oh wow i adore this song but i never thought i'd see something like this :D what a privilege! it's so out of this world actually watching her at work. thanks so much for this upload, you're amazing :)
@andrea111292 so you've told me several times, but not everyone would care so much to keep putting up so many videos out of their time for the fans on youtube :D just take it, lol!
This footage is amazing! I love Shirley and Bear McCreary. I really loved all the music in tscc but of course... Samson and Delilah was my favorite. :)
@ShUrkaSl you're kidding right? timbre is what makes the music or sound special- anything that adds to it but can't be pinned down by the concepts of pitch or loudness. and Shirley has one of the finest examples of one of the most beautiful (and rare) 'timbres' of all- contralto. and anyway the evidence is right here! it took me a while to get used to acapellas because there's no support from the music, but it just means you have to listen more carefully to appreciate just how well she sings.
In my opinion, her voice sounds unsteady. And it has always been like that.
I'm sorry, it's hard for me to explain what I mean in English. I love Shirley, but I'd say , she is not a perfect vocalist. She is more of an actress. She can make you feel the song , but sol-fa is not her strong point.
@ShUrkaSl First of all she's an artist, which means she produces a work we can call art. The vocals work. Of course she can't sing a Beyoncè's song, but who the hell cares about that?
@ShUrkaSl yes, i guess you're right in that respect. i do often notice her voice has a certain quaver that makes her pretty much who she is as a singer. she seems to be able to sing more note-perfect in some songs, and in others not so much. but it's what i love about her the most. i'm sorry if i sounded mean. but i admire her so much for that ability she has, to make you feel the song. it's just personal preference. to me, artistry in singing is far more important than pitch-perfection.
@ShUrkaSl and besides- who, really, is pitch-perfect all the time? probably no-one. and here's another thing. pitch perfect singing on a record, where you've done probably more than one take to get it 'perfect', is one thing. good live singing is another. Shirley's live singing is amazing quality, which shows how great a singer she really is. it's a real feat to be able to physically rock out on stage as hard as she does, then sing on top of that using the same breath!
@ShUrkaSl thank you for understanding that. and thanks for taking my comments so well. i never meant to personally attack you. what i was doing was simply defending my singing idol :)
original song
TheRealKeith77 3 months ago in playlist Noctus - Sonic Dark
I love her!
iamstarstuff001 4 months ago
hay!!! is its a singer with actual vocal talent!!
JoHannaWaechter 7 months ago
Bear needs Shirley to sing on something dark similar to "baltar's dream".
Icepacalapse 7 months ago
that was awesome...
IChoseTheRedPill 8 months ago
Oh my god.
klined 8 months ago
wow
materialgirl130 9 months ago
excellent babe! love the growl
TheRealKeith77 9 months ago
SHE IS STILL GOOD IN FACT BETTER, IF NOT THE BEST! LOVE HER AND THANKS FOR UPLOADING THIS
jtarantula3390 9 months ago
Such a shame, she's not that good anymore. Wish I was 15 in the 90's.
BlueRhythm64 10 months ago
What a nice video!!! It's like being a band member too! Thanks for the upload!
Videogametube 10 months ago
she is SOOOOOOOOOOO PERFECTTTT!!! ♥♥♥♥
informacionceleste 10 months ago
totally (dry) orgasmic
metalgothcat 10 months ago 2
a real privilege ... that woman is a badass rocker!
zigetgoo 10 months ago
mega wowwwww!!
mrkfitz 10 months ago
i am visitor number 666 !
k3ngarbage 11 months ago
isn't this from the Sarah Connor Chronicles DVD?
<3Shirley<3
<3Terminator<3
IsilionNELE 11 months ago
PERFECT!!!!!! SHIRLEY IS PERFECT!!
CarlosDRMX 11 months ago
I love this video!!!!!!!
Gorgeous!!!!!!!!! Amazing!!!!! In didn't believe that I would see a video od Shirley recording the vocals of a song!!
tembra8 11 months ago
She ROCK
elektra647 11 months ago
oh wow i adore this song but i never thought i'd see something like this :D what a privilege! it's so out of this world actually watching her at work. thanks so much for this upload, you're amazing :)
badbloodopera 11 months ago 5
@badbloodopera I am nothing without the Garbage Tracker website and the people that upload things there for everybody to see and download...
andrea111292 11 months ago
@andrea111292 so you've told me several times, but not everyone would care so much to keep putting up so many videos out of their time for the fans on youtube :D just take it, lol!
badbloodopera 11 months ago
@andrea111292 which site is the garbage tracker?
jtarantula3390 2 months ago in playlist More videos from andrea111292
@jtarantula3390 If you search Garbage Tracker on google it appears as first result!
andrea111292 2 months ago
Comment removed
badbloodopera 11 months ago
Woaaaaa, great voice!!!! Thx Andrea
kacari 11 months ago
SHE ROCKS!!!!!
boburiinchankludho 11 months ago
Great!
Northern5tar 11 months ago
wow!!
shirleymanson09 11 months ago
cool!
Yokonono99 11 months ago
BRILLIANT ... DIVINE ! ! !
lideelo 11 months ago
Love it!! thanks Andy!
jeanselina 11 months ago
AWESOME!
pongue 11 months ago
This footage is amazing! I love Shirley and Bear McCreary. I really loved all the music in tscc but of course... Samson and Delilah was my favorite. :)
Thank you for posting this!
ginnypottermusictv 11 months ago
THANK YOU @andrea111292!
feuds90 11 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
No. She can't sing. Still there is something cool in her timbre.
ShUrkaSl 11 months ago
@ShUrkaSl she can't sing?!?!?! She's an amazing rock n' roll vocalist! What the hell are you talking about?
belcanto87 11 months ago 6
@ShUrkaSl you're kidding right? timbre is what makes the music or sound special- anything that adds to it but can't be pinned down by the concepts of pitch or loudness. and Shirley has one of the finest examples of one of the most beautiful (and rare) 'timbres' of all- contralto. and anyway the evidence is right here! it took me a while to get used to acapellas because there's no support from the music, but it just means you have to listen more carefully to appreciate just how well she sings.
badbloodopera 11 months ago
@badbloodopera
In my opinion, her voice sounds unsteady. And it has always been like that.
I'm sorry, it's hard for me to explain what I mean in English. I love Shirley, but I'd say , she is not a perfect vocalist. She is more of an actress. She can make you feel the song , but sol-fa is not her strong point.
ShUrkaSl 11 months ago
@ShUrkaSl First of all she's an artist, which means she produces a work we can call art. The vocals work. Of course she can't sing a Beyoncè's song, but who the hell cares about that?
andrea111292 11 months ago
@ShUrkaSl yes, i guess you're right in that respect. i do often notice her voice has a certain quaver that makes her pretty much who she is as a singer. she seems to be able to sing more note-perfect in some songs, and in others not so much. but it's what i love about her the most. i'm sorry if i sounded mean. but i admire her so much for that ability she has, to make you feel the song. it's just personal preference. to me, artistry in singing is far more important than pitch-perfection.
badbloodopera 11 months ago
@ShUrkaSl and besides- who, really, is pitch-perfect all the time? probably no-one. and here's another thing. pitch perfect singing on a record, where you've done probably more than one take to get it 'perfect', is one thing. good live singing is another. Shirley's live singing is amazing quality, which shows how great a singer she really is. it's a real feat to be able to physically rock out on stage as hard as she does, then sing on top of that using the same breath!
badbloodopera 11 months ago
@badbloodopera
"it's just personal preference" - Exactly! =)
ShUrkaSl 11 months ago
@ShUrkaSl thank you for understanding that. and thanks for taking my comments so well. i never meant to personally attack you. what i was doing was simply defending my singing idol :)
badbloodopera 11 months ago