Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (165)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Wouw wouw wouw! I love the version of this song soooo much! I do love the vocals in the back! I love old fashion they showing on stage!

  • She Is.

  • SHE SHOULD HAVE BECAME FAMOUS

  • She is, "OUTSTANDING".

  • You are still so amazing to me! :)

  • I feel like I'm not watching American Idol when I see this. Just watching like some concert of an amazing artist.

  • she is beautiful, good luck to you girl and your baby.... you are the best

  • Your Fans Are Still Out Here!!!

  • She's got soul. Hope she doesn't sell it. Love her singing.

  • I liked how she looked, until she smiled.

  • I only like looking at her 'cause she's pretty.

  • The falsetto near the end was so unnecessary, forced and quite simply shit.

  • And if anybody is cold blunt is Simon and he is absolutely right on this performance. She is a true artist.

  • the other guy won just because he was more charismatic, not bcz he had a better voice

  • Wish you would have won Crystal! Haha

  • I still don't understand how she didn't win.

  • Crystal is not just a singer she is a musical artist big difference!!!

  • fuck this is one wicked performance

  • @reprogrammingx5337 yοս сaո watϲh tv frοm all οvеr the ԝorld on your рc јսst by dοԝոlοаdіnց ѕomе рroցram, it'ѕ ցot thοuѕaոds οf ϲհanոеls οո it. ϳսst gο tο linevid com (рut а . befοrе the com οbvioսѕly, it ԝοn't let mе pοѕt links for sοmе reаsοn) іt'ѕ ոοt exасtly frее bսt іt's just onе timе рayment aոd іt wοrkѕ rеаlly well

  • I absolutely loved Janis Joplin, and I think Crystal is better, only time will tell. Good Luck Crystal, you absolutely should have won, it wasn't even close in my book.

  • y america.. u had one of the best artists the world has ever seen and she came second.... still cant believe it... this woman actually sings a gladys song better than gladys... no one can do that!.... not even gladys!

  • Obergeile Stimme!

    

  • GOD I love this song! And with Crystal singing it? A new Classic!!! I hope her first album goes platinum the first day. She deserves it.

  • Still loving this song but her onstage performance sounds better to me than the studio vers

  • wow, great singer, great song! very talented young-woman. Greetings from the Netherlands

  • FTW FOR THE WIN!

  • AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!ILY CRYSTAL!!

  • This makes me wish I never quit the piano...

  • excelente bello y que talento

  • WOW! MY MOST FAVORITE GLADYS KNIGHT AND THE PIPS SONG-EVER! CRYSTAL NAILED IT! NAILED IT! I GET CHILLS EVERY SINGLE TIE I HEAR AND SEE HER PERFORM THIS! CRYSTAL BOWERSOX IS A S-T-A-R! NO DOUBT!

  • crystal should have won.

    hands down.

    this performance definitely shows that.

  • Instead of saying she sings like a black woman just say she's got soul lol. But yea Crystal is an amazing artist and even though she didnt win i think she is going to be a big star regardless. :)

  • she is so beautiful and amazing i love her!@

  • This white lady really plays  black music perfect. Wow!

  • OMG i'm in love with her BEAUTIFUL voice! She is AMAZING!

  • she sings like a black woman :D

  • She should won!

  • did anyone see them sing this on house, it was the greatest part of that show ever

  • Comment removed

  • oohh is that sue sylvester 3:15-3:19? wheeee

  • she's too good for American Idol.

  • @ck8y and every time you leave a note, it makes me wanna take a leak.

  • She is the best. Judge on her vocals - power, range, control. Judge on originality versatility, and uniqueness. Vote for the talent that STANDS OUT, and not big looks and small talent.

    Go Mamasox, vote for the true musician and artist in this season. Anyone with her qualities deserves to win it, and Crystal;s the one with it!

  • She was wonderful. She did look a bit uncomfortable on the piano, but I thought she sounded terrific. I didn't really think Simon's point was too relevant. It's going to be hard for me to vote this week. I really love both Crystal and Lee. They're just different. They're like apples and oranges, but both good artistic fruit (sorry for the pathetic metaphor). I hope they both successful in their careers.

  • Damn it... U do not talk back to Simon Cowell!

  • She's gorgeous and her voice is just to die for. So beautiful and rich!!!

  • She has an incredible voice and is incredibly GORGEOUS!!!

  • This is absolutely amazing!  I don't know what Simon is listening to but I think it has A LOT to do with the microphone they're using this season.

  • Most versatile singer. Power vocals. Risk Taker. Goes after lyrics in song choices. Shows she has many sides to her singing style. Original and Creative. Best in the season.

    Vote for the Artist and True Musician = Vote for CRYSTAL MAMASOX!!!

    Dont waste your vote on mainstream voice who chooses easy melody to cover up his out of tune habits.

  • Oh my God that was beautiful! WOW. If that isn't the best version I've ever heard!!

    I loved it! YOUR IT CRYSTAL!

  • @Ilikefewthings She could be better.

  • I think Simon was dead wrong -- there are several moments in this song where we get closer to the heart of who Crystal is than /any/ previous performance.

  • I like the way crystal replies the judges.

  • i don't like the way Crystal talks back to the judges.. tsk tsk..

  • @nikkibella21, why not? !

  • Jane Lynch is rooting for her!

  • Agree - Crystal and Lee with Crystal to win it. Man, who'da thunk it...

  • Crystal and Lee - The Final 2

  • All those who have nothing good to say about crystal can eat the over-ripe-verging-on-rotten bananas on my countertop. Deaf bitches

  • The best idol ever!

  • she looked so pretty here.(:

  • finaly....a reason to watch idol

  • This girl has IT. I dont know what IT is. But she's got IT.

  • ridiculous! she just slayed the competition!! crystal all the way!

  • CRYSTAL, YOU ARE FUCKING AMAZING!!! Iam Loooovvvinnnggg YOU!!! VOTING FOR YOU MAMASOX!!! YOU ARE A STAR!!! A M A Z I N G as A L W A Y S!!!!P.S. SEE YOU IN CONCERT!!!! VOTE! VOTE!! VOTE!!!

  • Girl for every single mommy out there...and the talent you exude...I am rooting for you all the way....love you...you are a breath of fresh air in the music industry

  • Flawless. Already WON IMO.

  • TALENTED!!! Wow - week after week, she never disappoints. She refuses to change who she is and that tells me she will go far. IMHO - it is either her or Lee...and she deserves it!

  • Win or lose I'm first in line for her first CD. She'll be huge!

  • The best,

    Sorry Simon classic is never and will never be old fashion.

    She is great ,and she is all ready a winner!

  • oh yeah Bowersox FTW!

  • She's is incredible, and very pretty in the everyday way, as opposed to the plastic hollywood look! She should win hands down.

  • beautiful, natural voice LOVE IT!!!

  • CRYSTAL MUST WIN!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • This wasn't Crystal at all. I am glad she wasn't "uncomfortable" but I think she is lying to herself. The piano playing was a great idea, but stilleto's? I can't even spell it. Just my opinion. She gives a strong performance every time.

  • Amazing is the only way to describe her voice. A God given gift.............

  • Definitely the most talented contestant this season.

  • she makes it look so easy that actually some people think it is. She's so good.

  • It started off a little rocky for me because I felt like she was concentrating on the piano too much, but when she relaxed and then got up and moved center stage it was breathtaking. Absolutely stunning performance from that point on.

  • check out crystals originals (farmers daughter and holy toledo) she an unbelievable song writer .this girl is as good as any ever. and simon is right

  • crystal bowersox is totally the next american idol!!!

  • She is so great! I sincerely HOPE FOX doesn't make her the "surprise contestant voted off too soon" this year. I just never believe the actual voting results.

  • She is just so remarkably good.

  • She is just so remarkably good.

  • umm this show needs to end so this girl can make some of her own music i dont even watch the show they all suck i just watch her on youtube

  • crystal u go girl! u hve an amazing voice.&everyone in toledo is rooting 4 u:)

  • Crystal Bowersox....if she doesn't win...which im sure she will....she will be my american idol!!!! The most unique i have ever seen!!!!

  • she is going to become the next idol

  • THANKS American Idol for putting these songs on iTunes. I downloaded both the live AND full length studio version of this. It was totally worth it and I am already ready to buy Crystal's debut album!!

  • This song is beatiful.Hope this song is on her album.You are amazing Crystal.Kiss from Poland

  • And she is not boring for god's sake. Andrew without his mother is boring. Michael Lynche without his wife and child, is boring. Didi without the tears for a dead friend is boring. Crystal alone, talking and singing, is interesting.

  • I hope she goes back to looking simple. Watching her all glammed up makes me cringe. Still love her though.

  • Have watched this video over and over......you are amazing crystal, look out world here you come. A huge fan from downunder. Thanks Crystal, your'e already there

  • Now WE ARE LOOKING at this season's AMERICAN IDOL!

    Fantastic girl... Every song she sings turns into masterpiece..

    Go, Bowersox!

  • this girl is amazing its sick

  • First off, Usher is such an amazing person. This song fits Crystal so well that I got goosebumps for like the first time in this dreadful season of mediocrity.

  • IMO, Simon was wrong. This song suits her as much as the "rawer" ones, song just shows a different side of her. Would have been boring with only the Janis Joplin-ish ones. I do agree that the background singers were NOT necessary, Crystal can hold her own no matter.

  • IMO, Simon was wrong. This song suits her as much as the "rawer" ones, song just shows a different side of her. Would have been boring with only the Janis Joplin-ish ones. I do agree that the background singers were NOT necessary, Crystal can hold her own no matter.

  • @alyroxx2010 crystal is amazing... stop smoking crack she has an incredible voice..

  • @KyuubiNemesis94  that was my sis but i still agree siobhan should win all the way! I just think crystal is sooo boring.

  • @alyroxx2010 All those who have nothing good to say about crystal can eat the over-ripe-verging-on-rotten bananas on my countertop. Deaf bitches

  • @alyroxx2010 All those who have nothing good to say about crystal can eat the over-ripe-verging-on-rotten bananas on my countertop. Deaf bitches

  • this made me laugh... thank you for supporting...She has it all.  Simon says "at times incredible" I agree she has it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Wow, why don't they just give her the title already!?

  • Comment removed

  • This girl is amazing! She's batting 1.000 right now and it doesn't look like she's gonna slow down anytime soon. Why no one ever picked her up out of the subway stations she used to play in and sign her is unbelievable. She doesn't need Idol to make her career. But since she's here now, she might possibly be the next Kelly Clarkson / Carrie Underwood Idol success story.

  • What kind of songs will they be singing next week, does anyone know?

  • @YT102008 Mccartney/Lennon

  • @Seifsalama: Thank you.

  • The fact is...Crystal takes these great old songs, sings them, and knocks it out of the park. She doesn't screw the song up, butcher the sound, or even tinker with the arrangement to sound all hip and cool. She just does what she does best. The other contestants try entirely too hard to look unique, and they end up looking stupid and sounding worse... a real artist never gets swallowed up by the song, it just comes natural to Crystal. She is the real deal.

  • UGH, you people kill me with your "all knowing" critiques. Kara's looking for this or that...Crystal isn't current...WTF do you people know? Really? People are loving this girl, so you're obviously wrong. Suck it up and shut it up...cause you really don't have a clue what you're arguing about.

  • @Rastis35 You voted for Bush?

  • @Jurek1979 ... What? If that was an attempt to be a smart ass, you failed.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Simon is so right alot of these talent shows want to change what got them there. He said it best do not let them suck away who you really are. She reminds me a bit like Jewel. I don't know she will be mainstream because most mainstream is total toilet water now. But she is a true artis & hopes she keeps to that.

  • She's the only one who consistently sings very old songs and is not unique. There are other singers who do the same she's trying to do. They never call her on not being current the way they do everyone else. She's arrogant which I can't stand and is probably the reason I'm starting to dislike her. Also, she really can't sing that great. Seriously.

  • @IvaCitizenJournalist :  Get lost, your not fit to comment on this one... Common, she's really a great artist and how come she's arrogant? Maybe u are... arrogant.

  • @IvaCitizenJournalist All those who have nothing good to say about crystal can eat the over-ripe-verging-on-rotten bananas on my countertop. Deaf bitch

  • I luved this performance!! shes awsome my #1 fav :))

  • I luved this performance!! shes awsome my #1 fav :))

  • With a lot of musicians, most of the time, I simply just hear their music. With Crystal I feel her music, as well as hear it.

  • Kara finds it so hard to be complementary to Crystal. Why? Is she jealous? This girl is amazingly talented. What a find for Idol! I think she's incredible and I would go to see her in a concert. Simon is correct, she shouldn't change, but she is showing her versatility. She's going to have a powerful career anyway.

  • @sammimitsu my remarks are mainly about her singing not to be current ... " very old fashion girl very 70's flower power type " ... Simon made a similar remark to the backup girls. Not 1 single performance from her was current she always sings the same way like she is living in the 70's.

  • @wldnemesis Alanis isn't current?

  • @sammimitsu If Kara finds it hard to give Crystal a complement that's because she is looking for that new comtemporary sound that is lacking in Crystal performances. We are living in the 21 century it's time to evolve that's what recording companies look for a new sound not just a good voice because if that was the case there are plenty of good singers in the show.

  • Talent is never "old fashioned" or "out of style". Talent is talent and it doesn't have an era. This is an incredibly talented woman and it's sad that some people would prefer that she weigh 98 pounds and run around the stage jiggling her bare butt at the audience like more "modern" female singers do. It only serves to demonstrate the sad state of the music industry and the taste level of the general public.

  • She's going to be a legend and it's in the making for this generation. Sure do hope they know a rare gem when it's right in front of them - we did, with Janice Joplin.

  • I don't see the big deal with this girl... I'm not saying I don't like her, I do, but she is a very old fashion girl very 70's flower power type even her clothes are out of style... they want something new but she is not... like Simon said once she is a subway/bar singer!! cannot be compared to the idols from last year... not for 1 m The judges influence the people's votes and they are making this show a low class one, like a little soap opera, I guess it's all about the audience numbers...SAD

  • @wldnemesis: : Last year's idols? You mean Lambert and that forgettable winner. The only thing that makes Lambert not forgettable is his gay life style, otherwise he is forgettable too. Crystal is the best thing happening to Idol and its falling ratings. Idol in the past was the only venue giving the mediocre national exposure. People realize that and began moving away. Crystal's pure natural talent brought many back to Idol this season. Crystal is the best ever on Idol.

  • @wldnemesis The points you make about her appearance are insignificant, few stars start out with great looks. They all get makeovers but what makes Crystal different is that she is a consummate musician & very talented. She is not Cheryl Cole, or Posh Coathanger Spice. None of these tarts can sing but they look good, so now society pressurises female singers to look like models. It's ludicrous.

  • Comment removed

  • *hands out Grammy*

  • She is goin' to be the next american idol,nobody can't beat her in the american idol season 7,she look peaceful on stage,love every time she sing

  • Comment removed

  • Win or Lose, I Iook forward to buying her music. With some artist you hear their music, with Crystal you feel her music.

  • Love the piano! Another amazing performance. BUT...kill the high heels.!! : ( They do not match the "you" I was beginning to think I could trust would stay true to herself. Simon's clear warning to make no change to your performances is spot on. We who are voting for you, "Power Sox," expect/want what you gave in your previous performances....and as Simon says, "It's yours to lose." Take no more chances....until you've won....pleeeeze!

  • i've heard this song a thousand times, and what I love about Crystal is, as with all the other songs she has done, she took it, spun it, and made it her own, not just a regurgitation of previous versions.

  • Beautiful just beautiful, I would like to hear her do the complete song, one of my favorites. I'm so happy that she shows that she is not just a rock singer. I do agree with Simon that she must remain true to herself, and I think she understands it. Besides her awesome vocals, its her originality that sets her apart and I think we all love.

  • Amazing, what a star.

  • she's amazing! she's so real. love her!

  • Crystal is amazing, a born performer and should definitely win the American idol!!!!

  • OMFG Crystal sounds so damn good

  • AMAZING!!

  • Ok critics...she put her guitar down...did something different...guess what? Beautiful Crystal continues to astound us with that unbelievable God-given voice. As Randy stated...Great performance again Crystal.

  • Wow! wow! wow!

  • Crystal MommaSox never cease to amaze me. She made that song sound like it was a recent hit. Again, another magnificent performance. Yes, maybe she's a bit uncomfortable on the piano, but with that kind of talent and determination, she'll be playing virtuoso in no time at all.

    She's in it to win. She gets better everytime.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more