You want some salsa with those chips? Haha I can't help it- I'm a trumpet player. French Horns can choose from pretty much any movie soundtrack and you choose "Bugler's Holiday"? Haha no it's all good, but just for the record, Trumpets 1 French Horns -10
The recording and hall acoustics are not very good but that does not explain the intonation problems they have (I think the main problem is in the low horn part)
The solo's are cool. The original horn music is crud though.. I just don't like any of Leroy Anderson's music.. All the horn music seems to be endless upbeats
The 'mushy' sound as someone called it is due in a large part to the room they're playing in, not necessarily the instrument/player. It sounds/looks like it could be in a chapel or something like that, so it's a large room and the sound/articulations are getting lost. Someone said it's bc of the instrument, and while it may not be the easiest instrument to play a piece like this on, it is certainly possible.
@yos313 Go listen to something likt the London Horn Sound recording of 'Tico-Tico', they manage to pull of this style of playing quite well. Not 'mushy' at all. All that being said, nice job to the girls in the recording!
@AngryBaldCat the blend could be better too. attacks, Releases, colour it could have used some more work. still cool though. we just played this (the trumpet version) in university concert band. yay off-beats!
Great Job - I really do not think it is too slow. It is a bit mushy but that is the instrument. I have played both on a collegiate level. Last summer I played in a band that did this with 3 Bassoons taking the lead. It was good variety piece.
@wvwoodman the french horn is mushy? you're really going to say that where almost everyone reading and posting comments on here is a passionate french horn player? lol.
Awesome job! And great creativity for your recital. I am also a French Horn player and when I did my recital tried to choose unusual pieces as well. I did the PDQ Bach Concerto for Horn and Hardart. Gave the audience a good chuckle.
I agree with Aresthesaint24 as a French Horn and Trumpet player this song trumpets can really bring out the articulations and brightness while the French Horn has a nice warn tone thats great for lyrical songs
I didn't have a good first impression of this song back when I played it for band. The horns were stuck with boring upbeat eighth notes the whole time. Listening to this now, I appreciate how well you guys sounded together, but horns just aren't suited for this song.
Yes, the horns sound great! Yes, it's too slow. Much too slow! But what's really needed is to edit out the first thirty seconds of the video! We don't want to watch them adjust their stands and move their water bottle around... (water bottle on stage? What, is this concert so long that she's going to get dehydrated?)
You're right about the first 30 sec and the water bottle but my feeling about the tempo is that it's appropriate for french horns, which attack notes in a different manner than trumpets. Also, just because trumpets have a quicker response time, doesn't necessarily mean that they need to go 200 mph Athletic performances at a high tempo often times do so with a complete disregard for fine tuning the nuances of dynamics and interpretation.Overall, this was an average performance with glitches.
Of course they're double tonguing. Noone plays Bugler's Holiday without double tonguing. But this is still the slowest I think I've ever heard this played. That said, I really like the sound of a French Horn trio on this piece.
You want some salsa with those chips? Haha I can't help it- I'm a trumpet player. French Horns can choose from pretty much any movie soundtrack and you choose "Bugler's Holiday"? Haha no it's all good, but just for the record, Trumpets 1 French Horns -10
johnsurs22 1 month ago
Not bad... well yeah it is bad, but there IS a reason roy anderson put BUGLER in the title :)
Buglers play trumpets OR bugles but NOT french horn.
jacobbrashears 1 month ago
HAHAHAH nice! i bet its kinda hard to traspose it from Bb to F...well i can easily! can u?
8747800 5 months ago
If it was meant for horns it probably wouldn't be called "Bugler's" Holiday, lol
alawrence99 5 months ago
Not for bad for french horns. I would have rather have a concert band back them up instead of a piano.
blaquejew 5 months ago
Very unfortunate.
bervy8 7 months ago
The recording and hall acoustics are not very good but that does not explain the intonation problems they have (I think the main problem is in the low horn part)
trr321321 7 months ago
The solo's are cool. The original horn music is crud though.. I just don't like any of Leroy Anderson's music.. All the horn music seems to be endless upbeats
gorthjrod 8 months ago
Hmmmmm ......
Yep .........
coltonlostemo 8 months ago
The 'mushy' sound as someone called it is due in a large part to the room they're playing in, not necessarily the instrument/player. It sounds/looks like it could be in a chapel or something like that, so it's a large room and the sound/articulations are getting lost. Someone said it's bc of the instrument, and while it may not be the easiest instrument to play a piece like this on, it is certainly possible.
yos313 10 months ago
Comment removed
yos313 10 months ago
@yos313 Go listen to something likt the London Horn Sound recording of 'Tico-Tico', they manage to pull of this style of playing quite well. Not 'mushy' at all. All that being said, nice job to the girls in the recording!
yos313 10 months ago
Oh my god I love it!!!!! Where do I get the music oh my gosh!!!!!!!
connorjordan95 11 months ago
I think part of the problem was the echo from the performance hall. I wonder if Kerry Turner could get a hold of this and write it out for the AHQ.
zphoto86 1 year ago
Speed it up and it would sound much better
jguzman455 1 year ago
haha. we have to rewrite your mozart horn concertos. good to see it works the other way too.
DiVeronica 1 year ago
so slow! Pitchy, as well. As a horn player, one of my biggest pet peeves is an out of tune horn.
AngryBaldCat 1 year ago
@AngryBaldCat the blend could be better too. attacks, Releases, colour it could have used some more work. still cool though. we just played this (the trumpet version) in university concert band. yay off-beats!
bignut4567 1 year ago
Great Job - I really do not think it is too slow. It is a bit mushy but that is the instrument. I have played both on a collegiate level. Last summer I played in a band that did this with 3 Bassoons taking the lead. It was good variety piece.
wvwoodman 1 year ago
@wvwoodman the french horn is mushy? you're really going to say that where almost everyone reading and posting comments on here is a passionate french horn player? lol.
bignut4567 1 year ago
Cool, very ambitious =)
saxofoneprincess 1 year ago
Not that good.Slow.Ugh.
We6Montsters 1 year ago
Though it sounds good, this song is definitely not made to be performed by horns.
Maybe I'm wrong cause I ONLY do play tuba.
RavenAbraxas 1 year ago
WOW !!! good job Jennifer.... looking 4ward to play this arrangement w/ FASO.
chokmolina 1 year ago
I can never decide if I like the harp or the French horn best..........yeah I know they are completely different, just bear with me.
MrCombat1965 1 year ago
Awesome job! And great creativity for your recital. I am also a French Horn player and when I did my recital tried to choose unusual pieces as well. I did the PDQ Bach Concerto for Horn and Hardart. Gave the audience a good chuckle.
OctoberMountainGal 1 year ago
I'm always proud to see ladies as they take on leadership roles.These ladies are good and they're going to get better just because they choose to .
MRLOVINGOOD 1 year ago
My friends and I are playing this for our horn recital. We are playing it up to tempo though. :)
frenchhorngal09 1 year ago
this song is absolutely not meant for horns to play ever.
michaelsafley 1 year ago
I agree with Aresthesaint24 as a French Horn and Trumpet player this song trumpets can really bring out the articulations and brightness while the French Horn has a nice warn tone thats great for lyrical songs
TrumpetMaster1000 1 year ago
There is a reason this is meant for bugle don't get me wrong I love horn but this sounds way too mushy for my taste
Aresthesaint24 2 years ago 21
I didn't have a good first impression of this song back when I played it for band. The horns were stuck with boring upbeat eighth notes the whole time. Listening to this now, I appreciate how well you guys sounded together, but horns just aren't suited for this song.
gingerpi93 2 years ago
I am a horn player myself, and I just love this!!! :D This sounds really good.
furirox4ever 2 years ago 4
@furirox4ever This is the shit. I like it better than on trumpet!
Mrdianalynn 1 year ago
Yes, the horns sound great! Yes, it's too slow. Much too slow! But what's really needed is to edit out the first thirty seconds of the video! We don't want to watch them adjust their stands and move their water bottle around... (water bottle on stage? What, is this concert so long that she's going to get dehydrated?)
mdickinson 2 years ago
You're right about the first 30 sec and the water bottle but my feeling about the tempo is that it's appropriate for french horns, which attack notes in a different manner than trumpets. Also, just because trumpets have a quicker response time, doesn't necessarily mean that they need to go 200 mph Athletic performances at a high tempo often times do so with a complete disregard for fine tuning the nuances of dynamics and interpretation.Overall, this was an average performance with glitches.
ddfrhh 2 years ago
@mdickinson Only a hair or so.
turtleshell56 1 year ago
how could people say this is too slow. the players are probably already double tonguing! anyway, good job. : D
XBOXliveStUmMpY 2 years ago 2
Of course they're double tonguing. Noone plays Bugler's Holiday without double tonguing. But this is still the slowest I think I've ever heard this played. That said, I really like the sound of a French Horn trio on this piece.
glinkaboo 2 years ago 3
Allen Vizzutti can play it without tonguing at all.
littleyogi16 2 years ago
And he can play upside down and inhaling haha
But seriously though... His double tonguing octaves is ridiculous.
t39046 2 years ago
that is probably why i said that they are double tonguing. :)
XBOXliveStUmMpY 2 years ago
Haha..... sounds better with horns. (:
Just my opinion.
HahaMelia 2 years ago 2
the french horn is the best horn ever you guys kilt it
jill08ian12 2 years ago
U. of South Carolina or Southern California?
Great job!
Marcu5r0xs0x 3 years ago
This is the University of Southern California.
OzTrumpet 3 years ago
@OzTrumpet the better USC :D
jk i just love the trojans
WhillieMan23 1 year ago
lentissima!
robertoreference 3 years ago
horn is one of the most loveliest instrument to play!!!!i love it when i start playing it!!!
sokjaer567 3 years ago
Perhaps I can get someone to record it when we play "Holiday for Horns" in the Spring.
hornalicious 3 years ago
where is my ballping hammer, PLEASE
whatever7x7 3 years ago
to slow =[
shirkenXCCR 3 years ago
always people have critics
horns are one of the hardest instruments to learn.and why to slow??i wanna see you play this pice
lap116 3 years ago
Bravo Jennifer !
kwonotae 3 years ago
Would have been much cooler with the band. Still awesome. I want to play this! Good job.
sgpepper123 3 years ago
brave!
angelobonaccorso 3 years ago
Wow! It was Great:) But th sond is little bad because of the videocamera! (:
superklar 3 years ago
this is so GANGSTA! hahaha can i get this arrangement?
d(-_-)b
kadjrare 3 years ago
Composer Jarrett,Jack M.
Publisher C.L. Barnhouse Co.
Copyright 1967
It is a quartet with band. been looking for a recording.
youtheducation 3 years ago
Nice! Got anyone playing Holiday for Horns?
youtheducation 3 years ago
Nope. Who wrote Holiday for Horns?
OzTrumpet 3 years ago
@OzTrumpet
A Google search tells me it's a composer named Jack M. Jarrett.
quadibloc 8 months ago