Just an opinion okay, guys? I think Hebe did better than Xian Zi in this song. And where is Will? Also why did she use the Korean rap instead of Will's?
i agree she is pretty. thats an awesome stadium to perform in, i wonder where it is....? ooh and i wish i could do the choreo with the team, it looks so much fun!!! everytime i listen to this song on my ipod i always feel like dancing. anyways excellent performance....
can any1 tell me y she's using the freestyle's korean version instead of will's chi version? i just think its weird cuz i mean she's singing it in chi but using a the korean for the rap part
I'll admit, Fahrenheit at times really doesn't have any energy...As if they're like bored...But I never said she had no energy...I said she needs MORE. I like her singing...
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
shes singing at a lower key? lower than the ones in the MV... why is that? is it cos she has to sing the whole song to herself...so she made it to cater both the high chorus and the part which wilber suppose to sing?...
she is really good live usually singers who sing live r horrible shes pretty and can sing good live and not live on music videos and can any 1 tell me what bu dai bu ai means plz
Where the hell is Wilber Pan???????? That song sounds widowish without a guy part!! And the rapping part was taken from the original Korean version, wtf!!
i think hebe is better at this song. because she sounds more like the original. but xian zi has a very beautiful voice also, it can reach such high pitches.
there isn't a version of her by herself, the version with her singing the majority of the song has freestyle in it and it's a mixed chinese/korean version.
Thumbs up if you're watching this in 2012. This is a really nice song~ Such a soothing voice and melody.
AzndoubleAA 1 month ago
she hot...
goldenharry 7 months ago
Comment removed
r0ck3ts11 7 months ago
i love her voice! thumbs up if u r watching this in 2011 :))
whereisthelove1824 8 months ago 10
her voice is awful.
xBl00dBrothersX 8 months ago
her voice so exciting...
forpsln 10 months ago
Any HD quality video of her singing Bu De Bu Ai?
She's so cute...
VashStepler 10 months ago 5
Comment removed
KoreaVANKChannel 11 months ago
wow fucking copy song singing on the stage
Haha that singer is not ashmed????
That singer Not allow original singer in korea (Freestyle-y).
Just copy song
Not remake song Just shit copy song
birdol2626 1 year ago
@birdol2626 yeah, but they got permission, so what's the problem?
stripeytofu 10 months ago
i like the way she sings but i think it'll be a bit better with wilber and speaking of wilber i wunder where he is
woahCxDuel 1 year ago 2
even if she was just standing there singing the song, without the backup dancers, ID STILL BE WOWED !
2001ALS2008 1 year ago
she's beatiiFuL ' and voiiCe GeniiaL!!
Desdeee Mexiicoooooooooooo!!!
i Love wiiLber paN
QkesttupiidasOs 1 year ago
shes so awesome!!! ^^
marimar268 1 year ago
she sounds better in the mv
kang1996 1 year ago
que linda voz tiene : )
3lizabt 2 years ago
Love her!!
Ghostrider1981 2 years ago
shes good!
faraong 2 years ago
wow! she sang wilber's part! very great!
tepihebe 2 years ago 2
Very nice voice.
blader4thewin 2 years ago
the girl sounds like lao yin ming from "the voice"
chinesemonkeystyle 2 years ago
Just an opinion okay, guys? I think Hebe did better than Xian Zi in this song. And where is Will? Also why did she use the Korean rap instead of Will's?
MzYiJoANN 2 years ago
@MzYiJoANN shes better than hebe... hebe is not that great...
hype0ff 1 year ago
whoa i didnt know she was gona sing the whole song :P i was expecting wilbur. but she sounds good.
Gproducshizz 2 years ago
Elle chante pas mal mais je suis quand même un peu déçue, vu la différence de sa voix entre la musique commercialisé et le live :/
DidiFromPortugal 2 years ago
yeah i'm a little dissappointed too!
iDramaholic 2 years ago
wow that is the best place and wonderful song and voice
143cinderallle 2 years ago
beautiful voice.
cartman726 2 years ago
cool~
supernml 2 years ago
cool!:D
ChrmdThree 2 years ago
i agree she is pretty. thats an awesome stadium to perform in, i wonder where it is....? ooh and i wish i could do the choreo with the team, it looks so much fun!!! everytime i listen to this song on my ipod i always feel like dancing. anyways excellent performance....
runeknight5 2 years ago 2
xian zi is so cute!!~~~
LegendaryHacker1 2 years ago 17
ahhhh would be nice if will pan can join this version.
rrzlj17 2 years ago 4
它低音了
watchonutube 2 years ago
great~
nikoarwenda 2 years ago
damn thats a big stadium lol, but yea, i like her singing, very nice =]
bboy1029384756 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
shes out of tune....o.O
craz33pers0n 2 years ago
Original Song
Singer - Freestyle(Korean)
Title - Y (Please Tell Me Why)
Album released at 2004-07-16
Copy Song
Singer - Wilber Pan(chinese)
Title - 不得不愛 Bu De Bu Ai (Have To Love)
Album released at 2005-07-08
doobshop 2 years ago 2
is it really copied? or did wilbert just buy the tone legally and add chinese lyrics to it?
4646asdfasdf 2 years ago 2
he does a lot of remakes of krn songs . .another one is 快樂崇拜.
babyace19 2 years ago
she is so cute/pretty how come there's almost nothing online about her?
jeishun 2 years ago
is she famous in china ? cuz i can see that she isn't famous in youtube ,how old is she anyway ?
Creuzillion 2 years ago 2
can any1 tell me y she's using the freestyle's korean version instead of will's chi version? i just think its weird cuz i mean she's singing it in chi but using a the korean for the rap part
icehearts01 3 years ago
totally agree!!!
wilbur24 2 years ago
Comment removed
2k9test 2 years ago
So beautiful. <3
OoItsJohn 3 years ago
gosh. i dream of singing of her but omg. i hate her outfit
vballgoofball 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
No offense...But she sorta messed it up a bit by adding you are my boy boyfriend part...
lovinfahrenheit 3 years ago
i didnt give u thumbs down but she has more energy than fahrenheit band members singing
Crapidiot 2 years ago
I'm not sure about that
I'll admit, Fahrenheit at times really doesn't have any energy...As if they're like bored...But I never said she had no energy...I said she needs MORE. I like her singing...
lovinfahrenheit 2 years ago
Err...I don't know why everyone's giving thumbs down to everyone that likes this song.This song is good, but it's not perfect.
1.She sounds a bit weak, not enough energy
2.Wilber's not there
lovinfahrenheit 3 years ago 2
I don't know why people are giving me thumbs down, I mean I'm not saying this song isn't bad I just said she doesn't have enough energy.
I never said she sucked.
lovinfahrenheit 3 years ago
i agree with you about her voice not enough energy, if she can change that she could do better
1992kkw 3 years ago 2
Thank You!!
Everyone else idk why gave me thumbs down
I never said she sucked.I personally, LOVE this song
Xian Zi is a great singer,I mean she can even do Wilber's part nicely...I just don't think she had enough energy
lovinfahrenheit 3 years ago
she has such a cute voice
limbakho 3 years ago 58
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She's really cute....
coolboi08 3 years ago
she is ^____^
babyhlee 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
cute song
cedrik2003 3 years ago
i like it ^^___^
babyhlee 3 years ago
I love this song!
revol14 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
me 2!
siddharthdhami 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I agree with u xD love dis song also. xD <3
XxMaiLuvHimxX 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
shes singing at a lower key? lower than the ones in the MV... why is that? is it cos she has to sing the whole song to herself...so she made it to cater both the high chorus and the part which wilber suppose to sing?...
kuya4307 3 years ago
she is awesome
U2B8 3 years ago
i don't know why people don't agree with you...your right she is awesome
babyhlee 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the rap part is actually korean from the original song Y..
her voice is so beautiful singing this song.. wish i can be there to watch..
Sekundez666 3 years ago
i wish i was there too
babyhlee 3 years ago
cute!
she has clear and high tone voice♪
可愛い~
hweedo 3 years ago 2
its still good XD
BanditXYZ21 3 years ago
she is really good live usually singers who sing live r horrible shes pretty and can sing good live and not live on music videos and can any 1 tell me what bu dai bu ai means plz
fuzzyfuzz01 3 years ago 3
bu de bu ai means Have To love or Gotta Love
BanditXYZ21 3 years ago
Have To love
Mikechen177 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I hate to be the prick, but if you want a direct translation, it'd be Can't not Love.
liuping999 3 years ago
she is beautiful..
but is very different
with live and mv..-.-
XXXperience1234 3 years ago 2
Where the hell is Wilber Pan???????? That song sounds widowish without a guy part!! And the rapping part was taken from the original Korean version, wtf!!
chingiz88 3 years ago 6
so many fucking trolls. lol, haterz.
azn3xdawgg 3 years ago
is it just me or on the mv/cd her voice seems higher?
ciaolyre 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Her stage presence seems starnge. Just awkward imo...
TheMuteAWN 3 years ago
Her Voice Is soo high thats what i like about his song
beautyqueen5 3 years ago 7
i think hebe is better at this song. because she sounds more like the original. but xian zi has a very beautiful voice also, it can reach such high pitches.
lilithao 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wtf i want a fuckin celeb aunt
loannguyen1983 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she never told me about this concert dam
XianZimyAunt 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
thats my aunt
xian zi
XianZimyAunt 3 years ago
are you serious??? she's your aunt???!!!
XiHuanArron 3 years ago
Yea well I don't Believe her.
beautyqueen5 3 years ago
She so cute!
FADEHoe 3 years ago 4
i love this
sharonabear 3 years ago 2
i lvoe the flute sounding part
genkers 3 years ago
yea me 2
FADEHoe 3 years ago 3
she sings both parts?
bluenyellowshorts 3 years ago
i love her :) i think we all do
shawnster44 3 years ago 3
where can i get the guitar tabs?
Hamburglar202 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
잘한다.근데 뒤에 렙 한글이넹.
OoItsJohn 3 years ago
u know linda chung?
i feel it she looks like her!!
beautyqueen5 3 years ago
Yeah
that's what i thinking to
she looks like linda
williamko85 3 years ago
they both cute though
beautyqueen5 3 years ago
kinda looks like a young vivian man...
azn3xdawgg 3 years ago
really? I think linda is not pretty at all and xian zi is. So i think they're very different.
dragonteeth4 3 years ago 2
She's pretty and cute and a nice voice!!
EXCELLENT!
thansk for uploading
beautyqueen5 3 years ago
Beautiful!!
Thing114 3 years ago
wow! she can actually sing this song by herself without a guy there to sing the song with her! how can sh keep tha high pitch voice so much?
XxMaiLuvHimxX 3 years ago 5
her voice is another, because its not a cover. She Sing alone without another woman Voices...
I think the Wilber is better
lordcritias1 3 years ago
O_O
pepps say she sound diff but i think she sound teh same
cartoonlover01 3 years ago 2
your tonedeaf lol.
SecretLove4Aoi 3 years ago 4
i love it. its nice
jianyu 3 years ago
does anyone have the mp3 for this song?
....this version with just her by herself?
verypoorboy 3 years ago
there isn't a version of her by herself, the version with her singing the majority of the song has freestyle in it and it's a mixed chinese/korean version.
aegacy 3 years ago
i have it
hiphopanime 3 years ago
ugh..
you guys are lucky that u have the version just herself... ^=^
Solki2008 3 years ago 2
her vioce is so soft n nice, remind me of a cotten blanket that can snuggle up to XD
but is it only mi or does she seem a lil expresionless on stage? like a tad too nervous ... O_O
whitefrost01 3 years ago 2
Of course she can survive...
Wish her the best!!!
bugaboo8834 3 years ago
she is no beyonce, that is no insult
CelestialSuperDragon 3 years ago
i wonder if she can survive in china alone or if she will depend on taiwan for her music career
CelestialSuperDragon 4 years ago
i love her singing .
cindiie28 4 years ago 7
she is not bad without him*^
ResidentDragonNightX 4 years ago 4
i luv the background soundtrack but.......... does she sound kindaof different when she sings with Wilber Pan Weo Bo, to now?
XxMaiLuvHimxX 4 years ago 4
i think sound the same
o-o
cartoonlover01 4 years ago
Lol, was the back rapping in Korean??? And yes, this song does need a male part!
chingiz88 4 years ago
yea lol...kinda sounded like epik high
sinblader 4 years ago 2
wilber brings a guy aspect into the song that it needs. but in terms of vocals this girl singing by herself beats having wilber around
engerlandt 4 years ago 3
我认为她将成为最了不起的女歌手在瓷, 很美丽, 没有差错。v33 she looks like gong li only she sings lol
ResidentDragonNightX 4 years ago 3
I love them both, but shes way better than the girl who sings Y live.. ♥ it
TeddyToys 4 years ago 2
its not the same without wilber
RiULam 4 years ago 4
but shes still good
RiULam 4 years ago
yeh i agree...
soulestazn 4 years ago 2
Did she this song alone because she broke up with Wilbur?
eggroll121 4 years ago
wait what they used to go out??
strawberryhearts6 4 years ago
or he was sick idk
eyesack9 4 years ago
she probably too nervous with him this is her own version
hiphopanime 4 years ago
dis song cant be sung by one person. her voice just too high for wilbur's part
taichimastas 4 years ago 2
of course live doesnt sound precisely like the recorded version.
I really appreciate that even though she is very goodlooking she just sings, because thats what she is: a singer!
not like western female "singers" who just dance and strip like some cheap prostitute (I will add "on drugs", thinking of Britney Spears...)
21stCenturyEuropean 4 years ago 10
Not the same without Wilber. She sounds totally different each time she sings this song.
an00b1z 4 years ago 4
: )
That's good ahaha.
SadisticHuman 4 years ago 2
shes good but she sounds different like in every song
hiphopanime 4 years ago
that's exactly why she's good
tangpa 4 years ago 5
yup
animebaby20 4 years ago
She is so good i love
wo hen xi huan ni ni chang hen hao ting
lunargy 4 years ago 5
shes singing bu de bu ai check out her and wilber pan singing bu de bu ai
hiphopanime 4 years ago
She is great i love this song, dont even know what shes singing, could sommbody explain ? ;D
Kurupts 4 years ago 2
HOT stuff!
REtiRO 4 years ago