Death penalty for a Muslim who leaves Islam is not an Islamic Law by Dr. Zakir Naik.

[ginu1]

why must one beat ones wife?

[ginu1]

muhammad was a liar just like zakir is

[TheDajjal1]

Bukhari (84:57) - [In the words of] "Allah's Apostle, 'Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him.'"

Bukhari (89:271) - A man who embraces Islam, then reverts to Judaism is to be killed according to "the verdict of Allah and his apostle."

[gxbmb]

fuck islam

[SearchingForChrist]

it is a rule but not a standard rule ?? Do I understand that right??

[forgottenmemories63]

Disgusting Religion for Savages and Brain dead people

[JustSivas58]

@forgottenmemories63 People come here for proves that Islam is practised wrong by wrong people, but you come here to insult without facts. Your hate is based on your low IQ.

[LeSage013]

Even if you put yourself in a neutral point of view, as a believer I mean, the act of apostasy is not just a crime against the community you are in, it is also a crime against the one Creator you believe in. In terms of society and spiritual, you have sinned heavily.

If you don't believe in Islam and God, why join in the first place? Just for fun?? If so, I believe you are liable for a heavy punishment. If you can't understand why, I don't know how you relate yourself as a human being.

[MARZ8734]

@LeSage013 You're mad. No-one should be killed just because they don't want to follow a certain religion. The majority of people in the world would disagree with your views.

[TheApocalyps4]

If the death penalty for those who leave Islam is not an Islamic law, then it is the law of Allah. If you don't believe me then see sura 4:89 and 3:85 of your Quran.

Muslims - please read your Quran and Hadith before you make any statements and stop using Taqiyya or Kitman. We already know the truth.

[CulturalMyths]

'depending upon the act?'

like what? perhaps telling people why they left islam?

is that enough reason to kill someone?

lol

shut up naik you snake

muslims... gorw up

[Amrruk]

THIS MAN WHO IS AN ARDENT PROPONENT OF THE HADITHS LIES TO PROTECT HIS ISLAM.

Allah's Apostle said, "The blood of a Muslim who confesses that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah and that I am His Apostle, cannot be shed except in three cases: In Qisas for murder, a married person who commits illegal sexual intercourse and the one who reverts from Islam (apostate) and leaves the Muslims.- Sahih Bukhari

Whoever changed his (Islamic) religion, then kill him.- Sahih Bukhari

[Amrruk]

LIER ! LIER ! LIER !

Muslim who follow the collections of Hadiths, the Islamic traditions (i.e. Sunnis, Shiaa...etc), are summoned by Bukhari's "authentic hadiths" to kill MUSLIMS WHO REJECT ISLAM !

[agate3live]

To whom it may concern. Lazy censorship by spam flagging is a sure sign that you have no convincing counter arguments.

[amlh2000]

For 1400 years the world hide the goodness in Islam, killing anyone for changing their form or denomination of Islam goes against Allah as Allah created each of us with a Great Purpose and that is to sort into groups for skills development & medical Treatment and gain the Leadership Skills to Lead ourselves, our Families, Communities, Nations & World in Creating & Maintaining a Lasting Legacy in Personal & World Peace!

Mashallah! Mashallah! Mahshallah!

We all have a share in this effort!

[amlh2000]

As Salam Aliekom

There are no Apostates as One can neither join nor leave Islam = One can never leave the process of the Evolution of Our Submitting & Cooperating and each Religion is a Form or Denomination of Our Evolution of Our Submitting & Cooperating and each is a valid way to express Our Islam!

Any questions?

Ma Salam

Sister Anne Marie Elderkin

The Earth Personified is Risen & There are Mountains to Move & Motivate including Myself!

[agate3live]

@amlh2000 This is very enlightened but sadly bears no resemblance to the barbaric and intolerant creed actually laid out in the Koran and Hadith and revealed in its true colours by the actions of muslims (as a "valid way to express their Islam") in such places as Nigeria, Sudan, Pakistan and Indonesia today. My question to you, an educated woman, is why defend the indefensible?

[amlh2000]

@agate3live Waliekom Salam, from my experience and years of research I have found the majority of Muslims I have met to be peaceful, considerate and diplomatic.

In all cultures, religions there are those who have used violence to try and solve a difficulty and usually the difficulty has been ignorance, misinformation, and trying to hide the truth under threats of voilence, dirogitory remarkks when in fact many of the laws for women were not know in europe or the world for 1400 years.

[amlh2000]

@agate3live Technically europeans and other cultures and religions have feared change and have tried to hide the truth of the wonders of other cultures religions and spiritual, medical practices that could have saved many lives.

Islam was also the 1st to provide sexual health information when called on to anyone who had questions, this was done by the wives of the Prophet Mohammed, Mohammed & Other Scholars during his time.

[amlh2000]

@agate3live Islam encourages a Life Long Quest for Knowledge, Compassion & Understanding.

Our Islam = Our Evolving Our Ways & Means of Submitting & Cooperating with Allah, God, the Creator is a process we all do in degrees making us all Muslims 1st or ones who submit

[amlh2000]

@agate3live

Each religion is a form or denomination of our evolving our ways & means of submitting and cooperating and each is a valid path though some practices may bring us closure or farther from the truths & proofs of excellence in our submitting & cooperating & expressing our form of Islam.

[agate3live]

@amlh2000 Well, you certainly replied but have not really addressed my problem. Monotheistic religions such as yours have a disastrous and murderous history of intolerance towards heretics and unbelievers. Otherwise good men will commit utterly evil acts if they believe their God and holy book demands it. Unfortunately the Koran, as the unchanging word of Allah, and the recorded actions and sayings of his Prophet, clearly sanction injustice, cruelty and murder. Why submit to that?

[amlh2000]

@agate3live

I hate to tell you this but everything in this universe is in a process of evolving. Islam and all religions are in this process too. Just look at the good old USA and their tolerance of the KKK for years and how segregation has disappeared.

Sure there may always be some evil or inhuman behaving people but with the rest of the world evolving it is just a matter of time in changing hearts & minds towards a Life Long Quest for Knowledge, Understanding, Compassion

[amlh2000]

@agate3live

Sentencing a Person, a People to a hateful labeling campaign does nothing but feed the demon of evil inside the perpatrator & closes doors rather than opening them. Hate brings anger, distrust while a geniune interest in the ways and being of others opens conversations, diologue and the beginning of the development of understanding & compassion.

We do not need another holicost to teach us another lesson what we need is participation in the ongoing currents of Positive Change!

[amlh2000]

@agate3live

What you have said can easily be said for Judaism, Christianity too!

I do not submit to evil no matter where it is found. The Process we call Islam could & can easily be called Life itself, we are all in a process of submitting to something or someone my efforts are directed at encouraging positive & productive evolution of our ways and means of submitting & cooperating. To be a Muslim or a Christian does not mean we have to submit the way our for fathers did nor should we

[minorreb]

This is a classic example of the Islamic doctrine of “Al-taqiyya" which states that it is OK to lie to infidels for the good of Islam. In fact the Koran is the "Mein Kampf" of holy books and, together with the medieval Hadith, sanctions Jihad against all non-muslims, the execution of apostates, the institution of slavery, stoning, amputation and the subjugation of women.

[agate3live]

What's not to love? Islam's take on the Arts perhaps? The Prophet said, "It is better for a man to fill the inside of his body with pus than to fill it with poetry."(and had several poets killed). He also said, "Such people as paint these pictures (of animals) will receive the severest punishment on the Day of Resurrection." While Rasulullah  said: "Listening to music and singing is sinful. Sitting at such gatherings is fisq (immoral transgression). Deriving pleasure from it is kufr."

[SouljaAli810Flint]

Lol America so funny. How in the world can we allowed free world and not accept Islam? I love Islam.

Peace

[gangizkhan]

the blood of a muslim can not be shed EXCEPT the one who revort from ISLAM .

SAHIH BUKHARI V 9 BOOK 87 .NUM 17

[bagh98]

@gangizkhan: The authenticity of Hadith collection is another long and big topic.

[arunkumarvikram]

Clearly he has retracted from his former statement. Watch this video

/watch?v=Coux2mS4tbg&feature=r­elated

He clearly says if one converts and propagates his new religion then the penalty is death(no edit this is a full video).

[ALMayda79]

@arunkumarvikram

I’ve just viewed the video you presented and it does not go against this video. You may have misunderstood it. He is saying that if are a Muslim who leaves Islam and becomes an enemy of Islam then it is the death penalty for you. If you leave Islam peacefully and have nothing against Islam then there is no punishment for you.

[MARZ8734]

@ALMayda79 So people should die if they're against Islam? See that's what I don't like about Islam, it avocates death and murder.

[ALMayda79]

@MARZ8734 No you’ve misread my message its called treason. It’s not just in Islam you will find it in none Islamic countries too. If you go against your own country you may get the death penalty. If you create war against Islam then you are against Islam. If you leave Islam peacefully, if you don’t want to follow the Islamic way and have nothing against Islam then there is no punishment for you according to the speaker Dr. Zakir Naik.

[Amrruk]

@ALMayda79 This only proves that Islam is NOT A RELIGION, less so a RELIGION OF PEACE BUT A POLITICAL IDEALOGY ! Muhammad was not a man of God but a POLITICAL LEADER who united the Arabs under one FABRICATED RELIGION. I am a born ex-Muslim, now Christian who discovered that Muhammad was a false orophet, that the Quran is nothing else but a forgery and I am against Islam's false teachings ! I am considered a Murtad, an apostate, and should be executed according to your Hadiths !

[LeSage013]

@MARZ8734 Well, modern western civilization advocates death and murder too if you commit treason. It's a very universal concept, not just in Islam.

[Serpico261]

@ALMayda79 what if i were a poet back than and had simply mocked the perfect prophet, would he kill me for that? :-)) im curious

[ALMayda79]

@Serpico261 .

Simple answer to that, if you were truly a Muslim then why would you wanna mock the prophet?

[Serpico261]

@ALMayda79 what if the poet was not a muslim? Otherwise it wouldnt make any sense...thats clear. You would NOT kill a poet if he mocks you, and you are surely against that and condemn that, why do you change your mind in case of muhammed? just asking

[ALMayda79]

@Serpico261 .

well there were many people like that at the time of mohamed(saws) Not necessarily poets. Mohamed(saws) simply sent his messengers to them in a peaceful way, only to change their hearts and their opinions about the prophet, they were never killed unless they attacked with violence. Fight words with words, Fight violence with violence.

[TheApocalyps4]

Any muslim leaving the Muslim faith is to be killed according to the Quran sura 4:89. This man is not telling the truth. Remember every muslim has to obey the Quran and the hadith and any defector is an infidel. To see the facts visit my website at endtimes.us.com

[Amrruk]

@TheApocalyps4 Not only to the Quran but also the Hadiths where their Islamic Laws come from...

-Allah's Apostle said, "The blood of a Muslim who confesses that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah and that I am His Apostle, cannot be shed except in three cases: In Qisas for murder, a married person who commits illegal sexual intercourse and the one who reverts from Islam and leaves the Muslims

-Whoever changed his (Islamic) religion, then kill him- Sahih Bukhari

[TheApocalyps4]

@Amrruk Maybe you can explain the following suras; 2:191, 5:33, 5:45, 8:7, 8:12, 8:39, 9:14, 9:29, 9:123, 66:9, 9:11, 9:36, just to name a few.

The penalty for leaving Islam is death, see suras 32:22, 16:106.

[cure4atheism]

AL QURAN Chapter 2 Al-Baqara (27) How can ye reject the faith in Allah? Seeing that ye were without life, and He gave you life; then will He cause you to die, and will again bring you to life; and again to Him will ye return.

[ALMayda79]

Yes I do agree with you! But did you know out of all 2 billion Muslims half are blind believers who reads the Quran in Arabic and dose not know the meaning but they believe because there fathers and forefathers did. And out of the other half: - 2/3 are the ones who say they are Muslims but inside they do not believe! They are forbidden to question the Quran, they are afraid. They are the misguided or the unguided ones. Only 1/3 of the half are true Muslims who follow by the Quran.

[sabpwin]

@ALMayda79 yea, people should read it with understanding in the language they know best .

[RSVR90]

@ALMayda79 AGREED!

[JustSivas58]

@ALMayda79 I don't entirely agree with you. You're stating that not knowing Arabic means you're not a good Muslim, that's very false.

[zbvvc]

@ALMayda79 forbidden to queation islam!? no we are not christans and the quran warns us to force annybody to islam like chrisitans did and actuly those who knows the meaning practice their religion much better.