My Cast for The Lightning Thief

[TheNaqibGUITAR]

Those are some wicked cast but still it's way over budget..and I think Lucas Till should be Luke Castell

[DaughterOfPoseidon10]

And Luke was awesome 2

[DaughterOfPoseidon10]

Hades, Ares, and Clariesse=funny!!! Johnny Dept would make a awesome Hades. :) :) I don't no y but I always imagined he'd come out as Hades, but singin the Pirates of the Caribbean song. "Yo ho yo ho a pirates life for me!"

[YesImmaCowgirl]

I liked Clarisse and Luke...not so much some others. I don't feel that Annasophia has that 'intimidating' look to her, although she does have blonde hair and she's the right age, I can give you that :)

[LUV04111]

No

[iseeugod]

sally jackson = milf

[tomer945]

So..youre just using the Bridge of Terabithia Cast?

[LoveMitchelMusso92]

bad choices on ALL of them!

[CatieCatb3]

@LoveMitchelMusso92 actually, this is for LT, so the ages are okay...though I completely disagree with sally, clarisse, poseidon, hades, and medusa...the real choices are excellent. But i would've liked to see jsh hutcherson in the first couple, then logan lerman in the last couple. First because they looks similar, so it's not completely different, and second, because the age is right.

[LoveMitchelMusso92]

@CatieCatb3 its my opinion, so shut up idc if they match the book, i read it but i like the cast the director chose better. now i can c y u dnt have a career in casting ppl in movies, u wanna know y? well im gonna tell u anyway, U SUCK

[CatieCatb3]

@LoveMitchelMusso92 umm...I didn't say anything to inuslt you soo...why do I suck? I just said I think these choices are okay. just like you think they suck. I respect your opinion. I didn't go all, "YOU SUCK BECAUSE YOU HATE THESE CHOICES! I didn't mean to offend you with MY opinion.

[peacelovemusic32399]

I'm sure these choices would be a LOT better for the cast, though the ages wouldn't work all together.

But I looooooooove your Clarisse, Ares, Hades, and Medusa :D

[portalzombies]

luuuuuuuuuuvvvvvvvvvv it!!!!!!!

[WillUCarryMe2TheEnd]

I actually like Clarisse's casting that you did. Most people try to make her crazy-crazy skinny/waif-like You picked a girl that at least looks like they can make her look bigger. :D

[thewisegirl31]

I loved all the cast but your grover

[hunterd2001]

I like the books more then the movie. They did such a sucky job filming. In the book it said Annabeth's knife was small, in the movie her knife was big. Grover looks nothing like they said, he dosen't wear the hat they described. Luke sort of dies in the first movie. By the way there's no Clarisse

[imsoepic48]

@hunterd2001 but isnt that the case for all books turned into movies, the books are always better

[102876DB]

/watch?v=vSUhozMqpEE --> Please watch my new video, I also made a new cast for Percy Jackson, based on popular ideas combined with my one opinion. I hope you'll like it!

btw: Your cast is amazing!

[grannygrooveclub]

Carrie underwood for Percy is just like plain WRONG!!! the cast 4 the real movie is way better

[Welihy]

@grannygrooveclub

Actually, no its not. Not at all. They're much too old. For one thing, Percy and Annabeth are supposed to be TWELVE. Not, like, twenty or however old they made them. And the Annabeth isn't blond. And I know this is irrelevant, but the movie was absolutely NOTHING like the book what-so-ever

[ShiekGirl101]

I think Carrie Underwood is a bit too pretty and young to be Sally actually. Sally is described as an average looking middle-aged woman ^^;

[ashandmayforever98]

i dont really like the people for percy and annabth i think they seem 2 younge and as for jason dolly as luck i could see him as one of the stoll twins

[hillgirl397]

i dont like grover sally hades

[mypaintedhero]

I love all of them!!!! Except for Luke I still like jake Abel for Luke.... But I loved ares and hades!!!!

[rdjXproductions]

Carrie is too pretty to be Sally D: I like the Johnny Depp and Vin Diesel idea tho

[MinishZap]

perfect medusa

[ilikepieandinvisable]

man! i didnt realive helen whoever was bellatrix!!! amazing actress!!!! anyone who can make you hate them that mmuch is really good! i like the choices for percy and annabeth. logan learman would have been good if he was like actually 12 not 17 or whatever!

[misswierd1563]

That would have been an amazing medusa

[4everBookLover]

4 some reason Josh and Anna Playing Percy and Annabeth sounds HORRIBLE! MY OPINON...How ever u spell it

[wherewolf456]

nice Rupert Grint is a pretty good choice for Grover

[pheobeobia]

one thing, carrie underwood is WAY to young to be Percy's MOM she would've had him when she was like twelve

[Dogzrock2468]

why cant we have nobodies like in the real percy jackson that what i love about it not star you alll ready know, people that you dont now

[chimbob67]

Uh i dont agree with any of this.

[JaJaJaProductions]

#LOL LUKE JASON DOLLEY?? #FAIL LMFAO

[4everBookLover]

@JaJaJaProductions HAHAHA! No offence

[cantcatchme1970]

Percy:ugh no..never Annabeth:nope grover: :'( I miss juniper!! Luke: huh the scars gone but I look so much hotter than that Sally:I have brown hair... Poseidan: im a little bit more... less muscular Zeus:hey i know im a god and all but hes way too old Clarisse:I think im gonna puke Ares:Uhhuh thats right Hades:Ozzy Osborne would be alot better Medusa:her hair is a rats nest!

[EclipseSnowClan]

@cantcatchme1970 Percy: YES!! Annabeth: Definitely! Grover: I don't know. Luke:

No way! Sally: I have brown hair. Poseidon: Not quite right. Zeus: Maybe. Clarisse: Good one *Haha*! Ares: What me daughter said. Hades: NOOO!!!! EVERYONE WANTS HIM TO BE ME!! I KNOW I CAN LOOK AS YOUNG AS I WANT BUT HE DOASNT SEEM OLD ENOUGH!! ALSO THE NAME JOHNNY I DONT WANT TO BE INVOLVED WITH!! I WANT SOMETHING WITH MY AURA LIKE NYSSA OR SHAKIR!! PS. I MISS PERSEPHONE!! MEDUSA: YES!

[EclipseSnowClan]

@EclipseSnowClan Chiron: *Cries* WHAT ABOUT ME??!!

[AnimeGirl623]

Percy: WHY DOES EVERYONE THINK I LOOK LIKE JOSH HUTCHERSEN?! Annabeth: *coughs* Umm, I don't think so. Grover: I DO NOT HAVE RED HAIR!!! Luke: Ehhh.... *shakes head* No, no... Sally: She's way to young to play me. Poseidon: It could work. Zeus: Perfect! My own son gets to play me *AnimeGirl623 covers mouth* AG623: ZEUSY, SHUSH! That's supposed to be a secret!!! D= Clarisse: *cracks knuckles* No way in Tartarus Punk. Ares: Sure, why not. Hades: Perfect. Meduse: Brilliant ~AG623

[scholarforadollar]

um he cant be grover he doesnt look like a goat

[KKandlilsrule25]

yes i so agree especially cuz johnny depp is awesom

[saaddapunkrocker]

you got a bunch from bridge to tierrebetha and put them in this

[Sparkler40]

I really think that Logan Lerman was a great pick for Percy.

[pianoplaya103]

first two from other same movie would make the movie kiddish

[dvaebo]

percy: totally! annabeth: it could work. grover: grover doesn't have red hair, but it's not bad. luke: maybe if he cut his hair... sally: ABSOLUTELY NOT!!!!!!!! poseidon: i couldn't really see his face, but otherwise it looked good. zeus: YES!!!!!!!! clarisse: YES!!!!!! ares: yeah, sure hades: i don't know... medusa: PERFECT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[ww19661101]

better than some of the real people but i didnt like some of the people........

[thelongsdaleguy]

percy = both good annabeth = fail grover = fail luke = not bad

[littlemillsy23]

that wouldve been the best cast

[kisa154]

i dont really like percy's and grovers but atleast grover's is better than the real casting.

[generationm0vies1]

compaired to the book  ( in my opinion) the movie sucked they left out the whole st. lois arch and ares and the big pit

[princess01181]

@generationm0vies1- Yes, I agree with you, but they only do that because you're not using your common sense. If you read th ebook, there's no sense in just goin' to the theater to watch a movie that's exactly like the book! I read about this in "The Diary of a Wimpy Kid MOVIE DIARY."

[TMAvids]

I dont like grover. i think the one who it is should stay. percy could be that one or the one who accualy was chosen

[guitarman12390]

This is good. The actors actually look the right age.

[cycilliam98]

omg! are you freakin kidding me???

carrie underwood as Sally???

heck no!

[xoxanimechickxox]

Helen Bonham Carter would've made an awesome medusa ! but i don't see rupert grint as grover though :P

[jazzyt333]

great picks! you definitely shouldve casted for the movie. the actors sucked!

[Hockey23Girl]

Here is what i think who should have played who,

Percy: Jake Cherry

Annabeth: Chloe Moretz

Grover: Nolan Gould (its hard to find someone who is worthy of the Grover part :D)

Clarrise: Bianca Ryan

and thats it so far

[AmberBrook5000]

Phail Grover......lol.....

[Samhplover]

0:32 Shes at the Harry Potter and the Order of the Pheonix Premire (I think)

[porahforamillion]

It never actuallly says anything about Grover being black or white it just says he's skinny short and walks kinda funny

[21jakeable]

grover is black not white (no offense)

[to2cute4u]

WHY do YOU always say no offense ?

[LluviaEmpress]

he's supposed to be white though

[NadiaLFCullen]

ahh, the Parcy looked quite toooo young..

[99PLATINUM]

medusa,sally,and zeus r not good

[RawrCutie101]

I like these!! Much betterrr then some of the actors they picked for the charaters

[liferoxinthisworld]

Everyone allways has the same

Annasophia robb/ Dickota Finnaing

Josh Hutchison

Rubert Grint

[JOJO8512]

OH MY GOSH!! Perfect! Too bad they didn't have this cast... except for Sally of course because she has brown hair.

@MusicMan118 no he had dark brown almost black hair and although he didn't have that dark of skin he still had that kind of powerful body and eyes

[LluviaEmpress]

dude I SO AGREE annabeth is supposed to be blonde and no offense to alexandria daddario but i pictured annabeth kinda...well, she woulda been PERFECT

[MuzicMan118]

i dont agree with ares :S isnt he supposed to be shorter and have red hair similar to hargrids? :P or is that just how i pictured him?

[psychoGigi]

hahha thats funny how u put johnny depp as hades hahaaha i would like to see that

[CrazyNaruto555]

like the cast it's just what i though of when i read the book but i think sally jackson off the real cast fits more then ur's to bad that they forgot about ares and that

[legomyeggo336]

Finally some1 includes Clarisse Almost no one does

[collinsep23]

i totally agree w/ PromiseMeJoy

[sango90]

this is creeppy but i always pictured this cast well mosat of it while reading the book. i ALWAYS thought jason dolly should play luke and i agree with ur choises except for grover,sally,and ares

[ctr4vr]

oh and rupert grint is soooo PERFECT for grover i hope they keep him a satyr (sp?) and not make him a demigod

[ctr4vr]

these r perfect! i like how percy looks like hes 12 but logan lerman is soooo much hotter.

jakes creepy but thats ok

i think that harrison ford should be posideon and hugh jackman should be zues.

[SailerNicki]

I agree with everyone except Percy and Sally Jackson. I like the ones they picked for the movie.

[loganlermanrox]

logan lerman is soooo much hotter!!!!!!!!!

[123sunnyfunny]

those are horible pics that would never be in the movie

[kelseyisabum]

i think these would be really good and awesome characters but logan lemer is HOTT and all the cast in ur video would be really good together

[razzberrySk8ter2]

yeah! logan lerman = cutee

[tongo12345]

i realy liked and totaly agreed.

it is much better that the oficial cast.

nice choice.

P.S. : yes, i don't speak english very wel. i'm brasilien.

[ledman8]

same here all the way i liked it mostly b/c annabeth had blonde hair

[qwanoesrox14]

I just like the annabeth and percy you picked

[iluvjonasbrothers456]

I dont agree.

I like the cast they picked now.

Who cares if some of the characters have flaws?

Who cares if Annabeth is a brunette?

Who cares if Grover is black?

If you guys LIKED the book and want to SEE the movie, you'd all shut the hell up.

[ledman8]

dude really idc grovers black i like him black annabeths supposed to be blonde if they base it on the book it should be like the book

[iluvjonasbrothers456]

I admit, Annabeth not being Blonde bugs me, but still.

[Poopinapantry101]

this totally should be the cast in the movie coming out annabeth has brown hair it just dont seem right and also in the new movie grover has brown hair it just dont seem rite

[ledman8]

al the way

[uneek35]

When are they going to realize that it's hard to fill a movie with an all-star cast. And that arnie makes a way better Ares than Vin Diesel.

[hornsage1]

i love your ideas, they make alot of sense!

[maiariela]

LOVE your Choices! =]

[iwuvtwilight44]

this shud be the cast!! 5 star!!

[angelofheaven25]

i agree on all of them except for rupert grint as grover

[rbickhart007]

this is freakin flat out BULL!

[maxxorrokks]

sorry i don't agree withem all some are good though. just my oppinion

[xCielaOrianna]

lolwut? Dead on Arrival? That was Crush by David A.

[foxmulderxf]

I totally agree with u on all your cast ideas!!

I especially agree with u on Hugh Jackman as Poseidon, Johnny Depp as Hades, AnnaSophia Rob as Annabeth.

Man I wish this was the actual cast,

I think they did a bad job on picking the cast except for Percy…

[Anabell1001]

i liked the peopel you picked fot posiden and madusa

[koolkat18181]

this is a better cast lol

[6cuttie]

100% they way it should be

[9189erbear1195]

i cant see carrie underwood as percys mom, and jason dolley as luke... not so much

but otherwise perfect cast

[koolkat18181]

yah i agree

[cowlover724]

i like ur ideas, Beletrix A strange is a perfect cast part. Jason Dolley and Johny Depp, not so much.

[Greendayfan2121]

Ok this sucks and jhonny depp makes a horrible Hades. I only agree woth the Medusa one. P.S I WANT MY 3 MIN 31 SEC OF LIFE BACK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[alvarodacool]

this is dumb if ur watching this dont its f up

[jubilee03]

yo amen to that XD

[joepac12]

i agree on everything sept for rupert as grover... hes a bit to tall and old

[nmij333]

why is ron from harry potter one of your choices the? but i do LOVE percy!!!!

[FFX2ME]

i love your picks. especially : Annabeth, poseidon, zeus, and ares and i love your choice fore medusa she totally fits

[11carlosl175]

sally is to hot tho

[divadnessej97]

@11carlosl175 and too young looking

[skittyslap1997]

your choice for luke is okay but i just cant imagine him being evil

[GioTheFatty]

Harrison Ford would play the best zeus in the world, but he would cost more money just to act in it than the film itself.

[poolinpools]

agree with everyone except for sally!!!!!!!! but otherwise the best cast i've seen!!

[harrypotter3tdg]

song?

[GioTheFatty]

crush by david archuleta

[kyleclev1]

this sucks cow nipples..

i mean this cast is most likely for a harry potter self cast -.-

[ILuvHorsez0102]

I second this! I LOVE your choices!

[peacegrl65]

I think I might of imagined the ppl differently

[gummybear2239]

I agree

[ILuvHorsez0102]

Your a better casting director than theperson who picked the people in The Lightning Theif!:)

[sakura2d2]

@ILuvHorsez0102 yh that is a gd choice! the other lot lk totally different to what i imagined. although mayb sally could do with a different person..lol

[isleesmefan]

i imagined poseidon older then that and clasrsse way different but other than that theyre how i imagined them good choices

[asiasharp]

i love the cast but i dont agree with sally

[Flyingcloud98]

i totally agree wid annabeth!!

[DolphinLuv23]

i liked it only hades should be more skinny

[trailerlu]

Those are good except for percy i would do the little boy from "Mr.Mongoriums wonder emporium" and from "Kit kittredge". I love that kid. Also for Sally Jackson I would do somebody with red hair

[sabira97]

i love your choices!!!!!!!!!!!!

[KiLLaZoMbiEgiRL]

These actors were almost EXACTY how I imagined the characters! Good choices! BUT...Carrie Underwood is a bit young to have Parcy for a son...maybe picking Nicole Sullivan or possibly Reese Witherspoon! (: GREAT CHOICES!!!!!!!!

[KiLLaZoMbiEgiRL]

*Percy*

[AnimeGirl623]

Percy isn't that good. I'm not that fond of josh hutcherson. I think they did well with Steve in Cirque Du Freak. That's the only movie he's good in, in my opinion.

[lilygabby71]

i agree for all of them! much better than the oringinal cast!!! :) good job

[jamesasasin24]

nice picks but i dont think abt josh to play as percy... and also carrie underwood to play as sally jackson... it wud b better if u put daniel radcliffe as percy... but d rest r awesome...

[catlover800736]

I love the cast but I think you should switch Hades and Ares.

[howbcc]

ya i would have put these aswell much beter than the cast they picked!!

[InianLove]

The only thing that i thought was better than what they have was Annabeth but thats just cuz she's blond.

[prankkidjustin]

annabeth should be her

[XxSpiritxXxAlbarnxX]

well percy is good josh is a good actor :D

[arintaiseale]

I only watched half but I think Grover should look more nerdy and Sally to actually look like a mom. and for posiden to look older. other than that I agree with u.

[DarkAngelSpiceyKitty]

I think your ideas are dead on but I still like Logan Lerman for Percy. Everyone else I really like. They match what it says in the books. Oh and 6868Axel, shut the hell up! Can you be any more immature?

[free2rhyme1357]

luke should be mitchell musso if he cut that hair but its cool.

[KSROCKS1]

Luke should be Jason Smith!

[6868Axel]

WOW THIs cast sucks eggs whats up with Zeus He is a good actor but he is getting to old I still Think This Cast Sucks

[ilovejacobICE]

perfect*

[ilovejacobICE]

I think your ideas are rerfect but not so much zeus. :)

[Lollypoplizz23]

All the poseiden pics were shirtless

[FudgePop101]

i love your choices for luke and clarisse! too bad luke was different :(

[SmartGirl445]

Why isn't there a Rachel? The last vid I saw of this didn't have her.

[VideoGamez4life]

@ smartgirl445

there is no rachel becys she doesn't come into the sieries until book 2 or 3

[Longshot12ify]

dude. if they cast jason dolley as luke, this movie would show up on disney channel in the next few years. after its kinda old.

[TheARProductions11]

this WOULD be a great cast

[thenickpandoshow1]

OMG!!!! this cast is awesome!!! especially percy and annabeth!!!! but grover i think should be someone else like that half goat half human guy in narnia!!! mr. tummnas or something!!!!!

[zorrow27]

Yeah,Mr Tummus is played by James McAvoy :D

[MrCaptainawesome007]

good casting.

[DoubleMintness]

i think josh and annasophia should be percy and annabeth. they look the part and everything. even though logan and whatever her name is look sort of the part. i think they would of done better.

[mysteryboy109]

i love those choices there good

[hulksmash123100]

heres my cast

percy jackson:logan lerman

grover:rupert grint

chiron: the guy who played dumbledore

dionysus: the guy who played snape

[JamieDotNet]

Josh and AnnaSophia would be EXCELLENT for this movie. You STUPID casting people, why didn't you PICK THEM!

[berfibulous]

Yeah tons of people put bellatrix lestrange as medusa

[BannanaBoy4]

i think its funny that all your pictures of hugh jackman have him with no shirt really good choices though

[sammipaul]

love the rupert grint playing grover!!!! and loved hades and medusa! aweeeesome and also sally jackson!

[jrockerbear]

thats a perfect pick for medusa

[masterranger12345678]

love the cast but why exactly would Annasophia Robb and Josh Hutcherson be in the same movie... again. I mean they were already in Bridge to Terabithia together and usually actors don't do that unless it's like a series or somethin

[UltimateSpiral]

i like when movies use actors that erent that big...like twilight did..so jason dolly and carrie underwood i dont like...plus they might not have a clarisse for the movie!!!

[SliverWannaBe]

wtf jason dolley isn't a good luke...

[MrTmii]

yeah Jake Abel is perfect

[12BookwormGirl]

UGH no offense to you but I am SO sick of people putting Josh Hutcherson and AnnaSophia Robb as Percy and Annabeth! Grrr...

[zkshan283]

what is with u people and ur charcaters these suck

[2kewl2touch6]

wow..since so many ppl choose annasophia robb as annabeth >={ they should really change it =\ or re film it of something =\ cuz i dont want them to mess up on the movie

[mybuthole56]

OMG those r really good.

better than the real cast

i think so too! NICE JOB

[sarenna18]

The images are pretty blurry. I would hate having the actor that plays Ron as one of the actors in the lightning thief. Nice song though.

[nicolerocksursocks]

I like everyone but josh cz now he looks way older than before hes looks like hes 16 not 12 anymore so thats why