This really is brilliant.I don't care that the quality isn't very good because the beauty of the performance still shines through so brightly.She is Ophelia here,truly.What i would give to have been there. ..
It's not easy to nail a Smith's song but she did .
Could you guys ever focus on the passion and emotion in the song and not always the sound of it? If you could listen to this instead of hear it, I'm sure you would like it a lot more. Sometimes emotion isn't always pleasant to the ears but I could feel the intensity and that's what makes it sound so beautiful.
She did an amazing job, I loved it! EA has a unique voice no one else can sing like she does, so all of you calm the fuck down she can sing better then you tone deaf freaks!
is it just me or is the piano part towards the end "Asleep"? I think it sounds like "Asleep"... anyway, I love both the original and this one. EA does a hella job here, she sings so emotional... Adorable. She's so young here...
I'll never understand the people who feel like a cover has to be a carbon copy of the original song. Are you people serious? Emilie Autumn isn't a country club singer— she's an artist. If you want to hear The Smiths do this song, then listen to The Smiths do this song.
I have to agree as well. I love her songs, but... The Smiths have a way with their music... making monotone give out emotions. Emilie just can't do the same thing... But she can compensate with her lovely voice and talents.
Wow, i just love this video. She is just so floaty, etheral, surreal and beautiful. I wish I could have met her back then. She's such an amazing musician. <3!
This proves the fact that you shouldn't judge a musician by the music they compose. Honestly, I never thought she'd do a cover of such a song. But now I feel guilty for thinking that. She does a great job. It makes me happy to see her doing such a rarely covered song, and by such an amazing band.
I agree. No doubt she is amazing now but if she would have kept it at this than she could be in the big music career, like with music videos. But she turned emoish goth and gay and now she scares me. She is still my fa singer.
This makes me realy sad. It has so much feeling in it, and Emilie sings it beautifully. I have always felt that this is in more than one level very close to my feelings and life, wonderful song.
I love this, and she's doing it really good. The original is a very amazing song, and so is this. The Smiths is her favourite band, so for Christ's sake let her do her cover ;)
She's killing the song...I'm so sorry for saying this and I know it's gonna be a poor comment,isn't it? Haha but the smiths version is the best and the best cover is jeff buckley's cover! But this is a piece of shit!
I'm actually quite a big fan of Morrissey and The Smiths and I think she does very well. Better then alot of people I've heard cover this song (and I've heard two or three). I really like it
I wouldn't expect Emilie to cover a song like this nowadays. This is from way back in her "Enchant Era". :] It's so beautiful, I think I prefer it to the original song!
You can only kill a song, Once you kill everyone who's heard of the song, But before you even get to your tenth person who listened to it, The feds would probally bust yer ass.. Or mabye the 3rd..
I really don't know who she is..but i can surely affirm that the original singed by Morryssey is something that will never be compared to no other possible version
p.s:sorry for my not so perfect english,but i'm from Italy eheheh.One last thing..the smiths rules!!!:)
??? I don't get it? Whats so incredibly special about her??? I mean, I've watched like, 5 vids. and, yeah, I still don't see anything that makes her better than the ppl that get kicked off american idol. Which is a lame show by the way. All tv is lame.
It's not really the same thing, is it? American Idol is about pop stars. I bet Geddy Lee or Les Claypool wouldn't fare well on that show either, but they're both talented vocalists in their own way.
It's something that really has to be in you to see what makes this so special. The Victorian age is dead but its beauty lives on in things such as this.
the original is from evanescence inen'd it?? but this version is wonderfull i love emilie autumn she is a great musisian: ) she is totaly herself in her music in her clothes in everything all the musicians now are so 'made' their like how the paparazzi want them.. she is just 'EMILIE AUTUMN!!' her piaono her violin her voice its all wonderfull.. and beautifull: )
hehe No, I wish, although who knows what the future holds. I think I was born in the wrong country (USA...figures, right? lol), so I might end up moving to Europe some day. *u*
She's much more than a singer, though. There are many singers out there, but few who can do everything that she does, which is pretty much everything. She's got it all...just brilliant. *u*
This really is brilliant.I don't care that the quality isn't very good because the beauty of the performance still shines through so brightly.She is Ophelia here,truly.What i would give to have been there. ..
It's not easy to nail a Smith's song but she did .
oliviaisgod 1 week ago
i wonder if morrissey likes this??????? i bet he does she sings so beautiful!
pbrzombie562 1 week ago
<3
Living4damusica 2 months ago
this song makes me cry every time i sing to it
PorSiempreGolden 5 months ago
@PorSiempreGolden Yes,me too...
I wish that she would performe this song in her live concerts again.. <_<
Toshiya231 4 months ago
Ophelia...is that you?
GilliLee 6 months ago 4
I miss the old Emilie Autumn!!
She needs to be so like in this video again!! ;__; Here is she beautiful <3
Toshiya231 6 months ago 5
Emilie the best... She is like a GoddesS
EdwardAutumn 7 months ago
shes so beautiful <3
xallyouleavebehindx 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Want to get EA on the radio?! I certainly do!
.
I think EA fans across North America should get organized & call radio stations on a specific day & time to request the SAME song by EA.
.
Visit my channel for details about voting. Give this a thumbs up if you think it’s a good idea & so other fans will see it.
.
<3 EA
rsgirl10 8 months ago
Could you guys ever focus on the passion and emotion in the song and not always the sound of it? If you could listen to this instead of hear it, I'm sure you would like it a lot more. Sometimes emotion isn't always pleasant to the ears but I could feel the intensity and that's what makes it sound so beautiful.
RobinTeenTitansGO1 8 months ago 6
The awful comments on here are so contrary to the lyrics of this song.
agentno923 8 months ago
Very pretty song.
dee11unnoticed 10 months ago
wow... she looks like the corpse bride emily... <3
goth69goth 11 months ago 6
That's some priceless stuff :) I totally adore both "Emilies": the faerie and the wayward victorian one :)
dziebuszadziedym 1 year ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I prefer her fairy look than the actual victorian prostitute look....
petitanyell1 1 year ago
Best Smiths cover ever! If only the guys will forget the past & at least do one last reunion tour
leo231985 1 year ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
This is a fantastic cover. I don't think the original is possible to beat, but Emilie and Jeff Buckley both come pretty damn close.
PlunderingDesire 1 year ago
This is a fantastic cover. I don't think you can ever beat the original, but Emilie and Jeff Buckley come pretty damn close.
PlunderingDesire 1 year ago 2
I think this is such an amazing song.. and this cover is SO beautiful!
Her voice gives me goosebumps in a very very good way <3
-seriously, haters... are you familiar whith a word called polite? Is it that hard saying you don't like the cover in a polite tone?
phoebsxD 1 year ago 5
She did an amazing job, I loved it! EA has a unique voice no one else can sing like she does, so all of you calm the fuck down she can sing better then you tone deaf freaks!
EmilieAutumnW14A 1 year ago
She did asleep much better. Her voice is a little too soulful for this. It sounds too much and makes it slightly repetitive, but it was a good try.
BrainDeadIntellect 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
awful awful awful.....IS THAT POLITE ENOUGH YOU HOMO?
kimmythebrat 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
awful awful awful.....IS THAT POLITE ENOUGH YOU HOMO
kimmythebrat 1 year ago
@kimmythebrat dude/dudette, chill?
xshotgunweddingpatdx 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
SHUT THE FUCK UP....awful boring remake
kimmythebrat 1 year ago
@kimmythebrat You should shut the fuck up if you can't give criticism in more polite way.
Fruttabella 1 year ago
@kimmythebrat Stfu and go in a fucking pit.
TheHinun 1 year ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
SHUT THE FUCK UP....awful boring remake
kimmythebrat 1 year ago
*good
ProudToBeAPlaguerat 1 year ago
Her hair was so long there :) sadly she cut it all off... whatever makes her happy is god :3
ProudToBeAPlaguerat 1 year ago
I'm sooooo glad she loves the Smiths!!! :D
moderndaypandora 1 year ago
I love the hair flick at the end!!! Shes so cute!! Id love to see one of her shows!
Tvweekfan 1 year ago
is it just me or is the piano part towards the end "Asleep"? I think it sounds like "Asleep"... anyway, I love both the original and this one. EA does a hella job here, she sings so emotional... Adorable. She's so young here...
MinorRowan 1 year ago
@MinorRowan Yes it is. :)
Fruttabella 1 year ago
@MinorRowan Yes it is. :)
Fruttabella 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Isn't this the very same performance that's on "A bit o' this and that"???! WOW!!! She's so talented with just a piano, too.
Semi76 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Isn't this the very same performance that's on "A bit o' this and that"???! WOW!!! She's so talented with just a piano, too.
Semi76 1 year ago
Isn't this the very same performance that's on "A bit o' this and that"???! WOW!!! She's so talented with just a piano, too.
Semi76 1 year ago
She looks like the Lady of Shallot here...(I'm referring to the painting..)
ArabellaMuerte 1 year ago 3
Erk tuning ;s
UltraSimon007 1 year ago
She's so talented... I wasn't expecting this cover from her.. but it sounds pretty great!
queenohearts1011 1 year ago 3
Love her look here!
NuclearLullaby 2 years ago
people you cant compare smiths and emilie autumn i like both versions but classic is still classic
anjica123 2 years ago
I'll never understand the people who feel like a cover has to be a carbon copy of the original song. Are you people serious? Emilie Autumn isn't a country club singer— she's an artist. If you want to hear The Smiths do this song, then listen to The Smiths do this song.
PunkCabaretFTW 2 years ago 20
This comment has received too many negative votes show
WHAT THE FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUCK
JODQ11 2 years ago
Ohhh!! qué pequeñita estabaa! ^^
KataStrange 2 years ago
No doubt about it. She gets more beautiful in my mind with every video I see of her. Long live EA.
xSnipSnipx 2 years ago 8
Long live the Queen. I love her.
opheliac19 2 years ago 6
She looks like a faerie :D
TheVictoriaPoet 2 years ago 80
This comment has received too many negative votes show
although I like her... No one should ever cover The Smiths. They are too unique
xxAntixx87 2 years ago
Totally Agree ... Love Emilie ... But the cover isn`t fair to the original song ...
luciaramirezbernal 2 years ago 2
I have to agree as well. I love her songs, but... The Smiths have a way with their music... making monotone give out emotions. Emilie just can't do the same thing... But she can compensate with her lovely voice and talents.
gladedreamer 2 years ago
She havent even tried to do it that way. ;)(If i understood you corectly)
Because she does her own style, and that 's with a lot of emotions.
Fruttabella 2 years ago
Does anyone know how old she is in this video?
need more light to see emilie ...light^^ love her♥
kartenhausprinzessin 2 years ago
According to wikipedia she is born in 1979
In the beginning of the vid is stated that it was recorded in 2001
+2001-1979=22
Therefor Emilie Autumn was 22 years old.
cadavernl 2 years ago 9
Amazing, it's so strange to see her back in the Enchant era comared to now. I love them both very much and can't even choose which one I prefer.
OpheliaLaOpheliac 2 years ago 10
adorable. how many times am i going to fall in love with the same person!?
I love seeing glimpses of the younger EA, how come there aren't more videos like this?
BobigailE 2 years ago 15
Aww it is so beautiful. I love it, even though it's 'just' a cover. Emilie makes everything sound so much nicer. This song means a lot to me. <3
XxXBleedingAngelXxXX 2 years ago 10
wow just amazing. love you ea<3 i wish i could have seen her live back in the enchant era:(
elsalovesfrankie 2 years ago 8
Oh my! She was so pretty (well she is still beautiful), but this is just a perfect girl sitting there singing :)
PrincessBrokenTeacup 2 years ago 4
Wow, i just love this video. She is just so floaty, etheral, surreal and beautiful. I wish I could have met her back then. She's such an amazing musician. <3!
nightbeauty02 2 years ago 2
This proves the fact that you shouldn't judge a musician by the music they compose. Honestly, I never thought she'd do a cover of such a song. But now I feel guilty for thinking that. She does a great job. It makes me happy to see her doing such a rarely covered song, and by such an amazing band.
IdealVisions 3 years ago 5
beautiful as ever. <3
xXxRav3rRawrBabyxXx 3 years ago 2
she was so young...so cute :-)
romagen 3 years ago 5
think i just feel in love with her again.nice cover and long beautiful hair
fetteredfey 3 years ago 4
She's so amazing.
DinoSaro 3 years ago 4
I cant notice her without her hair pink and a heart under her right eye!
WithLoveAliceCullen 3 years ago
lol...Did anyone think she'd go from this to making out with Crumpets on stage? lol!
Opheliac666 3 years ago 5
I love her music(especially the new stuff)
But still I can't believe she started so.....
normal is the only word to describe
IAmAnEmoNinja 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I agree. No doubt she is amazing now but if she would have kept it at this than she could be in the big music career, like with music videos. But she turned emoish goth and gay and now she scares me. She is still my fa singer.
WithLoveAliceCullen 3 years ago
uuum, dear there is NO emo in anything she does...just clearing that up.
Opheliac666 3 years ago 13
Fortunatly, not everyone wants to be mainstream :)
OdSlatromEkil 3 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Not emo, suicide-ish lyrics.
WithLoveAliceCullen 3 years ago
the lyrics reflect how she is feeling, theres a difference between being depressed and being 'emo'
kreeperyeo 2 years ago 66
@kreeperyeo it's a cover of The Smith's.
zombiequeen118 1 year ago
@kreeperyeo you mean how morrissey was feeling
steve0619 7 months ago 6
@steve0619 Just because Emilie didn't write the song, doesn't mean that she wasn't feeling that way when it was recorded.
EvoVocalChick 1 month ago
@kreeperyeo THANK YOU! Emo is a style. People who don't know the difference between the two are ignorant.
EvoVocalChick 1 month ago
@WithLoveAliceCullen so ur homophobic too?
alternativesunshine3 1 year ago
Yeah. She likes The Smiths. Apparently she's a big fan of Morrisey.
alimaiden1220 3 years ago
Her hair is soooooooooo long here... :o
spongebobfan107 3 years ago 5
Arghh
Why is the video no longer available??
And it's a good cover=)
kimkommer 3 years ago
Emilie Autumn=love The Smiths=Love
Emilie Autumn covering The Smiths=Hott sex
XxBackToTheAsylumxX 3 years ago 4
EA is a deadly siren with that voice
vampyre017 3 years ago 12
Emilie Likes The Smiths? WOW! Its like... the band i listend to as i was growing up and still listen to them today!
My Dad Will like Her! I think I'll Introduce her music to him with this song!
XxOTTxX 3 years ago 4
She Look Purdy And Pixie-like in this vidio! it's realy lovely! And So is She!
XxOTTxX 3 years ago
she believes i fairys
patrocom 3 years ago 2
I think what I love most is that her voice ISN'T perfect. So it sounds real. And amazing.
agentno923 3 years ago 12
I love her, she is a fairy with a siren's voice.
rawrisimo 4 years ago 13
To be honest, I cannot decide if I love her music or hate her music.
But I sure keep coming back to her.
Alas, I am in a dilemma, Emilie Autumn.
xBeguiledx 4 years ago 9
i agree with you. completely.
Duskaholism 3 years ago
Just keep trying ...;)
Fruttabella 2 years ago
the first time i heard this song, it was one of my best friends singing it ^.^ haha
ive heard three different versions, but i dont know which one i like more haha
Ne0nR0se1700 4 years ago 4
This makes me realy sad. It has so much feeling in it, and Emilie sings it beautifully. I have always felt that this is in more than one level very close to my feelings and life, wonderful song.
*bows*
nuuhkusakura 4 years ago 7
i didnt even know that song before :P BUT I LOVE EMILIE!!!
AvrilAshleeRose 4 years ago 5
oh god.. first i hated this song.. but now i just can´t stop listening to it^^.. it´s so beautiful^^
chocoholiclady 4 years ago 4
I love this, and she's doing it really good. The original is a very amazing song, and so is this. The Smiths is her favourite band, so for Christ's sake let her do her cover ;)
Speilbilde 4 years ago 9
This has been flagged as spam show
She's killing the song...I'm so sorry for saying this and I know it's gonna be a poor comment,isn't it? Haha but the smiths version is the best and the best cover is jeff buckley's cover! But this is a piece of shit!
dolunaydainsanolan 4 years ago
This is such a lovely cover, I wish the sound was of a better quality though =/
Regardlessly, her voice is so amazing
insanityvision 4 years ago 7
I'm actually quite a big fan of Morrissey and The Smiths and I think she does very well. Better then alot of people I've heard cover this song (and I've heard two or three). I really like it
clairvoyantXdagger 4 years ago 3
lowlow quality
skatrs 4 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
fa cagare...ma dai, stai zitta!!! fa schifo!
ClaraRama 4 years ago
This is a cover song for The Smiths. She sings it nicely.
xraggedyannx 4 years ago 2
i love it
JoinMyFear 4 years ago
i like it... the recording quality isnt the best, i like the origional but she did a very lovely job in my opinion
XxBackToTheAsylumxX 4 years ago 2
It's a little unfair to judge her with quality this bad.
But sweet Jesus, does she ever fuck this song up.
Eldomina22 4 years ago
the acoustics is very bad here! it sounds quite awful!
i love Emilie but the noises and that awful "hum" from the piano sounds bad.
0mri 4 years ago 3
I like it. Never heard the original version, but it must be a great song. If you don't like her, just post it in your mind XD don't be ridiculous
DagorMorwen 4 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ridiculous
pindaxx 4 years ago
Never come across her before, was looking for a live version by The Smiths. This is one of the best covers of a Smiths song I've come across!
hodges123 4 years ago 4
Honestly, the only thing I think was MAJORLY different is that Emilie's pitch is better live. I think she did a good cover.
AshNight1214 4 years ago 7
I wouldn't expect Emilie to cover a song like this nowadays. This is from way back in her "Enchant Era". :] It's so beautiful, I think I prefer it to the original song!
arottentomato 4 years ago
better than the original :)
ClockworkHeart 4 years ago
sorry...but dont like her version of the smith "I know is Over"
diomy83 4 years ago
A foul act of malicious murder has been committed against a great Smiths song!
Giacobinmugatu 4 years ago
Stop saying things like that. God. You can't kill a damn song.
nemesis2329 4 years ago 3
You can only kill a song, Once you kill everyone who's heard of the song, But before you even get to your tenth person who listened to it, The feds would probally bust yer ass.. Or mabye the 3rd..
Nasfbe 4 years ago
haha. True
nemesis2329 4 years ago 2
I really don't know who she is..but i can surely affirm that the original singed by Morryssey is something that will never be compared to no other possible version
p.s:sorry for my not so perfect english,but i'm from Italy eheheh.One last thing..the smiths rules!!!:)
grazianeddu 4 years ago
...yeahhhhhhhh
tiegrasola 4 years ago
??? I don't get it? Whats so incredibly special about her??? I mean, I've watched like, 5 vids. and, yeah, I still don't see anything that makes her better than the ppl that get kicked off american idol. Which is a lame show by the way. All tv is lame.
kyoandinuyashalvr01 4 years ago
It's not really the same thing, is it? American Idol is about pop stars. I bet Geddy Lee or Les Claypool wouldn't fare well on that show either, but they're both talented vocalists in their own way.
lemur821 4 years ago
I really don't know. I just don't understand why ppls are obsessing over her.
kyoandinuyashalvr01 4 years ago
It's something that really has to be in you to see what makes this so special. The Victorian age is dead but its beauty lives on in things such as this.
9Deja9vu9 4 years ago
The victorian age isn't dead.
kyoandinuyashalvr01 4 years ago
Wow!! Beautiful!!! I love her voice.
Acirema1973 4 years ago
sorry but evanescence are incapable of writing a song as good as this, as are pretty much all bands
barbarism2000 4 years ago
the original is from evanescence inen'd it?? but this version is wonderfull i love emilie autumn she is a great musisian: ) she is totaly herself in her music in her clothes in everything all the musicians now are so 'made' their like how the paparazzi want them.. she is just 'EMILIE AUTUMN!!' her piaono her violin her voice its all wonderfull.. and beautifull: )
Roodxkapje 4 years ago
Original? What do you mean? Evanescence never did a song intitled "I Know It's Over". o_0;;
Veetanitu 4 years ago
The Original is from the Smiths. I prefer Morrissey, althought this version is nice too.
tsalokan 4 years ago
fuck'n seXXXy beautiful, this girl!!!!!!!!
EnigmaticWandererSex 4 years ago
somebody 's remember NICO ?
ultra88violet 4 years ago
I have two copies of NICO's final albums on cassette called "The Hanging Gardens" Great stuff to listen to.
Acirema1973 4 years ago
This song was already absolutely great ! With Emily, it's astonishing !!!
Habibasse 5 years ago
hehe No, I wish, although who knows what the future holds. I think I was born in the wrong country (USA...figures, right? lol), so I might end up moving to Europe some day. *u*
iridescence544 5 years ago
Emilie Autumn is frickin awesome!
DemonxxHunter 5 years ago
Yeah, she is. *u*
iridescence544 5 years ago
Emilie rules!
spongebobcraz1984 5 years ago
it wont work damn it, someone want to send it to me please??
JuggalogieBizzle 5 years ago
Without words...
<3
DarkOceansoul90 5 years ago
a very old but amazing vid.
basuchianu 5 years ago
she's bloody briliant!!
judegrave18 5 years ago
Absolutely. *u*
iridescence544 5 years ago
Oh man, The Smiths + Emilie Autumn is a thing of beauty.
xxinfinitedreams 5 years ago
do you have the URL to her Myspace?
Brennas 5 years ago
I wish she'd come to Toronto.. :(
Rocky1138 5 years ago
some one know where is these show?
amefragile 5 years ago
shes an ace singer what acan i say shes ace
darknessx10 5 years ago
She's much more than a singer, though. There are many singers out there, but few who can do everything that she does, which is pretty much everything. She's got it all...just brilliant. *u*
iridescence544 5 years ago