the fisrt time i'm listening and watching your video, the song ring me a bell. I can't remember where and when I heard it and now I know, I had to play this sketch for Xmas at the church.
Sorry i can't speak english very well but i can say you this, your clip is very perfect, it's beautiful and i love it ! <3 ;-)
Where on earth is the love button?! This is too beautiful. And you're so cool for receiving a comment from Vic. Congrats! I love that you used both animes here and that you used the Resembool Trio. This is wonderful!
THAT WAS AMAZING! I LOVED IT AND I LOVED HOW YOU ADDED THE LYRICS IN THE VIDEO AS WELL! (the rhythm of the song made it perfect for you to do that....would it be rhythm? idk haha!) BUT I love that song and that anime! I was a beautiful combination and beautifully made!!!! Can't wait to check out more of your videos!!! XD
The fact Vic himself spoke highly of this shows it's true class, I love the song but you made it better by the great emotion mixed with the visuals, you should be proud of this masterpeice
This is the best FMA AMV I have ever seen (and I've seen a lot)! I wish I could like this a million times, this is my favorite song and you depicted the anime so well with the song. 4:00 part was planned out so well! it was my favorite part!
Gorgeous song, beautiful trio, and perfect anime!
And amazing that you got a comment from Vic!
:D
I absolutely love Fullmetal Alchemist and Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood. And I especially love Edward and Winry as a couple. I was ecstatic to find out that Edward and Winry end up together! And I'm always happy to point out that I am a proud Winry cosplayer. It's my life and my oxygen! Well hobby wise anyways. :3 <3
This is so beautiful, I mean it. It's gone everything you'd want in a video of them.
I love it, there's no words for how wonderful this video is, and being commented by Vic, that's somehting to be proud off, not a lot of videos get his comments
You truly deserve to have many fans, I hope many more people see this vid
Seriously, this is the best anime AMV I've ever seen. Ive watched the HD version like 15 times now, and I still tear up at the chorus. I'm commenting here because it has more views. You could not have done a better job with effects, scene-choices, timing, the quote at the end, and the song is perfect. This video is perfect. You have a gift, and I wanna see more.
ohhh..........my goodness..........*subscribes, thumbs up, favorites, etc* this is so amazing!!!!! i'm only upset because i havent finished the series yet so i cant finish this video until i finihs brotherhood!!!! but . . . i dont have the words this is pure MAGIC thank you so much i SO have to finish brotherhood NOW :D
Thank you for making this video. =) I like FMA ALOT and I love my brother as much as Ed loves Al,so this song brought up all the feelings I have for my brother and my loved ones,so THANK YOU SO MUCH! =D You did well making this. =)
Oh my...! It's just.. beautiful! It leaves you speechless. It goes through sadness, pain, grief but in the end leaves you with a great warm in the heart. Lovely <3 (and sorry for my horrible english -_-)
This is just gorgeous. <3 Words are failing me right now. You almost had me crying there, and I don't cry easily. This is just so beautiful and so powerful and so emotional and so moving. Thanks for posting this. I love it. :)
Wow...such a nice video. It's really a moving song and it encapsulates the beauty of the relationship between Ed, Al and Winry. The editing is good too. Especially when it picks up pace and you did a great job capturing the moment when Ed and Al reunited at the Gate in the end. Tear worthy ;_;
And WOW Vic commented on your video. Congratulations! That must mean a lot :D
Such a beautiful , well made video, showing amazing emotions.. You've created something so awesome, out of something we all love.... FullMetal Alchemist! <3 Love it!
Oh my goodness, this is absolutely amazing. <3 I can't wait to see more from you in the future!! You should try and enter this into an AMV contest for a convention sometime. It's very moving and beautiful. <333
hi dearheart, this is Miku Tsukino, one of the Risembool Rangers, telling you that you did an awesome job on this video. Oh and congratulations on getting Vic to comment, if that doesn't mean you did a good job I don't know what does, keep up the good work.
incredible. great job. you know, i got my ears pierced exactly like winry's so that i wouldn't forget this show and the lessons i took from it. great tribute
(First of all, congratulations on your comment from Vic! ^^)
Oh jesus. I just had to watch and comment again. Even after watching this AMV a couple of times, I still break down sobbing. Helplessly clenching my fists and crying my aching heart out. This video is everything good, sad, heartbreaking, lovely, admirable, touching, strong and irreplaceable of the bond between these three, in condenced form. It can't get any better than this.
@HolyCowWorshipper Thank you~ <3 Vic is so awesome...and oh my goodness, if you keep leaving compliments like that, I'M going to start crying... *passes tissues around* xD I'm glad to hear I did the Golden Trio some justice. It's not everyday you find characters as awesome or close to each other as them; they deserve nothing less than the best I've got. =3
@Dearheart42 You did a beautiful job on this video... My mom passed away yesterday morning and when it says you are the light I cannot help but thinking of my mother...
@happyLILwierdo Wow, thank you so much! FMA and the "Golden Trio" are very dear to me and I really wanted to do them justice, so I'm glad this became art to you instead of "just" another AMV. That means I did something right. ^__^
@QuothTheRaven24 Yes indeed, I am very lucky. I still have NO idea how he found my AMV out of the thousands on YouTube, but I'm sure not complaining. xD Thank you! I'm happy you liked this!
This was a beautiful AMV! It really moved me and not many have the power to do that. You really showed the bond of brotherly love between Ed and Al and the care, love and devotion between Ed and Winry. Just awesome! :D
@Tonksy57 Aw, thank you! The way I've always seen it, Al and Winry are equally precious to Ed; they complete him in different ways. Two halves of a whole. So I'm really happy to hear I highlighted their relationships well. That's exactly what I was shooting for. =)
This has to be one of the best FMA AMV's out there right now. The song sets the mood of the characters perfectly. You have definatly captured the moment of the three of them. Simply breathtaking, amazing and sweet. Nice One!!! :D <3
@iamkool11223 Thank you!! <3 I've loved this song for a while, but it was only after I read the last FMA chapter and realized how perfect it was for the Golden Trio and the mood of the ending that I got hooked on it. I knew I had to do something with it, or else I'd go crazy. So I did. =3
@Dearheart42 Dude . . . I saw this and all I can say is beautiful. I'm just starting out on amvs--I only have one that I actually like that I made XD and this song really is perfect for them. It kind of inspired me to make one with this song. Would you mind, considering you're my inspiration? I will credit you as inspiration but this song is so beautiful especially for Ed and Al.
I'm sitting here, at 5:30 am, browsing youtube because I can't sleep. Maybe it's because I'm so tired, maybe it's because FMA has a very deep effect on me. I don't know why these characters effect me so much... they're just characters after all. Whatever the reason, I'm sitting here sobbing, but with a smile on my face.
@mignogahnogahnoo Wow...that's high praise to hear, coming from the voice of my all-time favorite protagonist! I know you're a busy guy, so it means a lot to me that you took time to watch this, let alone compliment it. You just put me on cloud 9! Thank you so much!!
And while I'm at it, thank you for everything. Your music, your acting, your shining witness for God, the heart you put into Ed...I see so much joy in you, and it's beautiful. I hope someday I can bless you as you've blessed me. =)
FMA is just the most unique and beatiful anime that I know. It's just simply amazing - and you put all that epicness into this one vid. So, how could it not be loved? Beatiful, just beatiful.
This is too much for me to take in! It is absolutely brilliant! It honestly gave me goose bumps when the music started to accelerate, while in the beginning I was overwhelmed by such strong emotions! And I also agree with you, the anime's ending gave me a feeling of happiness, of ..peace and quiet..if I make any sense ^_^. I just wish I could have seen a kiss between Ed and Winry..maybe this saddens me a little bit. Anyway...FAVES! :D
@bebe4styll Aww, thank you so much! *warmfuzzies* I put a lot of love into this and I hoped people would feel it, so I'm really glad to hear it touched you so much. (I bawled like a baby when I read the last chapter. Such a beautiful ending...)
And hey, we got EdWin BABIES and a /wedding ring/ at the end. That's even better than a kiss IMO. ^__^ Cheer up, my fellow EdWinner! (At least the yaoi fangirls can't deny that it's canon anymore!) =P
LOL I agree! Babies is even better than a kiss. It proves that they're *ultimately* canon. Like Ed won't run off with Roy in the future or anything. *rolls eyes* Besides, it's not just one baby, it's TWO! *squeeeee!*
OK, what is wrong with this computer!?! Why could I write that?!
I'll try again:
It's MsLinn from the fma forum, I just have to comment here too! It was so brilliant! ;_; So soothing in the begining and so epic in the end. It made me cry, and smile. Thank you fo the text, it was beautiful and made me, the non-english person, apprieciate it easier, if that makes sense.
the fisrt time i'm listening and watching your video, the song ring me a bell. I can't remember where and when I heard it and now I know, I had to play this sketch for Xmas at the church.
Sorry i can't speak english very well but i can say you this, your clip is very perfect, it's beautiful and i love it ! <3 ;-)
excrim2 1 month ago
Where on earth is the love button?! This is too beautiful. And you're so cool for receiving a comment from Vic. Congrats! I love that you used both animes here and that you used the Resembool Trio. This is wonderful!
Mayeoli22 1 month ago
so beautiful, one of the best i've seen
grammarphail93 1 month ago
and after 1000 times, i still love it xD <3
DinosaysRaw 2 months ago
and after 1000 times, i still love it xD <3
DinosaysRaw 2 months ago
Beautiful! I love it! ♥♥♥ +
Lawliet1177 3 months ago
Beautiful!!! Full of heart! Keep creating! Thank you and thank you, Arakawa!
Eowyn47 6 months ago in playlist Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood- the best amvs
THAT WAS AMAZING! I LOVED IT AND I LOVED HOW YOU ADDED THE LYRICS IN THE VIDEO AS WELL! (the rhythm of the song made it perfect for you to do that....would it be rhythm? idk haha!) BUT I love that song and that anime! I was a beautiful combination and beautifully made!!!! Can't wait to check out more of your videos!!! XD
Cha0ticAng3l 7 months ago
It is just wonderful *o*
EveryMiranda 8 months ago
What software did you use to make that video?
please answer me, I was really cute
Anri230 8 months ago
its brilliant mate!!
dangerardo80 8 months ago
The fact Vic himself spoke highly of this shows it's true class, I love the song but you made it better by the great emotion mixed with the visuals, you should be proud of this masterpeice
TamaRanEd 8 months ago
This is the best FMA AMV I have ever seen (and I've seen a lot)! I wish I could like this a million times, this is my favorite song and you depicted the anime so well with the song. 4:00 part was planned out so well! it was my favorite part!
mmproh 9 months ago
This made me start crying.
Gorgeous song, beautiful trio, and perfect anime!
And amazing that you got a comment from Vic!
:D
I absolutely love Fullmetal Alchemist and Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood. And I especially love Edward and Winry as a couple. I was ecstatic to find out that Edward and Winry end up together! And I'm always happy to point out that I am a proud Winry cosplayer. It's my life and my oxygen! Well hobby wise anyways. :3 <3
KaoruAyame 9 months ago
This is so beautiful, I mean it. It's gone everything you'd want in a video of them.
I love it, there's no words for how wonderful this video is, and being commented by Vic, that's somehting to be proud off, not a lot of videos get his comments
You truly deserve to have many fans, I hope many more people see this vid
Good luck and great job
yunagirl181 9 months ago
Seriously, this is the best anime AMV I've ever seen. Ive watched the HD version like 15 times now, and I still tear up at the chorus. I'm commenting here because it has more views. You could not have done a better job with effects, scene-choices, timing, the quote at the end, and the song is perfect. This video is perfect. You have a gift, and I wanna see more.
kyorgadorgen 9 months ago
Wow, I've literally got tears in my eyes.
kyorgadorgen 10 months ago
i was gonna make a thumbs down button joke but apparently everyone who's seen this video has a brain X3
Livin4TheKing316 10 months ago
ohhh..........my goodness..........*subscribes, thumbs up, favorites, etc* this is so amazing!!!!! i'm only upset because i havent finished the series yet so i cant finish this video until i finihs brotherhood!!!! but . . . i dont have the words this is pure MAGIC thank you so much i SO have to finish brotherhood NOW :D
i love you for this video <3
Livin4TheKing316 10 months ago
Man that was breathtaking, now I feel like an idiot, because
compared to this video my videos look like shit. but
I don't care cuz this is so outstanding 6/5.
Danston0 10 months ago
dude this video is amazing!!!!! it about made me cry! this is fullmetal alchemist in a nutshell for yah :) pure awesomeness :)
drawingem1993 10 months ago
So. Dam. Perfect. :'D
darkeyeshadowtheo 11 months ago
really, this is a beautiful video. i never cried this much over a video :')
but i am glad i cried, cuz its something meaningful.
sorry, i just cant seem to explain this feeling.
its hard to put this into words..
if only i could make my 'crying moment 'into a video XD
then u would see how fma meant much to me..
and this video definitely explained everything to me...on the reason i love fma.
p.s. congrats on vic's comment! :D
foreverkhin 11 months ago
Thank you for making this video. =) I like FMA ALOT and I love my brother as much as Ed loves Al,so this song brought up all the feelings I have for my brother and my loved ones,so THANK YOU SO MUCH! =D You did well making this. =)
JOHNHELEN17 1 year ago
O.O.........................wow
Shadowhero43 1 year ago
Ok, this one did make me cry.
I fricken love this song.
This song always provokes a rediculous amount of emotional response from me.
and, yea, the way you made it speak for all tree charecters.
JSKLJADSKL:JLSJFLKDFJDK:L
I AM OUT OF WORDS.
UAHH
AcaaraUchiha101 1 year ago
Oh my...! It's just.. beautiful! It leaves you speechless. It goes through sadness, pain, grief but in the end leaves you with a great warm in the heart. Lovely <3 (and sorry for my horrible english -_-)
Sarephen 1 year ago
Aw, so lovely :D I adore it!
HitomiFlowers 1 year ago
I have watched this over and over, and now I suddenly started crying.
This is everything.
YamashitaTheWildCat 1 year ago
what program did you used?
jekysiy 1 year ago
This is just gorgeous. <3 Words are failing me right now. You almost had me crying there, and I don't cry easily. This is just so beautiful and so powerful and so emotional and so moving. Thanks for posting this. I love it. :)
Wolfdemonzz 1 year ago
Wow...such a nice video. It's really a moving song and it encapsulates the beauty of the relationship between Ed, Al and Winry. The editing is good too. Especially when it picks up pace and you did a great job capturing the moment when Ed and Al reunited at the Gate in the end. Tear worthy ;_;
And WOW Vic commented on your video. Congratulations! That must mean a lot :D
Kurisuta1 1 year ago
I'd also like to add, it has me crying after watching it again >_<;;
(SailorMoon)
sailorscout74110 1 year ago
Such a beautiful , well made video, showing amazing emotions.. You've created something so awesome, out of something we all love.... FullMetal Alchemist! <3 Love it!
sailorscout74110 1 year ago
Oh my goodness, this is absolutely amazing. <3 I can't wait to see more from you in the future!! You should try and enter this into an AMV contest for a convention sometime. It's very moving and beautiful. <333
EdoKun519 1 year ago
hi dearheart, this is Miku Tsukino, one of the Risembool Rangers, telling you that you did an awesome job on this video. Oh and congratulations on getting Vic to comment, if that doesn't mean you did a good job I don't know what does, keep up the good work.
-Miku
narutoxsakura08 1 year ago
man this is great. i commented before but really, i couldn't help but say it.
constantina382 1 year ago
incredible. great job. you know, i got my ears pierced exactly like winry's so that i wouldn't forget this show and the lessons i took from it. great tribute
constantina382 1 year ago
(First of all, congratulations on your comment from Vic! ^^)
Oh jesus. I just had to watch and comment again. Even after watching this AMV a couple of times, I still break down sobbing. Helplessly clenching my fists and crying my aching heart out. This video is everything good, sad, heartbreaking, lovely, admirable, touching, strong and irreplaceable of the bond between these three, in condenced form. It can't get any better than this.
HolyCowWorshipper 1 year ago 4
@HolyCowWorshipper Thank you~ <3 Vic is so awesome...and oh my goodness, if you keep leaving compliments like that, I'M going to start crying... *passes tissues around* xD I'm glad to hear I did the Golden Trio some justice. It's not everyday you find characters as awesome or close to each other as them; they deserve nothing less than the best I've got. =3
Dearheart42 1 year ago 5
@Dearheart42 You did a beautiful job on this video... My mom passed away yesterday morning and when it says you are the light I cannot help but thinking of my mother...
HeartlesRose 7 months ago
@HeartlesRose I'm so sorry to hear about your mother. God bless you and your family.
ThePineappleKiller 3 months ago
If you don't mind me asking, what program did you use to make the video?
LadyDragon167 1 year ago
This is such an incredibly beautiful tribute to the entire series...wow....such art. I commend you for making me tear up at the end.
happyLILwierdo 1 year ago
@happyLILwierdo Wow, thank you so much! FMA and the "Golden Trio" are very dear to me and I really wanted to do them justice, so I'm glad this became art to you instead of "just" another AMV. That means I did something right. ^__^
Dearheart42 1 year ago
gorgeous!!! I can't believe vic himself commented on this!!! amazing job~!
Loki8207 1 year ago
This was beautiful! Wonderful job!! Keep up the good work! And you lucky duck... Vic commented it!! :D
QuothTheRaven24 1 year ago
@QuothTheRaven24 Yes indeed, I am very lucky. I still have NO idea how he found my AMV out of the thousands on YouTube, but I'm sure not complaining. xD Thank you! I'm happy you liked this!
Dearheart42 1 year ago
Wow. That was, like, life changing. Beautiful.
RoyMustangFTW 1 year ago
That was just beautiful. I don't know any other way to put it.
And congrats on getting Vic's attention!
AlchemyDetective 1 year ago
OMGAHHHHH LOVE!!!!! 8DD
0renji 1 year ago
This was a beautiful AMV! It really moved me and not many have the power to do that. You really showed the bond of brotherly love between Ed and Al and the care, love and devotion between Ed and Winry. Just awesome! :D
Tonksy57 1 year ago
@Tonksy57 Aw, thank you! The way I've always seen it, Al and Winry are equally precious to Ed; they complete him in different ways. Two halves of a whole. So I'm really happy to hear I highlighted their relationships well. That's exactly what I was shooting for. =)
Dearheart42 1 year ago
This has to be one of the best FMA AMV's out there right now. The song sets the mood of the characters perfectly. You have definatly captured the moment of the three of them. Simply breathtaking, amazing and sweet. Nice One!!! :D <3
iamkool11223 1 year ago 3
@iamkool11223 Thank you!! <3 I've loved this song for a while, but it was only after I read the last FMA chapter and realized how perfect it was for the Golden Trio and the mood of the ending that I got hooked on it. I knew I had to do something with it, or else I'd go crazy. So I did. =3
Dearheart42 1 year ago
@Dearheart42 Dude . . . I saw this and all I can say is beautiful. I'm just starting out on amvs--I only have one that I actually like that I made XD and this song really is perfect for them. It kind of inspired me to make one with this song. Would you mind, considering you're my inspiration? I will credit you as inspiration but this song is so beautiful especially for Ed and Al.
Livin4TheKing316 6 months ago
I really loved it. So beautiful. This song sounded like it so belonged with the series. Awesome job.
83elemental 1 year ago
I'm sitting here, at 5:30 am, browsing youtube because I can't sleep. Maybe it's because I'm so tired, maybe it's because FMA has a very deep effect on me. I don't know why these characters effect me so much... they're just characters after all. Whatever the reason, I'm sitting here sobbing, but with a smile on my face.
Thanks for this, I needed it.
BBonelessStudios 1 year ago
What an absolutely beautiful video. You did an AMAZING job. I think I can speak for Edward when I say.... I LOVE IT :)
vic mignogna
mignogahnogahnoo 1 year ago 144
@mignogahnogahnoo Wow...that's high praise to hear, coming from the voice of my all-time favorite protagonist! I know you're a busy guy, so it means a lot to me that you took time to watch this, let alone compliment it. You just put me on cloud 9! Thank you so much!!
And while I'm at it, thank you for everything. Your music, your acting, your shining witness for God, the heart you put into Ed...I see so much joy in you, and it's beautiful. I hope someday I can bless you as you've blessed me. =)
Dearheart42 1 year ago 43
Faved+ :D
Awesome work there ^-^ wish i had your editing skills!
konohamarutard 1 year ago
FMA is just the most unique and beatiful anime that I know. It's just simply amazing - and you put all that epicness into this one vid. So, how could it not be loved? Beatiful, just beatiful.
Ferunia 1 year ago
I totally started crying at the end. I love this show!!!
QueensMaddHatter 1 year ago
i love fma brotherhood, watching it taught me so many life lessons
and the portal of truth was the greatest idea i've ever seen. i realized how important that symbol is when i finished the series.
thanks for uploading~
NekooChan 1 year ago
that was so sweet, my god, it actually made my heart hurt!
MissMarientose 1 year ago
I wish I could like this a billion times. <3
meepmeepzoooom 1 year ago
Comment removed
Clannah42 1 year ago
This is too much for me to take in! It is absolutely brilliant! It honestly gave me goose bumps when the music started to accelerate, while in the beginning I was overwhelmed by such strong emotions! And I also agree with you, the anime's ending gave me a feeling of happiness, of ..peace and quiet..if I make any sense ^_^. I just wish I could have seen a kiss between Ed and Winry..maybe this saddens me a little bit. Anyway...FAVES! :D
bebe4styll 1 year ago
Comment removed
Clannah42 1 year ago
@bebe4styll Aww, thank you so much! *warmfuzzies* I put a lot of love into this and I hoped people would feel it, so I'm really glad to hear it touched you so much. (I bawled like a baby when I read the last chapter. Such a beautiful ending...)
And hey, we got EdWin BABIES and a /wedding ring/ at the end. That's even better than a kiss IMO. ^__^ Cheer up, my fellow EdWinner! (At least the yaoi fangirls can't deny that it's canon anymore!) =P
Dearheart42 1 year ago
@Dearheart42
LOL I agree! Babies is even better than a kiss. It proves that they're *ultimately* canon. Like Ed won't run off with Roy in the future or anything. *rolls eyes* Besides, it's not just one baby, it's TWO! *squeeeee!*
xMoonlitRose 1 year ago
Ohmy, this is absolutely gorgeous.
Breathtakingly gorgeous.
xMoonlitRose 1 year ago
Comment removed
Clannah42 1 year ago
@xMoonlitRose Oh gosh, thank you! No one's ever said "breathtakingly gorgeous" about any of my FMA videos before... <33
Dearheart42 1 year ago
ill kill ed for having such ugly children.
xxxcoolchickxxxxx 1 year ago
amazing *OO*
what's the episode at 3:42? answer me please =)
SweetChan91 1 year ago
@SweetChan91 It's ep 38 or 39, sorry I'm not more specific...
HolyCowWorshipper 1 year ago
This is just too full of awsomeness!!!!!!!! it really was a beautifull video
FullmetalAnime94 1 year ago
Good amv, really liked the end
MaatiSan 1 year ago
awww its absolutely perfect!!! Made me cry....not many things can do that
the quote at the end literally took my breath away T^T
wickeddance93 1 year ago 2
That is so beautiful~! Amazing how it could make me cry haha, I love it, great job on making this one~!!
AshTheBlackBird 1 year ago
OK, what is wrong with this computer!?! Why could I write that?!
I'll try again:
It's MsLinn from the fma forum, I just have to comment here too! It was so brilliant! ;_; So soothing in the begining and so epic in the end. It made me cry, and smile. Thank you fo the text, it was beautiful and made me, the non-english person, apprieciate it easier, if that makes sense.
HolyCowWorshipper 1 year ago 2
I can't comment for the love of god!!!
HolyCowWorshipper 1 year ago
Hey, its flower-in-the-light from deviantart. Really beautiful video, and I agree with all you said in your description.
AerithHeartillyHope 1 year ago
beautiful, just...beautiful <3
close to indescribable
Strayist 1 year ago
oh can i couldn't agree more ! (to everything you said in the description)
atouchofpoisonx 1 year ago
wow, that was amazing. I loved it.
atouchofpoisonx 1 year ago
That was really beautiful.
Great combination of both series.
KidaLing 1 year ago 2