MELISSA SMITH vs NATALIE MEJIA

[xDemiBeex]

I thought that Melissa R was prettier than Melissa S :/

[hyafire123]

NAT DUHHH

[MsYeahBlah]

melissa S is better.

[MsYeahBlah]

both are bitches in personality. period.

[raahb1]

nataliee! duhhh



[perroramer0]

Mel <3

[Bitch92331]

natalie <3<3

[dar1toknow]

Natalie is way sexier, no comparison.

[smexistephie]

i can't choose i love them both XD

[FOBPrincessSara]

Hahaha Melissa is bomb dude

[Nesbynesby]

NATALIEEEE:))

[alvarezjurado]

Mel all the way!



[Ferrantheworthy]

Melissa is way more better than Nathalie!

I like Nathalie but Shes not better than Melissa!

Sorry Nathalie fans -3

[TheLoveissocruel]

Natalie cause Melissa's ugly and can't sing.Natalie was an all right singer with a nice tone of voice.Melissa was just too ugly,she looked like a 50 years old person if you look at her face! They both were bitches,divas.Melissa S thought she was better than chelsea,chelsea was an excellent singer and melissa couldn't sing.

[dcman077]

natalie is real pretty but she got no ass!!!!! I love melissa!!

[FelixDcat777]

Natalie all the way !!!

[mizzoctober420]

obviously natalie... don't get me started with melissa...

[kamran7143]

melissa sucks i like natalie better!!!!! <3

[pinktbear5]

no offence but melissa looks like a granny lol

[Sarahhww]

i fucking love Natalie. Her voice, look & all. <3

[raydeandrademaciel]

NATALIE (l)

[camijazz1]

NATALIE OF COURSE!

[GirliciousStation]

NATALIE MEJIA OF COURSE <3

[LilaMya22]

I love NATALIE MEJIA and HATE Natalie.

[TheQwertykeybored]

natalieeeeee

[kardashian27]

natalie is soooooooo pretty!!!

[sexybanana12]

NATALIEEEEEEEE <333333333.

[rainbow2sexxy]

natalieeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!

[mskatiecutie1212]

Natalie

[LaUrEn1261]

Like...this isnt even a competition! NATALIE BLOWS MELISSA RIGHT OUT OF THE WATER!! YAY NAT!!

[ReviewCam]

hate both of them, but melissa is def prettier.

[fetchism]

it's funny how Melissa doesn't stand a chance against Natalie. Melissa sucks!!!!!

[w4nnie]

they were both kinda bitchy but Natalie is so sexy just hate her bangs nowadays

[llK3lll]

NAT....2:44 she look puuuure latinaaa, I just love her , mi latina hermosaaaa Natalie Mejiaa 100000000000000000000000000000­00%

:D

[MsNatalielicious]

the beauty queen : natalie mejia and everyone knows it : )

[gigglebunny144]

Melissa is a fucking bitch, but Natalie is the best and she is even beautiful.

[GirliciousStation]

Natalie !!!! OF COURSE LOL!!! <3

[riririri66]

Natalie!!! <3

[MissAmanDuhMad]

natalie is sultrier mellisa is just cute

[Jarretsabean]

Hate both , but Natalie .

[Kesha1fanable]

easy peasy natalie mejia!

[Kesha1fanable]

natalie



[Tosky105]

Nataliee per sempreeee <3

Melissa Non sa Nemmeno kantareeee !

[911girlicious]

nat duh!

[Mswannabe]

How are you gonna put the poor girl up against Natalie? Don't get me wrong, melissa is gorgeous by normal standards; if you saw her on the street you'd probably take a double take, i know, i would but cmon. Natalie is flippin drop dead gorgeous she's up there with adriana lima, meg fox, kim dashian ( from the front). Nat, has somethign about her that NONE of the other girls had, mind u , they were all pretty. As soon as i saw her i knew if she had a decent voice she wa s gonn b in the group.

[lolibunny00]

definitly NATALIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[ladygagafan58]

melissa all the way!!

[Kesha1fanable]

natalie

[iRHAPEzombiies]

I hate Melissa she so stuck up and so rude to Chelsea and now Chelsea is bigger star then her. Asia didnt even sing Melissa R should have won it.

[UrbanFelling]

NATALIE NATALIE NATALIE NATALIE NATALIE NATALIE NATALIE NATALIE NATALIE NATALIE NATALIE NATALIE NATALIE NATALIE NATALIE NATALIE NATALIE

[9862972]

@iwilsing4u no you didn't under what I meant and u twisted my words smartass lol I men how in girlicious natilie wass real and her and everyone was saying how jenna wouldn't be there if she wasn't as pretty as she was and natilie was kinda bitchy and dramtic ...look at the comments throughh out the episodes and with melissa in SFTNPCD she was mean and a bit of a bitch to chealsy saying how she sucked as a dancer and was talkin shit.....thhats all

[gatarharo]

I hated melissa smith,she was so fake,and that was here second reality show,DEPREESING!!!!

[9862972]

its soo wierd how in search for the next pusscat doll melissa was a bitch to chealsey who had the best vocals and in girlicious natilie wasthe bitch who was mean to jenna who also had great vocals lol its like mother daughter over here haha

[iwilsing4u]

@9862972 what are you talking about chrystina natalie & jenna were friends....

[Welniukex]

love love Natalie she's my idol sexy

[girliciousfan247]

NATALIE!!!!

[rshura0]

i love nat

[LaUrEn1261]

this is not even fair........NATALIE kills her by a long shot

[gatineaugirl]

Natalie Is Wayy Better. She the Hottest Singer Of All.

[123Dudettes]

natalie all the way

[BeauTfulCallie]

They are both good. Both are pretty.

the only difference is one made it and the other didn't

[bestie08]

Melissa smith ofcourse

[litenjonsson]

Natalie of course!

Natalie is a better dancer and singer!

Melissa sounds like a dying goose when she sings!

[sexymarc2008]

MELISSA SMITH

[loveyunakim]

wow nat obviously

[SweetyGirl363]

NATALIE! <3

[xoxsafina]

natalie cuz she is more hotter than melissa

[MissyK20]

natalie obviously!!!!!!!!

hands down...thats not even a question!!!

LOL!

i loveeeeee natalie sooooooooo much!

[23itsntb]

Natalie is pretty can dance and her voice is nice

[Beljoul]

natalie is the best all the way

[avataranime101]

Melissa! She could sing and dance! Natalie could only dance, her voice was really nasaly. I didn't like Natalie from the beginning especially when she said "Beauty is a Talent." Ugh! That was a really bitchy thing to say. Melissa began to be a bitch that one week before she left, but I just like her better!

[TheNiakey007]

GOSH! I hate Melissa and i love Natalie. Natalie is the best. HANDS DOWN! ;D

[riririri66]

@TheNiakey007 me too i hate Melissa and i love Natalie

[felixbabe]

I loved them both in the show but Nat was always my fav from the beginning ! :)

[Job21190]

natalie far way better !

[PoilQuiPut]

Nathalie is the most sexyyy hottt

[sexymarc2008]

Melissaaaaa SSS ALL THE WAYYY SHES SO HOTT

[SHELOVEROMEO]

Melissa and Nathalie are same

[Roloz12]

nattaalie :)

[appleman58]

@5h1rl37 and nat was nice she was catty as hell and mean to other girls as well

[itsandreeamarcil]

natalie mejia forever & alwaaaaaaaaaaays =)<3

[crystalgeorgiabff]

Natalie because she acually made the group but I have to give some credit to Melissa because she is way nicer!!

[BabyFaceKia97]

natalie

[ineslucas7]

Natalie mejia

[disneybaby27]

natalie can't sing so melissa n ive never liked natalie

[TheHawo123]

natalie of course!

[SuperTwilightAddicte]

MELISSA.S

[MsNatalielicious]

Omg, your stupid if you do not know the answer is Natalie =)

loove her!!!!

[PeppermintSuga]

Mellissa S was a bitch because she was jelous

where as Natalie, is a bitch because shes honest

[gothicangele]

Natalie

[xxmonstermaniacxx]

Natalie sounds a hell lot better. And Natalie wasn't as much as a bitch as Melissa S.

[MJBRITNEYPCD]

NATALIE !!!! ALL THE WAY!!!

[dannyboy1001000]

natile is latin and im mexican so natile plus she is hotter

[sellby]

NATALIE!!

[x0xAmandax0x1]

thesee two were the best oness in their own comeptition i cant really choosee ..both of them are very alike not in the looks but in the way they presented theirselves mm viby voicee and awesomeee danceee talent.. they are both extremely GORGEOUS!!

[x0xAmandax0x1]

i completely agreeee

[MsSweetheart98]

obveoulsy natalie!!!!!!!!!!!!! SHES MY FAVORITE IN THE GIRLICIOUS BAND

[TheAlbera]

they're both bitches, it's impossible to choose between 2 arrogant people

[xoxsafina]

both

[scorcherz]

mel s aint got nothing on Natalie.

[fefynathebest]

NATALIEeeee

[lyli113]

natalie for sure!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[SGLMBFFL09]

Natalie coz wen meliss a danced she looked like a stripper they sed that on the show ! but she is s gud singer!

[Sarahhww]

OBVEOUSLY NATALIE!!

Natalie is WAY Sexier.

& shes a better singer as well!

<3

[kirbykirbyfurby]

i like both

[MissCindyShale]

easily natalie!

[gatarharo]

i don't really lik ethier but if i gotta choose i'd pic nat becuse i hate melissa s

[x0xAmandax0x1]

weelll i love thm bothhhh i think they are both equally sexy and beautiful girlss

[x0xAmandax0x1]

natalieeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee better hotterr

[JessicaLeighAllen]

that melissa girl doesnt even compare to natalie!! haha who made this!? melissa herself? she wishes she was on the same level as that AND her vocals are HORRIBLE!! yuck! Natalie rules!

[LYRICALLYNESS]

Nat is better!!

[BorEdZz]

NEITHER. they're both slutty as fuck.

[badmaruz]

Melissa!!!!!!!!!!1

[Bosnianbaby20]

NATALIEEE ALL THE WAY:)

[franct901]

Natalie

[xoXthewaywewere]

Melissa

[BoznianBoii]

Natalie!

[SEXYR68]

MELISSA :D

Natalie is pretty but Melissa is Stunning and much better at everything in my opinion =]

[Marielolilol]

Natalie is so much hot then melissa !

[annehhh09]

natalie .

[Leeland16]

melissa

[Job21190]

natalie rules !

[CheerBoyX1]

omg i thought melissa was natalie from girlicious! >.>

[snuimcmoelre9]

natalie def!!!!

[carmenyellow20]

natalie has no class...melissa is so much better

[vampiremelodies]

Natalie.

[sweetstarxo]

natalie!

[llilhunnie]

NATALIEE!!!! BBBAAABBYYY ! =) <3333

[bridg2terabithia]

haha both my favorite girls from both the shows!

but NATALiE is MY LOVERRRR!

[asiansugaa]

Natalie! Because I believe that she has a great voice (she also improved) and a talented dancer.

Melissa still has that decent singing voice and i'd give her a 7 for her dancing. She's really not that good of a dancer, she just looks like one, imo.

[MajestyXP]

natalie was at least a likable bitch during the show(:

[wwefan3123]

Melissa!!!!!!

[jrla]

natalie <3

[Boy0nFire]

Nat Nat Nat

Duh!?

[samanthadavis17]

definelty Natalie

[Gemapecruz]

natalie mejia

[JusticexWilliam]

melissa s i love her

[music4ever156]

omg they are both my favourites from each season! i can't really choose. from sexy, cute and talented. can't really choose.

[Pinklover125]

nattttttttttttttttt duhhhhhhh

[luvcookies97]

nat hands down

[DjDavidReggaetonMIX]

NATALIE MEJIA ! Love you girl <3

[lorylory123456]

OF COURSE MELISSA SMITH... SHE'S THE BEST...SHE GONNA BE THE NEW PUSSYCAT DOLL...SHE HAVE EVERYTHING FOR TO BE A PCD... -SHE'S SEXY -SHE HAVE CHARISMA -SHE'S BEAUTIFUL -SHE CAN SING -SHE CAN DANCE -SHE HAVE CLASS Other???:D She's Awesome!!! Also Natalie is my favourite in the GIRLICIOUS with Chrys... <3 xoxo XD

[bb0bwoi]

natalie straight up melissa s sucks

[HaybeRaydoo]

NATALIE MEJIA

[KristinaandSarahShow]

REQUEST: Can you make one with Carrie (Girlicious)vs. Nicole(PCD) for best singer. Please!!

[ILoveGirliciousSFTND]

i'll do it... if you want to vote i made one with carrie (girlicious) vs chelsea (search for the next doll) for best singer

[kathylu22]

i like them both alot

[pcdrey]

What the hell is this question , nat hands down :) She's my idooooole (L)

[anakarol091]

NATALIE IS THE BEST !!!! Definitely Natalie.We love her s2.

[steelie001]

both

[boycrazy1001]

Melissa! no wait...Nat! I uno BOTH!

[charmed3prue]

hoe & hoe :)

but like more

Natalie cus she actually won

unlike Mellissa S. who lost the chance to be in both Danity Kane and Pussycat Dolls how sad

[ardieno16]

MELISSA S...

[scorcherz]

Obviously Natalie<3

[123ChocolateCake456]

I love both of them!

[firecat1992]

NATALIE. hands down.

[nhlmrey01]

natalie. she is awesome

[haniloves89]

two sluts

[ChattyCindii23]

lmfaooo

i dont even like both of themm

[KailTrueman]

Natalie 4 shizzle! She was my second fav, of girlicious. And I always hated Melissa S. she was a bitch to chelsea that's y she got kicked off b4 chelsea! lol

[brittanylynn55]

Natalie.

i haaated melissa.

[MetroGoddess20]

IMO, they pretty much mirror one another--very pretty, strong dancers, okay singers & were mean at some point in the competition...Natalie sounded better in the performances & Melissa danced better, but I'll have to go with Natalie Mejia!! (I love that last name)

[ILuvBaconDogs]

they do awfully alike...

[MattPCD]

Idk... I think Natalie because she is AMAZING while Melissa was OK and a b to Chelsea (my fave of both seasons)

[mysteryjade]

Natalie, hands down.

[Marisha8]

NATALIE!!!! Love her...

[ladiijulez]

sorry..but its defitnetly MELISSA!!! =]

idc if she was mean on the show its a competition..=]

[Laregina89]

NATALIE'S THE BEST she's beautiful and I like her voice

[jungik09]

MELISSA S. CLEARLYYY

[LittleMissSeton]

Natalie =)

[Hunniie67]

NATALIE CLEARLYYY

[SHORTYDOUI2]

i say mellisa!. shes way prettyer, and sings better. I LOVE HER!. lol

[HopeDaily]

Nataaaaaalie.. adore that girl!

[cglg1234]

Natalie all the way! :D hehe

[xxsuzaxx]

i like natalie better she was a bitch on the show but she isnt really now she prettier sings better n better dancer i hate melissa smith she a slut im glad she didnt win she was a bully on the search for nex pcd she was mean to my fave chelsea :(

FIRST TO COMMENT!!!:)

[stronzettina89]

natalie