Aside from all the talk of national influence this music is amazing and as an Englishman with Scots and Irish ancestry it makes me proud, as for the rest, this isle has ALWAYS been tribal in the extreme and regardless of english welsb scots or irish influences or anything else for that matter it will probably always remain tribally diverse
Is this song about a girl called Bhruinneallaigh? I hear them keep repeating that word, and it sounds like a name to me. I don't know Irish, but I have relatives in Ireland. In any case I like Liam's voice and he did a good job in the soundtrack for Ned Devine.
He sang this at Oranmore Celtic Shore Fest in Galway recently. He stopped and chatted to me after his outstanding performance. What a character! Nil ach aon Liam O'Maonlai!
Who can stand against this? - no external force, no army or malevolent spirit could ever encumber - They would lay down their arms to be wooed by perfection
I apologize so .. yunno You tube commenting should be done away with in my opinion - It just incites aggrevation misunderstanding and in some cases hatred - context is always lost
Wow, this is absolutely new for me. I'm from latin america, and I've only heard this musics on movies or tv, but I reaaaally liked it. I have no idea what it says and I don't quite understand what ppl are arguing about hehehe but I'm definitely gonna hear more of this music and when you decide whether if this is Irish, or Scotish or from Galway Ireland.. I'll read more about this culture :)
@EZEEKEEL It;s penny whistle tuned to C. whistles in D are more common in Irish music, but C whistles seem to be more popular in Scottish and English tunes. I happen to prefer the C whistle, not because I'm Scots, but because I have really big hands so the D whistle is not as comfortable for me.
@ethomson0 No that's definately not a Clark (I have a bunch). It looks like one of Paul Bushman's composite whistles tuned to C. They're expensive, but if "yer makin moony off'n it" then it's worth the $250. Just do a Google search on Paul Busman composite whistles and you should find them.
@Lilkong100 what a beautiful name - it just so happened that I was attending the inauguration f my daughters entry into the Bridgins that I heard a little one mention her name was Saidbh. I got to tell you that I wanted to shake the hands of the parents for taking a chance on rejuvinating our birthright.
It will be a sad, sad day if Gaelic dies. And I agree with Amanda. I grew up in the Maritimes, in Canada. Atlantic Canada is one of the last Bastions of Irish and Scots Gaelic langugae and culture. We make no distinction, as most came here before there was a major division between the two groups. I feel that the division was imposed by others and that is wht you dont see it here.
@RealCanuckian Nice honest opinion - it does go deeper but hey yunno you split that arrow in two and yer spot on - I am always amazed to see a documentary on newfees and hear them talk as if they were my next door neighbour - the division in Scotland and Ireland is not made by the Gaelach of either country because we have a blood tie and neither will deny the other - The Romans - I mean the British influence has made a division but the subject is too large for you tube
@linkinparkingra What is now the Gaelic language was brought to what is now Scotland by settlers from Ireland. Ireland and N Scotland formed a single cultural area until only a few centuries ago. The word Gael derives from a Welsh word meaning raider and originally referred to people from Ireland. The Romans called these raiders from Ireland Scoti.
@fartybraindeath You are absolutely correct - but politically today would you not agree as a result of this that the playing field has shifted somewhat - Scots want to be Scots - They don't see themselves as Irish and willl always deny that they are related - it's bizarre
Can you tell Liam thank you for the song "If you go". I have been playing it when I need to cry. My husband was killed by a car last week and in a coma. Life support was switched off on Tuesday. I t really helps that I can cry my heart out to this song...away from my little kids Cian and Emily. Music is sometimes a blessing. Please thank him for me. X Claire
I learned Irish from this man. Unfortunately it's not that helpful because there is no books with it for the spelling. He says so himself "There are no books required for this course" I disagree with that. We need to know the spelling.
Why is he pronouncing the name that way? What's his dialect? Can't figure it out... He's saying what can be approximated as 'how' but it's pronounced 'Sive'...
@Sadhbhishness its pronounced differently throughout the country. Sadbha is how its spelt in my area, pronounced "sawa" or "a hawa" when you are calling her name or talking directly to her. "Sive" is an english version of the gaelic name. Hope this helps!
LOL. I have the same CD, but had not opened it. When I bought it either I didn't know what I was doing or thought it was music. However, if it's that "sultry", I suddenly feel an overwhelming urge to learn Gaelic.
not as crazy as you might think Lochbesda16 - most of our early American folk songs originated from the Celts and Acadians that immigrated to the Colonies. Songs like this are every bit the forebearers of our American folk tradition, and as such still tugs at the hearts of modern audiences. :)
lol... it's not crazy at all... look where the ancestry in Appalachia and others comes from... Certainly American immigrants didn't just magically invent 'new sounds'. They reached into their collective cultural memory.
The gents and the missies, young and not so alike, all look like they're having a happy time of it with this tune. I guess it's one of those that can bring people together and re-unite a common heritage. Music does that to people. A shared love of the music keeps my mum and pop's families from getting on a row with one another. Me mum and her family are from the Northern Counties of Ireland, pop and his are from county Midlothan, Scotland with me being the only yank among the whole lot.
I love Liam! Want to hear something,listen to him singing with the Black family on 'North Country' on a song called 'Grey Dusk of Eve' sooooo haunting. Just perfect!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
So long as you all know this is Irish and not Scottish, enough of that shit going on, just like the Uilleann Pipes of Braveheart!!! Go raibh maith agatsa. Tabhair aire don ceol, cultur, an dteanga agus an Tir. Nil cead ag aon duine eile ghoid ar cultur.
Yes, well it's a Gaelic song, as much as that classifies as a 'Scottish' song. Some may disagree on that point.
Mícheál Ó Domhnaill did a lot of collecting of songs from the Western Isles and Hebrides.
To clarify, I don't make as clear a distinction between Gaelic culture in Scotland and Ireland. I don't think the divisiveness imposed by competitive nationalisms helps the cause of Gaelic. This clip comes from a show that sought to show the links and richness of all Gaelic music.
I couldn't agree with you more! I've maintained for a long time that the Scots and Irish are the basically same people separated by a strip of water and the political developments of the last few hundred years or so. I'm not a Gaelic scholar, aren't the dialects bascially a contiuum from Southern Ireland through to the the Islands and Highlands of Scotland?
The only difference might be that the Celts who moved to Scotland mixed with the Picts to a large extent to form a slightly different nation from Ireland. Discuss!
I might give you that. A different flavour of Gael (just like the Manx are yet another flavour). But I'm under the impression that we don't really know much about the Picts (language/culture) and other groups that lived in the area that's now Scotland and Northern England. But really we do better by looking at what we have in common.
I reckon scholars are divided as to whether the Picts were of Celtic origin or native Scots descended from the iron age folks who lived here before them.
As Columba, a Celt himself, needed an interpreter to talk to the Picts, it is thought perhaps their language was not Celtic in origin.
Whatever, the Picts were the biggest influence, ruling the east and north of Scotland in loose bands that were never truly united. A fascinating people who we'll likely never know the whole story.
I know that there is continuity in the music, from back when the gallowglasses (Norse-Scottish soldiers) settled in Northern Ireland/County Donegal. Donegal is one of the few places in Ireland where people play strathspeys, a Scottish tune.
@amandaberesford - Its quite Obvious that you don't understand the lyrics! - This is a song from Galway Ireland and I'm afraid that you are very wrong - not that it is very important but it is most definitely NOT a Scottish song - sorry
Sorry. I don't think you followed the earlier discussion. I am not speaking of the song Liam is singing. I was responding to another comment. I clearly stated that the song I was referring to was the Bothy Band's version of Fionnaghuala, which Mícheál Ó Domhnaill picked up in the Hebrides.
@amandaberesford I would totally agree with what what you are saying but your wrong in saying that this historically a scottish song - it's from the west of Ireland
@amandaberesford I'm sorry I don't think I read your original post - Scottish / Irish ... same thing anyway - just changed a little over time - I love Scottish lilts and airs but what is forgotten is that a lot of them ... not all of them but some of them .... have their roots in Irish history and music migratory to the gaelic part of Scotland - and it just annoys me that that is not remembered. It is with great respect that I recognize that the Gael are very strong in Scotland and continue to
Yes, as someone with predominantly Scottish Gaelic ancestry, but also Irish ancestry from Munster, I concur. I am actually really glad that there are Gael's from both Ireland and Scotland developing more of an interest in each other. I think one of the obstacles for both communities is seeing and hearing each other through English mediums. Hopefully the cultural linkages will also extend on the linguistic side.
Who cares where its from, its a great song. I think perhaps you should spend more time perfecting your Irish grammar than writing nonsense on youtube....Níl aon difir idir na Gaeil, cé acu Alabanaigh nó Éireannaigh iad.
Thats a fair point hivesrock - I think a lot of people and I include myself feel very protective of these traditions for a lot of reasons that aren't worthy to indulge here - but fair play - You're absolutely right
TomT, THANK YOU for posting this wonderful music. This is the 1st one I heard. I've heard many since. I think this music is in my blood. I found Liam's my space & the language lessions, maybe I can learn it. Thanks Again.
Gabh mo leithsceal ach nil aon ach moran Gaeilge agam anois agus is feidir liom comhra as Bearla.. I think that the box the man does be playing is similar to one in which there is springs/wire not too far removed from the snare drum. I've seen such similar instruments in folk music and strangely enough, flamenco. You generally find they double up as a seat on which the player sits as well. Anyhoo, just a thought. Beir bua ;-)
Is e instrument ceart os Spain, an bosca ata an fear sin ag seinm . Bionn a lan ceolteori flamenco ag usaid an bosca seo chun sort 'rhythm' difriuil a dheanamh. Anois, bfhearr le a lan ceoltoiri traidisiunta a usaid an bosca seo no an bodhran, chun rhythm nua a cruthaionn sa ceol traidisuinta. Mar shampla, usaideann Kila an bosca seo i gcupla amhriann.
the album version isnt as great as this version because hear he actually sounds like an old sailor that is singing about a girl. the album version is good but just sounds so produced.
THanks for your comments. This is a powerfull performance and sounds slightly African. However, this type of "call and response" is quite common in Celtic music. A search for "highland sessions" will find other examples.
Aside from all the talk of national influence this music is amazing and as an Englishman with Scots and Irish ancestry it makes me proud, as for the rest, this isle has ALWAYS been tribal in the extreme and regardless of english welsb scots or irish influences or anything else for that matter it will probably always remain tribally diverse
MrCeallaigh 1 month ago
fab!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
gaelicflower33 1 month ago
The tune they play after the song...I believe it's called Out On the Ocean, if anybody's interested.
NolanBryanLynch 1 month ago in playlist Highland Sessions
is deas liom an cajon!
cmacd505 1 month ago
no her first name is Sadhbh ( usually pronounced as 'si-ev' but he pronounces it as- 'sow' like how, and her surname is Ní Bhruinneallaigh
caitin55 2 months ago
Is this song about a girl called Bhruinneallaigh? I hear them keep repeating that word, and it sounds like a name to me. I don't know Irish, but I have relatives in Ireland. In any case I like Liam's voice and he did a good job in the soundtrack for Ned Devine.
guyfihi 3 months ago
@guyfihi Yes Saidbh Ni Bhruineallaigh is a Girls name First name and last name and its a song of Courtship
SPAREPARTSCENTRE 2 months ago
Hey, what is the tune he plays at the end of the whistle? Thanks.
stcefce 4 months ago
Irish music is GREAT
d777md 4 months ago
He sang this at Oranmore Celtic Shore Fest in Galway recently. He stopped and chatted to me after his outstanding performance. What a character! Nil ach aon Liam O'Maonlai!
SH3RIFF187 5 months ago
@SH3RIFF187 force of nature
SPAREPARTSCENTRE 2 months ago
Who can stand against this? - no external force, no army or malevolent spirit could ever encumber - They would lay down their arms to be wooed by perfection
SPAREPARTSCENTRE 6 months ago
I apologize so .. yunno You tube commenting should be done away with in my opinion - It just incites aggrevation misunderstanding and in some cases hatred - context is always lost
SPAREPARTSCENTRE 6 months ago
Wow, this is absolutely new for me. I'm from latin america, and I've only heard this musics on movies or tv, but I reaaaally liked it. I have no idea what it says and I don't quite understand what ppl are arguing about hehehe but I'm definitely gonna hear more of this music and when you decide whether if this is Irish, or Scotish or from Galway Ireland.. I'll read more about this culture :)
natty71991 6 months ago
Goes right in the heart... what can I say...
angelabinu 10 months ago
Níl ach aon Liam Ó Maonlaí!!!
hEireannSeanan 1 year ago
Ah my mind is slowly exploding with class from the awesomeness of this!
Jabberwocky010 1 year ago
What type of whistle does he use towards the end!!??!?! Please msg me the answer! :D lol
EZEEKEEL 1 year ago
@EZEEKEEL It's called a penny whistle.
citizenfitz 1 year ago
@EZEEKEEL It;s penny whistle tuned to C. whistles in D are more common in Irish music, but C whistles seem to be more popular in Scottish and English tunes. I happen to prefer the C whistle, not because I'm Scots, but because I have really big hands so the D whistle is not as comfortable for me.
ethomson0 11 months ago
@ethomson0 Do you happen to know what make this tin whistle is? Is it a clarkes?!
EZEEKEEL 9 months ago
@ethomson0 No that's definately not a Clark (I have a bunch). It looks like one of Paul Bushman's composite whistles tuned to C. They're expensive, but if "yer makin moony off'n it" then it's worth the $250. Just do a Google search on Paul Busman composite whistles and you should find them.
ethomson0 7 months ago
And hello to you, Piardog from Bearrnabas up in the North. It's a great song.
bearrnabas 1 year ago
my name is sadhbh
Lilkong100 1 year ago
@Lilkong100 what a beautiful name - it just so happened that I was attending the inauguration f my daughters entry into the Bridgins that I heard a little one mention her name was Saidbh. I got to tell you that I wanted to shake the hands of the parents for taking a chance on rejuvinating our birthright.
SPAREPARTSCENTRE 2 months ago
It will be a sad, sad day if Gaelic dies. And I agree with Amanda. I grew up in the Maritimes, in Canada. Atlantic Canada is one of the last Bastions of Irish and Scots Gaelic langugae and culture. We make no distinction, as most came here before there was a major division between the two groups. I feel that the division was imposed by others and that is wht you dont see it here.
RealCanuckian 1 year ago
@RealCanuckian Nice honest opinion - it does go deeper but hey yunno you split that arrow in two and yer spot on - I am always amazed to see a documentary on newfees and hear them talk as if they were my next door neighbour - the division in Scotland and Ireland is not made by the Gaelach of either country because we have a blood tie and neither will deny the other - The Romans - I mean the British influence has made a division but the subject is too large for you tube
SPAREPARTSCENTRE 2 months ago
Tá an fear seo ag teacht chuig ár scoil amarach
friel1234567890 1 year ago
I am deep impressed!!!!! How strong Gàidhlig is :-) Still today and forever :-)
chakotay1965 1 year ago
I hate when people call Irish, or things associated Gaelic. The Irish language is not called Gaelic!
linkinparkingra 1 year ago
@linkinparkingra Dont be daft. What other word is there to describe the shared culture between the celtic parts of Irland and Scotland? Burn
gary06uk 1 year ago
@linkinparkingra
It is, the clue is in the name "Gaeilge"
TheCrosaidi 1 year ago
@linkinparkingra What is now the Gaelic language was brought to what is now Scotland by settlers from Ireland. Ireland and N Scotland formed a single cultural area until only a few centuries ago. The word Gael derives from a Welsh word meaning raider and originally referred to people from Ireland. The Romans called these raiders from Ireland Scoti.
fartybraindeath 1 year ago 2
@fartybraindeath You are absolutely correct - but politically today would you not agree as a result of this that the playing field has shifted somewhat - Scots want to be Scots - They don't see themselves as Irish and willl always deny that they are related - it's bizarre
SPAREPARTSCENTRE 2 months ago
It sounds like every so often he's says the word 'sausages'.
gary06uk 1 year ago
Liam is a frikkin legend. What a performer. Savage stuff.
squiresfan 1 year ago
i am greek..and i love everything irish but most of all their music..must be a previous soul or something..lol
MERILYNMO 1 year ago
Irish soul music! Makes you homsesick for Ireland even if you've never been there.
citizenfitz 1 year ago
@citizenfitz ridiculous comment
FadoIrishPub 1 year ago
@FadoIrishPub Really? How so?
citizenfitz 1 year ago
@citizenfitz How can you be home sick for somewhere you have never been? Just doesn't make sense.
FadoIrishPub 1 year ago
@FadoIrishPub Not to you perhaps. But I'm sure there are others who understand.
citizenfitz 1 year ago
@FadoIrishPub you horrible bastard...haha... why would you just cuss someone for loving a style of music...i bet your not even irish lol
lsdvine 1 year ago
he lives 2 minutes away from me ! im best friends with his son cian !
orangejuicedrink 1 year ago
@orangejuicedrink
Can you tell Liam thank you for the song "If you go". I have been playing it when I need to cry. My husband was killed by a car last week and in a coma. Life support was switched off on Tuesday. I t really helps that I can cry my heart out to this song...away from my little kids Cian and Emily. Music is sometimes a blessing. Please thank him for me. X Claire
luxy651 1 year ago
I know Liam and will pass that on. And our thoughts are with you as we connect with what you're saying here. God bless. Strenght from music a chara.
mrbrianquinn 1 year ago
LOVE IT>> LOVE LIAM..... ID marry him tommorow......pure magical genius...
lornafleur123 1 year ago
Tá sé go maith ag canadh
tá sé ag canadh faoi mo ainm
:) XxX
sadhbh1234 1 year ago
I learned Irish from this man. Unfortunately it's not that helpful because there is no books with it for the spelling. He says so himself "There are no books required for this course" I disagree with that. We need to know the spelling.
MusicIsMyLife6991 1 year ago
ní caithigh tú níor úsáid mé leabhar
sadhbh1234 1 year ago
@MusicIsMyLife6991
Google- Liam Ó Maonlaí Irish Independent - and you will get the transcripts the transcripts are in pdf format, thees 2 of them, dl them
TheCrosaidi 1 year ago
@TheCrosaidi - Thank you so much!
MusicIsMyLife6991 1 year ago
'Sé an t-ainm ceart 'tá ar an 'drum-box' sin ná 'cajon'
turd121 2 years ago
kind of reminds me of lyle lovett both in voice and looks, except i cant understand any of it. maybe thats why hahaha
jeremyhillaryboobphd 2 years ago
The man is a genius
TheBobbymagee 2 years ago 5
fab !!! just discoverin this fella, oh his singing irish songs especially give ya shivers!!!!
gaelicflower33 1 month ago
Why is he pronouncing the name that way? What's his dialect? Can't figure it out... He's saying what can be approximated as 'how' but it's pronounced 'Sive'...
Sadhbhishness 2 years ago
@Sadhbhishness its pronounced differently throughout the country. Sadbha is how its spelt in my area, pronounced "sawa" or "a hawa" when you are calling her name or talking directly to her. "Sive" is an english version of the gaelic name. Hope this helps!
thehivesrock 2 years ago
its pronounced sive
sadhbh1234 1 year ago
@sadhbh1234
Sow in conamara, sive in munster
TheCrosaidi 1 year ago
Comment removed
fleminnj 2 years ago
I have a CD of Liam teaching how to speak Irish Gaelic. His voice is so calm and cool and sultry . . . like he's trying to seduce you. . .
SSJCuchulainn 2 years ago 6
LOL. I have the same CD, but had not opened it. When I bought it either I didn't know what I was doing or thought it was music. However, if it's that "sultry", I suddenly feel an overwhelming urge to learn Gaelic.
Legaleze50 2 years ago
@SSJCuchulainn yes I also have it.
The CD teaches me in parts of lesson, began with "Dia dhuit."
:)
Joy133597 2 months ago
go hÁlainn ar fad.
Ní iarrfainn de spré le Sadhbh Ní Bhruinnealla
ach Baile Inis Gé is cead éalú ar choinníní.
Curfá:
Óra a Shadhbh, a Shadhbh Ní Bhruinnealla,
A chuisle is a stóirín, éalaigh is imigh liom.
Fear maith i mbád mé togha fear iomraimh
Fear sluaisid' is láí ar dhá cheann an iomaire.
Frankieireland 2 years ago 2
Real Irish folk music: sea chanty performed really well here.
bookkeeper57 2 years ago
Even Liam O,M moving and dancing are Indian like!
mrlennyman 2 years ago
it's crazy how much this sounds like some American hymnals that you would hear in the south and in Appalchia.
Lochbesda16 2 years ago
not as crazy as you might think Lochbesda16 - most of our early American folk songs originated from the Celts and Acadians that immigrated to the Colonies. Songs like this are every bit the forebearers of our American folk tradition, and as such still tugs at the hearts of modern audiences. :)
heatherwind 2 years ago
true dat
kingofdaherbz 2 years ago
lol... it's not crazy at all... look where the ancestry in Appalachia and others comes from... Certainly American immigrants didn't just magically invent 'new sounds'. They reached into their collective cultural memory.
ORAquabat 2 years ago 2
Působivé!
papajaga 2 years ago
agus an-bhlas Gaeilge ata ag an bhfear seo
Ghrathas 2 years ago
I'm sorry. I accidentally clicked the thumbs down thing. I ment the thumbs up. XP
PastryMagician420 2 years ago 3
thank you for sharing!
yourstory08 2 years ago
music for the soul
donivendetta 2 years ago 3
Amazing song share!! Thank you!
2allpeace 2 years ago
I absolutely love this, gives me goosepimples, and all the Highland Sessions, but how can you get hold of the CDs, do they exist anymore?
Mossandmeg 2 years ago
you will find more ike this on my channel
:)
cosinbrother 2 years ago
Well, better ' throw' on a pot of 'tea- this Cape Breton'er is coming over! (lol)
Gillhoolee 2 years ago
welcome cousin, its brewed! :)
cosinbrother 2 years ago
Good stuff!- You know we like it brewed 'strong enough to stand on'. eh.?
Seriously , thank you for the great site and the effort you must have put into it.
Regards
Gillhoolee 2 years ago
The gents and the missies, young and not so alike, all look like they're having a happy time of it with this tune. I guess it's one of those that can bring people together and re-unite a common heritage. Music does that to people. A shared love of the music keeps my mum and pop's families from getting on a row with one another. Me mum and her family are from the Northern Counties of Ireland, pop and his are from county Midlothan, Scotland with me being the only yank among the whole lot.
ljbabysprite 2 years ago 4
My god! That is such an amazing song. One of the best I've heard. Goes straight to my heart. =]
PastryMagician420 2 years ago 3
Handsome guy!! As great as the song!
Laulanmad 3 years ago
Name of tune is tiocfaidh tu abhaile liom (you will come home with me)
alanbreathnach 3 years ago
Hi...Briar again...I meant The Rankin Family...forgive the space out.
Chastalard 3 years ago
I love Liam! Want to hear something,listen to him singing with the Black family on 'North Country' on a song called 'Grey Dusk of Eve' sooooo haunting. Just perfect!
Chastalard 3 years ago
i love this!!
Kinger00010 3 years ago
What is the name of the tune he plays on the whistle.
johnnycoolman 3 years ago
It's called "Banish Misfortune" I think. They always play it at weddings around here...
thehivesrock 2 years ago
It's actually Tiocfaidh Tú Abhaile Liom, Will you come home with me.
Kilfarboy 2 years ago
liam o maonlai is a very nice guy,
seesnap 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
So long as you all know this is Irish and not Scottish, enough of that shit going on, just like the Uilleann Pipes of Braveheart!!! Go raibh maith agatsa. Tabhair aire don ceol, cultur, an dteanga agus an Tir. Nil cead ag aon duine eile ghoid ar cultur.
hallion12 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Petty, petty. typical anglo-nationalist.
amandaberesford 3 years ago
And what "shit" would you actually be referring to? Maybe like Bothy Band "borrowing" Fionnaghuala?
amandaberesford 3 years ago
Is Fionnaguala a Scottish song?
mhicnanolc 3 years ago
Yes, well it's a Gaelic song, as much as that classifies as a 'Scottish' song. Some may disagree on that point.
Mícheál Ó Domhnaill did a lot of collecting of songs from the Western Isles and Hebrides.
To clarify, I don't make as clear a distinction between Gaelic culture in Scotland and Ireland. I don't think the divisiveness imposed by competitive nationalisms helps the cause of Gaelic. This clip comes from a show that sought to show the links and richness of all Gaelic music.
amandaberesford 3 years ago 19
I couldn't agree with you more! I've maintained for a long time that the Scots and Irish are the basically same people separated by a strip of water and the political developments of the last few hundred years or so. I'm not a Gaelic scholar, aren't the dialects bascially a contiuum from Southern Ireland through to the the Islands and Highlands of Scotland?
mhicnanolc 3 years ago 6
The only difference might be that the Celts who moved to Scotland mixed with the Picts to a large extent to form a slightly different nation from Ireland. Discuss!
nacho1560 3 years ago
I might give you that. A different flavour of Gael (just like the Manx are yet another flavour). But I'm under the impression that we don't really know much about the Picts (language/culture) and other groups that lived in the area that's now Scotland and Northern England. But really we do better by looking at what we have in common.
mhicnanolc 3 years ago
I reckon scholars are divided as to whether the Picts were of Celtic origin or native Scots descended from the iron age folks who lived here before them.
As Columba, a Celt himself, needed an interpreter to talk to the Picts, it is thought perhaps their language was not Celtic in origin.
Whatever, the Picts were the biggest influence, ruling the east and north of Scotland in loose bands that were never truly united. A fascinating people who we'll likely never know the whole story.
nacho1560 3 years ago
I know that there is continuity in the music, from back when the gallowglasses (Norse-Scottish soldiers) settled in Northern Ireland/County Donegal. Donegal is one of the few places in Ireland where people play strathspeys, a Scottish tune.
Ceibhfhionn 2 years ago
@amandaberesford - Its quite Obvious that you don't understand the lyrics! - This is a song from Galway Ireland and I'm afraid that you are very wrong - not that it is very important but it is most definitely NOT a Scottish song - sorry
SPAREPARTSCENTRE 9 months ago
@SPAREPARTSCENTRE
Sorry. I don't think you followed the earlier discussion. I am not speaking of the song Liam is singing. I was responding to another comment. I clearly stated that the song I was referring to was the Bothy Band's version of Fionnaghuala, which Mícheál Ó Domhnaill picked up in the Hebrides.
amandaberesford 9 months ago
@amandaberesford I would totally agree with what what you are saying but your wrong in saying that this historically a scottish song - it's from the west of Ireland
SPAREPARTSCENTRE 6 months ago
@SPAREPARTSCENTRE
I'm not claiming that the song that Liam is singing here is Scottish. I mentioned the song I was referring to in my original post.
amandaberesford 2 months ago
@amandaberesford I'm sorry I don't think I read your original post - Scottish / Irish ... same thing anyway - just changed a little over time - I love Scottish lilts and airs but what is forgotten is that a lot of them ... not all of them but some of them .... have their roots in Irish history and music migratory to the gaelic part of Scotland - and it just annoys me that that is not remembered. It is with great respect that I recognize that the Gael are very strong in Scotland and continue to
SPAREPARTSCENTRE 2 months ago
@SPAREPARTSCENTRE
Yes, as someone with predominantly Scottish Gaelic ancestry, but also Irish ancestry from Munster, I concur. I am actually really glad that there are Gael's from both Ireland and Scotland developing more of an interest in each other. I think one of the obstacles for both communities is seeing and hearing each other through English mediums. Hopefully the cultural linkages will also extend on the linguistic side.
amandaberesford 2 months ago
"enough of that shit going on, just like the Uilleann Pipes of Braveheart!!!"
You might want to look up the shared tradition of the pastoral pipes and union pipes of Both scotland and Ireland!
seonidh 3 years ago
Who cares where its from, its a great song. I think perhaps you should spend more time perfecting your Irish grammar than writing nonsense on youtube....Níl aon difir idir na Gaeil, cé acu Alabanaigh nó Éireannaigh iad.
thehivesrock 2 years ago 13
Thats a fair point hivesrock - I think a lot of people and I include myself feel very protective of these traditions for a lot of reasons that aren't worthy to indulge here - but fair play - You're absolutely right
Munchhurdle 2 years ago
@thehivesrock Aontaim leat. Mar sin fein ta difriocht beag idir Alabanaigh agus Eireannaigh !
Neamhchodladh 3 months ago
TomT, THANK YOU for posting this wonderful music. This is the 1st one I heard. I've heard many since. I think this music is in my blood. I found Liam's my space & the language lessions, maybe I can learn it. Thanks Again.
GenPerk 3 years ago 3
Tá an ceol go hiontacht!
SaorEire 3 years ago 3
Ceol galánta. An bhfuil fhios ag einne cad é an bosca atá an fear sin ag seinim? An instrument ceart é nó just bosca? GRMA.
mairtor 3 years ago 2
Gabh mo leithsceal ach nil aon ach moran Gaeilge agam anois agus is feidir liom comhra as Bearla.. I think that the box the man does be playing is similar to one in which there is springs/wire not too far removed from the snare drum. I've seen such similar instruments in folk music and strangely enough, flamenco. You generally find they double up as a seat on which the player sits as well. Anyhoo, just a thought. Beir bua ;-)
Uaigneach78 3 years ago 4
apologies on the terrible irish grammer but:
Is e instrument ceart os Spain, an bosca ata an fear sin ag seinm . Bionn a lan ceolteori flamenco ag usaid an bosca seo chun sort 'rhythm' difriuil a dheanamh. Anois, bfhearr le a lan ceoltoiri traidisiunta a usaid an bosca seo no an bodhran, chun rhythm nua a cruthaionn sa ceol traidisuinta. Mar shampla, usaideann Kila an bosca seo i gcupla amhriann.
fleminnj 2 years ago
gaeilge maith. maithiú. is breá liom an bosca sin. is amhráin an deas é seo.
Frankieireland 2 years ago
Fìor direach alainn!
caileaniain 3 years ago 3
Thar cionn! Amhrán álainn is ea é
murrayp4 3 years ago 2
peacefull i like listen to it non stop lol
txgirl115 3 years ago 4
I am really struggling with the lyrics! But I love the sound. Quality.
RockoKnobski 4 years ago
I can't stop replaying this!
IfanSaer 4 years ago 8
This version is fantastic. The album version is great as well, but I prefer this one, now I've heard it! Gorgeous song!
TwoSkirts 4 years ago 5
Really like this too - these Highland Sessions were brilliant!
tomtscotland 4 years ago 3
You're absolutely right on!
technonana 3 years ago
HOW DO WE GET LEGIT COPUES OF THIS MUSIC - IT'S FANTASTIC !!! GenPerk
GenPerk 3 years ago
buy liam o'maonlai's album - Rian - it is magical...
zapawarrior 3 years ago 4
Bought it last night after seeing him do a gig up in Armagh..it is indeed magical mate :-D
CBigMac31 2 years ago
@tomtscotland
Tom, what is the status on the Transatlantic sessions? Are there anymore in the queue?
JMD0429 1 year ago
the album version isnt as great as this version because hear he actually sounds like an old sailor that is singing about a girl. the album version is good but just sounds so produced.
Lotrfan99 4 years ago
beautiful music have to say proud to be irish american and is it just me or does he look like dane cook with a dublin accent
Lotrfan99 4 years ago 2
A Stiofáin.
Chuir mé r-phost chugat leis na liricí. Bain sult as, a mhac.
Claíomh.
Uaigneach78 4 years ago
Please help me understand the language. I would love to comment!
technonana 3 years ago
I love this song so much I bought his album...
I want more like this.
Jesjes1 4 years ago
beautiful man, beautiful voice !!!
ellenfar 4 years ago
An bhfuil fhois ag aon duine, cár fhaigheann mé na liricí don amhrán seo??
Anyone know where I can find or get the lyrics/tablature for this song?? Please!
stiofain1979 4 years ago
Rinne mé iarracht teacht orthú agus nílim :(
Jesjes1 4 years ago
Maith an fear, a Liam. Is maith liom do ghuth.
Uaigneach78 4 years ago
Amazing vocal performance!
Dawnsteed 4 years ago
Is math sin!
animalunaris 4 years ago
once again tom, you post the best stuff!!! Keep it up
mamajw2 4 years ago
anyone know the tune at the end??
alanbreathnach 4 years ago
I'm back to hear it again. The sound is so unique. I'd love to hear this group sing something with Connie Dover.
RCherryman 4 years ago
THanks for your comments. This is a powerfull performance and sounds slightly African. However, this type of "call and response" is quite common in Celtic music. A search for "highland sessions" will find other examples.
tomtscotland 4 years ago
I enjoyed your music. Thanks for posting.
RCherryman 4 years ago
If Liam looks familiar - he is the vocalist with the band Hothouse Flowers.
tomtscotland 4 years ago