Added: 4 years ago
From: old77bat
Views: 36,171
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (135)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Beznadzieja moim zdaniem .

  • Może nie tak wyjebane jak oryginał, ale fajne :)

  • siteul vostru nu apare pe prima pagina la search "magica" pe google. l-ati cam lasat in paragina. bine ca l-ati pus aici.

    iar doamna arata mai bine inainte sa se tunda :p

  • oh finalmente una che non fa figuaracce cantando canzoni dei within temptation e so quanto è difficile ice queen. brava! e naturalmente bravi anche i musicisti

  • Nothing will top the original. However, this is a pretty good remake of an awesome song. They dont try and add their own stuff to the song

  • she actually does a good job at singing this song > :)

  • suna foarte bine !! are voce faina tipa.

  • Well done, difficult one !

  • cool cover : )

  • Is very awesome! Our band is like yours we have female vocals but except we have male backing and a violinist to! Wish you guys would come to the uk and we would support ya! :)

  • Very nice cover indeed. Any upcoming tour?

  • both the original was good and this is too.... damn good cover

    i like magica and within temptation. didnt know that magica had covered this song...

    thanks for sharing :)

  • it is not a bad cover its pretty good, she obviosly has a classical training, maybe im wrong but she has a mezzo-soprano voice. This is way better than seeing annette trying to sing like tarja.

  • @polecat987 Anette is not trying to sing like Tarja *rolls eyes*

    But yea, Ana is a soprano

  • I think her voice stronger than Sharon's

  • WOW! Awsome!!!! Great!

  • Wauw it isn't that bad! You need a good voice to can do it :O

  • i'm a within temptation fan and i have to say this cover is good, despite the recording quality. very good voice and band.

  • Excellent Cover :)

  • da-o dreak pe Sharon. Ana e the best!

  • Coool but Sharon is better

  • Tell me, how many are like me in playing waaaaay too much elder scrolls or other shit, and thats why the name of this band made you click it. lol

  • @joelwinters100 - I can surely tell you that the guitar player of Magica is a fan of Morrowind & Oblivion

  • Well, I think she is not that bad. I like Sharon more but she is pretty good, too.

  • Thanks for the info, Amy 66654. I´ll try to find some music of them. I think they´re a very good band and I hope see them in concert someday in Spain.

  • Bravo! Superb cover! Desi vocea Anei este complet diferita de a lui Sharon, a reusit sa pastreze perfect tot "feeling-ul" melodiei! Nu zic asta pentru ca as fi nationalista, dar e printre cele mai bune cover-uri de acest gen pe care le-am vazut. :) Mai este unul superb facut de o alta trupa romaneasca dupa "Passion and the Opera" a formatiei Nightwish si care suna la fel de perfect. Astfel de trupa ma fac sa ma simt totusi putin mai atasata de tarisoara asta... :) Congratz!

  • This is spectacular! That voice gave me chills. Sharon would be very proud of you all! Bravo!

  • Great band. Where are they from?

  • @varnaevicen Romania! :D

  • very good cover. has vocal skills to cover any of nightwishes songs

  • Congratulations! Very good singer..

  • Soo good!

  • what a shame they didn`t give there own style

  • I've meant the song ;)

  • mwhaaa tipa canta mai bine ca Sharon den Adel ce tare:))))

  • aproape la fel de buni ca Within Temptation :)

    5 stele oricum

  • gooood WT cover^^

  • nice..!

  • It would be interesting seeing a Nightwish cover from Magica.

    I think Ana will be able to sing Tarja's songs..

  • Comment removed

  • Not bad! Prefer WT but very nice vocals.

  • This is a really good cover, but since the original is one of the best songs I know, this one still fades to be a feeble version. Sharon is a way better singer, and that says a lot, because the lady in this video is really good too.

  • Sharon sounds way much better live.

  • que lindos !

  • vream sa-i dau 5 stele, oricum... frumos!

  • This is good. :)

  • Ma nu stiu de ce dar de la mijlocu piesei i se aude mai bine vocea si canta chiar..fain

  • i love ana. So do i love sharon. And I Love when such great vocalists cover each other or sing in a duett. I think its kinda interesting =3

  • best ice queen cover!

  • Impressive!

    Para um cover eu dou nota 10!

    se pudesse por estrelas era 5 stars com certeza!

    Parabéns pela voz!

    Abraço

  • Pretty good, but the original is definantly better.

  • of course the original is better...specially the one recorded in studio :))

  • she sing better than the original!

  • You should listen better... No way better.

  • I hope this is a joke...

  • There is no question about which is better..after all it is a WT song. But Ana performs very good and does the song justice. They can keep their heads up high for this performance !

  • Comment removed

  • sunt mandra ca avem o astfel de trupa din tara noastra de rahat.

  • Pacat ca mai nimeni de pe aici nu a auzit de ea .

  • Really powerful, beautiful voice but I dont think it fits well with this song. The singer sounds trained where Sharon has more of a natural sound. It wouldnt be so much of a clash if the singer chose one or the other, but there are places in the song where she does the catches & characteristic technique sharon uses when drawling out longer notes and the two methods DONT fit well together. the parts where she does that sound awkward, but other than that and the boring stage presence, good cover

  • Fantastic cover! A hard song to sing but Ana does it nicely :)

  • very good cover

  • good cover, really good voice!!

  • very good cover, they really have the right sound

  • The sound is really terrible but for photo camera very good! :)

    Though I like it, Sharon's voice belongs to this song.

  • I love this version as much as the orignal. Please come to Australia...

  • this girl can sing (:

  • pretty good (:

    but it's a within temptation's song, so their version had to be better (:

    Well, i do like magica :D

  • muy buena version! recopada!!

  • Well that's the whole thing with covers, they don't have to sound like the originals, they have to be original ;)

  • take it for what it is, a very good cover. of course nobody can do it like sharon, that should go without saying, but some people are just too stupid and bring it up anyway.

  • Agree. Her voice in this cover remembers me of the girl vocalist of After Forever... I forgot her name lol!

  • Floor Jansen

  • Shes pretty good but no one can sing it like Sharon does. Very pretty though :)

  • Hmm ciudat, imi place WT dar Ice Queen nu imi place la ei. In schimb imi place in versiunea Magicilor la Ice Queen. Buna treaba, gasca! /,,/

  • prea tare!

  • a bad cover !!???? ahahahaha seriously some peoples have not good ears tssss perfect job !

  • Replace ??? Who wants to replace ?

  • I agree, why would Ana try to replace Sharons vocals. They have very different voices, I think Anas is trong and Sharons more.... soft. I think this is a great cover and I love Anas voice in this.

  • Agree... Dunno what he was trying to say though lol

  • actually it sounds very similar to sharon doing this live...if you don't know the difference between live and album versions, go back into your basement and stay there...

  • Don't be so arrogant...

  • I think it was well deserved criticism. much like all the futile blab about the new nightwish singer. It is a cover, not a carbon copy. If you do not know what you are talking about, say nothing instead.

  • Excelente cover, me encnata su voz, y la banda lo hace muy bien..lastima la calidad del video

  • Bah de ce nu canta astia ceea ce le trebuie lor?!

  • This is a very good cover, this song is very hard to do. But this group did a good job.

    Please come check out my cover of the song. :)

  • Oh, I love her voice. Im a big fan of Within Temptation, but this is a very nice cover. Usually i dont like Magica that much, they're too much power metal for me I suppose.

  • Ecellent! ana's voice is amazing and the band is just great

  • Awesome cover!!!

    You're a great guitar player Bat!!!

    =)

  • Haha thank you ! this song requires soo much skill :)) hahaha..but anyway it is a awesome composition.

  • i want her to cover nightwish song with tarja on it im sure it will kick ass good job dawg as randy jackson will say

  • :) as a matter of fact we did covers for "She is my sin" and "Nemo" but I don't know why we never recorded them on video :(.

  • man ceea ce va trebuie e un show mare si nu ca opening band...ceva ce sa va scoata la suprafata ! nightwish au inceput exact ca si voi ! puteti deveni ceva MONDIAL ! sunteti excelenti ! cum am mai zis ma facti mandra sa fiu din romanica. BRAVO !

  • asdf

  • She sings very well LIVE!Good band...

  • Pretty good power metal band,they did a great cover(but a video man...)Anyway i like them!Magica come to Serbia!We are near!

  • OMG!!!

    Is nice the way she sings Ice Queen

    I like more the W*T version... but even a W*T fan must admit that this version is completly awesome...

  • great cover, really it's not an easy song to sing...so Ana is really perfect, love definitively this band. Hope to see them soon in France.

  • Don't like it much...no one murder me :D

  • vreo sansa sa apareti in Timisoara? :D Eu vin!

  • Daca suntem invitati de vre-un club sau festival noi venim..Nu prea avem contacte in Timisoara..nu stim cine se ocupa cu organizarea de fest-uri

  • The singer trys to impress herself very good.

    YOU REALLY NEED THAT !

  • ? I don't understand what you are trying to say!

  • nvm anywayz ;p

  • best cover of wt,great voice ana...keep rocking magica!

  • 5/5 :) it`s better than the original song ;)

  • NO! I think its not exagerated, the voice and the other instruments give the song a new touch, it sounds different, than the WT-version, so its something special. Its my opinion to this song AND I LOVE THIS VERSION OF ICE QUEEN!!!!!!

  • OH WOW! Sounds great!! I think it sounds as good as the WITHIN TEMPTATION version!!!

    MAGICA- GREAT BAND!!!!!!

  • wow! let's not exagerate ! :)

  • 4/5 i dont like the tarja style singing

  • I will NOT allow stupid comments! If somebody has something to say they should explain it. When you only say :"It sucks"...it's stupid thing to do and I hate it. It's ok not to like something but that doesn't mean't sucks.Grow up !

  • hahaha, she turned it to a lovesong mode! jesus! its a rock song gurl! dont put a melody on it . .

  • Lovesong mode?... Sounds really good to me, there's no diffece between the singing style but the voice.

  • I mean, difference*, between the singing style...

  • the best cover of ice queen in the world! perfect!!

  • wow...all I can say is wow...I love Magica since Lightseeker and I still love em now :]

  • Ice Cream.... mmmmm.... :))

  • what does that have to do with anything?

  • it's just a word game

  • de ce nu ati fost printre invitati la artmania 2007 in deschidere la Within temptation?

  • Hmm.. accualy I prefer WT version of Ice Queen, but I think if it wouldn't be live record, it would be very, very nice too!

  • great cover,this song got me into within temptation, and this has got me into magica!

  • no sabeis que bien me siento al ver que os interesa magica:) a mi tambien me gustan muchisimo y espero su tercer album.

  • Magica...eeeee... de donde soys?¿ por que por el nombre...

  • La banda es Rumana. La cantante se llama Ana Mladinovich y llevan inactivos tras publicar 2 discos (the scroll of stone en el 2002 y Lightseeker en el 2004). Afortunadamente han firmado un contrato con el sello AFM records y el 19 de octubre de este año sale su nuevo disco titulado "Hereafter"

  • Absolutely amazing cover of Ice Queen! This song is very difficult to sing, and I think Ana is the only person who could sing it just as well as Sharon.

  • they must be huge WT fans :]

  • cant help but agree...Ana is an amazing singer...I wish one day they come to the US

  • NO WAY

  • :O!!!!

    8/5 stars

    genial!

  • cool,love WITHIN TEMPTATION AND MAGICA...they rule

  • great band and great cover. magica rulz

  • Nice, Magica dalways perform nice covers, like Nemo at Ninkasi Lyon (FR) ...

    But we are still waiting the new album !!!! come on !!!!

  • uuu...nice, very nice

  • Great Job! Rock On !

  • Best WT cover, great band ! You rock !

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more