Added: 3 years ago
From: CarrieFan4Lyfe
Views: 146,423
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (156)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • lyrics wrong!

  • Always great to hear a super, natural voice, I just love it.

  • I'LL BE WAtching you....

  • @MrNAZEREY creepy....:)

  • amazing ot the point i can't explain it better then beautiful.*-*

  • AMAZING...

  • She's got a great voice. And kudos to her for managing to make lyrics about stalking, sound romantic. I personally don't understand how anyone can confuse this song to a romantic love song in the first place. Or if this indeed IS meant as such, then The Police has the creepiest idea of romance I've evr known.

  • @VampireOutlaw agreed

  • @LindsayLoving Yeah and I did my reseach after posting that comment and found out that Sting's indeed said he didn't mean it as a positive love song and was surpised how dark it turned out and thinks he was subconsciously thinking of control, surveillance and Big Brother from 1984. Resulting in this originally meant exactly what it sounds to all those who actually listen to the lyrics; extreme case of obsession and stalking. :P

  • @VampireOutlaw

    it's not about stalking, it's about broken up and broken hearts...it's just an expression towards somebody.  It's not about literally stalking somebody, get with the idea of the song.

  • @zzzthaoster Not literally, but still it is. Even Sting himself says so: "It sounds like a comforting love song. I didn't realize at the time how sinister it is. I think I was thinking of Big Brother, surveillance and control." and also "Sting later said he was disconcerted by how many people think the song is more positive than it is. He insists it's about the obsession with a lost lover, the jealousy and surveillance that follows." Hmmm? Hence, stalking!

  • When I was a kid, every time I heard the original The Police version of the song, I was unsettled even though I had no idea what thelyrics were about, I mean I wasn't old enough to draw those conclusions. That goes saying these lyrics are indeed very sinister. As a teen I connected the lyrics to stalking, and I wasn't surprised at all when as an adult when I learned that this indeed is a song that was written in a stalky state of mind.

  • @VampireOutlaw

    yeah but Im sure he doesn't go around stalking her like parking his car behind the bushes just to look at her haha. It's just about still having strong emotions/feelings for somebody even after you've broken up with them, it's something pretty normal and natural.

  • @zzzthaoster The point is that he was subconsciously stalking her. It's enough to make the outcome a song about stalking. He doesn't have to actually end up doing it practically himself to make the song so.

  • @VampireOutlaw

    even so, Im sure most us have done that before one time or another towards somebody in our lives. So it's not that crazy.

  • @zzzthaoster I never said it's crazy. i just pointed out that because of that, this song's lyrics are about stalking/borderline-stalking and not just a mere impression of emotions. I mean, yes it can be put down to that but that is not all there is to it.

  • @VampireOutlaw

    ok you win, I lost hehe...jk.

    I see your point too, respectfully.

  • OMG! really loved it! naaaaah!

  • oh cant you belong to me'?????

  • i'll be watching you

  • she sings beautifully

  • GREAT!!!

  • i truly believe that season 7 was one of the greatest seasons.

  • Not Bad! She rocked in Let It Be!

  • love ittt

  • é muito bom nossa muito tri mesmo.

    GREMIO COPA

  • she's my favorite 2nd to ramiele...

  • she's always better on her piano :)

    her playing on the piano brings out the best of her solemn voice :)

    nice nice

  • I love Brooke White!

  • this is ok, i personaly like the live version with just her and the piano alot better

  • Please can I have the download link to this please! i love brooke soooo much and i love this song. i remember her singing this really clearly when she stopped and stuff.

    Please send me the link!

    ;]xoxo

  • Ddue I remember that! I felt so bad when she stopped lol. I think partly keeping her in was a pity vote from america. But she was still good.

  • love brooke!

  • Wow, this is awesome!

  • i love her version of this song. i wish i could find her studio version of Love is a Battlefield. but i think she should have just stayed w/ the piano on this song.

  • agreed

  • omgosh i LOVE THIS SONG. and brooke is amazing. i wish she had another album

  • It's only his opinion,

    'can you sing like this'? what a question, that has nothing to do with his opinion:S

  • agree

  • Brooke is amazing!!! :D :D

  • I think Brooke is only good when she has a piano other than that i think she is vuneralable and isn't very good....but thats just my oppion.

  • excuse me, can u sing like this?

  • buddy, even when bobjob66 cannot sing like Brook, he still has the right to comment, as long as the comment is constructive

  • agree

  • I was just saying that when she had a piano she was awesome....other than that i hated the way she was singing, like when she sang I am a beliver it was terriable. so it is not a matter if i can sing like this or not. I was being a critic!

  • ok, sorry it was just a stupid comment coz i was just upset.. but u'r right, i think ppl can like her, hate her.. or whatever... u'r free to do that

    however, a "critic" can be a "good critic" or "a bad" one.. i leave u to decide that part

  • Ask a less stupid question please.

  • if u'r talking to me, that's not ur business.. a smart person doesnt get involve in other's business

  • Okay Simon-wannabe

  • i luv this song brooke white roxx

  • Anyone else agree that she looks more like Jennifer Aniston than herself in those pictures? Especially the first one?

  • Brooke was one of my favorite this last season of AI and she is still one of my favorite.Her voice is very cool and everytime that i listen to her i feel the same emotion as the very first time i heard her sing.

  • omg. she's amazing. love it!

  • i luv breath she ah-mazing

  • aly and aj ....haha

  • i am really glad they made a studio version of this with her. I think people were too harsh on her at the live performance. Sure she messed up the piano but the competition is about her voice not how well she plays her instrument each show. And when she messed up on the piano her voice stilled sounded amazing

  • She has a very relaxing voice.

  • brooke white looks like aly....LOL

  • yeah i think that too.

    but brooke is more beautful <3

    and her voice better <3

  • Whose Aly?

  • I think she means Aly from Aly & Aj? Maybe idk.

  • This version might not seems to have much climax at first but is actually very listenable and gets more so as one plays it more.

    Very nice.

  • Brooke rocks!

    She's a great singer. She gets nervous and it makes her mess up, but the studio versions prove that she is an AMAZING singer. She deserved to go farther than Jason. He was good, but he only stayed longer than Brooke because of his fan base.

    Syesha's good too, so people shouldn't be saying she's not as good as Brooke. I love Brookie, but Syesha is better. : (

    I didn't like this studio version much, but I loved the ending. I've never heard Brookie sing high at all. : )

    GO BROOKIE!!!

  • omg she's so beautiful! and adorable and sweet and talented...my gosh brooke i want to be you, lol. you have a ton of support; keep it up even after idol. ^^

  • all I can say is beautiful! :D

  • i love you brooke!!!

    keep it up!!

    you have tons of support

  • BROOKE WHITE, JASON CASTRO, AMANDA OVERMYER, DAVID COOK, and MICHAEL JOHNS= THE BEST EVER!!! too bad all of them but David went home. ahhhh! Brooke, Amanda, David Cook, and Jason are on my iPod!!! Syesha was not better than brooke!!!! NOOO!

  • brooke and syesha r both great. brooke is a wonderful singer but syesha is great @ singing high notes.

  • i love that song and for a girl you did a good job. keep your head up high. you need a good song writer to fit your voice or sing the songs that you wrote or sing some Patsy Cline i loved her voice but she died march 5,1963 when i was a teenager and you were not born yet. you go girl love ya.

  • love this performance!

  • depends on what. sure, syesha's better at broadway and wannabe-diva numbers. brooke's better at being a singer/songwriter/musician and connecting with the audience. brooke will have more commercial, musical success. don't get me started on syesha's dish-rag personality.

  • too bad, she was eliminated tonyt

  • umm...yea it is her..

  • That IS Brooke! whats wrong with your ears!?

  • wat r u talking about? that IS her

  • david a. is my american idol but brooke is def. my favorite girl :]

  • sameee!

  • I love her! She has so amazing voice!

  • my only problem with this, is that it is her best performance and i think she peeked to soon so now she can't liv up to that, fter all they all set their own standards and with this she set her's really high but i do love it overall

  • okay, shes pretty, and she can sing RLY WELL!

  • this is one of my favourite performances..although i like the live version better!!! please vote for her today!!

  • she looks a lot better with her hair like that! she sings amazing 2!

  • VOTE FOR BROOKE WHITE!!!

    The true musician and the most genuine person on Earth! She's a breath of fresh air amidst the belter singers we've had in the past. Singing isn't just about yelling a song - it's also about the emotions. GO BROOKE!

  • stocking song lol

  • brooke is awesome

  • my favorite song from her from the whole competition up to now!

  • Much better with the piano arrangement, and not that Desmond Child manufacturedness...

    It's lucky I didn't waste my iTunes fund on this.

    Don't tell anyone, but I rather listen to the live version. Much more exciting and human. Brooke needs to do an unplugged album, since this arrangement/production by Child does no justice to that honesty and genuinity in her voice.

  • i love this version of it!

  • She may no be the best singer in the competition...but she is a good role model for youngsters:)

  • totally true!

  • LOVE IT!

    LOVE HER!!!

  • Brooke is gonna win it all!!!!!1

  • i love her...n she sound great live and in studio...

  • he  is the best

  • Brooke sounds like every other "dime a dozen" good singer. Nothing special in her voice. She doesn't stand out as a "pop star"; however, she does seem like a wonderful, sweet person and I'm glad that many young people admire her.

  • "pop" music doesn't make you an American Idol. No one in the cast this year sings "pop" music. Leave that for Justin Timberlake. We want people who can sing with hits on the radio. Her type of voice has never really been shown on American Idol before on any season.

  • i agree with u but i think brooke has this softness to her voice(:

    but i also like that many young people admire her and enjoy listening to her.

  • Brooke White doesn't stand out as a "pop star". That's why she isn't one. If you noticed every performance since that one, she picks and most honest songs and sings it without an inch of multi-million 'manufacturedness' (I'm talking to you, Carly Hennessey/Smithson!) This studio version (produced by 3rd-rate crackhead (gotta admit it!) Desmond Child) does no justice to her take on this song; just listen to the live one.

  • I think she is underated

  • does anyone know how to get the mp3 files of this song?

  • where did u get this?

  • AMAZING!

  • This version is amazing!!! She is sooo great. I really hope she wins AI but sadly i think David A will win because people think he is "adorable"....he is soooo not idol material.

  • i don't think david a will win... great voice but i think he's getting boring. brooke stands a better chance if she picks good songs like this. she does have her way with really popular, classic, pop songs.

  • i know

  • i don't think david a will win... great voice but i think he's getting boring. brooke stands a better chance if she picks good songs like this. she does have her way with really popular, classic, pop songs.

  • archuleta is a gay H-e-l-e-r !!!!!!

    :-(

  • great, great voice. she proves that you don't have to be a belter to convey the message of the song.

  • i cant wait to buy her cd

    she is such a good singer

    welll i hope she wins

    but i think she will she is the best singer out of the whole competiton

    GO BROOKE WHITE

  • forgot the word "up"?

  • Can you see? Everyone loves Brooke---including me. She's absolutely AMAZING! And she has a lot of confidence, audience connection, passion, she has a great voice, she;s beautiful, and everything! She's DEFINIETELY AMERICAN IDOL MATERIAL!

  • the only thing i dont like about her is that she always says something back to the judges.

  • That is her. Let's accept it.

  • I don't have a problem with them talking to the judges, as long as they aren't smartmouths like some have been...and Brooke obviously doesn't have a rude bone in her body.

  • Can you see? Everyone loves Brooke---including me. She's absolutely AMAZING! And she has a lot of confidence, audience connection, passion, she has a great voice, she;s beautiful, and everything! She's DEFINIETELY AMERICAN IDOL MATERIAL!

  • brooke white is so pretty and she is such a good singer!i hope she wins!she's amazing!

  • THIS ROX MY SOX!!

  • this is 1 of my favorites song sung by her! vote 4 brooke!!! :)

  • i hope she make it to at least top 2! Try your best Brooke!

  • she cannot belt out high notes but she's genuine and passionate in her preformance. i love her.

  • The most talented on that show....by far...

  • I really dont understand why she's in the bottom..she's a really sweet girl and she's so talented!!! :(

  • I don't know if she'll win, but she's one of my favourites. You can really tell that she's emotionally connected to nearly every song she performs.

  • VOTE FOR HER!!!!! Couldn't believe she was in the bottom three! vote vote vote!

  • she changed the lyrics:0:43-0:44 she changed it from every night you stay to every step you take

  • brooke fans please vote for her!!!! can't beliv she was one of the bottom three!!!!

  • my personal fave, because she has such a humbleness about her and she is such a great influence

  • Yeah, i honestly dont think she'll win. but i love brooke. one of my favorites. and my only favorite girl in the competition this year. she's really good. i think she'll make it to at least the top 3.

  • As far as the contest is concerned, I don't think she'll win, but Brooke is my personal favorite. She has class and a style all her own. I look forward to hearing her performance every week.

  • im mad. i forgot 2 watch American Idol tonight, so idk how she did!!

  • She will win no matter What!

  • I hope she does "Islands In The Stream" and yes this studio version rocks!!

    Love ya Brooke :)

  • I've loved this girl since the first auditions! She's amazing, I REALLY hope she wins! I NEED her CD! :P Desperately! But I don't know what she's going to do this week for Country week.. :S Could be a little messy. but then again, I've loved ALL of Brooke's performances, and I love country music, so I'm sure she'll find some way to make whatever song she chooses her own. ♥

  • I love Brooke She sounds like Carly Simon mixed with Stevie Nicks and Juice Newton

  • well just like what randy and simon said, I really think she is better off with the piano alone^^ no offense, I really luv her^^hope she'll pick a right song next week^^ (opps should be a few days later^^)

  • Brooke and David A. ARE the top 2!

  • She reminds me of Sheryl Crow!

    and Sheryl Crow is a good singer

  • Even though country isn't her style, I can't wait until next week to see what she sings. She reminds me of Faith Hill in a way.

  • oh I'm actually thinking that country may suit her, with her unique voice^^

  • wow more people need to see this, too bad they're watching the ai version

    i love brooke, only wished she was still single

  • Go Brooke!!!! I THINK YOUR REALLY GREAT.. you've improved.. I should know because since the beginning I really liked you already!!! I'm from the philippines!!! and all my friends say your great.. you and ramiele both,,,:D

  • WHOO!! Brooke and David A. all the way!

  • WHOO!! Brooke and David A. all the way!

  • SAME FAVORITES :D

  • ALSO MY FACES xD

  • My favorites too! :]

  • Apperently everyone loves them XD I think they are going to be in at least the top three, but there are so many awesome contestants this year that they have a large variety of competition :( I just hope one of them wins :D

  • AHH TOO GOOD!

  • OMG! I just got the chills! GO BROOKE!

  • this is phenomenal! i was never sure that i could listen to her voice on a full cd but i was proven wrong - brooke for the next idol!!!!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more