Kelly Clarkson- Because of You live at Echo

[nelsoooon22]

Made up lyrics were just as good!

[Indiebanana]

Omg she forgot the lyrics! Hahaha! but managed to cover it up! She's awesome! Who cares if she's fat or not? She's such an inspiration to all!

[samantha0605]

lol did she just make up words as she went along? freaking epic :D

[sofiMADMONKEY]

Schön !!

Weiss jemand wo ich die schlagzeug partition davon her krig ?

[97198037]

her hair is pretty here~! which color match her most? her dark brown or her blond?

[schnakenschnulli]

bester Echo-Auftritt ! ♥

[The197boy]

its so budeful wehn i listen to that i a liddlebit sad and fireflives in me I LOVE IT :-)

[hninaung]

I love her strong vocal!!!

[Quicky1921]

alle die unter mir geschrieben haben sind schwul ! thumps up 

[21ctm21]

HA!!! What a basses just makes them up!!! Wish a I was that cool!!!!

[overluc]

QUE MULHER MARAVILHOSA!

Eu adoro suas musicas.

Quando ouví suas músicas fiquei apaixonado..

Kelly clarkson,você quer casar comigo?

[overluc]

QUE MULHER MARAVILHOSA!

Nossa!..Eu amo essa mulher..A primeira vez que ouví as suas músicas eu disse: pronto achei a mulher perfeita...

Vou pedí-la em casamento.

[funnykellymovie]

looove her eyes at the beginning the make up makes them look even prettier

[panduski]

Hey, my name is Scythe, check out my new latest love single about KELLY CLARKSON called BROWN HAIR / BROWN EYES with lyrics on my channel..

written by me and composed

And if you are liking it.. feel free to spread it around..

Thanks x

-Scythe-

[XxXtinaLover]

Did she forget the words? :-/

[michaellover10]

She's the single best singer ever

[BladeAndSoul]

When kelly forgets lyrics she makes them up instead.

She said that in interview xD:

[MeEnUh13]

u go kelly even if u messed up giiiirl u still the bomb!! luuuv her!!

[MovieMagic01]

There all like wtf at the second verse

[lyricsnmore]

No matter what song she sings, she sing it from the bottom of her heart. Love you kelly=]

[markjowell272]

great lyrics

kelly ur the best

[XenoMiang]

Must be an alternate version she wrote along with the original lyrics. I like it too!

[kellybriannefan27]

love it. she sang it from the heart

[Spitweet]

"I've learned the hard way, that living on was better without you" - LOVE it...wish it was in the original song.

[whattup001]

man she messed up!.. hahaha.. she's so funny,, she always admit it thought,, that's what makes her cool,,

[guiler82]

@whattup001 she didnt mess up.....she has sung those lyrics before on this song.

[d4phn3ch3ung]

i lovee <3 it wen she she says "for tha same damnn thinggggg!" SUCH A STRONG VOICE (:

[PrincessLeslieNC]

you could tell she was messing up because she was so emotional.

go kelly<3

[SBhatti54]

Haahaha I LOVE kelly!!!! She is the best!

[supagirlie303]

i love this!!!!!! kelly rox!

[joycevidad]

AMAZING KELLY CLARKSON FOREVER ....

[kellybriannefan27]

so emotional

[ubnoxis1]

; hl8vjnty

[RFOO6YDEMI]

love her

[VAFAN101]

yea she def. forgot the lyrics but it doesnt really matter

[crazyshorty129]

no she didnt. that was the original version that she wrote when she was 16...the part she sung differently was the part the record label changed for the radio and the album

[hnyoung]

Well, if you listen, it almost sounds like she's spewing out lyrics from a previous version of the song, like maybe the original lyrics before they were changed a bit, as happens with most songs.

Ironic, though, that the stanza she forgot begins with "I lose my way." Yeah, I'll say.  LOL! Good recovery, though.

[harlequinsacrifice]

no yeah she did, she said she always does lol but that the beauty of being a performer right lol

[brujis66]

lol i think she didnt forget it... she just changed it for this ocassion. you should all see since u been gone live at napster its awesome

[TexasCowgirl62]

Being a person of child abuse and later on spousal abuse this is how many abuse victims feel and act!!

[0bla4e]

hahaah she forgot her own lyrics! What can I say.. I just.. love her!! She's the best! <3

[sinaisita]

she's the best

[LitschiegirL]

I love kelly clarkson, her songs are so true..

the way she sings is so amazing her voice makes me feel goosebumbs

[Hangloosebaby]

Oh she´s just awesome!! I saw her live in Melbourne she just rocks and nobody cares if she´s thin or fat!!! I think she´s beautiful the way she is...

[EvFan1985]

from the way she looks here to the fatass she is now

[sonriesmile]

She is important for her voice and music not for her body..

[kingsom12]

what do u mean by fatass? oh please she is not fat at all , i admit da she did put on weight . but even if so.....WHO CARES?? SHE JUST ROCKS!! A WAY BETTER SINGER DEN ANYONE ELSE, REAL , COOL AND FUNNY SINGER , WHAT ELSE DO U WANT? SHE JUS GREAT!!

[Jas93kc]

amazing performance!!those are the original words!

[Charizilla]

She dyes her hair a lot. Meh, she's got a good voice and good taste in music.

[jjenniferberg]

she's singing so damn beautiful !

[d0mm3]

hallo

[vaedalynn]

She is one amaxing performer. And she is gorgeous.

[xXAspennXx]

.........

[tara10987]

did she forget some lyrics? Either way she is great. I thought she forgot them at 1:16

[loessmit89]

I gues... Improvising. She did a great job.

[geurgo]

yea forgot some fo sho i see it too

[vronielectroni]

she looks so pretty... and shes awesome live !!

[davidsonghello]

this is SICK

[crazybanks]

the best superstar of all-time........

[stefan1983berat]

beautifull, love it!!

[3vilcat2111]

ya she change the lyrics.........before is better than tis time

[aamanmoosa]

look at those gorgeous eyes in the beginning!! she is beautiful....

[PoppaLocca]

LoLz she changed the lyrics =D Pretty awesome~

[Arrkadan]

ahhjee was fürn' texthänger ;)

die hat sich bestimmt beim versingen gedacht, ach scheiße, ich dichte ma eben was dazu, das sind ja eh' deutsche und verstehn' nich was ich singe :D

trotzdem gut gemacht,great voice:)

[LivingProof21]

Das ist witzig. Aber so blöde sind wir Deutschen nun auch wieder nicht ;-)

[Andilacus]

first: she looks so pretty!

I think she describes with the lyrics her current life situation!

But -> she sings so good! She's the best and is very very amazing.

[afghanboxer16]

ich singe diesses lied bei das supertalent ich heisse morsal fazel

[brco2003]

I love how the camera tries to avoid her while she is messing up the lyrics. Kelly is the most talented musician living today.

[maxxis405]

what do you mean messing the lyrics up?

[MendMyWickedWings]

i absolutely love this version!!! i love how she changed the lyrics! simply gorgeous!!!

[FeliciaKremser11]

i Love kelly Clarkson

[Shakugan520]

2 tumbs up <333

[TwojjaaStaraax3]

<333.

[grandmasgurl97]

she did not go with the song but it was good?

[shnobunnie]

I love Kelly !!! Such an awesome singer!!!

Check out a Hot band from Vancouver BC. Search for "Brandon Paris Band + Say Goodbye"

<3 Rachel

[markjowell72]

omg she change the lyrics but once again its good and unbelievable thats all i can say and superb and amazing love you kelly

[Apollo4420]

she did change the lyrics here,in some preformances she changes the lyrics for some reason,jus for a change i guess but the orignal real one from when she was 16 is"I lose my way,And it's not too long before u point it out,I can not cry Because thats weakness in ur eyes,I'm forced to fake A smile,a laugh everyday of my life,My heart can't possible break When it wasn't even whole to start with"< i maybe wrong but from videos i've watched i'm almost 100% sure:)

[7thingsilikeaboutuko]

those are right i think b/c the video i watched w/ lyrics had those ones but i'm not 10o% sure

[aminoalex]

one of the most beautiful voices of these times

[month00]

" i look at you and it's not too long before you point it out, i cannot be anything i ever wanted, i lost my way and now i sit and stare without your love, i've learned the hard way that livin on was better without you"

[tgtmhnb]

did she change some of the lyrics?

[Surfgirl3901]

yes

[tgtmhnb]

why? it gives a whole diffrent meaning to the song, what was wrong with the original lyrics?

[yazuack]

these are the original lyrics she wrote when she was 16 =]

[LivingProof21]

Is it "and now I sit and stare without your love" or is it "and now I sit insane without your love" ?

[bustag91]

aww she forgot the words

[freedomii6]

Is it just me or did some verse get added or changed or something??

At one minute ten secs this is what I hear....

i look at you

and its not too long before you point it out

i cannot be (breath?) anything i ever wanted

i lost my way and now it sit and stare without your love

i learned the hard way that livin i was better without you...

I haven't heard that version????

[LivingProof21]

I think it is:

"I lose my way and its not too long before you point it out. I cannot be anything I ever wanted. I lost my way and now I sit INSANE (or stare) without your love. I learned the hard way, that living on was better without you"

[deadprincesskatie]

I love her so freakin' much :) Can't wait for the new single! 'My life would suck without you' out 19th Jan! :)

[KellyokeCrazy]

absolutely love her hair in this wonder how to do it? lol her new lyrics too are awsome amazing that she can do that kind of thing in the spare of the moment :P excellent as always and i think this showed more emotion than the original even though they are both amazing!

[9ooner]

here's from jason halbert's blog:

"Got a couple questions. Why is everyone playing different instuments here? And did she really forget the words? It seems like she changed it on purpose, Or is she really THAT good at coming up with new words when she forgets? LOL --> Anon"

[9ooner]

.: well, a lot of times when we're in europe, they won't let the band play live due to technical issues. so we go into the studio before we leave and pre-record just the band. kc ALWAYS sings live, as you can tell by the 'creative' lyrics she brings to the songs sometimes ... and if by chance she did happen to forget a word or two, she really is THAT good ...

[9ooner]

.: anyway, back to the band, we thought it would be fun since we were just miming instruments anyway, to switch instruments ... it was inspired by a Prince performance on American Bandstand ... we thought it was funny ... the Germans, not so much ...we keep threatening to do it for real one show ... i wanna play bass ...

[9ooner]

( Have to split it coz it's too long n posting here is limited ;P)

[Aubergini]

why does it sounds funny

is she singing an another text or did she forget it

[9ooner]

I think she forgot it...coz you can hear she humming lil bit like she thinkin' n then....voila!!! she make another great lyrics in seconds...amazizing...

[Addicted2kelz]

I love this version.. =)

Whether she messes up a line or whatever.. she always sounds great.. she sung this song perpectly.. has anyone got this version of the song?

[xXxKellyClarksonxXx]

But she forgot the text and fits another text that's not a misarable show great idea kelly!

[nezi2311]

she didn't forget the lyrics...it was totally on purpose :P

[drbotanus]

The phrase Pop is just short for Popular. It goes back to the 1800s when musics popularity was gaged by the sales of the sheet music.

Is it just me or does Kelly keep getting better looking?

[MovieMagic01]

how is this a pop song? pop songs are songs u dance to with ur friends and like britney spears songs this isnt a pop song

[sutarts]

Living always' better without you...

Kelly ROX!!!

[ninfan92]

I seriously doubt that she just "forgot the lyrics", considering she's performed this song a billion times and never done it before. I think that was intentional, she does occassionally mess with the lyrics of her songs in live performances. She seemed to in control for that to just be improv. And if it was improv, then she's really good at improv. lol

[cocodior111]

love it

[phantomgrey]

forgotten the text? is that code for forgetting the lyrics to the song she wrote?

[LucHermann]

She is such a diva.

Damn I got chicken skin cuz of her.. Really amazing and unbelievable voice

[KaeseKuchenxD]

she is brilliant!

she forgotten the text,but she goes on and improvised..respect <3

i love you kelly =)

[Madlen1995]

She forgotten the text! :O

[08Colix06]

My point of view here! is that! she was indeed a brilliant singer and as a performer!!! she handled it professionally! aren't u happy with dat guyz? I guess! when u started loose ur words it will never stops! but she carried it!!! She improvised I think!! in the middle of her PANICKING HEART! it was still amazing! deliveration!! She still deserved to give recognition! A STANDING OVATION!! after that!!

[kevinkelly51]

oh come on guys still kelly is amazinng

[Cynthsam21]

LMAO are her band members in the wrong spots? LOL!!!

[DorothyOverTheRainbo]

OMFG I just clicked favorite a milion times!

I don't think she messed up, but she just changed the words. She seemed to be kinda on the brink of crying anyway so these lyrics were in this case even better than the "I can not cry" part.

I love it when she sings this song with some extra feelinng to it :)

[chorizow]

you could see the emotion in her eyes, especially at the end

[DorothyOverTheRainbo]

You can see the song is written from the heart by the way she performs it. I ABSOLUTELY

[DorothyOverTheRainbo]

love it!

[breehilll]

LMFAO.. that's hilarious

but at least she covered it okay..

but everybody who knows the words was like WTF?

[MellaBellamoi]

come on she's not a robot, people can't be perfect! she messed up one time , so what!?

[Addicted2kelz]

who cares if she messed up or not!! Its Kelly Clarkson, she sounds good what ever! Tbh dont know why people are saying she messed up.. did it not occur to people that she may want to change some of the lyrics?! Its a great version.. and people need to stop sayin she messed up.. coz she so didnt!!

[repentyourselff]

lawlz i love that her band switched instruments

the background music is pre-recorded

[TheHell2008]

She never messed fucking up she obviously changed them on fucking purpose jesus christ are you people really that stupid not to notice.

She wrote it so she can fucking change it which she did.

[repentyourselff]

she messed up

it says so on her piano player jason's, blog

it's obvious, too, she mumbled the first line of the 2nd verse, forgetting what it was

are you really that stupid not to notice

don't get me wrong i love kelly just it's obvious

[mcd309543]

This is a very good song. And it is better because Kelly sang it.

[jokc7179]

They said that when they produce that song , Kelly had already wrote it . So maybe those lyrics were the real one and they've change them with the producers ? Maybe ,or she maybe she just forgot her lyrics !

[narden1]

I just guess she forgot the lyrics :) But she handles it so well

[Pinkin1211]

love the hair, kelly!

[Addicted2kelz]

wow im lovin these other lyrics =) sounds well good.. if anyone has got this song please let me know.. amazing voice amazing person!! Oh yea and the lyrics aint made up.. and even if they were, it would still sound amazing!! Kelly u go gal he he

[kloklo12]

now every body knows that sche is a brillant live singer and songwriter

[Barkseh77]

The only thing that's messed up here is you, you fucking crank.

Rock on Kelly!

[TheHell2008]

the lyrics aint fukin messed up she chose to do somthing different.

[K11Fan]

ich find ihre "textänderung" nicht schlimm...find das eher tollich xD is mal was anderes ....und das jmd mal den text vergisst...ist doch nicht schlimmen ..passiert jedem mal ....vll. war sie nicht so gut drauf..sieht man ihr i-wie an :[

[Kai141290]

oh gott.

[K11Fan]

was 'oh gott' ??

[SportfreundeSiegen]

ist schon peinlich.....bei einem Auftritt im Ausland

[cgbstix]

did she have a stuffy nose here?

[rcdbeast]

i actually kind of like the mess-up lyrics better than the original...

[lernypop]

Lol, me too. It was just interesting to hear something else.

[narden1]

Did u guys notice at the end , she was like almost crying . it's so sad :)

[bonesbroke]

i was suspose to go to her concert but missed it it was sold out

[Jamiedana]

I wonder if the crowd knows English/what she's singing about..

[Franziii1990]

i'm from germany too. and i know what she's singing about.

[Morpheus90210]

Why she did it sing in a wrong way i never heard the text that she sing before.....??????

Strange Singers..............

[Jamiedana]

she probably forgot the lyrics so she made some new ones that fit

[Youka07]

great kelly =)

i think because of you is th ebest song of her =)

[deadprincesskatie]

Can somebody please tell me, what are her lyrics between 1.16 & 1.43

Anyone?!

Please?!

Thanks :)

[bellastar245]

I think she sings...

I cannot be anything I ever wanted

I lost my way and now I sit and stare without your love

I've learned the hard way that living on is better without you

???

[tonyhemi426]

It goes goes like this,She does mumble alittl at the beginning,but I think this is the way it goes."I lived with you. And it's not to long before you point it out. I cannot be. Anything I ever wanted. I lost my way,and now I sit and stare without your love. I've learned the hard way, that leaving I was better without you. Because of you

[brco2003]

Indeed, she screwed up, but Kelly rocks!

[chordvette]

i think it goes like this

i lose my way and it's not too long before you point it out. i can not read anything i ever wanted. i lost my way and now i sit and stare with out your love. i've learned the hard way, that living is always better without you.

[narden1]

But i don't understand one part " i can't read " ??? i mean .............. what does it mean ?

But she didn't screw up at all , because the " messup up lyrics " r so great and emotional especially the part" i've learned the hard way, that living is always better without you." and it shows how amazing she is as a songwriter becaus e she created these lyrics just at once and this is great talent

[callandorwot]

She said "I cannot BE" not I can't read

[narden1]

haha someone said that she said " i cannot read " hahaha thanks anyway , it makes sense now :)

[TheHell2008]

i thought it was living on is better without you????

[narden1]

i dunno , maybe that too :D cause my first language isn't english :)

[Jamiedana]

it's I cannot be anything I ever wanted..this makes more sense

[filfab19]

love this song soooo much!

filven

[daydreamer191]

yeah she does looks stunning, but the crowd is like " huh? wtf?" they are all motionless, stiff, boring. no one practically moves.

[kiogah]

ela eh tudo d bom msm....

essa musica foi o maior sucesso de sua carreira...

because of you estava em todas as paradas de radio do mundo todo....

por isso foi a cantora revelação do mmento....

parabens kelly!!!!!

[irelandaoife]

ok, screw the lyrics change... who cares, if she forgot or if it was intentional.. the lyrics still fir perfectly in the song!!

SHE LOOKS STUNNING!

[o0ber]

Even if she forgot the lyrics (which I do believe she intentionally changed), it would be really impressive that she was able to improvise the rest after messing up.

[WhopperBuzz001]

:O

she melts me away every time

[KCrules123]

She didn't forget the lyrics. I saw an interview with her, and somebody emailed in and asked how come she always changes the lyrics to this song, and she said that she usually gets bored with singing the same lyrics all the time so she likes to change it up. I think that she also said that different lyrics sometimes sound better with piano and some lyrics sound better with guitars. Whatever. :)

[23socks]

Yeah....but isn't this the only time she has changed the lyrics to this song? If not, what other time. It is still great, but I think she forgot the lyrics for a sec and improvised, which actually proves how great she is. but at 1:18 she seems to hum a few lines like she can't remember what to sing and immediately following she "changes" the lyrics.

She forgot them! :)

[KCrules123]

I know she's changed the lyrics before, but not as much as she did here..but I see what you mean about her humming the lyrics at 1:18. I guess we'll never know unless somebody askes her. :)

[totallycharmed]

i dont think she forgot the lyrics 

i think she changed them before hand

and forgot that she did

she eventually remembered lol besides that she still did awesome

[mizzmanc]

did she forget the lyrics

[unspokenbond]

She looks and sounds stunning!

[eheath]

Her voice and song have so much emotion in them shes got me in tears

:'(

[EmoRockBarbie]

how GOOD* she had done. xD sorry

[EmoRockBarbie]

I saw it at the evening she sang it.

i was shocked, I gone she had done!

I had to cry O.O really!

I LOVE THIS VERSION. <3

[cortnan]

she sounds like shes gonna cry :(