The judges screwed her with the judges pick song. By giving fat country girl a perfect and mass appeal song like "Hope You Dance" and sticking Haley with the angry Allanis Morressette loser of a song, they f'd her out of the final two. All along, Randy and Jennifer wanted her out. They finally got it done with that loser song choice as the final performance in top three show.
Haley didn't have to win. All she needed was a chance to show the world the spectacular performer that she is. I can't wait to see her in concert. Hopefully in a smaller more intimate venue than a stadium. GO HALEY!!!
Haley should of won! I can't believe that stupid Scotty and that untalented Lauren made it to the finale. It just shows how many rednecks vote on this show.
Haley didn't win because her fan base is older and don't know how to vote like the younger fans of Scotty and Lauren - they probably voted thousands of times each for them while Haleys fans prob stopped at 20 votes - there is no way to know but I think Steven is right in saying you have to find the singer first then worry about what kind of record they will make. Idol was pushing for Scotty because he's in a specific genre - still doesn't mean he will see success of like Carrie Underwood
@ArcDrako cookiefan listed the 4...how she didn't get a standing o for blue and piece of my heart is just beyond me....the girl is just the greatest female singer in the last 25 years... i've seen em all and it's that simple
Haley = Legend to Be
I've played music semi professionally for 20 years and frankly i've never seen anything like her
can mimic patsy klien & janis joplin and still make her own...tremdeous stage presence....can rock it out to led zepplin
Haley can sing "the classics" with ease....and grace, and she can just ....just fit comfortably to most all styles of music! More talent in her little finger...than all of the other singers...............NO DOUBT!
@irockvery Good question. Personally I have no problem with Scotty being the winner but I think Haley and Scotty should have been the top two with Haley coming out the winner, Scotty will do well with or without idol whereas Haley needed that break, Lauren, sweet as she is couldn't make up her mind on what kind of artist she needs to be while Scotty and Haley remained true to themselves as artists. Why America couldn't see that is the question.
I loved it when they sang it together. i love her voice!
oneyeardown100 2 weeks ago
Tony Bennett did a lot of duets...I think this is the best.
nicozzz13 2 months ago
she should have deff been on his duets 2 album!!!!!!!!!!!!!
bazzingaification 4 months ago 3
this music sounds like the type of music they play in the coco bango club in the movie the 'mask' lol
shamvara 6 months ago 4
@shamvara so so true...good movie mask
VIPER534 1 month ago
@singerboy100100 Hellll no you're not lol
lpauzus 7 months ago
She really chose the right song. She had the best opportunity to sing with Tony Bennett. I love the beat. Fantastic. :)
olanojmd 7 months ago 4
The judges screwed her with the judges pick song. By giving fat country girl a perfect and mass appeal song like "Hope You Dance" and sticking Haley with the angry Allanis Morressette loser of a song, they f'd her out of the final two. All along, Randy and Jennifer wanted her out. They finally got it done with that loser song choice as the final performance in top three show.
zeroeasy 9 months ago 4
love Haley so much^^
nngmoney 9 months ago 6
who are the two people who disliked this?
pjatrix965 9 months ago
Haley has the BLUE NOTE in that voice, naturally.
picturedlife1 9 months ago 7
haley literly looks and sounds like she stepped out of a old black and white movie, shes amazing.
JewFroCartoonist94 9 months ago 3
Haley didn't have to win. All she needed was a chance to show the world the spectacular performer that she is. I can't wait to see her in concert. Hopefully in a smaller more intimate venue than a stadium. GO HALEY!!!
cookiefann 9 months ago 6
Haley should of won! I can't believe that stupid Scotty and that untalented Lauren made it to the finale. It just shows how many rednecks vote on this show.
littlebittyz 9 months ago
Haley didn't win because her fan base is older and don't know how to vote like the younger fans of Scotty and Lauren - they probably voted thousands of times each for them while Haleys fans prob stopped at 20 votes - there is no way to know but I think Steven is right in saying you have to find the singer first then worry about what kind of record they will make. Idol was pushing for Scotty because he's in a specific genre - still doesn't mean he will see success of like Carrie Underwood
fiddleDdee 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
she would be a good jazz singer
tnao123 9 months ago
Her voice is suitable for jazz music than pop music. She have very sultry voice for jazz. She can be very successful in that stream.
pinkychang 9 months ago
when did she got the other 4 standing ovations?
ArcDrako 9 months ago
@ArcDrako
1. Benny and the Jets,
2,House of the Rising Sun,
3I Who Have Nothing
4. What is and What Should Newer Be.
She should also have gotten the standing O for the Earth song. She did an amazing version that Randy was deaf too because of his hidden agenda.
cookiefann 9 months ago 7
@ArcDrako cookiefan listed the 4...how she didn't get a standing o for blue and piece of my heart is just beyond me....the girl is just the greatest female singer in the last 25 years... i've seen em all and it's that simple
Haley = Legend to Be
I've played music semi professionally for 20 years and frankly i've never seen anything like her
can mimic patsy klien & janis joplin and still make her own...tremdeous stage presence....can rock it out to led zepplin
just THE TOTAL PACKAGE/LEGEND 2 B
renduke 9 months ago 7
she should of won she had the best voice
Basketball25Legend 9 months ago
i think she can sing better than he can haha
skylermerop 9 months ago
this is BS, she should have won!
sildor3 9 months ago
Haley can sing "the classics" with ease....and grace, and she can just ....just fit comfortably to most all styles of music! More talent in her little finger...than all of the other singers...............NO DOUBT!
jinan0014 9 months ago
I hope this girl continues on with her music career because she is amazing. When she comes out with a CD, I will be one of the first in line.
kitty103a 9 months ago 2
Why the hell isn't this girl the winner after 5 standing ovations & the highest youtube views overall by over double?
OfficialGleek18 9 months ago 54
@OfficialGleek18 She doesn't have a penis or sing about Jesus.... That's why
ikemendes1 9 months ago 10
SO CLASSIC. I should have been around in the 50's. She's amazing.
numommy310 9 months ago
LOVE HER!
TvRealityTv 9 months ago
haley's voice is so sweet in this performance! Absolutely love it!
XyranJ 9 months ago
And Haley got her 5th standing ovation. In the finale. Can anybody tell me again why she didn't make it through the finale?
irockvery 9 months ago 80
@irockvery Good question. Personally I have no problem with Scotty being the winner but I think Haley and Scotty should have been the top two with Haley coming out the winner, Scotty will do well with or without idol whereas Haley needed that break, Lauren, sweet as she is couldn't make up her mind on what kind of artist she needs to be while Scotty and Haley remained true to themselves as artists. Why America couldn't see that is the question.
2swanway 9 months ago 3
@irockvery because there are too many people that like country :P
darkmaster24i1 8 months ago
first
gazillionsomething 9 months ago 2