Based on "A day in the life, Yellow Submarine, All you need is love, Imagine, Hey Jude, Being for the Benefit of Mr. Kite!" and more. What happened to Eric?? ... Was a Rutle Only Musicians Reunion?? Greetings from Mexico. Sorry my bad english.
I believe that Eric Idle and Neil Innes had a real bad falling out and the guitarist doing Idles bits Ollie Haskell sadly died not too many years after the All you need is cash was release. So Neil fills in for the Dirk songs.
@BozRyan It's true, Eric and Neil had a falling out over the Archaeology - Eric refused to be involved because he felt like the joke had been played out; then he made "The Rutles 2", which exploited all of the Archaeology music, despite Neil not being involved in the film.
The rutles changed a little bit the music of The Beatles, it's not better than the beatles but I think even if you change a little bit of their music it will stay beautiful.
And that was the work of 4 men who changed the world of the music ;)
@Sirblahblah24 It's not the song itself. There might be a dozen Beatles songs quoted in this thing. It's all reminders of a better time that's completely gone.
We ought to petition the BBC to release the Rutland Weekend Television series onto Youtube, if they're not going to Bother showing it themselves. There's Trillions of archive programmes in there which no-one will want to see in a few years more.
Dirk was still live in the mid seventies!! According to my Rutles record sleeve "Albums currently available on Rutle" one of the records is "The Punk Floyd (with Dirk McQuickly) ~ White Dopes On Punk", and there his is on the front cover with a massive safety pin thru his nose" Also it was Stig who was supposed to have died ~ on the Sgt Rutter album he is leaning in the exact position of a dying Yeti (from the Rutland book of the dead) In the words of Viv Stanshall so therrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr...
Dirk IS dead, now -- proven by no involvement with Archeology. Rest in peace, Mr. McQuickly, in that great buffet hall and sitar paradise in the sky...
Dirk isn't dead. He simply left the Rutles to go into comedy. I heard he and some other mates formed some comedy troupe that went on to appear in a cult favorite tv show in the early '70s and even made a handful of very wild movies. But you can't believe everything you read on the Internet.
Few know that Nasty invented the Slinky which was marketed by his ex wife Ann Coulter who stole the rights from him making a fortune for herself and donating it all to the John Birch Society
Esa cancion me recuerda mucho a ti muñequita, esa rola escuchaba a cada rato cuando estaba enamorado de ti, siempre seras parte de mi vida, de mi presente y de mi pasado, y me habras de acompañar hasta el ultimo instante y hasta mi ultimo aliento mi muñequita preciosa.
Me trae recuerdos muy gratos y muy dolorosos esta cancion, gracias señor Eric Iddle, gracias señor Neil Innes. y hasta siempre muñequita, siempre seras mi gran amor
Nice @ 4:37. "We're Free-eee- To Be Whatever we are." That's a reference to the lawsuit Neil Innes conflicted on The Oasis track 'Whatever' as the notes were lifted from Innes` 'How Sweet To Be An Idiot.' He got co-writing credit from that.
Eric and Neil had a falling out over credits of the Monty python songs, Neil Innes name was removed from a bunch of ones he co-wrote, and Eric didnt want to take part in this reunion. I do believe they have since made up and appeared together as the rutles.
the guy who is dressed as Michael Jackson is a great friend of mine..Joby Rogers, who was the only MJ impersonator endorsed by MJ himself. We've worked together (me as McCartney) on the McCartney / Jackson duets for over 20 years and most recently 2 weeks ago. Back To The Rutles...genious..with or without Dirk McQuigley!
This is one of my favorite songs of all time. Though this version cuts out about another 3 minutes of "La de do dah la de dah here we are in Shangri-la" it's not too much of a difference otherwise. I just love the lyrics, especially "you can be whoever you are in Shangri-la".
R.I.P. Dirk McQuigley, one of the true geniuses of rock music. And on top of that he invented the system that ensures the light in your fridge is out when you shut the fridge door. Pity Dirk was accidentally shot in December 1988 outside his apartment in the Manhattan building in North Dakota by a fan who took out a pen for Dirk to sign an autograph. He'd bought it at Christie's, but forgot it had been used in one of the James Bond movies and that it was not a pen, but a semi-automatic weapon.
@scarface12347 Yeah, but they used a stand-in who had plastic surgery to look lie Dirk. Didn't you hear about this "Dirk McQuigley is dead" myth (THE MUTH)??????????? Many clues on their albums to prove the point.
@gibson3524 It should also be remembered that Dirk was the founder of the Indicator Gallery and bookshop in London which had the finest collection of car indicators in the world. It was here where John Lennon met Yoko Ono when he tripped over her while she slept in the doorway wearing nothing but a shopping bag and at the same time invented Bagism.John at the time was looking for a rear light for his 1967 Mini Cooper.
It's quite clever as Parodies go actually...because until GH died, there were only 3 Beatles. When you look at it that way, it seemed logical that should the Beatles ever reunite...there'd only be three of them right? So, 3 remaining Rutles seems appropriate :-)
Re: 'How Sweet To Be An Idiot' - Oasis had to cough up 10% of the royalties from 'Whatever', which is why the song has never appeared on any live albums or compilations (and never will). Innes received payment from the single, released in December 1994. At 4:38 on 'Shangrila' you can hear 'Free-ee to be whoever we are', the vocal line taken from 'Whatever' as a reference to the lawsuit.
Across The Rutleverse, a parody of the Across The Universe film, That's a Screenplay I'm Working on as we speak. But Instead of Just Referencing Rutles Song, I'll add Beatle songs that weren't used in ATU. If someone has already come up with that idea, then by god, produce it and make it a musical f'n' comedy.
my god the beginning of that with the violin sounded note for note the same as oasis,s {whatever}, please someone listen to it and tell me it does it is all becoming very clear now they must have listened to the rutles
I notice Neil Innes managed to get Riki Fataar and the one who plays Barrington Womble. I guess though securring the services of Eric Idle were not financially possible. Let us also not forget that one of the original writers of that 1978 spoof is now dead, George Harrison.
Actually, no. Eric Idle refused to take part. Remember, he did not sing or play on the songs, and this album was by the Rutles musicians. In fact, Idle was so jealous Innes was getting fair credit he basically ruined Innes life and levt him literally homeless from legal battles.
And because of that I'm stunned to find a 2008 interview on YouTube where Eric appears with the other 3 guys! What's up with that?
Personally, I love the Rutles. I'd rather hang with Neil, Rikki & John than any combination of Beatles. I wish there were pics and/or videos of them with Ollie. Eric is not a Rutle!
I hate the Rutles tHEY riped the beatles
cozycrunchez1 1 week ago
Comment removed
cozycrunchez1 1 week ago
Dirk isn't dead; that myth was about Stig not Dirk
Harold6913 3 months ago
It's Oasis!!!
misterdirtyknees 4 months ago
god bless the rutles
MultiRich71 5 months ago
Based on "A day in the life, Yellow Submarine, All you need is love, Imagine, Hey Jude, Being for the Benefit of Mr. Kite!" and more. What happened to Eric?? ... Was a Rutle Only Musicians Reunion?? Greetings from Mexico. Sorry my bad english.
VoyeurRex 7 months ago
@VoyeurRex
I believe that Eric Idle and Neil Innes had a real bad falling out and the guitarist doing Idles bits Ollie Haskell sadly died not too many years after the All you need is cash was release. So Neil fills in for the Dirk songs.
If Im wrong let me know but that is what I heard
BozRyan 6 months ago
@BozRyan It's true, Eric and Neil had a falling out over the Archaeology - Eric refused to be involved because he felt like the joke had been played out; then he made "The Rutles 2", which exploited all of the Archaeology music, despite Neil not being involved in the film.
SecretTimeWarp 3 weeks ago
sounds like for no one
corgi1998 8 months ago
The rutles changed a little bit the music of The Beatles, it's not better than the beatles but I think even if you change a little bit of their music it will stay beautiful.
And that was the work of 4 men who changed the world of the music ;)
scheinokt 8 months ago
I enjoyed this but in a way it's very sad.
Hadding1933 8 months ago
@Hadding1933 its sad in the begining but gets better so i would say its a song of mixed emotions...
Sirblahblah24 8 months ago
@Sirblahblah24 It's not the song itself. There might be a dozen Beatles songs quoted in this thing. It's all reminders of a better time that's completely gone.
Hadding1933 8 months ago
Shangri la is paradise?
Sirblahblah24 8 months ago
We ought to petition the BBC to release the Rutland Weekend Television series onto Youtube, if they're not going to Bother showing it themselves. There's Trillions of archive programmes in there which no-one will want to see in a few years more.
Tornfreedom 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'd hand them the Beatles Anthology and say - "This is our Bible"
LODGE4444 10 months ago
Sardine sandwiches and onions.Me Favorite.....
Hairyarmpit 10 months ago
they are the best band ever RUTLEMANIA!!! brilliant;)
specialme2 10 months ago
I want a Rutles Rockband game, So please make one, thank you!
drummingjohn4u 11 months ago 2
walks a fine line...
jedf666 1 year ago
I love the Penny Lane in this.
Miracle490d 1 year ago
Dirk was still live in the mid seventies!! According to my Rutles record sleeve "Albums currently available on Rutle" one of the records is "The Punk Floyd (with Dirk McQuickly) ~ White Dopes On Punk", and there his is on the front cover with a massive safety pin thru his nose" Also it was Stig who was supposed to have died ~ on the Sgt Rutter album he is leaning in the exact position of a dying Yeti (from the Rutland book of the dead) In the words of Viv Stanshall so therrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr...
SuperNevile 1 year ago 2
If aliens landed on earth and asked me to explain the Beatles to them in as short a time as possible... I honestly think I'd play them this song.
YellowYoshi398 1 year ago
@YellowYoshi398 I'd hand them the Beatles Anthology and say - "This is out Bible"
LODGE4444 10 months ago
Dirk followed the leg of former manager Leggy Mount-Baton and accepted a teaching position in Austrailia.
grski88 1 year ago
I thought it was Ron Nasty who was shot....
arw11515 1 year ago
This is legitimately a pretty good song..... it might be because The Lost Horizon is my favourite book...
CrazyLazySnazzyJazzy 1 year ago
is very funny and god this son the rutles forever!!
fernangod 1 year ago
Esta cancion me recuerda a una chava
rollingstone80 1 year ago
Dirk IS dead, now -- proven by no involvement with Archeology. Rest in peace, Mr. McQuickly, in that great buffet hall and sitar paradise in the sky...
Notebooked 1 year ago
2:01
Who's the fourth guy there?
a CLUE!
RUTLE CONSPIRACY CONTINUES!!!
Dirk?....
WizardOfLies 1 year ago
Dirk isn't dead. He simply left the Rutles to go into comedy. I heard he and some other mates formed some comedy troupe that went on to appear in a cult favorite tv show in the early '70s and even made a handful of very wild movies. But you can't believe everything you read on the Internet.
FlamingoKicker 1 year ago 5
@dgoren1 Music hasn't been the same since The Rutles broke up. I mean those impersonators The Beatles.... What are they playing at? WTF???
Never beat the originals can you?
thatsthewayitgoes09 1 year ago
at 3:33 thats Munch from law & Order Special Victims Unit
scarface12347 1 year ago
Few know that Nasty invented the Slinky which was marketed by his ex wife Ann Coulter who stole the rights from him making a fortune for herself and donating it all to the John Birch Society
homemoviescolorado 1 year ago
I love it.
cathymaid 1 year ago
Brilliant - is that Peter Gabriel at 4:12?
mjlewis104 1 year ago
@mjlewis104 It's all fake.
GaryNull 1 year ago
ha rutles. the bootleg beatles
moonshinevessel 1 year ago
actually, they were better than trhe beatles! lol
fireblade95 1 year ago
Esa cancion me recuerda mucho a ti muñequita, esa rola escuchaba a cada rato cuando estaba enamorado de ti, siempre seras parte de mi vida, de mi presente y de mi pasado, y me habras de acompañar hasta el ultimo instante y hasta mi ultimo aliento mi muñequita preciosa.
Me trae recuerdos muy gratos y muy dolorosos esta cancion, gracias señor Eric Iddle, gracias señor Neil Innes. y hasta siempre muñequita, siempre seras mi gran amor
rollingstone80 2 years ago
Brilliant! They're legends in their own lunchtime...
asktunes 2 years ago 14
Free As A Bird, with flashes of Strawberry Fields, Penny Lane, Being for the Benefit of Mr. Kite, and ending up with Hey Jude
But Real Love has to be in there somewhere, right?
LittleDragon2000 2 years ago
@LittleDragon2000 with a little twist of whatever by oasis
tarkothegreat123 1 year ago
damn...this is a good song!
calimar28 2 years ago
Chords? Anyone?
stesto1 2 years ago
Neil still looks great. So do Rikki and John.
RoyFive 2 years ago
Nice @ 4:37. "We're Free-eee- To Be Whatever we are." That's a reference to the lawsuit Neil Innes conflicted on The Oasis track 'Whatever' as the notes were lifted from Innes` 'How Sweet To Be An Idiot.' He got co-writing credit from that.
ZomgrulerZ 2 years ago
better than anything
HGRKzk 2 years ago
yeh..wheres Eric ?
Has he passed on?
Stanzman 2 years ago
dirk has been dead for ages, honsestly! (sorry, could not help myself) nooo, nothing wrong with eric, he is still alive and kicking
kyrastube 2 years ago
Neil Innes is a legend. This tune is great. The album that this is off is one of my favourite albums ever. The Rutles "Archaeology".
GlenLouder 2 years ago
Better than the original Rutles??
Blendeture 2 years ago
Yup definitely.
GlenLouder 2 years ago
@GlenLouder Yes, this is on my top 10 list too, . . and I have heard a lot of albums, . . and I have "high standards" ,.. or whatever.
GaryNull 1 year ago
Wheres Eric Idol?
GTM57 2 years ago
Eric and Neil had a falling out over credits of the Monty python songs, Neil Innes name was removed from a bunch of ones he co-wrote, and Eric didnt want to take part in this reunion. I do believe they have since made up and appeared together as the rutles.
emrabt 2 years ago
the guy who is dressed as Michael Jackson is a great friend of mine..Joby Rogers, who was the only MJ impersonator endorsed by MJ himself. We've worked together (me as McCartney) on the McCartney / Jackson duets for over 20 years and most recently 2 weeks ago. Back To The Rutles...genious..with or without Dirk McQuigley!
maccamikeM 2 years ago
Is Michael Jackson one of the singers in the crowd?
sajawebb 2 years ago
No- Michael Jackson is not in there,
but there's a guy dressed up like him,
I'm not sure if it's on purpose.
SteveWalrus 2 years ago
This is one of my favorite songs of all time. Though this version cuts out about another 3 minutes of "La de do dah la de dah here we are in Shangri-la" it's not too much of a difference otherwise. I just love the lyrics, especially "you can be whoever you are in Shangri-la".
Freedomwriter24 2 years ago
Rutles Forever!
(though not actually even in the first place)
loZoneranger560 2 years ago
what would leggy mountbatten think??
hanghang71 2 years ago
He would appreciate their trousers.
kittyprydekissme 2 years ago
Spot the celebrities at the end. I see Cindy Lauper, Richard Belzer, possibly Howard Stern.
lmao at the cue cards - all of which say the same thing.
doctorcastille 2 years ago
This is my favorite Rutles song!!! Too bad you can't buy it on iTunes... :*-(
nak54222 2 years ago 2
R.I.P. Dirk McQuigley, one of the true geniuses of rock music. And on top of that he invented the system that ensures the light in your fridge is out when you shut the fridge door. Pity Dirk was accidentally shot in December 1988 outside his apartment in the Manhattan building in North Dakota by a fan who took out a pen for Dirk to sign an autograph. He'd bought it at Christie's, but forgot it had been used in one of the James Bond movies and that it was not a pen, but a semi-automatic weapon.
gibson3524 2 years ago 40
Yes, I remember it was all over the news.
kittyprydekissme 2 years ago
@gibson3524 Actually, he went into comedy, according to Nasty.
secondeagle 1 year ago
@gibson3524 :(
scarface12347 1 year ago
@scarface12347 Yeah, but they used a stand-in who had plastic surgery to look lie Dirk. Didn't you hear about this "Dirk McQuigley is dead" myth (THE MUTH)??????????? Many clues on their albums to prove the point.
gibson3524 1 year ago
@gibson3524
Dirk is dead man, miss him, miss hIM, MISS HIM!!!
Love the 3 Rutles
WizardOfLies 1 year ago 2
@gibson3524 Brilliant. You got it.
davemetalbutler 1 year ago
@gibson3524 It should also be remembered that Dirk was the founder of the Indicator Gallery and bookshop in London which had the finest collection of car indicators in the world. It was here where John Lennon met Yoko Ono when he tripped over her while she slept in the doorway wearing nothing but a shopping bag and at the same time invented Bagism.John at the time was looking for a rear light for his 1967 Mini Cooper.
davemetalbutler 1 year ago
shangri la is a song by the kinks
thepablofanquesfair 2 years ago
this is different song
elo also did a song with the same name
cowpigs99 2 years ago
Where's Eric Idle? did he quit?
phojodave 3 years ago
He was invited to participate in the Archeology project but declined .
In 2008 all 4 Rutles reunited for a 30th anniversary screening of All You Need Is Cash.
In 2009 Neil Innes has uploaded a new Ron Nasty song on his website called Imitation Song ( a parody of Imagine )
45rpmSINGLES 2 years ago 2
It's quite clever as Parodies go actually...because until GH died, there were only 3 Beatles. When you look at it that way, it seemed logical that should the Beatles ever reunite...there'd only be three of them right? So, 3 remaining Rutles seems appropriate :-)
tudorsmithuk 2 years ago 2
Except Harrison is dead now also, but I see your point.
Get the albums people, it's great music, especially if you like that Beatles era stuff.
foureyedtroll 2 years ago 2
two of them are ex bonzo dog doo dahh band members
if you watch the magical mystery tour
by the beatles
the bonzo dog doo dahh band makes a cameo
discojosh69 3 years ago 2
They actually invited Oasis to be in the crowd, but Oasis turned 'em down.
StephanieLives 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this & how sweet to be an idiot where ripped off from oasis-whatver
mckshrmptn 3 years ago
How Sweet To Be An Idiot was written in 1977. Fail.
StephanieLives 3 years ago 3
Ha ha! Get it round ye, Mckshrmptn!! :D
EddieG1888 3 years ago
Gosh, and Oasis have never ripped off the beatles?
wildenfree 3 years ago
oasis are the original bootleg beatles
hanghang71 2 years ago
When did Michael Moore join the Rutles as drummer?
bobbyt65 3 years ago 5
All together now..one, two, three.......
wolfkarel 3 years ago
four can i have a little more, five six seven eight nine ten, i love you!
discojosh69 3 years ago
the first line sents kitties down me spine
volandvasoliono 3 years ago
great stuff
davidroot8 3 years ago
Re: 'How Sweet To Be An Idiot' - Oasis had to cough up 10% of the royalties from 'Whatever', which is why the song has never appeared on any live albums or compilations (and never will). Innes received payment from the single, released in December 1994. At 4:38 on 'Shangrila' you can hear 'Free-ee to be whoever we are', the vocal line taken from 'Whatever' as a reference to the lawsuit.
MrSifter8 3 years ago 2
Boor
sonnybuddy2001 3 years ago
My moose is at the cleaners !!!
tottingham 4 years ago
Across The Rutleverse, a parody of the Across The Universe film, That's a Screenplay I'm Working on as we speak. But Instead of Just Referencing Rutles Song, I'll add Beatle songs that weren't used in ATU. If someone has already come up with that idea, then by god, produce it and make it a musical f'n' comedy.
maxx5rocker 4 years ago 3
Oh come ON. That's just sad.
BlueDiscProductions 3 years ago 2
wow dude, Thats a very very good idea
blakeandcrap 2 years ago
my god the beginning of that with the violin sounded note for note the same as oasis,s {whatever}, please someone listen to it and tell me it does it is all becoming very clear now they must have listened to the rutles
truemansparks 4 years ago
Yeah, Oasis copied that tune from Neil's "How Sweet to be an idiot", and there was a lawsuit, so Neil actually copied himself rather than Oasis
Scarperguy 4 years ago 2
yeh i actually meant that oasis copied them but reading my original message it does sound that i thought they had copied oasis
truemansparks 4 years ago
Blatant plagiarism - hilarious. What talentless tossers they were.
IseultCharms 4 years ago
jajajajajajaja
baloisaac 4 years ago
This is just an old Neil Innes song reheated, with archive footage of the Rutles film. It's also not nearly as funny as the old Rutles.
BobMonkfish 4 years ago
You're right, I think The Rutles 2 is pretty pitiful... they should have done a LOVE spoof instead, like the one I'm working on
Scarperguy 4 years ago 2
oletko suomalainen jakkivanukas?Minä myös.
cyberpunk1991 4 years ago
Are those real celebrities in the chorus or, are some of them celebrity impersonators?
nickelstew 5 years ago
I notice Neil Innes managed to get Riki Fataar and the one who plays Barrington Womble. I guess though securring the services of Eric Idle were not financially possible. Let us also not forget that one of the original writers of that 1978 spoof is now dead, George Harrison.
richrom5 5 years ago
Actually, no. Eric Idle refused to take part. Remember, he did not sing or play on the songs, and this album was by the Rutles musicians. In fact, Idle was so jealous Innes was getting fair credit he basically ruined Innes life and levt him literally homeless from legal battles.
Qermaq 4 years ago
And because of that I'm stunned to find a 2008 interview on YouTube where Eric appears with the other 3 guys! What's up with that?
Personally, I love the Rutles. I'd rather hang with Neil, Rikki & John than any combination of Beatles. I wish there were pics and/or videos of them with Ollie. Eric is not a Rutle!
ftg3plus4 3 years ago
I need that song. LOL
Thanks :D
xlizlennonx 5 years ago
the Monkees were better than Oasis. Gorgeous pastiche.
henthree 5 years ago 2
Terrific! I really wish I had that on Dvd!! Thanks for sharing that.
rutlemike 5 years ago