I don't know why, but while they are in the Houses of Healing and after when Eowyn wakes up and sees Faramir and he smiles back, makes me cry. Does every single time ><
You know, Karl Urban should have used the black hole just like Spock to travel back time to cure her little sister, as he is now made it to be a doctor (star trek 2009)...
Seeing Eomer in such a state makes me think of my brother, and I wonder if he would ever do the same for me. I would never want to put him, or myself, in that situation. But, seeing their bond always makes me think of him.
I'd react just like Eomer if I found MY "little" sister in such a condition. Especially if I thought she had passed heh Gorgeous song. Prompted me to click "like" on LI'vs Facebook thingie.
Every time I see Eomer screaming like that, I always think of if it were me screaming and my best friend (who's like a brother to me) was on the ground. It makes me cry because I put myself in that situation and it's heart breaking.
@tristancalin My favorite scene was cut too, Boromir & Faramir together TT^TT I'd love it if some indie theaters played the extended DVDs before Hobbit comes out.
There's something incredibly sexy about 0:51 - poor Eowyn in the moment she awakens from what she hoped would be her glorious end and looks right into the face of the very one she was trying to forget - and he looking terribly desirable at that! Any woman with less strength than she would've then gone into cardiac arrest & died on the spot. :P
This is enchanting. I remember when I saw it in the extended version. Of all the masterpiece scenes and quote worthy moments in LOTR, I think one of the best is, "Even the smallest person can change the course of the future."
My God, I haven't watched these films in a few years. This scene, coupled with everything going on in the world today, pierced my heart, brought a tear (s) to my eyes. Eomer's pain, his sadness, his despair...I felt every emotion. Amazing scene, amazing movie, amazing trilogy (thank you Mr. Jackson), amazing books (thank you Mr. Tolkien).
<3 one of my favorite movies...i really hope all the precious lives buried under corrupted buildings in christchurch, nz will be saved... thank you so much for sharing ☆
@izzysaurusRAWR This was a hugely moving scene. The whole movie was great. I think one of the only other scenes that was as moving was Gandolfs call for retreat after the orcs and trolls breached the city. The pull was the other way but the concern and worry that was portrayed there was intense!
@Lazyboy5298 Hi. I really don't think he is smiling in a condescending way. I've thought about this before and I think that "smirk" on Gandalf's face is his way of his way of acknowledging that all war involves loss, especially those who do not deserve to be lost. BTW: Arragon has to heal her. He backed out of healing Frodo in the first movie, but now that he knows who he is by this point, the power is in him to heal her. What do you think? Cheers!
incredible scene. one of the best in the trilogy. the song sung by Liv Tyler really brings the two women together, the two women who love Aragorn. And when Eowyn wakes up and stares out the window, I believe she finally accepts that Aragorn is in love with another, but she never stops loving him in a way. I just love this scene!
Cannot express how much I LOVE this scene. Her voice is stunning. They definitely shouldn't have cut this scene, but i guess all the lord of the rings fans will have the extended box set, so thats fine?
Easily the best scene in the LotR. It shows Karl Urban is shown as more than a simple warrior, it shows Viggo as more than a heart-throb back-up progatnonist, it portrays Miranda Otto as a valuable character and it cements the relationship she has with David Wenham as the hope for mankind outside of the Royal line of Gondor.
I cannot IMAGINE how someone could not like this video. It makes me think they got the wrong button or were completely jealous they couldn't find the uncut version of the movie (which adds TREMENDOUSLY to the meaning and depth of the film btw). I would definetly suggest finding and purchasing it.
this just touches my hart and wen i first saw the film i was only 2 years old and when i heard this i would not jump around in bed my mom would sing it to me so it makes me cry and that was 9 years ago
@AustenFugitive I know what you mean! But it's sctually not because it wasn't epic, or the movie producers thought it was bad, but it was because it slowed down the pace of the movie. Directors will cut even a movie cut of a few seconds, because it slows the movie down or messes with the film. They have to keep the story going, and not get sidetracked. But I know what you mean! This really was one ob the bestest scenes in the movie!
put this song on a speaker and listen to it up to your ear,..and feel the vibrations of sound....i think that might actually be what Heaven sounds, and feels like. <3
Just taking this segment out makes you really think about the elements that make this scene absolutely rock, the music, Karl Urban's cry, Viggo's wonderful poise and soulful quality he has... oh it just doesn't end!
I'm cannot quite explain why, but this is one of my favorite scenes in all of the films. It is an extremely tender scene full of unspoken meaning yes...Karl Urban's emotion and Liv Tyler's beautiful singing...but it reaches into the story of future generations as well. Eowyn and Faramir had each lost someone, uncle/father, and both almost died in battle. They fall in love here, carry the unwritten story of the future.
This scene makes me cry every time... Karl Urban is so into it with his acting, I can't believe how real it is. THAT there, ladies and gents, is the REAL effects of war
this is my favourite part in the books the chapter called the steward and the king. i love how eowyn and faramir come together . i love how eomer looks so destroyed at 1:05 its haunting
@PolishPixie YES!! That's *my* favorite chapter as well! Faramir's love for Eowyn healing him, melting her heart, and ultimately healing her is the most beautiful part of the whole book! I still can't get over how unfair it was of them to leave it out of the film. : (
@HopeUnquenchable yes that's right!!! I first saw the movie and all I saw was how they looked at each other at the wedding and I thought hell I'd like them ending up togehter but surely they just did it in the movie so noone could ask: "What about Éowyn???" But then when I read it i just thought damn I WANT IT IN THE MOVIE still it's not enough but the two scenes are really touching...
@quotecat7 I feel you there! I read the books after the films as well, and had the same reaction as you when discovering the story behind Eowyn and Faramir. It's a crying shame that it was left out of the film; such a beautiful story deserves to be told!
I was a little dissappointed at ho they didn't show Merry getting healed. And that they still had him fight at the Balck gates when in the book only Pippin went.
@orliluvr1432 I know, and Faramir. i wanted to see that too. That's when he first met Aragorn, and he had Black Death in him too. But all the same this with the time Faramir almost was burned alive are my some of my favorite seans!
ok I know the movie was already trying to beat or tie with Gone with the Wind for longest running time, but they couldn't have found room for this and the little moment between her and Faramir, Come on it was a little tenderness amidst all the chaos of Mt Doom, and the song was so nice!
@VintageRose93 I concur on both fronts! x100000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
I didn't have then extended edition so I haven't seen some scenes eg.this one! ARG!!! Why didn't they keep this in!!!!!!I have to go and buy the extended edition! NOW! :D
i love this scene! i watched it years ago and it still makes me cry. i just finished the houses of healing chapter in the book and i wish more of faramir & eowyn could have been put into the movies. they did a spectacular job though :)
I cry every time. EVERY TIME. Karl throws such raw emotion into this scene. and it doesn't help that the scene right afterwards is Pippin's discovery of Merry's broken body.
this is my favorite part in return of the king. his emotion is pure and it breaks my heart every time i watch it. i just wish that they didn't cut it out for the final cut
Such powerful emotions in these scenes. Karl Urban's cry of agonised sorrow...well, it just about tears at your heart to hear it. The deep feeling he puts into his eyes is fantastic, whatn a truly talented actor. I was rather upset they didn't insert this into the film, it was my favourite chapter in the book as a child.
I know, I have all the special editions. :) My nerdy marathon earlier this summer turned it into a sleepover where none of us actually slept. Fantastic night! But what I meant was that I wished they'd put this into the screened version of the film, because there were a lot of people who missed out on it as a result. And we also had to wait an extra however many months before the extended edition was released on DVD. Still, this was an adequate reward for all that waiting.
@IncomingSanity Very true. I never saw any of them in theaters because my dad made me read the trilogy AND the Hobbit before I was allowed to see any of the movies. Of course, I was also only 6 when the first came out, and I didn't read the books until I was 7.
I can't BELIEVE they cut this out!! I'm sure no-one would have cared if they sat for another two minutes in the cinema if this scene could have been included.
Karl Urban was bloody brilliant in this scene. love it. Should have stayed in the theatrical.
I still wish, though, that they had made it longer and had included Aragorn healing Faramir as well (that still that you can find on the web of the filming of it still makes me hope that one day we'll see some raw footage...)
I agree Karl Urban was more than amazing in this scene! I wasn't even paying attention at the time, I just heard the scream and looked at the screen and the tears just poured out of me! They should've kept this scene! I didn't know that Liv Tyler could sing like that... the whole scene is great!
Karl Urban did an amazing job portraying the emotion in this scene...no, it was beyond amazing. I could watch this scene over and over, it's brilliant. It's heart-wrenchingly beautiful.
You can find this song on the Complete Version of the Soundtrack for The Return of the King. You can find it on BestBuy's website, on Ebay, or on Napster (there are undoubtedly other places, but I know these off the top of my head.) The CD is a complete recording in that there are many sequences that aren't on the normal version such as the charge of the rohirrim. Only problem is the price which is about $60-$80, but you get 4 CDs worth of music for it.
Im really annoyed at jackson in the end for not adding this small part into the film because the acting is just too brillant and this scene means something to the film i think.
Karl Urban's acting in this part gets me every time. He looks completely destroyed. And the choir in the background is perfect. Liv Tyler inherited more from her dad than that mouth of theirs, haha.
Why didn't they leave at least this one scene in the theatrical cut? Heck, the movie would've only been like 2 minutes longer. (BTW, I unfortunatly don't own the extended edition :( ) This would've helped to make sense of Faramir and Eowyn standing next to each other at Aragorn's crowing. The Houses of Healing was one of my favourite parts of the book, too. Oh, well, at least I get to see it here.
it was NOT taken out. it is in the extended edition. you know? the four-hour long version of Return of the King? that is why it was not in the theatrical preview. the movie is insanely long.
By taken out I mean taken out of the original movie. I'm not talking about the extended cut. Seeing as I own the original movie and not the extended edition, the only way for me to watch this scene is here. So yes, it WAS taken out.
well, your own fault you bought the short one... ;)
kidding. but i suggest you buy the long one. it is a huge pleasure for those who read the book because they understand those extra scenes. and the entire movie makes more sense and is so much more beautiful with them. adieu
Liv Tyler (Arwen) sang the song for this scene, even though it was meant for the scene where she sees her son in the forest as she rides for the Grey Havens. she has an amazin voice and i think it fits into this scene perfectly
I don't know why, but while they are in the Houses of Healing and after when Eowyn wakes up and sees Faramir and he smiles back, makes me cry. Does every single time ><
Robofish12 1 week ago
the first time i saw Eowyn and Faramir together i thought that this was Tolkien's greatest idea for a new love story.
cefanine 2 weeks ago 2
i still cant believe they cut out this scene, esp with Eomer.
Hchickrocks 1 month ago
This is Liv Tyler (arwen) singing ♥
MIGHTIM0USE 1 month ago
Faromir and Eowyn are so cute at the end :)
HannahfromSeptember 1 month ago
Very powerful acting by Karl Urban. The scream, the cry, the maddening look.... all perfect.
BreathofArda 1 month ago 2
You know, Karl Urban should have used the black hole just like Spock to travel back time to cure her little sister, as he is now made it to be a doctor (star trek 2009)...
huyentran1811 1 month ago
Eomer's scream is so haunting. He captured that moment perfectly. His scream echos in my mind even when Liv begins singing...which is beautiful. :)
ThexSoundxofxSilence 1 month ago
errr wattttttt? eowin diesssss? wt watttt?>
redvenizkx 1 month ago
Seeing Eomer in such a state makes me think of my brother, and I wonder if he would ever do the same for me. I would never want to put him, or myself, in that situation. But, seeing their bond always makes me think of him.
Imatotalfreak 2 months ago
I'd react just like Eomer if I found MY "little" sister in such a condition. Especially if I thought she had passed heh Gorgeous song. Prompted me to click "like" on LI'vs Facebook thingie.
magnacore11 2 months ago
Only the "death" of his sister could bring the mighty Eomer to his knees.
Bragithepoet 2 months ago
I love this scene to bits.
bluephoenix52 2 months ago
Every time I see Eomer screaming like that, I always think of if it were me screaming and my best friend (who's like a brother to me) was on the ground. It makes me cry because I put myself in that situation and it's heart breaking.
RoryThePanda 3 months ago
What's the elvish bit at the beginning of the song?
NymphetamineVille 3 months ago
@NymphetamineVille Immen dúath caeda / Shadow lies between us
Sui tollech, gwannathach omen / as you came, so you shall leave from us
Boe naid bain gwannathar, / All things must pass away,
Boe cuil ban firitha. / All life is doomed to fade…
TheDihLyne 3 months ago
@TheDihLyne thanks!
NymphetamineVille 3 months ago
it's surprising how one of my favorite scenes from the movie was cut from main version.
tristancalin 3 months ago
@tristancalin My favorite scene was cut too, Boromir & Faramir together TT^TT I'd love it if some indie theaters played the extended DVDs before Hobbit comes out.
explodingplant2 1 month ago
You really get the sense of the gift of the men of Numenor -- their nobility, their power, their healing.
whitetower67 4 months ago
I personally wouldn't have minded an extra 2 minutes in the theatrical version. So glad for the extended
defyingravity23 4 months ago
Faramir's look at the end when he sees her....
PrincessSparkle333 5 months ago 3
At 1:45 ...never seen Faramir look more like his brother Boromir.
ThePalaeontologist 5 months ago
This is nearly my favorite song in the movies, second to Pippin's "Edge of Night" song, which was just heartbreaking. This is so beautiful, though.
…And the first time I saw this, Eomer screaming just about ripped my heart out. So intense. I love how much he cares for his little sister.
partytree92 5 months ago 25
Holy crap...Karl Urban screaming scared the sh** out of me
pippacrawford 6 months ago
Eomer's emotion is just... wow. Probably the most emotional scene in the films for me.
TheThreeWeavers 6 months ago 2
Liv Tyler did such an incredible job on this song... I love her voice! Such an amazing film.
CyraUK 6 months ago
There's something incredibly sexy about 0:51 - poor Eowyn in the moment she awakens from what she hoped would be her glorious end and looks right into the face of the very one she was trying to forget - and he looking terribly desirable at that! Any woman with less strength than she would've then gone into cardiac arrest & died on the spot. :P
HopeUnquenchable 6 months ago
They should have put this is in the normal version..because this is whats really happening after a battle..not the feeling of victory..
IrisReidsma 7 months ago
:'( i dont have the extended edition but will get the whole shabang in blu ray soon ^^ cannot waiiiiieeeet
demon4411 8 months ago
@demon4411 i know EEK
mhgirsl 7 months ago
This is enchanting. I remember when I saw it in the extended version. Of all the masterpiece scenes and quote worthy moments in LOTR, I think one of the best is, "Even the smallest person can change the course of the future."
IIemzyII 8 months ago 2
Immen duath caeda
Sui tollech, gwannaomen
Boe naid bain Gwannathor
Boe cuil ban firitha
Shadow lies between us
as you came, so you shall leave from us
all things must pass away
all life is doomed to fade
danishAEF 9 months ago 12
This is one of the better scenes in the entire trilogy. It should have made the theatrical cut.
heresmichelley 9 months ago
This song reaks my heart-over and over again. Loss. We have sustained such losses. I greatly wish this had been part of the film.
mishlenlinden 10 months ago
My God, I haven't watched these films in a few years. This scene, coupled with everything going on in the world today, pierced my heart, brought a tear (s) to my eyes. Eomer's pain, his sadness, his despair...I felt every emotion. Amazing scene, amazing movie, amazing trilogy (thank you Mr. Jackson), amazing books (thank you Mr. Tolkien).
yogini34 10 months ago
Guys Guys!
the soundtrack u hear is nown as Arwens Song! (:
found it out just now haha
MrBubbles0o0o 10 months ago
how do you get these scenes?
HawleyChanna 11 months ago
<3 one of my favorite movies...i really hope all the precious lives buried under corrupted buildings in christchurch, nz will be saved... thank you so much for sharing ☆
AphroditeEros33 11 months ago
What the crap, ends too quickly.
mpalm887 11 months ago
the best movie ever..
lillygmail 11 months ago
god this part destroyed me, it physically hurts to see a man cry and karl was losing his mind. perfection. <3 every bit of it.
izzysaurusRAWR 11 months ago
@izzysaurusRAWR This was a hugely moving scene. The whole movie was great. I think one of the only other scenes that was as moving was Gandolfs call for retreat after the orcs and trolls breached the city. The pull was the other way but the concern and worry that was portrayed there was intense!
moviedirectorliol 11 months ago
the part with eowyn and eomer :'(
gets me everytime
and awww faramir, just standing there watching her... thats sweet XD [and a bit stalkerish :P]
TechnologiclyTechno 1 year ago
What the HELL Gandalf! Don't just stand there smiling, you old fool! Heal her!!!
Lazyboy5298 1 year ago 2
@Lazyboy5298 Hi. I really don't think he is smiling in a condescending way. I've thought about this before and I think that "smirk" on Gandalf's face is his way of his way of acknowledging that all war involves loss, especially those who do not deserve to be lost. BTW: Arragon has to heal her. He backed out of healing Frodo in the first movie, but now that he knows who he is by this point, the power is in him to heal her. What do you think? Cheers!
jizydorczak 11 months ago
Faramir's like =O
PrincessSparkle333 1 year ago
incredible scene. one of the best in the trilogy. the song sung by Liv Tyler really brings the two women together, the two women who love Aragorn. And when Eowyn wakes up and stares out the window, I believe she finally accepts that Aragorn is in love with another, but she never stops loving him in a way. I just love this scene!
akroliko 1 year ago
Cannot express how much I LOVE this scene. Her voice is stunning. They definitely shouldn't have cut this scene, but i guess all the lord of the rings fans will have the extended box set, so thats fine?
rOcKcHiCk1062 1 year ago
WHAT SONG IS THIS?? i cant find it! lol.
aarongbrooks 1 year ago
@aarongbrooks
the houses of healing (feeat. Liv Tyler) It's on the extended version album of Return of the King
akroliko 1 year ago
Easily the best scene in the LotR. It shows Karl Urban is shown as more than a simple warrior, it shows Viggo as more than a heart-throb back-up progatnonist, it portrays Miranda Otto as a valuable character and it cements the relationship she has with David Wenham as the hope for mankind outside of the Royal line of Gondor.
gigasloth 1 year ago
Those strings are threatening to leave me in heaps.
Raymint 1 year ago
Who's the douchebag that needs to get devoured by orc mounts, that disliked this?! =|
Maximus1Decimus 1 year ago
I cannot IMAGINE how someone could not like this video. It makes me think they got the wrong button or were completely jealous they couldn't find the uncut version of the movie (which adds TREMENDOUSLY to the meaning and depth of the film btw). I would definetly suggest finding and purchasing it.
moviedirectorliol 1 year ago
mornie utulie mornie atlantie si man i yulma nin enquantuva? namarie
akumie 1 year ago
@akumie yeah you're so cool, speaking elvish and all. wooooow. >_>
RinEditionB 1 year ago
Comment removed
akumie 1 year ago
@RinEditionB jaja well it soundedcool, just sad both msn and youtube dont accept tengwar
Just a side not, there is no language called elvish just as no language is called european
akumie 1 year ago
With a sigh,
You turn away,
With a deepening heart,
No more words to say
You will find that the world has changed forever
The trees are now turning from green to gold,
And the sun is now fading,
I wish I could hold you closer
rboser 1 year ago
What a song. Her articulation is impeccable and the dynamic inflections- too good
capitnox 1 year ago
this just touches my hart and wen i first saw the film i was only 2 years old and when i heard this i would not jump around in bed my mom would sing it to me so it makes me cry and that was 9 years ago
mhgirsl 1 year ago
If someone wants to download it, download complete recording ost the lord of the rings
Boboboteno 1 year ago
I got the song of the houses of healing, it's incredible
Boboboteno 1 year ago
Does anyone think that these extra scenes-the ones NOT covered, but most certainly superior-will come out in some EXTENDED extended edition?
mishlenlinden 1 year ago
This isnt in the movie? right?
EmmaWikkeHornbak 1 year ago
@EmmaWikkeHornbak It's in the extended version.
Andabraud 1 year ago
@EmmaWikkeHornbak yes
mhgirsl 1 year ago
i guess Aragorn was expecting Éowyn to forgive him.
lilemby13 1 year ago
@lilemby13 um sorta idk
mhgirsl 1 year ago
I think one person was so blinded by their tears at the incredible depth of this scene that they missed the like button.
victimofaguillotine 1 year ago 10
@victimofaguillotine i know its my song i sing to my friends mostly every day so they could focus on their work
mhgirsl 1 year ago
....how could someone dislike this?!
Jenckles 1 year ago
How is that THE best scene in the Lord of the Rings Trilogy did not make it into the final cut?
AustenFugitive 1 year ago 2
@AustenFugitive I know what you mean! But it's sctually not because it wasn't epic, or the movie producers thought it was bad, but it was because it slowed down the pace of the movie. Directors will cut even a movie cut of a few seconds, because it slows the movie down or messes with the film. They have to keep the story going, and not get sidetracked. But I know what you mean! This really was one ob the bestest scenes in the movie!
ForeverisGone13 1 year ago
put this song on a speaker and listen to it up to your ear,..and feel the vibrations of sound....i think that might actually be what Heaven sounds, and feels like. <3
IlovetheeMiranda 1 year ago
Just taking this segment out makes you really think about the elements that make this scene absolutely rock, the music, Karl Urban's cry, Viggo's wonderful poise and soulful quality he has... oh it just doesn't end!
janellp1 1 year ago
I'm cannot quite explain why, but this is one of my favorite scenes in all of the films. It is an extremely tender scene full of unspoken meaning yes...Karl Urban's emotion and Liv Tyler's beautiful singing...but it reaches into the story of future generations as well. Eowyn and Faramir had each lost someone, uncle/father, and both almost died in battle. They fall in love here, carry the unwritten story of the future.
MeredithWaters 1 year ago 5
This scene makes me cry every time... Karl Urban is so into it with his acting, I can't believe how real it is. THAT there, ladies and gents, is the REAL effects of war
orliluvr1432 1 year ago 3
this is my favourite part in the books the chapter called the steward and the king. i love how eowyn and faramir come together . i love how eomer looks so destroyed at 1:05 its haunting
PolishPixie 1 year ago 2
@PolishPixie YES!! That's *my* favorite chapter as well! Faramir's love for Eowyn healing him, melting her heart, and ultimately healing her is the most beautiful part of the whole book! I still can't get over how unfair it was of them to leave it out of the film. : (
HopeUnquenchable 6 months ago
@HopeUnquenchable yes that's right!!! I first saw the movie and all I saw was how they looked at each other at the wedding and I thought hell I'd like them ending up togehter but surely they just did it in the movie so noone could ask: "What about Éowyn???" But then when I read it i just thought damn I WANT IT IN THE MOVIE still it's not enough but the two scenes are really touching...
quotecat7 3 months ago
@quotecat7 I feel you there! I read the books after the films as well, and had the same reaction as you when discovering the story behind Eowyn and Faramir. It's a crying shame that it was left out of the film; such a beautiful story deserves to be told!
HopeUnquenchable 3 months ago
@HopeUnquenchable absolutely. but, well at least we have something. the scene in the houses of healing when they talk to each other is just beautiful.
Such wonderful actors, such a good story, and far too little of the story filmed! Damn it!
quotecat7 3 months ago
i get very bad goosebumps every time:-s it's kinda scary how it gets me when i listen to it
SataniKID 1 year ago
I love the sound of her chainmail when she starts breathing loudly.
ImladrisMiruvor 1 year ago
I was a little dissappointed at ho they didn't show Merry getting healed. And that they still had him fight at the Balck gates when in the book only Pippin went.
orliluvr1432 1 year ago
@orliluvr1432 I know, and Faramir. i wanted to see that too. That's when he first met Aragorn, and he had Black Death in him too. But all the same this with the time Faramir almost was burned alive are my some of my favorite seans!
GaurdQueen 1 year ago
ok I know the movie was already trying to beat or tie with Gone with the Wind for longest running time, but they couldn't have found room for this and the little moment between her and Faramir, Come on it was a little tenderness amidst all the chaos of Mt Doom, and the song was so nice!
NYmovieGIRL 1 year ago
i love you, Ben x
IlovetheeMiranda 1 year ago
This is an amazing song and Karl Urban is beautiful.
VintageRose93 1 year ago 3
@VintageRose93 I concur on both fronts! x100000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
NYmovieGIRL 1 year ago
One of my favourite scenes.
VintageRose93 1 year ago
beautiful song.... i love it, it makes me wanna cry! and this scene, ohhh just the best :)
musztardanawynos 1 year ago
I didn't have then extended edition so I haven't seen some scenes eg.this one! ARG!!! Why didn't they keep this in!!!!!!I have to go and buy the extended edition! NOW! :D
bodiedoyle3745 1 year ago 4
Such a pretty song i love it. Has a very nice new age/celtic feeling to it. her voice is so soothing.
frdo66 1 year ago 3
Liv's voice is just beautiful here. What a haunting song for this scene...
kittycorp 1 year ago 5
hehe Aragorn has the wisdom of the Valar... very nice and touching scene showing how a captain car revive someone...
maiki1978 1 year ago 2
i love this scene! i watched it years ago and it still makes me cry. i just finished the houses of healing chapter in the book and i wish more of faramir & eowyn could have been put into the movies. they did a spectacular job though :)
irrevocablyinlove16 1 year ago 5
brings a tear to my eye every time i hear it
jvforever72 1 year ago 3
i love this song!!!! it's so emotional, but so beautiful.
abbeygirl502 1 year ago
liv tylor song is great
XF3DeX 2 years ago
I was so happy when i saw this scene in the extended version!
mykyjohn 2 years ago 4
@mykyjohn
me too!!
sakucherrry 2 years ago
I cry every time. EVERY TIME. Karl throws such raw emotion into this scene. and it doesn't help that the scene right afterwards is Pippin's discovery of Merry's broken body.
Hse07 2 years ago 45
@Hse07 so true thats how i reacted
mhgirsl 7 months ago
@Hse07 I so agree. Plus Theoden's passing two scenes before it.
RoryThePanda 5 months ago
@Hse07 You are stupid. Slapper.
Peppepoppldoppl 4 months ago
this is my favorite part in return of the king. his emotion is pure and it breaks my heart every time i watch it. i just wish that they didn't cut it out for the final cut
ZutaraTwilight 2 years ago 5
Such powerful emotions in these scenes. Karl Urban's cry of agonised sorrow...well, it just about tears at your heart to hear it. The deep feeling he puts into his eyes is fantastic, whatn a truly talented actor. I was rather upset they didn't insert this into the film, it was my favourite chapter in the book as a child.
IncomingSanity 2 years ago 32
@IncomingSanity Well it's still in the extended edition.. To me the only version worth watching :)
Yannick20 9 months ago
@IncomingSanity It's in the special edition version. All three make for a delightful nine-hour marathon.
thenerevarine13 6 months ago
@thenerevarine13
I know, I have all the special editions. :) My nerdy marathon earlier this summer turned it into a sleepover where none of us actually slept. Fantastic night! But what I meant was that I wished they'd put this into the screened version of the film, because there were a lot of people who missed out on it as a result. And we also had to wait an extra however many months before the extended edition was released on DVD. Still, this was an adequate reward for all that waiting.
IncomingSanity 6 months ago
@IncomingSanity Very true. I never saw any of them in theaters because my dad made me read the trilogy AND the Hobbit before I was allowed to see any of the movies. Of course, I was also only 6 when the first came out, and I didn't read the books until I was 7.
thenerevarine13 6 months ago
@thenerevarine13 More like eleven and a half.
MrMagikWaffle 6 months ago
@MrMagikWaffle Right. The originals are the ones that are only three hours long. I thank you for your correction.
thenerevarine13 6 months ago
Ahhhf, his yell! and the song (house of healing)...ssoooooo gooooood!!!!!
darkhorsefan15 2 years ago
whats the name of the song
Gfather6969 2 years ago
Evenstar !
sakiread 2 years ago
@Gfather6969 not evenstar. It is called Arwen's Song.
Hse07 2 years ago 2
Eowyn is so beautiful :)
Minyadagniriel 2 years ago
I agree! Karl Urban is so amazing! I cry every single time I see this because of him screaming...
bals93 2 years ago 2
So captivating, so mysterious, so peaceful!
For this 1 minute 47 second I just feel at rest. Deep Peace
SirPricelot 2 years ago 5
hearing this song makes me think of the first time I read the book, alone in the mountains... you will find that the world has changed, forever...
juliasaul 2 years ago
I've seen this scene hundred times and more.
And I've cried every time.
adeurIncarnate 2 years ago 3
I can't BELIEVE they cut this out!! I'm sure no-one would have cared if they sat for another two minutes in the cinema if this scene could have been included.
ButterflyZo 2 years ago 3
The best scene in the whole trilogy. Karl Urban was under used so much, he was wonderful as Eomer.
nannybebe74 2 years ago 4
such raw grief
vincentvalentinedark 2 years ago 2
Why can't movies be this great anymore? Beautiful scene one of my favorites.
oraslayer9199 2 years ago 7
His sream thrills me! He did an amazing job!
15CF 2 years ago 3
Karl Urban was bloody brilliant in this scene. love it. Should have stayed in the theatrical.
I still wish, though, that they had made it longer and had included Aragorn healing Faramir as well (that still that you can find on the web of the filming of it still makes me hope that one day we'll see some raw footage...)
AinuLaire 2 years ago 3
theirs a still on the web, do you have the link? I'd be interested to see that!
VsWomen 2 years ago
Mhm. Karl Urban was amazing in this scene.
drovethroughghosts 2 years ago 5
He was good but Ian Mckellen makes the scene for me just by watching with that music in the background
rokerroar 2 years ago
This scene was beautiful. Scenes this great are rare nowadays.
oraslayer9199 2 years ago 4
I agree Karl Urban was more than amazing in this scene! I wasn't even paying attention at the time, I just heard the scream and looked at the screen and the tears just poured out of me! They should've kept this scene! I didn't know that Liv Tyler could sing like that... the whole scene is great!
maffassina 2 years ago 7
rawr. shoulda kept this scene.
chrissyluvhorsey 2 years ago 2
i always lol at 0:10 XD
Leviicrazed 2 years ago
Spectacular scene.
MadaboutBrewno 2 years ago 3
Karl Urban did an amazing job portraying the emotion in this scene...no, it was beyond amazing. I could watch this scene over and over, it's brilliant. It's heart-wrenchingly beautiful.
FlutieCutie 2 years ago 5
I love farimir at the end of this!
latentlullaby 2 years ago
You can find this song on the Complete Version of the Soundtrack for The Return of the King. You can find it on BestBuy's website, on Ebay, or on Napster (there are undoubtedly other places, but I know these off the top of my head.) The CD is a complete recording in that there are many sequences that aren't on the normal version such as the charge of the rohirrim. Only problem is the price which is about $60-$80, but you get 4 CDs worth of music for it.
jepsheehan 2 years ago
Karl's acting is superb... he looks totally at loss... I like how he just takes Eowyn and rocks her back and forth...
edualym 2 years ago 7
This should have been in the film! Liv's voice is beautiful,and Karl Urban's acting is great!
Lynn15 2 years ago 2
Im really annoyed at jackson in the end for not adding this small part into the film because the acting is just too brillant and this scene means something to the film i think.
laura123roxx 2 years ago 3
Karl Urban's acting in this part gets me every time. He looks completely destroyed. And the choir in the background is perfect. Liv Tyler inherited more from her dad than that mouth of theirs, haha.
SnareTheDrummerGirl 2 years ago 85
this sends shivers up my spine...
gringolazlo 2 years ago 44
@gringolazlo everytime..., but it feels good doesn't it?
Morkoor 1 year ago
Liv Tyler's voice is Amazing :D i wish they'd shown this in the movie! eowyn and faramir are perfect!
wickednestle 2 years ago 2
My two favorite scenes in Return of the King are this and Pippin's song for Lord Denethor. I look forward to them every time I watch it.
cookieking3 2 years ago 5
Why didn't they leave at least this one scene in the theatrical cut? Heck, the movie would've only been like 2 minutes longer. (BTW, I unfortunatly don't own the extended edition :( ) This would've helped to make sense of Faramir and Eowyn standing next to each other at Aragorn's crowing. The Houses of Healing was one of my favourite parts of the book, too. Oh, well, at least I get to see it here.
Alaska263 2 years ago
SPEACHLESS !!! Every time i see this, remain hipnotized by the song and specially Liv Tyler voice
Nebuz69 2 years ago 2
God, where are these scenes in the film? Is it a longer version? Is it available to watch? Where?
DriveMeMad09 2 years ago
Yes, there are extended editions of the movies. Available everywhere.
robertsmith3006 2 years ago 2
amazing. i can listen to this for hours and hours. it sounds like liv tyler though. is it?
this is a true masterpiece.. the most beautiful melody i have ever heard. and her voice is just peferct for this..
carolinelineline 2 years ago
it is her.
orliluvr1432 2 years ago
i LOVE this....why did they not leave it in the movie!!!
RandomCrap818 2 years ago 4
man can she sing she is a really beautiful singer
Prettyelf77 2 years ago 2
Liv Tyler, who plays arwen is the one who sings this.
alvawhite 2 years ago
WHY did they take this scene out of the final cut? It's soooooooooo beautiful!!
AustenFugitive 3 years ago 5
it was NOT taken out. it is in the extended edition. you know? the four-hour long version of Return of the King? that is why it was not in the theatrical preview. the movie is insanely long.
btw, i wish it were longer. ;)
OperaNotes 3 years ago 4
By taken out I mean taken out of the original movie. I'm not talking about the extended cut. Seeing as I own the original movie and not the extended edition, the only way for me to watch this scene is here. So yes, it WAS taken out.
AustenFugitive 3 years ago
well, your own fault you bought the short one... ;)
kidding. but i suggest you buy the long one. it is a huge pleasure for those who read the book because they understand those extra scenes. and the entire movie makes more sense and is so much more beautiful with them. adieu
OperaNotes 3 years ago 2
Liv Tyler has a beautiful voice.
*favs*
Ziffaroo 3 years ago 5
they should have left this in the movie
sn0wbunnny 3 years ago 2
they did. in the extended version.
OperaNotes 3 years ago
it IS a great song! Wow! Can you get these songs on itunes?
dummyinblue 3 years ago
OMG!
it's the first time i watch this scene of the film!!
why I hadn't bought the extended version! oh.. shit!
it's gorgeous that song!
mymybalo 3 years ago
why the fuck was gandalf smiling
himynamelscolin 3 years ago 2
he isn't smiling. i think he only knows that aragorn is going to heal eowyn. he probably knows from the skills.
TamlDaml 3 years ago
i love liv tyler her voice its so pure
JessicaLiefde 3 years ago 3
lovely song! my new my space song!!
aghamora 3 years ago
you really wouldnt think thats liv tyler.. amazing
federz666 3 years ago
Why is Eomer sooo sexy when he's screaming in agony and grief? :P
MelodieofLife 3 years ago 2
i know right *sigh*
aghamora 3 years ago
Liv Tyler (Arwen) sang the song for this scene, even though it was meant for the scene where she sees her son in the forest as she rides for the Grey Havens. she has an amazin voice and i think it fits into this scene perfectly
HeavyGundam7 3 years ago
why haven't i seen this =S.
are there deleted scenes!?
scungilli102 3 years ago