Harold you are one of the most annoying people I've ever heard...why did you interview Shlomo when you constantly answered your own questions...I was waiting for him to tell you to shut the hell up! You ruined an otherwise informative video.
Who was the first Palestinian leader? What religion was he aligned with? What is the history of Palestine? When it comes to facts even the Arabs know there is no such thing as a 'Palestinian"! Mohammed knew Jews..but he never new a "PALESTINIAN!
1170 AD- 1440 jews in the whole of Palestine- Benjamin of Toledo
1267 AD- two families of jews in Jerusalem- Nahmanides
1845- 12,000 jews among 350,000 Palestinians
1880- 25,000 among half a million in Palestine
Jews settled in Palestine to escape persecution in other countries not out a sense of returning to a homeland and were welcomed by the Arabs and Christians
@greenmagoos lol ..look when it comes to using ad hominem as an argument I give it to you ..you win.
When iit comes to facts you dont hold a candle to me...yawnnn so hopefully this "debate" will allow you to learn a few more foul words...lol .You lose when it comes to facts! At the end of the day facts win out all of the time. That is why 1.6 billion Muslims are still living in the 7th century killing eachother every single day in the name of their religion of peace! That is a fact!
Give me the facts then because you only seem interested in using idiotic comments about islam to justify a state full of people who don't belong to either the biblical house of israel tribes or to Palestine.
@greenmagoos Lol you really crack me up- Yawnn too easy to debate- but its fun to play with you. "Idiotic comments about Islam? By Shlomo Sands belief Islam is a "religion" and not a people- So how did 57 countries non Islamic coutries become Islamic? Islam is not a government? Lol explain why it is that people who live in the 57 Islamic countries have to live by the rule of religion and not by the rule of "people"! That is Shlomo Sands argument not mine. "Religion" and "people" are separate
@greenmagoos Lol - you have such a great sense of humour...lol...I bet if you put your mind to it you could peel a bannana with your feet! Lol ....yawnnn blah blah blah blah...he btw Israel just inbented the Re Walk...it helps crippled people to walk... maybe one day Israel will invent something that will help morons like you to think! Until than keep practicing peeling bannanas with your feet..lol
No actually practisors of judaism and the kabbala seem to have a great sense of humour offering up prayers to satan and switching between hebrew and aramaic because angelic gate keepers are too stupid to understand both-lol what a load of blaspheming evil garbage.
I like bananas but its never been my staple diet unlike you zionist tree swinging hun.
@greenmagoos Lol you are a real joker..lol well as far as sense of humour it is no coincidence that the great comedians of the world happen to be Jewish...lol...Charlie Chaplin to Jerry Sienfeld..well yawnn got to go...satan is waiting for me ....she is hot..and no virgin for sure. Any way who the hell wants 72 virgins!
lol- they were judaism practising jew comedians you mean. Thats not the same as pharisees, sadducees, and essenes which were the 3 main types of philosophy practised by tribe of Benjamin and Judah Judeans 2,000 years ago.
You may as well claim roman catholics, Lutherians and mormons all worship Christ the exact same way.
lol- why do judaism practising rabbis suck the blood out of circumsised babies. I'm fairly sure that practise came from the talmud. Hail Satan.
@greenmagoos Lol ...you should be a comedian..."Judaism practising rabbis suck the blood "- Lol Lol are there Rabbis who dont practice Judaism? Lol you crack me up..gee ..let me guess you just finished reading about the Blood Libels...Lol hey giuess what I am eating? Matzo- Yeah I made it fresh from the blood of Arab children..Lol deeeeelicious..... excpet I have to spit out the STONES! lol GET IT STONES! LOL
Can anyone tell me what a "Palestinian " is? Cause that is a very well kept secret! Up until 1967 there were no Palestinians- Yawnnn guess they are like magic beans!
There are 57 Islamic countries - once non Islam and converted to Islam by brutal 1400 year expansionism- If 57 Islamic states are legitimate - Constaninople was Christian as is the Hagia Sophia up until Muslims invaded Constantinople(Now named Turkey) in the 15 th century and the Church of Hagia Sophia was converted to a Mosque than why is Shlomo Sand not judging the Muslim world as not being legitimate as Muslim states? Islam- ideology is partly predicated on Judaism!
I believe Shlomo Sand is accurately describing the history of the conversion of peoples to a practise called Judaism which is only connected to Palestine because a sect of Judeans called Pharisees wrote a oral tradition into a book that became the Talmud and used that to convert GENTILES to become 'judaism practising jews'.
Pharisees are the same sect of Judeans that Jesus described as "being of their father the devil" - John 8:44 who then plotted to have him crucified.
If "Palestinians" have never been a country- Nation - State- than how can they claim to be a "Muslim Nation"? "Palestinians" consider themselves as Muslim 1st and foremost. There fore logic says" If a people with no history of nation hood or being a state -"Palestinians" can make a claim of statehood that is Muslim- than why cant a people - Jews- who have over 5000 years of history as a people- state- nation - with all of the evidence to prove that as fact not be a Jewish state? Yawnn
LOL - NORMAN FINKLESTIEN - PROFESSIONAL JEW BASHER- WRITES A BOOK CALLED THE "HOLOCAUST INDUSTRY " ALLEGING JEWS MAKE A PROFIT FROM THE HOLOCAUST??? LOL NO ONE GETS IT...LOL NORMAN FINKLESTEIN IS MAKING A PROFIT FROM THE HOLOCAUST ! HE IS ON EDITION TWO OF HIS BOOK AND HE MAKES A LIVING FROM BASHING EVERYTHING JEWISH! WHAT AN EASY GET RICH FORMULA..IT TAKES NO TALENT WHAT SO EVER! LOL LOOK AT HOW POPULAR HITLERS MEIN KEMPH IS IN THE MUSLIM WORLD. 1.6 BILLION SERVED! LOL INSANE!
How many romani gypsy settlements are there among the land of the mongolian hun khazarian converts to Judaism in Israel. How many peoples with mental problems, ethnic poles, nuns, priests, freemasons, jehovahs witnesses, homosexuals, poltical opponents to nazi-ism, soviet pows etc did zionists think about when they over-ran Palestine?
Jews,jews,jews. Thats all that matters
The Israeli holocaust is just cover up the real victims are gypsy
@greenmagoos I see you are ggetting frustrated with facts...lol all Jew bashers resort to name calling when faced with facts. It is very Islamic of you...lol. Now tell me about the Virginians please...how many?? 72...wow!
lol- I can discuss the history of 'hebrews', 'israelites' and Judea/ Galilee with you as long as you like because you are brainless little zionist orc and I'm a red haired Celt from Scotland who believes in Jesus not a follower of Muhammad.
Shlomo Sands like Nroman Finklestein and their ilk would remain totoal obscurities if they deid not turn to an easy living become Professional Jew bashers. Finklestien is on edition two of the 'Holocaust Industry", a book that alleges that Jews make profit from the Holocaust - Well he might just have a point seeing he is on edition 2 of his Holocaust Book that is selling so well that his publishers wanted Edition 2..Lol the irony of these people is hilarious! They make a living from Jew bashing!
Schlomo Sands is a PHD on LSD! Lol - it is lie arguing a fact after the fact! Philosphy acid 101! If I took a mental retard out of a hospital and added "PHD" at the end of his name he would fool most people! That is why 1.6 Billion people believe in a religion predicated on brutal violence, intolerance and expansionism- while demonizing a tiny dot of a country - 20,000 sq km - and a people whose world pop iis 14 million! Insanity !lol
The fact that Islam, Christianity, Catholicism are predicated on the tenets of Judaism - Ie Jesus was a rabbi Jew- Moses- a Jew- Ten commandments - lends credibility to Judaism if ever there was an example of credibility. Moses brought the Jews to the "Promised land" - he did not bring the "people" to the promised land! Jews were enslaved because they were Jewish not because they believed in Judaism. Jews cannot escape their Jewishness even if they wanted to- .Hitler proved that fact.
Jesus did most of his ministering in GALILEE OF THE GENTILES. A totally seperate state from Judea. Simon Maccabee had recalled all Judeans from Galilee and barred intermarrying between the peoples before Jesus.
"Discrimination" is the singling out of one group or person . If Judaism is singled out to provide evidence of authenticity than why is Islam, Christianity, Buddhism, Hinduism, etc not held to a standard of scrutiny that Jews face since the beginning of time? Let alone that Islam makes Jews prophets of Islam- Moses and Jesus- in the Koran in spite of the fact that Islam was fabricated in the 7th century! Why is Islam the "religion of peace" when it is predicated on war and expansionism?
Jusdaism is a fact of history in spite of any nuances that are common with all religion and race. Judaism is no exception but in fact is the oldest religion next to Hinduism in the history of the world. So why not point to the legitimacy of Hindusim and compare how the "oldest religion in the world" is never mentioned when it comes to proof of authenticity that Jews have faced since the beginning of time.What makes Islam of Hinduism legitmate? And than compare them to Judaism!
Muslims and Hindus don't claim their religious practise makes them descended from the house of Israel tribes or that their 'practise' gives them exclusive rights to Palestine..
If you want to point to a racist "religion" Islam has a 1400 year ongoing history of expansionism based on "religion" . Muslims and Islam conquered what was once 57 non Islamic countries using brute force and violence? I mean if you want to make an example that 'religion and people are separate and there fore are not entitled to territory based on their religion - WHY ISRAEL WHICH IS 20,000 SQ KM(GIVING UP LAND) AND NOT THE ISLAMIC WORLD WHICH IS OVER 20 MILLION SQ KM AND EXPANDING
Why is there no real mention of 'judaism' practising jews in the history of european countries until the dispersal of the Khazarian nation circa 1000 ad?
Where exactly where these 'jews' for 1000 years after the biblical stories? I know the Sandhedrin can be accounted for because they were located in Galiee then Constantinople where they finished that supremely holy book the Talmud before they sent Rabbis to Khazaria to convert the locals.
@menodimi1 Apartheid Israel is a colonial settler project for European Jews on Palestine a land doesn't belong to them and it's belong to its native population. We don't live in a world combine of religious states, dummy. No one should talk about Muslim, Christian, or Jewish state in the 21st century. I'm not defending any religion, as all are the same, but I would like to hear from you, Islamophobic, which country Muslims conquered and evicted its native population to make it a Muslim state?!
@menodimi1 Ben Gurion answered your lies a long time ago: ""Why should the Arabs make peace? If I was an Arab leader I would never make terms with Israel. That is natural: we have taken their country. Sure, God promised it to us, but what does that matter to them? Our God is not theirs. We come from Israel, it's true, but two thousand years ago, and what is that to them? There has been anti-Semitism the Nazis, Hitler, Auschwitz, but was that their fault? Cont..
@menodimi1 They only see one thing: we have come here and stolen their country. Why should they accept that? They may perhaps forget in one or two generations' time, but for the moment there is no chance. So it's simple: we have to stay strong and maintain a powerful army. Our whole policy is there. Otherwise the Arabs will wipes us out". (The Jewish Paradox by Nahum Goldman, p. 99).
The Zionists criminals themselves are the best to explain their own crimes, not a brainwashed Zionist.
Shlomo Sand aint no rocket scientist- his name contradicts his allegations that Jews are a myth- You see "Shlomo Sand" has a flaw in his argument that "Jews are a myth"- and it starts with the most obvious- HIS NAME!
Every single SHLOMO in the history of the world is a JEW not an Israeli!
This moron is like philosophy meets LSD...LOL!
Shlomo, meaning God's peace, is a common Hebrew male given name.
@menodimi1 There is a difference between Jewish "people" and Jewish Identity. Shlomo is calling the first a myth and he is not saying the Jews "are myth", so fix your, intentional, wrong argument, and next time add RELATED facts to the issue and what Shlomo is saying, beside the earth is flat!
@abumiz Jewish people are not a "myth"?? Lol how ridiculous! I can give you 5774 years of related fact to that point.If Jews are not a "people" than what are Americans, Muslims, Buddhists, Hindi,Shiite, Sunni, Christians, Catholics, etc...what is the definition of a "people" if not what they represent based on cultural and historically specific fact? Shlomo Sands could never stand the test of factual scrutiny and you would fail miserably with him!
@menodimi1 Judaism is a religion and people can convert to it regardless of their ethnic background. There are Indian Jews and Indian Muslims, are they different people? Many kingdoms converted to Judaism. The term Christian , Muslim, Jewish "people" is an old term from the dark ages and from the time when people thought the earth is flat! Remember your unrelated fact.
The historical cultural connections between American Muslim and Russian Muslim is similar to American Jew and Russian Jew.
@abumiz Conversion to a religion is not the same as having a blood line to a people who are the original source of that religion. This is based on science and medical fact. When a group of people assimilate and generations of them move into thhe future- in the case of Jews there is 5774 years- than they begin to have cultural and genetic characteristics that become common. For instance it is not a coincidence that Jews have a unique medical condition - Tay-Sachs Disease, is one of them!
@abumiz Shlomo's name is in fact a historically relevant Jewish name based on a people - JEWS! You cannot name someone based on a religion and a people if that religion or people never existed!Shlomo means Solomon!
@menodimi1 You said: "You cannot name someone based on a religion and a people if that religion or people never existed"! Don't add people to your amazing logic! You can name someone based on religion and that doesn't mean the religious myths are facts. The fact that you stuck with the name is enough, lets say a religious freak father gave him the name, for example!! You know now about his book, try to bring one Idea and to debunk it, otherwise everything else you say is only meaningless trash.
@abumiz Look if you want to argue that "all religion is a myth" add "all religion" not one religion. Sands is biased when he singles out Judaism.Fact is that no one wanted to convert to Judaism when Hitler was targeting Jews and their genetic family lineage. So Jew bashers pick and choose their battles based on their momentary argument. If they want to deny Jewish rights to Israel they claim Judaism is not a race- if they want to kill Jews they look to the genetic history of Jews.
@menodimi1 Your talk is a complete trash, just back up what you say, like the "genetic characteristics" and the 5774 years which is mostly related to your religious myths and legends in your holy books!! Again you want to talk about Sand's book so bring some of his talk and try to debunk and show what is wrong, with sources and facts, not impotent talk. And don't mix between European Jews and Arab Jews. A German Jew related to Palestine as an American Muslim is related to Saudi Arabia.
Next time I get myself a dog I'm going to call it Ben Yoseph Solomon and claim its ancestors were in Judea 2,000 years ago and would sink their teeth into any Romans who tried to put a leash on them.
Even though the dogs ancestors were definitely tribe of Benjamin and Judah 'jew' dogs they still had to be converted to judaism in eastern europe 800 years later when some rabbis appeared with the talmud and dog food.
@greenmagoos The dog does not point to the history of Judaism the name does...lol. You are too easy to debate.Why not add buildings named after Jewish history? Like maybe the Temple Mount- or cities like Jerusalem? Just names eh? Lol...your arguments are weak at best. If you disect the history of humanity you will end up with a worm - LOL the first human being came from an Ameoba...lol
@greenmagoos Look if you want to point to a racist "religion" Islam has a 1400 year ongoing history of expansionism based on "religion" . Muslims and Islam conquered what was once 57 non Islamic countries using brute force and violence? I mean if you want to make an example that 'religion and people are separate and there fore are not entitled to territory based on their religion - THAN WHY ISRAEL WHICH IS 20,000 SQ KM AND NOT THE ISLAMIC WORLD WHICH IS OVER 20 MILLION SQ KM AND EXPANDING
I'm not particularly interested in debating Islam or what constitutes 'racism'. I would prefer to delve into the house of israel tribes and why peoples that were converted to become 'jews' make the error of assuming that their practise of 'judaism' allows to them to believe that they are descended from those tribes.
@greenmagoos Lol your arguments are really weak. Jusdaism is a fact of history in spite of any nuances that are common with all religion and race. Judaism is no exception but in fact is the oldest religion next to Hinduism in the history of the world. So why not point to the legitimacy of Hindusim and compare how the "oldest religion in the world" is never mentioned when it comes to proof of authenticity that Jews have faced since the beginning of time.What makes Islam of Hinduism legitmate?
There is no mention of the practise 'judaism' in the bible. According to the nt Jesus mentions pharisees and sadducees and the practise of judaism came from blaspheming rabbis who formulated an oral tradition into the Talmud and then went to the land of Khazaria and converted GENTILE PAGANS to 'judaism'.
According to Josephus the Roman/Judean historian there were Essenes, Sadducees and Pharisees- three sects of Judean philosophy.
Sometimes things just fly right over Mr. Channers head, if he'd just keep his mouth closed for a second, he'd be a lot better interviewe. Likeable fellow, nothing against him though.
"Now that we have Italy all we need are Italians" reflects the fact that the majority of the people didn't speak Italian. They each spoke their own dialect as part of a continuum which once stretched from the boot of Italy all the way to the north coast of France. So that if one began at one end and at each village learned the language, you would not be able to tell when one language began or ended.
This is interesting in that if archeologists find no evidence of Jews in ancient Egypt. There is apparently hardly any evidence of ancient Jews in Israel even. If archeologists are to believed there is no evidence of any 1st or 2nd temple. Was there no City of David? Maybe the whole thing was made up. Who knows what the Jews were and where is the proof, beyond their bible. And where are the original manuscripts of the bible even?
Even if every single person of Jewish faith was a descendant of the Khazars, they're cultural connection to Palestine would still be undeniable and have no bearing on the right of every Israeli to remain safe and secure in their home.
@WilhelmDrake - It's just an attitude pressed as a fact. Zionism originally thought of setting up in Uganda, South America or Alaska. Had they done so they would have created cultural connections, heritage and more...with any land they chose to claim. It's all about finding reasons to claim power and control. Something to incessantly ram down the world's throat.
Although the interviewer spoiled the interview we can easily begin to observe from Shlomo's book and videos scatered through out the internet and several other respected authors - not by israeli jews of course for obvious reasons and fanatics of all branches - that many tabus and myths are beggining to fall apart....more and more the israeli society will have much trouble to sustain some myths..let's wait and see what will happen in the next 2 or 3 generations..
Judaism and who is a Jew is defined in the Talmud and Rabbinic literature. We are Rabbinic Jews. Certainly modern statest Zionism and Rabbinic Judaism are not similar in any way. But we live in a modern world with ethnic states everywhere. In fact, any culture not protected by a national state will not survive. The language and culture will not survive. You do have hasidic Jews living Brooklyn, but only with mental illness as they live only to define themselves against the modern other.
What about the Roma? Do they get a state? If so, where? Do they have a right to a state in northern India? They've been gone for less than 2000 years, can they ethnically cleanse a region for a Roma State? If Jewish people can why not Roma?
Harold just pisses me off with his interruptions. He REALLY destroys the interview. It seems he really never learned how to do interviews???? This is a disaster.
however many jews outside of israel whether religious or not do retain an ethnic identity as jewish, because as minorities in the midst of other cultures they continue to be aware of the distinct nature of their culture and heritage...
so, mr. sand's life experience as an israeli of jewish heritage shapes and limits his ability to understand the perspective of people who live as ethnic minorities among other cultures, and do retain a sense of their ethnic identity, culture & heritage...
many jewish israelis, as they are for the most part secular, and in the ethnic majority in their country, do not continue to consider themselves jewish, as for them, the term jewish, has come to have more of a religious meaning than an ethnic meaning. instead, they now have a national identity, as israeli, and don't particularly feel a sense of connection with jewish people outside of israel. (continued).
mr. sand doesn't seem to understand that people do retain their ethnic identity even when it is distinct from their national identity. there are many ethnic communities around the world living outside of their original homelands who continue to retain their ethnic identities.
Hunnic empire used Gothic as a national language. Hunnic empire ends 469 CE. Turkut empire succeeds them. They are followed by the Khazars in the late 500's. The Scythians (Ashkenaz) were the subjects of these empires and remained where they had always been. After converting the Khazars traced their origin to Kozar a son of Togormah granson of Japheth.
Priscus, "I was surprised at a Scythian speaking Greek. For the subjects of the Huns, swept together from various lands, speak, besides their own barbarous tongues, either Hunnic or Gothic, or as many have commercial dealings with the western Romans, Latin, but none of them easily speak Greek." Scythians (Ashkenaz) spoke Gothic as a second language and knew some Latin but little Greek. Yiddish = 10% Slavic substrate, 80% Germanic, Romance loanwords, few Greek loan words, and 10% Hebrew Aramaic.
The Khazars were the third turkic dynasty in 200 years to rule the Scythians the semi nomadic inhabitants of the steppes of southern Russia.
The Scythians were their subjects. "Scythia" in Hebrew Aramaic is "Ashkenaz." Before the Turks the Scythians were the subjects of the Goths. The Scythians continued to use Gothic as a state language after the turkic conquests. Yiddish is 80% Germanic, 10% Slavic, 10% midieval Hebrew Aramaic. Hebrew Aramaic coming from the conversion to Judaism.
This is the worst host ever. He wont let Sand finish a sentence!!
alsdyall 3 weeks ago
Lol @ the good, the bad and the ugly ring tone. I wonder who's phone it was??
anyway... good interview, a good summary of a complex thesis, especially the dna aspect.
whereisthejustice1 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Cut the B.S. go see this if you are looking for real facts not conspiracy theories lies !
Abraham's DNA - DNA of the Chosen People
youtube.com/watch?v=TDDI0TwfG8A
creatingfl 10 months ago
Harold you are one of the most annoying people I've ever heard...why did you interview Shlomo when you constantly answered your own questions...I was waiting for him to tell you to shut the hell up! You ruined an otherwise informative video.
Amocee 11 months ago
Harold you still use a video camera? By the way the first rule in Journalism is let the interviewee answer the question free of interruption.
Amocee 11 months ago
great material by shlomo but channer is annoying and doesnt know hot conduct an interview. btw fake jews will learn much from this video
plenty2say 1 year ago
Who was the first Palestinian leader? What religion was he aligned with? What is the history of Palestine? When it comes to facts even the Arabs know there is no such thing as a 'Palestinian"! Mohammed knew Jews..but he never new a "PALESTINIAN!
menodimi1 1 year ago
@menodimi1
Figures for 'jews' in Palestine
1170 AD- 1440 jews in the whole of Palestine- Benjamin of Toledo
1267 AD- two families of jews in Jerusalem- Nahmanides
1845- 12,000 jews among 350,000 Palestinians
1880- 25,000 among half a million in Palestine
Jews settled in Palestine to escape persecution in other countries not out a sense of returning to a homeland and were welcomed by the Arabs and Christians
greenmagoos 1 year ago
@greenmagoos You like statistics? Me too! 14 million Jews world wide- 185 Nobel prizes- 1,6 Billion Muslims world wide- 7 Nobel prizes! YAWNNN
menodimi1 1 year ago
@menodimi1
14 million people practising judaism worldwide who stupidly believe they are Gods choosen. Have a mongol hun banana you boring little zionist orc.
greenmagoos 1 year ago
@greenmagoos lol ..look when it comes to using ad hominem as an argument I give it to you ..you win.
When iit comes to facts you dont hold a candle to me...yawnnn so hopefully this "debate" will allow you to learn a few more foul words...lol .You lose when it comes to facts! At the end of the day facts win out all of the time. That is why 1.6 billion Muslims are still living in the 7th century killing eachother every single day in the name of their religion of peace! That is a fact!
menodimi1 1 year ago
@menodimi1
Give me the facts then because you only seem interested in using idiotic comments about islam to justify a state full of people who don't belong to either the biblical house of israel tribes or to Palestine.
What have nobel prizes got to do with anything?
greenmagoos 1 year ago
@greenmagoos Lol you really crack me up- Yawnn too easy to debate- but its fun to play with you. "Idiotic comments about Islam? By Shlomo Sands belief Islam is a "religion" and not a people- So how did 57 countries non Islamic coutries become Islamic? Islam is not a government? Lol explain why it is that people who live in the 57 Islamic countries have to live by the rule of religion and not by the rule of "people"! That is Shlomo Sands argument not mine. "Religion" and "people" are separate
menodimi1 1 year ago
@menodimi1
Away and join a cabbala cult and offer prayers up to Satan you judaism colluding little monkey zionist moron.
greenmagoos 1 year ago
@greenmagoos Lol - you have such a great sense of humour...lol...I bet if you put your mind to it you could peel a bannana with your feet! Lol ....yawnnn blah blah blah blah...he btw Israel just inbented the Re Walk...it helps crippled people to walk... maybe one day Israel will invent something that will help morons like you to think! Until than keep practicing peeling bannanas with your feet..lol
menodimi1 1 year ago
@menodimi1
No actually practisors of judaism and the kabbala seem to have a great sense of humour offering up prayers to satan and switching between hebrew and aramaic because angelic gate keepers are too stupid to understand both-lol what a load of blaspheming evil garbage.
I like bananas but its never been my staple diet unlike you zionist tree swinging hun.
greenmagoos 1 year ago
@greenmagoos Lol you are a real joker..lol well as far as sense of humour it is no coincidence that the great comedians of the world happen to be Jewish...lol...Charlie Chaplin to Jerry Sienfeld..well yawnn got to go...satan is waiting for me ....she is hot..and no virgin for sure. Any way who the hell wants 72 virgins!
menodimi1 1 year ago
@menodimi1
lol- they were judaism practising jew comedians you mean. Thats not the same as pharisees, sadducees, and essenes which were the 3 main types of philosophy practised by tribe of Benjamin and Judah Judeans 2,000 years ago.
You may as well claim roman catholics, Lutherians and mormons all worship Christ the exact same way.
lol- why do judaism practising rabbis suck the blood out of circumsised babies. I'm fairly sure that practise came from the talmud. Hail Satan.
greenmagoos 1 year ago
@greenmagoos Lol ...you should be a comedian..."Judaism practising rabbis suck the blood "- Lol Lol are there Rabbis who dont practice Judaism? Lol you crack me up..gee ..let me guess you just finished reading about the Blood Libels...Lol hey giuess what I am eating? Matzo- Yeah I made it fresh from the blood of Arab children..Lol deeeeelicious..... excpet I have to spit out the STONES! lol GET IT STONES! LOL
menodimi1 1 year ago
Comment removed
greenmagoos 1 year ago
@menodimi1
Big hairy tree swinging evil coward zionist hun orcs from Russia prove just how much like King David they ain't
Israelis attacking children on their way to school
watch?v=KVuxQ7AHBCM
greenmagoos 1 year ago
Can anyone tell me what a "Palestinian " is? Cause that is a very well kept secret! Up until 1967 there were no Palestinians- Yawnnn guess they are like magic beans!
menodimi1 1 year ago
There are 57 Islamic countries - once non Islam and converted to Islam by brutal 1400 year expansionism- If 57 Islamic states are legitimate - Constaninople was Christian as is the Hagia Sophia up until Muslims invaded Constantinople(Now named Turkey) in the 15 th century and the Church of Hagia Sophia was converted to a Mosque than why is Shlomo Sand not judging the Muslim world as not being legitimate as Muslim states? Islam- ideology is partly predicated on Judaism!
menodimi1 1 year ago
@menodimi1
I believe Shlomo Sand is accurately describing the history of the conversion of peoples to a practise called Judaism which is only connected to Palestine because a sect of Judeans called Pharisees wrote a oral tradition into a book that became the Talmud and used that to convert GENTILES to become 'judaism practising jews'.
Pharisees are the same sect of Judeans that Jesus described as "being of their father the devil" - John 8:44 who then plotted to have him crucified.
greenmagoos 1 year ago
If "Palestinians" have never been a country- Nation - State- than how can they claim to be a "Muslim Nation"? "Palestinians" consider themselves as Muslim 1st and foremost. There fore logic says" If a people with no history of nation hood or being a state -"Palestinians" can make a claim of statehood that is Muslim- than why cant a people - Jews- who have over 5000 years of history as a people- state- nation - with all of the evidence to prove that as fact not be a Jewish state? Yawnn
menodimi1 1 year ago
Demonization by Assiciation: Israel, Palestine, Hitler and Wilders
watch?v=mPvggGnftO4
greenmagoos 1 year ago
LOL - NORMAN FINKLESTIEN - PROFESSIONAL JEW BASHER- WRITES A BOOK CALLED THE "HOLOCAUST INDUSTRY " ALLEGING JEWS MAKE A PROFIT FROM THE HOLOCAUST??? LOL NO ONE GETS IT...LOL NORMAN FINKLESTEIN IS MAKING A PROFIT FROM THE HOLOCAUST ! HE IS ON EDITION TWO OF HIS BOOK AND HE MAKES A LIVING FROM BASHING EVERYTHING JEWISH! WHAT AN EASY GET RICH FORMULA..IT TAKES NO TALENT WHAT SO EVER! LOL LOOK AT HOW POPULAR HITLERS MEIN KEMPH IS IN THE MUSLIM WORLD. 1.6 BILLION SERVED! LOL INSANE!
menodimi1 1 year ago
@menodimi1
How many romani gypsy settlements are there among the land of the mongolian hun khazarian converts to Judaism in Israel. How many peoples with mental problems, ethnic poles, nuns, priests, freemasons, jehovahs witnesses, homosexuals, poltical opponents to nazi-ism, soviet pows etc did zionists think about when they over-ran Palestine?
Jews,jews,jews. Thats all that matters
The Israeli holocaust is just cover up the real victims are gypsy
watch?v=veovCg6Bd-I
greenmagoos 1 year ago
@greenmagoos I see you are ggetting frustrated with facts...lol all Jew bashers resort to name calling when faced with facts. It is very Islamic of you...lol. Now tell me about the Virginians please...how many?? 72...wow!
menodimi1 1 year ago
@menodimi1
lol- I can discuss the history of 'hebrews', 'israelites' and Judea/ Galilee with you as long as you like because you are brainless little zionist orc and I'm a red haired Celt from Scotland who believes in Jesus not a follower of Muhammad.
greenmagoos 1 year ago
Shlomo Sands like Nroman Finklestein and their ilk would remain totoal obscurities if they deid not turn to an easy living become Professional Jew bashers. Finklestien is on edition two of the 'Holocaust Industry", a book that alleges that Jews make profit from the Holocaust - Well he might just have a point seeing he is on edition 2 of his Holocaust Book that is selling so well that his publishers wanted Edition 2..Lol the irony of these people is hilarious! They make a living from Jew bashing!
menodimi1 1 year ago
Comment removed
greenmagoos 1 year ago
Schlomo Sands is a PHD on LSD! Lol - it is lie arguing a fact after the fact! Philosphy acid 101! If I took a mental retard out of a hospital and added "PHD" at the end of his name he would fool most people! That is why 1.6 Billion people believe in a religion predicated on brutal violence, intolerance and expansionism- while demonizing a tiny dot of a country - 20,000 sq km - and a people whose world pop iis 14 million! Insanity !lol
menodimi1 1 year ago
The fact that Islam, Christianity, Catholicism are predicated on the tenets of Judaism - Ie Jesus was a rabbi Jew- Moses- a Jew- Ten commandments - lends credibility to Judaism if ever there was an example of credibility. Moses brought the Jews to the "Promised land" - he did not bring the "people" to the promised land! Jews were enslaved because they were Jewish not because they believed in Judaism. Jews cannot escape their Jewishness even if they wanted to- .Hitler proved that fact.
menodimi1 1 year ago
@menodimi1
Jesus did most of his ministering in GALILEE OF THE GENTILES. A totally seperate state from Judea. Simon Maccabee had recalled all Judeans from Galilee and barred intermarrying between the peoples before Jesus.
greenmagoos 1 year ago
@menodimi1
Stop saing the word 'jew' when referring to the tribes of JUDAH and BENJAMIN who occupied the land of JUDEA and nobody was practising JUDAISM.
greenmagoos 1 year ago
"Discrimination" is the singling out of one group or person . If Judaism is singled out to provide evidence of authenticity than why is Islam, Christianity, Buddhism, Hinduism, etc not held to a standard of scrutiny that Jews face since the beginning of time? Let alone that Islam makes Jews prophets of Islam- Moses and Jesus- in the Koran in spite of the fact that Islam was fabricated in the 7th century! Why is Islam the "religion of peace" when it is predicated on war and expansionism?
menodimi1 1 year ago
Jusdaism is a fact of history in spite of any nuances that are common with all religion and race. Judaism is no exception but in fact is the oldest religion next to Hinduism in the history of the world. So why not point to the legitimacy of Hindusim and compare how the "oldest religion in the world" is never mentioned when it comes to proof of authenticity that Jews have faced since the beginning of time.What makes Islam of Hinduism legitmate? And than compare them to Judaism!
menodimi1 1 year ago
@menodimi1
Muslims and Hindus don't claim their religious practise makes them descended from the house of Israel tribes or that their 'practise' gives them exclusive rights to Palestine..
greenmagoos 1 year ago
If you want to point to a racist "religion" Islam has a 1400 year ongoing history of expansionism based on "religion" . Muslims and Islam conquered what was once 57 non Islamic countries using brute force and violence? I mean if you want to make an example that 'religion and people are separate and there fore are not entitled to territory based on their religion - WHY ISRAEL WHICH IS 20,000 SQ KM(GIVING UP LAND) AND NOT THE ISLAMIC WORLD WHICH IS OVER 20 MILLION SQ KM AND EXPANDING
menodimi1 1 year ago
@menodimi1
Why is there no real mention of 'judaism' practising jews in the history of european countries until the dispersal of the Khazarian nation circa 1000 ad?
Where exactly where these 'jews' for 1000 years after the biblical stories? I know the Sandhedrin can be accounted for because they were located in Galiee then Constantinople where they finished that supremely holy book the Talmud before they sent Rabbis to Khazaria to convert the locals.
greenmagoos 1 year ago
@menodimi1 Apartheid Israel is a colonial settler project for European Jews on Palestine a land doesn't belong to them and it's belong to its native population. We don't live in a world combine of religious states, dummy. No one should talk about Muslim, Christian, or Jewish state in the 21st century. I'm not defending any religion, as all are the same, but I would like to hear from you, Islamophobic, which country Muslims conquered and evicted its native population to make it a Muslim state?!
abumiz 1 year ago
@menodimi1 Ben Gurion answered your lies a long time ago: ""Why should the Arabs make peace? If I was an Arab leader I would never make terms with Israel. That is natural: we have taken their country. Sure, God promised it to us, but what does that matter to them? Our God is not theirs. We come from Israel, it's true, but two thousand years ago, and what is that to them? There has been anti-Semitism the Nazis, Hitler, Auschwitz, but was that their fault? Cont..
abumiz 1 year ago
@menodimi1 They only see one thing: we have come here and stolen their country. Why should they accept that? They may perhaps forget in one or two generations' time, but for the moment there is no chance. So it's simple: we have to stay strong and maintain a powerful army. Our whole policy is there. Otherwise the Arabs will wipes us out". (The Jewish Paradox by Nahum Goldman, p. 99).
The Zionists criminals themselves are the best to explain their own crimes, not a brainwashed Zionist.
abumiz 1 year ago
Michael Hoffman II - The Religion of Judaism part 3 of 5
watch?v=PJ_yhlAIRLM
greenmagoos 1 year ago
For those of you who take this guy seriously- I have some enlightening news for you!
THE WORLD IS NOT FLAT!
menodimi1 1 year ago
Shlomo Sand aint no rocket scientist- his name contradicts his allegations that Jews are a myth- You see "Shlomo Sand" has a flaw in his argument that "Jews are a myth"- and it starts with the most obvious- HIS NAME!
Every single SHLOMO in the history of the world is a JEW not an Israeli!
This moron is like philosophy meets LSD...LOL!
Shlomo, meaning God's peace, is a common Hebrew male given name.
King Solomon a Jew - Solomon is Shlomo
menodimi1 1 year ago
@menodimi1 There is a difference between Jewish "people" and Jewish Identity. Shlomo is calling the first a myth and he is not saying the Jews "are myth", so fix your, intentional, wrong argument, and next time add RELATED facts to the issue and what Shlomo is saying, beside the earth is flat!
abumiz 1 year ago
@abumiz Jewish people are not a "myth"?? Lol how ridiculous! I can give you 5774 years of related fact to that point.If Jews are not a "people" than what are Americans, Muslims, Buddhists, Hindi,Shiite, Sunni, Christians, Catholics, etc...what is the definition of a "people" if not what they represent based on cultural and historically specific fact? Shlomo Sands could never stand the test of factual scrutiny and you would fail miserably with him!
menodimi1 1 year ago
@menodimi1 Judaism is a religion and people can convert to it regardless of their ethnic background. There are Indian Jews and Indian Muslims, are they different people? Many kingdoms converted to Judaism. The term Christian , Muslim, Jewish "people" is an old term from the dark ages and from the time when people thought the earth is flat! Remember your unrelated fact.
The historical cultural connections between American Muslim and Russian Muslim is similar to American Jew and Russian Jew.
abumiz 1 year ago
@abumiz Conversion to a religion is not the same as having a blood line to a people who are the original source of that religion. This is based on science and medical fact. When a group of people assimilate and generations of them move into thhe future- in the case of Jews there is 5774 years- than they begin to have cultural and genetic characteristics that become common. For instance it is not a coincidence that Jews have a unique medical condition - Tay-Sachs Disease, is one of them!
menodimi1 1 year ago
@abumiz Shlomo's name is in fact a historically relevant Jewish name based on a people - JEWS! You cannot name someone based on a religion and a people if that religion or people never existed!Shlomo means Solomon!
menodimi1 1 year ago
@menodimi1 You said: "You cannot name someone based on a religion and a people if that religion or people never existed"! Don't add people to your amazing logic! You can name someone based on religion and that doesn't mean the religious myths are facts. The fact that you stuck with the name is enough, lets say a religious freak father gave him the name, for example!! You know now about his book, try to bring one Idea and to debunk it, otherwise everything else you say is only meaningless trash.
abumiz 1 year ago
@abumiz Look if you want to argue that "all religion is a myth" add "all religion" not one religion. Sands is biased when he singles out Judaism.Fact is that no one wanted to convert to Judaism when Hitler was targeting Jews and their genetic family lineage. So Jew bashers pick and choose their battles based on their momentary argument. If they want to deny Jewish rights to Israel they claim Judaism is not a race- if they want to kill Jews they look to the genetic history of Jews.
menodimi1 1 year ago
@menodimi1 Your talk is a complete trash, just back up what you say, like the "genetic characteristics" and the 5774 years which is mostly related to your religious myths and legends in your holy books!! Again you want to talk about Sand's book so bring some of his talk and try to debunk and show what is wrong, with sources and facts, not impotent talk. And don't mix between European Jews and Arab Jews. A German Jew related to Palestine as an American Muslim is related to Saudi Arabia.
abumiz 1 year ago
@menodimi1
Next time I get myself a dog I'm going to call it Ben Yoseph Solomon and claim its ancestors were in Judea 2,000 years ago and would sink their teeth into any Romans who tried to put a leash on them.
Even though the dogs ancestors were definitely tribe of Benjamin and Judah 'jew' dogs they still had to be converted to judaism in eastern europe 800 years later when some rabbis appeared with the talmud and dog food.
greenmagoos 1 year ago
@greenmagoos The dog does not point to the history of Judaism the name does...lol. You are too easy to debate.Why not add buildings named after Jewish history? Like maybe the Temple Mount- or cities like Jerusalem? Just names eh? Lol...your arguments are weak at best. If you disect the history of humanity you will end up with a worm - LOL the first human being came from an Ameoba...lol
menodimi1 1 year ago
Comment removed
greenmagoos 1 year ago
@greenmagoos Look if you want to point to a racist "religion" Islam has a 1400 year ongoing history of expansionism based on "religion" . Muslims and Islam conquered what was once 57 non Islamic countries using brute force and violence? I mean if you want to make an example that 'religion and people are separate and there fore are not entitled to territory based on their religion - THAN WHY ISRAEL WHICH IS 20,000 SQ KM AND NOT THE ISLAMIC WORLD WHICH IS OVER 20 MILLION SQ KM AND EXPANDING
menodimi1 1 year ago
@menodimi1
I'm not particularly interested in debating Islam or what constitutes 'racism'. I would prefer to delve into the house of israel tribes and why peoples that were converted to become 'jews' make the error of assuming that their practise of 'judaism' allows to them to believe that they are descended from those tribes.
greenmagoos 1 year ago
@greenmagoos Lol your arguments are really weak. Jusdaism is a fact of history in spite of any nuances that are common with all religion and race. Judaism is no exception but in fact is the oldest religion next to Hinduism in the history of the world. So why not point to the legitimacy of Hindusim and compare how the "oldest religion in the world" is never mentioned when it comes to proof of authenticity that Jews have faced since the beginning of time.What makes Islam of Hinduism legitmate?
menodimi1 1 year ago
@menodimi1
There is no mention of the practise 'judaism' in the bible. According to the nt Jesus mentions pharisees and sadducees and the practise of judaism came from blaspheming rabbis who formulated an oral tradition into the Talmud and then went to the land of Khazaria and converted GENTILE PAGANS to 'judaism'.
According to Josephus the Roman/Judean historian there were Essenes, Sadducees and Pharisees- three sects of Judean philosophy.
Not 'judaism' practising 'jews'.
greenmagoos 1 year ago
Comment removed
menodimi1 1 year ago
Sometimes things just fly right over Mr. Channers head, if he'd just keep his mouth closed for a second, he'd be a lot better interviewe. Likeable fellow, nothing against him though.
WilhelmDrake 1 year ago
"Now that we have Italy all we need are Italians" reflects the fact that the majority of the people didn't speak Italian. They each spoke their own dialect as part of a continuum which once stretched from the boot of Italy all the way to the north coast of France. So that if one began at one end and at each village learned the language, you would not be able to tell when one language began or ended.
WilhelmDrake 1 year ago
This is interesting in that if archeologists find no evidence of Jews in ancient Egypt. There is apparently hardly any evidence of ancient Jews in Israel even. If archeologists are to believed there is no evidence of any 1st or 2nd temple. Was there no City of David? Maybe the whole thing was made up. Who knows what the Jews were and where is the proof, beyond their bible. And where are the original manuscripts of the bible even?
JohnnyRock2000 1 year ago
Even if every single person of Jewish faith was a descendant of the Khazars, they're cultural connection to Palestine would still be undeniable and have no bearing on the right of every Israeli to remain safe and secure in their home.
WilhelmDrake 1 year ago
@WilhelmDrake - It's just an attitude pressed as a fact. Zionism originally thought of setting up in Uganda, South America or Alaska. Had they done so they would have created cultural connections, heritage and more...with any land they chose to claim. It's all about finding reasons to claim power and control. Something to incessantly ram down the world's throat.
JohnnyRock2000 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Cut the B.S. go see this if you are looking for real facts not conspiracy theories lies !
Abraham's DNA - DNA of the Chosen People
youtube.com/watch?v=TDDI0TwfG8A
creatingfl 1 year ago
Although the interviewer spoiled the interview we can easily begin to observe from Shlomo's book and videos scatered through out the internet and several other respected authors - not by israeli jews of course for obvious reasons and fanatics of all branches - that many tabus and myths are beggining to fall apart....more and more the israeli society will have much trouble to sustain some myths..let's wait and see what will happen in the next 2 or 3 generations..
dionisio454 1 year ago
Judaism and who is a Jew is defined in the Talmud and Rabbinic literature. We are Rabbinic Jews. Certainly modern statest Zionism and Rabbinic Judaism are not similar in any way. But we live in a modern world with ethnic states everywhere. In fact, any culture not protected by a national state will not survive. The language and culture will not survive. You do have hasidic Jews living Brooklyn, but only with mental illness as they live only to define themselves against the modern other.
alln205 1 year ago
@alln205
What about the Roma? Do they get a state? If so, where? Do they have a right to a state in northern India? They've been gone for less than 2000 years, can they ethnically cleanse a region for a Roma State? If Jewish people can why not Roma?
WilhelmDrake 1 year ago
The "Leading" Israeli historian? What a joke!
IWannabeJew 1 year ago
harold was awful - he was booming over everything.. - i hope shlomo has done the same interview with someone else
it was still interesting -thanks
timewilltell7 1 year ago
Harold just pisses me off with his interruptions. He REALLY destroys the interview. It seems he really never learned how to do interviews???? This is a disaster.
SheerGenius2 1 year ago
Shlomo why wouldn't you go back to Austria?
NJIT22 1 year ago
Harold it's a great inteview but you need to let the man speak. I can barely hear him and you keep interrupting him.
neohubris 2 years ago
Harold gets great people for interviews which is why it's so much more frustrating that he never SHUTS THE *^#$ UP long enough for them to answer.
rgs11 2 years ago
Comment removed
timewilltell7 2 years ago
however many jews outside of israel whether religious or not do retain an ethnic identity as jewish, because as minorities in the midst of other cultures they continue to be aware of the distinct nature of their culture and heritage...
so, mr. sand's life experience as an israeli of jewish heritage shapes and limits his ability to understand the perspective of people who live as ethnic minorities among other cultures, and do retain a sense of their ethnic identity, culture & heritage...
yviva 2 years ago
many jewish israelis, as they are for the most part secular, and in the ethnic majority in their country, do not continue to consider themselves jewish, as for them, the term jewish, has come to have more of a religious meaning than an ethnic meaning. instead, they now have a national identity, as israeli, and don't particularly feel a sense of connection with jewish people outside of israel. (continued).
yviva 2 years ago
mr. sand doesn't seem to understand that people do retain their ethnic identity even when it is distinct from their national identity. there are many ethnic communities around the world living outside of their original homelands who continue to retain their ethnic identities.
yviva 2 years ago
thanks
sleeplessintokyo 2 years ago
Hunnic empire used Gothic as a national language. Hunnic empire ends 469 CE. Turkut empire succeeds them. They are followed by the Khazars in the late 500's. The Scythians (Ashkenaz) were the subjects of these empires and remained where they had always been. After converting the Khazars traced their origin to Kozar a son of Togormah granson of Japheth.
yeaa96704 2 years ago 7
Khazars were ethnically Turkic.
kzd444 2 years ago
Priscus, "I was surprised at a Scythian speaking Greek. For the subjects of the Huns, swept together from various lands, speak, besides their own barbarous tongues, either Hunnic or Gothic, or as many have commercial dealings with the western Romans, Latin, but none of them easily speak Greek." Scythians (Ashkenaz) spoke Gothic as a second language and knew some Latin but little Greek. Yiddish = 10% Slavic substrate, 80% Germanic, Romance loanwords, few Greek loan words, and 10% Hebrew Aramaic.
yeaa96704 2 years ago 6
The Khazars were the third turkic dynasty in 200 years to rule the Scythians the semi nomadic inhabitants of the steppes of southern Russia.
The Scythians were their subjects. "Scythia" in Hebrew Aramaic is "Ashkenaz." Before the Turks the Scythians were the subjects of the Goths. The Scythians continued to use Gothic as a state language after the turkic conquests. Yiddish is 80% Germanic, 10% Slavic, 10% midieval Hebrew Aramaic. Hebrew Aramaic coming from the conversion to Judaism.
yeaa96704 2 years ago 5
This book was published in French.
websuccess123 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The DNA evidence shows the Ashkenzai Jews are not Khazarian . Sand is a complete fraud.
You anti-semites will use anything to harm the Jews and the State of Israel.
websuccess123 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Shlomo Sand is not the leading Israeli historian.
His theory has been debunked completely.
websuccess123 2 years ago