The cymbal crash at 1:21 is the best part ... otherwise, the performance is so- so. Whats's better? Zubin Mehta LA Phil 1976 is the best (tho' the recording engineers of that excellent performance did not record that cymbal crash loud enough). Other (better-than-Abbado) performances of Mahler 5 are: Solti/CSO/1970 and Levine/Philadelphia/1977.
That one "idiot", guys, had opinions different from your own. Respect it... Even if the whole world thinks something is great or true, there is always going to be someone with a different way of thinking. Kind of like Galileo.
This is actually the first version of Mahler's fifth that I heard. And I've since become an avid Mahlerian - and still this is far and away the best I've heard of the 5th. Impeccable!
@1337evan, when I was in 19 yrs old, I played 2nd violin in the Chicago Civic Orchestra, (which is an amateur training orchestra whose members often advance to the Chicago Symphony Orchestra) and had the opportunity to be conducted the Mahler's 5th by Claudio Abbado. He didn't make hardly any stops, just conducted all the way through. I remember he had wide swinging arms in his conducting which was dramatic. I don't know if he was a magical experience .but he had a thick Italian accent
Still....depressing music...
rihannalover93 6 months ago
@rihannalover93 but then there is the finale rondo which is one of the happiest movements in classical music.
jin12345678 6 months ago
@jin12345678 Strange,what I am hearing is laughter through tears ,even in this movement....
rihannalover93 5 months ago
ahhhh the tympani at 0:30, followed by that inspired horn lick that comes out of nowhere
astrophilip 6 months ago
Comment removed
astrophilip 6 months ago
reinhold friedrich is THE BEST principal trumpet player of any orchestra that ever exited. sorry bud herseth...
now5230 8 months ago
@now5230 Strong words indeed. I think that you'd have a hard time convincing many people with this statement.
PINCHUNO 8 months ago 2
The cymbal crash at 1:21 is the best part ... otherwise, the performance is so- so. Whats's better? Zubin Mehta LA Phil 1976 is the best (tho' the recording engineers of that excellent performance did not record that cymbal crash loud enough). Other (better-than-Abbado) performances of Mahler 5 are: Solti/CSO/1970 and Levine/Philadelphia/1977.
h0ll0wm9n 8 months ago
My dad had the great experience of working under Abbado a few times with the CSO, including a great performance of Tchaikovsky's 6th symphony.
Maazel456 9 months ago
Better than Chicago and their silly way of playing Mahler (Solti).
GregHales 9 months ago
@GregHales false
Benefactors 9 months ago
@Benefactors true
GregHales 8 months ago
LOVE 0:32 !!!
SchwarzeDose21 10 months ago
Comment removed
omri967307 11 months ago
Comment removed
omri967307 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is arguably the greatest 2 minutes and 33 seconds of music ever performed.
bandgeek00726 1 year ago
Comment removed
bandgeek00726 1 year ago
Abbado is Mahler's man.
LordMgls 1 year ago
I LOVE THIS
now5230 1 year ago
Es lebe die Freiheit!
Es lebe Claudio Abbado!
robertrstevens 1 year ago
It does not matter where is the conductor from, if matters if his technique is good enough , Abbado is a masterpiece a great Maestro indeed!
ritty2952 1 year ago 3
That one "idiot", guys, had opinions different from your own. Respect it... Even if the whole world thinks something is great or true, there is always going to be someone with a different way of thinking. Kind of like Galileo.
Apples1006 1 year ago
This is actually the first version of Mahler's fifth that I heard. And I've since become an avid Mahlerian - and still this is far and away the best I've heard of the 5th. Impeccable!
LazarusErlking 1 year ago
Euroarts when will be available in blu-ray 2pcm 24bits, with introduction - Mahler anniversary - ,please Medici tv - Mahler symphony 7 too !!!!!!!!!
pauloalfredo100 1 year ago
who is that idiot who can wote "dislike" to a masterpiece, like this??...:(
Saanyooo 1 year ago 2
@Saanyooo He or she probably missed the button
sebastianrc 1 year ago
@Saanyooo Sadly, the world is full of such idiots. I could no more say I disliked this symphony than I could say I dislike my left arm.
ChuckyJesus666 1 year ago
ONE of the GREATESTS MAHLERIAN ... CLAUDIO ABBADO ! Almost all recordings of Mahler's symphonies are stunning & unparalleled ! Bravo Maestro !
BRAVO !
sam0xin 1 year ago
reinhold friedrich!!! alter schwan!
MrGoldentrumpet92 1 year ago
@1337evan, when I was in 19 yrs old, I played 2nd violin in the Chicago Civic Orchestra, (which is an amateur training orchestra whose members often advance to the Chicago Symphony Orchestra) and had the opportunity to be conducted the Mahler's 5th by Claudio Abbado. He didn't make hardly any stops, just conducted all the way through. I remember he had wide swinging arms in his conducting which was dramatic. I don't know if he was a magical experience .but he had a thick Italian accent
freeqwerqwer 1 year ago
Abbado.. one of the bests..
staynvale 1 year ago 2
这是我听过的最热血沸腾的版本 圆号和小号吹出了乐曲的高潮
WangHantrumpet 1 year ago
Epic trumpet playing in this performance
alonshofar 1 year ago
does anyone have the link to the first half of this performance? i cant find it anymore
now5230 1 year ago
oboe player EPIC SOLO at 1:52, lol.
humor aside, this is one of the best performances of Mahler I've seen.
flamingdingleberry 1 year ago
but the thing in the video is that the bass drum part cannot be heard
Pr0k0f13v913 2 years ago
this is definitely one of my favorite recordings on youtube along w/ the chicago and berlin versions
tubadavid123 2 years ago
his recording with the berlin phil is even better than this! but this is still phenomenal! :)
Pr0k0f13v913 2 years ago
Absolutely stunning, bravo, maestro Abbado.
mahler151 2 years ago 4
Abbado is one of the greatest conducters......
Johntcb 2 years ago 37
I absolutely love lucerne, and also Reinhold on solo trumpet!, brilliant!
Trumpetism 2 years ago 4
One of my life long dreams is to be conducted by Maestro Abbado, playing Mahler 5... or any Mahler symphony for that matter.
1337evan 3 years ago 27
@1337evan me too!
lbrinin1701 8 months ago
stunning!
ziogustav 3 years ago 6