The "point" of Dylan's songs (if there is one, which I seriously doubt) is that many of them are universal..... This version isn't even on the same map as his original..... It's almost a new song, but it's flat out wonderful, IMHO!
This IS a great tribute to Bob...but, I have to argue with anyone who says Bob isn't a great singer. I think he's been top-notch every step of the way. "Great" is not always pretty.
The musicianship is top notch here and she certainly sings her own version, which is good but I just think maybe this is not the best choice for her vocal.... Who am I though? Saying that, I keep coming back for another listen...... suppose thats the test!
This version is simply fantastic... But just clear things up about Bob.. Maybe not the best singer but yes a great poet...but lets not forget where the original melody came from... Words on paper only create 1 part of the story, the rest is in the melody and delivery... And there we pay respects to Mr Dylan....
Quite originally profound, bohemath. I've engaged, myself, in the exercise of assisting the uninnitiated, or the casual observer, in the depths of the talent Bob has shared with the world for close to 50 years.
thanks for this cool video! my names Stephanie, kinda feelin bored if any1 wants to join me on cam or wana chat i will be signed on at __ PLAY-CAM...dot...COM __ my user ID there is Stephanie_psnzr chat soon xx its FR33 to j0in! mwah
I think what needs to be remembered is this song is styled after old, old traditional ones. With that in mind, this vocalist does a very good job because she's inflecting herself, whatever emotions it brings to her heart into the way she's singing it. Altho I too prefer Nanci Griffith's version, I am very appreciative of this one too. I'm not trying to ride the fence or anything. I just enjoy what each put into it and how it makes me see the song from different perspectives.
This is a very good cover of Boots. The great thing about You tube is you get to hear so many different covers. It' ok if you don't like it but to say her voice is painful is rude and shows that you are missing a musical ear.
Stick to genres that you know something about. I think that you would do better to avoid celtic music if you would call Cathy Jordan's voice painful. One of the most successful bands out of Ireland.
such a saucy video! my names Sofia, kinda feelin bored if any1 wants to join me on cam or wana chat i will be signed on at __ FriendlyFlirts(.COM) __ my user ID there is Sofia_ohqjviaawr chat soon xx its FR33 to j0in! mwah
nanci griffith does it the same way. the musicianship is great. nanci has the best dobro I ever heard, which covers the aforementioned misconception. It works best up tempo.
Could this possibly be the best version of this fantastic song ever? This is why Dervish should have won the Eurovision :-) Love this amazing performance, but Nanci Griffith also did a nice job.
Im pretty bitter that you can not buy (or find) any of Dervish MP3s (especially this song). None on iTunes or any other MP3 providers. Have to buy the whole old-fashioned CD. eeerrrrrrrrr
Ceol deas. Mór an truaigh nach bhfuil ach droch-Ghaeilg aige'n amhránaí nuair a bíos sí 'ceol sa teangaidh sin. Ach ar an iomlán tá dúil agam 'na gcuid ceoil.
my music teacher show my class video about dervish b4 and i thought they were so i cant listining to them now im from Ireland and im not really into Irish music that much
Thank you so so much for posting this, I remember seeing this on tv a few years back, and looking everywhere for it to no avail. It is a truly touching version of a great song!
This has to be my favourite Dervish song.
Flauterfiddle 1 week ago
Does this bitch know she can actually open her mouth when she sings? This is an abortion
TheChubbbhead 2 months ago
@TheChubbbhead
Good thing your opinion doesn't matter
streetgangtm 3 weeks ago
@streetgangtm It matters so little that you found the need to take time to comment on it. Fucking imbecile
TheChubbbhead 3 weeks ago
IMHO, the best cover of this song. I won't compare it to the original though. Dylan is incomparable.
PackerBronco 2 months ago
brought me to an orgasm !!!!!
rylaneirl 5 months ago
The "point" of Dylan's songs (if there is one, which I seriously doubt) is that many of them are universal..... This version isn't even on the same map as his original..... It's almost a new song, but it's flat out wonderful, IMHO!
Oldguard900 5 months ago
Comment removed
Oldguard900 5 months ago
fantastic. Made my day.
musicvh 5 months ago
I heard them do this song earlier tonight at the Lowell Folk Festival - absolutely spell-binding. A truly outstanding band, and oh, what a voice!
3883vale 6 months ago
This IS a great tribute to Bob...but, I have to argue with anyone who says Bob isn't a great singer. I think he's been top-notch every step of the way. "Great" is not always pretty.
effronwhite 8 months ago
Sublime.
juxtapotato 10 months ago
This is a beautiful tribute to music's Heathcliff. Bravo.
mkunizak 10 months ago
This is a beautiful tribute tomusic's Heathcliff. Bravo.
mkunizak 10 months ago
I just heard this song a couple hours ago at the North Texas Irish Festival <3
sesshora44 10 months ago
i was at the celtic festival in Rotterdam yesterday, and they did this song too... shivers down my spine
BouweHillen1 11 months ago
you know, just come to Spain :)
Rilu666 1 year ago
beautiful!
sbarnett89 1 year ago
my heart i swear just sunk ...that was sooooooo beautiful i need to keep listening to her god i love her voice
highlanderinakilt 1 year ago
Eurovision. Magic.
neilb229 1 year ago
love you Cathy ;-)
richeart1 1 year ago
This is my favorite Celtic band. Such conviction!
jbhplewis2 1 year ago
wooooow
MrElmariachi90 1 year ago
The musicianship is top notch here and she certainly sings her own version, which is good but I just think maybe this is not the best choice for her vocal.... Who am I though? Saying that, I keep coming back for another listen...... suppose thats the test!
Whippy930 1 year ago 2
I think this is a silly version of Bob Dylan's song, but I can't stop listening to it. Maybe there's something to it after all?
PatrickWhite85 1 year ago
Comment removed
PatrickWhite85 1 year ago
Comment removed
PatrickWhite85 1 year ago
What an angel! This version just transports me to somewhere else.
dubmixxx 1 year ago
Beautiful ! :o)
cantaroooo 1 year ago 2
Incredible!
CJRath1 1 year ago
The best rendition so far i just love all the different people s ways of singing and the song is inspiring...
MsLouise1960 1 year ago
The best cover I've heard so far is by Julia Haltigan on a tribute compilation. This is good though.
elcochon 1 year ago
truly amazing
Kubek89 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
These guys suck
Dylan is soooooo much better
sillystupidpeople 1 year ago
GENIALLLLLLL GRACIAS
RIOJANITO1 1 year ago
So pure as the country they come from, the beautiful Ireland.
valverdista 1 year ago 3
its a bob dylan song
danlikestacos 1 year ago
Just saw them this past saturday at Leeward Community College, Oahu.
Loved it!! :D
Anduril101 2 years ago
I just saw them in Hilo too. Awesome show. This was my favorite song of the night along with Red Haired Mary.
satouame 2 years ago 2
saw Dervish tonight in Hilo, Hawaii - i'd never heard of them before - but absolutely LOVED the show... unforgettable!!!!
JADEakiko 2 years ago 2
i just gave u 5 stars for playing the bodhran. I like Nanci Griffith's version too
Isismusicnow 2 years ago
I see :) Thanks. I love her eyes
Isismusicnow 2 years ago
I don't know anything about this girl/band but I love this version. She is a lot older than she looks? Right?
Isismusicnow 2 years ago
Another tribute to Bob Dylan! God bless her.
rufusandburne 2 years ago
She is simply mesmerizing. I can't not return, night after night.
rvcrvc2 2 years ago 3
Brilliant
b0wsh 2 years ago
I can't stop listening to this song. The beauty is overwhelming.
paulwautlet 2 years ago
This is an incredible version of one of my favorite songs of all time. Great instrumentals and the vocals too.
paulwautlet 2 years ago
This version is simply fantastic... But just clear things up about Bob.. Maybe not the best singer but yes a great poet...but lets not forget where the original melody came from... Words on paper only create 1 part of the story, the rest is in the melody and delivery... And there we pay respects to Mr Dylan....
bohemath777 2 years ago 15
Quite originally profound, bohemath. I've engaged, myself, in the exercise of assisting the uninnitiated, or the casual observer, in the depths of the talent Bob has shared with the world for close to 50 years.
rvcrvc2 2 years ago
@bohemath777 shut up kid!
rufusandburne 1 year ago
Classic stuff. They really nailed it here. Beautiful.
tenday2 2 years ago 3
where can i get more music from this band??
i just love it so much
fernits05 2 years ago
I'm so proud to be Irish
groovemonzter 2 years ago 3
Dervish does it better than Dylan, actually.
What a great group. . . I just love their singer *melt*
OperaBard 2 years ago
Dylan isn't a singer, he's a poet.
Could Dervish do it better than he?
Ulises53 2 years ago
Funny, seems like he made a career being a singer.
His songs are excellent, I just don't think he's always the best performer.
This cover is excellent and there are a number of covers that I like better than the original versions.
cmsciulli 2 years ago
He can't sing, he recites his poems, tells his stories. Any cover is better than Dylan version, even mine. =)
Joan Baez, The Byrds, Jimi Hendrix...
But I can't compare them with Dylan.
Ulises53 2 years ago
I think you are perhaps referring to Dylan Thomas, the welsh poet.
RavenholmeCP42 2 years ago 2
No... to Bob Dylan.
"I consider myself a poet first and a musician second. I live like a poet and I'll die like a poet"
Bob Dylan.
Ulises53 2 years ago
omg so amazing.
leahfran419 2 years ago
beautiful sad eyes
Isismusicnow 3 years ago 2
i love them...it has been YEARS SINCE I HAVE HEARD THIS SONG!!!!!!!!I LOVE DERVISH
kimaxh 3 years ago 2
Fantastic cover from a fantastic group!
Go Irish!
jazcalvert 3 years ago 2
excellent !
shyly2 3 years ago
Cathy Jordan is as beautiful as her voice. Gift from above.
DoubleDizzle1 3 years ago
She sings with such heart. She does Dylan justice!!!
54spiritedwill54 3 years ago
I prefer to not compare versions. There are hundreds if not thousands of good ones.
fiddleit 3 years ago 3
Awesome cover and thanks to Brian for posting & jacquesmees for sharing!
arkgunslinger 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
Nice Video lolz, my names Savannah, im feelin n0rty and h0rn3y if any guyz wana chat im usually on
___ PLAY-CAM..dot..COM ___
chanson86 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
thanks for this cool video! my names Stephanie, kinda feelin bored if any1 wants to join me on cam or wana chat i will be signed on at __ PLAY-CAM...dot...COM __ my user ID there is Stephanie_psnzr chat soon xx its FR33 to j0in! mwah
CarlosMills 3 years ago
Esti cantar ponmi el pelleyu de pita... Guapísimu!!
cazafantasma 3 years ago
I think what needs to be remembered is this song is styled after old, old traditional ones. With that in mind, this vocalist does a very good job because she's inflecting herself, whatever emotions it brings to her heart into the way she's singing it. Altho I too prefer Nanci Griffith's version, I am very appreciative of this one too. I'm not trying to ride the fence or anything. I just enjoy what each put into it and how it makes me see the song from different perspectives.
bsobb 3 years ago
Wow. Lovely comments about a lovely songstress with a lovely voice singing a lovely song to make yer heart yearn lovingly.
(the musicians are so lovely as well...)
erth2myk2b 3 years ago 3
Arghh! What penguins said!
alexkx3 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The instrumentation is fabulous, but lord her voice is painful. So overblown you lose all the subtlety of the original.
the3penguins 3 years ago
Obviously you are retarded when it comes to judging music. Cathy has one of the most unique voices of Ireland. Truely amazing!
pplasqui 3 years ago
Obviously you are retarded in judging quality music. Cathy has one of the most unique voices of Ireland. Truely amazing!
pplasqui 3 years ago
Obviously you are retarded in judging quality music. Cathy has one of the most unique voices of Ireland. Truely amazing!
pplasqui 3 years ago
This is a very good cover of Boots. The great thing about You tube is you get to hear so many different covers. It' ok if you don't like it but to say her voice is painful is rude and shows that you are missing a musical ear.
Tutone66 3 years ago 3
Stick to genres that you know something about. I think that you would do better to avoid celtic music if you would call Cathy Jordan's voice painful. One of the most successful bands out of Ireland.
fyrpiper3 3 years ago 2
This is such a great cover. It really does the song its justice.
IngaDylan 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
such a saucy video! my names Sofia, kinda feelin bored if any1 wants to join me on cam or wana chat i will be signed on at __ FriendlyFlirts(.COM) __ my user ID there is Sofia_ohqjviaawr chat soon xx its FR33 to j0in! mwah
fjgala 3 years ago
nanci griffith does it the same way. the musicianship is great. nanci has the best dobro I ever heard, which covers the aforementioned misconception. It works best up tempo.
mcob1 3 years ago
a less grouchy myself loves it
mcob1 3 years ago
Beautiful. Thanks.
MarkMKelly 3 years ago 2
Could this possibly be the best version of this fantastic song ever? This is why Dervish should have won the Eurovision :-) Love this amazing performance, but Nanci Griffith also did a nice job.
hjortshoj 3 years ago 4
But I just thought you'd want something fine
Made of silver or of golden
Either from the mountains of Madrid
Or from the coasts of Barcelona..
Auburne 4 years ago
Just carry yourself back to me unspoiled.
I'd forsake them all for your sweet kiss
For that's all I'm wishin' to be ownin'.
misspiderly 4 years ago 3
Dervish are terrific. Cathy Jordan is spellbinding. She becomes one with the music. This cover of BoSL is featured on my Playlist, Bob with Covers.
Aentnothan 4 years ago
liked it.
mcob1 4 years ago 4
She sings with such heart. She does Dylan justice!!!
bornintime22 4 years ago 17
Heartbreakingly beautiful..
HandShock 4 years ago 3
wow.
this is truly beautiful. They really do the song justice.
PrawdehFish 4 years ago 3
Yet?
damancadas 4 years ago
superb...Im a musician myself and yet this band can move me to tears.....
wingandaprayer 4 years ago 3
Superb!
shelleymcc 4 years ago 2
hmmmmmmmm nice
Candywarholl 4 years ago
absolutely marvelous, the sense Dylan has in mind
BIRDsero 4 years ago 2
Im pretty bitter that you can not buy (or find) any of Dervish MP3s (especially this song). None on iTunes or any other MP3 providers. Have to buy the whole old-fashioned CD. eeerrrrrrrrr
DoubleDizzle1 4 years ago
Hmm... strange. Dervish have about 8 albums available on iTunes. Same on Amazon's mp3 section, both have the album Spirit, which has this song on it.
crontie 2 years ago
Hmm yeah indeed strange.. Except for the fact that I wrote this comment OVER ONE YEAR AGO!!
"DoubleDizzle1 (1 year ago)"
I have it now btw.
DoubleDizzle1 2 years ago
Moving, one of the best renditions ever heard.
brunocat4 4 years ago
Ceol deas. Mór an truaigh nach bhfuil ach droch-Ghaeilg aige'n amhránaí nuair a bíos sí 'ceol sa teangaidh sin. Ach ar an iomlán tá dúil agam 'na gcuid ceoil.
Lughaidh2 4 years ago
great song..! wirklich schön, kann mir jmd den schicken bitte..? 466641765 .. (: Thx!
XxLiliy 4 years ago
Man, I love Dervish! This and "Red Haired Mary" are my two favorite songs by them.
Thanks for posting this!
ShyMyst 4 years ago
good stuff.
mongobaer 4 years ago
well thats what you think but everybody else thinks that they are brilliant. so just stick with that
MJakea 4 years ago
The fact that everybody likes U2 is the main reason why they are completely dull.Stick with that(whatever that means)
eoinpac 4 years ago
I'm Irish and yes U2 are shit and bono is a twat Rory Gallagher and Thin Lizzy are the best bands we produced.
eoinpac 4 years ago
thin lizzy are good for sure, but even they arent worthy of rory, hes not the best this country has produced but the world
dsingo 4 years ago
I just said that other people think they are and dont swear
MJakea 4 years ago
Jesus what a song, still prefere Dylans own version, but shes really good...
TeenQueenRosalie 4 years ago
the most famous band in the word is irish U2 we have great music and singers.
MJakea 4 years ago
bonos nice if ya chat to him,
he's a good guy...
Candywarholl 4 years ago
yeah my mom met him and he's a really nice guy
MJakea 4 years ago
means well
Candywarholl 4 years ago 3
really fucking great .
jdollyyy 4 years ago
Love her voice !!!! nice song!!
mimundoprivado 4 years ago
beutiful voice
DementedGael 4 years ago
peaceful
brencor56 4 years ago
amazing. i just love your voice. love it!!!!!!!
carbaily27 4 years ago
great version of this song
confuz7 4 years ago
Delicate and sweetly sang Ms. Jordan. A beautiful creation.
TheDhubh 4 years ago
If they played it at the Eurovision Song Contest, they would have won! Amazing Cover.. i still love Dervish!
xXevelOnXx 4 years ago
U were good at Latvia with afroambient ;)
hankeys 4 years ago
my music teacher show my class video about dervish b4 and i thought they were so i cant listining to them now im from Ireland and im not really into Irish music that much
craigmurray4 4 years ago
Thank you so so much for posting this, I remember seeing this on tv a few years back, and looking everywhere for it to no avail. It is a truly touching version of a great song!
phatmanwc 4 years ago
"simply amazing, prooves that there are actually good dylan covers"
--hey man, there are tons of excellent Dylan covers.
krustyburger66 4 years ago
simply amazing, prooves that there are actually good dylan covers
jimmybeam12 4 years ago
Well, I've discovered dervish thanks to the ESC. Now I can't stop listening to their music.
wakkogra 4 years ago
Excellent
cesbass 4 years ago