But wait, your English probably isn't as good as mine. So you're not Han enough and you are not westernized enough. THEN WHAT ARE YOU? Today, Taiwan is more traditional than China. At the same time, we are also more modern than you. China is neither modern nor traditional. That's the tragedy of this whole situation. Yes, I know you will say we are BECOMING a modern nation. But that still doesn't make you white. Without REAL tradition, China is just paper tiger to the rest of the world.
How can you say oh look I have 56 different ethnic minority groups when these people don't even have any culture left because you wiped out their language. Then you say we pride ourselves in diversity? Cantonese and Hokkienese came from ancient Han language. If Han people lose their language then who are they? Mongols? Manchus? Then DON'T EVER call yourself a Han! Don't EVER use Confucius's name! Don't even bother changing Han writing to simplified. Just write in English, like me!
@5922846 So what, how much diversity can you have when Chinese govt try to make everyone speak mandarin. Just look at Hong Kong. They try to make the Cantonese speak Mandarin. Why don't YOU speak Cantonese? How about in Fujian? Young people don't know how to speak their own language. What is Mandarin? Mandarin is a fucking foreign language from the Manchus. Are you all slaves of the Manchus? Why is the capital in Beijing again? That's a Mongol city during Yuan dynasty!
@5922846 Then what are you talking about 56 different ethnic groups? In what way are they different? They have no unique culture, no unique language. It's all FAKE. All of China's culture today is FAKE. China's problem today is because it doesn't care about preserving REAL culture. You guys just make up a lot of FAKE things. Ok, that's fine. But I don't want to hear you guys call the language you speak Han language. Call it Beijing language or Manchu language.
@5922846 Cultural diversity indeed. You mean it's a Manchu/Mongol/Northern culture that is trying to wipe out all other cultures. Fucking communist tries to promote this fake northern culture they call Han culture. Go study ancient Han language and you will know what language they use in ancient China. Today, everything in China is FAKE! People dressing up in colorful cheap costume. That's what you call diversity? Where is the tradition?? It's so disgusting!
很欣賞原住民文化！讚！
zinc12185 2 weeks ago
我是原住民 過去是過去 現在是現在 不計較過去仇恨 只在乎我們都是台灣人 不分你我的一家人
a25311892 3 months ago
@minglian0212 台灣原民算是在地最草根的文化吧! 被罵不被尊重也是應該的...，你所謂的多元就是少了認同，就是因為不認同才會忽視這項文化...，想到忘了放上原民文化才急就章的請原民到世博跳跳舞露面? 由此可見，我們的政府是多麼的尊敬台灣的弱勢族群...順道一提，新住民與原住民是有很大的差別的先生~在我的觀點來看，你就是所謂的新住民啊~難不成你是原住民喔!? 美國的族群更多元...也不乏很多的台灣新移民在哪裡，你的意思是...如果台灣人通通移民到美國去，美國就會把台灣特色放在他的文化中來做宣傳嗎?聽不懂你的論述耶~~這樣有道理嗎?
TaipeiDidi 11 months ago
@minglian0212 我的身分是原民，看了你的觀點說實在的很令我不以為意...台灣所有"原住民族"的人口比例佔總人口數的46/1，也就是2300萬中只佔了區區50萬人...多數的原住民部落都身在偏遠及教育資源極為貧乏的山區，為什麼原住民族都生活在山區裡?太多歷史因素因為複雜就不多做闡述...但可以很肯定的告訴你並非原民所願意的!我要提的是，原民是社會中長期的弱勢族群是不爭的事實，至今仍是!台灣有多少部落可以跟神木村一樣享有你所謂的"高品質建設"?溪頭內湖國小因921重建的美輪美奐也要說的好像原民吃盡了甜頭一般，你要不要自己的家鄉被震的一踏糊塗之後再來幫你重建啊?下面的朋友說的真的一點都不差...虧你還是台灣人，如果不懂得原民就不要胡亂做出這樣無知的評論，你若願意繼續用你這樣膚淺的理論來跟我辯論，我只能告訴你自己省省吧~不要再做笑話給你看了!做好功課再來跟人辯論吧!
TaipeiDidi 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
闽南人不知道杀了多少原住民
但早在吳沙帶著漢人開墾宜蘭平原之前，噶瑪蘭人農耕範圍已遍及各 地，吳沙所率領的「羅漢腳仔」只能找較為偏僻的地方墾拓。故漢人 以許多手法，侵占噶瑪蘭族的土地。例如將死貓、死狗丟入噶瑪蘭族 的田地，使噶瑪蘭族因覺得不吉利而放棄田地。或是暗夜推移田埂， 使噶瑪蘭人的田地縮減。漢人種種欺壓行為，終於迫使噶瑪蘭族往花 東遷移[2]。
kickong 1 year ago
@minglian0212
不管你讲什么，台湾的原住民都是台湾最弱势最贫困的一群居民，不过是霸道的福佬人为了向外面显示台湾有多么的多元的花瓶而已，他们付出和得到的差很多，如果你不能理解这点那就当我没说好了
5922846 1 year ago
@5922846 我同意你的觀點朋友! 我本身為台灣泰雅族的青年，台灣原民現今仍是你所認知的弱勢族群，但我要跟你分享一個觀點，多數的原住民族(全世界)因為沒有發展出屬於自己的文字，所以多以口傳文化為主!原民各項文化的體現也因而以舞蹈及傳統歌謠方式做文化的傳承!當然還包括了樂器..服飾...圖騰等等....我之所以這麼提，是因為我不能認同你所謂的"花瓶"觀點，因為原民展現歌舞的同時，也就等同在宣揚自己族群的文化，這對資源相對弱勢的我們來說，無疑不是一種自我宣傳的大好機會!拿一個台灣最近的廣告來舉例，台灣LUXGEN車商用了台灣原民卑南族的音樂來做品牌廣告，因為原民歌手紀曉君(曾拿下台灣金曲歌后)優美的原民古調，意外的造成網路大家瘋狂的點閱，因為一首歌曲讓更多人真正的想開始認識原民進而彼此了解到認同，車商也因此達到了他想要的廣告效應，是一舉兩得最成功的寫照! 現今台灣原民仍不斷努力在提倡自己的文化，我想所謂的多元也要包含認同，如果無法認同就談不上尊重! 這是我們一直在努力的點，也希望我們台灣的政府，能有一天真正的來看待我們這些弱勢的族群~~
TaipeiDidi 11 months ago
@TaipeiDidi 加油吧！不过台湾本来就是你们原住民的，干嘛养那么多闽南沙猪，这些垃圾把原本属于你们的土地据为己有，屠杀你们的祖先，把你们赶到山上，还不要脸的说自己是正港的台湾人，见过不要脸的，没见过像台巴这么不要脸，你们也太随遇而安了吧，把闽南杀猪敢出台湾，夺回你们的土地吧！
5922846 10 months ago
@5922846 謝謝! 沒有想過要奪回土地這事，因為那是不可能的事... 只希望大家所謂的多元文化，能多給原住民族一點尊重就夠了! 事過境遷... 我們只想在這片土地上好好的生活並延續自己的文化!
TaipeiDidi 10 months ago
But wait, your English probably isn't as good as mine. So you're not Han enough and you are not westernized enough. THEN WHAT ARE YOU? Today, Taiwan is more traditional than China. At the same time, we are also more modern than you. China is neither modern nor traditional. That's the tragedy of this whole situation. Yes, I know you will say we are BECOMING a modern nation. But that still doesn't make you white. Without REAL tradition, China is just paper tiger to the rest of the world.
raininthesouth 1 year ago
How can you say oh look I have 56 different ethnic minority groups when these people don't even have any culture left because you wiped out their language. Then you say we pride ourselves in diversity? Cantonese and Hokkienese came from ancient Han language. If Han people lose their language then who are they? Mongols? Manchus? Then DON'T EVER call yourself a Han! Don't EVER use Confucius's name! Don't even bother changing Han writing to simplified. Just write in English, like me!
raininthesouth 1 year ago
是多元的文化之美还是花瓶，大陆有56个民族，比你们多元！
5922846 1 year ago
@5922846 So what, how much diversity can you have when Chinese govt try to make everyone speak mandarin. Just look at Hong Kong. They try to make the Cantonese speak Mandarin. Why don't YOU speak Cantonese? How about in Fujian? Young people don't know how to speak their own language. What is Mandarin? Mandarin is a fucking foreign language from the Manchus. Are you all slaves of the Manchus? Why is the capital in Beijing again? That's a Mongol city during Yuan dynasty!
raininthesouth 1 year ago
@raininthesouth
讲什么语言很重要吗，世界上每年有几百种语言消失那有怎么样，语言就是用来交流的，只要能交流，用什么语言真的不重要！不管是广东话还是福建话，如果不能适应，消失也没有关系！
5922846 1 year ago
@5922846 Then what are you talking about 56 different ethnic groups? In what way are they different? They have no unique culture, no unique language. It's all FAKE. All of China's culture today is FAKE. China's problem today is because it doesn't care about preserving REAL culture. You guys just make up a lot of FAKE things. Ok, that's fine. But I don't want to hear you guys call the language you speak Han language. Call it Beijing language or Manchu language.
raininthesouth 1 year ago
@5922846 Cultural diversity indeed. You mean it's a Manchu/Mongol/Northern culture that is trying to wipe out all other cultures. Fucking communist tries to promote this fake northern culture they call Han culture. Go study ancient Han language and you will know what language they use in ancient China. Today, everything in China is FAKE! People dressing up in colorful cheap costume. That's what you call diversity? Where is the tradition?? It's so disgusting!
raininthesouth 1 year ago
怒赞！
etsyy 1 year ago
很有味道啊
赞
YouTuGood 1 year ago