the harmony from/with the anonymous backing vocals is of course what makes this such a magic tune...I get it why DB had her in the back, his sense of humor. But holy $%^@ she really did justice to his chord changes eh!? Who was/is she?
Not the most original Talking Heads song, but Talking Heads is the most original band ever in my view. Name one band that is or were as innovating as them? They sounded like nothing else!
Stop Making Sense is the best live rock gig on tape period. Talking Heads wouldnt be my number 1 favourite band, i do like them a lot though, but this gig is extraordinary.
As for Tina Weymouth, she is a great bass player. She wouldn't be in the band if she wasn't. He's playing accoustic here so she has to simplify her style to suit the song. Otherwise the bass would dominate the song and the song would suffer as a result.
Saw this concert in the Capitol cinema in Cork, when it first came out. The whole cinema got up and danced in the isles. Amazing concert, fantastic band.
Flame away youtube trolls... hahahahahahahahaha! Talking heads are the shit, regardless of whether or not you think the bass player drags, or is playing with the wrong finger -- they are a band, and a great band, I feel it is unfair to judge them individually. Plus, it is hard to play with a singer/strummer and no drums! Maybe she is trying to keep it from rushing
I disagree with the comment about her bass playing. In this song, she hangs deliberately off the beat by about a sixteenth, it's what gives the whole track it's helpless, eventless flavour, hence the marked look of concetration on her face: whilst she technically leads, she also has to follow Byrne's playing.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Okay, I love the Talking Heads, I love David Byrne, Tina, all the band.
But one thing bugs me.
They're all awesome composers, but Tina is a terrible bass player. She just can't seem to grasp interchanging strings, and she plays her E string and A string with her Thumb (Whereas not a terrible thing) she is terribly sluggish on changes on strings.
And no, I'm not hating, she plays some great stuff, just not well (From fellow bass player PoV)
Where are the backup vocals coming from? Tina doesn't move her mouth once. I wonder about what else in this movie is just coming from the sound board.
does anyone know when/where this was recorded. It looks a lot like the orpheus (sp?) in Boston bout 81 or 82. I saw that concert, but gosh for some reason just don't remember all the details, except of course that it kicked ass and took me a few days to recover. in college at the time. Anyone?
That would be guitarist/keyboardist and back-up vocalist Jerry Harrison. He remains off camera for this song (his instrument isn't used - just Byrne's guitar and Tina's base). He enters at the end of the next song, "Thank You For Sending Me An Angel".
Can anybody give me the Q lazzarus version of this song.... this was a part of the philedelphia ost ... but i never found that version... I ll qwe u one for life
i wish this song to be my funeral song ... along with others. i love talking heads so much. they remind me of my family every time i listen to 'em. we all always sing along to the tunes but, this one's the heart wrencher! cheers and much, much love to eveyone! hugs! :)
My band and I played this in the mid-80s (I forget which year) at a benefit concert for an AIDS hospice in a NYC bar. I sang lead vocals and our woman guitarist (we had three guitars, I was rhythm only, and we had two leads, one man and one woman, who swapped off lead roles depending on the song) sang backup. The crowd was so quiet you could hear a pin drop. Then they started waving lighters and I almost cried it was so beautiful. What a great song, an all-time classic.
this is the most beautiful song. i dont care what it is about but it makes me remember a time in my life and i love that time. i put my emotions into this music and that is why i love it. perfection in imperfection.
Really great - thanks for posting. This was definitely the highight of SMS for me. Is Tina awesome or what? I would love to see footage of the full electric version of this track.
When does Tina do that voodoo/pogo/80's dance? I think it's later when she does the Tom Tom Club bit w/ her now hubby, Chris Frantz on drums. "we lost our heads when we took cocaine". Muh, hummideh, muh hummedeh...
pintilism is a placid point to, up, look. one said there was look, there's a dead bird. they looked up. my favourite soup, must be a soup, with lentils are happenin'
the name of the bar is called heaven...........heaven is a gay club in london for those who don't know.songs about getting pissed in a gay bar in london,great song btw
because that's what someone does when they like a club: they write a song about it and say that nothing ever happens there. and that everyone leaves at exactly the same time. you're right, it's totally about the club, nothing more. especially considering how david byrne's lyrics are always simple and straightforward like that. yeah, that makes sense.
yes,becuase in the uk when this was wrote all clubs kicked everyone out 1 AM.get the dvd and listen to the band commentary where the band stae what this song is about.......a gay club in london called heaven.
it's kinda funny to have the backing vocals offstage when you think about it. The way they did show was very much what you see is what you get, like in for some purist film makers, only playing music when the musician/music players were being being filmed.
Anyway, I was at one of those concerts in Providence RI (sept 1982). Anybody else still alive?
Dude they are brilliant! look at my taste music!!1 I include all types of rock even things you cant place in this genre!!!! Love this song!!!! asdfjkbwhjitugjklgjbhoigujhbh
Bass is the center of the music. It's a rhythm AND a melody instrument, so it ties the leads and rhythm together. I'm a bassist, so i guess i'm a bit biased, but bass itsself seems like the glue to me.
I will guarantee you that drummers, guitar players and lead singers will say the same thing about themselves. No one ever talks about the cowbell player!
always fancied Tina, then she married that geek drummer grrrrr
gards2 1 month ago
this could be the anthem of end 70's and 80's..love you Tina Weymouth forever...your funky bass rymed all along my days to grow up..xxx
waterloo2003 3 years ago
GREAT!
geothehitman 3 years ago
beautiful
marsvoltaguy 3 years ago
too right
geothehitman 3 years ago
oh..just read the initial responses. It's so mean she was off stage. hee hee
darcsaster 3 years ago
the harmony from/with the anonymous backing vocals is of course what makes this such a magic tune...I get it why DB had her in the back, his sense of humor. But holy $%^@ she really did justice to his chord changes eh!? Who was/is she?
darcsaster 3 years ago 2
THE BAR IS CALLED HEAVEN!!!!!
Inveridiot 3 years ago
Aagh! Oh my gosh, I had totally forgotten how much I love this song!
xrockangelx 3 years ago
Heaven is NOW!
134being 3 years ago
be kind to silver and he will respect you
dumpkinson 3 years ago
Its a toss up between this and songbird(fleetwood mac) as to which song im going to get buried too. Both are beautiful.
colinslimline 3 years ago
how about 'and she was' ?
also talking heads .
great song to get buried to .
taniajosefa 3 years ago
so nice!!
i love the youtube-community!
let peace rule
and heaven is in reach!
love & light,
goaholix 3 years ago
Lol look at the Tina Weymouth's head at 0:11 she suddenly grows a pair of white eyebrows which dissapear almost instantly xD
Diimpy 3 years ago 2
WOAH wtf! I saw it too! That's weird.
SenorSlopez 3 years ago
It's deep ! "Everyone wants reach heaven". I loved it.
piorgus 3 years ago
I wonder who was the back up vocal. Just about the best song I have heard in a long time.
sixstringfender 3 years ago
I actually went and saw this film at the Library of Congress a couple weeks ago and they actually never show the person doing the backup vocals.
PantsSquad 3 years ago
Not the most original Talking Heads song, but Talking Heads is the most original band ever in my view. Name one band that is or were as innovating as them? They sounded like nothing else!
pinheadsen 3 years ago
"...heaven is a place where love is...! Fab song!
RedBreenie 3 years ago
this tune is sex
artikal 3 years ago
My favourite song
CROMPTON761 3 years ago
Dude, Tina Weymouth is one of my favorite bass players. Right up there next to John Taylor, Flea, and Steve Harris, at least in my mind...
Sauron338 3 years ago 6
Don't forget John Entwhistle. Man is a legend. Tina is great too though :D
F22RaptorSquadron 3 years ago
Stop Making Sense is the best live rock gig on tape period. Talking Heads wouldnt be my number 1 favourite band, i do like them a lot though, but this gig is extraordinary.
angryadams 3 years ago
Yes, This one moves even me! Go David B.
kiwiaress 3 years ago
so !@&# good
svennar1 3 years ago
Just covered this song at 4:30 in the morning..ha.
Come check it out, it's one of my all time favorite songs....
GiveAwayThePlot 3 years ago
Yeah great song and so true.
Snarlez 3 years ago
It dont get any better than this,,,,,huge respect.
archiecat989 3 years ago
i love this song ots soooo good
danyella1993 3 years ago
Actually, I like how she mixes it up a bit in this rendition.
If she didn't, it may sound too simple/ 'flat'.
Adds character.
bubblerings 3 years ago
As for Tina Weymouth, she is a great bass player. She wouldn't be in the band if she wasn't. He's playing accoustic here so she has to simplify her style to suit the song. Otherwise the bass would dominate the song and the song would suffer as a result.
munsterfloyd 3 years ago 3
Saw this concert in the Capitol cinema in Cork, when it first came out. The whole cinema got up and danced in the isles. Amazing concert, fantastic band.
munsterfloyd 3 years ago
the greatest band EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEver!!!
Inveridiot 3 years ago 2
I fucking love Talking Heads and this is the perfect concert
pigyob 3 years ago 5
yes it is, pigyob.
eclecticbgirl 3 years ago
Flame away youtube trolls... hahahahahahahahaha! Talking heads are the shit, regardless of whether or not you think the bass player drags, or is playing with the wrong finger -- they are a band, and a great band, I feel it is unfair to judge them individually. Plus, it is hard to play with a singer/strummer and no drums! Maybe she is trying to keep it from rushing
mackgrout 3 years ago 2
I disagree with the comment about her bass playing. In this song, she hangs deliberately off the beat by about a sixteenth, it's what gives the whole track it's helpless, eventless flavour, hence the marked look of concetration on her face: whilst she technically leads, she also has to follow Byrne's playing.
Shroomseleven 3 years ago 3
Exactly right, it's called back beat, you play behind the beat to create tension with the song.
davideirth 3 years ago
Better than the album version.
ROCK5LIN 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Okay, I love the Talking Heads, I love David Byrne, Tina, all the band.
But one thing bugs me.
They're all awesome composers, but Tina is a terrible bass player. She just can't seem to grasp interchanging strings, and she plays her E string and A string with her Thumb (Whereas not a terrible thing) she is terribly sluggish on changes on strings.
And no, I'm not hating, she plays some great stuff, just not well (From fellow bass player PoV)
Flame away Youtube trolls.
Shaybot 3 years ago
I don't agree.
(From fellow bass player POV)
jdodd82 3 years ago 2
I agree, Tina is to bass guitar what Ringo is to drums!
shannpe 3 years ago
Byrne did say that all the members of the band were miles apart, musically.
SlyVictim 3 years ago
i dream of heaven!
lonfia 3 years ago
I love Tina Weymouth :D :D :D :D
TheDancingRaikage 3 years ago
Splendida Lina al basso!
chiamamenestore 3 years ago
Tebgo una copia en VHS de este concierto STOP MAKING SENSE que compré en un viaje a Madrid hace ya más de una década... Y aún me sigue fascinando e
inspirando.
Jonathan Demme y Talkind Heads, IMPRESCINDIBLE.
betashure 3 years ago
Fallos de ortografía por doquier...Imaginaos que escribo casi a las cinco de la mañana.
Imaginaos que el cielo es un lugar donde nunca sucede nada...
betashure 3 years ago
Byrne is one of the few true genius of last century in the music world. Peace.
rockaires 3 years ago
my favourite version, by far
(desert island play list)
anybody know whether Edna or Lynn took the back-up?
classof80extant 3 years ago
What concert is this from?
phausser 3 years ago 2
This is from the STOP MAKING SENSE concert movie. The entire concert is incredible, you should go pick it up on DVD or CD.
CokeMachineGlo 3 years ago
Lovely.
otherjacko 3 years ago
My favorite Heads song. I MISS THEM!
beaglehowl 3 years ago 2
You hear the new Eno and Byrne album ?
trollfinger 3 years ago
"a place where nothing ever happens." Dude's a great philosopher.
tinnycringe 3 years ago 4
Talking Heads defining moment.Brilliant
egomeme 3 years ago 4
It was one of the brides from funkenstein. basically either Dawn Silva and Lynn Mabry. absolutely beautiful voices.
crodgee 3 years ago
Oh, ok=)
mookao23 3 years ago
Where are the backup vocals coming from? Tina doesn't move her mouth once. I wonder about what else in this movie is just coming from the sound board.
mookao23 3 years ago
I'd assume they are singing backstage. That is not an uncommon technique. As far as I know, only the first number is pre-recorded.
Svippong 3 years ago
it's only an 808 drum machine and byrne playing/singing along. *technically* not pre-recorded. ;)
sydneyconfirm 3 years ago
die eric burdon version ist eindringlicher
loplop60 3 years ago
their most sheerly gorgeous song ever. the album version is heartbreaking. so simple; so magnificent.
baadpuddytat 3 years ago
k, i meant "later" not "earlier", see kids this is what comes with age. gettin old sucks!
ramblinalways 3 years ago
Thanks to aliensatemybrain2 for sending .Stop Making Sense 5 stars
giantplanet 3 years ago
does anyone know when/where this was recorded. It looks a lot like the orpheus (sp?) in Boston bout 81 or 82. I saw that concert, but gosh for some reason just don't remember all the details, except of course that it kicked ass and took me a few days to recover. in college at the time. Anyone?
ramblinalways 3 years ago 2
It was shot at the Palladium on Sunset boulevard in LA in 1984
spuzzum888 3 years ago
thanks. a little earlier then I remember the concert in Boston, but just awesome. awesome. thanks again.
ramblinalways 3 years ago
There aren't enough stars to rate this video.
loveyoutodeathbut 3 years ago 3
Who's doing the back-up vocal? Clearly not Tina...
meredumais 3 years ago
That would be guitarist/keyboardist and back-up vocalist Jerry Harrison. He remains off camera for this song (his instrument isn't used - just Byrne's guitar and Tina's base). He enters at the end of the next song, "Thank You For Sending Me An Angel".
NYisontop 3 years ago
Jerry H has a voice like a woman does he?
lagowski 3 years ago
i went to this club called heaven cool place
adrianaekielska 3 years ago
I think they are great...he is really good.
Thank you
diane189444 3 years ago
can anybody send me somehow version of this song from philadelfia?
adrianaekielska 3 years ago
heaven
zuton100 3 years ago
Can anybody give me the Q lazzarus version of this song.... this was a part of the philedelphia ost ... but i never found that version... I ll qwe u one for life
karanatrv 3 years ago
whatever your orientation is,
this song is awesome
therealthomas 3 years ago
When you find a bar called heaven you'd pretty much have to go in whether you were gay or not.
And if you were a songwriter I don't see how you could not write a song about it.
Are there any bars with a better name than heaven?
equifilibricum 3 years ago
haunting, isn't it
dullath 3 years ago
i wish this song to be my funeral song ... along with others. i love talking heads so much. they remind me of my family every time i listen to 'em. we all always sing along to the tunes but, this one's the heart wrencher! cheers and much, much love to eveyone! hugs! :)
-louie louie
shmooieshmow 3 years ago 3
Just so you know " heaven " is a gay bar. That is what the song is about.
gitsirius 3 years ago
My band and I played this in the mid-80s (I forget which year) at a benefit concert for an AIDS hospice in a NYC bar. I sang lead vocals and our woman guitarist (we had three guitars, I was rhythm only, and we had two leads, one man and one woman, who swapped off lead roles depending on the song) sang backup. The crowd was so quiet you could hear a pin drop. Then they started waving lighters and I almost cried it was so beautiful. What a great song, an all-time classic.
bckm54 3 years ago
Fantastic!
gmansi 3 years ago
this is the song for my funeral
TheDentist27 3 years ago
Mee too! oh, me too!
hemlockgourmand 3 years ago
this is the most beautiful song. i dont care what it is about but it makes me remember a time in my life and i love that time. i put my emotions into this music and that is why i love it. perfection in imperfection.
joeltietzer 3 years ago 4
This wakes me up on Saturdays!
LOVE IT
BazzariusDe9 3 years ago 2
Great performance. Too bad Lynn Mabry wasn't on-stage next to them.
SybeSatellyt 3 years ago
Really great - thanks for posting. This was definitely the highight of SMS for me. Is Tina awesome or what? I would love to see footage of the full electric version of this track.
jts001 3 years ago
Pure magic!
kunghasse63 3 years ago 2
Has this ever been supassed ? I mean this very performance.
3691grass 3 years ago
very disappointing only bad song ive heard him sing pick your game up a bit old fella
jwf27 3 years ago
i agree. however, the studio version is a little better.
oysteranatomy 3 years ago 2
Yer probably just really into god.
sefluent 3 years ago
Ah man, fantastic.
Blacklamass 3 years ago 2
When does Tina do that voodoo/pogo/80's dance? I think it's later when she does the Tom Tom Club bit w/ her now hubby, Chris Frantz on drums. "we lost our heads when we took cocaine". Muh, hummideh, muh hummedeh...
drewlsy 3 years ago
"at EXACTLY the same time"
Pkmink 3 years ago
I wonder if they overdubbed the female vocals on this because I don't see her singing the part. This song is really relaxing.
bigslimcdub 3 years ago
one of the backing singers sang backstage lynn mabry i think .had something to do with continuity as they came out later in the show
watchstrap1 3 years ago
I don't think that's Tina. I can't remember their backing singers names.
trollfinger 3 years ago
pintilism is a placid point to, up, look. one said there was look, there's a dead bird. they looked up. my favourite soup, must be a soup, with lentils are happenin'
ePhilosopher 3 years ago
the name of the bar is called heaven...........heaven is a gay club in london for those who don't know.songs about getting pissed in a gay bar in london,great song btw
pumapele 3 years ago
i think the song's meaning is more complicated than that...he's talking about how unpredictability is good and a perfect world wouldn't be enjoyable
1293hymc 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lmfao,no hes talking about gay club heaven.
pumapele 3 years ago
idiot
pumapele 3 years ago
because that's what someone does when they like a club: they write a song about it and say that nothing ever happens there. and that everyone leaves at exactly the same time. you're right, it's totally about the club, nothing more. especially considering how david byrne's lyrics are always simple and straightforward like that. yeah, that makes sense.
1293hymc 3 years ago
yes,becuase in the uk when this was wrote all clubs kicked everyone out 1 AM.get the dvd and listen to the band commentary where the band stae what this song is about.......a gay club in london called heaven.
pumapele 3 years ago
I'm ready to die. Well, not quite yet.
77pinehead 3 years ago
what a perfect version of a perfect song, needsa heroin to be appreciated fully, lol
tiberiumdemo 3 years ago
häh?
fpertack 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
tina is kindof sucking it on this song.
i guess i can see why byrne would bitch.
and i'm more of a a tina fan than i am of byrne.
r0ck1r0ck2 3 years ago
You are a freak! Tina Rocks on this!
Jigs1girl 3 years ago 3
The band look so happy together, I wish they would get back together.
sclops 3 years ago
talking heads should reunite
woodboy747 3 years ago 3
yes, its my favourite talking heads song too.
very much Inspired!! Never tired to listen it.
fmanuelcruz 3 years ago
beautiful song, simple but beautiful!!
From the albun "Fear of Music", about 1979 i think!!
fmanuelcruz 3 years ago 2
Awesome. The whole concert is. She sure reminds me of Marianne Faithful. Beautiful song. Thanks for post.
Leanne60 3 years ago
Watching this video as a young lad made me want to pick up the guitar.
niceandeasygeorge01 3 years ago
the perfect song. I saw a cover of it once, then new this is the only way it should be performed. the "Stop making sense" way.
deneifeltoren 4 years ago 2
this is my favorite talking heads song...i saw them in Berkeley and it is one of my all time greatest gigs...bravo...
cuculainn57 4 years ago
That was so beautiful. I've loved and followed this band since I was 14.
That would be since I heard of them, basically, in 1979.
KingCast65 4 years ago 2
Wow I woudnt be playin music if it werent for Talking Heads respect from Hoovers and Sledgehammers the ultimite Talking heads fans
yegnom59 4 years ago
f-a-n-t-a-s-t-i-c-!
winnentoe 4 years ago 9
i love (and album stop making sense);)
noir068 4 years ago 3
the best
stefymarty 4 years ago 2
my "favorite song" from "fear of music"--so haunting, chilling and gorgeous.
baadpuddytat 4 years ago 4
i do absolute agree, brilliant song!
encorra 4 years ago
Anyone know who's singing the beautiful backing vocals? Obviously it's not Tina.
deyoungparker 4 years ago
The Brides of Funkenstein were backup singers on that tour.
bellinghamster 4 years ago
bellinghamster is right!
At this moment Lynn Mabry (a.k.a. The Brides of Funkenstein) is still offstage, but she sing the chorus of this fantastic song from the backstage.
There is another backing vocalist, Ednah Holt, but she doesn't sing on this one.
pfonyt 4 years ago
it's kinda funny to have the backing vocals offstage when you think about it. The way they did show was very much what you see is what you get, like in for some purist film makers, only playing music when the musician/music players were being being filmed.
Anyway, I was at one of those concerts in Providence RI (sept 1982). Anybody else still alive?
FeodorMikhailovitch 4 years ago
make that 1983.
FeodorMikhailovitch 4 years ago
the first time i heard this song, i had to replay it over and over again i liked it so much
Ben5039677 4 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ah, heaven is spread upon the earth, and you guys just do not see it. oh, well
-god
mmiaxx2002 4 years ago
please go away
kiwi2u 4 years ago
one of my favorite songs...just great!!
mabarmabar 4 years ago
i have this tape, and this is the best song on it.
Leanne60 4 years ago
shit hot!
alxm79 4 years ago
What came to my mind was: "Play it one more time, play Paranoid".
Apjooz 4 years ago
Rispacta to Kkkkklf for posting this video.
I love this song.
AlexanderChatzakis 4 years ago
Dude they are brilliant! look at my taste music!!1 I include all types of rock even things you cant place in this genre!!!! Love this song!!!! asdfjkbwhjitugjklgjbhoigujhbh
Pandemic16 4 years ago
mint
ponkey71 4 years ago
Tina:ADN
FFGM1973 4 years ago
i've been to heaven quite a few times and believe me -- stuff happens!
ekimshield 4 years ago
i was just watching "stop making sense" dvd!
amazing song
thanks for uploading it :)
phototrip 4 years ago
tina is the glue in this group, look closely
mmiaxx2002 4 years ago
what does that mean?
willwat25 4 years ago
Bass is the center of the music. It's a rhythm AND a melody instrument, so it ties the leads and rhythm together. I'm a bassist, so i guess i'm a bit biased, but bass itsself seems like the glue to me.
DamNationDiplomat 4 years ago
I agree, plus Tina is kinda hot.
barnyardstory 4 years ago 4
I will guarantee you that drummers, guitar players and lead singers will say the same thing about themselves. No one ever talks about the cowbell player!
hanscarter 4 years ago
im a guitar player and bass is rhythm and melody... its true. drums follow bass guitar follows drums thats the way it is.
ag3nt00sexy661 4 years ago
"Heaven" is a bar in Pittsburg
oleshatterbutt 4 years ago
Damnit!!!
That's pittsburgH
mgshave 4 years ago
I really hope that when I die and go to Heaven, that David Byrne is God! Because I am worshipping him now!
Jigs1girl 4 years ago
Thanks! I have been thinking about this song a lot lately. One of my favorites.
guziboy 4 years ago
Righteous
solutionz99 4 years ago
Beaut
tubaraoesoeu 4 years ago 2
iful
hanscarter 4 years ago
Just great.
cnocan2007 4 years ago 2
My favourite song by TALKING HEADS.
"Heaven" a great classic.
Simply beautiful. To listen always!
KARLITOS61 4 years ago 2
Impresionante. Gracias, David y gracias Tina.
veintemil20 4 years ago
What a song! Always loved it and always will.
mrhjsimpson 4 years ago
It's amazing how simple songs expres the complex.
powhatanbud 4 years ago
beutiful song' legendary band.
chrissyman77 4 years ago
saw the talking heads at berkeley's greek theatre and they rocked - simply one of the greatest bands ever. period.
jackienew 4 years ago
this song always makes me want to cry...i never do of course, but if i were going to cry, the background music would this song
RUSHofbloodtomyhead 4 years ago
my name is Ben and i am 7 years old,and I love this song.
My dad plays this all the time.
354sd 4 years ago
keep it up mate
354sd 4 years ago
Calidad de imagen y sonido inmejorable.
betashure 4 years ago