Added: 4 years ago
From: ToTspc
Views: 55,979
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (141)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Thumbs up if you're watching this in 2012. This is a really nice song~ Such a soothing voice and melody.

  • she hot...

  • Comment removed

  • i love her voice! thumbs up if u r watching this in 2011 :))

  • her voice is awful.

  • her voice so exciting...

  • Any HD quality video of her singing Bu De Bu Ai?

    She's so cute...

  • wow fucking copy song singing on the stage

    Haha that singer is not ashmed????

    That singer Not allow original singer in korea (Freestyle-y).

    Just copy song

    Not remake song Just shit copy song

  • @birdol2626 yeah, but they got permission, so what's the problem?

  • i like the way she sings but i think it'll be a bit better with wilber and speaking of wilber i wunder where he is

  • even if she was just standing there singing the song, without the backup dancers, ID STILL BE WOWED !

  • she's beatiiFuL ' and voiiCe GeniiaL!!

    Desdeee Mexiicoooooooooooo!!!

    i Love wiiLber paN

  • shes so awesome!!! ^^

  • she sounds better in the mv

  • que linda voz tiene : )

  • Love her!!

  • shes good!

  • wow! she sang wilber's part! very great!

  • Very nice voice.

  • the girl sounds like lao yin ming from "the voice"

  • Just an opinion okay, guys? I think Hebe did better than Xian Zi in this song. And where is Will? Also why did she use the Korean rap instead of Will's?

  • @MzYiJoANN shes better than hebe... hebe is not that great...

  • whoa i didnt know she was gona sing the whole song :P i was expecting wilbur. but she sounds good.

  • Elle chante pas mal mais je suis quand même un peu déçue, vu la différence de sa voix entre la musique commercialisé et le live :/

  • yeah i'm a little dissappointed too!

  • wow that is the best place and wonderful song and voice

  • beautiful voice.

  • cool~

  • cool!:D

  • i agree she is pretty. thats an awesome stadium to perform in, i wonder where it is....? ooh and i wish i could do the choreo with the team, it looks so much fun!!! everytime i listen to this song on my ipod i always feel like dancing. anyways excellent performance....

  • xian zi is so cute!!~~~

  • ahhhh would be nice if will pan can join this version.

  • 它低音了

  • great~

  • damn thats a big stadium lol, but yea, i like her singing, very nice =]

  • Original Song

    Singer - Freestyle(Korean)

    Title - Y (Please Tell Me Why)

    Album released at 2004-07-16

    Copy Song

    Singer - Wilber Pan(chinese)

    Title - 不得不愛 Bu De Bu Ai (Have To Love)

    Album released at 2005-07-08

  • is it really copied? or did wilbert just buy the tone legally and add chinese lyrics to it?

  • he does a lot of remakes of krn songs . .another one is 快樂崇拜.

  • she is so cute/pretty how come there's almost nothing online about her?

  • is she famous in china ? cuz i can see that she isn't famous in youtube ,how old is she anyway ?

  • can any1 tell me y she's using the freestyle's korean version instead of will's chi version? i just think its weird cuz i mean she's singing it in chi but using a the korean for the rap part

  • totally agree!!!

  • Comment removed

  • So beautiful. <3

  • gosh. i dream of singing of her but omg. i hate her outfit

  • i didnt give u thumbs down but she has more energy than fahrenheit band members singing

  • I'm not sure about that

    I'll admit, Fahrenheit at times really doesn't have any energy...As if they're like bored...But I never said she had no energy...I said she needs MORE. I like her singing...

  • Err...I don't know why everyone's giving thumbs down to everyone that likes this song.This song is good, but it's not perfect.

    1.She sounds a bit weak, not enough energy

    2.Wilber's not there

  • I don't know why people are giving me thumbs down, I mean I'm not saying this song isn't bad I just said she doesn't have enough energy.

    I never said she sucked.

  • i agree with you about her voice not enough energy, if she can change that she could do better

  • Thank You!!

    Everyone else idk why gave me thumbs down

    I never said she sucked.I personally, LOVE this song

    Xian Zi is a great singer,I mean she can even do Wilber's part nicely...I just don't think she had enough energy

  • she has such a cute voice

  • she is ^____^

  • i like it ^^___^

  • I love this song!

  • she is awesome

  • i don't know why people don't agree with you...your right she is awesome

  • i wish i was there too

  • cute!

    she has clear and high tone voice♪

    可愛い~

  • its still good XD

  • she is really good live usually singers who sing live r horrible shes pretty and can sing good live and not live on music videos and can any 1 tell me what bu dai bu ai means plz

  • bu de bu ai means Have To love or Gotta Love

  • Have To love

  • she is beautiful..

    but is very different

    with live and mv..-.-

  • Where the hell is Wilber Pan???????? That song sounds widowish without a guy part!! And the rapping part was taken from the original Korean version, wtf!!

  • so many fucking trolls. lol, haterz.

  • is it just me or on the mv/cd her voice seems higher?

  • Her Voice Is soo high thats what i like about his song

  • i think hebe is better at this song. because she sounds more like the original. but xian zi has a very beautiful voice also, it can reach such high pitches.

  • are you serious??? she's your aunt???!!!

  • Yea well I don't Believe her.

  • She so cute!

  • i love this

  • i lvoe the flute sounding part

  • yea me 2

  • she sings both parts?

  • i love her :) i think we all do

  • where can i get the guitar tabs?

  • u know linda chung?

    i feel it she looks like her!!

  • Yeah

    that's what i thinking to

    she looks like linda

  • they both cute though

  • kinda looks like a young vivian man...

  • really? I think linda is not pretty at all and xian zi is. So i think they're very different.

  • She's pretty and cute and a nice voice!!

    EXCELLENT!

    thansk for uploading

  • Beautiful!!

  • wow! she can actually sing this song by herself without a guy there to sing the song with her! how can sh keep tha high pitch voice so much?

  • her voice is another, because its not a cover. She Sing alone without another woman Voices...

    I think the Wilber is better

  • O_O

    pepps say she sound diff but i think she sound teh same

  • your tonedeaf lol.

  • i love it. its nice

  • does anyone have the mp3 for this song?

    ....this version with just her by herself?

  • there isn't a version of her by herself, the version with her singing the majority of the song has freestyle in it and it's a mixed chinese/korean version.

  • i have it

  • ugh..

    you guys are lucky that u have the version just herself... ^=^

  • her vioce is so soft n nice, remind me of a cotten blanket that can snuggle up to XD

    but is it only mi or does she seem a lil expresionless on stage? like a tad too nervous ... O_O

  • Of course she can survive...

    Wish her the best!!!

  • she is no beyonce, that is no insult

  • i wonder if she can survive in china alone or if she will depend on taiwan for her music career

  • i love her singing .

  • she is not bad without him*^

  • i luv the background soundtrack but.......... does she sound kindaof different when she sings with Wilber Pan Weo Bo, to now?

  • i think sound the same

    o-o

  • Lol, was the back rapping in Korean??? And yes, this song does need a male part!

  • yea lol...kinda sounded like epik high

  • wilber brings a guy aspect into the song that it needs. but in terms of vocals this girl singing by herself beats having wilber around

  • 我认为她将成为最了不起的女歌手在瓷, 很美丽, 没有差错。v33 she looks like gong li only she sings lol

  • I love them both, but shes way better than the girl who sings Y live.. ♥ it

  • its not the same without wilber

  • but shes still good

  • yeh i agree...

  • Did she this song alone because she broke up with Wilbur?

  • wait what they used to go out??

  • or he was sick idk

  • she probably too nervous with him this is her own version

  • dis song cant be sung by one person. her voice just too high for wilbur's part

  • of course live doesnt sound precisely like the recorded version.

    I really appreciate that even though she is very goodlooking she just sings, because thats what she is: a singer!

    not like western female "singers" who just dance and strip like some cheap prostitute (I will add "on drugs", thinking of Britney Spears...)

  • Not the same without Wilber. She sounds totally different each time she sings this song.

  • : )

    That's good ahaha.

  • shes good but she sounds different like in every song

  • that's exactly why she's good

  • yup

  • She is so good i love

    wo hen xi huan ni ni chang hen hao ting

  • shes singing bu de bu ai check out her and wilber pan singing bu de bu ai

  • She is great i love this song, dont even know what shes singing, could sommbody explain ? ;D

  • HOT stuff!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more