I personally was not a fan of the books, but thats probably because I have an undying hatred of old english. I will forever despise those thee's and thou's. Loved the movies though.
I think it's stupid how ppl lean towards the movies, rather than the book when the subject of this is brought up. I don't think Tolkien would have loved that his life's work be remembered only as Orlando Bloom as Legolas or Gandalf and Sauron marching in the gay pride parade. Noone should watch these movies until they have read the book has so much more to offer..As much as I love this song I hate how it has clips of the film. I like the film n all but doesnt even scratch the surface of his work
@ToxicFloodBrew Why would you bring up the sexuality of Sir Ian McKellen? Do you honestly believe that when people will hear the title Lord of the Rings in the future, they'll remember Bloom as Legolas and the actor playing Gandalf would be gay? To make a goddamn movie you need some sort of visual aspect, you can't just photograph the pages of the book.
@FrostWinds Ok you're right I shouldn't have brought up his sexual preference. I just hate that most younger generation will never read his amazing works and Lord of the Rings will mostly be remembered by the masses as a Peter Jackson film. I mean there is so much more in the book and so much wrong with the films. Elves never fought at Helms Deep Glofindel bore Frodo to RIvendell not Arwen, I mean yes I enjoy the movies it's just I grew up with these books and then I saw the cartoons.
@ToxicFloodBrew The books are fantastic, what's with the gay pride joke though? Feel free to explain if you're so much brighter than the fans of the films.
@MRDEREVKO He's a fantastic actor and I think it would take a delusion caused by hatred or fear to pretend that his "gayness" was apparent on the screen or got in the way of the portrayal.
@AMpufnstuf Like I said in a previous comment, sorry for the low jab.My whole point was I'm a HUGE fan of Tolkien and hate for his legacy to be lost ti Peter Jackson
@ToxicFloodBrew sooo... go and film your own movie then... I mean not like filming a movie is hard. I worked for the production of TROY as a traslator. You don't have a clue what it takes to film something of this proportion. LOTR is probably the best trilogy ever made and if you don't like it, go watch Harry Potter sir.
@ToxicFloodBrew And then you know there's people who grew up on the books but are no longer able to read because of vision issues and for them? The movies are a life saver because they can still enjoy the magic of Middle Earth.
What is it with people thinking directors can literally translate word for word a book to screenplay, long books, a lot of it not needed, Jackson chose the bits that he wanted to put into a film and what would be best.
@SatanicGaia Gil-galad was in the film. In the theatrical release he appears for about a half second, stabbing an orc at the battle of the last alliance. Dunno if he's got more of a part in the Extended version, or if Tom Bombadil has a part
@OogyTheMango I know I meant I wanted gilgalad to have an scene longer than three seconds, and no tom bombadil is not in the extended versions sadly, peter jackson didn't do lord of the rings justice, hopefully the hobbit will be better and more true to the books,
@SatanicGaia I totally agree, but honestly of all the changes they could have made, taking out Tom Bombadil was probably one of the most obvious. His only bearing on the plot later is that he gives them the Numenorean swords, which enable Merry to help defeat the witch-king--though since Numenor is never explicitly explained, it doesn't matter (unless, like me, you're a hardcore fan). 3 hours doesn't begin to cover LotR but Jackson did the best he could.
@OogyTheMango yes lotr needs to be done as a mini series a feature length movie is no where nere long enough to do it complete justice, also take out elijah wood as frodo he ruined that character
@SatanicGaia Ohman, LotR Miniseries would be awesome :) Mostly the writing, I think, that ruined Frodo--he's way weaker in the movies. Merry and Pippin also, especially Pippin, have become comic relief which was really disappointing
@OogyTheMango well frodo is a wimp sam is the hero not him so that part peter jackson did right it's only elijah wood has a wimpy style of acting and he always seems to be fumbling around or too weak for this task, it's almost to the point where you have to wonder why didn't elrond smack him in the face and say I'm taking this fucking ring because your a pussy, aragorn has daddy issues as well as boromir, gimli isn't near smart enough and legolas is a massive twat
@SatanicGaia I love Sam, as a character. He really is the true hero of the book. I wish they'd made Faramir have more of a role, and make him truer to the book. I agree that Aragorn was too conflicted abotu his king choice--in the book he basically knew it was his destiny
@OogyTheMango And Gimli was turned into comic relief as well. Instead of becoming a true friend to Legolas and a living symbol of the renewed bond between the Free Peoples who finally put their differences aside.
Lovely song - but a question for elf fans: given all the deaths in battles and combat by male warriors, and the fact that elves are immortal, can anyone tell me why there are not many, many more females alive than males? I assume equal numbers of each sex are born.
If you want the song go to cnet.com and search for a youtube downloader that come with a video > MP3 converter, thats what I did anywya. Then you can put it on a cd.
feanor and fingolfin were far more powerful than gil-galad
ruckanucka4ever 2 weeks ago
just waiting for the hobbitt,
jmcfintona999 1 month ago
amazing
darkangelzephyron 1 month ago
It's ANOIS not Aonis!...
Elvarel 1 month ago
I personally was not a fan of the books, but thats probably because I have an undying hatred of old english. I will forever despise those thee's and thou's. Loved the movies though.
DarkStar53535 2 months ago
@DarkStar53535 the mouth of sauron was pretty much the only character that actually speaks using thee and thou. :)
darkangelzephyron 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@DarkStar53535 the mouth of sauron was pretty much the only character that actually speaks using thee and thou. :)
darkangelzephyron 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@DarkStar53535 the mouth of sauron was pretty much the only character that actually speaks using thee and thou. :)
darkangelzephyron 1 month ago
@DarkStar53535 By the way the English in your post leans towards the formal and old-fashioned....
raysteer 1 month ago
I find you amazing...good work
SamMironov 4 months ago 2
The name is ANOIS not Aonis.... You can find them here it's a dutch band by the way making celtic music, so their website ends with .nl
WindowOfMyEyes 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Can anyone tell me where i can buy a CD of Aonis/Anois ?
saftsack11 4 months ago
Comment removed
saftsack11 4 months ago
I think it's stupid how ppl lean towards the movies, rather than the book when the subject of this is brought up. I don't think Tolkien would have loved that his life's work be remembered only as Orlando Bloom as Legolas or Gandalf and Sauron marching in the gay pride parade. Noone should watch these movies until they have read the book has so much more to offer..As much as I love this song I hate how it has clips of the film. I like the film n all but doesnt even scratch the surface of his work
ToxicFloodBrew 5 months ago 17
@ToxicFloodBrew :(
panflutelistener 5 months ago 4
@ToxicFloodBrew Why would you bring up the sexuality of Sir Ian McKellen? Do you honestly believe that when people will hear the title Lord of the Rings in the future, they'll remember Bloom as Legolas and the actor playing Gandalf would be gay? To make a goddamn movie you need some sort of visual aspect, you can't just photograph the pages of the book.
FrostWinds 5 months ago
@FrostWinds Ok you're right I shouldn't have brought up his sexual preference. I just hate that most younger generation will never read his amazing works and Lord of the Rings will mostly be remembered by the masses as a Peter Jackson film. I mean there is so much more in the book and so much wrong with the films. Elves never fought at Helms Deep Glofindel bore Frodo to RIvendell not Arwen, I mean yes I enjoy the movies it's just I grew up with these books and then I saw the cartoons.
ToxicFloodBrew 5 months ago
@FrostWinds I'd just hate to see one of the best pieces of Literature get overshadowed but its Hollywood counterpart..
ToxicFloodBrew 5 months ago
@ToxicFloodBrew The books are fantastic, what's with the gay pride joke though? Feel free to explain if you're so much brighter than the fans of the films.
AMpufnstuf 3 months ago
@AMpufnstuf
I agree the book are fantastic and I would also like to know what the "Gay Pride" quip was about, who cares if Ian M is Gay.
MRDEREVKO 3 months ago
@MRDEREVKO He's a fantastic actor and I think it would take a delusion caused by hatred or fear to pretend that his "gayness" was apparent on the screen or got in the way of the portrayal.
AMpufnstuf 3 months ago
@AMpufnstuf Like I said in a previous comment, sorry for the low jab.My whole point was I'm a HUGE fan of Tolkien and hate for his legacy to be lost ti Peter Jackson
ToxicFloodBrew 3 months ago
@ToxicFloodBrew sooo... go and film your own movie then... I mean not like filming a movie is hard. I worked for the production of TROY as a traslator. You don't have a clue what it takes to film something of this proportion. LOTR is probably the best trilogy ever made and if you don't like it, go watch Harry Potter sir.
felathar1985 1 month ago
@ToxicFloodBrew And then you know there's people who grew up on the books but are no longer able to read because of vision issues and for them? The movies are a life saver because they can still enjoy the magic of Middle Earth.
MeSillyWoohoo 1 month ago
@ToxicFloodBrew
What is it with people thinking directors can literally translate word for word a book to screenplay, long books, a lot of it not needed, Jackson chose the bits that he wanted to put into a film and what would be best.
EshnehGaming 2 weeks ago
i'm crying
TheHellsarcher 5 months ago
I love it, I really love it.
Agnika18 6 months ago
Ya know it's funny, the dwarves are know as the great craftsmen, but I think the elves make much more detailed and beautiful things.
majormcjansen 6 months ago
I love this. Your interpretation is incredible, and I wish I had the talent to do something similar.
Benzeimin 6 months ago 7
@Benzeimin Thank you sir!
panflutelistener 6 months ago 3
Such a mystical song
WargoDsssss 7 months ago
great song
Syrefin 7 months ago
Comment removed
Syrefin 7 months ago
Aonis? Fail
Silverlance988 8 months ago
very very beautiful song and a nice video. even the millennia old gandalf can't hold his tears... :)
xyz4live 9 months ago
That is the song i want to be played at my funeral
Slipsnake1900 11 months ago 2
There are a hundred complaints you can have about the Lord of the Rings movie trilogy.
But you have to understand that, as far as movies based on books go, it's fantastic. Sometimes you have to settle for less than perfect.
StationaryHawk 11 months ago
Very sad sound, does create a great sense of mourning
AB213100 1 year ago
I am so sorry for the Witch-King....I wanna cry :( Dont give a fuck about elves and men
WiseSoul22 1 year ago
JUST BEAUTIFUL!!!
SSJ3Croat 1 year ago
How beautiful!!
Don't elves resurrect in the land of Valinor?
But long ago he rode away
And where he dwelleth none can say
For in the darkness fell his star,
In Mordor where the shadows are.
...For in the darkness shone his star
forever bright where shadows are.
...In Valimar shineth his star
forever bright where Heroes are!
svyatoslavlipsky 1 year ago 7
Beautiful.
Best version is the BBC one though.
Vortex42 1 year ago
One thing I like about this song is how it actually has something of a medieval sound to it, don't you agree?
WhiteTiger950 1 year ago
ThankYou From Tucson,Az
Sanyhte 1 year ago
I wonder why gilgalad, and tom bombadil were not in the movies, especially since peter jackson filmed scenes with them in them
SatanicGaia 1 year ago 2
@SatanicGaia Gil-galad was in the film. In the theatrical release he appears for about a half second, stabbing an orc at the battle of the last alliance. Dunno if he's got more of a part in the Extended version, or if Tom Bombadil has a part
OogyTheMango 1 year ago
@OogyTheMango I know I meant I wanted gilgalad to have an scene longer than three seconds, and no tom bombadil is not in the extended versions sadly, peter jackson didn't do lord of the rings justice, hopefully the hobbit will be better and more true to the books,
SatanicGaia 1 year ago
@SatanicGaia I totally agree, but honestly of all the changes they could have made, taking out Tom Bombadil was probably one of the most obvious. His only bearing on the plot later is that he gives them the Numenorean swords, which enable Merry to help defeat the witch-king--though since Numenor is never explicitly explained, it doesn't matter (unless, like me, you're a hardcore fan). 3 hours doesn't begin to cover LotR but Jackson did the best he could.
OogyTheMango 1 year ago
@OogyTheMango yes lotr needs to be done as a mini series a feature length movie is no where nere long enough to do it complete justice, also take out elijah wood as frodo he ruined that character
SatanicGaia 1 year ago
@SatanicGaia Ohman, LotR Miniseries would be awesome :) Mostly the writing, I think, that ruined Frodo--he's way weaker in the movies. Merry and Pippin also, especially Pippin, have become comic relief which was really disappointing
OogyTheMango 1 year ago
@OogyTheMango well frodo is a wimp sam is the hero not him so that part peter jackson did right it's only elijah wood has a wimpy style of acting and he always seems to be fumbling around or too weak for this task, it's almost to the point where you have to wonder why didn't elrond smack him in the face and say I'm taking this fucking ring because your a pussy, aragorn has daddy issues as well as boromir, gimli isn't near smart enough and legolas is a massive twat
SatanicGaia 1 year ago 3
@SatanicGaia I love Sam, as a character. He really is the true hero of the book. I wish they'd made Faramir have more of a role, and make him truer to the book. I agree that Aragorn was too conflicted abotu his king choice--in the book he basically knew it was his destiny
OogyTheMango 1 year ago
@OogyTheMango
This movie was meant for all types of viewers, thats why they made it like this.
Just like pirates of the carribean, id loved to see it more serious but its made in such a way a large group enjoyos it,
Zeddicus111 1 year ago 3
@OogyTheMango And Gimli was turned into comic relief as well. Instead of becoming a true friend to Legolas and a living symbol of the renewed bond between the Free Peoples who finally put their differences aside.
aemmel1970 1 year ago
I believe it is Anois this band is called, not Aonis. Am I wrong? A beautiful song indeed, and Tolkien was a great writer
SmirkAt 1 year ago 31
@SmirkAt
Quite much the best there ever was.
No one made a world such complicated and complex.
He also "created" the "elven" language,
Silmarillion, including legend stories, red story lines, forgotten tales etc etc everthing the history of a world would need
Zeddicus111 1 year ago
@Zeddicus111
Silmarillion is my bible
kamo124 1 year ago 6
@kamo124
You must be an Elf. ;p
Holmes245 9 months ago
Comment removed
SmirkAt 1 year ago
is there ANYTHING more of them? it's awesome!!!(but "aonis" doesn't get any matches -.-)
Darkenchild 1 year ago
effing A dude!
ertlif 1 year ago
beautiful.
dueldr 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Lovely song - but a question for elf fans: given all the deaths in battles and combat by male warriors, and the fact that elves are immortal, can anyone tell me why there are not many, many more females alive than males? I assume equal numbers of each sex are born.
wen2110 1 year ago
If you want the song go to cnet.com and search for a youtube downloader that come with a video > MP3 converter, thats what I did anywya. Then you can put it on a cd.
TheTwoHunters 1 year ago
I WANT THAT SONG BADLY
ShotokanEditor 1 year ago
Where can I get this song? D: I want it so badly.
tatsuhina500 1 year ago
where do yiou get the first picture in the video?
LOTRLEGOLASFAN88 1 year ago
beautiful song
thanx
*****
Q8Secular 2 years ago 2
beautifle
elwingofwind 2 years ago 4
Super******
piotr3339 2 years ago 3
not so many hero songs now.
TheWoodoochild 2 years ago 32