Final Song - Haley Reinhart - Bennie and the Jets - Top 3 Results - American Idol 2011 - 05/19/11

[racefish]

I like Lauren and Hayley. Lauren is a great country singer and Hayley has that rock-girl sexy growl to her voice.

[shaiinuhxx]

I truly wish Haley won American Idol. She has one of the most unique, beautiful voices I have heard in a very long time.

[giannaisamazing5]

omg i miss haley so much <3

[racefish]

@giannaisamazing5 Don't worry, she'll be around.

[Richmos3]

You know, it actually doesn't matter that she got third because everyone knows shes the best anyway. . . go HALEY!!!

[ThatNerdyGuy3]

@karenZmusic Check out her new album. She's REALLY skinny now. (I would suggest Georgia Peaches. That's my favorite from Lauren.)

And I would bet that next to her you would look like a fat cow.

[karenZmusic]

@ThatNerdyGuy3 so...? i don't care anything about that copycat...........

[ThatNerdyGuy3]

@karenZmusic So now she's a copycat? How? She has an album that's HER OWN. Also, even if she is fat, so what? Susan Boyle isn't exactly a stick figure, and neither is Adele. But LOOK at how far they've gotten. Now don't get me wrong, I would choose Haley above Lauren EVERY TIME, but looks have nothing to do with it.

[karenZmusic]

@ThatNerdyGuy3 on her audicion she didn't make growls, and didn't tried to make raspy, but then she listened to Haley and she began to do it, cuz she knew that that was the only way of keep on the competition... 

[ThatNerdyGuy3]

@karenZmusic No she didn't. She only had some raspy songs, because they were supposed to be raspy. Like "Keep me Hangin On" and "Flat on the Floor"

[karenZmusic]

@ThatNerdyGuy3 but if haley wouldn't do raspy she never would do that and the growls too...

[ThatNerdyGuy3]

@karenZmusic She barely growls. Haley does WAY more growling. Haley and Lauren are WAY different.

[karenZmusic]

@ThatNerdyGuy3 ofcorse haley is so so much better.......

[ThatNerdyGuy3]

@karenZmusic Of course. However they are both talented and do not deserve to be insulted.

[karenZmusic]

@ThatNerdyGuy3 I talk to haley and she told me that lauren and scotty told her that just she deserves to be in the finals...

(sorry about my english i speak spanish and im just one year studing it... lol)

[karenZmusic]

@ThatNerdyGuy3 what vis your email? i think you are nice...... LOL

[ThatNerdyGuy3]

@karenZmusic I dont give out to my email

[karenZmusic]

@ThatNerdyGuy3 what do you mean?...

[karenZmusic]

@ThatNerdyGuy3 are you a male or female?

[ThatNerdyGuy3]

@karenZmusic male

[karenZmusic]

@ThatNerdyGuy3 how old are you?

[Sakuraxxx1]

she totally sounds like stevie nicks in that video

[redbaron991]

She knows she's better than the others

[karenZmusic]

@redbaron991 every person with ears knows it.... lol

[baunilha86]

I can't believe she didnt win.. Its amazing (not) the lack of soul of the other too.. they can't feel the music at all.. look at them! this is real music..

[gnarlyincubus]

It's official! Haley's first single will be released MARCH 1ST!!!!

Be sure to support this shindig and download! =)

Thumbs up to spread the word!

[micciloi]

The Best among the rest!

[MsSexyDiva4Lyfe]

She sings so effortless!  And I love the way she growls when she sing!

[HappyTalkKeepTalking]

I tuned into this right when she started singing, so I originally thought with this fantastic performance that she'd won...

[AwkwardForLife]

Lauren Alaina is such a dumb cunt, seriously.

[laserbeam898]

IMPORTANT MESSAGE TO ALL HALIENS!!!!

Go to HaleyReinhartVEVO's channel and subscribe so VEVO will give her more attention and release more songs for her!!!!

[15hoski]

I remember sitting watching this live and I was so pissed off....and then finding myself smiling watching haley cuz she kicked ass. I LOVE her attitude singing this. THEN of course that awkward moment when everyone realized oh #@$! theres still two ppl left in this competition. Priceless!

[LookingAtYouFool]

@dangerousjoey

You "liked" the video: "Justin Bieber & Usher : Chestnuts ( The Christmas Song )"

[sparkl3zzz2110]

the best version of this song ever

[LookingAtYouFool]

@dangerousjoey

Most adults don't understand how Bieber is a worldwide sensation. But you "like" him.

[backtothestar]

Randy and Jlo we haven't seen them yet. Whoh!! but they're so spaced out. LOL!!!!!!!! Did I hear correct? ROFL

[jonnyplastic]

Haley's finale performace signing "benny and the jets" was sexy, soulful and dan entertaining to say the least. I 've watched this 200 times!

[tjp1041]

she was the best!!!

[stalematesibling]

BENNEEEEEEEEEEEE!!! BENNEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!! BENNEEEEEEEEEEEEE!! bENNY and the jetsssssssssssssssssssssssssss­sssssssssssss....

she still got me singing until now .....lol

[StarfireandSakura]

It's like a subtle middle finger, but in musical form...

[tybell50]

@StarfireandSakura my thoughts exactly.

[Micben123]

How the heck did she not win?

[blaqpirate]

It seemed to me that haely and laren wasn't the best of friends, they were always separated and they didn't show a tight bond like most of the same sex contestants when the numbers get low.

[MizzJalen]

I actually have listened to this song over 600 times according to my itunes

[hapigal101]

1:05 Uhmm Lauren, honey, I see you looking at the screen. Don't you fake it when Haley's singing.

[thecottingleyfairy]

lol she just got kicked off and she ROCKED the house.

[SmackDonald34]

flood warning ...

[anicapam1]

This still gives me goosebumps every time i hear it. She is a wonderful singer.

[iheartiker]

I love Jacob jumping in the background like he was in church! Awesome!

[cratou4]

Best performance....she got the flow

[HaleyReinhartForever]

Haleyween trended on twitter!!!

Good job Haliens. Happy Haleyween also trended! We got two TT in less then an hour. Oh #thepowerofhaliens -3

[Gagafan26]

look how she got the entire crowd into this!! NOONE will EVER!!! and i mean EVER get the crowd into a song like haley did!!! :) she will be the BEST american idol contestant EVER on american idol :) GO HALEYY

[THECARS7879]

@Gagafan26 Hell Yea ! 

[MisterT468]

she needs to hurry up and put out a single soon before people forget about her then she's done.

[THECARS7879]

@MisterT468 Noone will forget about her. She's signed with interscope right now.

[halabrdave]

@thedisneygirl1234 I see why this was spammed, you put McPhee, Archuleta, Kris and Lee, that's preposterous. It's Daughtry, David Cook, Adam Lambert and Crystal Bowersox. From your list I only agree with season 1, 2 and 10 of course, Haley Freakin Reinhart! she is the best I've seen and none other lame ass would have rocked it out with so much grace and even humor on their way out.

[instantnoodler1]

body and voice of a goddess.

[nikond3000kmb]

I would go to her shin dig..

[NathyRodenas101]

I just got goosebumps from that performance!!!! She should have won!!!

[jesssssx0]

It's October and I'm still watching this. We miss you Haley! <3

[DanikaJadeee]

2:28 Is that Elle Fanning behind Hayley's dad?

[click4bio]

@DanikaJadeee Yes, it's her.

[DanikaJadeee]

Cold shivers she's so good.

[DanikaJadeee]

She is honestly the best artist I've seen come out of Canadian Idol and American Idol.

[RonPaulBias2012]

it is not even funny how much better Haley was then Scottie and Lauren!! She was totally robbed

[barbaric37]

I cant wait to hear her album, she's gonna be huge!

[CallieAnn111]

@barbaric37 When is it coming out? What is called? Where will it be sold at?

[TheBonz33]

Soooooooo BEAUTIFULLLLL!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[shunix123]

a total disaster from idol!!

[deezza1]

maravilhosaaaaaaaaaaaaa!

[ProverbialAuthor]

I'm glad Haley didn't win. It keeps her from being tied down by the American Idol contract that the winners sign. This way she can pursue her OWN music and have more creativity. An artist like her shouldn't be shackled down!

[bazzingaification]

@ProverbialAuthor sooo trueee

[itsmarsyashamshul]

whats up with the girl in the blue dress.......

[MAVSROCK1995]

She shoulda won...

[nhadz16]

ATTENTION: PLEASE VOTE FOR HALEY, SHE'S GETTING BEHIND!

idolheadedDOTcom/blog/2011/09/­the-final-3-all-time-american-­idols-who-makes-the-final-and-­what-will-they-sing/

[SarahBrennan7]

@nhadz16 American Idol is already over.

[dehellstar]

haley should have won.....big fan from the beginning.....voice i love..

[dramaqueen465]

Not to be mean or anything but I don't like what she did with the song. But she has a wonderful voice.

[233roz]

This was a travesty of justice that the 2 tweens remained and Haley got eliminated. But I firmly believe that Haley is going to be the bigger star, she is so much better than them. They are good, Haley is great and unique.

[pebbles7364]

WHY DIDNT SHE WIN??!! IM STILL PISSED. >.<

[OreoTheCat04]

Haley is the best singer in american idol, Casey and haley♥ Do you agree?

[PlaceforAnything]

@OreoTheCat04 Yes i do agreee but like james to.

[woohoojazelyn]

@OreoTheCat04 lolz, someone that knows EXACTLY what i think!! ;)

[karenZmusic]

@OreoTheCat04 i agree but i prefer Haley and John Mayer

[233roz]

Could you please go and vote for Haley on Idolhead Ed She is in 3rd place, way behind.

[NoTimeForBullCrap]

@233roz For a reason! lol

[233roz]

@NoTimeForBullCrap The reason was so she could win. But I understand that a lot of people don't go on that page because of the spy ware.

[supersamquake]

I loved Haley and I was sad but sometimes it not the best thing to win the show I mean he got signed along with James and pia

[Gagafan26]

i LLOVEEE how much she growls!! she rlly growls ALOT here :) hah I LOVE U HALEY!!

[ando1135]

I like how haley picked tge right 2 judges when she sang " o randy and jlo have you seen them yet? O but there so spaced out" very clever, because they were spaced out for almost all haleys performances

[craftycat98]

she has such soul!!!!!!! xDDD

i <3 her!!!!!! :)

[hpeselyk]

LOL I'm still getting chills watching this right now

[tybell50]

Haley is worth 1.5 million. album buzz is insane. website is up and running. this girl is still on fire.

[lukeschuss]

I like her singing, but this performance was nowhere near as good as her Top 11 performance of the same song. Look how sad she is, she's going through the motions. Her smile isn't sincere. Her voice is quivering, she's not hitting the highs with the same power, and her 'growl' isn't as good.

I love her singing and the arrangement, but her Top 11 performance is the one to watch.

[CallieAnn111]

Wait who are those teens on stage?

[cuebrod]

i dont think Jennifer liked it when she called her "Jlo" lol, look at her facial expression lmao!

[marylhere]

@cuebrod She looked truly sad actually...she knows who was suppose to be the winner.

[draschka10]

Too bad the country geeks weren't as cool as her! She sooooo much should have won.

[THECARS7879]

@draschka10 I know,  thats so true !

[gab10rocks]

i cried so hard that day, i hated to say goodbye to her, im already in tears again from watching this!

[draschka10]

Whoever TheNookie is, please find some good things to say. If you don't like her, then don't look her up on youtube.

[CallieAnn111]

@draschka10 Agreed

[draschka10]

I wanted her to win. She's awsome!!

[sakis3warnings]

she is a masterpiece.just unbelievable!

[gpili]

@seinesalz good point! best reason i've heard about the criticism of haley

[mrmsportsman34]

i just treolized tht made no sense

[mrmsportsman34]

she is worth being immature haha

[mrmsportsman34]

HALEY SHUD HAVE WON IT!!!! AT LEAST SHE GOT A RECORDING CONTRACT

[xHcivic00x]

why the fuck u ppl still arguin about this? this was back in May! We are in August! u guys are like stupid! This was Idols best season, the Top 13 were awesome! she made Top 3 out of millions thats pretty fucken awesome! and she is signed! Im a Lauren fan and see how im not bashin ur idol like u guys are bashin Lauren seriously grow up! the girl has a single out already and has been number 1 on Pure Country Top 12 & is the Top Most Popular Artist on CMT! so shes not boring! Peace!

[marina051997]

How does Lauren dance?

[Amazingmasyer1]

Couldn't watch the whole ting was about to start balling again:,( I luv u HALEY u r a big inspiration to me!

[GLEEKKLAINE]

she should've won!

[MoriahRiot]

I love how she sang this.. it's great. I just don't understand America.. why would you send off talent like that???? I mean we already have a Carrie Underwood and Josh Turner.. I don't think we need two more. (I'm not saying that they are bad singers.) But they aren't as unique as Miss Haley. :)

[sweetdie512]

Wooooow Haley!!!!! Yeiii :D !! I will buy your cd!!!! ..... Lauren and Scotty are BORING!!!!!! why the teenagers voted???? Mmmm! :/

[233roz]

I did cry when Haley got eliminated. But I am so happy for her because she has a wonderful career in front of her. This girl is magic.

[233roz]

@mgebi1 You must be sick and demented to say those horrible things about Haley. Also you would not know talent if it hit you in the face. Go somewhere else, why are you even here if you don't like Haley. You are not wanted here. Only good, decent people allowed. Haliens unite.

[mhonful]

top 3's all deserves to win..

[SoVintageRockk]

yea me too! I couldnt cry though, just seeing how happy she is...

[Ilovetoms04]

I almost cried when they voted her off

[howyoudoindirector]

@Ilovetoms04 me too.

[chauanh1234]

HALEY NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOO.

[DrRubberDuckie]

1:04 LOL AT SCOTTY

[mistymoore23]

mgibi1, you must be a girl (hater) bc if you think haley doesn't have talent, ya might need to get your hearing examined! Just bc haley is beautiful, talented, and feisty people HATE!!!! I hope she records an album bc this girl is my fav, woohoo go haley!!!!!

[mgebi1]

If I was stuck on an island and had to listen to this bitch talk and sing everyday I think I WOULD CHOOSE SUICIDE. she sucks. iF YOU WANT TO HERE A TRUE MUSICIAN AND TALENTED ROCKER CLICK AN AN ELTON JOHN VERSION. WHAT THE FUCK IS WRONG WITH THIS GENERATION!!! There were however other contestants with good voices.

[ryanfreshman789]

@mgebi1 Fuck you you selfish prick. She is great. She has been signed and she will now be big and actually have a life, unlike you. So go cry to your mommy about how your life suck. kbye.

[TheNoookiie]

@ryanfreshman789 Look at 1:03-1:07; Lauren doesn't even like Haley. As soon as the camera gets to her she acts more happy.

[xHcivic00x]

@TheNoookiie u shouldnt say things u dont kno! when the judges were hard on her Lauren was in the bak comforting her! so stop makin judgements off something u see on tv/ youtube! they had an apartment together! And the way she hugged Haley when she made Top 3, go bak and watch!!!

[xHcivic00x]

@TheNoookiie ur very immature lol

[TheNoookiie]

@xHcivic00x Im not. It's video-proof wtf?

[TheNoookiie]

@xHcivic00x Well that's because the people of American Idol made them stay in the same hotel. But ok.

[xHcivic00x]

@TheNoookiie ur a fucken moron!! lol! u dont shit! and u cant judge something cuz of a fucken clip! get a life!

[sexybre1231]

hailey should of won the whole thing for me she was the best singer there i love hailey !!!!!! :))

[xJessieRuex]

I love lauren and scotty but personaly haleys better. Her voice is more interesting and she has amazing control and a huige range of options for her. I doubt well see the last of her. She should have one between those three.

[heeyitsskyee]

This song fits her voice soo perfectly! I think she sang it better than the original.

[5laaaau]

She was the winner for me

[CallieAnn111]

Hottest. Idol. Ever.

[livingbl]

Haley is the woman!!! However, my fav thing about this video is Lauren's initial INability to clap and sway to the beat...

[BlaineLloyd]

Be Mine <3

[Chocol8smiles]

I loved this girl, glad she got a record deal

[multiiloveadam]

ok BEST final song in the history of American idol. Haley is freakin amazing!

[cpownall518]

@multiiloveadam i know she was my favourite and had the beat voice there scotty and lauren should not have made it to fanale you can hear there vouices anywhere

[kittenchan100]

0:27......did anyone else see what i saw ?

[CallieAnn111]

@kittenchan100 What?

[gnarlyincubus]

@kittenchan100 Putting her hand on her hip? Haha? Stop being such a prude.

Haley, my beautiful Haley, you rocked your final performance and handled being unjustly eliminated so well.

[caroycoral]

Haley is the REAL american ídol, the BEST!!

[TURDUCKENSRRUS]

2:02 they took time to show casey, love it, love haley, love them

[SceneKidd132]

love this song



[SceneKidd132]

this song is good



[lilynafez]

Me and my family were jumping up and down and cheering when she got out. If all I had to do was growl, I can get 3rd place in american idol to.

[cpownall518]

@lilynafez ya that s not reALLY true haley has an amazingf voice and the growl just makes it better you would probably not even ,make it to hollywood haley does more than just growl she actuallly probably has the best voice there even though she didnt make it to finale doesnt mean lauren and scotty were better it just meant that they had more family and friends to vote

[lilynafez]

@cpownall518 Uhuhh....if that's what you say I guess it's right. Just kidding!! We all have different opinions and stuff, but ya could've said that just a tad bit kinder. Haley sucks and the truth hurts. [i don't mean this in a mean way]

[hpobsessor1]

She sang this song AMAZINGLY in the actual performance, but this is way better than that!

[bluegreenyellow1000]

I love the song benny and the jets and i love haley reinhart

[bnatrl88]

when the heck is her album coming out?!?

[jwowww18]

the flood warning is from all the tears coming from haley's millions of fans.

[weronika83]

Haley is the winner for me! I can't stop listening to her.... POLAND LOVES YOU HALEY!!!

[15hoski]

What a great finale!!! oh wait... this wasn't the end of the show?...darn I guess I missed the last show : )

[DeathEater692]

@VeeRazzles ya I guess. But Pia was kinda forgettable, in my opinion she was good, but I don't think she woulda made it far in everyday life after the show. I think James wasn't as good as her, but he would've gone farther in the rock industry than she would've gone.

[camiliahogue12]

swear to godd i thought it was penny and the jets

[DeathEater692]

The top 2 was a joke. It should've been James and Haley and Haley win. Lauren is going to go nowhere, and Scotty is just another white boy with a guitar. Nothing different. It sucks that little girls vote and pick based off age and how cute you r. Personally I think Haley is the prettiest, but wateve. Scotty is a one trick pony and Lauren hasn't done well since her audition. How they were the finalists? I have no idea. Haley is great

[VeeRazzles]

@DeathEater692 It actually should have been Haley and Pia, they were the only two worth a crap in the top 11