How do you solve a problem like Maria Top 7 - Chitty Chitty

[jamiesexonlegs]

this was rubbish tbf.....

[placeboeffect2004]

I didn't really enjoy Siobhan's acting here. I think part of the problem was that she didn't get to sing until quite far into the song, and there wasn't a great deal of choreography. I don't think the throwing and catching really worked, but that's not her fault!

[riftintimeandspace]

This is really... cringe?

[pinkpumpkin9]

i like this version but i think i like jessie and gwion's version better

[lastakat]

i used to thnk she was amazing but after watching id do anything and over the rainbow i know think she is just average, the talent gets better every year

[riftintimeandspace]

Gwion + Jessie from i'd do anything were sooooooooo much better than this!

[sarahsandiego2]

thats soooooo cute!!!

[scootyscoot4]

Those children are so pretentious. Siobhan's voice is beautiful, her acting since the show has come on heaps and bounds and she would be perfect for Maria now.

[BarberellaCosmetics]

how do you know?

[scootyscoot4]

Cos I've seen her in stuff since the Maria show, quite simple really.

[koikoiboi]

Jessie kicks her ass!

[beurlover95]

I like the kids singing better

[malteseboo]

OMG this totally ruined the actually Truley Scrumptious song. The tempo is way off and the melody is different.

[terribithiajjls12]

what is this?

[GeorgeLover2008]

i love her voice :) but i really liked the nancys better than the marias i think most of nancys were mor talented :)

[childofdestiny]

I actually prefer Siobhan's version..to Jessies..I like them both- but Siobhan's voice has such a 'breezy' sound, and it suits the song. She's also stunning!

[BluueSkyyScape]

I loved Siobhan, + thekids are very cute. But I prefered Jessie + Gwion's version of this song, really I don't think anyone could ever beat that for me x

[MissFletcherFletch]

the nancy's were more talented than the maria's.

obviously.

[hollyollyollyxxx]

I never noticed before how different the Marias voices are compared to the nancys

Marias sound all girls and sweet

Nancys sound tough but in a good way x

[ciaraellensarah]

Siobhan is very good here. But I completely agree with Cams10Jovi that Jessie and Gwion are just brilliant when they sang it in Id Do Anything. Anyone who hasn't seen it should search it.

[Cams10Jovi]

I thought Jessie sang this with Gwion better in IDA. It was really lovely!

[xLittleLewisx]

yes she defiantly should have won shes good

[stringydoll]

she should of won shes fantastic

[sharpay12121]

I wish she won.

I mean you can fall in love with her by just looking, watching and listening.

[musicalgirl07]

these kids are fab and siobhan is amazing wish she had won. love her so much lol! she did a great job here. the kids are great as well. saw them in the birmingham production.

[Jenniferrrrrxox]

i love this! :] shes fantastic and there well cute!

[xkisskiss91x]

okay

[positiveprincess92]

she should sooooooo play Truly in CCBB!! She suits it so well!!!

[samjhart]

She would be great in chitty chitty bang bang! She's gorgeous and the kids love her. Go siobhan!! Really hope she's get the part and bring out the album (Ok I'm being too optimistic)

[Mungojerriestar]

I'm not happy that shes not on stage as SOMETHING. ok she got a record deal, but shouldn't she be mary poppins or someone?

[xxVicsxx123]

siobhan was great at that part, and the kids obviously loved her. the kids are so sweet!

[carab87]

she is absolutely beautiful

[GirlyGirly93]

(this is off topic,i know) the little girls penifore was not the one from the show it didnt move the way it should and she was to tall for the penifore it was way above the dress. and what was up with jemima keep trying to hit jeremy j&j are soppused to have such a close relationship its like they are 1. sorry i just felt i needed to say that =]

[xkisskiss91x]

hey, what's penifore/ I have to agree with you about them hitting each other, as a fan of chitty bang I thought id never see jem and jemina hurting each other weird or what?

[Marshmallowe]

:O Chitty Chitty Bang Bang! ^_^ awww

[peppergal64]

she should have played in chitty chitty bang bang shes well gd at that song

[xGangOfOnex]

I thought she looked very uncomfortable there, although she sang it well she can't 'perform' like she's in a musical... and can't act. fiddling with hair!! Big NO NO! Apparently Abi did this in the rehersal and completly outclassed her

[Lucilon]

Sheer talent. Go Siobhan can't wait to see what she comes up with.

[sarie13]

when siobhan sung this she got the most votes and the judges wanted connie win so after that they alwas sed siobhan wasnt good so connie get the better comments

[karenwilson]

Siobhan has an amazing Voice, please vote for her tonight - BBC1 @ 6:45 and 9:15. Vote Siobhan!

Here's how:

Watch BBC 1 at 6:45pm and again at 9:15pm.

1. Press your Sky remote Red Button and vote Siobhan

2. Text your Vote for Siobhan

3. Phone your Vote through for Siobhan

myspacedotcom/siobhandillon

[tabletop246]

erm alw sed 'well she just lights up the stage doesnt she' basically he was very pleased with it

[xsilentxxseabreezex]

Wow. Does anyone knoew whether she was judged on this and if so, what the comments were like? I was away in France for two weeks and so missed lots of HDYSAPLM.

[rachelhepburn]

i want someone to load the clip of when they all rehearsed with the children - i cant remember how well the others coped with it!

[mosh2005]

And yes they r both different roles but her acting skills are coming along well so i reckon she'll do fine

[connie4maria]

siobhan was a crap actress.

[mosh2005]

I know that Maria is a tomboy role but i bet Siobhan could easier play her because she easily got into the role of Truly from chitty chitty bang bang

[everythinglesmis]

This is sooooo cute! I love it that the acting is so good here, the emotions are so realistic and the fact that people are saying she would be better as the women from Chitty Chitty Bang Bang only proves that she convinced you so well.

[Calluml]

i totaly agree... i think she is amazin but i think she would be better as the women from chitty chitty bang bang... i bet she gets an offer to do the next chitty chitty bang bang after the one that is on or will be on soon

[rhhy33]

i didnt watch it on sat why did only she do this song?

[everythinglesmis]

It showed clips of all of them practising with the children, but then ALW picked one of them to perform the whole thing live.

[sarie13]

Well done siobhan hope ya win xxxxxxxxx

[amazingfairytale]

love it

[dcyp]

absolubtly maria, siobhan just makes you smile when shes on stage.the perfect maria!!

[rachelb1310]

i hope siobhan does win. i think saturday just proved that she can be maria.

[hannahrose13]

siobhan is the best i hope she wins, this is really gd! its a shame the others didnt get a chance to do this too though

[kelcopop]

this is just soo cute, siobhan would be a great maria! i love it