Added: 4 years ago
From: DivinedDecayed
Views: 40,648
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (980)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • sad,,, 

  • sad,,, :S

  • Why are people cheering?

  • Does she really consider ";alksdjfowaeiudfjdlsfj" to be singing?

  • oh my god, my ears!

  • omg!

    2:25 LOL!!

  • anette (L) *.*

  • @07Devito I love her head voice 

  • You're slaying my ears!

  • I was about to say, WOW! however, the second part which should be named slaying the ears, seriously, dear anette, what were you thinking about?

  • is this recorded with a pencil?

  • not even....

  • I like the new songs with Anette Olzon but this is laughable and HELL YES the second part is awefull she is just screaming not singing anymore

  • Comment removed

  • LOL, this is just ridiculous, the second part especially.

  • Is this supposed to be comedy? Annette's voice just doesn't work for this song! Omg, this is disgusting.

  • Santo Dio benedetto! Ha distrutto una delle più belle canzoni dei Nightwish!

  • 3:54 AAAHHHHH

  • esa nena no canta si no grita q asco

  • we should kill Anette hahahahaha

  • Wow think she was screaming more then singing at the end of that song not the best performance by her

  • o_o S-O-S somebody help me press the "Pause" button cause this CRAP has paralized me! HELP! Annete you have a great voice better than 3/4 of pop-rock singers BUT Tarja has a better voice than 40/4 of ANY singer on this planet so STOP singing her songs!

    a. You will destroy your voice with all this screaming.

    b. You will destroy our ears (and our whole nervous system) with all that screaming. NW if you won't your fans to move MOVE ON TOO! Stop killing your old songs!

  • @TheFullmoonTraveller What do you expect them to play at shows? Only songs from Dark Passion Play? You'd rather they stopped touring until they had 2 or 3 albums released with Anette so they have more variety of songs to play at concerts? Some old NW songs I can only listen to if Anette sings them. Like Wishmaster.

  • @GreenDay1981 Many people Tarja's opera voice a bit "heavy" for their taste.And it's your right to prefer the pop-rock Wishmaster version like the majority of people to love Lady gaga. BUT Tarja is amazing and for me Annete singing her song is just hopeless...Nettie CAN'T sing that high no matter what! And I didn't say them to play only DPP songs, but limit in some easy songs Nemo and I Wish I Had an Angel. And that's only until they have a second album! 25 songs are just fine for concerts!

  • @GreenDay1981 To answear your question yes, I would rather NW stoped touring for a while but this is not a solution...

  • This is like WTF the Dreamer. Worst ever, shame on you Anette to trying this masterpiece.

  • it's always funny to see people bitching/discussing her higher notes and the fact how she did/couldn't do them live, absolutely forgetting about the rest of the song, like, the main part of it - the angry, desperate, wild and emotional verses which Anette sang perfectly, with so much real emotions involved.

    Are you listening to the whole song ot just skip everything but the high notes, I wonder? :)

  • @LerrenWinterHeart I listen but i still prefer Tarja's version. And don't think wrong of me. I LIKE Anette, i like Tarja as well. I just think there are some songs that Anette sings better and the other way round.

  • @LerrenWinterHeart I actually agree. ;) Thank you.

  • @LerrenWinterHeart Because high notes are the best part of the song, and Anette fucked it big time.

  • @buddhaboy1972 oh really? Then I guess you're a lucky man, seeing you don't give a damn about any sense the song has. Though it's your opinion.

    As for me, I can hear Anette's being uncomfortable on these high notes, struggling with them etc, but for me it doesn't make the whole song being "her worst try ever", 'cause the rest of the StD has been sang greatly. There's a room for improvement, always is, but still it was a good performance.

  • @LerrenWinterHeart High notes belongs to this song. Anettes singing High Notes sounds like dying seal.

  • que basura es esto me quedo con tarja esto no canta ladra

  • Comment removed

  • even Tuomas broke down at around 2.35 to 2.40 ... wonder what he was thinking at that moment ^^

  • Nightwish se debería conseguirse una cantante, no una (intento de) imitadora de Tarja!

  • what amazed me the most is that she and tarja are both sopranos, lyric ones indeed.... BOTH!!! and even if the style is different there are no high notes in the end at all!! why the heck didn't she reach them -even screaming >O<°!- that's omething i will never tolerate i mean it was so damn easy!

    I hope next album has a little -A LITTLE!- of classic style for being able to shut us up and say: "ok, she can use her head voice in the end :D".

    I am really waiting for that

  • @SakumaRyuichiNG Anette is not a lyric soprano. She can't be, since she is not a classical singer and "lyrical" is a sub-genre of the classical. If you have taken that information from her blog, she wrote that she WOULD be a light lyrical soprano IF she were a classical singer, but which she isn't.

  • @HeartsEyes I am based in her timbre, and sometimes i even think she could be a light type BECAUSE of her colour. Obviously the only think we can be certain since we have not listen her vocalize, is the fact that she's a soprano using belting. I particularly don't know the technique but i highly doubt this is right... but who knows, no idea if belting is shouting high pitches.

  • @SakumaRyuichiNG Yes, it is often disputed if belting is actually singing.. especially folks from the classical area often say it's not.

    Anette once said she had a soprano range until her first pregnancy, then lost her highest notes (I believe her, because I know women it happened to as well). Her range was not tested again after that, so I assume she went on as mezzo-soprano. Recently she said that she re-gained higher notes again now, but this video here is 4 years old.

  • @HeartsEyes I do think belting is singing, it's just another style. What I meant is that i don't know belting technique so, i really don't know if she's a good belting singer (I feel terrible when i listen the end of the song, not 'coz the technique 'coz she's shouting; I think that must had hurt.

    I highly doubt she's a mezzo, might be a soprano with lower range but a mezzo no, simply she doesn't have the colour, the notes and the streght needed.

    yes, i read she is training her head voice.

  • @SakumaRyuichiNG I think in this case it is just that it is above her comfortable range. Belting is a technique where unlike headvoice you have to keep your vocal chords shut and they get sore if they open. Anette's open here when notes are too high for her, that's where the screaming sound comes from, and yes, that hurt her voice a lot. By 2008 you could hear that.

    And I meant mezzo simply as being the range between soprano and alto, because an alto she is not, wasn't going into colour and so.

  • Comment removed

  • @HeartsEyes Oh, that explain the sound -the belting technique, btw, thanks for the explanation.-

    Yup, i remember how she sounded by 2008.

    I particularly would like she to learn some classical just for showing her voice -I like her, and her voice, I do dislike her slaying the dreamer but well, that's personal taste and interpretation is totally different to the voice itself.-

    Oh, that's it. You meant the comfortable range.

    yes, she's an alto nowhere XD.

  • @SakumaRyuichiNG I heard some decent performances of her singing Slaying the Dreamer in 2007, before her voice was too sore from all the touring. Not perfect, but I agree with LerrenWinterHeart there. ;)

    Also I think an aggressive song like this does not have to sound "beautiful" all the time, but I agree with you to some extent, because I don't like to hear how it hurts her to sing. But as far as I know, they have taken it out of the setlist anyway.

  • @HeartsEyes However, i'll really love listening this again but with another style (i don't mean she have to change her style, but use more styles as possible in order to allowe her perfomance better and more). I really think she has "angel" 'coz otherwise i don't know why i like her (it's not my "style") but she's like something i wanna listen :D (which -i have no idea why- i don't feel for Tarja solo project).

    Actually, I like Anette's interpretation, i just dislike the end ^^u

  • @SakumaRyuichiNG Tarja once said in an interview "Somehow the meaning of the words just goes to people with singing when the singing is true and you feel the singer on the spiritual level." I think that is true, and also that some people feel Tarja more and others Anette. And that has nothing to do with any details or qualities of their singing styles, people are just different.

    I just wish that people would stop fighting over that, but I don't need to tell you that, you aren't fighting. ;)

  • @HeartsEyes Indeed, that sounds like wise words!! that's probably what difference singers and their followers. Probably is just like that, a connection between them and the music.

    I think it's a triangle (music, interpreter and listener), for me Nw's music and lyrics are special and that's Tuomas (the most of the times). That's my reason for listening NW, no matter Tarja's not there.

    Agree!; some people are just like "blah blah" but usually there are no objective neither sensible :(

  • (u.u) Se lastimo la garganta!!

    Pobre Nettie, pero nimodo, toda la cancion le quedo divina, nadamas en final, pero el intento se hace y ella se divirtio apesar de eso :D

  • no no no NOOOOO! 3:54 GOD! WHAT THE HELL IS SHE DOING?

  • Que asco de mujer!

  • @mywinterstorm07 Jajajajaja Tu nick me dice que eres Tarjista ardid@!!

  • @NwDevotion Y tu comentario me dice que eres una ilusa. Si me da asco esta mujer tengo todo el derecho a decirlo al igual si a ti te cae mal Tarja o quien sea.

  • @mywinterstorm07 Pfff, Tarja no me cae mal :S

    Ardida! =)

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @NwDevotion Si claro, yo cuando veo que a Tarja le salio una nota mal o se le va la voz pues digo, joder que mal, pero no pongo excusas estupidas como la que tu has puesto. Esta mujer no canta, parece que está sufriendo. Ardido? Lo siento, a mi me hablas en castellano porque eso en mi país no se entiende.

  • @mywinterstorm07 Disculpa! que excusa puse?, no inventes cosas que sabes que no son verdad =) y no al contrario Anette no sufre, se divierte!

    y no me importa de donde seas pero en mi pais sabemos quienes son los ardidos y no te voy a estar dando el gusto de hablarte como tu quieras :@

  • @NwDevotion Cariño, crece un poco y luego hablamos :D

  • @mywinterstorm07 Todo a su tiempo... Tu lo que necesitas es madurar

  • @NwDevotion Un besito ^_^

  • what the fuck is that screaming? o.O omfg she could've done something different on that part of the song, something of her own...

  • I watched this to see if Tarja was better at singing the song.

    I was right! -_-

  • The song is not so hard to sing, and Anette does it really good, her only mistake, was trying to reach the same notes of Tarja when is not necesary, speaking about when she is doing "aaahhhh" at 3:24 and 3:54, this "aaa" is not really necesary, but, it's ok, is hard to do your own version of a song, specially if you learn it sung by someone else with other range and style diferent from you

  • 3.53.................. bitch!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • lol,,,,are u kidding drop the song NO TARJA

  • Q SON ESOS BERRIDOS Q ASCO 

  • Slaying the song!

    the first time I heard Anette's way of destroying this song I wanted to cry. Do NOT do that, do NOT try to "sing" what you canNOT sing, this is horrible and even offensive.

  • WTF juannete arruino una de las mejores canciones de nightwish, no entiendo como sigue en la banda... hasta yo canto mejorsss

  • @elyvanescente Entonces debiste audicionar como hizo ella a ver si Tuomas te escogia a ti... ¬¬

    Si Tuomas la escogió por algo debió ser... Quienes se creen uds para criticarlos?

  • @Caos0828 me creo una persona que estudio 10 años musica y que sé de lo que estoy hablando cuando digo que juanette apesta

  • @elyvanescente  Y? me hubiese gustado ver a Tuomas escogiendote a ti...

    Sinceramente... crees que te hubiesen escogido a ti? con sinceridad... ;)

    yo diría que no (sin dudar que sepas mucho), tu que crees?

  • si :)

  • @elyvanescente Wow debes ser muy buena!!! ¿...?

    me alegra que te tengas confianza... Pero por el momento, tu ves videos de Nightwish y Anette y la criticas... Y Ninguno de ellos sabe quien eres, y les daría igual si existes o no... Solo digo... No discuto que la tecnica de Anette no se compara con la de la voz de finlandia... Pero es hora de que los fans conoscan su puesto... Un placer hablar contigo =*

  • JJAJAJAJAAAAAAAAJAJAJAJAJAJAJJ­AJAJAJAJAJAJAJAJAJAJAAAAAAAAAA­JAJAJAJAJAJAJAJAJJAAAAAAAAAAAA­JAJJAJAJAJAJAJAM MINUTO 355 JAJAJAJAJAAAAJAJAJAJAJAJAJAJAJ­AJAJA

  • ok... Nightwish's project with anette is beautiful... new atmosphere, new songs, new style...This is great, super etc and anette is lovely.. Tuomas you made your point that you can do something different than what we used to call Nightwish... Now as at phantom of the opera lyrics is written "your spirit and my voice in one combined"... get Tarja back, put that f** letter in a box and through it away and do what nightwish supose to do... ty :)

  • She is good :)

  • Slaying The Annete

  • jajaja, le doy like, solo por que intento llegar ala nota mas alta, no mames si asi es con esta cancion, ya quiero escuchar la del fantasma de la operaXD

  • minuto 3:54... que mierda fue eso? O_O

  • the title of the video should be 'slaying the song' :S

  • @wantedcode93 Amén bro xD

  • oh..... my......god.......

  • VOZZZ NORMAL??? ESTA CHICA NO PEGA UNA NOTAAAA, SIN TARJA NO EXISTEN

  • Te amamos anette! 

  • Hahahahahahahahahahahahaha :D

  • DAMN her voice FUCKED itself.

  • She sounds like she's being tortured...

  • o MY GOOD, ANNETTE QUE LE HAS HECHOA LA CANCION , LA FREGASTE COMPLETA, WHAT THE HELL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!sorry anette en algunas canciones me parece q lo haces bien y cuando es en cd , pero hay cancionesq solo eran apra tarja o para una soprano sorry....:(

  • That was painful !!! However, give Annette credit for trying. Tuomas should not have her singing songs that fans identify so strongly with Tarja. Annette has a beautiful voice on Dark Passion Play.

  • anette .I.

    

  • WHOA! Marco sings his part here better than I've ever heard before!! :D Such a pity Anette's singing at the end was atrocious.

  • ANETTE, DO NOT SING TARJAS SONGS.

    You just kill them. I love the new Nightwish... but prefer the old, obviously. I just don't think Anette can pull of Tarjas songs.... they weren't written for Anette. -sigh- my only one dream is for Tarja to go back to Nightwish... it really is.

  • ugly singing

  • I'm sorry but as much as I love Anette, that ending was painful to listen to. I think this is the only song I don't like her singing, at least here she doesn't do the ending v=tXHTqyAxdI8

  • You're slaying the song.

  • jojo QUE VOZ PORFAVOR!!!!!!

    SE DESTACA MUCHO,

    PERO DESTACA POR SER LA PEOR CANTANTE DE ESTE PLANETA!

    ANETTE SABI QUE NO PODI CANTAR ESTA CANCION,

    PARA QUE MIERDA LO HACES!!!!

    HACES EL RIDICULO!

  • PERKELE O_0

    

  • I like Anette singing better. Sorry, I just do.

  • Toumas it's for you and only for you... WTF!!!!!!

  • Well, at least Marco is still fantastic...

  • i cried when i heard this, literally =(, she suuuuckkss, she cant sing the old songs... did u notice how she lost her voice at 3: 54 and 3:27??? idk why in earth did they chose annette....

  • @chimecho6 Because she is good singer and Nightwish needed replace greedy Tarja.

  • Tuomas admire you as a composer, but

    What the hell did!!

    ANETTE LISTEN WELL, SHE DOES NOT SING, SCREAM !!!!!!

  • owww,i want tocry she fucks all, terrible.look the tuomas face so ashemed,hahaha ,she is screaming like a little child.

  • THIS SUCKS!

  • ugly!!!!

  • Shoot me...

    I really regret about choosing Anett for being new vocalist. She has ear for music, she has nice voice, BUT she can`t sing as Tarja, or just like any rock\metal vocalist. Her awful trying of resing Tarja songs (for some stupides - it`s Tarja songs, `cause Thomas dont sing it) irritate me and force to be hung up...

  • @qDan10000 She isn't trying sing like Tarja.

  • @antonsdefrancua

    Yep, she trying to scream louder, and sometimes try to sing.

  • 194 People who pressed like are:

    1: Deaf and think it sounds good by looking at the visual.

    or

    2: turned Deaf right when it started of it and thus also press like.

  • She is really slaying the song!!What is she trying to prove?That she has no voice?It's not difficult.She has already proven that.

    Ok,I do appreciate her effort to become a better singer,but she must finally learn that she has no voice for Tarja's songs!!!I do go on listening to Nightwish and their new stuff,but Anette singing songs of the old era really makes me hate her!!

  • @travel23231 You makes me hate people like you, who are complaining all time. Why you watched this video if you don't like Anette.

  • disgusting as every old era song she sings! her screaming is AWFUL..stop slaying this song!

  • Anette must sing songs from DDP and next album (she have a great voice) , but not the old songs... Only Tarja can sing them !

  • slaaaaaaaaaaaying the soong!!

    I loooveeee this video xD

    it's just SO funny

  • Just enjoy the old vids of Tarja singing the old songs, and dont blame Anette for trying. She was never ment to be good at the old songs, but people still want to hear them live of course. They are after all Nightwish's songs. Tuomas wrote them! I like Anette's voice on the songs wrote for here, and there is only going to be more of them as time goes on. So if you want to hear the old songs, wacth them with Tarja, but dont cry because Anette cant do them so well.

  • She trys, but her are Tarja are two different types of singers. NW was not really looking for a Tarja clone like you all wish they had gotten. They were looking for some one with a softer voice. They were trying to get Tarja to sing softer since their 4th cd, but they ended up kicking her cuz i guess her and Tuomas where not getting along so well, and we all know the whole story with Tuomas and Tarja right? yeah she is never coming back...

  • when she shouts is ridiculous...

  • @Bakura2385 - indeed

  • about "fuckoffbitch" his comment is copy paste on allmost all of antte vids, ignore him.

  • this bitch shops at hot topic!! WTF??? STUPID CUNT!

  • wow, have you checked Tuomas at 2:33??????

    he looks so disappointed and worried...

    i guess he understands that everything was a big mistake... but now it's too late to do anything...

    and well... in this video Anette singing was so dreadful

  • she sounds like a drunk woman in a karaoke bar xD

  • @ClaudiaDenise Hahaha. Well said!! I can't stop laughing!!

  • Mucho grita, y no debe darle adornos q no van con la canción, si existe una partitura debe cantarla como está en la partitura, no es pop..... no me gusta Anette, lo hace mal en esta canción....... la ddetesto......

  • I LOVE Anette's version of this song. I mean, come on people, so what if it's different? You want her to try and sing like Tarja and be a Tarja clone? I didn't think so.

  • Lamentablemente no es la mejor interpretacion de anette. pero hay que tomar en cuenta que es una de las primeras, de esa fecha a estos días anette a mejorado muchisimo, ya a logrado un buen sigergismo con la banda. Quiza esta no es una cancion para ella, sobre todo la parte que es más lyrica. pero anette hace una buena interpretacion con otras canciones antiguas de nightwish.

  • Slaaaaying the soooooong. *sing*

  • totally awful!!! don't know if we have to laugh or weep...

  • It's horrible!!!

  • 3:54 q onda con ese grito?

  • honestly, i think BOTH Tarja and Anette fans agree that Anette can't pull off this song

  • hahahahahahahahahhaha anette make me laugh at the end of the song

  • This is a total piece of FAIL! Anette SUCKS!

  • JAA OMFG XDDDDDDD AAYAYAYAAAYAYAYAYAAYAYAYAYAYA!­!! XD 3:24 OMFG JAJAJAJA XDDDDDDDDDDDD NOO XDDDDDD This shit makes my day xDDDD honestly poor bitch I feel sorry for her... Ok No xDDD... NO ONE BETTER than Tarja.

  • xD horrible!!!! jajajajajajajajaja

  • Awesome song turned to shit!!!! @.@ 3:47 - 3:56 are you freaking kidding me!

  • Toumas thought 2:34 - 2:39 - "What have I done?" ahahaauahuau

    Sorry but I need to write this.

  • anette can't scream worth shit

  • This version is horrible,only tarja sings well this song...

  • la primera parte puede que sea pasable , pero porfavor.. que fue la parte final?? WFT?? eso ni los propios fans lo pueden negar xD

  • 2:28 to 2:35 made me cry inside for this song <//3

  • que asco

  • pudrete

  • Anette is a good singer... It has a versatile voice

  • @DarkSober hmmm you haven't seen this video, right???

    she can sing only ballads...in slow songs her voice sounds very sweet and clean, but in the other songs she just yells or forces her voice... she has a horrible technique and her voice is really weak for NW's songs.

  • odio la voz de esta mujer en esta banda...

  • Sinceramente, eu odeio ela

    ela é muito puta, destruiu a minha banda favorita

    ela me paga

  • Annett has one of the most disgusting female voices, which I've ever heard. She rapes with her ugly voice, this Nightwish classic song!!! I believe Britney Spears would does it better!!!

  • i thought she did pretty good. O_O

  • WTF ?! o_O

    She destroys the whole song.!

  • esta mina vale callampa wn es mas popera que chucha wn

  • Horrible horrible horrible, por eso ahora cuando la tocan , e esta parte Anette sale del escenario

  • 0.o OMG!

  • definitivamente el metal no es lo suyo ,

    espero que pegue su disco como solista

    para que una vez por todas se largue y le

    de paso a alguien que realmente tenga

    talento para este gran genero musical

  • anette canta como niña estriñida XD

  • she shoud sing pop music..lol

  • she sucks

  • What´s happened with these guy´s, that the must play on stage with a squeaking mouse?

  • 2:18 XDDD Is she showing to "stay as you lay" )))

  • i love her dress:)

  • Is that Anette still songing at 4:20? XDDDDD

  • Her outfit makes me so sad..

  • Legal levando em consideração as outras músicas que Anette canta .