and sad

  • Reminds me of old doordarshan days, very nice movie, well done Pakis.

  • excellent movie.. it made me tear up in the end...

  • A great movie,nice pic,Good Direction talented actors (specially younger Ramchand) make up.Screen play..... Everything was perfect.

  • PS: Would loved to have seen him running into Mum's arms at the end!

  • What a beautiful, poignant film, thoroughly enjoyed it, SO pleased there was a happy ending!

  • A great movie.

  • This is an awesome movie. I came upon it by accident on you tube - WOW! What a lucky mistake on my part. Nandita Das as Champa is one of the most beautiful women I have ever seen. She is stunning!!! I am in love!!! Also the scenery is very interesting and the colors of the fabrics etc. just woke up my eyes. I will look for other Pakistani films to watch and learn from any suggestions would be appreciated. I also enjoy Indian films very much and have seen dozens. Beat U.S. made films easily!!!!

  • excellent film! this film makes me think about all those who are still in indian and pakistani jails for simply crossing the border!

    why is it a crime to cross the border? why would a spy simply cross a border?

    why cant the government of these two countries think about these two questions and let the poor border crossers go?

  • I really enjoyed this movie. Reminded me a bit of Roberto Benini'sLife is Beautiful. I loved that it was about a subject very little cinematicaly explored: Pakistan.

  • Such a beautiful film, thank you!

  • muslims and hindus of indopak have almost the same nature of hatered for each other.

    I must congratulate the production team and specially the team leader,,,,and of course RAMCHAND

  • Very well portrayed .A movie that makes one feel do we really need borders?

    NO is the answer as long as we dispose off the junk in the right place in our own countries.

  • Hope to see a Pakistani movie about Kargil war where Pakistanis grabbed up Indians from their life lines and Nawaz sharif saved them.

  • Comment removed

  • underworld786: you're in desperate need of anger management or counseling. People like you shouldn't be allowed online.

  • lol dat was my reply to rsridhar..chill man

  • still a disgusting hate fed comment. You are the one who should chill and learn some respect, manners and culture