American Idol Season 9 Andrew Fenlon - House of the Rising Sun

[DESERVANT]

And THAT is why Simon will always be the best judge. I bet Steven Tyler would have liked him as well.

You NEED to put on some sort of act to get noticed. Wish they put him through. :(

[ahoustone]

Andrew was a bit arrogant and then he apologized. Therefore, kara and the others had no reason to react the way they did. They spent a good 90% of the time judging his personality and saying how much he was hated saying has he ever had a girlfriend and to me that is clearly unprofessional. If anyone of those judges were to attempt that crap with me, they would have been black and blue because i would beat the devil out of them and left the bodies on the floor! That was very offensive!

[zufgh]

There is a big difference between going to a record label with a record, performing in clubs and so on, and sitting in a room for hours on end and doing nothing.

[labelmeloren]

He is so hot

[fuzzybuni]

Oh God, I loved how good this guy was.

[MotCatalin]

I hate women like Kara...they really make me angry. She seemed moooore arrogant then him and by the way, is that a professional way of judging?....do we judge the man or his voice?! Simon is right and he understood him. But, anyway, that's how the human female is :)

[angelsbeatlesfan]

He sucked! He kept changing keys...

[letuhieuthien]

and when he took off his glasses, superman just got real

[MrJack0872]

This guy is Being a Fucking Duche bag



[Josefrectum]

he had a kind of cool Michael Buble sound but he was an asshole haha

[Supaduck0]

This man could be the next David Byrne

[Elithecomputerman]

2:59 shut the fuck up kara



[HeartShapeGlasses007]

Big deal, have you seen Simon? -_- Really? He's an ass ALL. THE. TIME. Plus Andrew's very very good and I've never liked Kara, she's always been a bitch

[Time4aKiss]

I thought he was wonderful!

[Cooljoshua567]

the minute he said fairly obvious, i was like -.- well hes fucked

[themrsclaus1]

lol

[chuahsang]

This is why Kara can't judge.. she gets personal with the contestants where she's supposed to be professional.. Bottom line Kara can't judge

p.s Andrew CAN sing

[UserRED13]

What is their problem..? THere have been plenty of artists over time with negative energy or that have been smart-assey that everyone loves. American Idol can shove it; they expect everyone to be this perfect, unoffensive boring person-next-door type.

[540ernie]

But....he could sing

[brunetteDUH]

its so funny how kara asks him a questions and he simply replies hes just on edge from waiting and she goes ape shit ...someone was on her period, thats a fact.

[BigAlbinoDonky]

Lmao....at 2:54 Simon totally has a feeling that it's about to go down by the way he says "thank you" and looks over at Kara.

[78nmartin]

this guy is the best. and kara can shut it

[jackstein104]

lol he's high as fuck.

[ALLINKNOTS]

They hardly judged his singing, they just judged him personally. Lots of musicians are assholes, I think he was just trying to play the part. And I agree, Kara wanted him ("You need a spanking," You're being naughty," "Do you have a girlfriend?, are you married?") Yeah, she definitely wanted him. LMAO.

[nrdjfh]

kara wanted him.

[MrJustlax21]

deep down I think Kara wanted to bang him.

[earthglamgrunge]

Am I the only one who found this just plain funny, and not much else?

[BlackLAHawk]

He had a decent voice, but essentially it is a business competition. Kara seems to get annoyed by unprofessional contestants and he was by far unprofessional. I think many people forget that the competition is a business. You have to ask yourself, if you were interviewing someone for a job and they came off as arrogant or unprofessional, would you hire them? The answer is no. That's just good business.

[isingrandomsongs]

I love this. I just love this. WHY did this guy have to be an asshole to the judges? haha he would have gotten through in my opinion.

[charias72]

Fuck you Kara. I never liked you.

[codykonior]

I still like watching this a year on. I'm still trying to work out if he's a psychopath, or on drugs, or what.

[MegaTrixel]

He was good! Kara was just annoyed that he could come up with better come-backs than her...and to add to the frustration with his suckish attitude he was good. I think that ticked her off.

[sushirollerboarder]

its great when someone stands after a stupid person who thinks that the world is around him!!

[razmatazz00001]

is it just me or does anyone else think he looks a bit like Cilian Murphy?

[robnicol101]

are you fucking tone deaf this guy is on it crazy good

[lemonator406]

bitches 

[XXcookiezNcream]

Where is this guy hiding the bodies! SCREAMS serial killer lol

[trishx95]

I think his was better than the original.

[ShadowsOfBlossoms]

she's actually reading it way to far... that's just how it is if you wait all day. and when kate said he hasn't got the goods to back it up and he disagreed, who would agree? she offended him :/

[normi550]

who is that f*** kara????

[LizLovesLollipops]

Kara and this guy would make a good couple

[aaronhoyos1]

trololololololololololol trololololol

[MissSovietBones]

He apologized several times and still they kept a negative biased about him. As they say - 'Dead on Arrival' - there was something he could have done after that point.

[yaelsprikut]

Fake. Very bad acting.

[MrJoef360]

I thought it was about the singing?

[parisianpancakes]

omg fuck i hate people like this guy, that fucking attitude

[Realkill010]

Kara, learn to put on a fuckin' make-up first.

[mkojic77]

this is a competition about talent and he had one! but i thing the judges said no because of his behavior! if he didn't talk back like that he would definitely passed! btw he has good voice

[mkojic77]

hahaha i love how kara reaction when simon said yes! "You are kidding me!" it was hilarious!

btw i think this is the first time that everybody said no and simon said yes! xD lol

[browseyfillerman]

Karen is a lousy choice for a Judge

[EardrumDreamInfinite]

His voice is seriously to fucking beautiful. Goddamnit.

[RoseyRed088]

somebody's on their time of the month.....anybody got some midol for this guy?

[eskimokids]

pepper

[MEpianist]

I didn't like anyone in this exchange. They're all just describing themselves.

[stylishgal9]

what a cunt!!

[MultiNatester]

That guy is a fucking beast!!!!!!

[steamyboy69]

Geez DIOGUARDI, glad youre not an AI judge anymore. Andrew shouldve went through. I love his cocky personality.

[charias72]

I think that's just his personality. . .

[hjm13107]

i mean he did apologize... so there shouldn't have been a problem...

[anistonlover08]

kara was more immature than andrew here. he just said a few smart ass things. as for kara, she yelled at him, and told simon to shut up. way to be professional there sweetheart.

[blusuck]

5:53 what the hell hapened hahahahhahhahaha

[blusuck]

Clarke Kent

[Mixsweet67]

Kara is freakin hilarious , I looooove her!! :) <3333

I miss her on Idol :( </3

[CityOnaHillStudios]

lol. all these ppl getting mad cuz he got cut cuz of his attitude have no idea what it takes to make it in the business. to make it as an artist, actor or a performer there is a lot of hurry up and get there on time, now wait all day. that's just the way it is and if you can't get through that without effecting the way you interact with people you aren't right for the business.

[sheanie2003]

lovvvvvvvvve

[electricmonkey27]

i loved him! this is why kara got fired. she's such a bitch. ur supposed to judge on singing, not attitude

[electricmonkey27]

i loved him! this is why kara got fired. she's such a bitch.

[Roberto77759]

Hmmmm.......appears to be a case of the next Superman, Mr. Kent.

And actually, it "IS" a case of the next Superman Mr. Kent, it "IS". Amen.

Love always, Robert Michael Crofoot, GOD (an eternal Andrew Fenlon fan)

[whaddupchicks]

she wants his dick sooo bad <33333

[angelzap100]

After watching some of his other videos on You Tube, he's obviously a performance artist. I actually suspected this when I originally watched him but tonight I looked him up.

He should try out for another show, ie, xfactor or next years' idol, but I'd like to see him do it seriously with a more controlled vocal performance

[Aspenfash899]

@angelzap100 yeah he is this was a joke im his friend on facebook lol

[diablo9333]

I hated this because he deserved to get in but they are taking it into personal issues instead of vocal abilities.

[14dorlan]

@diablo9333 he still wouldn't have won anyways

[diablo9333]

@14dorlan I wouldn't automatically say that. One performance doesn't say everything about a singer. Besides I wanted him to get in for justice I didn't know if he would win.

[bantermelon]

clark kent

[MrLemonfeet]

HAHAHA he was like 0_0 a spanking....

[BigDaddyJohnson]

His exit...LOL. Walking away while staring and smiling really creepy.

[loveingPATD]

OH MY GOD!!! What the hell! He was one of the best singers on the show and he didn't even do anything! He was probably stresses all day and waiting didn't help! Sorry Bitch but people get nervous!! And yes you should take a shower because your dirty from all the shit thats coming out of your mouth!

[LovePeaceErin]

He's kinda hot...

[Dmoore2084]

UR INSULTING THE GUY AND UR MAD CAUSE HES REACTING?!!!!!

[DAISYDUKESnRAINBOOTS]

oh, and i love the way simon is able to give an unbiased opinion no matter how much he dislikes someone.

[DAISYDUKESnRAINBOOTS]

i really dont think he was trying to be rude on purpose. i think hes just socially immature.

[aarongonzalez5]

I totally agree with Kara!!! She's right there are people waiting years to get on AI but he's mad cuz he had to wait 3 hours? Come on! STFU! He was alright but would have fallen out in Hollywood!

[crazydavebylaw]

You need a spanking? Seriously?

[crazydavebylaw]

Actually thought his performance was ok, great song choice and a pretty good voice.

[heytherebrotherbear]

I actually thought he did pretty good.

[shiguaman]

he's actually not that bad for a singer who's that pissed

[shiguaman]

he looks like superman

[dainius311]

@shiguaman haha i thought i was the only one who saw that

[WDRWHLLDY]

Who is Kara DioGuardi?

[sirmateo75]

HIPSTERRRRRR.

[Unfappable]

super man.

[Jamiebitchxoxo]

ahhh i loved him. haha he should have went through. lol n i hate kara

[deidah00]

he's a dick!

[zigzagcatzanddogz]

Kara pulled a paula

[jackstein104]

"you don't have the goods to back it up"...????? and a half corpse half english barbie doll does??

[vivalabraggs]

i think the judge shouldve shut her mouth and andrew shouldve learned how to be somewhat weasonable and less cocky

[jamesandjackproducts]

PEPPER DREAM TEAM

[morganite100]

anyone knows what happened to him I think that he's so unique and very charming in a strange way

[XCutePupa]

he is fucking awesome

[Drubylynn]

I love the song as he leaves. haha. & i love himm.

[GRAVVVES]

mushrooms

[cateyall]

Pepper <3 

[friedrichsalzmann]

He is trying to be cool and totally offends them

[dinomanj]

i think he had a great voice and should have went through cause he added his own flavor into the song

[dearbriellex3]

he has a nice voice tho.

[muffinmarisa]

Kara wanted him

[muffinmarisa]

victoria looks really weird all anorexic. she was prettier as Posh Spice when she had meat on her bones.

[drunkenhazernut]

It was not the rivalry in arrogance that sir Simon took an interest in young Fenlon. It was the boy that opened his eyes and made him smile in admiration.

[drunkenhazernut]

This time the judge made a mistake: They evaluated andrew's attitude in a talent show.

[selfishlyranting]

oh shut up kara

[sahba96]

kara pisses me off get the fuck out of here, victoria shut the fuck up who do u think u is. he had an incredible voice. it was soooo nice!!! ur loss bitches.

[frazshah1980]

kara's behaviour was totally non-professional.

[chrisgast]

@frazshah1980 at the end, yes. but not in the beginning.

[mistymonee]

@frazshah1980 It really was but I think she kinda wanted him too

[HACKERMAN24]

@frazshah1980 I hate more of the other gril with pink dress. He always imitate kara.

[321eli1]

ha ha the 2nd comment is funny

[321eli1]

kara likes to shart her pants

[321eli1]

kara's the biggest bitch ever,that guy was just nervous

[jellygoodnessify]

he was tottally nervous you can tell when he was at the door and when he asked if they knew the song he wasnt being a smart ass he was just asking. and i get mad when i have to wait for something watever kara your just pmsing!

[SarahMcKissick]

He is awesome >:D

[StephWesley]

Kara is a bitch.

[MrKingtyrant05]

u hear that everbody. single" lol he is bi. he didnt say u hear that ladys.

[1234stuff45678]

is this real? i genuinely thought this was a parody........ xD

[enilorac8181]

his attitude makes me want to punch him in the face

[Wafuller]

Fool walked in with a bad vibe. Sometimes you get that feeling you don't like that person when you meet them the first time.

[Wafuller]

Clark Kent Superman!

[CutieHoney13]

I actually think was pretty awesome! As another girl, it's totally obvious that Kara and Victoria wanted him so badly....did you hear the way Victoria said hello when he came in?? xD

[Stanislavyeungkl]

omg this guy's personality is just like mine... i swear...

[Leroy8127]

I don't see the huge reaction over his "attitude" @@

[FamilyGuyEps1]

5:31 serial killer

[steamyboy69]

oh and HEY VICtORIA , EAT MORE you luk like a skeleton with fake boobs,, you looked better when the spice girls started out in 1996, you cant sing too(: Andrew Fenlon can sing better.

[steamyboy69]

If i were to go guy it would be because of this guy

[medviation]

He has talent. The attitude that he showed there fit his song really well (really pissed off). And he made the judges feel the emotion. We need more artists like him.

[AndromechA]

LOL at how he looked at Kara at the end when he way leaving.

[cheatdath]

HE IS GOD

[booksarefriends101]

He was a jerk...I am sorry. He was good but he was a jerk.

[KittyzKatterz]

This makes me want to kick the female judges asses. GAAAAAAAAAR stupid catty bitches.

[chexnex89]

Kara and Andrew went out to dinner later that night, and after dinner Kara gave him that spanking he needed ;D

[abiifarias]

He looks like Chuck Bass!

[JackHDiamond]

epic character lol. that's dedication. this dude has other vids of this character.

[rockjam101]

Kara can spank me all night long

[leader4ya]

yes single yes 0:35

[theotherkaching]

Lol, I love Simon

[emmittpv2]

he was great

[Zeroxidy]

Totally right, his singing was good. Judges were judging his personality, which in actual fact shouldn't hinder his success. Besides, that arrogance would fit perfectly in modern tv. Unprofessional standards. That is all.

[wassupdam]

What a waste of talent, He'd make a good singer

[BehindClosedLipsxoxo]

I don't get why everyone thinks he should've gone to Hollywood, he sucks at singing this song, maybe his voice suits other songs, but I know from person experince this is a difficult song to sing because it goes so high and low and his voice sounds terrible with this song :s

[xmatt931x]

hes good at singing but hes a douche bad

[Favar0]

That judge is a bitch

[tiflotin8942]

A spanking lol? for what ?

[Camil90]

thos dang bitches

[DANCH1D]

what a 2 bitches O_O omg!

[kayleeQuinnn]

he should have gone on farther

[MrFoolish2009]

is that victoria beckham?

[Munky10001]

dem girls are bitches

[tannerrileyrusch]

His voice was pretty damn alright for most of the song. The lower parts were pretty meh though.

[DuckMyFog]

What is he saying at 1:33 - 1:37 ? .. i freakin listened to it 10 times and i am only pickin "nothing is that interesting of a question" , but it doesn't make any sense .. anyone ?

[michael07bleu]

I think the female judges were crushing on him when he walked in lol

[onatchrull1]

SHOULDA GOT PUT THRU TO HOLLYWOOD

[VanMcChicken97]

why did they ever had posh spice for a guest judge.....

[merocket]

these are two of the most vile cunts i've ever seen in my life.

[cc22ful]

atis that rachel zevita at 0:20??

[217d3]

people won't remember you for your attitude ,but for the voice people will hear , i think he should've passed , and apparently all you need is a good sob story and Just a little bit of talent to win the judges over .

[bLitz72]

LOL this guy is funny I think American Idol needs someone like him

[will320]

he didn't have a bad voice. he just ruined it for himself by being rude. was funny though

[iggypopisagod]

THAT FUCKING VICTORIA BITCH CAN EAT A FAT DICK!!!!!!!!!!!

[natpjohsnon]

@iggypopisagod

Thats not physically possible - Shes so plastic and tiny Mark Antony is the only one who will fit.

[ami22396]

@iggypopisagod quick question is that victoria beckham???

[Malviine11]

@ami22396

yes, she is. ;)

[iggypopisagod]

@ami22396 yep, she is a stupid talentless cow!

[Coldcuresmytragedy]

this guy is fucking hilarious.

[imnotsmartbutimtryin]

she wants him so bad.........she already had sex w/ him in her mind....now she feels dirty.......very dirty after the spanking.....

[MsSad101]

He's pretty good.....