Added: 4 years ago
From: coloraturafan
Views: 8,093
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (46)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Serra has such clear voice. a rare voice. brava. UNIQUE

  • ABFAB!!

  • Serra is the best. She won this contest. No question.

  • continuo a ripetere sempre le stesse cose )))) perche è cosi poco nominata ? perche non è cosi spesso in telivisione ...

  • forse perchè non le interessa l'apparire....

  • Non è brava!!! Di più!!! Un mostro sacro della lirica. Voce focussatissima sempre sostenuta e un timbro brillante che farebbe invidia ad un pettirosso.

  • Wow, its like a machine, fantastic !!!

    Thank you very much for posting it !

  • Ms. Serra did a marvelous job with piece. Her voice does not record particularly because of the abundant high formants that are natural to her instrument, however she brings a great balance of depth and brilliance to even out her tone. Not to mention she has one of the most flexible and agile of voices paired with an EXCELLENT technique. Her command of coloratura passages and phrasing overshadow her lack of a true trill :-) This video is an absolute pleasure to listen to. 5/5

  • The coloratura is forever unsurpassed!

  • Incredible voice. Thanks! My gold is for Luciana Serra.

  • Yeah, I give her silver for this contest, Sutherland gets gold

  • I totally agree! U r right! Dame Joan the greatest; great Luciana a wonderful, incredible, second prize!

  • OMG! This woman's voice is a flute! I prefer for this role a more lyric voice, but this is perfect!

  • Maravilloso.

  • thanks coloraturafan !

  • Great!!!! SE WON THE CONTEST!

  • Davvero grandissima: leggiadra, squillante, favolosa nelle agilità! Peccato che, come spesso le accade(va), ometta bellamente i trilli!

  • Vorrei tanto essere la bambina che le tiene lo strascico...

  • Haahahahahah! Sono d'accordissimo!

  • This may be a very very traditional and not very exciting staging but for once the veiled Enrichetta di Francia looks like Elvira, making it plausible that Arturo could escape with her. Serra sings accurately with a voice that may resemble the coloratura sopranos of the middle 19th century, who sang with as little vibrato as possible and with flute like tones (according to contemporary reports).

  • Perfect high note at 2:33

  • Yes, I marvel over that note every time I listen to Serra sing this. Hence my previous comment, her voice often sounds trumpet or even flute-like and its very clean and precise.

  • Oh wow! What a delightful contrast to that filthy whore Netrebko. I'm so glad I watched this after the super slutty farce by Netrebko! Really what a fantastic clean performance.

  • I agree that Serra is much better suited for this role than Netrebko, but insulting Netrebko in such a way you do, does not resemble any civilisation you might expect from an opera lover. Please mind you language.

  • Verdaderamente stupenda !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Of course in my opinion Luciana Serra won this contest ;-)

  • Wonderful performance full of passion, great Luciana Serra

  • Sharp, harsh and 'bold' of tone. It lacks real beauty and warmth (like Sutherland, Devia, Massis and Jo). Her technique although is to be respected! 2.5/4.5

  • I really enjoyed this - it's so bright and exciting. She does have a look of Bette Midler!

  • stupenda but gruberova is better ^_^

  • I agree! 4.5/4.5

  • She's such a trumpet. 4/5

  • 3.5/4

  • Occasionally shrill, but memorable vocalism. 4/4

  • Love this performance. Serra's voice never recorded well, so much better heard live.

    Netrebko should listen to this so hears how it sound be sung. 5/5

  • 4/4. I've always been a fan of hers.

  • This is about as good as it gets for Serra. There is NO hint of out of control high notes or wayward pitch that seem to haunt her whole career. She was obviously having a good nite. 5/4

  • She has a very brassy voice, almost like Ethel Merman, and her acting is like a small-town drawing room warbler. But I do get a kick out of you -- er, her. 3/3

  • Fantastica!

    grazie grazie grazie

  • One really misses the trills I must admit, but overall Luciana is charming here. 3/4.5

  • uh, no trill - at all.

  • Yeah, she has no trill, so I try not to hold that against her. She kind of makes up for that with a pretty solid technique.

  • 4.5/5. I think Kunde here is even better.

  • Madame Serra is amazing though I sometimes think she's being slightly shrill here

    4.5/5

  • I remember asking you to post this clip months ago, coloraturafan, when you did the "Vien, diletto e in ciel" contest. Great to see that it's finally up! 4.5/5.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more