The piece could probably use some slow practice in order to bring it up to tempo. A bit more range in the dynamics would do well, too, as there currently isn't much contrast between the forte and piano passages in the main theme.
@badsalad313 People play an instrument not just because they have to but because the love to.... instruments is a way to express your feelings from the heart
@ShinobiSasukeUchiha Practice make progress, nothing can ever be really perfected. You never know when someone plays it better, mainly because they play through the dynamics and key signatures. There is no definite perfection, just progress through enumerate practice.
@SyaoranXiaoLi "practice make perfect" is just a commonly-known phrase. :/ I didn't coin it. Since I was a child, I've always been told that line. I know nothing can ever be perfected, but that's just how the phrase goes. Every American knows that phrase.
@TrickGabriel Shut the fuck up, I'm asian. I play the piano, violin, guitar, cello and drums. Well, blonds or whites, they think they are good enough sometimes but this is just being RACIST.
Doesnt have to do fucking anything with being asian or not, its about how hard you train, if you train as hard as them, you'll get as good as them.. simple as that..
i thought u hit wrong ... but when i saw the time played was more than 2 minute ... i figure that u 'r perfectly done <3 ... but still , where's the part they used in that film ???
I'm an asian too and i can't play piano my fingers are very short even though my height is average hehe!!! Not all asian have long fingers and can play piano well, it is talent that just have develop to be more and more excellent.
I am asian and I do not think being good at piano has any thing to do with it. I teach myself how to play but im always scolded because when i attempt to learn a song I never finish it when I see my friends at school who attend music club learn it in a week and they are not asian. the true key is dedication thats what makes you good.
@verymary123 agreed...usually, when I put a certain song to my personal favourite list, I'd do anything to search the music sheet...when I have the music sheet, I would start on teaching the music to myself...I'd sit on the piano bench for hours..lo and behold, I only managed to get past the first 2 or 3 pages...if it has like 7 pages, then bye-bye..I won't be playing it anymore..>< looks like I have to have someone to rub it in on me..or else the sheet'll only rot under the bench. I'm n Asian 2
Beeing Asian has nothing to do with his fingers. I'm african and have long fingers (I play the piano to). And saying that because he is an asian ofc he's good, and that we will never be as good as him.. well that's a lie. My piano teacher once said, that if I want to be very good I have to practice. TO be better you must focus on practicing. That guy that is playing has probably practiced so hard many days to perform this wonderful piece.
@roblover96 I'm Asian and I have short, stubby fingers...and I could probably get some injuries too because some of the notes to a song is pretty hard to press...being it FAR AWAY APART FROM EACH other...I usually have to cancel one of the notes..and yeah, you have to practice a lot..if not, you can pretty much say good bye to being a marvelous pianist...you can be one, but with hours and hours of practice..
So instead of owning up to your own shortcomings in life, you instead push the blame on Asians? Basically karlng888 will never be recognized for their innate talent. Forever labeled as asian, their talent will strictly come from some bizarre connection with their skin colour.
Spewing out such comments...it merely creates mental barriers and handicaps for those who would fall to sociological labels.
@keetner lol no no no! it was a joke, learn how to take one. Duh being Asian has nothing to do with it.
keetner, I'm sure you're the life of the party, but taking offense to everything is annoying. I am Puerto Rican, does that make me a loud moth hispanic? I am one, but not because I'm hispanic..... He is Asian, does that make him a piano prodigy? He is one, but not because he's Asian.
Taking offense to everything... it merely creates annoying comments, so yeah,
Your technique is pretty good, but you just could not express the feel of the song. And also, the way you used the pedal cut of a lot of the notes from your left hand.
beautiful :) and im not just saying that because i saw flo from the progressive commercials play before your video played, making everything on earth look beautiful compared to her >:P
*clap clap clap!!!* stunning job in my opinion!! I like the sounds of the sharps and flats keys but I loath playing them. You did a wonderful job keep up the good work!
Positive criticism: Your fingers are too flat, no "egg" shape. Your left hand is too careless and too loud, it's even louder than the melody. Which is unacceptable.
@happyboy123123 If you try to play this, I disagree with your first crit. The "egg" shape is hard to maintain in this etude. Even if you play it slower. Maybe if he had Chopin's ginormous hands, he can do the egg shape a little . . .
where can i get the sheet music for this??
sweetatomictangerine 2 months ago
Chopin wasn't Asian. And he wrote the damned thing.
AREM16137 3 months ago 5
i have that jacket that you wear
eunicle 6 months ago
The piece could probably use some slow practice in order to bring it up to tempo. A bit more range in the dynamics would do well, too, as there currently isn't much contrast between the forte and piano passages in the main theme.
712Stephen 6 months ago
:0 i love it!!:3 nice nice nice.
flightnings 6 months ago
The way your hands moving is really amazing. Its like flying in the piano keys :D
Juliete123456 7 months ago
The way your hands moving is really amazing :D its like flying in the piano...you have done really well :D
Juliete123456 7 months ago
look at those fingers :O
caulimay 7 months ago
@caulimay
i know right?!?!, having long fingers is such an advantage when you are playing the piano .. =/
it's like you can play any piece..
scandiniviaGAL14 7 months ago
@caulimay
ow and yeah.. so fast :)
scandiniviaGAL14 7 months ago
wow .. what a talent
Joint145 8 months ago
make please tutorial:)
sembion999 8 months ago
LOL @ asian comment XD
BTW i like your jacket! :D
pinoykanaba 8 months ago
Subbed~I have some music to share with you also. =]
terrytyc 8 months ago
wao...!! :-bd
u so cool
heesungteuk 9 months ago
HOLY SHIZZ! your fingers look so elegant but their effing FAST!!!!!
chunggieable 9 months ago
is envy your long finger T_T
nikalyy 9 months ago
thats true..
Farock007 9 months ago
He wear like popeye
lonelyboiboi89 10 months ago
people need to stop with this " its cause hes asian " stuff... anyone can achieve this if they put time and effort to practice everyday.
Tr1balArt 10 months ago 119
@Tr1balArt I'm guessing ur not asain :P
Fleepeep 9 months ago
@Tr1balArt but who would put this much time and effort into it if their family honor wasn't at stake? (and therefore they are asian?)
badsalad313 9 months ago
@badsalad313 People play an instrument not just because they have to but because the love to.... instruments is a way to express your feelings from the heart
Tr1balArt 9 months ago
@Tr1balArt this. People need to learn the meaning of the phrase "practice makes perfect".
ShinobiSasukeUchiha 6 months ago
@ShinobiSasukeUchiha Practice make progress, nothing can ever be really perfected. You never know when someone plays it better, mainly because they play through the dynamics and key signatures. There is no definite perfection, just progress through enumerate practice.
SyaoranXiaoLi 5 months ago in playlist piano
@SyaoranXiaoLi "practice make perfect" is just a commonly-known phrase. :/ I didn't coin it. Since I was a child, I've always been told that line. I know nothing can ever be perfected, but that's just how the phrase goes. Every American knows that phrase.
ShinobiSasukeUchiha 5 months ago 2
@Tr1balArt yeah tell 'em, thats what i did! but still im asian xD
GuitarBoyZ100 6 months ago
@Tr1balArt don't forget that you need to be asian too.
SyaoranXiaoLi 5 months ago in playlist piano
@IckyWicky123 over 9000
shadowblade232 10 months ago
Only Asians can do that.
qwerty845john 10 months ago
@qwerty845john ^^ why? lol
nikalyy 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@IckyWicky123 come on man ... the piano duel is IN the movie ... check it out already ...
luke06101993 10 months ago
Your parents must be proud... Oh wait, they're Asian...
TrickGabriel 11 months ago 7
@TrickGabriel jealous¡?¡?¡?¡?¡?¡
malavida77 10 months ago
@malavida77 Haha, I guess so. : P
TrickGabriel 9 months ago
@TrickGabriel Shut the fuck up, I'm asian. I play the piano, violin, guitar, cello and drums. Well, blonds or whites, they think they are good enough sometimes but this is just being RACIST.
l3naleexxFreak 8 months ago
@l3naleexxFreak sadface.
TrickGabriel 8 months ago
Doesnt have to do fucking anything with being asian or not, its about how hard you train, if you train as hard as them, you'll get as good as them.. simple as that..
vengadorsky 11 months ago
@vengadorsky well it just so happens that it's more common to see an Asian doing that ;-)
1Sedicar 10 months ago
i thought u hit wrong ... but when i saw the time played was more than 2 minute ... i figure that u 'r perfectly done <3 ... but still , where's the part they used in that film ???
luke06101993 11 months ago
very good : )
mostloveji 11 months ago
Asian or not, practice makes perfect.
mrcrysis456 11 months ago 16
ohh, what does it care?? jay chou is asian he is good if u want to be very good u need have to pratice
HappyEverytimee 11 months ago
i need music sheet ?could u help me ?
NiwaDasuke 1 year ago
i'm feel sorry for your mother because you were probably born with a piano in your hand
Eleventytwoo 1 year ago 4
Chopin op. 10 number 5 ...What does the op. stand for?
zewenwu 1 year ago
@zewenwu it means opus. If an op 10 number 5 means it's a work numbered 10 and this is the 5th piece in the whole opus.
GraceOh 1 year ago
@zewenwu opus
JOICEWANG1 11 months ago
Comment removed
Pianidlo 1 year ago
I'm an asian too and i can't play piano my fingers are very short even though my height is average hehe!!! Not all asian have long fingers and can play piano well, it is talent that just have develop to be more and more excellent.
supergeneration4ever 1 year ago
so actually jay chou play it with several variation?
CookingCowell89 1 year ago
O.O
wow
bgumg1023 1 year ago
I am asian and I do not think being good at piano has any thing to do with it. I teach myself how to play but im always scolded because when i attempt to learn a song I never finish it when I see my friends at school who attend music club learn it in a week and they are not asian. the true key is dedication thats what makes you good.
verymary123 1 year ago
@verymary123 agreed...usually, when I put a certain song to my personal favourite list, I'd do anything to search the music sheet...when I have the music sheet, I would start on teaching the music to myself...I'd sit on the piano bench for hours..lo and behold, I only managed to get past the first 2 or 3 pages...if it has like 7 pages, then bye-bye..I won't be playing it anymore..>< looks like I have to have someone to rub it in on me..or else the sheet'll only rot under the bench. I'm n Asian 2
Sheira89 1 year ago
Great!!
Marina96424 1 year ago
im asian i have very short finger i can barley play an octive
pandaluvers555 1 year ago
Beeing Asian has nothing to do with his fingers. I'm african and have long fingers (I play the piano to). And saying that because he is an asian ofc he's good, and that we will never be as good as him.. well that's a lie. My piano teacher once said, that if I want to be very good I have to practice. TO be better you must focus on practicing. That guy that is playing has probably practiced so hard many days to perform this wonderful piece.
roblover96 1 year ago
@roblover96 I'm Asian and I have short, stubby fingers...and I could probably get some injuries too because some of the notes to a song is pretty hard to press...being it FAR AWAY APART FROM EACH other...I usually have to cancel one of the notes..and yeah, you have to practice a lot..if not, you can pretty much say good bye to being a marvelous pianist...you can be one, but with hours and hours of practice..
Sheira89 1 year ago
every chick who watches this is thinking about those fingers
zoquibax 1 year ago
tired of these commercials!!!
ajrgospel 1 year ago
verry nice
blubba518 1 year ago
Love it ^^, ur fingers remind my of mine :D
JJ4ev3r 1 year ago
踩板不对,下次练好了才发。谢谢
shishinanwei 1 year ago
you're amazing man !!! you've one of those fingers...!!!
kokittoful 1 year ago
love ur melody too much ^^ !
stillwater1801 1 year ago
Spider fingerssss !
TommyLeeBboyGhetto 1 year ago
WOW that's good!
iiROCKKidd23 1 year ago
you need practise dude :)
dont smach the keys so hard,this melody is supposed to be played like touching velvet.
ShaDowKilL1988 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
great .. perfect. sha will teach my child.
greetings Indonesia Raya..
MrAgus05 1 year ago
great .. perfect. sha will teach my child.
greetings Indonesia Raya..
MrAgus05 1 year ago
wt the fuck are you playing??!
mpopo123 1 year ago
holy shit..
babyBebzz 1 year ago
where's the key change? :)
Qboy316 1 year ago
@Qboy316 this is the original version, etude Chopin op10 no5, there is no key change as u see in the movie
channhoibong92 1 year ago
nicely done :D
Euphonium1996 1 year ago
..very amazing
youngpianist98 1 year ago
holy shit. thats amazing.
xArcticgurlx 1 year ago
You want to work on playing this piece technically AND musically. If you just smash the keys you're gonna end up being like Lang Lang. LOL jk.
But you should really consider redoing it. I never played this piece, but even I can tell that it needs work.. :/
wordlessmuse 1 year ago
did u change the key by any chance?
yoshplayr 1 year ago
why do urs dun sound the same as jay chou? sorry no offence but i watched the movie alot of times so i could recognize.
tammyleey 1 year ago
@tammyleey this is chopin's etude in g# minor ( black keys) Jay made his own variation of this to use in the piano battle scene of his movie
hope that cleared things up :)
AJACHACK 1 year ago
wtf shit version
jakub25baca 1 year ago
Part of it is the part I recognize from Piano Battle, But Later theres a different part, Is that the actual thing or your own improv?
IsukeRaichixTheOnly 1 year ago
of course youre asian
stlsgreatest27 1 year ago 100
@stlsgreatest27
Being asian has nothing to do with it T_T.
keetner 1 year ago
@keetner but it helps! 90% of all the pianists I see are Asian!
lol obviously it really has nothing to do with it, but believing that's why helps us cope with the fact that we will never be that good :P
10n3r 1 year ago
@10n3r
So instead of owning up to your own shortcomings in life, you instead push the blame on Asians? Basically karlng888 will never be recognized for their innate talent. Forever labeled as asian, their talent will strictly come from some bizarre connection with their skin colour.
Spewing out such comments...it merely creates mental barriers and handicaps for those who would fall to sociological labels.
keetner 1 year ago
@keetner lol no no no! it was a joke, learn how to take one. Duh being Asian has nothing to do with it.
keetner, I'm sure you're the life of the party, but taking offense to everything is annoying. I am Puerto Rican, does that make me a loud moth hispanic? I am one, but not because I'm hispanic..... He is Asian, does that make him a piano prodigy? He is one, but not because he's Asian.
Taking offense to everything... it merely creates annoying comments, so yeah,
TLDR take a joke ;P
10n3r 1 year ago
WOOOAAAAOOOWWW...
\^O^/
PRASIDHI 1 year ago
this isn't the secret version, it's chopin's etude in g# minor
EpicBloo 1 year ago
@EpicBloo it can be call as black keys =]
baven522 1 year ago
Whow that's so good! O.O Haha I'm jealous of your fingers (I wish mine would play like that XD)
Ellisz7 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
only an Asian could : )
Superblockman 1 year ago
wow. that was stunning D: !
Rainityy 1 year ago
so awesome!!!
LoweyLiu 1 year ago
Good job man! That's a difficult piece, and you play it very clean!
LostAndFound144 1 year ago
...
xXChingon2480Xx 1 year ago
everyone's gotta love octopus hands .... -_-.....
BboyChopstixSK 1 year ago
u know this is not the battle one.. this is just chopin op 10 n 5 its not from movie secret.
damonmaster999 1 year ago
is this one much easier than the white keys one?
sheets please xd
LamWeiXing 1 year ago
@LamWeiXing I don't think there is a "white keys" one. Black keys are just the nickname for this piece.
Torpensann 1 year ago
he changed it all the black keys. :P still awesome :)
SophiaD1000 1 year ago
@SophiaD1000 the original had no white keys lol i think
fdyadft 1 year ago
@fdyadft I guess so.. but I think Jay Chou's rearrange the one sounds more eolande.. :P
SophiaD1000 1 year ago
this reminds me of two things
1. JayChou's movie
2. Family Outing cooking scenes
x3MiiNTY 1 year ago
...Holy fucking shit o_o
MARiONN3TT3 1 year ago
@MARiONN3TT3 LMAO
Squirlster 1 year ago
@Kambuz44 LMAOO!! yeah i know the sound quality might not be great but this guy is AMAZING!! thumbs up if you agree!!
Wish4Skate 1 year ago
Piano Hero :D
MissHalibel 1 year ago
Interesting choice of fingering LOL...
Your technique is pretty good, but you just could not express the feel of the song. And also, the way you used the pedal cut of a lot of the notes from your left hand.
Nice attempt though.
Kambuz44 1 year ago
@Kambuz44 *Piece
FryderykFChopin 1 year ago
没换去白键?
AlexElric 1 year ago
i looove this song! so pretty!
hairdoodle 1 year ago
Nice piece... Impressive... I'm going to learn this piece man...
rUshhelI 1 year ago
O.O
Textaholic0223 1 year ago
attempt.
stress on attempt.
mrpoe123123 1 year ago
WOW, that's like crazy!!
aznfishie 1 year ago
damn
crimsonmeat44 1 year ago
i think i just died ... that was amazing O_o
MissLovelyMelody 1 year ago
I bet I could do that.....it might take a while to get used to XP
vampireknight1001 1 year ago
how u make ur fingers move so fast? i jus cant.... :(
yuipeha9111 1 year ago
ur fingers are so long O_o
xXBUKLAUXx 1 year ago 75
@xXBUKLAUXx you know what else is long? ;)
vandiagram 1 year ago
@vandiagram THE SONG RIGHTTTT?
xXBUKLAUXx 1 year ago
is this hard to read of a score? like lots of sharps or flats etc?
jaytee12394 1 year ago
AMAZING!!!!!!
deardian 1 year ago
OMG! You're fingers are moving so fast it's crazy! How do you do this?!! You are amazing! :)
Staraahhskinss 1 year ago
OMG, this is amazing , Do you by any chance have music sheets for this ? D:
kathyelletran 1 year ago
wow ur ... just wow... O= if only my fingers could play as fast as that xP (being a flutist i should, but i just cant xP)
katwinaxox 1 year ago
jay is better
ninjagaru 1 year ago
@ninjagaru Because he's asian.
BlackCloud21509 1 year ago
this is really good. a bit more emphasis on musicality and it'll be perfect
zensu123456 1 year ago
amazin',u r as fantastic as Jay!
pingVincentfan95 1 year ago
Wow, those 49 people who didn't like this are crazy.
jaeyinx 1 year ago
Holy balls o: I'm in love.
bo0xb0o 1 year ago
YOU'RE AMAZING=D
themosthappiestgirl 1 year ago
49 people miss the "like" button.
Shuffleboy34 1 year ago
@Shuffleboy34
why is there a comment like yours on nearly every video?
Hosker25 1 year ago
nice to,,,
jemond29 1 year ago
Still think the number of view is too little x.x
iceshow911 1 year ago
love this song :P
jaytee12394 1 year ago
holy shit
xoCbeanluvaox 1 year ago
OMG!!, very good!
jiggyjeff123 1 year ago
good....! i think youre better than jay chou.. but he's still a lot cuter.. hehe
ccscharlene 1 year ago
wow even youtube can't keep up with his ninja fingers!!!
modis15 1 year ago 3
beautiful :) and im not just saying that because i saw flo from the progressive commercials play before your video played, making everything on earth look beautiful compared to her >:P
but really, well played :)
creidefy 1 year ago
i think all of you shld go watch George Li's version as well. He's really good
DragonBonder 1 year ago
this guy is fast sounds like a cow boy bar
thepoppy1824 1 year ago
@happyboy123123, the left hand IS the melody, not the right
fruitvizard 1 year ago
cool deal
kilnlstay 1 year ago
*clap clap clap!!!* stunning job in my opinion!! I like the sounds of the sharps and flats keys but I loath playing them. You did a wonderful job keep up the good work!
krazedKillualover 1 year ago
Positive criticism: Your fingers are too flat, no "egg" shape. Your left hand is too careless and too loud, it's even louder than the melody. Which is unacceptable.
happyboy123123 1 year ago
@happyboy123123 If you try to play this, I disagree with your first crit. The "egg" shape is hard to maintain in this etude. Even if you play it slower. Maybe if he had Chopin's ginormous hands, he can do the egg shape a little . . .
erken 1 year ago
wow
voiceofexpression 1 year ago
PRE-TTY GOOD.
now next step is to work on the interpretation a bit more.
and if u want to look a bit more pro. where something with black sleeves when u make a vid
1Sedicar 1 year ago
@1Sedicar I don't think his intent is to look pro. It's more to entertain.
6clonedcows 1 year ago
Comment removed
1Sedicar 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@6clonedcows well thats what pianist do they entertain with their playing.
I'm just saying that it would look a lot better with black sleeves. it would look more pianist like. you just don't know what its missing.
don't even bother. you don't know anything about piano.
you don't even play piano and u probably never heard of Chopin or this song until u watched this.
1Sedicar 1 year ago
wow! COOL!!! it's really hard to play, isn't it??
fah5spring 1 year ago
lol fast fingles LOL!
kangwang 1 year ago
Meh, it was alright.
If by 'alright' I mean FREAKINCREDIBLE, that is.
badsalad313 1 year ago
wat piano is that?:0
SuperMilliee 1 year ago
BABEEEI AQUIII SERIO!
luigistart 1 year ago
wow !!
x3Chocolate3x 1 year ago
Dam u hav long fingers lol. Great job
ShadowedAce 1 year ago
haters are jealous seriously... this is amazing.
christinakwanx 1 year ago
@christinakwanx hey im not just haters are jealous..im jealous and i dont hate
Toby1Music 1 year ago
does anyone know the 3rd piano battle piece played?
ngnaso 1 year ago
You're like...EXTRA good!
higary1 1 year ago
love it! x
spazzyjazzy210 1 year ago
GREAT JOB! YOURE FUCKIN AWESOME!
BreatheForParamore 1 year ago
increible !!!!!!
lutr3z 1 year ago
Lacking Speed
TFChino 1 year ago
Lacking Speed
TFChino 1 year ago
work on speed and accuracy
gastmania933 1 year ago
in one word wow
demian14444 1 year ago
the actual tempo is a bit faster, and i think u may be lacking some dynamics
jaywyn 1 year ago 2
嘩隻手彈得好好睇呀....
AI913 1 year ago
God dam it
tlsxodn 1 year ago
WOW!!!!!!!!!!!
mashara5 1 year ago 3
I'm surprised that piano didn't start on fire! WOO! That was pretty awesome!
12KX21 1 year ago 8
hey i cant find the sheet T___T
Elixire121 1 year ago
好长的手指~。~
Elixire121 1 year ago 2