Agnostics who do not believe in Islam - Yasir Qadhi

[ihussain1011]

He doesn't have much knowledge

[harusame80]

i have a simple question out of curiosity,

why would you want a salvation? to enter paradise and live happily ever after?

meanwhile you consciously or unconsciously know that everything with a beginning, must have an end.

Therefore i wouldn't want to live for eternity, not in this world, not in any other worlds. Everything must have an end, otherwise you wouldn't be able to recognize which moments you must treasure, because you think you will have the eternity in paradise/heaven anyway

Thanks

[bewareofdajjal]

@harusame80 I must ask you then why is it that you seek to treasure a moment? Thus its precious for you; similarly despite the world being filled with problems you still wish to live longer, why? Subconciously you do not realise that you have accepted the timeframe of each individual n as always our mind dont like changes. So you just cannt think properly about living longer thus time is given to us for reflection. Heavens isnt comprehensive, just a tree shadow surpasses 100 000 yrs

[harusame80]

@bewareofdajjal

why we want to live longer is called survival instinct, one of the basic instinct all organism have

however, cells also have something called programmed cell death, means everything must come at an end for the better sake

so do we

i would want to live longer after my death in the heart of people my friends, families and people who know me, but definitely not in some afterlife place

[bewareofdajjal]

@harusame80 if you claim its the survival instinct of the laws of natural selection, then let me ask you what drives or what brought about the law of natural selection? Some of us choose not to believe due to the evidence, but yet when it comes to presumptions of theories, we believe blindly. ironicly it is more irrational to believe in unknown than what has been revealed to us. Anyway we know why do we not deserve punishment? The week to follow our desires and

[harusame80]

@bewareofdajjal

you have to stop thinking phenomenon in nature as a law

nature phenomena might be consistent, but it might be not

nature science is not math, where 1+1 always results in 2

if you ask me if something is behind those phenomena, the answer is i don't know, neither do you. Although you believe you do

That is why we don't jump into any premature conclusion, although it is your right to do so

[bewareofdajjal]

@harusame80 you have to stop thinking that all theists puts the Creator as god of the gaps. That might be the case in Christianity and hinduism as well as Atheism where faith is needed. Infact we muslims come to believe in God after an intellectual analysis of our surroundings, what has been revealed to us humans and our rational instincts. Although I would agree that we cannt point God but after our observations and understandins of nature, cosmos and complexity of minds, we can come to reason.

[harusame80]

@bewareofdajjal

actually any belief systems be it in theism or atheism claim to be on intellectual basis and provide rational explanation for all of their teaching. Otherwise people will abandon the belief at some point if there is nothing more than faith alone.

Anyway you are of course encouraged to believe in anything you want, as long as it makes you a better person. Only that's matter

[harusame80]

@bewareofdajjal

if there is god(s) it doesn't matter if all human being are atheist or believe in the wrong god(s), it still exists without any requirement of human worshipers

if there is no god(s), it doesn't matter if we have thousands of religions because it wont exists anyway.

So the value of truth is not something we have influence in

Anyway, christianity and islam (and judaism actually) have a lot more in common than it with hinduism, since they share the common god, the god of abraham

[winkratos]

screw Islam, these muslim skunks are retards, They do not promote peace nor will they ever at any point of time in future. The world has to face them as one and delete them like a bad program from the face of earth! Faggots! who allowed these people in chennai!

Truth is yoga is liberal, and tells you not to believe in it if you dont want to! you are still our equal.

by the way that guy is great for asking the question!

[winkratos]

screw Islam, these muslim skunks are retards, They do not promote peace nor will they ever at any point of time in future. The world has to face them as one and delete them like a bad program from the face of earth! Faggots! who allowed these people in chennai!

by the way that guy is great for asking the question!

[winkratos]

screw Islam, these muslim skunks are retards, They do not promote peace nor will they ever at any point of time in future. The world has to face them as one and delete them like a bad program from the face of earth!

by the way that guy is great for asking the question!

[winkratos]

screw Islam, these muslim skunks are retards, They do not promote peace nor will they ever at any point of time in future. The world has to face them as one and delete them like a bad program from the face of earth!

[Gypscrew]

Notice when that guy said "non Muslim doesn't believe in islam" the guy basically shrugged, looked to his left which in turn he started getting angry. Look at THAT, this guy is so full of hate it's seeping out of his skin and FACE. The Quran puts fear into people, even the laws use fear, hate, war, torture, suffering. It states eye for an eye but instead is more like what you do to me, I will do 100x worse to you. which is not eye for an eye. His comparisons are completely shallow.

[crook4real]

ask dr naik zakir plus this speaker is good

other religions did exist but the lord sent the quran

and told all religions to follow islam the one true religion

[mrburnjesus]

moron he is........if he thinks Islam is the right way only, it shows tht he already selfish ,Evil and a ignorance ........its not only Islam but the other religion too.They know nuts.....just have fear for life so they lie.....If they believe in GOD they wouldn;t fight ,jihad or even force ppl to have believe in GOD.Leave life n respect all living things, no matter of color ,race or religion.leave as one.........

[statickk14]

This speaker is a moron....

[0kz23bk011alv]

Agnostics who do not believe in Islam don't just stop there: they want to kick Mo Mad on back side,

[insidejokesarelame]

i do not think that he is right in anyway but i respect the way he says it and he seems like a rational person despite being religious so while i am happy that religion has rational people i am sad that they are still religious but if they do no harm to me they can think what they want

[asifmasih1]

my little 9yr old can write a better book than koran.Koran for the braindead sick following cult of islam.barbaric arabia filthy culture.

[papermizzle]

@asifmasih1 well if you think that than obviously you haven't read the qur'an.

[preetsunny]

come on guys grow up a little

[timetochilli]

look in the quran it says believer and non believer wcan be forgiven as long they are moral but a pretender of islam will not be!

[bosco786]

The 8 fold pah are a group of humanistic values compatible with any religion which values peace. Weather that is compatible with Islam is a judgment I leave the speaker to make.

[bosco786]

Its disturbing that the speaker makes statements in regards to Eastern philosophies without understanding their fundamental difference between Western faiths. The notion of ownership of the truth is not present in many Eastern faiths. The speaker misleads listeners by saying that the 8 fold path of Buddhism expounds exclusivity of truth that resembles the one used by Islam.

[bosco786]

This speaker uses fallacies left right and center. The rejection of Islam does not mean that Muhammad was a liar. The rejection of Islam means one does not believe the validity of the views proposed in the Koran. The speaker makes the assumption that the Koran was authored by the historical figure Muhammad. If one concludes that the Koran was not written by Muhammad (as many rationalists and atheists do) then the critique is against the text.

[abcass]

This guy would not have remained not debunked ...except that many other religions do not restrict salvations to themselves. This guy is simply extrapolating his own prejudices to other religions. Other religions are much more reasonable than he is trying to portray here.

[mike7ace]

The God of Islam is Satan, who is decietful and cunning in his ways.

Jesus tells us love our enemies and forgive those who persecute us, Islam is contary, Jesus is the only way, we are save by faith through grace, and not works of men such as praying 5 times a day

[9tiin]

@mike7ace i don't think he wants us to love satan,our enemy.i wonder if it was jesus who said those words him self,The God of Islam is the one and only God of everything.He is one,don't be so ignorant as to think Muslims worship some other God besides the most gracious God.He is one

[zulfitareen]

A challenge to all muslim brothers and sisters sura 18 : 94-100 dhul qarnain /alexander built a wall of iron and copper to protect a tribe from yajuj and majuj wall will be destroyed on judgement day That means the wall should still be here show me the wall of iron and copper if pyramids are still here, then where is the wall It was a mythical story from a book Alexander romance muahmmad heard it in Syria It proves that Koran is the word of Muhammad not gods THINK CRITICALLY.

[mosiefool]

first of all god has no relgion god isnt a muslim hindu sikh christan budhist jain jews baha or any other relgion god has no shape colour no gender anyone can obtain god doesnt matter about relgion intell a person doesnt learn that every relgion is the same and doesnt see god in every leaving specy he or she wont obtain god becoming like jesus guru nanak mohammed is the true salvation

[jugjones898989]

how can anything which cannot tolerate the other be good?

[mrcaptainpopeye]

Why must someone has to kill a person while feeding another? What a ridiculous example. What if he/she does not kill but only feed? :D 2nd part; so called Allah offering paradise as a reward if we become good guys. That makes every man materialistic in the meaning of having benefit of religion.

[786human]

@ mrcaptainpopeye

the example he is giving is just to explain about how committing a much worser sin than the good that you do, it can cancel that good thing out- when you say "what if he/she does not kill but only feed?" is a completly diffrent question which wasnt what he was asked. U r basicaly sayin wot if som1 only does good but he is talkin about som1 doin good but also a greater bad. hence good meaning to feed and bad meaning to murder. &also arn't rewards supposd to b only for doin gud??

[Egotruistic]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA comparing killing people (every day) to not believing in Islam and his messenger (no peace will be with him)... that is fucking sick.

[Cesarkerus]

This preacher is so full of shit...

[alex89843]

so what you are saying is that if you are raised to believe a certain way and you believe it for a time then it is impossible for them to enter Heaven?so you are saying if you reject islam once you are condemmed forever?that this so call mercyful god will punish you for rejecting him.but my God is the most merciful God then.because even if you reject Him even if you was introduced to Him at a time and stillrejct Him .He will still forgive you.

my God loves you.choose today.

[mikiw1978]

O...M...G...Why dont ppl start thinkin bout real problems like ehm, hunger, disease, aberrations like murder and rape? Why not actually try 2 find the REAL reasons for these problems? The Quran may the word of god but I think the MAN who wrote it needed a hearing aid! (same with the Bible etc)

Fuck, he just started bout Buddhism around 5min, Im Buddhist, I dont believe its the only way 2 salvation, THATs the thing about Buddhism, it says nothin of others only of the self: how 2 LIVE not JUDGE

[Jtherva]

Other religions do not teach that the way to salvation and freedom is simply to become one of them.

Its what you do not which group you sign yourself up to. This is politics not religious spirituality!

[Jtherva]

"NO if you dont join our cult you can't have the cookies. You only get cookies if you submit to our ways and become ...one of usssss"

Only an stupid person would teach this kind of political tribal mentality. He does not understand his own religion.

[jigglyfidda125]

yasir qadhi can go penetrate his sister

[mikiw1978]

LOL

[mohamedsucksdick]

That is such bogus Bull shit.

Feeds someone, and murders someone else!

A person cannot be good and not be a muslim?!

Who the fuck would want to go to a paradise full of such fucking wankers?

[09ri23ea30ri]

mohamedsucksdick-what an interesting name!

[786human]

astagfirullah- may Allah help you- theres no need to offend other religions with names like that. doo u not wonder y every1 hates each other? even u writin comments like that on here and sum1 readin them can cause so much anger in them and dats wher the hatred starts. wise up- better to stay quiet if u only talking to offend. If only u discover the truth for urselfs & not from the western media/tv

[786human]

U clearly have some issues or personal problems in life from what u write. I will not even try to explain anythin to u as u clealry dont care about anythin or any1. Allah will determine ur fate. Allah help us all.

[hannahr77]

786

And if ill-allah has as you ppl claim the books or scriptures in heaven why cant he just send down the unchanged Tanak and Brit Chadasah? Thats the Bible as a whole for you, muhammad had no problem with the Bible did he? Neither did ill-allah until now you ppl sure are funny.

[lumpybruisychickeny1]

At least the heating bill is cheaper in "HELL!!"

[ultradevon04]

WOW!! all religion is BULL SHIT

[GodMarley666]

he acknowledges the absolutes in other religions but remains arrogant sorry faithful in the fact his belief is right and others wrong. blind cant see the forest for the trees

[chowmein911]

watch the full version of the obama deception.

watch?v=eAaQNACwaLw&yt

[dingleberry59]

it is the age of information.. i am sure most of the world has at least heard of islam. so, according to islam, all these people who hear of islam but do not convert are going to burn in hell.

[hannahr77]

ding

so what abt the ppl before islam and those who haven't even heard abt islam will your ill-allah send them to hell 2?

[dingleberry59]

According to Islam, no to the former and yes to the latter. No to the latter, because, it is written, Allah calls all people in their consciences and it is then their duty to respond to the calling. Although, of course, there is that disclaimer that, in the end, it is all Allah's decision and He can do as he deems appropriate (we humans cannot conclusively label anyone as hell-bound or heaven-bound).

Just one question to you Hannah: Why do you stereotype me? I am an atheist-- not a Muslim.

[hannahr77]

ding

yeah right your an atheist sure and pigs fly

[dingleberry59]

What?! How old are you-- 5??

Let me enlighten you: there do exist people in the world who are knowledgeable about religions and still do not believe in any. WOW. That must completely blow your mind?!

[hannahr77]

ding

not really

[786human]

just because you have knowledge of some things doesnt mean you know everythin and u can criticize or disregard anythin you dont want to know about. If you had o much knowledge u wud understand a simple thing like that. may Allah help you

[786human]

Astagfirullah- No need to be ofensive with those words.da ppl b4 Islam wer also told about Allah thru the thousands of Messengers/Prophets that came before Muhammad (PBUH) like Noah, Lut, Jesus etc (PBUT) this is the same allah islam teaches bout and da same message hs been givn to nations upon nations.Unfortuntly ppl did change some part of the scripturs of the old books but The quran is the final buk & word of Allah.Only Allah knws who will go where and He can forgive you 4 anythin HE wants.

[hannahr77]

What 1000 of prophets, and don't forget that ill-allah chooses who he wills to be a muslim and since he hasn't chosen me therefore he has no claim over me correct? And suppose I would live in a remote place where no 1 has ever heard of ill-allah or muhammad then what? Would I go to jennah or hell? Even if I have done good deeds

[786human]

according 2 islam der hav been 1000s of prophets who hav spread the message of allah 2 da ppl of ther time and nation.dis is so that evry1 knows about Allah the 1 and only God.dis is exactly y u have been given free will to choose ur path in life& find out 4 urself, otherwise wot wud b da point of life,

[hannahr77]

@786human

Yeah according to islam but not according to all others, and if there had been 1000's of prophets don't you think that we would had know, it's suppose to be 120.000 or so prophets don't you think that we would had notices, and what abt all the ppl who had already died believing in JESUS and never heard abt ill-allah, surely how can he blame us for not believing in him if we never heard of him? You ppl are just as weird as your god

[786human]

Do u knw wot- jus by the way u write i cud tell u dont have time for other or respect others opinions. the language u use is offensiv & thers no point in talkin to sum1 who has no respect for anythin. my duty lik evry muslim is to let ppl knw but the ultimate decision is urs in wot u do wit the info. i cud answer ur questions bt i dont tink thers any point wit the offence u write bk wit. so Gud luk in life & hope u can b 1 of those ppl in this world who can learn to respect others beliefs.

[hannahr77]

@786human

hmm what do you mean my language is offensive, did I use foul language did I curse?

And just because I don't agree with your point of view then I have no respect, really now why don't you just answer my questions, tha't is you can which I don't think you can, so much for islam has all the answers, so fare you have none to give

[786human]

erm u said "u ppl are just as weird as ur god" i call that offensiv.the trouble wit u is u are so frustrated u dont want to listen to answers- u just read wot some1 writes without thinking about it or researching it and then you throw all this direspectful comments back. of course i dont agree with your views but i dont call u weird. & i have answered the questions u wrote if u luk back at my posts. it seems to me you dont want to read them as u keep askin more q's & sayn I havent answered you

[hannahr77]

786

if you think that calling some 1 weird is offensive hmm then you should se the language muslims use, you have not been able to answer this, what will happen to the ppl believing in JESUS being the SON OF GOD in pre-islam time, and if you didnt know of the teaching of islam then what will ill-allah do, how can he judge you? And for what will he judge you?

can you answer or not?

[786human]

also the quran states that if 4 woteva reason u have never heard of islams teachings then Allah the all forgiving wud forgive u- the only ting that is unforgivable is not beliving in Allah alone & once u die ur chance to repent is over. So dont waste ur chance to search 4 da truth- we as muslim r supposd to spread the message as Muhammad PBUH was the last messenger & ther will be no more messengers after him until the return of Jesus PBUH.Once we let ppl knw it is up to dem to choose their path.

[hannahr77]

@786human

Your lying according to shiat there will be 1 more and that's Mehid or something like that he is the 12 imam, and plz answer what will happen to the ppl who had died believing in JESUS CHRIST as the SON OF GOD and never heard of ill-allah, you do know that it was only in the yr. 700 that muhammad came up with his dream god ill-allah so for 700 yr. ppl died believing in JESUS CHRIST and still does till this very day so what now? What does muhammad's dream god say abt this

[bewareofdajjal]

@hannahr77 You must know it is God that is all Wise and knows the best. What you are exposed to is modern Christianity. Infact the followers of Jesus were called Nazarines thus Jesus from Nazareth. Look back in history and stop presuming things. Just like ppl are exposed to Truth but some dont wanna accept this has repeated over history all the time. The ppl before Islam had the proper teachings of Jesus or some true followers who were inspiring. Ppl also had signs through catastrophe

[hannahr77]

@bewareofdajjal

no my friend the frist Christians where called Natzrim just like as said in Jeremiah 31

[hannahr77]

786

None of this prophet ever told of ill-allah not a single word, and plz who are those 1000's of messenger names plz, places and years ok And if the Torah has been as you say change then produce your proof like the original manuscripts so we can make a comparison, and by the way what does the alleged changing of the Torah has to do with the 1000s of messenger? Do you even know anything abt the Torah or the Tanak = Old Testament have you ever read it?

cont

[hannahr77]

786

oh yeah forgot what where the teachings of Lod and Adam, where is it recorded, in the quran or the hadith

[musliminshallah]

WAHABI

[moosoo77]

wow, are you really a muslim?

[musliminshallah]

do you realy use your brain? or do you just follow the leader?

[moosoo77]

actually, its because I've used my brain that I some things just seem incredibly pathetic to me...like your comment...do you even know what that means?

[grezkorave]

a god that loves you will send you to a horrible place with pain 4ever if you wont accept him.. what a retard world we are living in!

[mahfuz1019]

what have made you think that you are worthy of God's love? God loves only those who are worthy of His love.

[hannahr77]

mah

so tell me in yor humble opinion who are worthy of GOD'S love only muslims?

6 Seek the LORD while HE may be found; call on him while he is near. (meaning while your still alive) 7 Let the wicked forsake his way and the evil man his thoughts. Let him turn to the LORD, and HE will have mercy on him, and to our God, for he will freely pardon.

Can you se the different between islam and Christianity?

[ressla]

3) Is it? Why bother saying something which can be interpreted as literal truth( and was by many scholars for many years).

This last answer is part of the reason i am an athiest now. If that part of the qu'ran shouldn't be taken literally ,what else in the qu'ran is not meant to be literal?

[ehsanul]

1) There is a distinction between practical impossibility and logical impossibility. Things like miracles etc. would be practical impossibilities. But what this means is that these things are extremely difficult. A lot of the things our computers can do now would've been thought impossible and miraculous years ago. But logical impossibility is different. A number that is both even and odd is logically impossible due to the definition of even and odd. The definition makes them mutually exclusive.

[ehsanul]

1)(continued) - Thus, it isn't that a number that's both even and hard is too difficult for God or anyone, but that such a number cannot exist, and is not a thing to be brought into existence, by definition. I say the same of triangles with 4 sides, a being who is both mortal and immortal, and any other "thing" which basically contradicts itself, because these abstract "things" are not really things at all, but words strung together that can have no real meaning.

[ehsanul]

2) I hadn't heard of this "egg shaped earth" thing before, and just answered without doing research. But it occurred to me that there might be a subtlety in translation, as I've known there to be elsewhere, given the richness of Arabic. So I did some trivial "research" and found a few of those sites that make exaggerated claims of science in the Qur'an in an almost propagandist manner, but then I found a more reputable site which seemed to provide a reasonable answer, and I'll provide the link.

[ehsanul]

3) The Qur'an says of itself that it contains verses which are not open to interpretation, and those which are not. What category a verse falls into is to be apparent by its very nature. For example, a statement in the Qur'an saying "God is one" cannot be interpreted away. We are told not to rely the most on interpretable verses, but that the clear ones come first. When something falls into the second category, one cannot insist on a certain interpretation when others are also viable.

[ehsanul]

3)(continued) - Thus, the tradition in interpretation has been that the most literal interpretation of verses is to be taken when it seems acceptable, and metaphor is turned to only when the literal meaning is clearly unacceptable, so as to minimize speculation on the meaning of verses and discourage private interpretation. There are many verses that are clearly not to be interpreted literally, but to some interpreters in the past, a literal setting of the sun did not seem unreasonable.

[ehsanul]

3)(continued 2) - But now that we know that the literal interpretation cannot be correct, we cannot use it, and have to interpret the verse in some other manner. That is not to say that the other interpretations were not valid before, they certainly were always valid. The preference was simply for the most literal interpretation, when it did not contradict anything else, but any other interpretation that is consistent with reality and the rest of the Qur'an is also valid.

[ehsanul]

3)(continued 3) - This is true for any verse in the Qur'an, it is open to interpretation and I'd say that it is meant to be interpreted, but some interpretations are invalid (basically when they contradict reality, or something else in the Qur'an). For the sun setting example in particular, it should be easy to see. When I say "I love watching the sun set in the ocean", I do not mean it actually sets into the ocean, but this is simply the way we talk.

[ehsanul]

I don't totally like his answer to the question about the good person who rejects Islam. In fact, even non-Muslims are meant to get the reward for the good that they do, but in this life. And the Qur'an tells us not to condemn a group to the hellfire, for those among the Christians, Jews, Sabaeans, and even pagans will have their place. So we cannot judge who goes to paradise and who doesn't that is for God alone to decide, and the decision will be just, that is for sure.

[saidpls]

Please to all the Christians, to all the Jews, to all mankind, read the Quran, nothing to loose and judge for yourself

All the best

[mastergm]

Who is he to answer who will go to heaven and who will go to hell?

[ahmarsidd]

He is not answering who will go to heaven or hell. He is stating what Allah (swt) has stated.

[hannahr77]

ah

so what abt the ppl before islam and those who haven't even heard abt islam will your ill-allah send them to hell 2?

does your oh so loving god has an answer for that or should we just guess?

[ressla]

This guy is using arguments only the feeble minded could find convincing. Comparing a murderer to someone who genuinely doesnt believe in the Quran is, frankly, ridiculous. You cannot choose whether you believe in a religion or not. If you read the quran and think its not the word of god then that's that.You cant force yourself to believe. You can pretend to believe for public consumption- but wouldnt Allah know and punish you anyway?

[mahfuz1019]

Dear Brother, the question here is when a person knows that islam is the truth and he rejects islam then what will be his destination. You know, most of the cases, it is impossible for a human to know whether a person is good or not. We cannot know the intention of a person. I agree with you that noone can force anybody to believe in anything. This is also in Quran. All we can do is to present the message in a polite way. Lets not follow anything blindly. Lets use our intellect.

[j40505]

the evidence is as clear as the night from the day, so a person doesnt reject Islam because of intellectual defecits, if he is then he maybe excused because the message that reached him was distorted, therefore they will be acountable in a just way in the hearafter.

Islam satisfies the emotional intellectual person societal and all human needs, which is why its the only religion valid on the day of judgement.

[ressla]

If the evidence "is as clear as the night from the day" then everybody who had read the qu'ran would automatically believe. However that doesnt happen. Thousands of perfectly reasonable people read the quran and decide it's not true.

Why wouldn't Allah just send a message that wasnt ambiguous? The argument I hear often is that people who don't believe are not knowledgable about the Quran and sunnah. Lol , why wasnt the quran made perfectly clear to ALL those who read it, not just believers?

[j40505]

first you need to realise that Allah guides whom he wills. If a persons heart is pure and wants to seek to know sincerely then Allah will guide him, the one whos heart is full of desires and just wants to enjoy or an easy way, wll only find something to suit his desires.

what is important is that we seek the guidance from Allah and be sincere, and be unbiased with our research.

bring to me what is stopping you from Islam, pls tell me

surely if its strong enough then you should tell me.

[ressla]

"first you need to realise that Allah guides whom he wills"- if that is correct we have no free will. So Allah has decided who will not believe, and then punishes them eternally for something they sincerely thought was correct?

"what is important is that we seek the guidance from Allah and be sincere, and be unbiased with our research." I have tried that ,more sincerely than you can imagine. However I still dont believe, hence I will be put in the hellfire for eternity???

Ridiculous.

[ehsanul]

I don't like how some Muslims keep saying that Allah guides who He wills, giving non-Muslims the wrong impression. It clearly doesn't mean that we don't have free will, if one reads what Islam is all about. So that has to be interpreted correctly.

And you say you've been sincere, but your three Islamic examples tells me otherwise. There is nothing impossible in any of those examples, it's not like you're asking for God to create a number that's both odd and even or something like that.

[ressla]

Thanks for your response. Please explain how you think there is "nothing impossible" in:-

1) Allah turned Lut's wife into a pillar of salt.

2) The earth is egg shaped

3) The sun sets in a pool of water.

I am very interested in your explanations.

Regards

Ressla

[ehsanul]

Thanks for the interest.

1) A feat like that is very simple for God. We are even made up of neutrons, protons and electrons anyway, so simply changing their positions might not be easy for us, but it's certainly easy for God.

2) The earth is in fact not perfectly spherical, and the fact that the world is not referred to as flat is significant. Another question you need to ask is "what type of egg?".

3) This is simply the language used to describe nightfall.

[ressla]

"1) A feat like that is very simple for God. We are even made up of neutrons, protons and electrons anyway, so simply changing their positions might not be easy for us, but it's certainly easy for God."

So why would making a number both odd and even be hard for allah?

"2) The earth is in fact not perfectly spherical"

The earth is flattened sphere. There are no commonly found eggs that are flattened spheres. Also the concept of a non-flat earth didn't begin with Islam.

Thanks

[ahmarsidd]

"So why would making a number both odd and even be hard for allah?" because we are the ones who came up with the concept of "odd" and "even" NOT Allah. We are the ones who decided to mutually exclusively label a particular number "odd" or "even"

[ressla]

BTW It is muslims ( and all other religious people) who fail to be "unbiased with (their) research."

If you are unbiased then you should carry out your research with the assumption that all outcomes are possible. However muslim doing "research" are not going to stop believing in Islam if the result doesnt go their way and fails to prove the quran is true. Instead they make excuses.

[ressla]

I'll give you three Islamic examples. If you can prove any one of these is scientifically true or even possible then I will genuinely reconsider my view on Islam.

1) Allah turned Lut's wife into a pillar of salt.

2) The earth is egg shaped

3) Thesun sets in a pool of water.

[ressla]

I'll give you three Islamic examples. If you can prove any one of these is scientifically true or even possible then I will genuinely reconsider my view on Islam.

1) Allah turned Lut's wife into a pillar of salt.

2) The earth is egg shaped

3) Thesun sets in a pool of water.

[glutusmaximus]

This guy just confirms why islam is the worst of all religeons,, they have no toleration of other peoples human right to choose their own beliefs and if their is such a place as heaven then this guy will not be heading their.

[j40505]

You obviously went dumb or deaf when you heard the lecture, why do you not drop away the biased bigotry?

Didnt you hear that all religions claim exclusive salvation?

You dont know what heaven is, nor show firm belief in it, and then have the audacity to say who will go there lol its simply laghable.

read and learn and research, go beyong the biased media, its for your own good. Islam wil only enrich your life and filter the dirt and filth.

[ressla]

sorry you're getting upset about this. so what if all religions claim salvation? They ALL maybe wrong.

No MUSLIMS have the AUDACITY to tell me that people who GENUINELY dont believe will go to hell for eternity. However even the worst muslim murderer or rapist may be granted jannah... that's totally illogical.

Another question - can you read and speak arabic?

[burningsoul89]

IF a believer REPENTS of COURSE he can go to jannah!!! Of course, this isn't christianity, our religion is fair.

[ressla]

And if you could try to answer my challenge i would appreciate it.

[ressla]

Yasir Qadhi in this lecture compares somebody who rejects islam to a murderer. The comparison is, frankly, idiotic.

All sane murderers KNOW they are doing wrong but still do it.

Someone who rejects islam genuinely does so because he doesnt think it's true. Hecant force himself to believe.

Allahs punishment of rejectors ( particularly apostates) shows that it is a weak religion. Why would a powerful creator want ex-muslims dead? Is he like a jealous child?

[Jalalisa]

MashaAllah Allah bless Yassir Qadhi. Amin

[shashi13m]

Hinduism is non-exclusive, you can be Muslim or Christian to do Yoga or in Buddhism to follow the eight fold path. Nothing is exclusive. Don't lie. Islam is a pernicious idea.