Other than some blur, I think this is quite an impressive, amazing, relevant video to an INCREDIBLE song. I wish the breakdown of her vocals wasn't cut...as she sings some off notes to the typical chords, but it's beautiful. Great job!
It is a silent anti war song. I saw Garbage live and Shirley explained this is their protest song against the war, the oil, the dying soldiers, etc...
Good pick for your Broadcast Design class, However... you really should finish it since you have more time to work on it. This is a huge song and the lyrical content should be in it's entirety. hope you will finish what you started.
U did so well n the video why did u cut out that part she sing"I wish I wasn't flesh and blood, I would not be scared of bullets built with me in mind, Then I could be saved.
My sweet Lord take care of me, for I think I'm done, Kiss my mother on her check, lay my burdens down, lay my burdens down." ???
This isn't the complete song -- the greatest part of the best song off the greatest Garbage album, the bridge that sent chills up my spine upon first listen, is when Shirley starts with, "I wish I wasn't flesh and blood..." Musically, this is the highlight of the album: her angelic voice coupled with the raw, mechanical percussion. How on Earth could you think that passage could be eliminated and still maintain the integrity of the song?
I didn't see anything anti-american...this is what's happening and u were pretty direct...this was a daring move from u.I loved the video not to mention the song.Bleed like me record was the only Garbage album i ever got and it's one of their best i think!
this is an amazing video........by far one of the best and fairly truthful. anyone offended by this probably doesnt use their brain very much or is very nieve ^_^
i disagree wth what people are moaning about, how that one bit of the song was taken out, i think this video was really well made, very creative and inspirational. good job x
And thus, the voices of a thosand misguided, dead soldiers are lost.
You screwed this up by removeing that part about the flesh and blood and the prayer. Step out of the safe box next time you want to make an unpatriotic statement.You weaken the point of this song, the people who suffer as a result of the government!
I'm guessing this is a fan made video. Very, very well done. Apologize for nothing. Forget the warnings. America is a free speech zone. The more we hide our true feelings and clam up the more the neocon fascists clamp down.
hey man, i really like your video, never said that to anyone before.. feels good. good work x
typhoidL7 4 months ago
i think the dinosaurs are for the oil thing. fossil feul
SuperAssassin117 4 months ago
Love this song so much. Please come back Shirley and Garbage. Love you so much. Your show in SF was the highlight of my life.
MsSmartiepants2 1 year ago
Other than some blur, I think this is quite an impressive, amazing, relevant video to an INCREDIBLE song. I wish the breakdown of her vocals wasn't cut...as she sings some off notes to the typical chords, but it's beautiful. Great job!
barbiboo 1 year ago
Pretty cool video, I must say.
Elefantebailarin 2 years ago
the dinosaurs are telling lies :O ! .. but joking aside i like the statement its trying to make
Foxy1202 2 years ago 6
love the song and the video but what point were you trying to make with the dinosaurs? I don't get it...
tallbrunette09 2 years ago
t is a anti war song, it really is. Idk about The boys wanna fight. That is not as powerful as this songs lyrics. Really listen.
Cherrylips333 2 years ago
It is a silent anti war song. I saw Garbage live and Shirley explained this is their protest song against the war, the oil, the dying soldiers, etc...
Cherrylips333 2 years ago 3
Good pick for your Broadcast Design class, However... you really should finish it since you have more time to work on it. This is a huge song and the lyrical content should be in it's entirety. hope you will finish what you started.
240X 2 years ago
U did so well n the video why did u cut out that part she sing"I wish I wasn't flesh and blood, I would not be scared of bullets built with me in mind, Then I could be saved.
My sweet Lord take care of me, for I think I'm done, Kiss my mother on her check, lay my burdens down, lay my burdens down." ???
Cherrylips333 2 years ago
You cut the song around 2:38 , though it's still good .
And you took it on a more political side.
Well done!
andrea111292 3 years ago
Comment removed
andrea111292 3 years ago
You cut the song up. Booo.
Mythicalnova 3 years ago
Great job! Must be some kick ass software too.
gracesuzi 3 years ago
This isn't the complete song -- the greatest part of the best song off the greatest Garbage album, the bridge that sent chills up my spine upon first listen, is when Shirley starts with, "I wish I wasn't flesh and blood..." Musically, this is the highlight of the album: her angelic voice coupled with the raw, mechanical percussion. How on Earth could you think that passage could be eliminated and still maintain the integrity of the song?
tlinn50 3 years ago
You're an angel to have this song up, it rocks!
vampirewitch3 3 years ago
I didn't see anything anti-american...this is what's happening and u were pretty direct...this was a daring move from u.I loved the video not to mention the song.Bleed like me record was the only Garbage album i ever got and it's one of their best i think!
WAY TO GO~
le0s0n 3 years ago 4
i have to say the girl has this smile on her faqce the whole time maybe you shouldve chose someone that had more serious eyes.
IHeArTrOcK20 3 years ago
pshaw the world isn't round lol love this song
tofurobot8 3 years ago 2
amazing video. good job.
twilightfreak13 3 years ago
wow this video is incredible i love it!!!>>>song too!
IHeArTrOcK20 3 years ago
this was awesome! it's so true that the world is messed up over the battle for oil and shit.
jazzfan4ever 3 years ago 3
this is an amazing video........by far one of the best and fairly truthful. anyone offended by this probably doesnt use their brain very much or is very nieve ^_^
eternalsenseofmind 3 years ago 2
How did you make this movie?
FireIceDown 3 years ago
Adobe AfterEffects for the animation, and Final Cut Pro for the editing.
LordSolaris 3 years ago
that's a really bloody remarkable thing you made, one of the best vid's on youtube i've ever seen
Turquenione 3 years ago 3
I think it's a good video for this song, great job!
goldmedal2 3 years ago
Bloody good job mate!
Top video.
mickyd1234567 3 years ago
9/11 was an inside job
gpx44 3 years ago
great job
rockinpoison89 3 years ago
Love the song lov the video
awesome job!!
1Amaya1 3 years ago 3
Amazing video, i love it, think you did everyone a favor, fabulous job
deadava 3 years ago
i disagree wth what people are moaning about, how that one bit of the song was taken out, i think this video was really well made, very creative and inspirational. good job x
N00D13 4 years ago 8
if i may ask.....what part was taken out?
eternalsenseofmind 3 years ago
And thus, the voices of a thosand misguided, dead soldiers are lost.
You screwed this up by removeing that part about the flesh and blood and the prayer. Step out of the safe box next time you want to make an unpatriotic statement.You weaken the point of this song, the people who suffer as a result of the government!
KryssySushi 4 years ago
Where's the bridge at!? "I wish I wasn't flesh and blood, I would not be scared..." You know, that part?
Paperkut98 4 years ago
I love this video--well done. And it's a shame that you have to put a disclaimer on this.
Ultraviolins 4 years ago
I like this. It could really open up some peoples eyes.
anoll94 4 years ago
Their best song ever!
2eclectic 4 years ago 4
Nice, sets up a good framework of modern times and relates the music and the imagery very well.
MarmotSama 4 years ago
I'm guessing this is a fan made video. Very, very well done. Apologize for nothing. Forget the warnings. America is a free speech zone. The more we hide our true feelings and clam up the more the neocon fascists clamp down.
jdbrown371 4 years ago 5
I think it's a very good video. It reminds me of the same idea behind the video for A Perfect Circle - Bodies.
shcantliff 4 years ago