Kat is indescribably beautiful with a fantastic voice. So looking forward to her new show SMASH and hope it will be a smash hit and lift her up to the superstardom that she deserves!!! Love you, Kat! XOXOX!
why is it that everyone wanting to perform this song does it with instrumental accompaniment ? I seem to be the only to have dared to post a vid of himself trying to do it a capella, despite my being only a novice at singing. I dare anyone thinking themselves professional at singing to do the same
every time I heard her sing this song I got good bumps, but I'm not a Kat fan so have not heard her sing in a couple of years ....yet once again she gave me goose bumps here. The girl definitely has a voice! ;D
McPhee does not sing out of tune. People may be off key, pianos get out of tune, she's neither. Glad to see this song back in the lineup. She's totally revitalized a song that's older than she is. That's what the Idol judges call making it your own.
@piefrance Maybe... but I'd bet if you could poll the whole country and ask who they associated with the song, most people my age would say Judy Garland and the young'uns would say McPhee. Most. then there are people like me who became Idol fans and would jump the generation gap and say McPhee.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I'm sorry but this is not a good performance. Out of tune in places, and compared with the one she did in 2006, which was amazing, this is poor. She should've stood up too which would've helped. A beautiful song ruined. Sorry Katharine!
I never thought she would be able to top her first Idol performance of this song, but almost 4 years later she continues to impress and show her special ability!!!!
Kat is indescribably beautiful with a fantastic voice. So looking forward to her new show SMASH and hope it will be a smash hit and lift her up to the superstardom that she deserves!!! Love you, Kat! XOXOX!
charliebergy101239 5 months ago
i was there and she was absolutely amazing, this was one of her best.
flawless
1katharinemcpheefan 1 year ago 3
anyway, i love israel's version...
e34063270 1 year ago
Wow that was wonderful!
psycheeros3704 1 year ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wow that was horrible
juanq1122 1 year ago
wait 0:08
tifflesss 1 year ago
0:10
tifflesss 1 year ago
very beautiful !
Norbert544 1 year ago 2
When I heard Kat singing this song on AI, I immediately became a fan. Glad this song has become her signature song. Kat is fantastic singer!
PukaLani 1 year ago
So seet, so nice ! Thanks :)
MlStef 1 year ago
@MlStef Oups ! sWeet, no seet ! sorry...
MlStef 1 year ago
If you don't like this, then GTFO
TheHighRoad7 1 year ago 2
why is it that everyone wanting to perform this song does it with instrumental accompaniment ? I seem to be the only to have dared to post a vid of himself trying to do it a capella, despite my being only a novice at singing. I dare anyone thinking themselves professional at singing to do the same
Bernysings 1 year ago
every time I heard her sing this song I got good bumps, but I'm not a Kat fan so have not heard her sing in a couple of years ....yet once again she gave me goose bumps here. The girl definitely has a voice! ;D
OMGoodnessMe 1 year ago 2
perfection
i love the eye contact she gives to the camera (dee)
tifflesss 1 year ago
She didn't sit in her performance of this in 2006. Look it up. All i'm saying is it could've been better if she stood up :P
TheSamuale23 1 year ago
I just didn't like the way she sang it
TheSamuale23 1 year ago
Very beautifull ! thanks for singin g this nice song ! Bravo ! 5*****
Norbert544 1 year ago 5
Absolutely incredible... Years after her first 'Idol' performance with this song, she still blows me away with this song. Wow.
kmcpheeverorg 1 year ago 3
So talented, it's insane!
elmorse 1 year ago 6
McPhee does not sing out of tune. People may be off key, pianos get out of tune, she's neither. Glad to see this song back in the lineup. She's totally revitalized a song that's older than she is. That's what the Idol judges call making it your own.
groucho3710 1 year ago 4
@groucho3710 I think Eva Cassidy gets the credit for revitalizing this song.
piefrance 1 year ago
@piefrance Maybe... but I'd bet if you could poll the whole country and ask who they associated with the song, most people my age would say Judy Garland and the young'uns would say McPhee. Most. then there are people like me who became Idol fans and would jump the generation gap and say McPhee.
groucho3710 1 year ago 6
@groucho3710 interesting. I disagree though that most of the younger generation associates this song with mcphee. Just my opinion, though.
piefrance 1 year ago
Wow, SIMPLY AMAZING!!!!!
tjhazukiv1 1 year ago 7
OMG completely agree it was FLAWLESS!
better than in idol omg!<3
alexdani15 1 year ago 19
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm sorry but this is not a good performance. Out of tune in places, and compared with the one she did in 2006, which was amazing, this is poor. She should've stood up too which would've helped. A beautiful song ruined. Sorry Katharine!
TheSamuale23 1 year ago
Comment removed
tjhazukiv1 1 year ago
@TheSamuale23 Sorry but it is NOT out of tune. She also sat in her performace in 2006. You need to step away and put the crack pipe down.
m0000012345 1 year ago 21
@TheSamuale23
Every note is IN TUNE. And the song is not Ruined.
kalabiandarkness 1 year ago 4
I like the camera click at the end...capture that moment!
cbotten106 1 year ago 2
I never thought she would be able to top her first Idol performance of this song, but almost 4 years later she continues to impress and show her special ability!!!!
radname 1 year ago 2
no comment, unbelieveble!!!
davisss12 1 year ago 4
woah
qg6ff 1 year ago 2
OMFG, I do believe this is the best I have ever heard this song sang. I have chills, and I feel just a little bit like crying! FLAWLESS
nothlithawk777 1 year ago 4