its really sad... that no matter what u call yourself, irish, german, scottish, american, british, no matter what, and no matter how smart we think we are. In the thousands of years and how far we've advanced.. we still cant find one single way to stop killing each other. Dropkick Murphys.. good song!!!
And we are coming full circle again into another global conflict brought on by human greed. We need to stop the cycle of conflict and find peaceful ways to settle things. The people need to unite across the world and prevent those who control our lives from manipulating us into yet another tragedy. The trenches solved nothing.
Its been 100 years since the Great War and all we have learned how to do since then is make stronger killing technologies............ RIP all soldiers and civilians who have died in wars we will remember you for years to come.War it will never change......(sigh)
i hate dropkick murphys they are american pretending to be irish !!!! drives me crazy!!! if you are american (born in usa)be proud to be american NOT irish!!! im irish(born in ireland)so im irish i dont pretend to be someone im not!!!!!hate wannabe irish people!!!!i dont care if your mothers cousins cat was irish that does NOT make u irish!
@mcsachsenhausen If you visited a foreign country would you cease to be Irish? What if you decided to live somewhere else? All American blood is foreign. We tend to categorize ourselves as German-American, Mexican-American, African-American, Anglo-American, Irish-American etc. Don't you know how many people of Irish ancestry reside in America and England? Like it or not, we are connected.
@INbredMonarchy i live in germany(that does not make me german)my parents are from kerry and limerick but i was born in dublin and raised there(so i am not from kerry/limerick)i am a dub)even tho my parents and their parents and their parents are all from kerry/limerick does not make me from kerry/limerick ! do u understand what i am trying to say???just because my name is a kerry name does not make me a kerrywoman(i find it very insulting)you should be proud where YOU are born(nobody else!!!)
@mcsachsenhausen I think I do understand what it is you are trying to tell me, but I'm just trying to explain how we Americans identify ourselves. To be "American" doesn't mean a whole lot because we hear(for example) Chinese, Vietnamese, and Japanese people say that simultaneously. So to erase some confusion we use sub-categories to further define ourselves. I think these situations are more prevalent in the U.S. and the U.K. where so many people are of foreign origin.
Nobody thinks that the songs written mean anything but The Irish going to fight...And WE will..Believe what is seen happened..and the Hitler side does't mean crap... They fought and stll fight today for freedom from England...I guess England doesn't recognize the fact that people want to live free of religios persicution
It's because people wish to live free of religious persecution, to preserve our freedom, our civil and religious liberty, the Willy McBrides of this world fight and die to preserve just that. Better that Willy McBride died in France than returned home to murdered in his own country and have his killers elected as his government for the next half century! The moment anyone starts referring to 'England' and not Britain you know what they are. How can we be free of ourselves?
@drtywteboy I believe that young Willie McBride was an Ulster Volunteer, fighting for freedom from Dublin rule. Besides, the song was written by a Scots-Australian folk singer, not by an Irish nationalist.
@hkeddieme i'm from scotland right, but i'd say there is a connection with ireland giving the fact that four william mcbrides died in world war one. one from scotland, three from ireland, one north, two south. this song can't be taken away from them with it being one of very few thing's the north and south can mourn together on. after more than 300 years of bad blood between them, unity is the key for peace, and this song gives them that.
The song is mourning all those who died in WW1 (and all wars) , including of course the Irish, Scots, English, Germans, Turks, Australians, Austrians, Americans and all others on both sides. It is not, as some seem to think, specifically about the Irish, or Irish nationalism. There is no particular significance to the name being Wille McBryde, it was just one of the many names on gravestones in the war cemeteries visited by Eric Bogle..
@hkeddieme "There is no particular significance to the name being Wille McBryde," You are quite right. I imagine the name McBride only stood out because it rhymed and scanned with graveside. It is not about one person though. That person was used to represent all the fallen. If he was Irish then he just happened to be Irish. No significance to it and the song has nothing to do with the political situation in Ireland.
there are two pictures of Hitler, one the first one his wwii photo, the second him as chancellor-- the picture appears just as the line in the song says "It all happened again" -- so fitting placement imo.
Sorry, let me clarify. There are 2 pictures of Hitler. About the 5th slide in is a picture of German soldiers in WWI. The soldier on the left with the "handlebar" mustache looks like a young Hitler. The 2nd picture is Hitler as the German Chancellor.
War will be ever a big lie and a shame of mankind. Young men dying for only little ideals of politics, for a lie, for oil.......no blood for oil. No war will end all wars!!
theres a picture of hitler in there and this song is about ww1 and hitler was ww2. so im confused of why hes in here. but i love this song so much its sooooo sad though.
this song always runs through my head when I look at the picture of my brother hanging on our wall...he was nineteen when he died. :( wars sucks!
grrldragon1821 55 minutes ago
first time i heard the song i cried.
underclas 2 weeks ago
its really sad... that no matter what u call yourself, irish, german, scottish, american, british, no matter what, and no matter how smart we think we are. In the thousands of years and how far we've advanced.. we still cant find one single way to stop killing each other. Dropkick Murphys.. good song!!!
Wandeere 2 weeks ago
Amazing, great job!
Zaymun 2 weeks ago
brilliant song
what a waste of life there is no glory in killing and dieing
whiteEngland1488 3 weeks ago
And we are coming full circle again into another global conflict brought on by human greed. We need to stop the cycle of conflict and find peaceful ways to settle things. The people need to unite across the world and prevent those who control our lives from manipulating us into yet another tragedy. The trenches solved nothing.
guitarfreakirl 3 weeks ago
Its been 100 years since the Great War and all we have learned how to do since then is make stronger killing technologies............ RIP all soldiers and civilians who have died in wars we will remember you for years to come.War it will never change......(sigh)
ArgonianMage465 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
Planktontube 4 weeks ago
wow
MegaBeerwolf 1 month ago
When the hell did this get 11k views? Olawdy.
BCRichShredder 1 month ago
@BCRichShredder
Well it doubled in a month now ^^
XDiamondManX 4 days ago
@XDiamondManX Holyshit. Wutduhfuuuuuuuhk. This is crazy. This is the only video I have to pass 5k views. I think.
BCRichShredder 3 days ago
@mcsachsenhausen , you are irish????
i don´t beleve that, your name sounds like a stupid german word.
and if you really irish, and you could not live with wanna be irish people, go dying, than you havn´t this problem any more.
rsskm 1 month ago
@rsskm of course im irish! yes i live in germany (well done) my 3 year old is more mature than you.
mcsachsenhausen 1 month ago
i hate dropkick murphys they are american pretending to be irish !!!! drives me crazy!!! if you are american (born in usa)be proud to be american NOT irish!!! im irish(born in ireland)so im irish i dont pretend to be someone im not!!!!!hate wannabe irish people!!!!i dont care if your mothers cousins cat was irish that does NOT make u irish!
mcsachsenhausen 1 month ago
@mcsachsenhausen If you visited a foreign country would you cease to be Irish? What if you decided to live somewhere else? All American blood is foreign. We tend to categorize ourselves as German-American, Mexican-American, African-American, Anglo-American, Irish-American etc. Don't you know how many people of Irish ancestry reside in America and England? Like it or not, we are connected.
INbredMonarchy 1 month ago
@INbredMonarchy i live in germany(that does not make me german)my parents are from kerry and limerick but i was born in dublin and raised there(so i am not from kerry/limerick)i am a dub)even tho my parents and their parents and their parents are all from kerry/limerick does not make me from kerry/limerick ! do u understand what i am trying to say???just because my name is a kerry name does not make me a kerrywoman(i find it very insulting)you should be proud where YOU are born(nobody else!!!)
mcsachsenhausen 1 month ago
@mcsachsenhausen I think I do understand what it is you are trying to tell me, but I'm just trying to explain how we Americans identify ourselves. To be "American" doesn't mean a whole lot because we hear(for example) Chinese, Vietnamese, and Japanese people say that simultaneously. So to erase some confusion we use sub-categories to further define ourselves. I think these situations are more prevalent in the U.S. and the U.K. where so many people are of foreign origin.
INbredMonarchy 1 month ago
is this Adolf Hitler below the cross at 1:12?
nennmichJ 2 months ago 5
@nennmichJ Yes, I belie
ve so, guy on the bottom row sitting down far left.
ihatesocialism100 2 months ago
@ihatesocialism100 yes
nennmichJ 1 month ago
@nennmichJ yea he is.
tehmatze 1 week ago
@nennmichJ yes he is !
tehmatze 1 week ago
@nennmichJ i dont want to live on this planet anymore!!!
AlphaFirstPrime 1 week ago
@nennmichJ he was in the german army in ww1...
spartinninja1149 1 week ago
@nennmichJ Yes it is. Surprised they would show that ass hat in a tribute to WWI regardless of who fought on which side.
cbeatty551 5 days ago
Nobody thinks that the songs written mean anything but The Irish going to fight...And WE will..Believe what is seen happened..and the Hitler side does't mean crap... They fought and stll fight today for freedom from England...I guess England doesn't recognize the fact that people want to live free of religios persicution
drtywteboy 2 months ago
@drtywteboy
It's because people wish to live free of religious persecution, to preserve our freedom, our civil and religious liberty, the Willy McBrides of this world fight and die to preserve just that. Better that Willy McBride died in France than returned home to murdered in his own country and have his killers elected as his government for the next half century! The moment anyone starts referring to 'England' and not Britain you know what they are. How can we be free of ourselves?
MrLorenzovanmatterho 1 month ago
@drtywteboy I believe that young Willie McBride was an Ulster Volunteer, fighting for freedom from Dublin rule. Besides, the song was written by a Scots-Australian folk singer, not by an Irish nationalist.
Kkardemumma 1 month ago
@drtywteboy This song has nothing to do with Ireland,. It was written by a Scots Australian, Eric Bogle, as an anti-war song.
hkeddieme 1 month ago
@hkeddieme i'm from scotland right, but i'd say there is a connection with ireland giving the fact that four william mcbrides died in world war one. one from scotland, three from ireland, one north, two south. this song can't be taken away from them with it being one of very few thing's the north and south can mourn together on. after more than 300 years of bad blood between them, unity is the key for peace, and this song gives them that.
RFCmorgan 4 weeks ago 5
@RFCmorgan
The song is mourning all those who died in WW1 (and all wars) , including of course the Irish, Scots, English, Germans, Turks, Australians, Austrians, Americans and all others on both sides. It is not, as some seem to think, specifically about the Irish, or Irish nationalism. There is no particular significance to the name being Wille McBryde, it was just one of the many names on gravestones in the war cemeteries visited by Eric Bogle..
hkeddieme 4 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@hkeddieme "There is no particular significance to the name being Wille McBryde," You are quite right. I imagine the name McBride only stood out because it rhymed and scanned with graveside. It is not about one person though. That person was used to represent all the fallen. If he was Irish then he just happened to be Irish. No significance to it and the song has nothing to do with the political situation in Ireland.
gaconnochie 3 weeks ago
there are two pictures of Hitler, one the first one his wwii photo, the second him as chancellor-- the picture appears just as the line in the song says "It all happened again" -- so fitting placement imo.
Fallschrimmjager 4 months ago
sori just listen to it
happyogre1 5 months ago
great but take the pew pew pew out...it's a kinda cheep prop
EricDavidFloyd 6 months ago
Sorry, let me clarify. There are 2 pictures of Hitler. About the 5th slide in is a picture of German soldiers in WWI. The soldier on the left with the "handlebar" mustache looks like a young Hitler. The 2nd picture is Hitler as the German Chancellor.
andrewsgf4life89 8 months ago
I also noticed the picture of Hitler. Hitler was a soldier in WWI. He was wounded by gas. He started WWII as the Chancellor of Germany.
andrewsgf4life89 8 months ago
War will be ever a big lie and a shame of mankind. Young men dying for only little ideals of politics, for a lie, for oil.......no blood for oil. No war will end all wars!!
ScottishHighlander77 9 months ago
theres a picture of hitler in there and this song is about ww1 and hitler was ww2. so im confused of why hes in here. but i love this song so much its sooooo sad though.
davidarchuletakrazy 10 months ago
@davidarchuletakrazy That picture was taken in WWI when he was a lance corporal.
apathist04 9 months ago
Cant wait to get to Afghanistan...nothing left for me here. I wanna go to war
HatersGonnaHate1000 10 months ago
this song brought me to tears....love it.......Really brings home the pointlessness of war....
alexamerling20 11 months ago
why 2 dislikes??
TheLightningSaix 11 months ago
red poppies are weeds that grew from the bomb shattered earth it was a symbol for peace which is why this is so interesting
PAGS4747 1 year ago
@PAGS4747 thank you Mr Arbogast
PAGS4747 1 year ago
awesome
Dwrecka85 1 year ago