Added: 4 years ago
From: cathykat
Views: 1,081,167
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (827)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • somebody should listen to real voice of Music rather listening to rihanna's fake singing voice

  • THIS VERSION TOPS DINOS....

  • I can't believe people are attributing this beautiful song to some talentless whores who only know how to 'sing' if their autotune is working that day! Dean Martin sang this song originally not the effin Pusstcat hoes! R u people serious????????

  • @libbyrock123 I think that you should choose your words wisely. Nicole, former leader of the PCD, is a classically trained and technically skilled vocalist. Don't let her appearance fool you :)

  • @l0os3nup It doesn't matter to me. Dean Martin sang this sing originally, and he deserves more respect than that. Her appearance doesn't at all fool me, but it may fool others. She appears as an overly made up woman to me but that's about all. It's all well and good that she has been "trained up" to know how to sing, but Mr. Martin was a pure natural!! There is no comparison!

  • @l0os3nup BTW no disrespect was intended to anyone by my comments. I just hate when people sample a song and the entrie credit is given to the one who covered the song. It's a little insulting to the original artist! This is all my opinion. i'm not trying to be rude to anyone! :)

  • at these contests music and talent isn´t the first thing that really matters, but the look, the figure and the wheight!!! it´s a tragedy, that people like melinda who looks amazing coupled with a gret talent won´t have a chance in this world of shit we live in!!!!!!

  • its okay

  • WAO! She touchs my heart with that voice

  • who says she doesn't have the looks??? Beautiful..

  • why didn't she win ? perfect voice, perfect notes.

  • @Edustin

    I COMPLETELY Agree.

  • I like her version better than the Pussycat doll one. the girls were hotter but this girl can feel the music, wow, she missed her calling.

  • @cabdriver13 i agreed

  • Dude, she got the lyrics wrong. "Like the lazy ocean hugs the SHORE", first off, and she missed the verse "Like a flower bending in the breeze/Bend with me/sway with easy" etc." SHe may ahave a gorgeous voice, but I still prefer the Dean Martin version.

  • @Kikiurakun  she didnt miss the verse, they just skipped it.

  • @Kikiurakun i agree with you, that dino sang it a million times better, but nothing compares to the King of Cool, so melinda did it well.

  • WOW

  • she was my favorite for American Idol that year. stop watching AI because a real talent like her didnt win.

  • i remember when everyone was bettn money she would win..its a shame she didn't

  • Well, i agree that she should have won but the problem with American Idol is that people like Melinda peak in the show waaaay too early. Look at the past seasons, people who were frontrunners in the early part of the season did not end up winning the show at the end.

  • Ever now and then American Idol throws in an established pro to raise the stakes and Doolittle was definitely season six's. Like seriously, what in the hell was there to 'judge'? She is fabulous.

  • From the start of Idol the 2 best singer was Melinda Doolittle and Kelly Clarkson!!! Rock from Montreal.

  • She was the best , because she was not as beautiful she lost!!!!!! Well IDOL should be a contest for singing first!!!!

  • this is the best voice for this ssong...sexy,sweet and deep

  • I think Michael Buble Sings it better.... but this is good also.

  • lakisha and melinda should've been the final 2 in season 6 :/ my personal list of winners: season 1"tamayra gray (duh :p) 2:didn't really like many of them lol but definately not ruben >.< 3:Camille Velasco/J.Hudson 4:meh bored with this season 5:TaylorHicks (andhe won so yehey :p) 6:Melinda/Lakisha 7:yeah i guess david cook :p 8:DANNY GOKEY 9:DIDI BENAMI!/Andrew Garcia 10:Casey orNaima:P
  • she does a great job on this song. wish we'd see more of her

  • I really hate this song (because it reminds me of that incredibly cheesy dance movie with Richard Gere), but Melinda Doolittle is soooo great! =)

  • I hope this girl makes career with this beautiful voice

  • I think she said "like a lazy ocean hugs the floor XD" haha but she did awesome! 

  • i forgot the pussycat doll's version.

  • Love Sway...and Melinda sings it so well...just wish she would do it again with a different do...she could really rock this one...

  • Hermosa version!!!

  • Studying Pharmacy? Unbelievable...not that pharmacy isn't a great profession...but how does Taylor Swift even have a singing career when there is true talent like Melinda walking around? What a superficial music world we live in.

  • What is Melinda doing these days?

  • @bh5606

    She's studying Pharmacy at the uni.

  • holy shit balls...

  • I no longer watch IDOL as it does not promote true talent.. case in point..

  • sehr gut

  • Pure as crystal!!!!!!

  • oh man!!!!!!!

  • she can be the next FAMOUS JAZZ SINGER!

  • did u notice she doesnt have a neck?

  • @yameted Not until you pointed it out.

  • SHe has a really good voice who is she

  • does she not just have the most beautiful voice and smile!

  • As much as I like Melinda, I don't think she ever had a chance of wininning Idol. She was, technically, the best singer that season, but she has an old-school, throwback sound that simply won't sell records in today's market. So you can see why Jordin Sparks won, she has a very good contemporary, pop vocal sound. I doubt if looks or even age had much to do with it.

  • Jordin Sparks. You know, the "winner" of Idol, had the looks, Melinda had the raw talent. Idol is not a singing contest, period.

  • @Edustin Jordin is also amazing and deserves all she has achieved. It's only a shame that only one of the great contestants can win

  • @Edustin I congratulate you for beeing so intelligent and so wright, ( IDOL IS NOT A SINGING CONTEST) period. Rock from Montreal

  • @Edustin Merlinda has the singing voice, not the talent, cause musically, she is very weak. She is falling out of the rythem over and over again, you can hear the band pick it up for her over and over again...

  • Best Version I have seen! Ever!

  • La ultima cancion para mi, siempre para mi, nunca lo olvides....<3 <3 <3

  • A monster of performer-this woman can sing anything-projects so well no one else does that while singing live-this is what i call power

  • I love this song so much !!!!

  • I didn't even realise she was from American Idol until I read the comments (I'm from England). I just assumed she was a professional! :S

  • the people who didnt like this video were deff or something

  • she said , like a lazy ocean hugs the floor it should be the shore

  • best singer that show ever saw. BECAUSE SHE'S A WO-MAN, W-O-M-A-N! she was too good to win. american hates the best unless they can feel sorry for them. that's why Fantasia won; she was a talented mess and worthy of "american" pity and--still is based on what's happening with her now. this the same reason russell won SYTYCD last year. they kept showing weepy footage of his "urban" story.

  • Comment removed

  • i love this song sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooo much

  • DAMNNNNNNNNNNN she is only 32 i thought she is like 60

  • @shahror09 Yeah and she was 28 here.

  • beautiful

  • WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOW the same sound

  • Love how a woman can sing that! You associate it so much to a crooner singer, not sung by a woman, and it sounds really good. Love it! :) Thumbs up for to Melinda Doolittle!

  • Wonderfully done Melinda!! You are the reason i no longer watch AI.

  • who originally sings this?

  • @misselizabeth101 One of the first recordings was by Dean Martin in 1954. IMO the versions by Rosemary Clooney and Julie London are excellent as is this one.

  • Another LOST talent!!! Where is she now?? I am sure she would sell !!

  • holycow! whatta voice!!! u rock!

  • Bravooooooo , she is very good

  • Melinda reminds me of Shirley Bassey...

    I can't figure out why she didn't win because she is a Diva personified....I love her!!!!

    ~MM~

  • The real winner of that season of American Idol !!

  • man i just looove her voice, she has so much control. and i don't ever think it's even possible for her to sing out of pitch, she just sounds like she has perfect pitch to me!!

  • Excelent.......... no words....

  • เพราะมากๆๆ

  • Damn, I didn't see this was on American Idol. I was asking myself where I know her from!!! This seemed to me like an actual performance for a tv show! :D :D :D Great job Melinda!!!!!

  • she was perfectly sexya as in desirable and not slutty. it's brilliant how she gets into chraracter with her songs.

  • Bella voce

  • I liked it but the end note definitely needs to be sang in falsetto. With such a sensual song a big belt can really kill the mood of the song.

  • she shoul've won.

  • BEST SINGER EVER!!!!

  • An undeniably gifted vocalist who was consistently excellent the entire season. But unfortunately, the entertainment/music business is a business is that is based on looks and let's just say that Melinda didn't have the right 'looks'.

  • @mikesterSTLMO I completely agree with you. Melinda had the most beautiful voice and the most talented. Too bad she didn't have the star look.

  • does anyone know where melinda dolittle is at now? does she have any cds? too bad she did not win. jordin has been forgotten, but melinda definitely left a big mark.

  • Her voice is like magic, when I listen to her sing I have a vibrating shiver though my whole body. Michael buble is another singer who can sing this song very well.

  • nalepsa pesma na svetu . cmok valerija

  • she is amazing

  • good song..i like that

  • I don't care at all for American Idol but wow, what a beautiful singing voice. I really enjoyed that.

  • Ella deberia haber ganado esa version...

  • i think her and blake should have been top two........... i didnt really care for Jordin

  • @judahsmom81 I am with you and the notion that it should have been melinda and blake no doubt about it. I wish we could turn back the hands of time and do it all over again.

  • Melinda is a genious

  • I will have to ask why Clive Davis did not offer her a contract. Does anybody know?

  • love it

  • Fantastic!!

  • love it

  • I said it before and I'll say it again:

    Melinda was Robbed!

    BEST skills of her season, I really think she should have won.

  • Only partially true I think. I think she has the best skills of just about all the seasons. She's so good it's ridiculous.

    Win, lose or draw it matters not. She'll be huge!

  • Great voice!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Melinda Doolittle again demonstrates her versatility with this standard. I still feel the best is yet to come for her career.

  • nice , but u need to feel the song more. thanks

  • Like a lazy ocean hugs the 'floor' @ shore..?

    She could have won...

  • Wow, what a lovely voice she has.  I really enjoyed that performance.

  • dean martin sings this so much better

  • I first heard that song on the dark city soundtrack. She sang it better!!!

  • she blew it out'a the box........yeh! yeh! yeh! outstanding

  • i like this song, is nice

  • Julie London does this song right with a

    Cuban touch

  • wow she dosen't even know the lyrics, its hugs the shore not floor

  • @Hikmat786 Yes, but that's no big deal - and it would be an easy thing to do, for a novice in a competition...standing there in front of everyone....!!! In fact, I thought she was very brave to choose this song!!! And don't forget, even Dean got the odd word wrong sometimes!!!! All in all, I think she handled this very well!!

  • @Hikmat786 Lay off, prick. Get up there in front of 50,000 ppl AND on national tv and remember all the words. Oh yeah, and sing a MILLIONTH as well as she did. Fuck off.

  • Not a bad version! But no one really can compete with the original Dino.

  • her performance is better than Dean Martin I think...I believe this is the best version of this song

  • Unfortunately on American Idol, it's not how many people vote for you, it's how many times people vote for you.

  • Wow...y do i not kow her..why did she not win!!!

  • Love Melinda but the lyric is not "a lazy ocean hugs the FLOOR..??..umm ..shore.

    I know because I sang the song in a revue.

  • Yeah you're right =)

  • she has too much class and talent for American idol she is like a pro up there

  • she is brilliant , crazy vibrato.

  • She like a young Sara Vaughn.If you close your eyes she has a quality in her voice that makes her stand out as a great talent.

  • she was robbed ! she definitely deserved to win. to think that Blake Lewis came in ahead of her is a joke.

  • Write-in vote Melinda for PCA's!!! =D You can write her in for Favorite Breakout artist, favorite female singer, favorite R & B artist! ;-)

    Go to the People's Choice website =)

  • I am so glad I bought her album.

  • baaardzo mi sie podobalo!!! veeeryyy goood!!!!:D:D

    =]...

  • Beautiful done, Melinda....our Dean would have been proud of you!!! Keep going, girl - you are a rising 'star'....and we all know it!!!

  • SUPERRRRRRRRRRRR

  • MELINDA CAN SWAY ME ANYTIME... WOW!!

  • Where is my Melinda? Fantastic, goose bump singing.

  • Fantastic!!!!

  • perfect!!!

  • This woman had more talent than that idiot kid "beat boxer" and Jordin Sparks combined.

  • couldn't agree with you more

  • @IryshGyrl ya well where is she?

  • @IryshGyrl no, jordin sparks had alot of talent bitch.

  • @adkjf100 hey hey people have different opinions. There's no reason to go insulting people over singing.

    I think both Jordin Sparks and Melinda Doolittle are great singers.

  • @IryshGyrl What in the hell do you think that that was about? The beat boxer did some interesting things but he did the same thing week after week after week. Melinda received rave reviews. I do believe that these kids are very talented but since they chose their own songs maybe they don't always chose the right ones for them...I think that Vanjyna is one who did that..he has a better voice than what we heard sometimes.

  • @IryshGyrl omg well said

  • somehow she's kinda hot :) good version!

  • wow amazing you're such an amazing person I hope when you die you don't come flying down

  • in some tiny little particular spots she sings off the tune, or maybe its just me, dont know. she has a decent voice though, very good.

  • she should've won based on this alone!!!!! this season is a joke without her!!!!

  • I like her version too--

  • if u like this song there is a new vwrsion on youtube; MEDVECZKY SWAY

  • Melinda,

    Did you ever record a CD? I need to get one. You need a good manager, you have a terrific voice girl.

  • I dont speake english but she´s have a wonderfull voice...thank you for that song...Caracas Venezuela

  • Melinda, You are really awesome. You've got a terrific voice, and the frosting on the cake is that you're sweet, kind and extremely nice....always.

    Sudsy

  • excellent.

  • your're great Melinda.

  • congratulations !

  • -YO!  Fab-u-loso!!!!!

  • Quite a professional performance. Gives the lie to AI as a "reality" show

  • Awesome talent!!

  • she signed with Hi Fi Recordings in the summer of 2008 and released her debut CD, Coming Back to You on February 3, 2009.

  • Its a shame that she did not get a record contract and is not out producing hits with this voice; life is not fair!

  • awesome!

    ive always been voting 4 melinda

    (well in my head anywayz......)

    can anybody tell me if she's made like an album or something & wats d name

    cuz i haven't really heard anything from her

  • Great voice! Stage performance is OK too for a shy girl ;)

  • I'm just curious. If she use to sing backup for renowned singers like Bebe and Cece Winans, how come they never gave her a record deal. No offense to bebe and Cece but It sure seems a bit skeptical that she had to go through American Idol

  • i think she kinda butchered the song. especially when she said "Like the lazy ocean hugs the floor" it's "shore" plus she missed a few lines.

    <