You should put this information on the false website "WikiIslam" which pretends to try and fight against Islamophobia yet works as hard as it can to nourish it. Their article on Muhammed and Aisha's marriage (or any other topic in Islam) is purposefully misleading and insulting. I would like to see if you could add any of this information on their website and they let you leave it there. I came here after reading the article to remind myself of these points.
- it is ok in Islam and according to Islamic jurisprudence to marry and consummate this marriage with a girl playing on a swing with her dolls?
- because all girls 2000 years ago were fully matured at an early age and all societies at the time allowed early marriage and sex, it was ok for Islam to follow suit?
- today's tradition of marrying off young girls in some Islamic cultures is acceptable?
you are not getting the message of this video right
1- it is OK in Islam to marry and consummate a marriage with a WOMAN who has reached puberty AND IS PSYCHOLOGICALLY MATURE and with CONSENT
2- we did not present any argument of cultural relativism, except to show how non-Muslim cultures follow cultural relativism to the detriment of society, and Islam's marital law applies effectively then and now
3- you cannot "marry off" anyone in Islam...see point 1
your question has already been answered, but let me try one more time:
you asked" is it ok to marry a girl playing with dolls"
In Islam, a "girl" cannot marry. Only when she becomes a woman, is psychologically mature, and consents to the marriage, can that marriage be consummated and the marriage contract finalized.
Regarding dolls, they are still used today as preparation for motherhood, as we explained in part 2 of the video.
if hazrat aisha was a woman when she was permitted into prophet's house, why did the prophet allowed her to play with dolls when only girls are allowed?
according to the majority of scholars, the hadith of playing with dolls resulted in the PERMISSION to play with dolls regardless of age, and this is provided in the references for the document.
1 there is difference between european and african girls or arabian girls. european girls become puber when she is 12. while african girls become puber 9. at school in Belgium we had an girl from marrocco while she was10 she wasstarting to puber while european(white skinned) was stil a little girl. i'm Turk caucasian which is also different.
aisha cannot just say to sahabas i'm 9 and saying "i'm consumated" come on a girl 9 cannot take RESPONSIBILTY to keep household. she most be MUCH OLDER 19
go calculate when Aicha died and how old she was when she died, use mathemathics and the year she married in and you will find her age was 17 at least not 6-9.
There's a Text where Aicha said she used to race with her husband once a week, that she used to always win in the first years and then started loosing when she got older, now u think she won at 6 and lost at 16 ?
People love propaganda wow, not all hadith are trustworthy, God wanted it this way so that we use our brains, not just repeat
@MrMuslim83 Forget about it bro. We all know they are ignorant and only see it the way they wanted to. Anyway their Bible actually allow raping child, in (Numbers 31:17-18 and Numbers 31:35-40). So I don't know why on earth do they think they have the right to criticize. Isn't it funny?
Historical events prooves the age of Ayesha (R.A) to be atleast of 19 wen she was married with prophet.
1) she participated in jung e badar, n no1 under the age of 15 was allowed in it. after about 1 to 2 yrs later she got married to prophet and 3 yrs after tht she moved to his house, which means atleast 19 yrs of age.
there r other events too prove Ayesha's age 2 b atleat 19yrs.
her age of 6 yrs in al book is narrated by same guy who was 73yr n week memory. look real age of ayesha vedio
@shahnawazalam2000 they worship Bukhari and Muslim as if they are flawless and the haters also desperately cling to "Bukhari is considered to be second to the Quran" it is second because it still has flaws unlike the Quran.
@selwawy I said that they took it to be flawless, hence I used "worship". We should remember that the hadith are the word of man, not Allah, and we should be prepared to accept that even the sources considered to be authentic might be incorrect sometimes.
@helookslikefamousppl "hadith are the word" the people who delivered Quran are the same people who delivered Hadith (companions), how could you trust the Quran then?
"if ye realise this not, ask of those who possess the Message."(Quran 16:43). those who possess the Message said that these Hadiths is considered to be authentic.
@selwawy You're only saying the obvious, I was wondering if you meant that even the weak hadith are authentic. Plus SOME hadith that ARE in Bukhari, Muslim and Abu Dawood aren't considered to be authentic the explanation being that the Bukhari and Muslim may be the most reliable but are still not flawless. The Quran is flawless because it was given by Allah but the hadith were words of men so we should be wary of faults. That was my point.
@helookslikefamousppl give 1 single hadith in bukhari was agreed to be week by SCHOLARS (not any impostor).
the hadith aisha's age discussed here was proved to be strong (truth) bay many many scholars through the last 12 century. what changed this in the last 3 or 4 decades.
@selwawy Most of the hadith that said Aisha was married at 6 and the marriage was consummated at 9 were by Hisham ibn Urwah. I read that scholars such as Yaqub ibn Shaibah thinks that he is unreliable. He said so in Tehzibu'l-tehzib. Also Malik ibn Anas disagreed with narrations by Hisham ibn Urwah in the same Tehzibu'l tehzib. It was also said in Mizanu'l Al Tidal Vol.4 p 301 that Hisham had a suffering memory. So his narrations are weak yet they are in Bukhari.
@helookslikefamousppl Scholars greater than ibn Shaibah like Yahya ibn Ma'in, abo hatem arrazi, addarqotny, and Ali ibn al-Madini said that ibn Urwah is reliable and an imam in hadith, even Yaqub ibn Shaibah said so but he started to deny on him lately when he moved to Iraq.
yet no one of the scholars you mentioned could say or prove that his narrations or any other narrations in bukhari are week !!(I think those scholars would know that better than me and you)
@selwawy actually there were more in Tehzibu't Tehzib. I'm not sure if you watched the video 'proof that Aisha (.R.A) was 18 at the time of her marriage' but to the end of the video they site quotes from a few other scholars. Also I believe Malik Ibn Anas and some others STUDIED under Ibn Urwah so they would probably be closer to him and would probably have more authority. Also I think the people who wrote the book on the narrators of hadith would at least know what they're talking about.
@helookslikefamousppl even if it's as you said. that also means Ibn Urwah was considered to be reliable until he got old after moving to Iraq that's why bukhari did't take all his narrations to his book. and also that's why no scholar denied the narrations in bukhari.
bukhari is not the second, scholars said literatim"bukhari is the most authentic books after the Quran". but can you tell me how can any muslim perform salat, zakat, fasting, hajj without haddith books (bukhari in first place).
@selwawy lastyly, Isn't it true that Bukhari is only second to the Quran in reliability? Why is it only second if the scholars think it has no mistakes?
this reason is specified in the video, in that psychological maturity is delayed in modern times, which is one of the requirements for marriage in Islam.
I was thinking Alaah The Almighty may made she (RA) like a 18 years when she was 9 years
but at least I got 2 lessons
1. A very clearly explanation that marriage contract can be made before puberty but consummation only until puberty and maturity. When peoples of another religions don't have any explanation except from their own desire.
2. No one of us can forbid this great girl to get her happiness (getting education from The Prophet (SAW), getting His love, etc)
I thought this video was well made and explained the difference between what is socially acceptable and what was practical in the past well, until it compared teenage sexual abuse in the west to traditional islamic marriage.The video turns from correcting some misconceptions about Islam, to attempting to illustrate Islamic superiority over western civilization. Teen sexual abuse is not acceptable in the west, therefore should not be a basis of comparison to traditional Islamic marriage
I recently came to know that Alexander died at age of 32. When he was 26, he was very ill and unable to move. This means that he went for wars at very early age and conquered such a great amount of land.
I always knew that children become dumb by going to school and are not as smart as street boys.
I accepted prophet's marriage to a 40 year old woman.. i accept his marriage to a 9 year old girl.. anyway they only actually consummated the marriage when she was older. So who cares right? It's a consenting marriage. I think what people are getting at is not really the fact that aisha was 9. But that they associate the prophet with all these lecherous people who have used the way of the prophet to legitimize their indecency. Allah s.w.t only knows. To all these men.. shame on you.
Sorry the name of the nasheed is not known to us (it is by a group from Morocco) but it is available for download at our site. Please search Google for the following 4 terms:
EARLYMARRIAGE MUHADDITH NASHEED MOROCCO
(our site needs correction, so the google search is the easiest way to reach it)
Thanks..very informative. I'll investigate further. I'm beginning to realize that all these "elite" insitutions United Nations,World Bank,IMF,World Health organization (WHO),RAND Corporation are biased.Their reports are all so BIASED!! - these insitutions only show/propogate one-side of the equation.And I'm personally very disappointed from using data from such reports without veryfying them.
I'm now going to be very very careful whenever I read or analyze reports.Blind trust is a bad thing.
And yes Muslims can meet before their future wives and even if he doesn't have the intention to marry her it is allowed in Islam that they meet and know each other if other people r present! The prophet's wife was a scholar whom men went to ask for guidance! And u r telling me that women r not supposed to meet up with men in Islam??! Muslim women used to participate in battles at the time of the prophet and played a great role in the Islamic nation!
I know that at least one Pope of the Catholic church who lived during or shortly after the time of Muhammad criticized Muhammad for marrying such a young girl (I forget which pope but can look it up) so at least some people did not approve at that time. Whether or not his disaproval was due to religious bigotry or true concern for Aisha's welfare I could not say. Today, I cannot imagine any country approving of marriage at such a young age but I don't know every country. thanks for reading
In 34 years of experience reviewing over 10,000 marriage records of New England 1620-1850 I have never found one for a woman under 15. until the late 18th century all of New England except Rhode Island was a theocracy which required a minister to approve of all marriages.
While you have made some very valid points regarding the needs of a population to procreate and the variation in puberty ages at different times and places you should be aware that marriage and procreation at an early age is not common in all places and times prior to the 18th century as you implied.
I do not claim to be an expert in all matters concerning marriage. However, I have been a genealogist for 34 years. As such I have had an opportunity to read over 10,000 original hand written marriage records throughout the six New England states including all known marriage records of New England from 1620 and 1700. I have also reviewed thousands of marriage records from medieval Europe between 500 AD and 1650 AD.
@shatros I asked a similar quetion to one of your similar comments...do you know what percent of these marriages were actually registered? does your data for New English and Medieval Europe include common law marriages?
We did provide references for the video, and we believe these references to be true. I don't know what else to tell you.
If this video does not explain it enough to you, that means you have a comprehension problem. May be it's about time to stop that hate and start reading books instead of spending all your time on facebook insulting people just because of who they are...
This is a complete fallacy and a lie The average age of menarche (age of first period) 1880 was 15.5 - the age decreased with onset of industrialisation, decreasing the age to 13 in 1960 Source Brudevol et al 1979. BBC news May 2001 report stated that average age was then 12 years 11 months.
Please give the html document links in MORE INFORMATION section as many people do not watch the whole video to get the site but may read the MORE INFORMATION
@PreciousDetective - They had a wonderful marriage and Aisha's hadiths prove it - we shud all be so lucky to have a marriage of love and mutual respect like they had :)
92w, I have debated young women on YT before. You are all very polite, but in fact, too polite. You don't ask the tough questions. You should. You should stand up and ask tough questions of me, your imam., your parents, your brothers and leaders of your community. Ask "Can a 6 year old really consent to marriage?" "If so in the 7th century then why not now if allah's moral code is unchanging?" "Does muhammed's immorality prove he was no prophet?"
U R practically accusing all past humanity of immorality
Show us (among the most stubborn enemies of our Magnificient Prophet) JUST ONE WHO OBJECTED (before the last 50 years) against early marriage: Whehter Christian, Jew, Atheist...
This is the tough question U should ask yourself, and our video answered yr question to us.
U represent the century of pornography, bestiality, etc. U R absolutely not qualified to invent an opinion on the subject just bcz it suits your Islamophobia.
@MuhaddithDotOrg Well in retrospect I take no offense when people question religions. I am a Muslim and this issue about Aisha made me curious. We must understand the ambiguous nature of society, so I don't apply cultural aspects to Prophet Muhammad because he sets those principles. Therefore if Prophet Muhammad did something he believed to be morally correct than it should apply to every1 even if it deals with Aisha. I don't believe he consummated her at that age because it is morally wrong.
yes im sometimes too shy to ask questions but not this question, because i already understand it i mean how could u compare something that happened thousands of years ago to now ! people change, our ways of thinking change everything is changing . people over the centuries never asked why did mohammed marry a young girl so that means that it was something normal at that time and it started to change by time
Prophets are sent for legalising all that is supposed to be done by mankind after them.There are circumstances when some rules can be restricted but the prohibitions are to be respected as prohibitions from God.
What Prophet legalised by marrying a woman who was 15 yrs older than him and a woman who was much younger than him was , that AGE IS NO BAR IN MARRIAGE FOR TWO CONSENTING ADULTS.
womhist . alexanderstreet . com /teacher/aoc . htm
Read woman history in America after removing the SPACES
Campaign to Raise the Legal Age of Consent, 1885-1914
American reformers were shocked to discover that the laws of most states set the age of consent at the age of ten or twelve, and in one state, Delaware, the age of consent was only seven
Our video CITES her own words: She considered herself the luckiest person in the world.
Enemies of truth have the guts to twist it and claim she was forced. Our videos are directed to impartial reasonable persons seeking the truth, and it is clear as daylight here. The others are simply hate mongers following the lowest impulses possible for of the human soul: Hatred, bigotry, racism, all leading them to permit themselves to difigure the truth.
just think of the time it was, and how long the people lived until they were 30...
and if u havent noticed... more than half of the catholic priests in the 21century, a molesting, and raping lil boys and girls... now thats JUST SICK !!! u wana judge a Prophet and his life 1500yrs ago... start judging them instead...
All I can say is WOW. This is probably the worst excuse for Muhammad sexually assulting young girls. And the fact that the video is giving reasons why it is acceptable makes it all that more disgusting. Just sick.
lol oh gosh...... r u really that narrow minded... considering the life span that many yrs ago, was min 30yrs... and if a women is not ready or mature enough to bare children, she wouldnt of had her periods. and at the beginning when her family asked her to marry him, she didnt respond, she didnt start living with the prophet until she was older...
And also, what do u say about all the catholic priests who molest children, and shaytan is, the devil, u have clearly done ur research.. NOT!!!
When a Muslim man commits a crime what do Christians do? They blame Islam as a whole even though it wasn't an Islamic act . When Jesus tells Christians to worship God (ALLAH) what do the Christians do? they worship Jesus instead. When talk of the prophet Muhammad (PBUH) rises what do Christians have to say? Child Molester. Not all Christians are bad.
What point are you trying to make? Are you saying Muhammed was just another muslim man?
The man sexually assaulted a 6 year old girl. He also traded human slaves. If he was a prophet of a just and existing god don't you think this god would have said something to him about his evil behaviour?
1. re. thighing 6 year old Aisha, this fatwa from the grand Mufti Abu Abdullah Muhammad Al-Shemary: "As for the prophet [pbuh], thighing his fiancée Aisha. She was six years of age and he could not have intercourse with her due to her small age. That is why [the prophet, pbuh] placed his [male] member between ber thighs and massaged it softly"
2. re. Muhammed selling a free man back into slavery, see Bukhari Volume 3, Book 41, Number 598.
@frid9999 - you ignorant ignorant ignorant person, i feel sorry for ppl like YOU.
@ Herman47 - loll, she actually didnt start living with prophet Muhammed (pbuh) until she was older, & she chose not to remarry out of respect for prophet Muhammed (pbuh) if she wanted to she could of. but she chose to spread the word of islam.
& we use the (p.b.u.h stuff out of respect.) not sure if u no wat that is. but maybe u shuld google it.. instead of Theodor H. Vandevelde. hilarious. u uneducated retards.
Child rape child rape child rape that's all you Christians bring up everyday. You see Jesus said to the people that claim to be his followers to worship God but instead they worship Jesus. Its like asking your son to hand you a pen but he hands you damn knife this pretty much sums up Christianity as a whole. I hope I don't go to hell for this but Christianity is corrupted and I'm beginning to believe the Bible is written through the lies of Shaytan.
@BulgyVeins Al Bukhari narrated (hadeeth 3683): He married Aishah (radi Allahu 'anha) when she was six years old, and consummated the marriage when she was nine.
Also narrated in Al Mustadrak, 6715/2313 and multitude of other hadeeth compilations.
yes she was 6 years old but not when he married her but when he proposed it's called "khotba" in arabic , the period of time before getting married is "the period of khotba"
it's not child rape don't u get it, back then that's how things were , girls used to get married when they were very young thats how it was u can't change the past , if u come to my country u'll see that most of the old women here got married when they were 13, thats how it was 50 years ago , but now most girls don't want to get married untill they're above 19 . it's all about time and cultures , the more time passes by the more people change and the way of thinking changes =)
What you are saying makes no sense 92w. Having sex with children is having sex with children whether it occured 10 days or 10 centuries ago. Everything we know about children's brains proves that 6 (or 9) year-olds can not possibly have the mental capacity to make an informed decision to marry or have sex (thighing). Tradition is irrelevant. This is about raping children. Do you think it is okay for man to thigh a 6 year old today? Then why do you think it is okay 1300 years ago?
if u bring a girl who is 10 years old now and a girl who was 10 thousands of years ago do u think that they would be the same ?? girls back then didn't think like how girls think now ,another thing is that girls who are from the middle east reach the age of puberty faster than girls who are from ur side of the world,for example my friend reached that stage when she was 10 but with most girls when they get 11,and it's know that when u reach that stage ur way of thinking totally changes u grow up
Oh come on 92w, you are simply grasping at straws. We are talking about a 6 year old girl being forced into a sexual relationship with a 51 year old man. Your excuses are pathetic. Muhammed was a pedophile - as simple as that. It may have been the custom of the Arabian savages of the time, but that is no excuse. If there was a real god and he was just, he would have told muhammed that thighing little girls is wrong!
she wasn't forced he proposed to her father "abo baker alsedeeq" and then they got married and he didn't have any sexual relationship with her until she was about 10, anyways u don't have to understand this and u don't have to accept it because it already happened i guess nobody understans this except for us muslims and that's okay =) i just want u to know that i don't have any hard feelings for u or anyone no matter what his believes are ,after all we all live in the same world, have a good day
First, if it's claimed that a society needs many children to survive, then it's utterly stupid for a six-year old to be marrying a sick 50+ year-old bastard. Aisha wound up having NO CHILDREN! No surprise, Muhammad's fecundity was waning, and she was only 6! Muhammad wound up dying when she was around 18, but she could not remarry! Of course, if she had gotten married at around 18 to say an 18 year old, how many children do you think she would have had?
if muhammad pbuh wants money and wealth, he would not reject the offer from Quraish tribe, to have the highest position of the quraish tribe, all the wealth they have and all the women,if only he(Muhammad pbuh) would shut up and stop preaching,
but he reject all of it!!! (wealth/pleasure/power)
a liar or a bad person wont reject all that, only a man of truth and faith in god would and that is Muhammad pbuh.
Being the narcissist that he was, what Muhammad wanted most (besides the sex) was the adulation of all those gullible enough to believe everything Muhammad tells them to believe (you know, guys like you, who use that "pbuh" stuff). Now Muhammad isn't going to be getting all that adulation if he shuts up, right?
On positive role of age difference in marriage Western academic speaking on this issue; the work is Theodor H. Vandevelde, Ideal Marriage: Its Physiology and Technique "When the differences (in ages) is great, e.g. exceeds fifteen to twenty years, the results may be happier. The marriage of an elderly (senescent) not, of course, an old (senile) man to a quite young girl, is often very successful and harmonious. The bride is immediately introduced and accustomed to moderate sexual intercourse."
Even if we accept your premise that a large age difference between spouses "MAY be happier," a premise I highly doubt, we must also consider human mortality here. Aisha & Muhammad were married for what, 9 years? HOW MANY DECADES DID AISHA ENDURE AS AN UNMARRIED WIDOW? Muslims believe that Muhammad was the best role model, setting a wise example for Muslims to follow. There are videos on youtube about 50+ year old Muslim men marrying 9 year old girls. How do you think that's going to work out?
In Islam the special reason the Prophet was able to marry more then the usual limit of 4 wives was for resolving political tribal issues via marriages. This was also common in European societies. Many of the Prophet's marriages where either to take care of someone (his older wives like Safiyyah) or to strengthen bonds across tribes and families like Aisha, etc.
excellent video. its a pity how some ppl will carry on being blind and ignorant to their own opinion which quite frankly, most of the times is BASELESS. even if 10 times more information was provided for them as evidence, they still wont believe due to their ignorant nature! may Allah SWT guide us all.
It's actually you who is brain washed. Your answer was in the vid, also Aisha wasn't the prophet's niece, which shows how little you know about anything. Watch the vid again, I'm sure no matter how thick you are eventually you will understand what is being said.
Alhamdulillah, very nice video, it provces that Islam is the most modern religion. What non muslims are doing today, Islam did 1400 yeard ago.
After seeing this, all non Muslims will shut their mouth, if not, it will prove their ignorance, and further prove that Islam is the only true religion.
@srizki Hahahahaha what a load of bullshit. I supose that Islam created Industrial Revolution & Nuclear Age 1400 years ago? It`s amazing (& pathetic) how ignorant people gloat about their "knowledge"...hahahahaha
Excellent Video brother may Allah reward you with the highest station in Paradise for defending His Prophet and His Prophet's Religion and Family! Ameen!
"Prophet's (pbuh) Marriage to Aisha (ra) - Dr. Ali Shehata"
An amazing lecture with PowerPoint given by Dr. Ali Shehata on Prophet Muhammad's (pbuh) Marriage to Aisha (ra). Dr. Ali discusses the noble character of the Prophet (pbuh), the authentic historical record of this matter, the cultural views in his era, the medical aspects related to puberty, a better understand of what constitutes pedophilia and the reasons behind the recent surge of relentless attacks on the Prophet (pbuh).
some muslim friends (girls ) told me in their book its mentioned that jesus is THE SPIRIT OF GOD and its mentioned that GOD SAID TO HIS MOTHER (before his birth ) YOUR BOY IS WORD OF GOD ok no problem but what is the real prophetic.. ? THE SPIRIT AND THE WORD ( OF ) GOD or just a spirit n a word ( FROM ) god !!! ??? . I realy dont know y to some friends its very hard !?
we've only two problems with our muslim friends, FIRST problem , they cant understand y we say father , son n holly spirit they think we have three gods No our friends its a trope expression like when u say to any citizen of mecca son of mecca is thats mean mecca is a father ? of course not so its only 1 god but appeared in the body of jesus and the word of god appeared in jesus too
you wrote: "when u say to any citizen of mecca son of mecca is thats mean mecca is a father ? of course not..."
you are right about one thing...for the Hebrew people who heard Jesus say he is the son of God, they knew he was speaking figuratively...and when he was accused of being the literal son of God, he referred them to the Old Test where the Jews were called the children of God (btw, Adam is called the firstborn son of God in the Bible).
dear friend u got my comments wrong so plz read them again but this time read very carefully , i didnt say body of god but i said spirit of god n word of god thats y we see the facilities and the features of god are only inside him as a spirit n word not his body
So show us where Jesus said SO ARTICULATELY that he is GOD'S SOUL (and not a soul from God).
In the meantime, Muslims have always showed Christians that Jesus says THE FATHER IS GREATER THAN I AM, and that he said WHY DO YOU CALL ME GOOD, ONLY THE FATHER IS GOOD.
Now meet our challenge and produce the claim of divinity. IF IT IS IMPORTANT HE SHOULD HAVE MADE IT CLEAR AS DAYLIGHT.
ha now i knew way you dont want to believe.. because you are looking for challenge , religion or faith is not a matter of challenge its just this simple TAKE IT OR LEAVE IT ( up to your deep heart ) wish u..good luck
ISA(LORD) relating GOD SHIVA is a phallic bi-sexual GOD far older then JESUS could ever be dating back several 1000 years in INDIA. I do find this SHIVA down right a scary thought to the truth JESUS is not a real prophet nor would exist as a SHIVA GOD. Im sure CHRISTIAN and MUSLIMS have to agree something is so wrong in this connection.
2- His words maintained otherwise, that ONLY THE FATHER IS GOOD!!!
3- His actions proved otherwise: Look, he used to eat, AND THEREFORE GO TO THE TOILET :) :) :)...
THIS IS NOT A GOD. WAKE UP.
WE DEFINITELY RECFUSE TO WORSHIP A GOD THAT PRODUCES EXCREMENTS, that even a plant does not produce. Go worship a tree, it's cleaner!!! We venerate Jesus, you insult him.
Isa means Lord or God. Hence its name itself is indicative of its importance i.e. It is named as Gods Upanishads. Like the Kena Upanishad, the Isa Upanishad takes its name from its first word, Isa. Isa Upanishad is said to be the essence of all Upanishad teachings so far as practical life is concerned. It is comparatively a very short Upanishad, though it is an integral gospel. ISA is the name Muslims give to JESUS so how is JESUS not LORD or GOD in the QURAN. So how is ALLAH and ISA the same?
Ok, lets say I agree. If the Bible states Mary and Joseph were Jews an circumcised JESUS as JEW. Theres no way on Earth MARY being the MOTHER of JESUS would dare name JESUS (ISA). The name ISA or ISSA would mean WOMAN. Blaspemous!!! JESUS does claim the FATHER and I are 1 in the BIBLE but no where does JESUS call himself a WOMAN!! Even the GREEK language of the NEW TESTAMENT would obvious see the error of using ISSA. Only the QURAN claims the use of ISA in no way knowing MARY's opinion.
'Isa is just the Arabic pronounciation of Yeshua (Hebrew) or Yesu (Aramaic), This wasn't an uncommon name, in fact Yashua, is just a form of Joshua. Furthermore the "Isa" of the Sanskrit literature is doesn't have the same consonants as Arabic or Hebrew. The Greek is just a translation of Aramaic. There is no connection to Sanrkit
The ARABIC language is also subject to foreign words introduced without knowing the origin or meaning. The linguistic origin of ISA or ISSA can be found related to a woman by looking at names of women themselves have acquired. The obvious denial ISA means WOMAN or LORD -GOD in SANSKRIT is the serious attempt to misrepresent the Quran's own truth. JESUS being called ISA introduces JESUS is actually a WOMAN not a MAN's name. GREEKS/ROMAN/JEWS never named JESUS ISA.
Of course; but that's not an indicator that this word is from Sanskrit, for example 'Isa means to "One who Cries Out for Help"; as you said Isa in Sanskrit LITERALLY means Lord. , Is not necessarily a woman's name in Arabic, not sure how you derived that.
Like I said , 'Isa is just the Arabic pronunciation of the Aramaic word Yesu, Aramaic and Arabic are closely related languages. Sanskrit is not. the Qur'an isn't in Sanskrit so your point doesn't cohere with evidence.
Assalamoalaikum
I have modified a part of this video and elaborated its references
Please accept my video as video response.
farzanatasneem 4 months ago
You should put this information on the false website "WikiIslam" which pretends to try and fight against Islamophobia yet works as hard as it can to nourish it. Their article on Muhammed and Aisha's marriage (or any other topic in Islam) is purposefully misleading and insulting. I would like to see if you could add any of this information on their website and they let you leave it there. I came here after reading the article to remind myself of these points.
IslamChika 6 months ago
Are instruments allowed in islam?? Plz answer
MrTheYoussef 7 months ago
Am I getting the message of this video right:
- it is ok in Islam and according to Islamic jurisprudence to marry and consummate this marriage with a girl playing on a swing with her dolls?
- because all girls 2000 years ago were fully matured at an early age and all societies at the time allowed early marriage and sex, it was ok for Islam to follow suit?
- today's tradition of marrying off young girls in some Islamic cultures is acceptable?
- all of the above is desirable and good?
StopSpamming1 9 months ago
@StopSpamming1
you are not getting the message of this video right
1- it is OK in Islam to marry and consummate a marriage with a WOMAN who has reached puberty AND IS PSYCHOLOGICALLY MATURE and with CONSENT
2- we did not present any argument of cultural relativism, except to show how non-Muslim cultures follow cultural relativism to the detriment of society, and Islam's marital law applies effectively then and now
3- you cannot "marry off" anyone in Islam...see point 1
islamophobia4dummies 9 months ago
@islamophobia4dummies
I don't see any differences.
My question is: is it ok to marry a girl playing with dolls?
What I see is that Islam's "marital law" follows the cultural habits of a society hundreds of years ago.
Reality has it that Muslims today marry off girls in arranged marriages. Is this acceptable or not?
StopSpamming1 9 months ago
@StopSpamming1
your question has already been answered, but let me try one more time:
you asked" is it ok to marry a girl playing with dolls"
In Islam, a "girl" cannot marry. Only when she becomes a woman, is psychologically mature, and consents to the marriage, can that marriage be consummated and the marriage contract finalized.
Regarding dolls, they are still used today as preparation for motherhood, as we explained in part 2 of the video.
islamophobia4dummies 9 months ago
@islamophobia4dummies
if hazrat aisha was a woman when she was permitted into prophet's house, why did the prophet allowed her to play with dolls when only girls are allowed?
ajkhan1989 6 months ago
@ajkhan1989
according to the majority of scholars, the hadith of playing with dolls resulted in the PERMISSION to play with dolls regardless of age, and this is provided in the references for the document.
islamophobia4dummies 6 months ago
I doubt that dumb Islamophobes will even understand this video!
JackSparrowDepp 10 months ago
@JackSparrowDepp Only Allah guides. We only pass on the message.
kotlianz 8 months ago
1 there is difference between european and african girls or arabian girls. european girls become puber when she is 12. while african girls become puber 9. at school in Belgium we had an girl from marrocco while she was10 she wasstarting to puber while european(white skinned) was stil a little girl. i'm Turk caucasian which is also different.
aisha cannot just say to sahabas i'm 9 and saying "i'm consumated" come on a girl 9 cannot take RESPONSIBILTY to keep household. she most be MUCH OLDER 19
karakan1453 10 months ago
Moreover, Aisha (RA) undoubtedly LOVED her husband (PBUH).
Saroona24434 10 months ago
go calculate when Aicha died and how old she was when she died, use mathemathics and the year she married in and you will find her age was 17 at least not 6-9.
There's a Text where Aicha said she used to race with her husband once a week, that she used to always win in the first years and then started loosing when she got older, now u think she won at 6 and lost at 16 ?
People love propaganda wow, not all hadith are trustworthy, God wanted it this way so that we use our brains, not just repeat
The9raya 11 months ago
some one sent me a message and he described about some body parts of Aisha (RA). Did he saw Her (RA)?
Every single girl who had menstruation got puberty and become an adult whatever her sizes
And he also said "the "consummation" was actually child rape".
we know She (RA) was satisfied about Her relationship with The Messenger (SAW).
just like another haters who makes propaganda but actually only show us their nescience or their evil. And some of them has many accounts.
حسبنا الله و نعم الوكيل
MrMuslim83 1 year ago
@MrMuslim83
Truly, Islam haters will make up anything to fit their agenda.
As for false claims about Lady Aisha herself, part 2 of this video answers most of them. watch?v=v4yyx1qDWhQ
MuhaddithDotOrg 1 year ago
@MrMuslim83 Forget about it bro. We all know they are ignorant and only see it the way they wanted to. Anyway their Bible actually allow raping child, in (Numbers 31:17-18 and Numbers 31:35-40). So I don't know why on earth do they think they have the right to criticize. Isn't it funny?
La19000 11 months ago
@La19000 shame on criticizable criticisms on Islaam
MrMuslim83 11 months ago
Historical events prooves the age of Ayesha (R.A) to be atleast of 19 wen she was married with prophet.
1) she participated in jung e badar, n no1 under the age of 15 was allowed in it. after about 1 to 2 yrs later she got married to prophet and 3 yrs after tht she moved to his house, which means atleast 19 yrs of age.
there r other events too prove Ayesha's age 2 b atleat 19yrs.
her age of 6 yrs in al book is narrated by same guy who was 73yr n week memory. look real age of ayesha vedio
shahnawazalam2000 1 year ago
@shahnawazalam2000 they worship Bukhari and Muslim as if they are flawless and the haters also desperately cling to "Bukhari is considered to be second to the Quran" it is second because it still has flaws unlike the Quran.
helookslikefamousppl 1 year ago
@helookslikefamousppl "they worship Bukhari"! a muslim shouldn't scandal his brothers without a proof.
"ascertain the truth, lest ye harm people unwittingly, and afterwards become full of repentance for what ye have done." (Quran 49:6)
selwawy 11 months ago
@selwawy I said that they took it to be flawless, hence I used "worship". We should remember that the hadith are the word of man, not Allah, and we should be prepared to accept that even the sources considered to be authentic might be incorrect sometimes.
helookslikefamousppl 11 months ago
@helookslikefamousppl "hadith are the word" the people who delivered Quran are the same people who delivered Hadith (companions), how could you trust the Quran then?
"if ye realise this not, ask of those who possess the Message."(Quran 16:43). those who possess the Message said that these Hadiths is considered to be authentic.
selwawy 11 months ago
@selwawy so ALL hadith are trustworthy then?
helookslikefamousppl 11 months ago
@helookslikefamousppl again !!
"if ye realise this not, ask of those who possess the Message."(Quran 16:43).
selwawy 11 months ago
@selwawy like I said are ALL hadith trustworthy? Seeing as most aren't seen as authentic
helookslikefamousppl 11 months ago
@helookslikefamousppl every single hadith agreed to be trustworthy by trusted well-educated devout SCHOLARS then it is trustworthy with no argument.
selwawy 11 months ago
@selwawy You're only saying the obvious, I was wondering if you meant that even the weak hadith are authentic. Plus SOME hadith that ARE in Bukhari, Muslim and Abu Dawood aren't considered to be authentic the explanation being that the Bukhari and Muslim may be the most reliable but are still not flawless. The Quran is flawless because it was given by Allah but the hadith were words of men so we should be wary of faults. That was my point.
helookslikefamousppl 11 months ago
@helookslikefamousppl give 1 single hadith in bukhari was agreed to be week by SCHOLARS (not any impostor).
the hadith aisha's age discussed here was proved to be strong (truth) bay many many scholars through the last 12 century. what changed this in the last 3 or 4 decades.
selwawy 11 months ago
@selwawy Most of the hadith that said Aisha was married at 6 and the marriage was consummated at 9 were by Hisham ibn Urwah. I read that scholars such as Yaqub ibn Shaibah thinks that he is unreliable. He said so in Tehzibu'l-tehzib. Also Malik ibn Anas disagreed with narrations by Hisham ibn Urwah in the same Tehzibu'l tehzib. It was also said in Mizanu'l Al Tidal Vol.4 p 301 that Hisham had a suffering memory. So his narrations are weak yet they are in Bukhari.
helookslikefamousppl 11 months ago
@helookslikefamousppl Scholars greater than ibn Shaibah like Yahya ibn Ma'in, abo hatem arrazi, addarqotny, and Ali ibn al-Madini said that ibn Urwah is reliable and an imam in hadith, even Yaqub ibn Shaibah said so but he started to deny on him lately when he moved to Iraq.
yet no one of the scholars you mentioned could say or prove that his narrations or any other narrations in bukhari are week !!(I think those scholars would know that better than me and you)
selwawy 11 months ago
@selwawy actually there were more in Tehzibu't Tehzib. I'm not sure if you watched the video 'proof that Aisha (.R.A) was 18 at the time of her marriage' but to the end of the video they site quotes from a few other scholars. Also I believe Malik Ibn Anas and some others STUDIED under Ibn Urwah so they would probably be closer to him and would probably have more authority. Also I think the people who wrote the book on the narrators of hadith would at least know what they're talking about.
helookslikefamousppl 11 months ago
@helookslikefamousppl even if it's as you said. that also means Ibn Urwah was considered to be reliable until he got old after moving to Iraq that's why bukhari did't take all his narrations to his book. and also that's why no scholar denied the narrations in bukhari.
bukhari is not the second, scholars said literatim"bukhari is the most authentic books after the Quran". but can you tell me how can any muslim perform salat, zakat, fasting, hajj without haddith books (bukhari in first place).
selwawy 11 months ago
@selwawy lastyly, Isn't it true that Bukhari is only second to the Quran in reliability? Why is it only second if the scholars think it has no mistakes?
helookslikefamousppl 11 months ago
@shahnawazalam2000 these Historical events were proven to be weak ضعيف narrations according to consensus of most of the nation scholars jurists.
"إن الله قد أجار أمتي من أن تجتمع على ضلالة" (mkhtasar alselsela alsahiha-elAlbany 3:319)
selwawy 11 months ago
It was acceptable in those days? Well why don;t the Muslim in Europe or the Arab countries let their daughters get married at age 9??
smk374 1 year ago
@smk374
this reason is specified in the video, in that psychological maturity is delayed in modern times, which is one of the requirements for marriage in Islam.
islamophobia4dummies 1 year ago
@smk374 Because the child's of 7th century are unlike the child's of 21st century.
selwawy 11 months ago
I was thinking Alaah The Almighty may made she (RA) like a 18 years when she was 9 years
but at least I got 2 lessons
1. A very clearly explanation that marriage contract can be made before puberty but consummation only until puberty and maturity. When peoples of another religions don't have any explanation except from their own desire.
2. No one of us can forbid this great girl to get her happiness (getting education from The Prophet (SAW), getting His love, etc)
MrMuslim83 1 year ago
I thought this video was well made and explained the difference between what is socially acceptable and what was practical in the past well, until it compared teenage sexual abuse in the west to traditional islamic marriage.The video turns from correcting some misconceptions about Islam, to attempting to illustrate Islamic superiority over western civilization. Teen sexual abuse is not acceptable in the west, therefore should not be a basis of comparison to traditional Islamic marriage
thekurgan89 1 year ago
WHAT THE WEST REALLY THINK OF MUHAMMAD /watch?v=ma3PFNHuNjw
atheist2islam 1 year ago
Please also watch:
100% Refuting Muhammad Pedophile Lies by Sam Shamoun at ABN
watch?v=4nGLHR1f9KI
pamuk7 1 year ago
I recently came to know that Alexander died at age of 32. When he was 26, he was very ill and unable to move. This means that he went for wars at very early age and conquered such a great amount of land.
I always knew that children become dumb by going to school and are not as smart as street boys.
johnnystorm28 1 year ago
I accepted prophet's marriage to a 40 year old woman.. i accept his marriage to a 9 year old girl.. anyway they only actually consummated the marriage when she was older. So who cares right? It's a consenting marriage. I think what people are getting at is not really the fact that aisha was 9. But that they associate the prophet with all these lecherous people who have used the way of the prophet to legitimize their indecency. Allah s.w.t only knows. To all these men.. shame on you.
bluedonkeycat 1 year ago
There are some good points made in this video, but I would suggest removing the horse audio clip (just tacky and somewhat disturbing)
pzjdsg 1 year ago
@pzjdsg
A picture is worth a thousand words.
And the audio clip here is worth a million in our view.
Anyway thanks for caring, we see your good intention although we do not agree with that opinion of yours.
Salam.
MuhaddithDotOrg 1 year ago
@pzjdsg you just seem angey and cant face the facts
MojowidanAK 1 year ago
Whats the name of the nasheed in the begining 0:05 ?
Sandzak95 1 year ago
@Sandzak95
Sorry the name of the nasheed is not known to us (it is by a group from Morocco) but it is available for download at our site. Please search Google for the following 4 terms:
EARLYMARRIAGE MUHADDITH NASHEED MOROCCO
(our site needs correction, so the google search is the easiest way to reach it)
MuhaddithDotOrg 1 year ago
@MuhaddithDotOrg
Thank you, i found it.
Sandzak95 1 year ago
@MuhaddithDotOrg You know brother, I think we've waited long enough for part 3... :P
helookslikefamousppl 9 months ago
Thanks..very informative. I'll investigate further. I'm beginning to realize that all these "elite" insitutions United Nations,World Bank,IMF,World Health organization (WHO),RAND Corporation are biased.Their reports are all so BIASED!! - these insitutions only show/propogate one-side of the equation.And I'm personally very disappointed from using data from such reports without veryfying them.
I'm now going to be very very careful whenever I read or analyze reports.Blind trust is a bad thing.
sabashsabash 1 year ago
@Factszz
brother, are you a scholar in islam ?
and what do you take as your source of information on matters relating to islam ?
lessirey 1 year ago
jazakom allah khair
Riteeta1 1 year ago
And yes Muslims can meet before their future wives and even if he doesn't have the intention to marry her it is allowed in Islam that they meet and know each other if other people r present! The prophet's wife was a scholar whom men went to ask for guidance! And u r telling me that women r not supposed to meet up with men in Islam??! Muslim women used to participate in battles at the time of the prophet and played a great role in the Islamic nation!
Riteeta1 1 year ago
I know that at least one Pope of the Catholic church who lived during or shortly after the time of Muhammad criticized Muhammad for marrying such a young girl (I forget which pope but can look it up) so at least some people did not approve at that time. Whether or not his disaproval was due to religious bigotry or true concern for Aisha's welfare I could not say. Today, I cannot imagine any country approving of marriage at such a young age but I don't know every country. thanks for reading
shatros 1 year ago
@shatros please do bring your reference for the long-ago pope who supposedly criticized the marriage
MuhaddithDotOrg 1 year ago
In 34 years of experience reviewing over 10,000 marriage records of New England 1620-1850 I have never found one for a woman under 15. until the late 18th century all of New England except Rhode Island was a theocracy which required a minister to approve of all marriages.
shatros 1 year ago
@shatros do you know what percentage of marriages were registered during this time? Does this include common law marriages?
MuhaddithDotOrg 1 year ago
While you have made some very valid points regarding the needs of a population to procreate and the variation in puberty ages at different times and places you should be aware that marriage and procreation at an early age is not common in all places and times prior to the 18th century as you implied.
shatros 1 year ago
I do not claim to be an expert in all matters concerning marriage. However, I have been a genealogist for 34 years. As such I have had an opportunity to read over 10,000 original hand written marriage records throughout the six New England states including all known marriage records of New England from 1620 and 1700. I have also reviewed thousands of marriage records from medieval Europe between 500 AD and 1650 AD.
shatros 1 year ago
@shatros I asked a similar quetion to one of your similar comments...do you know what percent of these marriages were actually registered? does your data for New English and Medieval Europe include common law marriages?
We did provide references for the video, and we believe these references to be true. I don't know what else to tell you.
MuhaddithDotOrg 1 year ago
thank you so much for this upload. Mashallah keep up the amazing work.
buru44 1 year ago
Please get the facts right.: Prostitution is not legal in Sweden. It is illegal to visit a prostitute in Sweden.
pirejknf 1 year ago
@pirejknf the prostitute does not go to jail...it is legal for her to sell, but not for the buyer....so it is half-legal. Is that better?
MuhaddithDotOrg 1 year ago
@MuhaddithDotOrg
hey, try search Islam: What Was The Age Of Aisha (RA) When She Got Married ?
in youtube, well, i m confussed something now :@
PreciousDetective 1 year ago
If this video does not explain it enough to you, that means you have a comprehension problem. May be it's about time to stop that hate and start reading books instead of spending all your time on facebook insulting people just because of who they are...
sourati 1 year ago
This is a complete fallacy and a lie The average age of menarche (age of first period) 1880 was 15.5 - the age decreased with onset of industrialisation, decreasing the age to 13 in 1960 Source Brudevol et al 1979. BBC news May 2001 report stated that average age was then 12 years 11 months.
Belganorma 1 year ago
@Belganorma ok, fine, you got one references about the avg age of menarche, but we had alot alot alot more references that proved the age was lower.
MuhaddithDotOrg 1 year ago
Great video, thank you.
projections 1 year ago
great job on this video
yomamasayuugly 1 year ago
Assalamoalaikum
muhaddithDotOrg
Please give the html document links in MORE INFORMATION section as many people do not watch the whole video to get the site but may read the MORE INFORMATION
trustworthyno1 1 year ago
***** WALL OF SHAME *****
┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬
┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬
┬┴┬┴┬┴ The Wall ┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴
┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬
┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴┬┴
DEMOLISH THIS WALL
DEMAND FREEDOM FOR PALESTINE!
MuhaddithDotOrg 1 year ago
good job victory is ours :)
Celixa0 2 years ago
i agree Victory is ours :) this is a bashing
BrotherSkillz 1 year ago
@frid9999
u got no point of insulting early marriages of Prophet Muhammad -,-
at the time Muhammad ask for marry Aisha, Aisha already matured. Muhammad treat Aisha nicely and they live happily... indeed.
So, there is no point insult their marriages..
go get a new point dude -,-
PreciousDetective,
KeepTheTruth,
HATE ME xD
PreciousDetective 2 years ago
@PreciousDetective - They had a wonderful marriage and Aisha's hadiths prove it - we shud all be so lucky to have a marriage of love and mutual respect like they had :)
Kimimus 1 year ago
92w, I have debated young women on YT before. You are all very polite, but in fact, too polite. You don't ask the tough questions. You should. You should stand up and ask tough questions of me, your imam., your parents, your brothers and leaders of your community. Ask "Can a 6 year old really consent to marriage?" "If so in the 7th century then why not now if allah's moral code is unchanging?" "Does muhammed's immorality prove he was no prophet?"
Stand up young woman!
frid9999 2 years ago
@frid9999
U R practically accusing all past humanity of immorality
Show us (among the most stubborn enemies of our Magnificient Prophet) JUST ONE WHO OBJECTED (before the last 50 years) against early marriage: Whehter Christian, Jew, Atheist...
This is the tough question U should ask yourself, and our video answered yr question to us.
U represent the century of pornography, bestiality, etc. U R absolutely not qualified to invent an opinion on the subject just bcz it suits your Islamophobia.
MuhaddithDotOrg 2 years ago
@MuhaddithDotOrg Well in retrospect I take no offense when people question religions. I am a Muslim and this issue about Aisha made me curious. We must understand the ambiguous nature of society, so I don't apply cultural aspects to Prophet Muhammad because he sets those principles. Therefore if Prophet Muhammad did something he believed to be morally correct than it should apply to every1 even if it deals with Aisha. I don't believe he consummated her at that age because it is morally wrong.
theyasin33 1 year ago
@theyasin33 I am sure we both agree that the consummation occured between 2 mature adults, period.
MuhaddithDotOrg 1 year ago
@MuhaddithDotOrg Yes I do..
theyasin33 1 year ago
yes im sometimes too shy to ask questions but not this question, because i already understand it i mean how could u compare something that happened thousands of years ago to now ! people change, our ways of thinking change everything is changing . people over the centuries never asked why did mohammed marry a young girl so that means that it was something normal at that time and it started to change by time
92whatever 2 years ago
@frid9999
U R in stubborn denial, regurgitating points debunked in our 2 videos.
Our magnificient prophet defined what's lawful:
RESPONSIBLE MARRIAGE COMMITMENT btwn adults (Aisha was more mature than U R, sorry to have noticed it).
He also defined what is NOT allowable:
Adultery, homosexuality, bestiality& fornication - whether among adults or among minors.
You remain disturbingly silent concerning fornication between teenagers & hypoctically critical of responsible marriage commitment.
MuhaddithDotOrg 2 years ago
@frid9999
u got no point of insulting early marriages of Prophet Muhammad -,-
at the time Muhammad ask for marry Aisha, Aisha already matured. Muhammad treat Aisha nicely and they live happily... indeed.
So, there is no point insult their marriages..
go get a new point dude -,-
PreciousDetective,
KeepTheTruth,
HATE ME xD
PreciousDetective 2 years ago
frid9999
Prophets are sent for legalising all that is supposed to be done by mankind after them.There are circumstances when some rules can be restricted but the prohibitions are to be respected as prohibitions from God.
What Prophet legalised by marrying a woman who was 15 yrs older than him and a woman who was much younger than him was , that AGE IS NO BAR IN MARRIAGE FOR TWO CONSENTING ADULTS.
farzanatasneem 2 years ago
frid9999
womhist . alexanderstreet . com /teacher/aoc . htm
Read woman history in America after removing the SPACES
Campaign to Raise the Legal Age of Consent, 1885-1914
American reformers were shocked to discover that the laws of most states set the age of consent at the age of ten or twelve, and in one state, Delaware, the age of consent was only seven
That was before 1920 very near isn't it?!!
farzanatasneem 2 years ago
Aysha was so smart 1 of the smartest women in the world ever
BrotherSkillz 2 years ago
92w - 1
Our video CITES her own words: She considered herself the luckiest person in the world.
Enemies of truth have the guts to twist it and claim she was forced. Our videos are directed to impartial reasonable persons seeking the truth, and it is clear as daylight here. The others are simply hate mongers following the lowest impulses possible for of the human soul: Hatred, bigotry, racism, all leading them to permit themselves to difigure the truth.
MuhaddithDotOrg 2 years ago
92w -2
Furthermore, our video also states how she alluded to the Prophet that she was shy to express her consent:
"But the maiden is shy to accept (verbally)"
upon which he said: The virgin's silence is the indication of her approval. (If she did not like that marriage, she would need be shy to say: NO! )
MuhaddithDotOrg 2 years ago
92w - 3
Finally, not one of these hypocrites WILL EVER BE ABLE TO BRING 1 SINGLE CRITICISM ABOUT THIS ISSUE BEFORE THIS CENTURY:
We R not defending a man: We R defending all past humanity against hypocrites of the century of pornography, gay marriage, bestiality, etc.
They R simply the LEAST qualified to discuss this subject, but all they care is fabricate attackss.
The challenge remains solid as a mountain: If it is immoral, why didn't the enemies of Muhamad criticize it FOR 14 centuries?!
MuhaddithDotOrg 2 years ago
good video thanks for ploading it =)
92whatever 2 years ago
styl does dis men da propht could marry er wen she was 9 or sumat while he was 53 sumat? he was old enough 2 be er grandad .
das wa i don understand evendow da am a muslim ma self.
afghanhuman 2 years ago
shawnlshs - and WOW ur such a loser...
just think of the time it was, and how long the people lived until they were 30...
and if u havent noticed... more than half of the catholic priests in the 21century, a molesting, and raping lil boys and girls... now thats JUST SICK !!! u wana judge a Prophet and his life 1500yrs ago... start judging them instead...
pwincessZsugarz 2 years ago
MASALLAH...VERY NICE....
tatlifanatiksongul 2 years ago
All I can say is WOW. This is probably the worst excuse for Muhammad sexually assulting young girls. And the fact that the video is giving reasons why it is acceptable makes it all that more disgusting. Just sick.
shawnlshs 2 years ago
lol oh gosh...... r u really that narrow minded... considering the life span that many yrs ago, was min 30yrs... and if a women is not ready or mature enough to bare children, she wouldnt of had her periods. and at the beginning when her family asked her to marry him, she didnt respond, she didnt start living with the prophet until she was older...
And also, what do u say about all the catholic priests who molest children, and shaytan is, the devil, u have clearly done ur research.. NOT!!!
pwincessZsugarz 2 years ago
When a Muslim man commits a crime what do Christians do? They blame Islam as a whole even though it wasn't an Islamic act . When Jesus tells Christians to worship God (ALLAH) what do the Christians do? they worship Jesus instead. When talk of the prophet Muhammad (PBUH) rises what do Christians have to say? Child Molester. Not all Christians are bad.
Fullmetalsnake54 2 years ago
What point are you trying to make? Are you saying Muhammed was just another muslim man?
The man sexually assaulted a 6 year old girl. He also traded human slaves. If he was a prophet of a just and existing god don't you think this god would have said something to him about his evil behaviour?
frid9999 2 years ago
Excuse my comment yesterday I was just really angry. Anyways I do think Muhammad was judged based on his actions both good and bad.
Fullmetalsnake54 2 years ago
@frid9999
and who told u that ? give me proof
sazzy949 2 years ago
@ sazzy
> and who told u that ? give me proof
1. re. thighing 6 year old Aisha, this fatwa from the grand Mufti Abu Abdullah Muhammad Al-Shemary: "As for the prophet [pbuh], thighing his fiancée Aisha. She was six years of age and he could not have intercourse with her due to her small age. That is why [the prophet, pbuh] placed his [male] member between ber thighs and massaged it softly"
2. re. Muhammed selling a free man back into slavery, see Bukhari Volume 3, Book 41, Number 598.
frid9999 2 years ago
@frid9999 - you ignorant ignorant ignorant person, i feel sorry for ppl like YOU.
@ Herman47 - loll, she actually didnt start living with prophet Muhammed (pbuh) until she was older, & she chose not to remarry out of respect for prophet Muhammed (pbuh) if she wanted to she could of. but she chose to spread the word of islam.
& we use the (p.b.u.h stuff out of respect.) not sure if u no wat that is. but maybe u shuld google it.. instead of Theodor H. Vandevelde. hilarious. u uneducated retards.
pwincessZsugarz 2 years ago
Prophet Muhammad------->A Child Fucking Pile Of Shit That Founded A Blood Thirsty Religion!
DenyTheHolySpirit 2 years ago
Holy fuck! This nutbag is using the quran to try to justify child rape!
frid9999 2 years ago
Child rape child rape child rape that's all you Christians bring up everyday. You see Jesus said to the people that claim to be his followers to worship God but instead they worship Jesus. Its like asking your son to hand you a pen but he hands you damn knife this pretty much sums up Christianity as a whole. I hope I don't go to hell for this but Christianity is corrupted and I'm beginning to believe the Bible is written through the lies of Shaytan.
Fullmetalsnake54 2 years ago
I have no idea who Shaytan is, but I agree with you, Christianity is bullshit.
But what does this have to do with Muhammed's sexual assault of 6 year old Aisha?
frid9999 2 years ago
She wasn't 6 ;)
BulgyVeins 2 years ago
@BulgyVeins Al Bukhari narrated (hadeeth 3683): He married Aishah (radi Allahu 'anha) when she was six years old, and consummated the marriage when she was nine.
Also narrated in Al Mustadrak, 6715/2313 and multitude of other hadeeth compilations.
Ammyai 2 years ago
yes she was 6 years old but not when he married her but when he proposed it's called "khotba" in arabic , the period of time before getting married is "the period of khotba"
92whatever 2 years ago
it's not child rape don't u get it, back then that's how things were , girls used to get married when they were very young thats how it was u can't change the past , if u come to my country u'll see that most of the old women here got married when they were 13, thats how it was 50 years ago , but now most girls don't want to get married untill they're above 19 . it's all about time and cultures , the more time passes by the more people change and the way of thinking changes =)
92whatever 2 years ago
What you are saying makes no sense 92w. Having sex with children is having sex with children whether it occured 10 days or 10 centuries ago. Everything we know about children's brains proves that 6 (or 9) year-olds can not possibly have the mental capacity to make an informed decision to marry or have sex (thighing). Tradition is irrelevant. This is about raping children. Do you think it is okay for man to thigh a 6 year old today? Then why do you think it is okay 1300 years ago?
frid9999 2 years ago
if u bring a girl who is 10 years old now and a girl who was 10 thousands of years ago do u think that they would be the same ?? girls back then didn't think like how girls think now ,another thing is that girls who are from the middle east reach the age of puberty faster than girls who are from ur side of the world,for example my friend reached that stage when she was 10 but with most girls when they get 11,and it's know that when u reach that stage ur way of thinking totally changes u grow up
92whatever 2 years ago
Oh come on 92w, you are simply grasping at straws. We are talking about a 6 year old girl being forced into a sexual relationship with a 51 year old man. Your excuses are pathetic. Muhammed was a pedophile - as simple as that. It may have been the custom of the Arabian savages of the time, but that is no excuse. If there was a real god and he was just, he would have told muhammed that thighing little girls is wrong!
frid9999 2 years ago
she wasn't forced he proposed to her father "abo baker alsedeeq" and then they got married and he didn't have any sexual relationship with her until she was about 10, anyways u don't have to understand this and u don't have to accept it because it already happened i guess nobody understans this except for us muslims and that's okay =) i just want u to know that i don't have any hard feelings for u or anyone no matter what his believes are ,after all we all live in the same world, have a good day
92whatever 2 years ago
First, if it's claimed that a society needs many children to survive, then it's utterly stupid for a six-year old to be marrying a sick 50+ year-old bastard. Aisha wound up having NO CHILDREN! No surprise, Muhammad's fecundity was waning, and she was only 6! Muhammad wound up dying when she was around 18, but she could not remarry! Of course, if she had gotten married at around 18 to say an 18 year old, how many children do you think she would have had?
Herman47 2 years ago
if muhammad pbuh wants money and wealth, he would not reject the offer from Quraish tribe, to have the highest position of the quraish tribe, all the wealth they have and all the women,if only he(Muhammad pbuh) would shut up and stop preaching,
but he reject all of it!!! (wealth/pleasure/power)
a liar or a bad person wont reject all that, only a man of truth and faith in god would and that is Muhammad pbuh.
rubae2004 2 years ago
Being the narcissist that he was, what Muhammad wanted most (besides the sex) was the adulation of all those gullible enough to believe everything Muhammad tells them to believe (you know, guys like you, who use that "pbuh" stuff). Now Muhammad isn't going to be getting all that adulation if he shuts up, right?
Herman47 2 years ago
Comment removed
themanishere4 2 years ago
On positive role of age difference in marriage Western academic speaking on this issue; the work is Theodor H. Vandevelde, Ideal Marriage: Its Physiology and Technique "When the differences (in ages) is great, e.g. exceeds fifteen to twenty years, the results may be happier. The marriage of an elderly (senescent) not, of course, an old (senile) man to a quite young girl, is often very successful and harmonious. The bride is immediately introduced and accustomed to moderate sexual intercourse."
themanishere4 2 years ago
Even if we accept your premise that a large age difference between spouses "MAY be happier," a premise I highly doubt, we must also consider human mortality here. Aisha & Muhammad were married for what, 9 years? HOW MANY DECADES DID AISHA ENDURE AS AN UNMARRIED WIDOW? Muslims believe that Muhammad was the best role model, setting a wise example for Muslims to follow. There are videos on youtube about 50+ year old Muslim men marrying 9 year old girls. How do you think that's going to work out?
Herman47 2 years ago
In Islam the special reason the Prophet was able to marry more then the usual limit of 4 wives was for resolving political tribal issues via marriages. This was also common in European societies. Many of the Prophet's marriages where either to take care of someone (his older wives like Safiyyah) or to strengthen bonds across tribes and families like Aisha, etc.
themanishere4 2 years ago
facts
- christians produce and consume the most alcohol in the world
- christians build and frequent the most gambling casinos in the world
- christians encourage the most sex outside of marriage in the world
- christians glorify adultery in media the most in the world
- christian women feature the most in adult porn and child porn
== by their fruits you will know them ==
theklux 2 years ago
Comment removed
theklux 2 years ago
h t t p : / / w w w . math . utep . edu / Faculty / sewell / articles / mathint . html
Kindly visit this site too for crushing ATHEISM and refer it to others
Wassalam
ThankAllahAlways 2 years ago
VISIT THIS SITE
AND REFER IT TO OTHERS
(to continue crushing atheism & evolutionists)
w w w .ridgecrest . ca . us / ~do_while / sage / newsletters . htm
(remove all spaces from the above link)
MuhaddithDotOrg 2 years ago
excellent video. its a pity how some ppl will carry on being blind and ignorant to their own opinion which quite frankly, most of the times is BASELESS. even if 10 times more information was provided for them as evidence, they still wont believe due to their ignorant nature! may Allah SWT guide us all.
fredsta786 2 years ago
This is a good upload,except for the music!
41moment 2 years ago
Assalamoalaikum
Visit this site and refer it to others to combat Atheism
h t t p : / / w w w . ridgecrest . ca . us / ~ do _ while / sage / newsletters . htm
Space is supposed to be removed to get the site
Salam
ThankAllahAlways 2 years ago
@ThankAllahAlways
thanks...
since enemies of truth tried to "spam" your comment, we copied it as one of OUR comments.
Keep it up.
MuhaddithDotOrg 2 years ago
@MuhaddithDotOrg
Jazakallahu Khair .
ThankAllahAlways 2 years ago
@arseneltic - What's pathetic is you having to repeat your post like 4 times because you're not getting the attention you want. LOL.
psychlopes1976 2 years ago
@psychlopes1976Look it really doesn't matter you are so brainwashed that you just can't hear
arseneltic 2 years ago
It's actually you who is brain washed. Your answer was in the vid, also Aisha wasn't the prophet's niece, which shows how little you know about anything. Watch the vid again, I'm sure no matter how thick you are eventually you will understand what is being said.
psychlopes1976 2 years ago
Alhamdulillah, very nice video, it provces that Islam is the most modern religion. What non muslims are doing today, Islam did 1400 yeard ago.
After seeing this, all non Muslims will shut their mouth, if not, it will prove their ignorance, and further prove that Islam is the only true religion.
srizki 2 years ago
@srizki Hahahahaha what a load of bullshit. I supose that Islam created Industrial Revolution & Nuclear Age 1400 years ago? It`s amazing (& pathetic) how ignorant people gloat about their "knowledge"...hahahahaha
skepticaldemocrat 2 years ago
Excellent Video brother may Allah reward you with the highest station in Paradise for defending His Prophet and His Prophet's Religion and Family! Ameen!
mpenbs 2 years ago
dirty propaganda!
petrichanin 2 years ago
prove it.
BeNGALi4LFE 2 years ago
may i ask do u belive in a stone god because if u do u need to learn
darklords123 2 years ago
Muslims don't believe in any stone or idol or anything created.
They believe in the oneness of God (Allah) and worship Him only.
sal786912 2 years ago
"Prophet's (pbuh) Marriage to Aisha (ra) - Dr. Ali Shehata"
An amazing lecture with PowerPoint given by Dr. Ali Shehata on Prophet Muhammad's (pbuh) Marriage to Aisha (ra). Dr. Ali discusses the noble character of the Prophet (pbuh), the authentic historical record of this matter, the cultural views in his era, the medical aspects related to puberty, a better understand of what constitutes pedophilia and the reasons behind the recent surge of relentless attacks on the Prophet (pbuh).
khalifahklothing 2 years ago
i liked this video very much
it is good explanation and response
jazak Allah
algarbio 2 years ago
stop following any source of law instead of the quran...it is shirk.
visitoroftheworlds 2 years ago
some muslim friends (girls ) told me in their book its mentioned that jesus is THE SPIRIT OF GOD and its mentioned that GOD SAID TO HIS MOTHER (before his birth ) YOUR BOY IS WORD OF GOD ok no problem but what is the real prophetic.. ? THE SPIRIT AND THE WORD ( OF ) GOD or just a spirit n a word ( FROM ) god !!! ??? . I realy dont know y to some friends its very hard !?
1989Alcira 2 years ago
we've only two problems with our muslim friends, FIRST problem , they cant understand y we say father , son n holly spirit they think we have three gods No our friends its a trope expression like when u say to any citizen of mecca son of mecca is thats mean mecca is a father ? of course not so its only 1 god but appeared in the body of jesus and the word of god appeared in jesus too
1989Alcira 2 years ago
1989Alcira
you wrote: "when u say to any citizen of mecca son of mecca is thats mean mecca is a father ? of course not..."
you are right about one thing...for the Hebrew people who heard Jesus say he is the son of God, they knew he was speaking figuratively...and when he was accused of being the literal son of God, he referred them to the Old Test where the Jews were called the children of God (btw, Adam is called the firstborn son of God in the Bible).
Jesus is a prophet, not God.
Islam4Dummiez 2 years ago
dear friend u got my comments wrong so plz read them again but this time read very carefully , i didnt say body of god but i said spirit of god n word of god thats y we see the facilities and the features of god are only inside him as a spirit n word not his body
1989Alcira 2 years ago
1989Alcira
1- Who cares what U say, when CHRISTIANS believe in THE TRINITY?
2- Tell us, is Jesus GOD (according to U) or not? Is he DIVINE, YES or NO?
If U say yes, then Islam4Dummies' comment remains valid (& your words R just a diversions, trying to pull the wool in front of our eyes).
And if you say no, then welcome to Islam.
3- Show us that Jesus said what you're claiming: "God is appearing in my body", and "the word of God appeared in me".
If it's IMPORTANT he should have said it CLEARLY.
MuhaddithProject 2 years ago
i dont no why u always like to change the subject which is ''ISLAM IS NOT BASED ON NEW THINGS OR UNIUQE THINGS''
Adam or any1 is a soul FROM god but not the god's SOUAL ''it self ''
1989Alcira 2 years ago
1989Alcira
So show us where Jesus said SO ARTICULATELY that he is GOD'S SOUL (and not a soul from God).
In the meantime, Muslims have always showed Christians that Jesus says THE FATHER IS GREATER THAN I AM, and that he said WHY DO YOU CALL ME GOOD, ONLY THE FATHER IS GOOD.
Now meet our challenge and produce the claim of divinity. IF IT IS IMPORTANT HE SHOULD HAVE MADE IT CLEAR AS DAYLIGHT.
MuhaddithDotOrg 2 years ago
ha now i knew way you dont want to believe.. because you are looking for challenge , religion or faith is not a matter of challenge its just this simple TAKE IT OR LEAVE IT ( up to your deep heart ) wish u..good luck
1989Alcira 2 years ago
1989Alcira
You say take it or leave it.
Well sorry to disappoint you, we take faith from UNEQ?UIVOCAL words of proven prophets:
1- You failed to provide UNEQUIVOCAL WORDS from Jesus.
2- Instead, you present YOUR words from you to us, to take or leave!!!! And of course we refuse you completely.
3- Worst of all, YOU ARE CONTRADICTING THE COMMANDS OF JESUS, by claiming he is God.
MuhaddithDotOrg 2 years ago
"YOU ARE CONTRADICTING THE COMMANDS OF JESUS, by claiming he is God. "
You are totally wrong, Jesus made it very clear on many occations that He is God.
And He never ever claimed Not to be God. You make errors because you do not know Real Scripture.
Ammyai 2 years ago
no dear i know of course i know but i've to explain it by simple way to our dear muslim friends
1989Alcira 2 years ago
ISA(LORD) relating GOD SHIVA is a phallic bi-sexual GOD far older then JESUS could ever be dating back several 1000 years in INDIA. I do find this SHIVA down right a scary thought to the truth JESUS is not a real prophet nor would exist as a SHIVA GOD. Im sure CHRISTIAN and MUSLIMS have to agree something is so wrong in this connection.
POWERequalsGOD 2 years ago
I never saw anywhere in the scriptures where he says I AM GOD..
all the other supposed evidence is purely interpolated distortions of "I AM" or other ambiguous statements
MuTaziliTajdid 2 years ago
lol many occasions?
LOLOLOLOLOL
please indulge me
birchissaud 2 years ago
Ammyai
1- Jesus absolutely never claimed divinity.
2- His words maintained otherwise, that ONLY THE FATHER IS GOOD!!!
3- His actions proved otherwise: Look, he used to eat, AND THEREFORE GO TO THE TOILET :) :) :)...
THIS IS NOT A GOD. WAKE UP.
WE DEFINITELY RECFUSE TO WORSHIP A GOD THAT PRODUCES EXCREMENTS, that even a plant does not produce. Go worship a tree, it's cleaner!!! We venerate Jesus, you insult him.
MuhaddithDotOrg 2 years ago
Isa means Lord or God. Hence its name itself is indicative of its importance i.e. It is named as Gods Upanishads. Like the Kena Upanishad, the Isa Upanishad takes its name from its first word, Isa. Isa Upanishad is said to be the essence of all Upanishad teachings so far as practical life is concerned. It is comparatively a very short Upanishad, though it is an integral gospel. ISA is the name Muslims give to JESUS so how is JESUS not LORD or GOD in the QURAN. So how is ALLAH and ISA the same?
POWERequalsGOD 2 years ago
Sanskrit words don't mean the same thing in Arabic. In Arabic 3isa, means "plea"., as in "pleaing for God". Therefore this comparison lacks cohesion
MuTaziliTajdid 2 years ago
Ok, lets say I agree. If the Bible states Mary and Joseph were Jews an circumcised JESUS as JEW. Theres no way on Earth MARY being the MOTHER of JESUS would dare name JESUS (ISA). The name ISA or ISSA would mean WOMAN. Blaspemous!!! JESUS does claim the FATHER and I are 1 in the BIBLE but no where does JESUS call himself a WOMAN!! Even the GREEK language of the NEW TESTAMENT would obvious see the error of using ISSA. Only the QURAN claims the use of ISA in no way knowing MARY's opinion.
POWERequalsGOD 2 years ago
'Isa is just the Arabic pronounciation of Yeshua (Hebrew) or Yesu (Aramaic), This wasn't an uncommon name, in fact Yashua, is just a form of Joshua. Furthermore the "Isa" of the Sanskrit literature is doesn't have the same consonants as Arabic or Hebrew. The Greek is just a translation of Aramaic. There is no connection to Sanrkit
MuTaziliTajdid 2 years ago
The ARABIC language is also subject to foreign words introduced without knowing the origin or meaning. The linguistic origin of ISA or ISSA can be found related to a woman by looking at names of women themselves have acquired. The obvious denial ISA means WOMAN or LORD -GOD in SANSKRIT is the serious attempt to misrepresent the Quran's own truth. JESUS being called ISA introduces JESUS is actually a WOMAN not a MAN's name. GREEKS/ROMAN/JEWS never named JESUS ISA.
POWERequalsGOD 2 years ago
Of course; but that's not an indicator that this word is from Sanskrit, for example 'Isa means to "One who Cries Out for Help"; as you said Isa in Sanskrit LITERALLY means Lord. , Is not necessarily a woman's name in Arabic, not sure how you derived that.
Like I said , 'Isa is just the Arabic pronunciation of the Aramaic word Yesu, Aramaic and Arabic are closely related languages. Sanskrit is not. the Qur'an isn't in Sanskrit so your point doesn't cohere with evidence.
MuTaziliTajdid 2 years ago