Added: 3 years ago
From: confusedmatthew
Views: 101,339
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (929)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 8:35

    that's because anakin's light side is gone and his dark side aka darth vader is here

  • 8:30

    actually his mind is fully twisted in ROTS while after his mind is half twisted in AOTC

  • 5:19

    it's because if they inform the senate. palpatine/sidious will unleash his rage or mulitply the sith and more clone troopers to kill the jedi

  • 1:38

    a sith is the opposite of the jedi. sith feel the dark side of the force, while the jedi use the light side of the force. the revenge was for when the sith became ewxtinct when killed by the jedi, so the sith might mirror what the jedi have done to them. the sith are well known for domination to the galaxy in an evil way, while the jedi are guardians of peace and justice(peace and justice my ass) x)

  • 5:25-5:32 roflmao xD

  • Lucas=biggest star wars hater!!!

  • 2:38 ikr, it's like the only thing missing is the Chocobo music.

  • "So how does one become a Sith?" The boss asks you: wanna be a Sith? Yeah why not.. Ok you're in. That's how. Anakin didn't have a reason. Nor did he need one. 2, the Sith Are the bad jedi. 3, they want revenge for having been kicked out of power ages ago. And that's been going on and on for millennia. Boring..

  • I love how Star War fanboys try to defend the prequels.

  • @ShadowGunner82 and i hate how star wars fans try to say the prequels are shit!

  • While if I feel the reivew was kinda bad in a some areas, but it was damn funny. :D

  • the mace windu narration was the best

  • u are such an idiot!!!, whats a sith??? its self explanitory

  • @GENERALSYKES

    WRONG!

    Lucas simply fucked up to explain it INSIDE the movie. It WAS necessary. Lucas DID fuck this up.

  • @qwuezalothus no? did they explain anything about it in the original trillogy?, it wasnt nessasary!, it was self explanitory, still do this day i dont know where it originated from,(cause i didnt play the kight of the old republic and i dont read the comics) what i know is that they use the knoledge of the force in a drak and evil way for there sleves, i cant say everything i know in one comment

  • @qwuezalothus in the same way that we didnt need to know that the force were medeclorians we dont need to know this!

  • @GENERALSYKES

    And we needed to know, what's in the prequels?

  • @qwuezalothus so ur complaining about the sequels now? whats so bad!!! about them!!!?, star wars episode 1 is favourite star wars movie and favourite movie of all time, (being a kid might a helped...but i dont think so) the trilogy is of course my second favourite, but with people hating the prequels is episode VI all over again, with the hole ewok thing...whats so bad about them? they were awesome!!!!!!!

  • @GENERALSYKES

    I'm rating the 6 episodes like this:

    TPM: 4/10 Weak, but accettable. |

    AOTC: 4/10 Weak, but accettable. |

    ROTS: 6/10 Stronger middle. |

    ANH: 7/10 Definitely good. |

    TESB: 9/10 Phantastic. |

    ROTJ: 7/10 Definitely good. |

  • @qwuezalothus i agree with u.with most of em, i rate the

    TPM: 8/10 amzing when i was a kid (darth maul is cool), but 8 cause of the hype i had

    AOTC: 6//10 its star wars, it had its scenes but its the worse of them

    ROTS: 8/10 it was amzing, with an amazing intro, and from start to end it was awsome..eh on dialouge

    ANH: 10/10 it was the first starwars, good story, characters and it was mind blowing!

    TESB: 10/10 it was better then the first star wars with the twist!!!

    ROTJ: 10/1 ewoks are cool!!

  • @GENERALSYKES

    ewoks are like the gummy bears of Star Wars.

  • @qwuezalothus ye but whats so bad about that!!!, everyone seems to jar jar binks and the ewoks, alot didnt even like jaba the hut..........there was nothing wrong with them, jaba was a gangster, the ewoks were something diffrent and showed more to the star wars universe after 2 movies!.... and jar jar was just funny as, i just watched star wars 3d and every scene with jar jar i cracked up in, and im not 8....i know whats good about characters and whats good about a movie,

  • @GENERALSYKES It might be self explanatory to you but not to the common moviegoer.

  • @ShadowGunner82 people that hate the prequels hate it because they just cant get over the fact the it wasnt like the original trilogy, there biggest complaints were, jar jar, boring, characters, plot and dialouge...with the dialouge i can understand, jar jar was funny, the plot was good, nothing wrong with characters, people hated young anikan in episode 1, i watched that as a kid, so i could relate to him much more, and he was my favourite character, and boring...reallly...........

  • @GENERALSYKES That is the worst explanation I have ever seen or heard. Good job.

  • @GENERALSYKES "there [sic] biggest complaints were jar jar, boring, characters, plot and dialogue"

    Yeah, because who doesn't want to be bored watching a movie? And a good plot and interesting characters? Pssh, who needs them?

  • The Utapauns' line always confused me?

    "Did he bring extra soldiers?"

    "He didn't say..."

    When I first saw this, I thought that meant the Utapauns were spies, but the plot point and the species as a whole are never seen again.

  • Yeah, this movie sucked, but the flipsvwere boss. YEAH ORIGINAL TRILOGY!!!!

  • That Hayden Christenson voice is priceless

  • "A wizard did it."

    I have to start using that.

  • anyone notice the chanceler mentions darth vader and that shit super confusing stuff

  • Lucas is the ultimate Dork Lord of the Shit.

  • @qwuezalothus why does everyone hate these movies!!, star wars episode 3 was epic, starting space battle!, it had 4 lightsaber battles, grevious, count douku, yoda and sidious, and the final battle, episode 2 had jango fett, the cool seimic explosions with the meteors.....and ye thats pretty much it, oh and the count douku battle, and episode 1, it had the fucking POD RACE!!!!, one of the best scenes in any movie, it had JAR JAR, and.......DARTH MAUL, most badass sith, darth vaders better though

  • @GENERALSYKES

    Ep1.: 4/10 Weak, but acceptable

    Ep2.: 4/10 Weak, but acceptable

    Ep3.: 6/10 Stronger middle

    Ep4.: 7/10 Good

    Ep5.: 9/10 Phantastic

    Ep6.: 7/10 Good

  • Its ironic that giraffes actually dont make much noise!

  • Obi didnt cut grievus head off cuz hes a jedi....

    hes not gonna kill someone in cold blood

    thats not the jedi path :/

  • @TheDan744 thats retarded, its not cold blood, its ending a war by killing a dangerous sith who is clearly evil

  • cry me a river

  • @Ikarosus How do you know I'm an idiot? You don't know who I am, you don't know my skills or personalities. See here is the thing instead of just being a bully and call someone an idiot you should know his or her personality. Ok I admit it my last comment was a little idiotic, but that doesn't mean I'm an idiot. Just a little advice if you meet someone who said something idiotic don't just call him an idiot just because of what he said just call him an idiot if he does something bad like sm

  • Read star wars books and you will know what a Sith is and you actually know the personalities of the Jedi who sit around and they do more in the books. The Sith want's revenge because they lost a war against the Jedi.

  • @darthdan1000 You are an idiot.

  • Comment removed

  • I agree with a lot of what you said here confusedmatthew, but at 8:32 when Yoda said, "The boy you trained, gone he is." He is not referring to his physical presence, he is saying that the person totally changed. He's no longer the person Kenobi trained, but in fact pure evil now.

  • LMAO! Ubaduba?! XD

  • stop trying to be funny dude, seriously because you aren't You know nothing about Star Wars future reference don't review it ..

  • @spider486 U mad bro?

  • @spider486 he is funny as hell, atleast for me. Your opinion.

  • Oh damn, my hand is cut off!

    ahhhhhhhh ahhhhhhhhh

  • the sith are the f*cking bad guys! learn your starwars!

  • @SkittleE275 Yea but why are they bad guys? Why are they fighting the Jedi? Whats the war about? I mean I would have never known who the sith are without playing Knights of the old republic.

  • @delta2ish well ya see*runsout the window*suckeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeer*­hits the ground*

  • @SkittleE275 Splat

  • @delta2ish ow

  • @SkittleE275 Quit it. You cannot just block out ONE LETTER of the word and expect it to get by me.

  • @SkittleE275 from a bunch of books and stupid comic books and video games and cartoons and gameboy advance shit, no one's that stupud to look that shit up just to find out something lucas culdve explained in ten seconds, why are they bad guys? idk, because lucas thinks we r retards and think we know what Siths are because they r "bad guys"

  • @superhuman295 my point exactly!

  • But because the plot needs me two I'm going to kill him.

    LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOl!

  • (5:10) I had it with these motherfucking siths on this motherfucking galaxy!

  • This movie was actually really good, in my top 3. Funny thing, a lot of people complain about anakin, but luke acts the same fucking way in all the originals until rotj. The cgi was dope, stop complaining about it, we all know you miss the old school look of star wars when you were 10, the cgi enhances the movie in so many different ways that lucas would have never have been able to create with puppets. plus the jedi were legit as fuck in all the prequels.

  • @BIM123123123 nothing personal dude, but CGI?... youre actually saying CGI is good?.. do you know what CGI is? lol.... CGI is NOT a filmed thing.... it is a computer generated image... you scoff at "puppets"... which atleast have been FILMED LIVE.... and yet you actually, commit a sentence that recomends an image that wasn't even flimed live.. i guess, you prob like "The Clone Wars"... i hope you do, because the way things look now, that's where the future lies... no offense meant by my comment.

  • @johnnyrockerfella the cgi was created to enhance the movie with a more realistic look rather than how the old movies looked. The new movies look crisp as fuck and so realistic. Yeah the old movies are sick as fuck, story lines are way better, better actors, they're classics, but the lack of cgi makes the movies dull imo because im 18 and i didnt get to enjoy them in the 80s, yeah they were amazing for the time but i prefer the more realistic looking star wars 1,2,3 than the old look of 4,5,6.

  • @BIM123123123 that's a fair point, like. i don't have anything against CGI ..but lets take Yoda he is an Imaginary creature does it really matter how he is done? yeah IMO cause as cheesy as puppets are they are the closest thing to reality at least the puppet is ACTUALLY there when watchin, CG, it kinda takes away from the purity Star Wars WAS.. it used to be all about being pure, the special effects done with creative camera work, which takes skill, but hey as i said, fair point man...

  • @johnnyrockerfella How is it wrong that CGI dopesn`t exist, that means it is pure technique, pure imagination, and a totally detailed simulation!!!!!!!!!

  • @reviewreviewer1 well... because CGI ... isnt alive.... it is undead... its a zombified entity.. it is not a living breathing or atleast inanimate but atleast REAL object.... it is not motion picture... it is not organic... it is plastic.. now you say hang on but made some pretty cool shit out of plastic... yeah.. maybe .. but gimme the real actual organic substance any day... CGI does have benifits howver.. ya only want a sprinkle.. ya dont want your human actors in a fake world like that ..

  • @johnnyrockerfella It is a film things don1t have to be real, they just have too look real, the same way everytrhing on your comnputer screen isn`t!!!!!!!!!!!1

  • @reviewreviewer1 But it doesnt look real.

  • @Ikarosus Hoe doesn`t it?????????????

  • @reviewreviewer1 It looks like video game. A bad video game. Costumes from original trilogy instead of aging, look better and better, compared to CGI in this.

  • @Ikarosus Oke HOW does it look like a video game?????????

  • @reviewreviewer1 That it doesnt look real.

  • @Ikarosus Again eplain analyse the differences!!!!

  • @Ikarosus Oke, no explanation, I rest my case!!!

  • @reviewreviewer1

    HOW!? What am I supposed to say? It looks fake! It looks like stuff from animated movie! It doesnt look cheap, I would be ok with that, it looks expansive and fake!

  • @Ikarosus Very simpily you do it like this: it does look real because 1. everything has depth and is 3 dimensional, in way t can be compared to real life, 2. it has the same amount of detasiil hardness mass and size, you can compre the geonosiers to rwal bugs and the droids and sand and arena all to real life objects just do it and I will have de,mnstrated my point, 3 it interacts with the real world it is light exactly as how much lighting thee is.

  • @reviewreviewer1 1. HAHAHA. Seriously?

    2. Again. Not true.

  • @Ikarosus Compare the sand arena the droids the water to real life counter parts it all is hard and detailed, and has depth!!!!!!!

  • @BIM123123123 THANK YOU!!! Luke indeed acted the same, the Jedio were legit, and the CGI rocks!

  • it could indeed have been done alot better... but i still find that mass whipe of jedi toutching

  • Confused Matthew needs to read a couple Star Wars books. That being said, I LOVE THIS. So freaking funny xD

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @MasterYoda12321 So he goes there to arrest Grevious and does so by completely surrounding himself and increasing his chances of getting killed by like 10000%?

    Stop making excuses for these shitty movies

  • @MasterYoda12321 Thats the stupidest thing Ive ever heard. You dont come close to killing yourself and permanently deform your face to gain a little sympathy. Plus, what, no ones gonna ask how a lightsaber wielding jedi burned your face? Also theyre gonna overthrow the republic and rather than kill you they just burn your face? And if you wanna make it look like a rebellion cut your arm off, that way you can get sympathy and just get a new robotic one.

  • @MasterYoda12321 Yeah cause animals wear clothes, build homes, have a language, use guns, and have the presence of mind to tie up a captured human. Man you're retarded.

  • @ElBombastico883 um I believe Obi Wan says there animals in a new hope so yeah who is retarded again

  • @petplatypus I just watched episode IV yesterday, and no he doesn't. Yeah, ur still a retard...

  • @ElBombastico883 According to the dictionary definition of "animal": "any member of the kingdom Animalia". Retard

  • @ElBombastico883 Rango or Fantastic Mr. Fox fan I guess, I'M WITH YA ON THAT....

  • Comment removed

  • I agree that one of the biggest story flaws in the Prequels was not giving any exposition concerning the Sith and their history. It left the audience just grasping at assumptions from what little information Lucas gave us. The information about what Sith are is in fact in the books, but that is irrelevant given that not everyone cares or read the books. The movies should have strong characterization and storylines on their own.

  • WOW doohde did you EVER break that down. I dont know which review I'd rather big headed Lucas hear!?! YOURS or Redlettermedia plinkett. Y not both!! U should maybe stay away from the Anakin impressions tho, WAAAAY more annoying than the real thing lol. BUt I get the point. I'm an 'average joe movie goer' in viewing these films in that I'm not a core SW fan, not a Star Warrior, so basically I use to think this one was O-KAY as a film and prolly roc'd to Star Warrirors. Now I C it SUX 4 BOTH of Us

  • I know why a lot of people complain about Matthew when he asks, "What is a Sith". Sure, most of us know from the various media that is out there on the subject but how about the casual move goer? They wouldn't know squat. Lucas could have easily put in a 5 minute little background on the Sith, why there so pissed off and want revenge.

  • @ShadowGunner82 yeah :( now im wondering what a sith is..

  • giraffes dont make noise. they are the doped-up ninja of african plains!

  • And Sidious was either always ugly as fuck and hiding his face with an ancient Sith Concealment technique - which shows how powerful he was to keep it up all day in front of Jedi and senators for over a decade - or as others argue (and would work either way anyway) Sidious deliberately allowed his face to deform, to be part of his evidence to present to the Senate of the 'Jedi Assassination Attempt'. Do not forget, at the time people still viewed him as a grandfatherly figure they loved/trusted.

  • Comment removed

  • I love how there is so much hatred for the prequels, and all the fanboys call those people, "haters", when in actuality, we're pissed off BECAUSE we're fans, and we're so angry that Lucas fucked these movies up sooooo bad. Meanwhile, the mindless sheep get pissed cause of how no one likes the prequels....who's the true fans here??

  • Best strate-line-scars on faces:

    1. Scar

    2. Sub-Zero

    3. Anakin

  • call me a sissy, but i cried when anakin started killing the younglings

  • For anyone who says these are "amazing" or "awesome" films (which I really disagree with...these movies are the some of the worst) what OTHER films do you think are amazing and awesome? I mean, I'm trying to understand fans of these films. What ELSE do you like?

  • @AGameProductions well i dont think their "amazing" but i enjoyed other films? forrest gump jurassic park jaws back to the future scott pilgrim vs the world district 9 inception the love guru the cat in the hat liar liar eternal sunshine of the spotless mind eraserhead the exorcist dog soldiers i could go on, but im bored
  • TO ALL THE HATERS OF CONFUSED MATTHEW NO ONE IS FORCING U TO WATCH HIS VIDS WHY DON'T U MORONS COMPLAIN ABOUT IT SOMEWHERE ELSE CAUSE NO ONE GIVES A SHIT !

  • @darthvenom30567 agreed... besides this is an actually great review in my opinion

  • @johnnyrockerfella yeah it's all just opinion it does not matter what matthew thinks even if he hates some films i like it's all just opinion ! get that through ur heads morons !

  • Dude the order 66 part was harsh, that scene was not disturbing by any means, but it was a harsh scene.

    Again, I'm defending anakin's action in episode 2, they MURDERED HIS MOTHER, HE WAS PISSED, YOU WOULD HAVE DONE THAT TOO!

    So far this review has been worse than the prequel, but maybe the end would be good

  • @theXramoneXpistolsXP im afraid you miss the point in these movies. anakin is portrayed in a new hope as being the embodiment of good, the fantastic friend. we see him slaughter people, despite the fact the order preaches peace. We also never see this friendship, we are told about it in a sixty second awkward dialog scene in an elevator, when obi wan mentions falling into a nest of dustbins.

    The flaw in these is that they are completely devoid of emotion or development. Just crap CGI stuffing

  • @mrlowhe nope, while youre right about the friendship of obi wan and anakin never being truly shown (or well developed) in the PT they never said anakin was a great person, what the ben said was "he was great pilot and cunning warrior... and he was a good friend" in none of the original films did they say he was a good man, nor the "embodiment" of good. So perosnally him having a darker side to him from the start would seem better, and better if there had been good development

  • Dumbass its basically an evil jedi, that's what a sith is if you can't see that you're more retarded and stupid than jar jar binks!

    Yeah, sneaking up to sneaking while being surrounded by more than a 100 droids, plus his robot guards,obi wan, is good, but not that good, he would have died, so fuck that, and hell take down his bodyguards first and then grievous. That's way better than your retarded suggestion.

  • @theXramoneXpistolsXP

    ^^

    ^^

    ^^

    Obvious Star Wars fanboy is obvious!!!

  • Dude come on, it was unfair, imagine you work hard at your job but you don't get a promotion, so naturally he was pissed not being ranked as a master.

    They were never directly told that the chancellor was evil, they were warned there was some corruption or something like, but fuck do you not get anything. And Anakin doesn't bitch, he's being ask to spy on a friend, you're saying you would just spy on a friend if another friends ask you to and you wouldn't mind? Retard

  • dude, its called a movie. suspend that overactive disbelief system for just a couple minutes pal. just because your name is 'confused matthew' doesnt mean you have to intentionally act like an oblivious dink ever time the plot doesnt go the way you would have intended it to turn out. and for the other holes in the plot you didnt understand...do some research before you just say "i don't understand this..im confused". your confused cause you clearly are not a fan.

  • it would have been better if you had actually done this as a review, or a critique, rather than just a plot summary. i know what happens in the film, i don't need to hear it all again- just review it or mock it!

  • My god this guys impressions of Anakin is 100 times more irritating and unfunny than jar jar binks ever was at any point!

  • the part where Confused Matthew talks about Mace Windu flip flopping for the convience of the plot, made me fucking laugh so hard, it hurt. Keep up the good work confused Matthew.

  • oh and i'm sorry that i killed innocent women and children

  • So then the four jedi that Windu brought with him use this ANCIENT technique called standing around and letting your opponent kill you. LOL !!!!!! I think star wars is the best, but Matthew does bring good points.

  • At 1:38...HOW FUCKING STUPID ARE YOU MATTHEW???? The Sith are Obviously the OPPOSITE of the Jedi the ones that use The Dark Side of The Force as opposed to the Jedi who use the Good Side DUHHHHH!!!!

  • Aayla Secura is blue not green. Okay so that's the only thing matthew didn't get right lol. The rest is soooo true.

  • STAR WARS Episode III. - Revenge of the $HIT!!!

    Anarchy Slime-water

    Only-one Kenu-B

    Senator Ubaduba

    Chancellor PandaBear

    Count Dracula

    Mouse Windy

    Yogi

    directed by: Darth Moneydady

  • "He tells her about all the awful yet routine things Anakin has done," for some reason that really made me laugh.

  • UBA DUBA!!!

  • and coupled with that! one of the security recordings was of Sidious standing over Anakin saying things that werent said the last time they met which was in his office which in not inside the Jedi Temple. So why have they got a recording of Palpatines office that isnt in the same building... that they just so happen to find... at a moment that just so happens to be integral to the plot. I mean they could have just as easily landed on the moment the cleaning lady is going around the office?

  • dude, theres even more continuity mistakes in this movie you missed lol. you know the security recording bit in the jedi temple... after watching Obi Wan says "send me to kill the Emperor". How does he know hes changed from supreme chancellor to Emperor? it just happend 5 seconds ago in a different building! and they've not talked to anyone!

  • dood, can you just stop talking about the bad CGI??!! they made this film in 2005 and you are reviewing this 3 years later.. starwars CGI is THE BEST OF ITS TIME..

  • go matthew go!

  • if being a jedi means ya cant have sex with women.... no wonder everyone turns to the dark side

  • @johnnyrockerfella yeah fuck being a jedi if ya can't get laid !

  • @johnnyrockerfella

    You can, but you can't grow attached to anyone.

    Basically hit and quit it.

  • @johnnyrockerfella I wonder if they hand out rolls of tissue paper during Jedi initiation day.

  • @johnnyrockerfella That comment was so hilarious and probably true!

  • @johnnyrockerfella it's means you can't have sex with anything, they can't even have thougths about it, no wonder indeed.

  • @johnnyrockerfella And that is why The Sith are the true defenders of galactic Freedom! 

  • "WHY DIDN'T YOU JUST COME CRASHING THROUGH THE WINDOW?!"

    Nah, nah, nah,nah,nah,nah,nah,nah,nah,na­h...OBI-WAN!

  • "They find any justification for dissatisfaction, but what they are really upset about is their own inability to enjoy the movies like they did as kids (on an innocent, awestruck level). They want their youth back. And when Star Wars doesn’t provide that. You don’t see seven year-old’s moaning and wailing about the quality of dialogue. They just enjoy the movie. Just like so many of you did as youngsters. You ignored the flaws in the original Star Wars films because you enjoyed them."

  • @mslewp I get what your saying (or quoting) but that really doesn't apply to confused matthew, he's made negative reviews of Back to the Future Part II and the lion king despite the fact they both came out during his childhood

  • @255ad It applies tot his though. The Original Trilogy had just as many things wrong with it. Episode 5 has the biggest flaw in the series: the Magic Tree.

  • @mslewp I can't speak to that I Havant seen the old trilogy in ages but if Confused Matthew thought they had stuff wrong with them he'd notice and say so.

    there's a difference between stuff like plot holes and stuff like blank characters

  • @255ad Confused Matthew is biased. There were blank characters in both trilogies.

  • @mslewp no he's not if he star wars didn't meat his standards he'd say so he said so about other iconic films that he saw as a child star wars sure as hell wouldn't be different but judge for you self watch this "Requested Review: Star Wars"

    P.S my views: yeah but in the new one the're all blank and any way I think you may be mistaking stereotyped for blank

  • @255ad We disagree about Mathtew, and I think we need to agree to disagree because it doesn't seem like either of us are going to change our mind. I think he is bias because the only way he could give such selective opinions is if he is bias.

  • @mslewp did you watch his Requested Review of Star Wars?

  • @mslewp "I think we need to agree to disagree" I'm sorry but that's not good enough for me, I've watched CM for years the one criticism I've never seen frown at him is that he's bias and if your going to say that I wont to know why? pleas send me a personal message explaining what's wrong with the old trilogy and why he's bias

  • Ancient Jedi defense technique known as standing there and letting you opponent kill you!One of the best parts of matthews reviews...along with Natalie Portman - the walking plot convenience! ^^

  • The sith are dark jedi who were basically wiped out. Darth vader was a sith aka a dark jedi.

  • I disagree with your review...the order 66 was actually very emotional.

  • 5:56 to 6:50 LMAO.

  • 5:53- since by this point Palpatine's screwed unless Anakin comes around, he's probably shooting the lightning to make it more likely he gains Anakin's sympathy. It's a heavy price to pay, but if Anakin does nothing he dies.

  • I would've also mentioned how Grievous only attacks with two lightsabers at a time despite having four at his disposal as opposed to Obi-Wans one (seriously, just block with one and kill him with the other three), how Padme refused to believe that Anakin was capable of killing children despite KNOWING FOR A FACT that Anakin had killed children on Tatooine, and how Obi-Wan and Yoda apparently never thought to present the holo-recording of Anakin as evidence before the Senate.

  • Continuting on from my other comment on your previous video. This movie has its problems like the shitty romance, wooden acting (save ewan mcgreggor and ian mcdirmid), plot holes, general weezie, Hayden christiansen, bad dialogue for Anikan, defiance of logic. But there are some great things are in this movie. Palpatine trying to pretend to be Anikan's friend, Palapatine manipulating the situation, some (small attempts) at friendship development between Anikan and obiwan, and the premise.

  • Confused Matthew: you make some valid points and bring to light various plot holes consistently. do you over analyze every movie like this?

    I happen to love StarWars:-) yes some of the acting and dialogue is wooden and forced , but it is quite a thrilling tale of love and hate, good and evil, life and death.

    That voice you make is really irritating...

    Ta!

  • These are better reviews than RLM. RLM has a wealth of movie making knowledge but a review should not be longer than the movie. And he could chop that length by 2/3 if we didn't have to listen to his very unfunny dry sense of humor.

    And lose the voice.

  • 83 people don't like good movies

  • the lightnings not being reflected in his face hes just being drained from doing it to much

  • those 3 jedi pretty much DID just stand there and let the emperor kill them... and wtf is a Sith anyways? And why do they want revenge? did they ever even try to explain that in the movies?

  • how does it look fake

  • A sith is like a fallen angel....only they're a fallen...jedi.

  • this is the definition of a bitch nitpicking

  • @BondedBlood This is the definition of a fanboy having his testicles removed with tweezers.

  • @ShadowGunner82 Fanboy, not at all. First of all i enjoyed this movie a hell of a lot better than the first two. I believe you should be calling the kid that made this video a fanboy. This reviewer obviously had way to much time on his hands to over-analyze the star wars story. Second of all whats with your sexual attraction to you removing my balls with tweezers? I mean kinda grime.

  • I Love the whining at 1:53