SNSD - THE BOYS English Ver. @ Madison Square Garden Live 111024 HD

[tadkan96]

y do you think they r lipsyncing

[iamthebest908]

For all of you says it's lip syned it's not they just put a recording over it to upload so stop bashing them

[SatoshiSakuragi]

Will they ever come to San Francisco..?

[FendiAlien]

the girl at 0:55 had a plastic surgery or not ? (i'm not sure, that's why i'm asking, i heard things about some of them who had surgeries)

[erinnysays]

@FendiAlien Sunny?! no waaaaay! .__.

[xxbacktodecemberxx]

PEOPLE. They DIDN'T lip sync. SM Town automatically replaces live audio when they upload videos, watch the videos they've uploaded. If you watch fancams of the same performances, you can see they didn't lip sync.

[Frutofruto]

lip-synch.. so sad and shame :(

[azibjazman]

Yoona!!!!!♥♥

[23moua]

Eww this is sad, they're performing on a stage where MJ danced and sing on, and they didnt even put effort into their performance. They lipsynch their performace! What a disgrace to KPop, the TOP girl group lip synch at Madison Sqaure Garde, one hell of prestigious stage, and they disrespected it's honor. Sorry but their attempt in the US like this will make them fail harder than Se7enor BoA in the US

[LadyJayELFandSONE]

@23moua

they didnt lip synch to it they sang it live and sm put the video with the audio ver

in sm town channel if u dont belive me watch the fancams of it

[justliketoro]

好明顯的錄音....

[khunnoohilla]

they're lipsyncing i hate it

[britster2345]

@khunnoohilla they aren't lipsyncing, they had to dub over their voices cause they fans were screaming too loud

[toan1437]

@britster2345 watch fancams they were lipsyncing. It's quite obvious they were lipsyncing based on the fancams. And i dont blame them, they didnt get enough time to clean up their english good enough for their live. In the fancam taeyeon span super fast without even making a alteration.

[veann09]

@khunnoohilla this video was replaced with the recording, but im pretty sure they did it live 

[dougiefresh415]

@khunnoohillado do you know how hard it is to sing and dance in heels at the same time

[OnewBias1]

@dougiefresh415 Really? They've done this song a million times before this in Korean and sang live. The fact is that not all members are fluent in English so they lip-synced. They've been in the industry for about 5 years, so the fact that it's hard to sing and dance at the same time shouldn't be an excuse any more.

[narrowstairs]

@khunnoohilla I don't think they are lipsyncing. Whoever edited the video seemed to put the album recording over the performance instead of using the live vocals. Which is stupid. We know our girls can sing live!

[disyang16]

@narrowstairs so true...i've seen a lot of their videos and i can say that they can dance and sing at the same time :)

[Ecksplisit]

1:23 DAT WINK. I MELTED.

[SmackTheseNutz]

@kalniac2 dude ur right the owner did put an audio over this cuz at the end their were no cheering but if u watch the same video but 'fan cam' u can see they are clearly signing not lipping the words . Idk how to copy the url down coz I'm on my phone so if u type in 'snsd the boys live eng' n it should b the first video with fancam awesum lol

[SmackTheseNutz]

Yes they sound great but idk if they are lip singing. But if u look at some of there live singing on a show n radio they sound the same also but with sum extra lyric added . Idk if this makes sence lol but idc lol I jus listen to them cuz their awesummmmm!

[Kalniac2]

@SmackTheseNutz I bet the owner of this video change the video with another live audio...

[SmackTheseNutz]

I'm not Korean but I do know how to minic their songs . And I kno what their sayin coz I study it. It's just like snsd they all might not b strong in English but they study the English language. And off topic believe it or not I'm not excellent on my English either, but u can clearly understand me cause I practice.

[SmackTheseNutz]

For those that say their lip singing and are fake because the have no Mic. But look closly their using mini mic. If u can't see then wow ur blind cuz I'm on my phone n I can see it. Beside saying they don't kno much English doesn't mean they can't sing English songs. I'm Asian and I could sing Spanish song fluiently. Some people think I'm Mexican for that ..

[Calumaritzu]

@SmackTheseNutz Yeah, the mics are there but if you've actually listened to the recorded version of this song, it sounds just like this one. Therefore, they're lip syncing. Either that or some idiot put the recorded audio over the live audio to cover it up. Not hating on SNSD, just stating a fact.

[KimBum89lover]

Looks like they are lipsyncing to the english version because they are not wearing micrphones but i loovvee you guys!

[msawesomecutie]

This is the best performance ! 

[cyndilovelovelove]

(: tiffany <3

i wonder why people think they r so good at english that they be able to judge these girls' english

yes they sound fob, so what, fob people can't sing?

[nuraqilaatikah]

ouh this is tooo hot ! i'm burning now !!! :)

[PureMagicalAngel]

love them! they usually sing live i guess because it's an english version? just randomly guessed.... should have sang live at madison s garden :)

[lolols321]

<3 !!

[dash12717]

Jessica!!♥

[xXxXsouless]

LOL this guy got the video then use the audio from the disc to cover up :D

[SicaFtwever]

@xXxXsouless SM removed the Audience's Voice .

[xXxXsouless]

@SicaFtwever LOL but they are still lip singing. You can tell that if you are listening to it carefully, its totally the same as the disc audio. And how can you dance and sing in tune for the whole song without getting out of tune?

[Krisik]

@xXxXsouless They did not sing this song live, but you can't really tell that from this clip. SM has put the audio track from the CD on the video footage from the New York Concert. The sound on this video is not the sound from Madison Square garden...

[itseffinsexxitime]

@xXxXsouless wow you're retarded or something. SM always puts the original track over smtown performances because it's far too hard to hear the audio with such a large stadium and fans screaming and chanting. please don't try to be smart when you aren't. thanks.

[xXxXsouless]

@itseffinsexxitime LOL Whatever!

[itseffinsexxitime]

@xXxXsouless lol retards these days

[kissmiss113]

Lips sing ?

[MsAwesomeaustralia]

i think the company only put the real song and not their live voices on top cos the audience was too loud. they do that sometime u noe...

[Henlichul]

i am having the hardest time understanding any of these words..

[fakeAsmile77]

Hyoyeon's hair is awesome!:D but i still like Yoona <3

[rw081]

soo young

<3

[embilak]

SOOYOUNG ♥___♥

[lamoskgr]

this morning a girl that hates kpop told me that she loves this song and i was so proud!

[patanapothung]

its like there's no audience...

[Dcmcfmc1428]

@patanapothung because its not a fancam , the company put the audio over so that its clear .

[NguyenDaiHai123]

Lame

Leap sing

Dancing like walking

[BBSOL01]

@NguyenDaiHai123 well....can u do any better??

[TaigaShana0Melon]

@NguyenDaiHai123 Oh yeah...it's not their real voice..maybe some of the members don't know english enough to sing it yet but let's hope we will hear it LIVE for real one day! :)

[snsdyoonyul24]

r they lip singing



[Dcmcfmc1428]

@snsdyoonyul24 No, the company put the audio over so that its clear .They sang it live .

[kakaulale]

@callmecherri yeah...i can imagine how it feels be in the middle of the crowd...full of goose bumps

[LoveMeUndone]

I know english music now sucks, at least half of it at least, and I like SNSD and all but to make it in the english industry you can't just translate a Korean songs and dances... it's a different industry for a reason, sure music is universal but the cultures do differ... I so want to see what 2ne1 comes up with cause their smart and have will.i.am, an actual english producer and artist with them

[sellaserra]

aneh nih yg comment

[charliecom]

Forever loving Hyoyeon!!!!! she's my ultimate girl crush.hehehe

[xBalsamiciousx]

their voices suck big time -_-' and the lyrics dont even make sense, lol

[Lyfelong397]

@xBalsamiciousx no one forced you here =/...

[xBalsamiciousx]

@Lyfelong397 I like the song and the music video, thats why I came here :) I just think their voices are not good, and to be honest! the lyrics really DONT MAKE SENSE, but i still love the song :)

[fusionboi]

too bad they lip singed...=[

[MapleDemonSlayer]

@fusionboi they didnt lip synced.....

[xXsTaRsXx9]

JESSICA <3 so gorgeous.

[SkyAngelsan]

their song is awesome but their choreography sucks!! What's with those hands holding forward and walking like a zombi, it just looks stupid.

[ParkHJung]

I'm not being mean but it's hard to accept the fact that they'll make it big in US, if they're lyrics make no sense.

[RasamiChannel]

@ParkHJung I know, but the lyrics are made by Teddy Riley, the same one who does songs for Micheal Jackson. :) But it's nice because this girl group is trying to break the Korean record and sell albums worldwide instead.

[kakaulale]

their hottt...!!! but where is the crowd??we can't hear them...i would like to hear taeyoon with exhausted breath singing on the microphones lively...it more sexy

[callmecherri]

@kakaulale i was there, everyone was going crazy, its just that when SM uploaded the performance they replaced the live audio with the audio from the track so you cant hear the audience and their breaths and sadly thats why people think they lipsynched this performance. it was all live but sm didnt upload it :/

it was amazing tho :) Yoona waved at me multiple times ^.^

[MsHimSmile]

Yeah, they can't really speak english, but however they had did their great effort. So, if you the fan of snsd, why don't you be proud of it? They're great ! .. p/s: the member that can really speak english is Jessica and Tiffany only.

[SoshiLover94]

@MsHimSmile Seohyun can speak English quite well too..

[loligeoff2]

@MsHimSmile Taeyeon and Seohyun can speak english too.

[novicalista]

SN SD can't really speak english

[kaizer8261994]

@novicalista well Jessica Sunny and Tiffany are very fluent in english :D they grew up in the states. :D

[OmgFalicia]

@kaizer8261994 Sunny didn't grow up in the states, she was born there but moved when she was an infant. //I'm Sunny biased//

[markKJ005]

Saranghaeyo Girls Generation. . . . .!!!!!!!!! Nice performance

[dilyaelf]

lipsynched

[rosenerdmcr]

can they zoom out a little so i can see the entire group

[babokute98]

đây thật sự là lồng giọng , giọng thật của họ ko trong như thế , khó tin

[ajyoonaloveskp0p]

Hyo & yoona :D

[tiffanysub14]

they're not lip sync, they really sing. Why don't you guys watch the fancam to see. I gaurentee they're lip sync

[aznbandit857]

@tiffanysub14

LOL wtf dude ur comment is confusing, you said they dont lip sinc and they lip sinc at the same time

[tiffanysub14]

@aznbandit857 oh I'm missing the word "not" before lip sync, so... and I'm a girl, not a dude, sorry

[oyx1559]

hyo yeon left side her shirt is tear at her armpit

[wahidinalamnuari]

Love YooNa So Much ... Hmm Seohyun So Cute There ... Love It ... !!!! Wow Tiffany And Yuri Have A Great Voice .... DAEBAK...

[nazreable]

love snsd..love their song..but sorry no offense..i can't wait to see their live performance- the boys english version-

[iluvsnsd9]

♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!! ♥SOOYOUNG!!

[iluvsnsd9]

♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥♥ sooyoung♥

[NancyMacc]

*someone sorry mistake

[NancyMacc]

They're not lip synching . It's just Zoe one put the studio version on top of the actual singing. Hope this helps :3

[ShiRuroYasHini]

SOOYOUNG SMILE SO URGHHHHHHHHHH!! SO HOT!..MY GOD SOOYOUNG SHIITAI. YOUR MAKING ME A BOY RIGHT NOW.... "O G WE MAKE YOU SO HOT" LIKE YOU^^..MY SOOYOUNG~~YOUR SMILE SO HOT AND SEXY OVER DUPER!!.. OMER na jud!!

[Kilayli]

Uhhh why is there music played over their actual performance? Ps Jessica and some others in the group haven't had even a touch of cosmetic surgery. I don't think any have had 'plastic' surgery, just minor cosmetic surgery. (maybe double eyelid)

[TheCreamer97]

because of the plastic surgery I can't see any aging in here...

[TheCreamer97]

@azndomorocks meanzzz they R lipsync ritezzzz??? If they can't sing because they dance why can they sing AND "DANCE" at the KOREAN verion?!?!?!?!?!?!?! Think the hell upzzzz -__-''

[dsmiles76]

As much as I like these girls, they're starting to look a bit underweight.

[karylleC]

they are all pretty esp hyoyeon's side :)) seohyun is getting matured..LOL snsd lovelots <3 

[XLoLiLoveUX]

YOONA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!! <3 <3

[e3dequinnluv]

sooyoung,,,like ur style.......!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[TheCreamer97]

lip sync.. again for English ver... Why oh why? -___-''

[azndomorocks]

@TheCreamer97 cuzz they cant rponounce everything ritee well dancingg

[tiffanysub14]

@TheCreamer97 they're not lip sync, why don't you watch the actual fancam to see :)

[IamMeYM]

@ChloeKohXD Nope:) Its the same as the MV

[IAmJaeLee]

YOONGIE!

[mileyhannah1231]

i wanna hear their voice live . but they are still awesome

[yulshinkim]

they can sing english very well .. i love that!!! i love SNSD!!!

[soshib0y]

wow cant believe it there performing in madison!

[vanezitais]

so beautiful SNSD ..!!! XD

[applelicious1314]

SNSD DAEBAK!

[reahit]

@applelicious1314 what was daebak mean?

[applelicious1314]

@reahit it means great! ^^ its a term koreans use~ 'jjang' too.