The Allied commanders, with the blessing of Truman, had intentionally decided to let the Soviets be the first in Berlin. "Let the Soviets do the 'spate work' and mangle their way into heavily defended Berlin," Ike had Suggested to Truman. It may sound cynical, but it was a smart move to conserve lives. Why risk more lives storming into a hornet's nest when the Soviets are prepared to do it? It was practical reality in April 1945.
This is the most interesting battle for me, it was entirely a revenge plot. Anyways anyone interested in this battle should read "The fall of Berlin 1945" by Antony Beevor
Mrs Nusbacher is a sack of shit he totally doesnt know what he's talking about. The Allies agreed way in advance that the Russians would attack Berlin, even though the US 83rd Army could have gotten there first.
You have to admit it's remarkable how long the Germans defended their lost Reich. With a huge material disadvantage they held longer than anyone expected
We Americans were glad to allow the Soviets the privilege of capturing Berlin for three primary reasons. One, we had already agreed about the lines of demarcation that follow the Surrender of the Third Reich. Two, the Soviet homeland had been devastated by the Nazi invasion and they deserved to dish out the revenge on Berlin. Third, The USA didn't have the emotional need to capture the German capital and USA would gladly avoid the needlesscasualties.
@randy109 Although there is sense in the last sentence of your comment, I would like to kindly ask you to refrain from the use of words such as "allowed". I think if you have read on the topic you would know, that at the time it was Stalin's word that mattered and both, Roosevelt and Churchill had no choice but to obey. Read Montgomery's book on Stalin.
Isn't it time to stop trying to paint the Germans as the bad guys??? Read everything you can get your hands on about pre-ww2 Europe. Russia manipulated the Germans into invading Poland. Stalin was the main manipulator of WW2.
@warisugly Did Stalin force Hitler to invade Czechoslovakia? Belgium? France? Please - your statement is ridiculous on its face. Hitler spent 10 years talking about Eastern Europe as Germany's "living space".
@de4th1snt3nough That's a pretty stupid criticism - why does a military historian have to be a combat veteran? How many of them actually are? How many generals, for that matter, have actually seen combat?
@kingtiger88 poor frodo turned into a girl. his crediability is extremely low. Take anything he says at face value. And i'm not being mean because he got a sex-change. He's been wrong before.
same with the russians, they could have pushed the germans back in 1941 if theyd have listened to the german sqeuealers, and if the lakes had frozen earlier in leningrad to get tanks earlier into leningrad etc.
Pushed the Wehrmacht and Waffen-SS back ???? ON OPEN GROUND OUTSIDE LENINGRAD!!!???
NO WAY! In the long run, deep inside Russia, YES! The long distances and the winters did a lot of damage. Stalins wanted the Germans as deep into Russia as possible ;)
i don't know if you have read any history books but it was actually germany that invaded the ussr, not the other way round. then they proceeded to murder civilians, burn villages and inflict untold suffering to millions of people. it was a war of annihilation. they meant to wipe entire soviet cities out of existence, 'reduce' the population ad turn the rest into slaves. so yeah, they got a taste of their own medicine.
Did I say That it was the UssR that invaded Germany?? No, I did not. So go and learn how to read maybe. Your American propaganda and holywood movies fried your brain. You have no idea what your talkin about. My Grandfather fought on the Eastern Front against the russians. Civilians always get caught up in the crossfire. Its called war. The Germans were the best soldiers the world has ever seen. For every 1 german soldier that gor killed 11 russian soldiers got killed. God bless Germany.!
The British and american cowards bombed german civilians during the entire war. When the japenese attacked Pearl Harbour ( military base ) 1,700 civilians got caught up in the crossfire. Thats the amount of civilians the USA lost during the entire war. The americans killed 145,100 japenese civilians and a couple of hundred thousend German civilians. What a bunch of worthless cowards.
i guess growing up in a more or less free world has left some people ungrateful to the sacrifices of the millions that died to defend freedom during wwii. 'worthless cowards'? you should be ashamed.
Those people (allies) sacrifised their lives for nothing. The world would have been a much better place if the germans had won the war. Capitalism is a failure and millions are starving to death. Free world? Pornography, Gay parades, Starvasion, Prostitusion, Drugs, Overpopulation, polution, ect.. thats what your "free world" is all about. The Germans fought for honour, truth, Culture, Pride, loyalty, Dignity, Heritage, ect.. WW2 wasn't won.. it was lost.
Germans never even killed 1 American civilian.. You killed hundreds of thousends of German civilians.. like your doing now in Iraq and Afganistan. That is what your good at, killing innocent women and children. You americans should learn to keep your noses out of other peoples bussiness!
The west allies where fooled by Stalin, a guy even more evel then Hitler, they gave up Europe and much of 2000 years of culture for a muderer and caos! and we still suffer today!!
The Germans at the battle of Berlin were a mixed bag. Some were highly trained and battle hardened veterans of various fronts of WWII to old men and young boys. The RKKA was made up for the most part of seasoned veterans of years of war. In accord with Soviet doctrine the Red Army relied on the huge amount of firepower of their tanks and artillery not to mention massive numbers of infantry to finally crush the German defenses in eastern Germany. The Germans fought well but they could not win.
Well they had good reason to be a bit pissed, after all they just lost 29 million people.And they had very good reason to be worried since there was a certain school of thought among American military planners that since they had the Bomb, they should use it against Russia and get rid of this Communist problem. As for the commentary,Berlin`s fate was discussed and agreed at Yalta. I think "terror" is a bit strong here, after all they were just through the Nazis occupation.
At 4:06 or so is when Stalin reminds me of Hitler a little bit. Isn't that weird?
vonPruts 2 weeks ago
@2:32 "oopsie daisy!" lol
trje246 1 month ago
The Allied commanders, with the blessing of Truman, had intentionally decided to let the Soviets be the first in Berlin. "Let the Soviets do the 'spate work' and mangle their way into heavily defended Berlin," Ike had Suggested to Truman. It may sound cynical, but it was a smart move to conserve lives. Why risk more lives storming into a hornet's nest when the Soviets are prepared to do it? It was practical reality in April 1945.
HPG747 8 months ago
i know it may sound a bit mad, but i wish i was there. best battle that has ever happened
ULTCrob 9 months ago
This movie is not worth watching.
Zenith4165 10 months ago
This is the most interesting battle for me, it was entirely a revenge plot. Anyways anyone interested in this battle should read "The fall of Berlin 1945" by Antony Beevor
you wont be dissapointed
thedicklick1 1 year ago
@thedicklick1 The only British historian worth reading is Basil Liddell Hart. Everything else is distorted illusions through the eye of the "allies".
Zenith4165 10 months ago
Mrs Nusbacher is a sack of shit he totally doesnt know what he's talking about. The Allies agreed way in advance that the Russians would attack Berlin, even though the US 83rd Army could have gotten there first.
MauserK43 1 year ago
You have to admit it's remarkable how long the Germans defended their lost Reich. With a huge material disadvantage they held longer than anyone expected
TheJBurner 1 year ago
We Americans were glad to allow the Soviets the privilege of capturing Berlin for three primary reasons. One, we had already agreed about the lines of demarcation that follow the Surrender of the Third Reich. Two, the Soviet homeland had been devastated by the Nazi invasion and they deserved to dish out the revenge on Berlin. Third, The USA didn't have the emotional need to capture the German capital and USA would gladly avoid the needlesscasualties.
randy109 1 year ago
@randy109 yeah but probably the brits and the french didnt have the same thoughts,so berlin WAS important to the western allies
TheWoodstock2009 1 year ago
@randy109 Although there is sense in the last sentence of your comment, I would like to kindly ask you to refrain from the use of words such as "allowed". I think if you have read on the topic you would know, that at the time it was Stalin's word that mattered and both, Roosevelt and Churchill had no choice but to obey. Read Montgomery's book on Stalin.
Zenith4165 10 months ago
only by seeing american things u know the germans were good people...
FrederEngelh 1 year ago
Isn't it time to stop trying to paint the Germans as the bad guys??? Read everything you can get your hands on about pre-ww2 Europe. Russia manipulated the Germans into invading Poland. Stalin was the main manipulator of WW2.
warisugly 2 years ago
It's amazing how people totally overlook the other sides to the war. To them Nazi / Japanese = the only aggressors.
gandhicakes 2 years ago 2
@warisugly I have only one word : concentrationcamps
Nightwithe 1 year ago
@warisugly Did Stalin force Hitler to invade Czechoslovakia? Belgium? France? Please - your statement is ridiculous on its face. Hitler spent 10 years talking about Eastern Europe as Germany's "living space".
guysmiley00 1 year ago
3:49-Dr. Nusbacher took too many drama classes!
June28July 2 years ago
And he recently had a sex change. And that is no joke!
kingtiger88 2 years ago 3
he's not half bad just a total virgin in actual combat situations
de4th1snt3nough 2 years ago
@de4th1snt3nough That's a pretty stupid criticism - why does a military historian have to be a combat veteran? How many of them actually are? How many generals, for that matter, have actually seen combat?
guysmiley00 1 year ago
WHAAAAAT!!! HOLY S***!!! TOTALLY OUT OF THE BLUE!!!
He was married to a woman... Now what?
June28July 2 years ago
Sex change?I thought he was just dressing up like a woman.
MokomaSusi 2 years ago
@kingtiger88
and i thought that was just tabloid news until i read it myself.... lol!!
sparticool 1 year ago
@kingtiger88 poor frodo turned into a girl. his crediability is extremely low. Take anything he says at face value. And i'm not being mean because he got a sex-change. He's been wrong before.
MauserK43 1 year ago
@kingtiger88 he always was a drama queen!
stevemarco5 1 year ago
@kingtiger88
I still thought you were joking...and so I checked. Oh my God! You weren't!!! LMAO!
derin111 1 year ago
hitler is bad :(
stiso12 2 years ago
FUCK ME! The USSR had a threw everything they had on Germany. And it was A LOT of stuff.
Ialocin85 2 years ago
Don`t mess with Stalin
Andiish08 2 years ago
Dont mess with the Germans boy.. The germans kicked Ruski ass man. For every 1 German soldier that got killed 11 Russians got slautered. Think again.
Poeskaas 2 years ago
you don't mess with the russians!
illbetilbake 2 years ago
The Finnish were messed with by the Russians in 1939, and STALIN GOT HIS ASS KICKED!
Ialocin85 2 years ago 9
well you still shouldn't mess with them
illbetilbake 2 years ago
USSR after ww2 and todays Russia....TRUE! Totaly agree with you!
Germany beat them in ww1 and could have beaten them in ww2. The Germans had all the odds against them....unlucky
Ialocin85 2 years ago
go read mein kampf or something. chill out.
illbetilbake 2 years ago
same with the russians, they could have pushed the germans back in 1941 if theyd have listened to the german sqeuealers, and if the lakes had frozen earlier in leningrad to get tanks earlier into leningrad etc.
cole3454657 2 years ago
Pushed the Wehrmacht and Waffen-SS back ???? ON OPEN GROUND OUTSIDE LENINGRAD!!!???
NO WAY! In the long run, deep inside Russia, YES! The long distances and the winters did a lot of damage. Stalins wanted the Germans as deep into Russia as possible ;)
Ialocin85 2 years ago
True man. The finns kicked their asses hard.
Poeskaas 2 years ago
Dont mess with the Russian cause they will rape your whole countries women. That sounds more like it. The Germans kicked their asses fuckin hard.
Poeskaas 2 years ago
i don't know if you have read any history books but it was actually germany that invaded the ussr, not the other way round. then they proceeded to murder civilians, burn villages and inflict untold suffering to millions of people. it was a war of annihilation. they meant to wipe entire soviet cities out of existence, 'reduce' the population ad turn the rest into slaves. so yeah, they got a taste of their own medicine.
illbetilbake 2 years ago 3
Did I say That it was the UssR that invaded Germany?? No, I did not. So go and learn how to read maybe. Your American propaganda and holywood movies fried your brain. You have no idea what your talkin about. My Grandfather fought on the Eastern Front against the russians. Civilians always get caught up in the crossfire. Its called war. The Germans were the best soldiers the world has ever seen. For every 1 german soldier that gor killed 11 russian soldiers got killed. God bless Germany.!
Poeskaas 2 years ago
The British and american cowards bombed german civilians during the entire war. When the japenese attacked Pearl Harbour ( military base ) 1,700 civilians got caught up in the crossfire. Thats the amount of civilians the USA lost during the entire war. The americans killed 145,100 japenese civilians and a couple of hundred thousend German civilians. What a bunch of worthless cowards.
Poeskaas 2 years ago
i guess growing up in a more or less free world has left some people ungrateful to the sacrifices of the millions that died to defend freedom during wwii. 'worthless cowards'? you should be ashamed.
illbetilbake 2 years ago
Those people (allies) sacrifised their lives for nothing. The world would have been a much better place if the germans had won the war. Capitalism is a failure and millions are starving to death. Free world? Pornography, Gay parades, Starvasion, Prostitusion, Drugs, Overpopulation, polution, ect.. thats what your "free world" is all about. The Germans fought for honour, truth, Culture, Pride, loyalty, Dignity, Heritage, ect.. WW2 wasn't won.. it was lost.
Poeskaas 2 years ago
gay parades are fun!
illbetilbake 2 years ago
Whatever tickles your fancy...
Poeskaas 2 years ago
And the Germans were under Nazi rule. If the Germans had won, the Nazis would have won. That's why the Germans had to lose.
June28July 2 years ago
Yes because the Germans and Japanese NEVER EVER hurt ANY civilians.
June28July 2 years ago
Germans never even killed 1 American civilian.. You killed hundreds of thousends of German civilians.. like your doing now in Iraq and Afganistan. That is what your good at, killing innocent women and children. You americans should learn to keep your noses out of other peoples bussiness!
Poeskaas 2 years ago
@Poeskaas
The Nazis killed plenty of civilians when they invaded Poland and Russia; they weren't American civilians but they were still civilians.
As for Iraq and Afghanistan, I'm sure there were civilian casualties during fighting but it was not intentional. We never gassed them.
June28July 2 years ago
Someone speak the truth!!thank you!!!
Master666555 2 years ago
@Poeskaas You also bombed the hell out of britain during the war..... cities not strategic targets....just saying you should think before you speak.
djdefjam89X 1 year ago
The west allies where fooled by Stalin, a guy even more evel then Hitler, they gave up Europe and much of 2000 years of culture for a muderer and caos! and we still suffer today!!
StaffanGoldschmidt 1 year ago
yeaaa but u gotta remember that NAZI Germany and the USSR both invaded poland in 1939.......thus both starting world war 2
de4th1snt3nough 2 years ago
The Germans at the battle of Berlin were a mixed bag. Some were highly trained and battle hardened veterans of various fronts of WWII to old men and young boys. The RKKA was made up for the most part of seasoned veterans of years of war. In accord with Soviet doctrine the Red Army relied on the huge amount of firepower of their tanks and artillery not to mention massive numbers of infantry to finally crush the German defenses in eastern Germany. The Germans fought well but they could not win.
PanzerGrenadierLSSAH 3 years ago 8
Germans had big forces in Tschech,Norway,Kurland
batalion666 3 years ago
Nothing against the Soviets xD
kalkunkage1 3 years ago
that dosent make the soviets 100% good guys! after the war they spread terror through the whole eastern europe!
Suomipanzerdiv13 3 years ago
Well they had good reason to be a bit pissed, after all they just lost 29 million people.And they had very good reason to be worried since there was a certain school of thought among American military planners that since they had the Bomb, they should use it against Russia and get rid of this Communist problem. As for the commentary,Berlin`s fate was discussed and agreed at Yalta. I think "terror" is a bit strong here, after all they were just through the Nazis occupation.
Stewie4321 3 years ago 4
They also attacked Poland, like HitlerGermany
Ialocin85 2 years ago
Thanks for uploading
raux111 4 years ago
cool
mariekeD24 4 years ago
Thx for upploading :D
Knifebeard2 4 years ago