Mariah Carey - Bye Bye (Live @ Good Morning America)

[ILoveMcWhMj4ever]

I Love you From The Bottom of my Heart!!! fantastic peformace especially being so early... You are the best singer on the entire Planet... no will ever take your place in my heart.. CRT forever... my hero... even after till the end of time..crt forever

[OKzs]

Still a great performance!

[TwoDeux]

I remember when I first listend to this song SHE SUN SUDDENLY BEGAN TO RISE! Sooo beautiful!

[swiitiichiil]

I can't imagine how it feels without Mariah Carey in the business ? It's just a bread without a butter ! I remember when I was young about 7 I always sing her song " Hero " and I always blame my Mom for not buying her album and now I'm 17 .. I'm 10 years fan of Mariah Carey :)

[itsnotpennysboat]

great live except the pink dress, this is shit, I mean her way of wearing...like 'Im a sweet pink candy" grrrr

on the other hand, this song,with mariah's voice make me cry espiecially today, there are 2years ago, 12.24.08 where my mummy died. RIP Mummy ILY IMY 4ever

Thank to Mariah for this song, it does touch people , and you use to do this with your perfection.

Sweet thing for those people who's just lost somebody.........

[chikorita123]

@itsnotpennysboat awww... :(

[JPhillippeMusic]

this was lipped in parts, the adlibbing in rehearsal is the same in same spot, same texture, same qualiy of sound, volume...cant argue with this one

[ronald3396815]

so emotional

[NekoPetrovsky]

I Love the  "and it´sTRUE ..." at 3:55 and the way she changed the note at 4:05... but it´s obvious that it´s part live part pre-recorded

[acdff777]

why can't she just admit herself that her voice isn't what it used to be? is she delusional that her voice cracks

[ThePumpkin000]

@acdff777 y dnt u get off her fukking bakk for 40 fukking years old i think she sings incredible at that age. u just jealous cause u cant sing like her y dnt u just admit it.

[acdff777]

@ThePumpkin000 I'm entitiled to have my own opinion so wateva

[portfaz18]

DIVA= Mariah Carey

[CharlesLMariah]

IDC wat anybody says Mc my hero is the best Fuckng female singer in the whole world.... I Love her, and She will always be my hero, Her Fucking voice is unbelieveable.... her new cd is fucking amazin all of them are, BUT She doesnt need to prove to anyone that she is the best, Love CHARLES

[wickedassnigguh]

sorry but htere is a DIVA here

shes the number 1 selling female artist of all time with 18 #1 hits so yes shes is a diva

[k9girrl]

Mariah: 'Is somebody goin to give me an intro?'

Diane: 'It's me, right here ....'

Talk about a diva .....

There's none here! LOL

[polute13]

she didn't know that the camera was on..

aha

[themusicking123]

4:05 is amazing!

[5ive6ix7even8ight]

"Are you guys gonna give me some kind of indication as to when we go on", dumb bitch, OF COURSE they're gonna let you know when you go on, if only you didn't interrupt them beforehand with your foolishness! Good voice or not, she's still 'CrAzY' Mariah to me, lmao!

[hollywoodcokewhore]

the song has a very short intro and for live singing this song takes more of an indication thn the 3 seconds given on the album

[KateConan]

She admitted that despite being at this top of fame, she feels embarrassed every single time she's on stage. No matter what everyone says, I love you, Mariah Carey!!!

[JPhillippeMusic]

@KateConan duh and she should be cuz she's a tricky bitch and has back production raising up the track on the hard parts. she's nervous of messing up hence "STOP singing my part now baby...lol classic

[AkiMC2u]

@JPhillippeMusic are you deaf or somethin? try hearing the original song, bitch. you'll see the great difference between this one and the original song

[KateConan]

Mimi is 40. A woman at that age is definitely not as strong and good at singing as she was at the age of 25. I still think she's the best voice ever. Though she can't dance like other female singers, she beats all of them with her unique voice. The most special thing is that she wrote her own songs and they'd been #1 on the billboards for a long long long time.

[craukf]

this live was bad o.O

[ray112244]

exuse me? shut the fuck up! this is great! you thiink your any better? huh? i thought not! no one is!

[nfduan1961]

if this had a bit more vocals then it might just hit no#1. sadly it only got to #19. im reely sad it isnt no#1

[sizzlemytwizzle91]

This should have been at least a top ten hit. I believe there must be alot of Beatles fans in the radio business because somebody does not want her to accomplish what is already inevitable. A voice like this cannot be stopped! MC3 2009 baby! Make it impossible for the haters to complain MC!

[tienanhnguyen]

E=MC2 is a little bit understated for her vocals i think !!! but anyway she is truely freed from her past !!!!

[milat87]

shes just sooo damn beautiful i love her sooo much! mariah fever forever!

[ray112244]

whos better than mariah? anyone? thats right, there isnt! She is and always will be on the top! I love you Mariah Carey!!!

[jesparza562]

i love that note at 4:05

[acdff777]

@jesparza562 you meant the note that cracked when she went bye bye at the end?

[acdff777]

@acdff777 my bad the note she cracked was 4:38 secs

[acdff777]

@acdff777 yes that note at the end where she cracks on bye bye and then trys to cover it up by singing no no no no no no LOL

[turtlyturtle111]

@jesparza562 dang dont she sound good tho. woow beautiful

[liljonjon19]

i love mariah so much,. hope to see her before i leave this wonderful world,.Ü

[ray112244]

This song just proves that its live cause at 3:51 listen and she leaves a huge gap in the song, probably cause she has to catch her breath.

[nfduan1961]

one of her best performances of this song, but i wud sugest to put in a dolphin whistle, that mite have made it a number 1 hit. i luv u mimi! U ROCK AND ALWAYS WILL!

[MusicLoveJaack]

Why did leona lewis come up on a mariah video?

[KerrSmith8]

Mariah is mariah, Leona is leona. Well leona might be good. But she's like a copycat. Besides she only sings whatever crap that the producer ask her to sing. Whereas Mariah writes her own materials and she produced the songs!!

[kellmarryme]

I agree with you.Mariah became the best seller with her own compostitions while Lewis does what Cowell and Davis want her to do.People like her and Carrie Underwood say that they listen to the gurus because they know what's best for their career.Well, maybe, but I highly doubt that Lewis and underwood will ever be called artists.

[marvelucla]

this song i personally think would have reached #1 in America if it was released before christmas cuz thats when people really miss them most, i know i do

[michaeljlailaty94]

OMG she sung this so beautifully I LUV HER!!! I hope she comes touring to Australia I really luv her album and her old music!!

:) love u, u have the best voice!

[PBax94]

Mariah! u r amazing!!

[iwntubadd9]

"i enjoyed you profusely" bahaha. that made me crack up.

& notice how she VERY carefully walks up the 3 steps due to how short her dress is & her shoes.

don't get me wrong, i love her.

[rui19]

her voice is not the same as it used to be a few years ago.. but still good

[jhensonrae]

boring? ypu call those songs boring? leona? mariah is mariah before leona appears. no one can kik her ass. she's so good. and it's not always about the high notes, it's also about the message of the song.

[silverside1]

What I've heard of her album so far sounds really boring and unchallenging for Mariah. I mean it's Mariah Carey for god's sake and she's singing all these boring, flat songs that don't seem to take off. I just don't get it. She deserves to have her ass kicked by Leona Lewis in the charts.

[YoBoIcHiNo]

hahahahah deserves to get her ass kick by Leona Lewis in the charts???? does it look lik shes going to make it as far as Mariah Carey is?? Yeah i didnt think so. No one can replace Mariah thats why shes the best and got 18 number one hits and more to come!

[kbgroupie]

Yeah you're an idiot. Regardless of whether she has 18 number one singles or not, her new songs are shite. I'm a fan of Carey or of Leona Lewis, but have a big enough mental capacity to construct a counter argument.

[MusicLoveJaack]

I agree with you on the part that the album isnt very challenging for mariahs voice. But like shes said, this album is like the desert, fun and playful.

[BGrade15]

I wish she'd done that whistle note.

[nfduan1961]

me 2

[iheartmuzic]

The "too you" (4:04) is so sexy.

[iheartmuzic]

The "too you" is so sexy.

[Minotti020]

This performance is the best... Love you Mariah!

[Monella07]

im so happy to see her again..

look young..

[BINATAKAN]

SHE IS REALY THE GRETATEST!

[lovertoall333]

this is such a deep song full of meaning!!!!

great job!

[ncpapi2007]

This video does not do her justice. It was brighter and lovely.

[ncpapi2007]

I love you mariah and congrats on the wedding. I was there and loved it. I drove 14hours to see her.

[ernstqntr]

go people.. mariah is hot! good voice... and I saw your video singing.. you suck.

[K3nny905]

oops was lookin at someone else's video..but would love to see u post a video of urself singing and then we can be the judge

[K3nny905]

LOL dude, i find it funny that u would give mariah singing advice. I just saw your video of u singing alicia keys's "no one" and ur in no position to be criticizing anyone..ESPECIALLY mariah. Dude u suck..lol..i can't believe u have the nerve to criticize mariah.

[B40H4nL0v3r]

mariah is sooo good when she sings in her albums and then wen she sings live there is nooo difference!!! like miley cyrus she sings better in album and then live she sings soo horrible!!!!! MARIAH ROCKS!!!

[18mariah]

she's great cos singing as early as 9:00am is very hard!

go mariah more p0wer!

[ernstqntr]

awesome

[luizusa]

I was thereeeee!!!

I LOVE U MARIAH!!!

[Lexierox55]

U were there! Were u in row 1

? Di u meet her! LEave me a messege in my inbox: Lexierox55\

[balco1983]

thank you mariah, God bless you!

[rellab15]

u can barely tell the difference between her album version, and her live version...wow....

[lordmykhel1222]

num1.. MARIAH IS THE BEST! ! ! haters go away! ! !

[ilovelctr]

Her voice has become far better after recovering from the mental sufferings. ^^ So glad to see now she sings live performances almost as well as when she first started in 90's. And she's managed to get much slimmer!

Just go on, Mariah! You're always one of the best vocalists on earth. We'll love you forever. <3

[makeitlast4life]

her voice's getting huskier, but that makes me love her more!!

[ernstqntr]

her album is number 1

[emmoichoi]

good.. her album is # 1

[ernstqntr]

good.. her album is # 1

[nhanv313]

Oh....but she generally sounds good...though.....

[bryan251979]

AMAZING as ALWAYS! its SUPER LIVE! GOOD JOB MARIAH! BEST PEERFOMANCE ever!!! BACK OFF STUPID HATERS! GO SUPPORT MADONNA! HAHAHAHA

[ernstqntr]

Important thing is that she still can record good album.. by the way is number 1 in the bill board..

[Rihannarobynxx]

I mean I can understand why she won't get rid of them.

[Rihannarobynxx]

I have nodules and I'm not getting rid of mines because if I do I want be able to sing. So I can't understand why she won't get rid of them. She still sounds good. She still same the same.

[initochanchan]

i love this performance! I love you Mariah

[ernstqntr]

awesome.. those guys that get here to critics mariah.. they just suppor her because this video or others have more views :)

[cici1618]

this goes out to "embryo813". You know what I hate when people hide behind "love" as a basis to spread "hate" and "negativity". If you were truly a MC lover you would know that mariah's voice is a gift from God and nothing or no one can take it away, "somethings are just like fine wine it gets better with age" and if you listed to her Emancipation of Mimi CD you would know this. My guess is that you know that your "singing career-ha" will never be as "relevant" as Mariah. THIS I ENJOY!!! BYE BYE

[initochanchan]

thank you! I love you hehe.

[nhanv313]

what are you guys talking about?....how come mariah has "poor" techniques...when she sounds so beautiful....?...i'm so confused....what are nodules...?....can you actually hear them affecting her voice?....mariah has a nice technique....to mee..

[initochanchan]

Mariah's voice is the way it is because she has nodules since she was a child.She just said it in an interview (technique or not, she'd have had problems). She doesn't want to remove them because she'd lose th texture it has. She still sings beautifully

[ernstqntr]

awesome.

[thatchickmimi]

it's so 100 percent live!!!!!i love her!!!she can sing it live!!!the high note is clear!!!

[ambetthebutterfly]

she's been sing all her life.... almost every literal time...., belting and hitting the impossible highest notes in this freaking world!! so!!!!, Don't expect her voice to be the same as 15 years ago!!! Ulul!!

[ernstqntr]

awesome .. the best.

[ernstqntr]

awesome.. this is my favorite one from all ..!

[initochanchan]

Are you talikng about this performance??? OMG This is wonderful, are you deaf?? so go listen to Beyonce as much as you like, jump like her and do crazy faces like her. We like Mariah Carey.

[tottfries]

Mariah is so spiritual, God bless Her!

[richmariahemancipate]

She looks stunning as usual and to haters out there, Lmabies won't say bye bye to you..

[ceazar]

sana kc next time pag kakanta xa sa mga shows sana kumanta xa ng 100% live kc ang panget pakinggan ung mga iba nyang kanta.50-50..50%live 50% LIPSYNC..

[ambetthebutterfly]

ulul!!

[ceazar]

anong nangyari sa last part parang kinain ng tape ang boses nya...

[ambetthebutterfly]

please speak in english, dahling, so your questions will be answered.... R u freaking deaf...Or, you just really don't have knowledge of what is live and lipped...! This is 200%% live!!

[ceazar]

you know i love mariah songs because almost of her songs are beautiful..her voices only sounds good in studio versions almost...but in her some live performances i am not satisfied...do you know REGINE VELASQUEZ she can sing all songs in LIVE..TRULY LIVE PERFORMANCES...

god bless us all....

[whitireia]

Too bad Regine copies everyone elses music

[codydunn87]

Wow. I liked this a lot! I like that it was different than the album version. It was more emotional that way I think.

[emancipation84]

beyonce? slut..n e way, let beyonce sing Mariah songs since 1990, and sing it live for more than 20 years, at a point i wanna see whether she still have da voice?? Got it?? Please compare mariah old performance with beyonce's current one. Its fair..anyway, mariah rock!!!

[LuvMCMIMI]

terrible like you !

[parkerdude2003]

clean your ears out.

[eteenn]

People can be so unforgiving. You should try to sing a Mariah Carey song at 8:30 in the morning and see how many notes you can carry.